Content deleted Content added
Kak Language (talk | contribs) No edit summary |
|||
Line 84:
:Fine I was comparing Kurmanci Kurdish than. The tables are basen on this [http://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/diq/b/b6/NW_Iranian.JPG table]--[[User:Daraheni|Daraheni]] ([[User talk:Daraheni#top|talk]]) 06:22, 27 April 2009 (UTC)
* Nope, it's not fine! You think you are smart and extra-genius, huh?! First, according to Encyclopedia Iranica, Zaza speakers speculate themselves as Kurdish, no matter if Linguistically their respective language is not a dialect of Kirmanci Kurdish (which is spoken by majority of Kurds). Also all historical evidences testify that Zaza speakers have been nothing else but Kurdish. The first indication to a distinct Zaza identity is made by a journalist no sooner than 1989. Therefore the so-called Zaza identity is a unprecedented identity which is seeking to imbibe original Kurdish identity among Zaza speaking Kurds. Otherwise we dont encounter even a pewee mention to a Zaza identity throu history, unless 1989 and Piya paper in Turkey!
*Also, what for you wanna compare Zaza only with Kurmanci Kurdish ?!! Since when they compare languages with selected Dialects?!! Both Southern and Central Kurdish words must be added to the Kurdish table along with Kurmanci dialect words. As well as Zaza words from Dimili and Northern dialects including "z" and "j" variants must be attached to Zazaki column. Otherwise you must assuredly prove what for "nimac, espice, roc, vac" are Original and "nimaj, espije, roj, vaj", or "espize, roz, vaz" are not!
*By the way, first go try to speak your mother tongue as fist language and dont involve yourself in Persian. Since many Persian entries are terribly incorrect too.--[[User:Kak_Language|Kak Language]]
| |||