Confession Conundrum: Penance, Forgiveness, And Sin

The act of showing up for confession does not guarantee forgiveness of sins. However, it is an indication of contrition, which is sorrow of the soul and detestation for the sin committed, together with a resolution not to sin again. While sins are forgiven by the sacrament even if the penance is not performed, penance is still important as it helps to internalise forgiveness and change oneself.

Sins are forgiven by the sacrament, even if the penance is never performed

The sacrament of confession is a gift from God, who desires to forgive us and embrace us with joy. It is a concrete, visible, and audible way of experiencing God's forgiveness. Through the sacrament, we are able to reflect on our sins, pronounce them out loud, and hear the words of forgiveness. This process is essential for our spiritual growth and transformation.

The act of penance is not directly linked to the forgiveness of sins. Even if we are unable to complete our penance or encounter difficulties in doing so, our sins are still forgiven through the sacrament. The forgiveness we receive is not dependent on our ability to perform penance but is a result of Christ's sacrifice on the cross.

However, penance plays a crucial role in our spiritual journey. It is not about earning God's love or forgiveness but about taking steps towards transformation. When we are forgiven, the door to a changed relationship with God and a new life is opened. Penance helps us to internalize that forgiveness and allow it to change us from within. It is the first step towards living a life that reflects our newfound reconciliation with God.

If a penitent feels that the penance they received is too challenging or impossible to fulfil, they have the option to request a different penance from the same confessor or another confessor. This ensures that the penitent can perform their penance with clarity and confidence, taking those first steps towards a new direction in their spiritual life.

In conclusion, while the sacrament of confession forgives our sins, the act of penance is about allowing that forgiveness to take root in our hearts and bear fruit in our lives. It is a process of transformation and growth, enabling us to leave our sins behind and embrace a new course in life.

The act of showing up for confession does not, in itself, obtain forgiveness of sins

Confession is an odd thing. It involves declaring one's deepest, darkest sins out loud and receiving words of forgiveness even before completing the assigned penance. This can lead to the question of whether penance is necessary if sins have already been forgiven.

The answer is that doing penance is not a way of earning God's forgiveness, nor is going to confession. Christ's sacrifice on the cross has already won us that forgiveness, and it is made present by the work of His Holy Spirit. However, forgiveness alone does not change us intrinsically. We must internalize that forgiveness, allowing it to transform us and set us on a new course.

Doing penance after confession is about taking those first steps in a new direction. It is about realizing that Christ's forgiveness is not just an abstract concept but a catalyst for personal growth and change. The grace of the sacrament works by changing our hearts, and if our hearts are truly changed, our actions will follow suit.

Therefore, while showing up for confession is a crucial step in seeking forgiveness for one's sins, it is not sufficient in itself. One must also engage in the process of penance to fully embrace the transformative power of God's grace.

Contrition does forgive sins when it is perfect

The Catechism explains that "When it arises from a love by which God is loved above all else, contrition is called 'perfect' (contrition of charity). Such contrition remits venial sins; it also obtains forgiveness of mortal sins if it includes the firm resolution to have recourse to sacramental confession as soon as possible."

Perfect contrition is a sorrow for sin that arises from the love of God. It is a recognition that sin is offensive to God, who is infinitely good and perfect. This type of contrition includes the intention of going to confession and seeking forgiveness. Even before the reception of the sacrament, sins are forgiven through perfect contrition, just as lepers in the Bible were cured before they reached the priests.

In contrast, imperfect contrition, or attrition, is a sorrow for sin that arises from the fear of punishment or other supernatural motives. While imperfect contrition is sufficient to receive pardon for sins during sacramental confession, perfect contrition is necessary when we cannot get to confession.

It is important to note that the act of perfect contrition includes the desire for the sacrament of Penance and the intention to receive sacramental confession as soon as possible. This promise is crucial, as it demonstrates our commitment to reconciliation with God.

Perfect contrition is a gift from God, and we can always seek it in any circumstance and at any time. It is a sure cure for our sins and a way to obtain God's forgiveness and grace.

The doing of penance is not a direct relation to the forgiveness received

In the Catholic Church, the doing of penance is not directly related to the forgiveness of sins. This means that even if an individual is unable to complete a penance, their sins are still forgiven by the sacrament. However, it is important to note that this does not mean that penance is unnecessary or unimportant.

The Purpose of Penance

Penance is not a way of earning God's forgiveness. Christ has already won forgiveness for humanity through his sacrifice on the cross. Instead, penance is about taking the first steps in a new direction and allowing God's transforming love to change one's heart and set them on a new course in life. It is a way to internalize forgiveness and ensure that it has truly changed the individual.

The Role of Confession

Confession, or sacramental confession, is the act of telling one's sins to a priest. It is not a way to earn forgiveness, but rather a means for individuals to reflect deeply on their lives and become aware of their wrongdoings. It takes courage to pronounce one's sins out loud and to admit them to another person. Through confession, individuals can hear the words of forgiveness and know that God has forgiven them.

The Importance of Forgiveness

Forgiveness is the first step in the process of reconciliation and a changed relationship with God. It is not the final step. The next step is for the individual to allow God's love to change their heart and set them on a new path. Penance helps individuals take those initial steps towards a new direction and a transformed life in Christ.

Seeking Guidance

If an individual feels that the penance they have received is too difficult or impossible to fulfil, they have the option to ask the same or another confessor to change it. This ensures that penance remains a meaningful and achievable part of the sacrament.

God's grace works over time, and God works in His own time

God's grace is His "favor and kindness" towards us. It is the unmerited mercy that is freely given to all mankind. God's grace is evident in the beauty of nature, in close calls that could have been accidents, and in the innate conscience that helps us differentiate right from wrong.

God's grace is also evident in the sacrament of confession. Even if the assigned penance is never performed, sins are forgiven by the sacrament. God's grace works over time, and He works in His own time. This is evident in the story of the children of Israel and their 40-year journey in the wilderness, a direct result of their disobedience, grumbling, and unbelief. God's grace was still at work, meeting their immediate needs and ensuring their clothing and shoes never wore out.

God's grace is further evident in the numerous ways He forgives us. When we repent, He forgives us, and He also gives us the ability to forgive others. Every day is a new opportunity to start over and do better. God's grace gives us the self-control to act with kindness, goodness, faithfulness, and gentleness.

God's grace gives us freedom—freedom to be ourselves and freedom from the opinions of others. We are "fearfully and wonderfully made with a purposeful design." Knowing this, we can faithfully serve God and live out our purpose. God's grace is a constant presence, and He is always ready to hold our hand and help us through trials.

God works in His own time, and His grace is sufficient for us. It covers all areas of our lives, and we can always depend on it, even in our brokenness.

Frequently asked questions