Charles Swainson (naturalist)

Charles Swainson
Born	1841 Northamptonshire , England
Died	1913 (aged 71–72)
Education	B.A, M.A
Alma mater	Christ Church , Cambridge University
Spouse	Isabel Augusta Gossip

Rev. Charles Swainson, M.A., was rector of High Hurst Wood, Sussex, from 1872-1874, from where he published his Handbook of Weather Folk-Lore which also included folklore and mythology relating to elements of nature and a short chapter on birds.

As Rector of St Luke's, Old Charlton, Kent, from 1874 to 1908, he published his best-known and most influential work, Provincial Names and Folk-Lore of British Birds, which collected the vernacular and regional names of British birds together with an array of British and European folklore related to birds. The 1885 edition (Provincial Names and Folk-Lore...) was published within the Dialect Society's blue cover papers, and the 1886 edition (The Folk-Lore and Provincial Names...), with the title slightly changed for emphasis, was published in the Folk-Lore Society's brown cloth covers.

Charles Swainson has been confused with his relative William John Swainson, a zoologist, ornithologist, and author, after whom several species of birds were named (e.g. Swainson's thrush), and with Charles Anthony Swainson, a theologian.

Early life, education and vocation

Swainson was born in 1841 in Crick, Northamptonshire, England to Rev. Charles Lichfield Swainson, who was then Rector of St Margaret of Antioch, Crick, and Harriet Littledale (nee France). He was educated at Harrow, took a B.A. degree from Christ Church, Cambridge (1863) and was ordained a deacon in 1864, spending less than a year at Wilton in Wiltshire, not far from Salisbury. He was ordained a priest in 1865, and moved to Crick to serve his father's parish as curate.

He married Isabel Augusta Gossip at Doncaster, Yorkshire, in 1865. He took an M.A. degree in 1866 and remained in Crick until 1871, when his father died. In 1872 he moved to High Hurstwood in Sussex, near Buxted and Uckley, where he remained for two years and published his first work, on weather-lore, in 1873.

In 1874 he was presented by the Maryon-Wilson family of Charlton House to the parish of St Luke's, Old Charlton, near Greenwich, east of London, where he remained until 1908 and where he prepared the manuscript for his seminal book on the Provincial Names and Folk-Lore of British Birds (1885-6). He contributed to his local Society of Antiquities in Woolwich on the subject of the treasures in his Old Charlton parish of St Luke's. In 1908 he left Charlton at the age of 67 and moved to a residence nearby until his death in 1913 at the age of 72.

Career

Swainson was a member of the English Dialect Society, and of the Folk-Lore Society, took Notes and Queries, and communicated with one of the ornithological luminaries of his day, J.A.Harvie-Brown. He drew on regional English, Scottish, Welsh and Irish dialects and traditions as well as from continental European cultures and languages - particularly German and French - and from other world cultures for his collection of vernacular names and common beliefs about aspects of natural history, particularly birds. In his introduction to Birds he thanks the G Lawrence Gomme (of the Folk-Lore Society, and of the English Dialect Society) for reading the proofs and assisting with the publication of the work, and acknowledges the highly-regarded ornithologist J. A. Harvie Brown for information, comments and corrections relating to Scottish birds.

He modelled the scheme of his Birds book on Rolland's La Faune Populaire de la France. His work was reviewed in the respected scientific and literary journals The Athenaeum, Nature, and The Academy in 1887, and the interest excited by his newly published work prompted a correspondent to the Ceylon Observer to collect from local people some dialect names and folk-lore about Sri Lanka's birds, which were noted in the journal Nature.

Swainson drew on sources from as far afield as Norway, Iceland, France, Germany, and Russia; relied on the great ornithological histories of Bewick and Yarrell; referred to the poetry of John Clare and the works of Shakespeare; drew examples from the lives of the saints and the legends of the middle ages; and referred widely to local English, Scottish and Irish glossaries and collections or provincial names for the birds. Many proverbs, songs and sayings illuminate and illustrate the natural history, which in turn gives substance and meaning to the folklore and rituals he describes. The whole is a treasure trove of much culture and wisdom, now lost, and of much superstition, now superseded by science.

Some criticisms in these reviews were taken up by Harry Kirke Swann and to some extent addressed in his own Dictionary; mainly, the possibility of dialect words having been omitted, the inclusion of "book-names", the lack of precise reference to Yarrell's 4th edition (edited by Newton and Saunders 1885), and the lack of etymological consistency, in that the root or meaning of all names are not worked out to their origins. The criticisms were mainly unwarranted in that Swainson did not set out to write a dictionary, nor an etymology, may not have been able to include references to Yarrell's 4th edition (which was published as he was preparing his own book for publication, and was in ill-health), and had no compunction about including "book-names" as part of the record.

Legacy and influence

Joseph Wright's English Dialect Dictionary

The English Dialect Society gave a mixed review to Swainson's work upon its publication in 1886. While acknowledging that "the list of local names is the best yet published", they expressed the reservation that Swainson apparently had not consulted any of the Society's own publications, and they concluded that many local or dialect names may have been omitted. They expressed a hope that his work would be built upon. In the same year the Society's founder and president, Professor W. W. Skeat, (author of a dictionary on the Anglo-Saxon roots of the English language), initiated a fund mainly from his own resources in order to set up a new project which would bring the work of the Society to its fulfilment. All 80 published volumes of the Society would be included in a new English Dialect Dictionary, and its compiler, Joseph Wright, a self-taught philologist, would involve a nationwide network of almost a thousand volunteers to assist and contribute to this massive cultural undertaking.

Swainson's work on weather-lore and on provincial birds' names and folk-lore was included in the massive undertaking which became The English Dialect Dictionary, published in six volumes between 1898 and 1905. It was dedicated to Professor Skeat, who had contributed so much to its inception. "It was no longer necessary to carry on the work of the English Dialect Society", as Wright says in his preface to the dictionary, and so, in 1896, it was disbanded.

Two major works on birds' names followed which cite Swainson as a major source: Harry Kirke Swann's dictionary of bird names, folk-names and lore (1913), which cites Swainson's work ahead of all other sources as "the first work approaching the scheme of the present volume", and Lockwood's Oxford dictionary of bird names (1984), which cites The English Dialect Dictionary, and Swainson's list of provincial names which it contains, as the second of its chief sources.

Harry Kirke Swann's Dictionary of English & Folk-names of British Birds

Charles Swainson's original and compendious research formed the foundation of several subsequent major works of ornithological literature, including William B. Lockwood's Oxford Dictionary of British Bird Names and Harry Kirke Swann's A Dictionary of English and Folk-Names of British Birds; with their History, Meaning and First Usage, and the Folk-Lore, Weather-Lore, Legends Etc Relating to the More Familiar Species.

In the latter work, Kirke Swann pays tribute to Charles Swainson in the first part of his introduction, and subsequently mentions other major works he has made use of, from Turner (1544) to Ray and Willughby (1678). He refers throughout his work to Swainson's names and derivations, and paraphrases parts of Swainson's original collection in his dictionary, published in the year of Swainson's death in 1913. An example of this practice is given in his article on the Redbreast (pp 189-190), where he briefly summarises parts of the Redbreast article (pp 13-18) in Swainson, which consists of original detailed research which is attributed, analysed and contexualised.

Swann, in the Preface to his dictionary, describes Swainson as sourcing and describing the meanings of over 2000 bird names, where Alfred Newton, an authority on the subject, and a member of the ornithological "establishment", had described "a great many less" in his Dictionary of Birds (1893). Kirke Swann claims to have covered about 5000 names in his own 1913 dictionary, but admits that this number includes variations or alternative spellings.

Swann offers his view that Swainson's work suffers somewhat by not being laid out like a dictionary. As Swainson avers in his Preface, his work follows the classification and nomenclature of the List of British Birds set out by a Committee of the British Ornithologists' Union, London, 1883.

Swann also offers his view that Swainson does not attempt to deal with the important matter of book-names of species. Swainson's provincial and vernacular names are all grouped under the heading of the accepted name for each species, as listed by the authoritative BOU.

In his Bibliography of Ornithology from the Earliest Times to the End of 1912, Kirke Swann pens a biographical note about Swainson and on pp 566-567 says "his 'Provincial Names and Folk-Lore of British Birds' has always been held in high esteem as a valuable contribution to the literature of ornithology".

W B Lockwood's Oxford Dictionary of Bird Names

In the former work, Lockwood in his Oxford Dictionary of Bird Names goes so far as to name his two main sources in this way: "The following books have been our chief sources: Firstly, the Oxford English Dictionary, 1884-1933, and its Supplement, 1972-, with its rich documentation reaching back to the earliest period of the language... Next, the English Dialect Dictionary, 1898-1905, a great repository of local names known to have been in use since 1700; it incorporates the collection found in Charles Swainson, Provincial Names ... of British Birds, 1885."

Swainson was member of both the English Dialect Society, and of the Folk-Lore Society, for both of whom he published his seminal book on birds' names and folklore.

Francesca Greenoak British Birds: Their Folklore, Names and Literature

Swainson is still widely referenced today as an authoritative and reliable source, for example by Francesca Greenoak in her British Birds; their Folklore, Names and Literature (1997) which was originally published by Andre Deutsch in 1979 as All the Birds of the Air, and by Stephen Moss in Mrs Moreau's Warbler; How Birds Got Their Names which treats principally of eponymous bird names, and of the people these names refer to, who often have little or no connection to the bird itself. Moss also includes lengthy quotations which he attributes erroneously to Charles Swainson; these are in fact attributable to William Swainson (on Latham and the merits of his works and of his memory, p 144 and p 320).

One of the principal "field guides" which were mainly concerned with bird identification in the field was published as a revised edition in 1966 (reprinted 1973) and gave alternative names as a point of interest for most familiar species. The Collins Pocket Guide To British Birds by R.S.R. Fitter and R.A. Richardson gave many provincial, vernacular and alternative names for the birds, some with a brief derivation or interpretation. It gave no attribution or source for these, mentioning only under "Names" on p12: "all alternative names in current use, whether book-names or folk-names, are given as well, but it has not been easy to find out which folk-names are still in current use."

Bob Montgomery of the American Ornithological Society in his 2017 article Bird Names Then and Now credits Charles Swainson with compiling "the names of common birds from both folklore and regional dialects across England and Scotland, and several books have since been published on the sources of common names in use today".