I read a LOT of YA fiction since I'm a school media center specialist (fancy name for librarian) and I feel like it's a sad statement about the quality of Christian YA available out there that this book has gotten such good reviews. Measuring it next to all YA available out there, this book would be in the low middle of quality, but measured against other Christian YA, it is sadly towards the top. We need more Christian YA that is not just good for Christians, but good quality literature in general. :( [Note 2022: Since writing this 10 years ago the quality of Christian lit for YA has improved a lot. Enclave and Thomas Nelson especially have really improved what is now available.]
The setting is an alternate universe that has been plagued by some sort of disease so that most of the planet is desert (did anyone else just think Dune?) but there are 7 springs of water surrounded by seven forests where people remain. The water has some sort of healing/sustaining property such that people need to bathe in it daily or they succumb to this desert disease that turns them into Scabs. (Think dry, crusty, Bubbles from LOTR --sorry, that's Lord of the Rings). The Scabs detest the people and think they’re repulsive and vice versa so of course they are at war.
At first I thought this was going to turn into a Ranger’s Apprentice-type book because it starts off and they are having a vicious, armed game of “football” that allows minor injuries (such as broken bones and flesh wounds) to decide which teenagers will be joining the army. The four young main characters encounter some interesting developments (can’t tell what in case you read it) and end up out in the desert on a quest for The Books of History. There are some minor allegories/allusions going on in the story, but most are subtle enough you appreciate Dekker’s craftiness and creativity. Some are more blatantly obvious, like Michal and Gabil are two white bat-like creatures called Roush who help the kids and there are evil black bat-like creatures too. They are supposedly things of legend; it turns out they exist, but only those with eyes to see them know they exist. I think most of you have probably figured out that allusion.
Was it the most amazing story I’ve ever read? No.
Will I need to read the next to read the next book. Yes. There was only one minor plot development resolved (ok, so it was life threatening and pretty important, but in the grand scheme of things still minor), and lots of other things left hanging. Thus the need for 5 more books. Oh, and Ted Dekker leaves this nice little note for you at the end of the book that if you want to know where the mysterious leader of the people, Thomas, came from and why the people on the planet only remember the past 13 years you have to read a parallel series of books: Black, Red and White. Grr. So that means I now have 5 more books in The Lost Books series to read and 3 more books in the parallel series to read. I’ll let you know if it is worth getting sucked into this black hole or not after the next book.
Note: Now that I've read pretty much the whole series, no, it isn't worth getting sucked into the black hole. Yes, Dekker has some good creativity going, the plot had great potential, but the execution fell far too short. I'm so fed up with Dekker's writing for teens I can't stomach the idea of reading any of the adult books right now. I know, he probably writes really well for adults, but I've still got a bad taste in my mouth from books 2-4 & the end of 6.