The American Scholar

OUR PETS, OUR PLATES

Jeremy Bentham scorned polite society but loved his London cats, even the pasta-eating swashbuckler Sir John Langbourne. Life with Langbourne led to feline character-study (“His moral qualities were most despotic—his intellectual extraordinary; but he was a universal nuisance”) and set the philosopher brooding on the rights of birds and beasts. “The question is not, Can they reason?” he wrote in 1780, “nor, Can they talk? but, Can they suffer?

In Monica Murphy and Bill Wasik ably unpack Bentham’s riddle. Their first book, (2012), offered a deft portrait of a single virus. more diffuse but much more ambitious, is at once a model and also the inventor of the flash mob—a useful credential, since the 19thcentury crusade for animal protection was a marvel of culture jamming.

You’re reading a preview, subscribe to read more.

More from The American Scholar

The American Scholar4 min read
Insisting On The Positive
Intellectuals, like baseball players, don't handle every position well. The philosopher tries to write an Umberto Eco novel, but drops the ball. The psychologist decides she's also a poet, but strikes out. Add the historian who transitions into a phi
The American Scholar3 min read
Feels Like Coming Home
I am not the first person to consider a tree a friend. The Giving Tree, A Tree Grows in Brooklyn, and The Secret Life of Trees, just to name a few books, are testaments to the reciprocity between trees and humans. I recall a friend from Israel who wo
The American Scholar23 min readMusic
Anchoring Shards of Memory
JOSEPH HOROWITZ is the author of 13 books exploring the American musical experience. His Naxos documentary €lms include Charles Ives’ America. As director of the NEH-funded “Music Unwound” consortium, he has initiated Ives sesquicentennial celebratio

Related Books & Audiobooks