Wikipedia talk:WikiProject Chess: Difference between revisions
Content deleted Content added
→Izaak Appel: Gaige isn't of much help with this |
→Akira Watanabe (chess): new section |
||
Line 105:
:{{spaces|3}}{{dagger}}{{spaces|4}}c1941
:[[User:Quale|Quale]] ([[User talk:Quale|talk]]) 02:40, 30 May 2024 (UTC)
== Akira Watanabe (chess) ==
Would someone from WP:CHESS mind taking a look at [[:Akira Watanabe (chess)]] and assessing the subject's notability (as chess player)? I'll ask something similar at [[:WT:JAPAN]] given that the subject might possobily be notable for reasons other than chess, but the current focus of the article and claim of notability seem to be the subject's chess achievements. The article also appears to be a translation of the Japanese Wikipedia article [[:ja:渡辺暁]] (based on [[:User talk:Ebefl#Ways to improve Akira Watanabe (chess)]]) but is lacking proper attribution per [[:WP:TFOLWP]]. A lack of proper attribution cn most likely can be "[[:WP:BEFORE|fixed]]", but a lack of notability can't. For reference, the Japanese Wikipedia article does seem to be pretty much the same content-wise and is also basically only supported by a single [[:WP:PRIMARY]] source (the other sources listed as "references" seem more like "explanatory notes").-- [[User:Marchjuly|Marchjuly]] ([[User talk:Marchjuly|talk]]) 21:51, 23 June 2024 (UTC)
| |||