Jump to content

Radiative cooling

From Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia
The printable version is no longer supported and may have rendering errors. Please update your browser bookmarks and please use the default browser print function instead.

In the study of heat transfer, radiative cooling[1][2] is the process by which a body loses heat by thermal radiation. As Planck's law describes, every physical body spontaneously and continuously emits electromagnetic radiation.

Radiative cooling has been applied in various contexts throughout human history, including ice making in India and Iran,[3] heat shields for spacecraft,[4] and in architecture.[5] In 2014, a scientific breakthrough in the use of photonic metamaterials made daytime radiative cooling possible.[6][7] It has since been proposed as a strategy to mitigate local and global warming caused by greenhouse gas emissions known as passive daytime radiative cooling.[8]

Terrestrial radiative cooling

Mechanism

Infrared radiation can pass through dry, clear air in the wavelength range of 8–13 μm. Materials that can absorb energy and radiate it in those wavelengths exhibit a strong cooling effect. Materials that can also reflect 95% or more of sunlight in the 200 nanometres to 2.5 μm range can exhibit cooling even in direct sunlight.[9]

Earth's energy budget

The Earth-atmosphere system is radiatively cooled, emitting long-wave (infrared) radiation which balances the absorption of short-wave (visible light) energy from the sun.

Convective transport of heat, and evaporative transport of latent heat are both important in removing heat from the surface and distributing it in the atmosphere. Pure radiative transport is more important higher up in the atmosphere. Diurnal and geographical variation further complicate the picture.

The large-scale circulation of the Earth's atmosphere is driven by the difference in absorbed solar radiation per square meter, as the sun heats the Earth more in the Tropics, mostly because of geometrical factors. The atmospheric and oceanic circulation redistributes some of this energy as sensible heat and latent heat partly via the mean flow and partly via eddies, known as cyclones in the atmosphere. Thus the tropics radiate less to space than they would if there were no circulation, and the poles radiate more; however in absolute terms the tropics radiate more energy to space.

Nocturnal surface cooling

Radiative cooling is commonly experienced on cloudless nights, when heat is radiated into outer space from Earth's surface, or from the skin of a human observer. The effect is well-known among amateur astronomers.

The effect can be experienced by comparing skin temperature from looking straight up into a cloudless night sky for several seconds, to that after placing a sheet of paper between the face and the sky. Since outer space radiates at about a temperature of 3 K (−270.15 °C; −454.27 °F), and the sheet of paper radiates at about 300 K (27 °C; 80 °F) (around room temperature), the sheet of paper radiates more heat to the face than does the darkened cosmos. The effect is blunted by Earth's surrounding atmosphere, and particularly the water vapor it contains, so the apparent temperature of the sky is far warmer than outer space. The sheet does not block the cold, but instead reflects heat to the face and radiates the heat of the face that it just absorbed.

The same radiative cooling mechanism can cause frost or black ice to form on surfaces exposed to the clear night sky, even when the ambient temperature does not fall below freezing.

Kelvin's estimate of the Earth's age

The term radiative cooling is generally used for local processes, though the same principles apply to cooling over geological time, which was first used by Kelvin to estimate the age of the Earth (although his estimate ignored the substantial heat released by radioisotope decay, not known at the time, and the effects of convection in the mantle).

Astronomy

Radiative cooling is one of the few ways an object in space can give off energy. In particular, white dwarf stars are no longer generating energy by fusion or gravitational contraction, and have no solar wind. So the only way their temperature changes is by radiative cooling. This makes their temperature as a function of age very predictable, so by observing the temperature, astronomers can deduce the age of the star.[10][11]

Applications

Climate change

PDRC can lower temperatures with zero energy consumption or pollution by radiating heat into outer space. Widespread application has been proposed as a solution to global warming.[12]
Passive daytime radiative cooling (PDRC) (also passive radiative cooling, daytime passive radiative cooling, radiative sky cooling, photonic radiative cooling, and terrestrial radiative cooling[13][14][15][16]) is the use of unpowered, reflective/thermally-emissive surfaces to lower the temperature of a building or other object.[17]

It has been proposed as a method of reducing temperature increases caused by greenhouse gases by reducing the energy needed for air conditioning, [18][19] lowering the urban heat island effect,[20][21] and lowering human body temperatures.[22][12][23][24][18]

PDRCs can aid systems that are more efficient at lower temperatures, such as photovoltaic systems,[15][25] dew collection devices, and thermoelectric generators.[26][25]
Passive radiative cooling technologies use the infrared window of 8–13 μm to radiate heat into outer space and impede solar absorption.

Architecture

Different roof materials absorb more or less heat. A higher roof albedo, or the whiter a roof, the higher its solar reflectance and heat emittance, which can reduce energy use and costs.

Cool roofs combine high solar reflectance with high infrared emittance, thereby simultaneously reducing heat gain from the sun and increasing heat removal through radiation. Radiative cooling thus offers potential for passive cooling for residential and commercial buildings.[5] Traditional building surfaces, such as paint coatings, brick and concrete have high emittances of up to 0.96.[27] They radiate heat into the sky to passively cool buildings at night. If made sufficiently reflective to sunlight, these materials can also achieve radiative cooling during the day.

The most common radiative coolers found on buildings are white cool-roof paint coatings, which have solar reflectances of up to 0.94, and thermal emittances of up to 0.96.[28] The solar reflectance of the paints arises from optical scattering by the dielectric pigments embedded in the polymer paint resin, while the thermal emittance arises from the polymer resin. However, because typical white pigments like titanium dioxide and zinc oxide absorb ultraviolet radiation, the solar reflectances of paints based on such pigments do not exceed 0.95.

In 2014, researchers developed the first daytime radiative cooler using a multi-layer thermal photonic structure that selectively emits long wavelength infrared radiation into space, and can achieve 5 °C sub-ambient cooling under direct sunlight.[29] Later researchers developed paintable porous polymer coatings, whose pores scatter sunlight to give solar reflectance of 0.96-0.99 and thermal emittance of 0.97.[30] In experiments under direct sunlight, the coatings achieve 6 °C sub-ambient temperatures and cooling powers of 96 W/m2.

Other notable radiative cooling strategies include dielectric films on metal mirrors,[31] and polymer or polymer composites on silver or aluminum films.[32] Silvered polymer films with solar reflectances of 0.97 and thermal emittance of 0.96, which remain 11 °C cooler than commercial white paints under the mid-summer sun, were reported in 2015.[33] Researchers explored designs with dielectric silicon dioxide or silicon carbide particles embedded in polymers that are translucent in the solar wavelengths and emissive in the infrared.[34][35] In 2017, an example of this design with resonant polar silica microspheres randomly embedded in a polymeric matrix, was reported.[36] The material is translucent to sunlight and has infrared emissivity of 0.93 in the infrared atmospheric transmission window. When backed with silver coating, the material achieved a midday radiative cooling power of 93 W/m2 under direct sunshine along with high-throughput, economical roll-to-roll manufacturing.

Heat shields

High emissivity coatings that facilitate radiative cooling may be used in reusable thermal protection systems (RTPS) in spacecraft and hypersonic aircraft. In such heat shields a high emissivity material, such as molybdenum disilicide (MoSi2) is applied on a thermally insulating ceramic substrate.[4] In such heat shields high levels of total emissivity, typically in the range 0.8 - 0.9, need to be maintained across a range of high temperatures. Planck's law dictates that at higher temperatures the radiative emission peak shifts to lower wavelengths (higher frequencies), influencing material selection as a function of operating temperature. In addition to effective radiative cooling, radiative thermal protection systems should provide damage tolerance and may incorporate self-healing functions through the formation of a viscous glass at high temperatures.

James Webb Space Telescope

The James Webb Space Telescope uses radiative cooling to reach its operation temperature of about 50 K. To do this, its large reflective sunshield blocks radiation from the Sun, Earth, and Moon. The telescope structure, kept permanently in shadow by the sunshield, then cools by radiation.

Nocturnal ice making in early India and Iran

Radiative cooling energy budget in a yakhchāl
Radiative cooling energy budget
Ice pool beside the Meybod yakhchāl in Iran
Ice Pool beside the Meybod yakhchāl in Iran

Before the invention of artificial refrigeration technology, ice making by nocturnal cooling was common in both India and Iran.

In India, such apparatuses consisted of a shallow ceramic tray with a thin layer of water, placed outdoors with a clear exposure to the night sky. The bottom and sides were insulated with a thick layer of hay. On a clear night the water would lose heat by radiation upwards. Provided the air was calm and not too far above freezing, heat gain from the surrounding air by convection was low enough to allow the water to freeze.[37][38][3]

In Iran, this involved making large flat ice pools, which consisted of a reflection pool of water built on a bed of highly insulative material surrounded by high walls. The high walls provided protection against convective warming, the insulative material of the pool walls would protect against conductive heating from the ground, the large flat plane of water would then permit evaporative and radiative cooling to take place.

Types

Earth's longwave thermal radiation intensity, from clouds, atmosphere and surface

The three basic types of radiant cooling are direct, indirect, and fluorescent:

  • Direct radiant cooling - In a building designed to optimize direct radiation cooling, the building roof acts as a heat sink to absorb the daily internal loads. The roof acts as the best heat sink because it is the greatest surface exposed to the night sky. Radiate heat transfer with the night sky will remove heat from the building roof, thus cooling the building structure. Roof ponds are an example of this strategy. The roof pond design became popular with the development of the Sky thermal system designed by Harold Hay in 1977. There are various designs and configurations for the roof pond system but the concept is the same for all designs. The roof uses water, either plastic bags filled with water or an open pond, as the heat sink while a system of movable insulation panels regulate the mode of heating or cooling. During daytime in the summer, the water on the roof is protected from the solar radiation and ambient air temperature by movable insulation, which allows it to serve as a heat sink and absorb the heat generated inside through the ceiling. At night, the panels are retracted to allow nocturnal radiation between the roof pond and the night sky, thus removing the stored heat. In winter, the process is reversed so that the roof pond is allowed to absorb solar radiation during the day and release it during the night into the space below.[39][40]
  • Indirect radiant cooling - A heat transfer fluid removes heat from the building structure through radiate heat transfer with the night sky. A common design for this strategy involves a plenum between the building roof and the radiator surface. Air is drawn into the building through the plenum, cooled from the radiator, and cools the mass of the building structure. During the day, the building mass acts as a heat sink.
  • Fluorescent radiant cooling - An object can be made fluorescent: it will then absorb light at some wavelengths, but radiate the energy away again at other, selected wavelengths. By selectively radiating heat in the infrared atmospheric window, a range of frequencies in which the atmosphere is unusually transparent, an object can effectively use outer space as a heat sink, and cool to well below ambient air temperature.[41][42][43]

See also

References

  1. ^ Fan, Shanhui; Li, Wei (March 2022). "Photonics and thermodynamics concepts in radiative cooling". Nature Photonics. 16 (3): 182–190. Bibcode:2022NaPho..16..182F. doi:10.1038/s41566-021-00921-9. S2CID 246668570.
  2. ^ Li, Wei; Fan, Shanhui (1 November 2019). "Radiative Cooling: Harvesting the Coldness of the Universe". Optics and Photonics News. 30 (11): 32. Bibcode:2019OptPN..30...32L. doi:10.1364/OPN.30.11.000032. S2CID 209957921.
  3. ^ a b "The Persian ice house, or how to make ice in the desert". Field Study of the World. 2016-04-04. Retrieved 2019-04-28.
  4. ^ a b Shao, Gaofeng; et al. (2019). "Improved oxidation resistance of high emissivity coatings on fibrous ceramic for reusable space systems". Corrosion Science. 146: 233–246. arXiv:1902.03943. Bibcode:2019Corro.146..233S. doi:10.1016/j.corsci.2018.11.006. S2CID 118927116.
  5. ^ a b Hossain, Md Muntasir; Gu, Min (2016-02-04). "Radiative cooling: Principles, progress and potentials". Advanced Science. 3 (7): 1500360. doi:10.1002/advs.201500360. PMC 5067572. PMID 27812478.
  6. ^ Heo, Se-Yeon; Ju Lee, Gil; Song, Young Min (June 2022). "Heat-shedding with photonic structures: radiative cooling and its potential". Journal of Materials Chemistry C. 10 (27): 9915–9937. doi:10.1039/D2TC00318J. S2CID 249695930 – via Royal Society of Chemistry.
  7. ^ Raman, Aaswath P.; Anoma, Marc Abou; Zhu, Linxiao; Raphaeli, Eden; Fan, Shanhui (2014). "Passive Radiative Cooling Below Ambient air Temperature under Direct Sunlight". Nature. 515 (7528): 540–544. Bibcode:2014Natur.515..540R. doi:10.1038/nature13883. PMID 25428501. S2CID 4382732 – via nature.com.
  8. ^ Munday, Jeremy (2019). "Tackling Climate Change through Radiative Cooling". Joule. 3 (9): 2057–2060. Bibcode:2019Joule...3.2057M. doi:10.1016/j.joule.2019.07.010. S2CID 201590290.
  9. ^ Lim, XiaoZhi (2019-12-31). "The super-cool materials that send heat to space". Nature. 577 (7788): 18–20. doi:10.1038/d41586-019-03911-8. PMID 31892746.
  10. ^ Mestel, L. (1952). "On the theory of white dwarf stars. I. The energy sources of white dwarfs". Monthly Notices of the Royal Astronomical Society. 112 (6): 583–597. Bibcode:1952MNRAS.112..583M. doi:10.1093/mnras/112.6.583.
  11. ^ "Cooling white dwarfs" (PDF). Physics Department, University of Patras.
  12. ^ a b Chen, Meijie; Pang, Dan; Chen, Xingyu; Yan, Hongjie; Yang, Yuan (2022). "Passive daytime radiative cooling: Fundamentals, material designs, and applications". EcoMat. 4. doi:10.1002/eom2.12153. S2CID 240331557. Passive daytime radiative cooling (PDRC) dissipates terrestrial heat to the extremely cold outer space without using any energy input or producing pollution. It has the potential to simultaneously alleviate the two major problems of energy crisis and global warming.
  13. ^ Wang, Tong; Wu, Yi; Shi, Lan; Hu, Xinhua; Chen, Min; Wu, Limin (2021). "A structural polymer for highly efficient all-day passive radiative cooling". Nature Communications. 12 (365): 365. doi:10.1038/s41467-020-20646-7. PMC 7809060. PMID 33446648. Accordingly, designing and fabricating efficient PDRC with sufficiently high solar reflectance (𝜌¯solar) (λ ~ 0.3–2.5 μm) to minimize solar heat gain and simultaneously strong LWIR thermal emittance (ε¯LWIR) to maximize radiative heat loss is highly desirable. When the incoming radiative heat from the Sun is balanced by the outgoing radiative heat emission, the temperature of the Earth can reach its steady state.
  14. ^ Zevenhovena, Ron; Fält, Martin (June 2018). "Radiative cooling through the atmospheric window: A third, less intrusive geoengineering approach". Energy. 152: 27. Bibcode:2018Ene...152...27Z. doi:10.1016/j.energy.2018.03.084. S2CID 116318678 – via Elsevier Science Direct. An alternative, third geoengineering approach would be enhanced cooling by thermal radiation from the Earth's surface into space." [...] "With 100 W m2 as a demonstrated passive cooling effect, a surface coverage of 0.3% would then be needed, or 1% of Earth's land mass surface. If half of it would be installed in urban, built areas which cover roughly 3% of the Earth's land mass, a 17% coverage would be needed there, with the remainder being installed in rural areas.
  15. ^ a b Heo, Se-Yeon; Ju Lee, Gil; Song, Young Min (June 2022). "Heat-shedding with photonic structures: radiative cooling and its potential". Journal of Materials Chemistry C. 10 (27): 9915–9937. doi:10.1039/D2TC00318J. S2CID 249695930 – via Royal Society of Chemistry.
  16. ^ Aili, Ablimit; Yin, Xiaobo; Yang, Ronggui (October 2021). "Global Radiative Sky Cooling Potential Adjusted for Population Density and Cooling Demand". Atmosphere. 12 (11): 1379. Bibcode:2021Atmos..12.1379A. doi:10.3390/atmos12111379.
  17. ^ Chen, Jianheng; Lu, Lin; Gong, Quan (June 2021). "A new study on passive radiative sky cooling resource maps of China". Energy Conversion and Management. 237: 114132. Bibcode:2021ECM...23714132C. doi:10.1016/j.enconman.2021.114132. S2CID 234839652 – via Elsevier Science Direct. Passive radiative cooling utilizes atmospheric transparency window (8–13 μm) to discharge heat into outer space and inhibits solar absorption.
  18. ^ a b Bijarniya, Jay Prakash; Sarkar, Jahar; Maiti, Pralay (November 2020). "Review on passive daytime radiative cooling: Fundamentals, recent researches, challenges and opportunities". Renewable and Sustainable Energy Reviews. 133: 110263. Bibcode:2020RSERv.13310263B. doi:10.1016/j.rser.2020.110263. S2CID 224874019 – via Elsevier Science Direct.
  19. ^ Benmoussa, Youssef; Ezziani, Maria; Djire, All-Fousseni; Amine, Zaynab; Khaldoun, Asmae; Limami, Houssame (September 2022). "Simulation of an energy-efficient cool roof with cellulose-based daytime radiative cooling material". Materials Today: Proceedings. 72: 3632–3637. doi:10.1016/j.matpr.2022.08.411. S2CID 252136357 – via Elsevier Science Direct.
  20. ^ Khan, Ansar; Carlosena, Laura; Feng, Jie; Khorat, Samiran; Khatun, Rupali; Doan, Quang-Van; Santamouris, Mattheos (January 2022). "Optically Modulated Passive Broadband Daytime Radiative Cooling Materials Can Cool Cities in Summer and Heat Cities in Winter". Sustainability. 14 – via MDPI.
  21. ^ Anand, Jyothis; Sailor, David J.; Baniassadi, Amir (February 2021). "The relative role of solar reflectance and thermal emittance for passive daytime radiative cooling technologies applied to rooftops". Sustainable Cities and Society. 65: 102612. Bibcode:2021SusCS..6502612A. doi:10.1016/j.scs.2020.102612. S2CID 229476136 – via Elsevier Science Direct.
  22. ^ Liang, Jun; Wu, Jiawei; Guo, Jun; Li, Huagen; Zhou, Xianjun; Liang, Sheng; Qiu, Cheng-Wei; Tao, Guangming (September 2022). "Radiative cooling for passive thermal management towards sustainable carbon neutrality". National Science Review. 10 (1): nwac208. doi:10.1093/nsr/nwac208. PMC 9843130. PMID 36684522.
  23. ^ Munday, Jeremy (2019). "Tackling Climate Change through Radiative Cooling". Joule. 3 (9): 2057–2060. Bibcode:2019Joule...3.2057M. doi:10.1016/j.joule.2019.07.010. S2CID 201590290. By covering the Earth with a small fraction of thermally emitting materials, the heat flow away from the Earth can be increased, and the net radiative flux can be reduced to zero (or even made negative), thus stabilizing (or cooling) the Earth.
  24. ^ Yin, Xiaobo; Yang, Ronggui; Tan, Gang; Fan, Shanhui (November 2020). "Terrestrial radiative cooling: Using the cold universe as a renewable and sustainable energy source". Science. 370 (6518): 786–791. Bibcode:2020Sci...370..786Y. doi:10.1126/science.abb0971. PMID 33184205. S2CID 226308213. ...terrestrial radiative cooling has emerged as a promising solution for mitigating urban heat islands and for potentially fighting against global warming if it can be implemented at a large scale.
  25. ^ a b Ahmed, Salman; Li, Zhenpeng; Javed, Muhammad Shahzad; Ma, Tao (September 2021). "A review on the integration of radiative cooling and solar energy harvesting". Materials Today: Energy. 21: 100776. Bibcode:2021MTEne..2100776A. doi:10.1016/j.mtener.2021.100776 – via Elsevier Science Direct.
  26. ^ Heo, Se-Yeon; Ju Lee, Gil; Song, Young Min (June 2022). "Heat-shedding with photonic structures: radiative cooling and its potential". Journal of Materials Chemistry C. 10 (27): 9915–9937. doi:10.1039/D2TC00318J. S2CID 249695930 – via Royal Society of Chemistry.
  27. ^ "Emissivity Coefficients Materials". www.engineeringtoolbox.com. Retrieved 2019-02-23.
  28. ^ "Find rated products – Cool Roof Rating Council". coolroofs.org. Retrieved 2019-02-23.
  29. ^ Raman, Aaswath P.; Anoma, Marc Abou; Zhu, Linxiao; Rephaeli, Eden; Fan, Shanhui (November 2014). "Passive radiative cooling below ambient air temperature under direct sunlight". Nature. 515 (7528): 540–544. Bibcode:2014Natur.515..540R. doi:10.1038/nature13883. PMID 25428501. S2CID 4382732.
  30. ^ Mandal, Jyotirmoy; Fu, Yanke; Overvig, Adam; Jia, Mingxin; Sun, Kerui; Shi, Norman Nan; Yu, Nanfang; Yang, Yuan (19 October 2018). "Hierarchically porous polymer coatings for highly efficient passive daytime radiative cooling". Science. 362 (6412): 315–319. Bibcode:2018Sci...362..315M. doi:10.1126/science.aat9513. PMID 30262632.
  31. ^ Granqvist, C. G.; Hjortsberg, A. (June 1981). "Radiative cooling to low temperatures: General considerations and application to selectively emitting SiO films". Journal of Applied Physics. 52 (6): 4205–4220. Bibcode:1981JAP....52.4205G. doi:10.1063/1.329270.
  32. ^ Grenier, Ph. (January 1979). "Réfrigération radiative. Effet de serre inverse". Revue de Physique Appliquée. 14 (1): 87–90. doi:10.1051/rphysap:0197900140108700.
  33. ^ Gentle, Angus R.; Smith, Geoff B. (September 2015). "A Subambient Open Roof Surface under the Mid-Summer Sun". Advanced Science. 2 (9): 1500119. doi:10.1002/advs.201500119. PMC 5115392. PMID 27980975.
  34. ^ Gentle, A. R.; Smith, G. B. (2010-02-10). "Radiative Heat Pumping from the Earth Using Surface Phonon Resonant Nanoparticles". Nano Letters. 10 (2): 373–379. Bibcode:2010NanoL..10..373G. doi:10.1021/nl903271d. PMID 20055479.
  35. ^ WO 2016205717A1, Yu, Nanfang; Mandalal, Jyotirmoy; Overvig, Adam and Shi, Norman Nan, "Systems and methods for radiative cooling and heating", issued 2016-06-17 
  36. ^ Zhai, Yao; Ma, Yaoguang; David, Sabrina N.; Zhao, Dongliang; Lou, Runnan; Tan, Gang; Yang, Ronggui; Yin, Xiaobo (2017-03-10). "Scalable-manufactured randomized glass-polymer hybrid metamaterial for daytime radiative cooling". Science. 355 (6329): 1062–1066. Bibcode:2017Sci...355.1062Z. doi:10.1126/science.aai7899. PMID 28183998.
  37. ^ "Lesson 1: History Of Refrigeration, Version 1 ME" (PDF). Indian Institute of Technology Kharagpur. Archived from the original (PDF) on 2011-12-16.
  38. ^ "XXII. The process of making ice in the East Indies. By Sir Robert Barker, F. R. S. in a letter to Dr. Brocklesby". Philosophical Transactions of the Royal Society of London. 65: 252–257. 1997. doi:10.1098/rstl.1775.0023. JSTOR 106193.
  39. ^ Givoni, Baruch (1994). Passive and Low Energy Cooling of Buildings (1st ed.). New York, NY: John Wiley & Sons, Inc. ISBN 978-0-471-28473-4.
  40. ^ Sharifi, Ayyoob; Yamagata, Yoshiki (December 2015). "Roof ponds as passive heating and cooling systems: A systematic review". Applied Energy. 160: 336–357. Bibcode:2015ApEn..160..336S. doi:10.1016/j.apenergy.2015.09.061.
  41. ^ Raman, Aaswath P.; Anoma, Marc Abou; Zhu, Linxiao; Rephaeli, Eden; Fan, Shanhui (November 2014). "Passive radiative cooling below ambient air temperature under direct sunlight". Nature. 515 (7528): 540–544. Bibcode:2014Natur.515..540R. doi:10.1038/nature13883. ISSN 1476-4687. PMID 25428501. S2CID 4382732.
  42. ^ Burnett, Michael (November 25, 2015). "Passive Radiative Cooling". large.stanford.edu.
  43. ^ Berdahl, Paul; Chen, Sharon S.; Destaillats, Hugo; Kirchstetter, Thomas W.; Levinson, Ronnen M.; Zalich, Michael A. (December 2016). "Fluorescent cooling of objects exposed to sunlight – The ruby example". Solar Energy Materials and Solar Cells. 157: 312–317. Bibcode:2016SEMSC.157..312B. doi:10.1016/j.solmat.2016.05.058.