"Taylor Swift just needs to rest, frankly," said Andrew Mall, an ethnomusicologist at Northeastern University.
It's a wholly reasonable sentiment when you look at what the megastar, who turns 35 on Friday, has accomplished, including releasing nine albums in five years alongside a concert feature film.
The career-spanning global odyssey of a tour she just staged was like nothing that came before it: 149 shows across the world that typically clocked in at more than three hours long each.
ALSO READ: Taylor Swift gets apology from Billboard for using controversial 'naked' Kanye West clip once she called 'revenge porn'
Popular in International
For Kristin Lieb, an expert at Emerson College on pop, gender and branding, the question of what's next isn't even particularly fair.
"The minute you finish a marathon, or the minute you win the World Series, or the minute somebody gets tenure, you know, the first question is, what are you going to do next?" she told AFP.
"I'm starting to make sense of that as a real cultural sickness."
ALSO READ: What is Taylor Swift-Travis Kelce's couple song? NFL star drops a hint
'Up to her'
But in an industry that's constantly seeking what's young, new or fresh, "what's next" is nevertheless always front of mind.The Swifties are still waiting on more "Taylor's Version" albums: Since 2021 Swift has been making good on her vow to re-record her first six studio records in a bid to own the rights to them.
Swift also has the Grammys in early February to look forward to, with six nominations including three in the most prestigious categories for her latest studio album, "The Tortured Poets Department," her fifth since 2019.
ALSO READ: Taylor Swift named No. 2 greatest pop star of the 21st century by Billboard. Who will top the chart?
At this year's gala she used her award acceptance speeches to announce that new album -- another surprise up her sleeve would surely delight fans.
But looking past "what's next" is perhaps a larger question: how does an artist define success when they're already a cultural phenomenon, awash in riches and fame?
"The good news for her is, like, she's literally the biggest star in the world, and so that is entirely up to her at this point," said Lieb.
Live albums, a Vegas residency, further extending her incredibly recognizable brand into products? Anything is possible at the House of Swift.
Years ago it was announced she had penned an original screenplay and would be making her feature directorial debut with Searchlight Pictures -- so maybe she now has her sights set on the Oscars.
ALSO READ: Apple IPO anniversary: A $1000 investment 44 years ago would have made you richer by 249,900% by now
Swiftie loyalty
In any case, at this point Swift doesn't necessarily need to keep her fans constantly fed to keep them loyal.She's fostered a community that is somewhat self-sustaining -- a contemporary, mostly online version of the fan engagement the Grateful Dead pioneered, which saw Deadheads commune in their reverence for the band.
Swifties might honor a request from their beloved to give her time and space, Lieb said -- "I do think that she's cultivated a relationship with them such that they could hear that and respect that."
The Eras tour, Mall pointed out, also bloomed from years of prolific music-making and audience-building -- so she might need time to develop more material before accomplishing another feat of that magnitude, if that's a goal of hers.
ALSO READ: Taylor Swift-Travis Kelce's love story to be made into Broadway big drama? Power couple weighing up $7.5m show offer
And in the mix of everyone else's expectations, Lieb said Swift might want to take a moment to consider what it is she herself wants: "What would be challenging and fulfilling for her?"
Swift does of course have a personal life, famously so: for more than a year she's been very publicly dating NFL star Travis Kelce, and might want simply enjoy herself and the fruits of her labor.
And in the grand scheme of it all, a key question remains: "Do we need Taylor Swift, or does she need us?" said Mall. "I think she doesn't need us, right?"
"And maybe we do her."