BBC History Magazine

THE POET, THE GARDENER AND THE WITCH: FORGOTTEN VOICES OF TUDOR ENGLAND

1 Elizabeth Stile, the condemned witch

Elizabeth Stile was a witch - at least, in the minds of many of her contemporaries. She was 65 years old, widowed, and living in Windsor when she was accused of witchcraft. Together with her associates, she was accused of killing several people and bringing harm to many others, with the help of familiars including a rat, a black cat and a toad.

All of the accused women were poor. Some of their alleged victims had been targeted, it was said, because they had refused to hand out charity, or had been responsible for some other small injustice against these already marginalised women. We might think that these alleged witches were just scapegoats, picked upon because they were already vulnerable, in an attempt to explain misfortunes for which there was no other explanation. Certainly, the one man implicated - who had rather better social standing - does not seem to have been brought to trial.

It was more complicated than that, though, because Stile herself appears to have believed in her own magical powers. While in prison in Reading, she seemingly had a change of heart, confessed all her crimes, and repented her association with the devil - in the process incriminating the three other women with whom she was, in due course, hanged. Her confession formed the basis of a pamphlet, A Rehearsal Both Strange and True, published in 1579, that both told her story - most likely with the intention of titillating its readers and also delivered a heavy-handed dose of pious moralising on the evils of witchcraft.

Elizabethan England was full of uncertainties, fears of the supernatural, and tensions within communities. Concerns about invasion from abroad could combine with fears of

You’re reading a preview, subscribe to read more.

More from BBC History Magazine

BBC History Magazine1 min read
Three Things I’ve Learned This Month
In this month’s Anniversaries, I was intrigued to discover that following Penguin’s victory in the 1960 obscenity trial around Lady Chatterley’s Lover, they sold more than 3 million copies of the novel in just three months (page 9). Because their rei
BBC History Magazine1 min read
Three Things I've Learned This Month
Charles Darwin spent decades researching the animals of the world, but I hadn't previously realised the breadth of his culinary interest in them – and was surprised to learn he'd chowed down on puma, armadillo and even an owl (page 43). Sticking with
BBC History Magazine2 min read
Scandal, Surrealism And The CIA
Sex and spying: it’s hardly surprising that the Profumo affair, involving the war secretary’s liaison with a young model, continues to fascinate us. Archive on 4: The Mandy Rice-Davies Tapes (BBC Radio 4, Saturday 19 October) offers fresh access to a

Related