Wikipedia:Peer review/TS-19/archive1

TS-19

This peer review discussion has been closed.
This article has reached GA status not too long ago, and I would like to nominate to FA status eventually. I have become more confident with my prose, but I'm still a little iffy as to whether it meets the featured article criteria. I would like some feedback on the current state of the article, and some suggestions on how to improve it.

Thanks, —DAP388 (talk) 17:49, 27 May 2012 (UTC)

Comments

• " the group finally " who's "the group"? For this to standalone as an FA, we need to understand what "the group" means.
• Any reason why "Daryl Dixon" is redlinked in the infobox?
• "and a 3.4 rating in" as a Brit, I have no idea whatsoever what that means.
• "highest-rated telecast in its first season." context? In the US?
• "walkers" you need to explain the zombie apocalypse you mention in the lead is directly relevant to the word "walker".
• "which Rick agrees to" -> "to which Rick agrees."
• "such as showers and wine," -> "such as taking showers and drinking wine..."
• Not sure we really need to link "suicide" or "rape" in an article in English Wikipedia, pretty common terms.
• "but is unsuccessful" perhaps just me but it's an odd turn of phrase when referring to a failed rape attempt.
• " to 8 hours after" eight.
• "if it can't power" avoid contractions.
• Don't force image sizes (other than lead images), so portrait images should be thumb|upright and landscape should be thumb only.
• Don't think you need "pictured" in an image caption.
• " ultimately explodes shortly thereafter" either ultimately or shortly thereafter, both not required.
• "The opening and concluding scenes of "TS-19" are reminiscent..." maybe note that "It has been noted that.." or similar since you're stating a kind of opinion here.
• Apparently New York Daily News is actually just Daily News (from New York)...
• Time Inc. has no comma.
• Wall Street Journal has a The included.
• Check ref titles meet WP:DASH.

The Rambling Man (talk) 17:07, 6 June 2012 (UTC)