The Atlantic

My Criminal Record Somehow Vanished

And I got a glimpse of a world where felons like me are not forever haunted by our past.
Source: Illustration by The Atlantic. Source: Tom Kelley Archive / Getty.

Sixteen years ago, during my last semester of law school, I caused a drunk-driving crash that killed my girlfriend. I pleaded guilty to negligent manslaughter and faced up to a decade in prison, but thanks to my girlfriend’s family’s forgiveness and whatever unearned sympathy I received as a middle-class white man, my sentence amounted to a few months in jail followed by several years on probation. Considering the sentences faced by many, I’d been very lucky.

Ever since, I’ve been among the 80 million Americans living with a criminal record and all its consequences. I’ve fantasized about what my life would be like if my record simply vanished. Not long ago, it sort of did—one more instance of a system that’s not just unjust but also capricious and poorly administered.

Given how , a criminal record is not an especially accurate indicator of guilt, nor is it necessarily an indicator of what kind of person someone is, particularly years after what may have been the worst deed of their life. Collateral consequences—legal and regulatory restrictions and discrimination that apply to people

You’re reading a preview, subscribe to read more.

More from The Atlantic

The Atlantic7 min read
The Charisma-vs.-Charm Election
To understand modern politics, including the Kamala Harris and Donald Trump campaigns, distinguishing between two qualities—charisma and charm—is vital. They are different kinds of political magnetism. And thanks to the sociologist Julia Sonnevend, I
The Atlantic8 min read
The Democrats’ Hail Mary
A few years ago, all of this would have been extremely weird. Actually, as the Democrats around me in the theater stood to applaud Liz Cheney—the pro-life, ultraconservative daughter of Dick—it still kind of was. The former third-ranked GOP House lea
The Atlantic3 min read
Trump Is Being Very Honest About One Thing
In the early 17th century, the English jurist Edward Coke laid out a fundamental principle of any constitutional order: No man can be the judge in his own case. Donald Trump thinks he has found a work-around. The Republican presidential candidate yes

Related Books & Audiobooks