Discover millions of ebooks, audiobooks, and so much more with a free trial

Only $11.99/month after trial. Cancel anytime.

Cultures of Growth: How the New Science of Mindset Can Transform Individuals, Teams, and Organizations
Cultures of Growth: How the New Science of Mindset Can Transform Individuals, Teams, and Organizations
Cultures of Growth: How the New Science of Mindset Can Transform Individuals, Teams, and Organizations
Ebook534 pages7 hours

Cultures of Growth: How the New Science of Mindset Can Transform Individuals, Teams, and Organizations

Rating: 0 out of 5 stars

()

Read preview

About this ebook

Award-winning social psychologist Mary Murphy offers a groundbreaking reconsideration of individual and team success—showing how to create and sustain a growth mindset in any organization’s culture.

Carol Dweck’s multi-million-copy bestseller Mindset transformed our view of individual potential, coining the terms “fixed” and “growth” mindset: in a “fixed” mindset, talent and intelligence are viewed as predetermined traits, while in a “growth” mindset, talent and intelligence can be nurtured.

In Cultures of Growth, Dweck’s protégé, Mary Murphy, a social psychologist at both Stanford and Indiana University, shows that mindset transcends individuals. A growth mindset culture can transform any group, team, or classroom to reach breakthroughs while also helping each person achieve their potential.

Murphy’s original decade-long research reveals that organizations and teams more geared toward growth inspire deeper learning, spark collaboration, spur innovation, and build trust necessary for risk-taking and inclusion. They are also less likely to cheat, cut corners, or steal each other’s ideas. And they’re more likely to achieve top results. In these cultures, great ideas come from people from all backgrounds and at all levels—not just those anointed as brilliant or talented.

Discover how a culture of growth helped make outdoor retailer Patagonia a leader in its field; how Satya Nadella transformed Microsoft; how winemakers Robin McBride and Andréa McBride John are leading with a mindset to disrupt and diversify the entire wine industry; and how a New York school superintendent reversed massive inequities for children of color by reshaping the district’s mindset culture. Drawing on compelling examples from her work with Fortune 500 companies, startups, and schools, Murphy demonstrates that an organization’s mindset culture is the key to success for individuals, teams, and the entire organization, teaching you how to create and sustain a culture of growth no matter your role.

Create environments where people want to be, where everyone can thrive and achieve their potential, both individually and together. In a world where success seems reserved for a chosen few, Cultures of Growth unveils a radically different approach to creating organizations that inspire learning, growth, and success at all levels.
LanguageEnglish
Release dateMar 12, 2024
ISBN9781982172763
Author

Mary C. Murphy

Mary C. Murphy holds a Jean Monnet Chair in European Integration and is Senior Lecturer in Politics at University College Cork. Her books include Northern Ireland and the European Union (2014) and The Europeanization of Party Politics in Ireland, North and South (2010) (coeditor).

Read more from Mary C. Murphy

Related to Cultures of Growth

Related ebooks

Leadership For You

View More

Related articles

Reviews for Cultures of Growth

Rating: 0 out of 5 stars
0 ratings

0 ratings0 reviews

What did you think?

Tap to rate

Review must be at least 10 words

    Book preview

    Cultures of Growth - Mary C. Murphy

    Cultures of Growth: How the New Science of Mindset Can Transform Individuals, Teams, and Organizations, by Mary C. Murphy, Ph.D.. Foreword by Carol S. Dweck, bestselling author of Mindset.

    CLICK HERE TO SIGN UP

    Cultures of Growth: How the New Science of Mindset Can Transform Individuals, Teams, and Organizations, by Mary C. Murphy, Ph.D.. Simon & Schuster. New York | London | Toronto | Sydney | New Delhi.

    For Arya, Conner, Ella, Everett, Friday, Jackson, Miles, River, and Tyberius.

    For my love, Victor.

    For you, the culture creators.

    Let’s build Cultures of Growth together.

    Foreword

    One momentous day in 2006, Mary Murphy walked into my office. At the time, she was a much-admired graduate student in our department at Stanford. So, I was delighted when she made an appointment to talk with me, and I couldn’t wait to hear what she had to say. Little did I know that after that conversation there would be no looking back.

    Let me give you some pre-Mary background. Decades of research on mindsets had shown that a person can believe that their important abilities, such as their intelligence, are simply fixed and can’t be developed. Case closed. We called this a fixed mindset, and we showed that it often leads people to shy away from challenges that could reveal low ability; to interpret mistakes or setbacks as reflecting a lack of ability; and therefore, to give up more easily in the face of difficulty. Other people, we found, held more of a growth mindset—the belief that abilities can be developed over time through, say, hard work, good strategies, and lots of help and support from others. And we showed that this belief often leads people to take on challenges that can increase their abilities, to learn from mistakes and setbacks, and therefore to persevere more effectively and accomplish more in the long run.

    When Mary came to my office that day, she said something like this: I love your work and I think it’s important, but you’ve been treating a mindset as something that simply exists in a person’s head. Yes, people do tend toward different mindsets and that can make a big difference—but the environment, the social context, the culture, the organization a person is in can also have a mindset. This mindset can be embodied in the dominant philosophies and practices of the group or organization, and it can powerfully affect the people there, no matter what their individual mindset might be.

    Now, we already knew that although people can favor one mindset or the other, they don’t just sit there in that mindset no matter what. A big setback or failure, for example, can send people into a fixed mindset even if they are usually in more of a growth mindset. But Mary’s idea was more profound than that. She maintained that no matter what personal mindset someone holds, the work or school environment they’re in will have a large impact. That is, people can have all the growth mindset in the world, but there are places where they won’t be able to use it. Those places are fixed mindset environments, or what she calls Cultures of Genius.

    How, exactly, can a work or school environment have a fixed mindset? Its philosophies and practices may be infused with the idea that abilities are simply fixed and cannot be developed—the idea that some people are smart and some just aren’t. Such an environment may value immediate perfect performance with no periods of confusion or struggle. It may value the appearance of genius over the fact of learning and growth. It may value those who seem to have that touch of genius over those that the culture deems do not. And, regardless of a person’s own mindset, the environment’s mindset will often win. It’s hard to take on big challenges or to value and learn from setbacks when you’re being judged as smart or not, worthy or not.

    In short, Mary’s message was: The environment you’re in can have its own mindset culture. It can be a culture that believes in and values the development of all people’s ability. Or it can be a culture that believes in and values fixed ability, a culture that expects some people to have more of it and some people to (permanently) have less of it.

    How did I react to Mary’s announcement in my office? I was super excited. I saw at once that this was a really new and really important idea—an important idea for research and, even more so, an important idea for society. So I said, Let’s do it! And before we knew it, Mary had launched her now-renowned program of research.

    In this research, Mary has demonstrated over and over that organizations and teams that hold a growth mindset and infuse their policies and practices with it have employees who are more motivated and committed, more mutually supportive, and more creative and innovative. They are also less likely to cheat, cut corners, or steal each other’s ideas. In college courses, instructors who create a growth mindset culture have students who are more motivated, learn more, and achieve higher grades. These Cultures of Growth honor every person, support them to grow their abilities, and create the conditions for every person to make a valuable contribution. In these cultures, great ideas and great contributions come from many people at all levels and in all segments of the organization—not just people who have been identified as brilliant, talented, or having high potential.

    I can’t stress enough how new and valuable this perspective was. It meant that it was no longer enough to simply teach members of an organization or classroom to hold a growth mindset. It was no longer just their personal responsibility to act in growth-mindset ways. It was now the responsibility of the leaders of the organization or classroom to create a growth mindset culture, one in which their actual practices motivated, supported, and rewarded learning and growth for everyone. But Mary’s impact didn’t end with this understanding. She inspired all of us doing mindset research to study how we could help create these cultures—by setting out to develop and rigorously test practices for teachers or managers that they can learn to use effectively. My original excitement about Mary’s idea has only grown with time.

    Mary has now studied and worked with countless organizations around the world—both Cultures of Genius and Cultures of Growth. She has learned exactly what they look like, how they operate, and how each mindset plays out. In this book, she shares this fascinating and incredibly valuable information so that all organizations and groups can get on the path of growth—creating cultures that support everyone to fulfill their potential and contribute to the productivity, innovation, and success of the whole. Imagine if this happened on a national or even global level. This is the book that can make it happen.

    —Carol S. Dweck, PhD

    Lewis and Virginia Eaton Professor of Psychology at Stanford University

    Author of Mindset: The New Psychology of Success

    Stanford, California

    Introduction

    Picture it: You’re starting a new job, and you’ve got that big, fresh, first-day energy. For years you’ve wondered what it would be like to work here, and now you’ve landed it—a coveted position at one of the highest-profile organizations in your field. You know it will be a challenge, but you’re up for it. Plus, it’s such an incredible opportunity to learn—you can’t wait to dive in!

    You look up at the clock and see it’s time for your first Monday morning team meeting. As the conference room fills, there’s a buzz in the air. The man seated next to you introduces himself. So, you’re new; where’d you graduate from? he asks. You tell him and he nods. Not bad, he replies. I graduated from MIT with a double degree. The meeting begins, and when the boss asks project leaders for status updates, each brags about their wins. When it’s revealed that a key deadline has been missed, the atmosphere becomes tense; lots of finger pointing about who’s responsible, but no clear answer. Finally, the boss asks for ideas about how to solve a thorny problem the team has been stymied by. You’re tempted to raise your hand, thinking you have a good suggestion, but you hold back. Considering what you’ve just witnessed, you worry about missing the mark. What if your idea isn’t very good? What will your boss and the others think of you? You decide that maybe it’s better just to keep quiet.

    By the end of the meeting, you have a sinking feeling in the pit of your stomach. You can’t help but wonder if perhaps you’ve made a mistake. Maybe you don’t have what it takes, after all.

    Now, let’s rewind and consider another possibility.

    You’re feeling that big, fresh, first-day energy, and you look up at the clock. It’s time for the Monday morning team meeting. After introductions all around, the boss says, I know you’re going to bring valuable skills and experiences to the team. We’re happy you’ve joined us. The status updates proceed, and the project leads share their successes, as well as a struggle they are dealing with, and the team offers suggestions to help them work it out. A big deadline was missed and instead of finger pointing, the team discusses what can be learned, how they will change their processes to make sure it doesn’t happen again, and what they’re going to do to meet the next milestone. Finally, the boss asks for ideas about how to solve a thorny problem the team has been stymied by. You wait for a few others to talk, but realizing you have a suggestion that hasn’t been offered yet, you speak up and your idea is greeted with enthusiasm.

    By the end of the meeting, you’re feeling a part of something. You can see how the team collaborates to work through problems, innovates solutions, and takes risks together. You’re excited to take on whatever challenges and opportunities tomorrow holds!

    It’s a tale of two cultures: a fixed mindset culture—what I call a Culture of Genius—versus a growth mindset culture—a Culture of Growth. As you can begin to see from just these two brief examples, when it comes to individual, team, and organizational performance, the culture you’re in matters. From the very beginning.

    Throughout this book, I’ll explain the difference between these mindset cultures, but at the outset it’s worth noting that when Satya Nadella became CEO of Microsoft, one of the first things he did was to make a public commitment to transform the company’s culture. He knew that Microsoft’s success relied on its ability to produce the most innovative and creative products, and then he asked: How can a growth mindset help us achieve that? In other words, how do companies not only put growth mindset into practice, but also use it to solve some of their hardest problems?

    In 2014, when Nadella took over, Microsoft’s stock price was roughly $36. In November 2021, it hit a high of over $340, and when tech stocks crashed in 2022 it remained a strong performer. Microsoft shifted from its heavy dependence on Windows to rivaling behemoth Amazon Web Services in its share of the cloud computing market, becoming, in 2021, only the second company in US history (after Apple) to receive a $2 trillion market valuation. Microsoft is often held up as a case example of employing this or that strategy, and so seeing them highlighted in yet another book could prompt a sigh. And yet most of the successes for which the company has been heralded stem from a single ideal: Nadella’s determination to shift Microsoft into a growth mindset culture. Today, as the computing world focuses on the promise of artificial intelligence, Microsoft is trying to improve workplace culture by tasking the technology with helping all of us inhabit our growth mindset more often. In the wake of some cringeworthy stumbles from their chatbot Tay (and more recently, Bing) Nadella directed his engineering team to find ways to tune their products to be more inclusive and growth-oriented. My collaborators and I have joined these efforts and are working together to create AI-powered tools that will help teachers and managers create growth mindset cultures in their classrooms and teams.

    But what, exactly, is a growth mindset culture? What is its true promise, what does it look like in practice, and what does a transition to this type of culture entail? In this book, I’ll show you. Additionally, I’ll show that growth mindset cultures don’t just work for large corporations, they also boost outcomes in schools, nonprofits, sports teams… essentially anywhere there’s two or more people working together. (It’s worth noting that three of the four teams to make it to the 2023 NBA final four playoffs were growth oriented, meaning they had coaches or team leaders who’ve publicly advocated for a growth-minded approach.) We’ll also look at the latest science on individual mindset, and how it intersects with what we’ve learned about mindset culture.

    Microsoft’s transformation owes much to Nadella’s reading of Stanford psychology professor Carol Dweck’s Mindset, first published in 2006 and now read by more than seven million people in more than 40 languages. Mindset refers to our beliefs about the malleability of intelligence: whether it’s largely fixed, or whether it can be developed. Fixed mindset beliefs assert that people either have it or they don’t, while growth mindset beliefs suggest that intelligence is something you can develop and expand. The concept of mindset has been nothing short of revolutionary in its impact on our understanding of individuals. People’s mindsets can tell us how they respond to challenges and setbacks, the goals they are likely to pursue, and their behavior. Operating in a fixed mindset can lead people to give up when they are frustrated, take fewer risks when it comes to their learning and development, and conceal mistakes.

    I first became acquainted with Carol when I began working with her as a graduate student in 2006. I was struck by how mindset matters not just individually, but in the context of other people—and especially in groups. The biggest influence on whether you’re operating from your fixed or growth mindset at any given moment isn’t necessarily between your ears—it’s outside of you. That’s right: Mindset isn’t just in your mind. Now as her colleague, I have spent more than a decade working with Carol to examine how mindset operates at the group and organizational levels. The results are transformative and fundamentally shift our understanding of how systems and teams work. And they speak to the power of how we impact one another.

    Imagine a fish swimming in a lake. Saying that mindset is a purely individual characteristic is like saying that how that fish behaves comes down to the fish, alone. It completely overlooks what’s going on in the water (or the other fish swimming around). Similarly, the mindset culture in which we swim significantly impacts our thoughts, motivation, and behavior.

    I know that these days, especially in Westernized countries, we’re all about personal agency. No matter what’s going on around us, we can learn to master our minds so that, ultimately, all is under our control—or so popular thinking goes. This meme is often used to blame individuals and blind us to organizations’ failings. I’m not here to undercut anyone’s agency or abilities, but I am here to bring to the fore the powerful influences that surround us. We survey the landscape around us to see what the norms are, what is expected of us, and how we can succeed and gain admiration. We derive this information from the culture.

    An organization may have a culture that worships and rewards fixed ability. As a result, it may admire and praise those who are deemed brilliant and judge and blame people who don’t measure up. How would you act in this culture? What would you strive for? Going against the culture would be like swimming upstream. Sure, it’s possible, but the truth is, it’s unlikely.

    A growth mindset culture is one that values, fosters, and rewards growth and development among all members. Of course, there’s the bottom line to think about, but such organizations believe that prosperity and success stem from people learning, growing, and developing in ways that move them and the company forward.

    The mindset culture we’re swimming in also starts to affect us on a deeper level, shifting how we see ourselves. Often without even knowing it, we may begin to adopt our organization’s mindset as our own, and that ripples outward to how we see and value others. We start reinforcing the mindset culture, making it stronger and creating a continuous and intensifying cycle.

    Every gathering of people has a mindset culture. Yet the reality is that most organizations have no idea what their mindset culture is, or how it influences the group and their outcomes. Throughout this book, I’ll be highlighting how mindset culture shows up in many groups whether in workplace contexts, schools, families, sports, or others, and I’ll use the term organization to refer to these different groups. I’ll also use leader and employee as shorthand, to make for easier reading. But know that fostering a growth mindset culture is possible in almost any setting, well beyond the workplace.

    Rather than something that lives inside us, mindset can best be understood as a system of interaction among three concentric circles: Your personal mindset can be affected by the local mindset culture of your group or team, which, in turn, is influenced by the organization’s larger mindset culture. Just as with individuals, organizational mindset culture is not fully fixed or growth, but instead functions on a continuum. Over the past decade of research, my team and I have identified the two ends of the mindset culture continuum: Cultures of Genius and Cultures of Growth.

    Culture of Genius sounds appealing, right? But consider several leaders emblematic of a Culture of Genius: First, Theranos CEO Elizabeth Holmes, who dropped out of Stanford to found a now-infamous blood-testing company with the backing of Stanford faculty members who thought they had discovered the next Silicon Valley disruptor. After Theranos’s leadership not only failed to deliver on its promise but also lied about their problems, Holmes was found guilty of fraud and conspiracy. Then there is Arif Naqvi, who similarly masqueraded as an impact investor whose Abraaj private equity fund was aimed at supporting conscious capitalism. Like Holmes, Naqvi dazzled investors who were impressed with his apparent genius, but it was all smoke and mirrors. In reality, Naqvi stole $780 million from the fund. We also have Charlie Javice, CEO of Frank, a financial aid assistance company Javice billed as the Amazon of higher education. Javice wowed early investors and quickly became a darling of tech media but was later charged by the Justice Department with falsely and dramatically inflating the number of customers of her company to entice JPMorgan Chase to acquire it for a hefty sum.

    A Culture of Genius aligns with the fixed mindset. It is one where the overarching belief is that talent and ability are innate, and you either have it or you don’t. Cultures of Genius value brilliance and smarts above all else—especially if they seem to come naturally. Cultures of Genius focus almost exclusively on high fixed intelligence, so people who apply for jobs in these organizations often feature their IQs, test scores, and academic and intellectual awards and achievements, hoping to be deemed worthy and among the chosen few.

    Cultures of Growth, on the other hand, also want smart people, but they want them to be highly motivated and excited about further developing their abilities by learning, trying new strategies, and seeking help when they’re stuck. As a result, people’s job applications are likely to highlight not only their successes, but also the challenges they overcame to get there, their commitment to their work, and their desire to develop further. A Culture of Growth centers the belief that talent and ability can be honed and enhanced through good strategies, mentoring, and organizational supports.

    Just as individual mindset is a strong predictor of behaviors and outcomes, so, too, is mindset culture. Research clearly shows that organizational mindset can forecast the success of individuals, teams, and organizations. It affects whether people collaborate; whether they come up with innovative ideas and solutions; whether they are willing to take risks; whether they engage in ethically problematic behavior like hoarding information, hiding mistakes, and stealing ideas; and finally, whether the company can benefit from the insights and talents of people from diverse groups, or whether their perspective remains limited. You’ll see in this book how Satya Nadella created a Culture of Growth that has shaped Microsoft’s investment strategy, its capacity to collaborate with Apple and other competitors, and its ability to rebound from technical failures. And you’ll see other Cultures of Growth success stories, like how two sisters are using a solution-oriented approach to disrupt the wine market and make top-quality products accessible to a broader and more diverse group of consumers, and how a belief in all students’ ability to learn revolutionized instruction and drastically improved outcomes at a community college.

    Fortunately, organizational mindset can be consciously shaped. Working with leaders, managers, and individual contributors, my team and I have seen firsthand the power of Cultures of Growth to spur people’s motivation and boost individual and organizational performance. We’ve discovered how to help organizations change to embody and promote a growth mindset. We’ve uncovered what shapes a company’s mindset culture, and how to change policies, practices, and norms to help people into their growth mindset.

    Furthermore, we have discovered the link between mindset culture and diversity and inclusion. Namely, organizational mindset shapes whether companies identify, recruit, and retain people from diverse groups. This has led us to create the Equity Accelerator, the nation’s first focused research organization to apply social and behavioral science to the challenge of creating—and sustaining—more equitable learning and working environments. Fostering inclusive growth mindset cultures is a big part of what we do there and what I’ll show you how to do on your own teams.

    Throughout this book, we’ll cover the groundbreaking research that reveals how you and your team can inspire growth mindset together. We’ll see how well-known companies and organizations in a variety of industries have changed the way their people work together to create Cultures of Growth. We’ll explore the worlds of education, nonprofits, sports, and more to see how Cultures of Growth flourish everywhere—as, for example, when a school superintendent in New York State reversed massive inequities for children of color in his district by reshaping the district’s mindset culture. And how a combination bakery–foundation has applied growth mindset principles to its hiring and development, creating career opportunities for formerly incarcerated people while running a hugely successful business.

    Importantly, I’ll also show you how to prompt yourself toward growth mindset, and inspire those around you, fostering a Culture of Growth team. This book is full of many exercises, tools, and practices you can start today to change how your organization works together. You’ll identify what cues trigger you personally toward your fixed and growth mindsets (spoiler: we all have both within us) and learn how to take the cues that move you into your fixed mindset and flip them around—turning them into situations where you can be inspired and develop. From this vantage point, you’ll be able to help others do the same—building the mindset culture you want.

    This book will change what you know about mindset, while also providing clarity as you learn new evidence-based insights and actions you, your team, and your organization can benefit from. In Part One, we’ll do a mindset reset, recasting our understanding of how mindset works. In Part Two, we’ll examine organizational mindset in depth, looking at how it plays out in five key areas:

    Collaboration, and whether we’re more likely to compete with our colleagues or work together;

    Innovation, and whether we can access new ideas or are stuck repeating the past;

    Risk-taking and resilience, and whether we’re willing to take chances or feel compelled to play it safe;

    Integrity and ethical behavior, and whether we take shortcuts or break rules to meet performance expectations, hide mistakes, or enhance their reputation; and

    Diversity, equity, and inclusion, and whether we seek to recruit and retain a workforce with multiple talents and perspectives, or hire based on a narrow prototype for success.

    I’ll show you how to identify your organization’s mindset and mindset influences, explaining how to shift toward growth and stay there. In Part Three, we’ll look at how mindset cues affect us as individuals. I’ll introduce the four common situational cues that shift us into our fixed or growth mindset:

    When we face situations where our efforts will be evaluated;

    When we encounter difficult challenges;

    When we receive critical feedback; and

    When we’re faced with the success of others.

    You’ll learn how to recognize which situations tend to trigger you along the continuum, and how you can invoke your growth mindset more often.

    Yet even though, as individuals, we are powerful, we can only do so much alone. The best and biggest work of our lives comes from collaborating with others to realize our fullest potential collectively. Mindset is a team effort, and I encourage you to share what you learn. The very nature of a Culture of Growth is to strive for growth for everyone. This can only happen if we shift toward our growth mindset, roll up our sleeves, and work together.

    PART ONE

    Mindset Reset

    CHAPTER 1

    The Mindset Continuum

    We’ve gotten mindset all wrong. Well, not all wrong, but we’ve oversimplified it drastically, and to our detriment.

    Mindset seems like an easy concept to grasp: Either you believe that intelligence and ability are largely set and can’t change much, or you think that we can grow and develop them over time. Yet when you reflect on your own personal experiences, you might sense something more complex than an either/or dichotomy.

    Think of a time in the past when you were met with a challenge. How did you respond? Let’s say your boss asked you to come up with some fund-raising ideas to help address a projected shortfall. Perhaps you played it safe, suggesting only initiatives that were in line with what the organization had done in the past. Or, maybe you saw in that request an opportunity to try something new, and you stretched yourself to offer unique solutions that went beyond traditional outreach and events. Or, maybe you started by listing the usual ideas, but then decided to push yourself a little.

    The reality is that no one has either a fixed or a growth mindset. Although we may favor a fixed or a growth mindset, we all have both—and shifting between them is something each one of us does. Moreover, when we shift from fixed to growth, it isn’t always like flipping a switch; sometimes it’s more like adjusting a dimmer.

    Mindset exists on a continuum. And where we fall on that continuum at any given moment often has to do with the situation we’re in and the people around us.

    However, the way we’ve come to think about mindset doesn’t reflect this complexity. Since Carol Dweck first introduced the concept, we’ve seen the following illustration displayed frequently in classrooms and on social media:

    What’s wrong with this image? Yes, people can differ in the mindset they typically endorse, but by focusing on our brains, this image implies that mindset is located entirely in the head. And it puts it in either/or terms. It asks us to identify what kind of mindset we have, implying that it’s one or the other. Can you see the irony here? Thinking we always embody either the fixed or the growth mindset is a very fixed way of viewing mindset!

    This image also shows a clear preference for one mindset over the other: Growth is good and fixed is bad. Although, as we will see, people and cultures with more of a growth mindset may have many admirable qualities, these misunderstandings have led to the moralization of mindset, especially in the American educational system and in corporations that have taken up the idea. When we view mindset as a fixed trait that resides inside an individual’s head, and when we believe that a person with one mindset is a better person than someone with the other mindset, it’s easy to use mindset to sort and label people. It also means that we put the onus of change on the individual, instead of considering the context and culture that creates and maintains mindset.

    Mindset culture as it exists outside of us is an active, collaborative creation. Still, organizational leaders often focus on individual mindset, as if identifying and retaining growth mindset employees will create a growth-minded organization. Many school systems have asked my colleagues and me if there are assessments to rate teachers on their fixed or growth mindsets; and investment firms have requested that I help them create assessments so they can identify which entrepreneurs to invest in. Often, organizations want to use such assessments for selection and hiring. The underlying assumptions behind these inquiries are that: (a) mindset is static; (b) it’s entirely individual; and (c) such assessments will reveal the truth about someone’s mindset—whether they have a growth (or fixed) mindset, and therefore whether they’ll be a good employee (or not). And when we affix these beliefs on individuals, they turn around and affix them on others.

    In the teacher training institute that my colleagues and I created, we see teachers who endorse this false dichotomy view of mindset labeling students who struggle with motivation or performance by saying things like, I’m sorry, this kid just has a fixed mindset and there’s nothing much I can do about it or This generation of students has really fixed mindsets. When we ask teachers what they’re doing to help students move toward their growth mindset, they sometimes say, That’s not my job. Students just need to have a growth mindset, or their parents need to be working with them to develop one. But labeling kids as unable to change is the definition of a fixed mindset—on the part of the teacher. And because some teachers may want learning to come easily and quickly (another fixed-minded attitude), they may short-circuit students’ struggles—and thereby their learning—by immediately offering the correct answers or reassuring them that, It’s okay, not everyone can be a math person.

    All of this misconstrues what mindset is, as well as the factors that determine our mindset in any given moment. And it turns mindset into a blame game, which doesn’t help anyone.

    Ask someone what their mindset is, and the accurate answer is: It depends. Even among those of us who study mindset, no one leans toward growth all of the time. Depending on the situation, our fixed or growth mindset can become activated.

    Meet the Mindset Continuum.

    THE MINDSET CONTINUUM

    Instead of simply having a fixed or growth mindset, we are nudged along a continuum either more toward our fixed or more toward our growth mindset, depending on the circumstance. But on this continuum, we also have a default set point. Perhaps you tend to hang out on the growth end of the continuum, or your initial response to challenge is more fixed. (Don’t hold too tightly to that idea either, because our set point can change over time and in different situations.)

    Understanding our mindset set point can be a helpful starting point, as Carol Dweck’s classic work shows, yet none of us lives in a vacuum. In fact, one of the most surprising findings of our research is how people move along the continuum based on predictable, discernable cues around them, which is why mindset assessments aimed at targeting our one true mindset often miss the mark.

    MINDSET CULTURE

    The culture surrounding us is one of the biggest influences on our beliefs, motivations, and behavior. This mindset culture exists at the group and organizational level.

    Mindset culture is so powerful that it can actually block an individual’s growth mindset. But when leaders focus on developing individuals, they almost always overlook the impact of the mindset culture they’ve created. In many cases, they’re not even aware of it! For example, Barre3 CEO Sadie Lincoln had built a fitness business that she thought had growth mindset at its core until an anonymous company-wide survey shattered the image she’d worked hard to develop—that of the perfect leader who made it all look easy. I really tried to play that part, even though it wasn’t always true, says Lincoln. I didn’t realize I had created a culture of perfection, and as a result we lost authenticity, trust, and our ability to innovate together. Perfection is one aspect of a fixed mindset culture. In an environment that demanded seemingly effortless, flawless performance (as modeled from the top), employees felt demotivated and demoralized instead of invigorated and inspired to take on challenges. This is mindset culture at work. Even an attentive leader such as Sadie Lincoln was shocked to learn that instead of a Culture of Growth, she’d unwittingly created what I call a Culture of Genius, an organization whose policies, practices, and norms embody fixed mindset beliefs.

    Lincoln knew she and her team had to overhaul their corporate culture, starting with taking ownership of her role in creating a toxic atmosphere. (We’ll look at how she did that in Chapter 11.) It wasn’t easy—and it wasn’t without consequences. I lost team members during this trying time, Lincoln told Marie Claire.

    Some people who bought into the fixed mindset culture of effortless perfection found it unsettling to see Lincoln openly acknowledging and owning her failures. But the people

    Enjoying the preview?
    Page 1 of 1