Jump to ratings and reviews
Rate this book

Shadow Players #1

For a Muse of Fire

Rate this book
A young woman with a dangerous power she barely understands. A smuggler with secrets of his own. A country torn between a merciless colonial army, a terrifying tyrant, and a feared rebel leader. The first book in a new trilogy from Heidi Heilig.

Jetta’s family is famed as the most talented troupe of shadow players in the land. With Jetta behind the scrim, their puppets seem to move without string or stick a trade secret, they say. In truth, Jetta can see the souls of the recently departed and bind them to the puppets with her blood. But the old ways are forbidden ever since the colonial army conquered their country, so Jetta must never show never tell. Her skill and fame are her family’s way to earn a spot aboard the royal ship to Aquitan, where shadow plays are the latest rage, and where rumor has it the Mad King has a spring that cures his ills. Because seeing spirits is not the only thing that plagues Jetta. But as rebellion seethes and as Jetta meets a young smuggler, she will face truths and decisions that she never imagined—and safety will never seem so far away.

Heidi Heilig creates a world inspired by Asian cultures and French colonialism.

512 pages, ebook

First published September 25, 2018

Loading interface...
Loading interface...

About the author

Heidi Heilig

10 books1,330 followers
Heidi grew up in Hawaii where she rode horses and raised peacocks, and then she moved to New York City and grew up even more, as one tends to do. Her favorite thing, outside of writing, is travel, and she has haggled for rugs in Morocco, hiked the trails of the Ko'olau Valley, and huddled in a tent in Africa while lions roared in the dark.

She holds an MFA from New York University in Musical Theatre Writing, of all things, and she's written books and lyrics for shows including The Time Travelers Convention, Under Construction, and The Hole. She lives in Brooklyn with her husband and their pet snake, whose wings will likely grow in any day now.

Ratings & Reviews

What do you think?
Rate this book

Friends & Following

Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!

Community Reviews

5 stars
418 (21%)
4 stars
719 (36%)
3 stars
597 (30%)
2 stars
190 (9%)
1 star
47 (2%)
Displaying 1 - 30 of 445 reviews
Profile Image for Heidi Heilig.
Author 10 books1,330 followers
Read
March 9, 2018
Okay I'm going to paste my preliminary author's note here, because it includes content notes at the bottom and I want to get those in front of people now because ARCs will become available soonish and I don't want anyone to be taken by surprise! I will format with spoiler tags as well, to keep anyone from being spoiled.

So! Here goes:

Sometimes, the inside of my head seems like the pile of returned books on a library cart. A well-worn high fantasy beside an account of the lives of party girls in Bohemian New York . . . a Shakespeare play sandwiched between a history of French colonialism and a book about shadow puppetry. These flying leaps from topic to topic are one of my favorite things about my own bipolar disorder, and they inform my world building in unexpected ways.

When I set out to write FOR A MUSE OF FIRE, I wanted to write about a main character who shares my mental illness, and seeks a real life treatment for it. But I also wanted to create a magical second world out of my obsessions, which are in turn informed by my own malheur: I spent a long time in theatre in my youth, where my manic highs let me shine in the limelight. I was obsessed with death and spirits for a while, those thoughts meshing with my maudlin lows. There is a hedonism to mania as well, which is so often reviled in young women (unfortunately, I was no exception), so the cast of Le Perl gives me especial joy.

And of course, my heritage and upbringing creeps in. I am half Chinese, but raised in a rainy valley in Hawaii down the road from a taro farm where a water buffalo grazed. I must admit, as a biracial person, I have sometimes felt like a man without a country, as it were. In this book, I leaned into the freedom that feeling can bring: inspiration for food, styles of puppetry, and language are taken from a broad cross-section of places and times.

The technology, too, is a bit out of history. Though the headers on the letters from the Aquitans note that the year is 1874, the year is not quite analogous to our own 19th century history.

Lastly, please note that while Aquitan and Chakrana are inspired in part by France and South East Asia, so many cultural, linguistic, political, historical, and religious liberties were taken that the story is truly a fantasy, and not an allegory or a close second world version. This might be most noticeable in the inexact but French-like nature of the Aquitan words.

CONTENT NOTES:
Profile Image for Elle (ellexamines).
1,113 reviews18.9k followers
Shelved as 'zzzzz-did-not-finish'
October 29, 2018
I'm going to be putting this on hold at about 33%. I'll keep this at a bulleted list because I'm... almost 200 pages in? and that doesn't quite feel like enough to actually Dislike The Thing, and also there is a good chance I will finish this at some point

→I think this might just be one of those fantasy books that is heavier on the world and plot than on character, and I honestly... don't find either worldbuilding or plot particularly interesting
→fantasy names for real life things are cool and i absolutely understand why they exist and i also can't keep them straight at all i really do struggle with names
→.......the arc doesn't have all the maps and stuff which makes sense!!! maybe i just need a final copy to appreciate that part of the story?
→okay here comes an actual issue: the plot is super super generic. like i'm 200 pages in and i can outline this book for you
→generally, however, i can go with a generic plot if i enjoy the characters and themes
→uhhhhhhhhhhhhhhh. maybe i'm just. missing them?
→points for a biracial and bipolar (and according to Heilig's twitter, queer!!) heroine
→buuuuuuuut i think i'm really struggling to get hold of Jetta as a character? she just doesn't have a very strong voice to me?
→Leo has literally no characterization he feels incredibly forced he did NOT need to be here
→i can't visualize anything for shit the writing is fine but it's not helping me picture what the fuck is happening
→I want to finish this primarily because it's postcolonial literature
→postcolonial literature is the only bitch in this house that i respect
→I also generally want to feel like I have something more to say about books I DNF, especially as I am currently higher on this book's page from my prereview than I feel is fair to the book? if you're wondering why this will not be on my blog or be boosted in any way shape or form, that's why
→i'm really forgetting details of this story only a month after i last picked it up and I think that's probably just a good note to end on. i'm not really keeping the plot straight in my head because i'm just,,, not that invested yet

Blog | Goodreads | Twitter | Instagram | Youtube
369 reviews238 followers
Want to read
October 2, 2018
Originally, I was going to power through this in a few days, but I just can't.

This isn't a DNF, I'm just going to put it back on my to-read pile and pick it up later in the future.

I don't hate it, but after 100 pages, I just can't get into it. Nothing has really captured my attention. Even the necromancy is lacking substance.

Hopefully I can read the story all the way, but for now, I'm setting it down.
Profile Image for Acqua.
536 reviews227 followers
May 16, 2019
To the mad ones

I knew I was going to like this book right from the dedication.

For a Muse of Fire is the first book in a YA trilogy set in a high fantasy world inspired by Southeast Asia during French colonization. It's the story of Jetta, a girl with bipolar disorder who is trying to get to a "magic" spring whose waters should be able to help her (because of the lithium which naturally occurs there).

It means a lot to me when I find SFF in which the main character is mentally ill. For two reasons: mental illness representation is only common in contemporary novels, but as I do not live in the US, they do not reflect my experience of living in a country in which there's very little (or: even less) awareness on these topics. The other reasons is that I like seeing mentally ill people being heroes in all genres.

I loved the representation of Jetta's bipolar disorder. It's subtler than I thought it was going to be: Jetta's lows are basically shown as a time jumps in the story. I think variety in representation of mental illness - books that do not show depressive episodes to avoid being too triggering and books that explicitly engage with the topics of depression or suicide - is really important, especially when it's ownvoices like this book.
"Subtle", of course, doesn't mean the representation wasn't there: Jetta's "malheur" is relevant to the plot and to her characterization.

I really liked following Jetta and her family through Chakrana as they try to figure out how to live in a place where the tension between colonizers and the rebellion is rising. I especially liked reading about shadow plays and the way this aspect was tied to the magic system.
The magic system itself was really interesting and imaginative: in For a Muse of Fire, you'll find necromancy in a way you've never seen it before.

Another thing that made this book stand out was the mixed media format: some of the chapters are told like plays, there's sheet music, there are maps, letters and telegrams.

Until now, I talked about what made For a Muse of Fire stand out. However, it didn't stand out as much as I hoped it would. While the themes are very different from the average YA fantasy, I found the plot very formulaic. There are people in power, there's a rebellion, at the beginning of the novel the main character thinks the people in power are not that bad, but then she changes her minds and falls in love with a boy in the process.
Formulaic diverse stories are important - and the diversity here wasn't just a dressing to make the story feel new without any actual depth to it, it isn't tokenism - but sometimes I wonder whether I've read too much YA fantasy. I predicted every single twist from the beginning.

It didn't help that the romance was very bland. There wasn't anything wrong with Leo, the love interest, he was just so forgettable that I had to look up his name, and I finished this yesterday. He doesn't stand out from a sea of very similar YA fantasy love interests.
The dancers at Le Perl - especially Cheeky, I want to know more about her - were far more interesting characters. This is also the only YA novel I know that has positive sex worker representation.

This book definitely could have been better in terms of predictability, but I didn't think it was just average: it's one of the books that executed this kind of plot better.
For a Muse of Fire is set in a colonized country, and the author shows the ways colonization affects a culture through the details - clothing, language, religion, even buildings - without any infodumps. I'm often disappointed by the worldbuilding in YA fantasy books, but I wasn't here.

The writing was solid, but I can't say it stood out. I love atmospheric books, and I would have loved if this had been one of them - I wanted to feel as if I was there with Jetta, but I couldn't always visualize how things looked.
I always say that books longer than 500 pages are longer than they need to be and usually have pacing problems. Here, this was true only for the ending, in which I felt like too much and not enough was happening at the same time. Anyway, the pacing was very good for most of it - I finished this 512-page book in less than three days.

One more thing: some parts of this book hint Jetta is also into girls, and I definitely read her as bi/pan. I didn't know whether to recommend For a Muse of Fire as a queer book, but the author mentioned Jetta is queer in a tweet, so it's canon.
Profile Image for Lauren  (TheBookishTwins) .
497 reviews207 followers
August 30, 2018
Disclaimer: I received a free copy via Edelweiss for review purposes.

Jetta is a member of a famed troupe of shadow players, where a story is told through the shadows cast by puppets. But Jetta and her parents have a secret to their success – Jetta's has necromancy powers and uses it to bind souls to her puppets so they can move without strings. With her skills and their fame, Jetta and her family are trying to make their way from Aquitan and Chakrana (the former inspired by South East Asia, and the latter by France, their interaction and history based on French colonialism), fleeing the rising rebellion, but also where rumor has it the Mad King has a spring to cure his ills, because the spirits of the dead are not the only thing that plagues Jetta. But as the rebellion lands on her front step, Jetta finds herself facing truths and decisions she never imagined.

I am a massive fan of Heidi Heilig's duology THE GIRL FROM EVERYWHERE, and so I was ecstatic to get my hands on an e-ARC of FOR A MUSE OF FIRE. It did not disappoint - not in the slightest. It's an Asian inspired fantasy with a vibrant and dynamic cast of characters, fantastic world-building, a unique magic system (NECROMANCY!), and such lush writing.

The characters – both the main and the secondary – were complex and well-developed and the group dynamics and interactions were exceptional. I adored Jetta, how intelligent, caring, and kind she was. Jetta's malheur is also very much inspired by the author's #ownvoices experience with bipolar. I adored Leo. I adored the feeling of found family, and I also adored the slow burn romance between Jetta and Leo.

Another thing that makes this book so unique, aside from the exceptional world-building and unique magic system, was that whilst most of it was written in the first-person narrative from Jetta's POV, there were letters and transcripts and folklore stories and it enhanced the reading experience and made it feel so immersive. Even though FOR A MUSE OF FIRE is a fantasy, it is very much based on history, with themes of colonialism. I do think that fans of both fantasy and historical fantasy/fiction will find a lot to love here.

FOR A MUSE OF FIRE is a book that I will be recommending to fantasy fans for a long time to come.
Profile Image for Namera [The Literary Invertebrate].
1,327 reviews3,498 followers
May 5, 2019
OH. MY. GOD.

THIS BOOK WAS AMAZING.


I started writing this review and it was basically a bunch of fangirling, so I’m starting over again. From the beginning this time. Here goes…

PLOT

So, Jetta and her parents are shadow players – they tour Chakra and put on plays with puppets. They’re famous for how easily their puppets manoeuvre. But what the audience doesn’t know is that the puppets are essentially alive: they’re animated by souls, because Jetta can do awful necromantic things like that, even if she knows she must never tell anyone or she’ll be imprisoned. After the reign of terror of Le Trépas, a necromancer who set himself up to rule over Chakra, such things are regarded with the highest suspicion.

Jetta has a malheur – a madness – quite separate from her necromancy. It is said that the Mad King of Aquitan has one too, and to bath at the Aquitan springs of Les Chanceux is the only way to cure it. So now Jetta and her family are planning to perform before the King’s half-brother, General Legarde, who’s currently in Chakra, in the hopes that he’ll bring them over the sea with him when he returns home. Right now he’s busy concluding a marriage between his daughter Theodora and Raik Alaika, the Boy King of Chakra (or rather, the Playboy King) who’s been little more than an Aquitan figurehead since they deposed his parents.

But enter the Tiger. A ruthless Chakran rebel determined to expel the Aquitans, his machinations put a brutal end to Jetta’s plans. Instead, she’s forced to fall in with Leo, a half-Chakran/half-Aquitan pub proprietor, if she wants to have any hope of reaching Les Chanceux. It’s going to be hard. Leo is deeply untruthworthy, the Tiger and his men menace her at every step, the Aquitans are not in a mood to look favourably on any Chakrans right now, and all the while her madness and her death-gift are sending Jetta’s stress level spiralling ever higher. To make matters worse, the old and feared name of Le Trépas is beginning to feature rather more in her life than it really should be…

CHARACTERS

Literally every single character was brilliantly drawn. Every. Single. One. Even the vast majority of the minor roles. Every single character was interesting, with a deep story! I’m actually shook at how well Heilig made sure that nobody was a throwaway, even if you saw them for only a page or two before they faded out of Jetta’s story.

Jetta of course is in the starring role. She’s sharp-edged, smart but desperate, ambitious, loyal only to those who deserve it. I LOVED HER, if you couldn’t tell. My only complaint would be that although there were frequent references to her madness, none of her actions struck me as particularly insane. In fact, she seemed remarkably clear-headed under her circumstances.
Leo remained for the most part an enigma, but we got enough flashes of his personality to know what motivates him. The death of his mother, his relationship with his father, his loyalty for his girls – everything combined to make him just relatable enough to root for, while unpredictable enough to be interesting.

Everyone else had their own stories too, from Jetta’s parents to Theodora.

WRITING

The fusion of cultures in this one was awesome. Aquitan is obviously France, while Chakra is East Asia; although there are several references towards skin colour, I felt like it wasn’t a massive element, despite the book being about colonialism. The whole white-people-taking-over-brown-people’s-land was a major plot point. Jetta herself doesn’t really devote a lot of time to thinking about it, but most other characters do and it’s interesting to see their various cross-purposes.
The format of the book is a little more unique than your average YA too. The chapters are all narrated regularly from Jetta’s POV, but in between are inserts from other characters in the form of play scenes. Not surprising, considering the title is a line from Shakespeare’ Henry V and Jetta herself is an actress of sorts.

Basically, I’m dying for the next book, and you should totally read this, if only because you’re looking for a YA world a little more interesting than the usual Russian fare.

[Blog] - [Bookstagram]

 photo c l i m b C2A0e v e r y C2A0m o u n t a i n 2_zpsykn9gbgr.png
Profile Image for Dani ❤️ Perspective of a Writer.
1,512 reviews5 followers
October 20, 2018
description
Check out more reviews @ Perspective of a Writer...


In a vivid, rich world inspired by Asian cultures and French colonialism… A bipolar young woman with a dangerous power she barely understands. A smuggler with secrets of his own. A country torn between a merciless colonial army, a terrifying tyrant, and a feared rebel leader. Told from Jetta’s first-person point-of-view, as well as chapters written as play scripts and ephemera such as telegrams and letters, we are taken on a journey that weaves magic, simmering romance, and the deep bonds of family with the high stakes of epic adventure.


The short review...

Let me preface this entire review by saying I enjoyed For a Muse of Fire!! That is important to note because I also had a bunch of stuff bug me... It didn't ruin the read but was quite a disconnect for me at times. I feel like the best way to distill my jumbled thoughts (that I've spent two days trying to pull together) is through a lovely list!! So please decide for yourself if this is a book for you!!


What I enjoyed?!

-The Added POVs.
We got other POVs through the plays, telegrams and letters in between chapters. That was neat even if I didn't really understand where these fragments came from (Who was writing the plays? Why was someone collecting this information?) I really enjoy getting more than just the main female's POV.

-I really liked Jetta!!
Such was NOT the case with The Girl from Everywhere so I was really happy about that. I felt for her that she lost her brother and that her and her parents last hope was this ship. I wanted to fully understand what was so forbidden about her art and to experience the trials of colonialism... And for the most part I got that all through Jetta.

-The shadow puppetry, necromancy and blood magic!
Yes, these all three are sort of the same thing and a little different. Suffice to say THESE are the REASON TO READ THE BOOK! I found it a rather incredible use of necromancy and I loved that it was used in such a benign way as a livelihood. The spirits and the puppetry truly felt from South Asia too!

-The oppression of an invading country.
Heilig has always been really great at creating intriguing worlds even if they don't always make sense... and this one does have both that creativity and that problem... But it DOES feel like a country that is being overtaken by another country's army. Their people are told their old ways are no good and are being killed when they don't accept being oppressed.


What I didn't...

-The bi-polar rep.
I actually forgot that it was in the book... Jetta kept calling it "malheur" and I kept wondering what the heck she was talking about because she didn't seem to be anything but normal?! Then when they introduced the "treatment" I remembered! But looking back at Jetta's actions I never saw a manic high or a maudlin low.

I know quite a few people who are all bi-polar to varying degrees and yeah not a whiff of it here. Really I LOVE MENTAL HEALTH!! I would give props to even hints of it. But frankly Wintersong is a better representation of bi-polar disorder. I applaud the publisher for mentioning it in the blurb so readers would be alerted but that effort was really wasted...


-This won't feel very Asian.
Now I know it IS based on legitimate South Asia cultures. I've read a couple books about Cambodia and it lightly felt like hints of that country if I stretched it (shadow puppetry, the jungle setting, the temple). Here's the thing though... it felt MORE French. Like even Jetta felt French. Her parents felt even MORE French. It was so freaking odd!

Even the half blood felt... FRENCH! And yet all the Aquitans (the invading colonists) were described as blondes (a sea of blondes was mentioned often)... and there are French blondes, but honestly they are mostly dark haired so I became so freaking confused! It honestly felt like a FRENCH world being oppressed by Vikings (or late Englishmen) and NOT Asian at all!

The two racial names of the people (Aquitans and Chakrans) were used so often to keep the two people separate that it became one of the few markers of the world. It was hard to visualize what each meant... So all I had to go on was the day to day life I experienced and that felt... FRENCH!


Unfortunately I READ For a Muse of Fire BECAUSE of the bi-polar mental health and the Asian culture!! So to be disappointed in these two things is pretty disheartening... The thing is though that I enjoyed the story without the bi-polar bit (it added zero even if I believed it) and without the cover and the blurb I wouldn't have thought this was so much Asian and so wouldn't have been disappointed that it lacked that element. The shadow puppetry, necromancy and blood magic ROCKED it!! Seriously I rated this such as I did because it elevated the story that much...


Cover & Title grade -> F

Between the cover with a huge Asian dragon and the blurb that boldly states a "vivid, rich world inspired by Asian cultures" I was expecting a vivid and rich Asian world... and that is decidedly NOT what I got... The expectations were all off... To me I would have played up the shadow puppetry and the blood magic instead... because that is what really slays in this book! As a result the cover gets the lowest rating possible for deceiving me and I don't much like the title either... Is Jetta the muse? What does fire have to do with it? Things did burn... but why is that made to sound like a positive thing due to the title?!

Personally as a graphic designer... I would have made a vector drawing of the dragon puppet to put on the cover... that would have been so awesome... I would have bought the book for that cover...


As a Writer...

I applaud utilizing your #ownvoices in the writing of your book as a writer myself. Even though I don't LOOK Asian I still apply my love for my culture to my own writing... I'm sure the author's feelings as a bi-polar and Asian POC are totally accurate and real... I just didn't feel it come across the page. *shrug* It's pretty bad when I can't even remember what the hell malheur was or why it was such a concern! And as a reader it makes me uncomfortable when I start rationalizing for the author why I'm not getting the world building I was told was going to be front and center. That's a risk we authors take putting ourselves out there at the poster child for our story...

I really enjoyed the necromancy and blood magic in For a Muse of Fire and feel you'll enjoy it if you read for that. Please though... don't rely on this to get a sense of the bi-polar mental health condition. And don't be disappointed that the Asian culture is quite light... the cover misrepresents the story and that's just a sad, sad thing...

⋆ ⋆ ⭐⭐⭐ Authenticity
⋆ ⋆ ⭐⭐⭐ Writing Style
⋆ ⋆ ⭐⭐⭐ Plot & Pacing
⋆ ⋆ ⋆ ⭐⭐ World Building

Thanks to Edelweiss and the publisher for providing me with a copy in exchange for an honest review. It has not influenced my opinions.

______________________
You can find this review and many others on my book blog @ Perspective of a Writer. See my special perspective at the bottom of my reviews under the typewriter...
Profile Image for Dr. Andy.
2,529 reviews247 followers
July 6, 2022
Reread finally! It took reading the beginning twice and reading the synopsis after starting, but I got into this one for real this time and I can say I am a fan! The ending was rude and I definitely want to read the sequel now.

For a Muse of Fire is a fantasy that tells the story of Jetta. A young girl who is trying to find somewhere to call home in the midst of a rebellion. Jetta is bipolar and is also seeking a cure/treatment for her disability. She's heard of a mythical pond that is said to help (though not completely spelled out yet, this spring can help her because of naturally occurring Lithium, this is not a curing disability story). Jetta also can perform magic but ever since her home country was colonised, that magic has been outlawed.

This was a great story and I really got to enjoy the commentary on colonisation and how the everyday citizen can feel displaced by power struggles. I loved Jetta as a character and I felt like I was able to see the various episodes of her bipolar disorder manifest this time around. This world captivated me and the way it ended was brutal! I definitely need book 2.

Rep: Southeast Asian coded bisexual cis female MC with bipolar disorder, Southeast Asian/biracial coded cishet male side character, Southeast Asian coded cis male side character with PTSD, Southeast Asian coded cast.

CWs: Colonisation, war, mental illness (bipolar), gun violence, murder, death, racism, violence, blood, fire, gore, body horror, possession by spirits. Moderate: torture, suicide, reproductive coercion, injury/injury detail, kidnapping.


CONTENT NOTES from author: Mental illness (bipolar), blood use in magic, gun violence, war, colonialism, racism, descriptions of dead bodies, mention of reproductive coercion, mentions of torture, mention of suicide.

____________________________________________________________
3.5/5

While I did like this, I generally feel a bit underwhelmed as a whole with this book. I think my brain was mostly in a "I don't want to listen" mood so a majority of the story probably went over my head. I think I'd really like this had I the time to sit down and read this book.

For example, it took me way too long to realize that Jetta was performing necromancy when she'd put spirits into her puppets. And this was such an essential piece of information to both the plot and many characters' motivations for acting certain ways. The other thing I supposedly missed is that Jetta is gay? And I don't know how I've missed this important info, but I have and I am sad.

The plot was pretty good if slow for the most part. It was hard to see where this story was driving to many times and the ending is still kind of crazy. I definitely will continue when the next book comes out.
Profile Image for Ricky.
Author 8 books179 followers
August 31, 2018
Welcome to the fourth in my series of reviews of ARCs for which I traded this August, and for sure one of the best, brightest, and most unique new books of the year! Heidi Heilig impressed me a great deal with her first duology, The Girl from Everywhere and The Ship Beyond Time. Now, she starts a new trilogy in For a Muse of Fire, another stellar fantasy in Heilig's signature style. It's dark and deadly, very lavish, highly critical of colonialism, and decidedly unconventional in its structure. Between almost every chapter is at least one piece of ephemera - a bit of dialogue between two side characters, presented in the form of a stage play; telegrams between officials in the Aquitaine armée (the colonial power of Aquitan being largely French-inspired, though with some subtle cultural differences; similarly, the Chakran people and civilization aren't inspired by any one Asian country - I sense aspects of Indian, Vietnamese, and Cambodian cultures, unless I miss my guess); in-universe folklore relevant to the story at hand (my personal favorite being the tale of the King of Death - very definitely a high point); that sort of thing.

Another major reason to read this book is because it's #ownvoices for Heilig as a bipolar writer. One of the driving forces behind heroine Jetta's journey to Aquitan is the possibility of finding a cure for her own illness in the same spring where the Mad King is said to help himself as well. But as with all the best #ownvoices leads, Jetta is nowhere near 100% defined by her bipolar disorder. Her strong family ties help define her as well, as do her magic (dangerous though it may be, using blood-magic necromancy) and her art (coming from a family of shadow puppeteers as she does.) Though I'm not reading this book #ownvoices, as an #ownvoices writer myself - for autism - I very much appreciate how engaging a protagonist Heilig gives us in Jetta. Heilig also helps set a new standard in the business, ensuring the inclusion of all relevant content warnings on the copyright page - something I'm still seeing in oddly few published books.

Perhaps the only issue I had with reading this book as an ARC is that some of the extra artwork details - notably, maps and sheet music - are still TK. For sure, I'll be taking a look at the final product as soon as it comes out to see how glorious these details are - and, knowing the lovely map work Heilig's books have gifted us with before, that's just another way my standards remain high.

And one last question - did Heilig name Leo Rath after the actor Jesse Rath? Just curious.
Profile Image for Adah Udechukwu.
669 reviews89 followers
October 2, 2018
The cover art is good, the title is good, the novel is not so good.
There is a spark of potential that needs to be exploited in subsequent books in the series.
Profile Image for Cori Reed.
1,135 reviews382 followers
November 16, 2018
I tried to read this book many months ago as a manuscript and couldn't get into it, but the audiobook is GREAT. An interesting and unique world that I have never seen before.

PS - There is quite a bit of French in here, definitely not enough to take away from the story if you're 100% unfamiliar with the language. That said, if you're a non-French speaking Canadian (like me!), the basic education we learned from the back of cereal boxes makes all the French thrown in really fun.
Profile Image for Patry Fernandez.
496 reviews252 followers
May 12, 2019
Reseña completa -> https://thewordsofbooks.blogspot.com/...

« La locura no define si eres una buena o una mala persona. Las acciones te definen. Y tus acciones son tuyas y de nadie más.»

Tenía muchísimas ganas de leer este libro y me ha sorprendido lo mucho que me gustó, sobre todo el tema de las almas, como la protagonista tiene el poder de atarlas a objetos y usarlas a su antojo. Y el final ha sido tan intenso que me quedé con ganas de mucho mas.
Profile Image for laurel [the suspected bibliophile].
1,736 reviews648 followers
February 27, 2019
Gently to hear, kindly to judge, our review.

Perform a shadow play before the General. Wow the General. Impress him so much he takes you to perform before Le Roi Fou. Get on a ship to Aquitan. Get cured.

Simple, right?

Wrong.

I absolutely loved this book. It took the oft-used YA plot of special girl with powers+boy+evil government+rebellion and turned it into something fresh and new and exciting.

There's necromancy as I've never seen it before. Shadow players and desperation. A world filled with Southeast Asian influences, French colonialism and a mishmash of late nineteenth century technology. A main character who is bipolar. A character who is mixed race, with all of the feeling of a foot in each world and wholly belonging to neither. A broken family struggling to stay together no matter what cost. A brutal genocide and rebellion running through the background, with civilians caught in the crosshairs.

Let me just taken in a deep breath over the world-building.

It. Is. Incredible.

There are so many layers of pain and hope and survival in this book and I just want to wrap all of these wonderful characters (okay, not all of them—many are awful people) and protect them and whisper that it'll be better. Maybe. Probably not.

Wrapped into the storyline is a play, and songs, and messages and letters that enhance the story even more—and the title itself is from Shakespeare's Henry V (layers, right?)—and reveal all of the complexities of colonialism, from rebellion to collusion to just trying to survive to the implications of what happens when a foreign power is actually better (kinda but not really and by not really I mean not at all just worse in a different way?) than the monstrous deposed ruler?

It took me four days to read 50 pages, and then I sat down and devoured the last 440 in one day. That is how hooked I became, and how intense this book is. It literally does not let up.

I cannot wait for book 2. Mostly because I want to know what happens next. Where do they go? Where is safe?

Just a warning: there is graphic imagery and violence in this book.
Profile Image for Scrill.
410 reviews228 followers
November 18, 2018

Blog | Bookstagram | Instagram | Twitter

ARC provided via Edelweiss for a fair review

In a land stricken with war between a country colonizing it and its local rebels, Jetta and her family make their way across the country to hopefully catch the eye of the Boy King as a shadow troupe. If they manage to catch his favor it may be their ticket out of the dangerous country and a new life.

The Story-
Okay, I’m not going to lie. For most of this book I was confused, and I still am about a few aspects. Most of my issue was in the back story that coincides with the world building, but I will dive into that below. As far as the story went, it was unique and compelling. I liked the story about this girl who was traveling with her family in hopes to escape a country that is riveted with war. It was unique in the fact that they’re just trying to get out of there. They’re not part of the rebellion or the army trying to keep control of the country. You discover through the story that there are actually a few other reasons they are traveling out of the country, one being Jetta’s malheur. This problem she had was woven into the story that I almost missed it until they blatantly started to point it out. I really wish it was a lot more evident in her actions as it does play a major role for motivation, and her decision making in general.

The story itself was slow in progress, but it had enough action to keep you turning the pages and entertained. through this action there are some trigger warnings that can include: death, colonialism, racism, blood magic, war, implied of torture, implied of suicide, implied sexual abuse.

The World Building-
This is where I had the most trouble with the book. So to curb the pain of trying to get it out, I am going to talk about what I liked first.

I liked the Asian culture mixed in with the French bits. I can see where some people may find it offensive that the seemingly Caucasians are invading this darker skinned populated jungle-like country. But that doesn’t bother me, even with having some Filipino heritage. I know it’s most likely not inspired by the Philippines, but there are parts that just made me think of it. So, let me just say in advance, if anyone has an issue with that sort of parallelism, just maybe stay away? Like I said, it didn’t bother me, so let’s not make a big deal about it. I loved the description of the jungle, of the housing raised off the ground, the animals, etc, etc. Even though I struggle with French, it was a unique feeling to have the language interwoven into the culture of the people because of who they are occupied by.

Okay, on to the parts that didn’t make sense. I really wished Jetta’s magic was explained a little better in the beginning, because it would have helped me understand some of what was happening. By the end, I had a decent grasp on her abilities and it’s range, but there are still parts that slip through, such as the type of different spirits. I sort of just went with it rather than trying to think too hard on which type she was talking about. I did really like the magic and how it worked, it was unique and fit into the story and her occupation seamlessly.

The other part that I had an issue with was the political bits, mostly just because there was so much going on, and not a whole lot explained. And when it was explained it came in bits and pieces that felt disjointed as I read. There was some Boy King..that was getting crowned? I don’t know where he came from. Is he the rightful heir? There is some rebel leader named The Tiger…who we don’t really need to know anything about except he’s some rebel leader. There is some other….old king/leader, named Les Trespas? I don’t know who he was except that he had the same power as Jetta and…had some sort of role? There was something called the Victorie that was….when the country invaded? When that guy was captured? I don’t know, but they refer to it, and I either completely missed the explanation of what that event was…or it wasn’t explained all together.

So you can see how some parts were a little bit hard to follow due to understanding of the history and it’s characters with how they impact the story.

The Characters-
Jetta was a great character to read about. Her love of her family and what she did really made her character likeable. I loved the uniqueness of her talent, her magic and situation altogether. I really wished her problem was discussed a little better and was a bit more evident, I realized the issue after the fact and saw it later in what she does. But for part of the book I seriously thought they were referring to her magic. Nope, it was something different. Oh what the hell, it’s mentioned in the synopsis, so I will tell you that she is apparently bi-polar and is trying to get a cure for it? Unfortunately, I don’t know enough about it to definitively say if it was represented well by her character.

The romance in the book is almost non existent, which is sometimes a breath of fresh air. It wasn’t a driving factor for this heroine. Her family and their safety is such a large focus for her that when the romance aspect did come in, it almost seemed forced because I didn’t ‘ship the characters at all. It was sort of like, okay well I guess they can have romantic feelings, didn’t notice it before, but yeah, okay.
Profile Image for Glory.
350 reviews53 followers
October 12, 2018
Весь мир – театр, говорят в народе.
Но эта сцена в рисовых полях
Для всей Вселенной может стать приютом.

Ведь на простой бамбуковой платформе
Владычица теней рисует сказку,
Сама сокрыта шёлком, а за нею
Взлетают искры в бархатное небо.
Вспотевший лоб, в глазах восторга пламя.
И пляшет тьма для огнеликой музы.

По бледному холсту струятся тени,
Сплетаясь, будто чары, в нить историй:
И в них драконы рвут волков когтями,
Крестьянин вдруг на царский трон восходит,
А сами боги – жизни, смерти, знаний –
Гуляют среди смертных, что им служат.

Толпа зевак за шёлковой завесой,
Попав в сей мир, о прочем забывает:
О том, как процветают чужестранцы,
А им таких богатств не получить.
Как в тёмных джунгля�� прячутся повстанцы.
И как солдаты скоры на расправу.

Уж лучше от тревог укрыться в сказке.
Для многих только это и доступно.

И потому весь час ликует зритель,
В сто голосов рыдает и смеётся.
Аплодисменты как муссонный ливень
Питают влагой жаждущую землю.

Все чествуют её, теней хозяйку,
Что вырвалась из сгубленного края,
Как феникс ввысь из скорлупы и пепла
Или душа из сломленного тела.


Так начинается эта история. Нет, не так. Сначала, как и положено в театре, нам представляют персонажей, да представляют так, что уже не получится пр��сто закрыть книгу и не заглянуть хотя бы на следующую страницу, а вот там уже такой своеобразный пролог.

Я не буду долго говорить о сюжете, ибо в чем-то он весьма банален, автор открыто пользуется шаблонами жанра, просто оборачивает их в необыкновенно яркую и атмосферную упаковку. За основу взята французская экспансия Юго-Восточной Азии века эдак девятнадцатого. В роли Франции выступает Аквитан, в роли захваченной страны – Чакрана. Конечно, это лишь фантазия на заданную тему, а не альтернативная история, потому в Аквитане и Чакране намешано много всякого, что их отнюдь не портит. Зато при чтении можно нехило прокачать французский язык, ибо французских словечек автор навтыкала предостаточно, и притом они каким-то чудом не задавили восточный колорит.
Итак, аквитанцы захватывают очередную колонию для своего императора, чакранские повстанцы бегают по джунглям и рисовым полям, отстреливаются и устраивают взрывы. И на фоне этого типичного для янг адалата бунта разворачивается история главной героини – Джетты.
Джетта и ее родители (а когда-то и брат) – актеры театра теней. Их труппа лучшая в стране, а то и в империи. Вот только главный секрет их успеха может стоит Джетте жизни – она в одиночку управляет марионетками, так как своей кровью привязывает к ним души умерших. Это запрещенное некромантское искусство, за которое неминуема казнь.
Своими выступлениями семья Джетты надеется заполучить приглашение в Аквитан, где театр теней нынче в большой моде. Рвутся они туда не просто так, а в поисках лекарства от недуга героини (как и автор она страдает биполярным расстройством). Но, угодив в разборки мятежников и армии, они теряют шанс, и, как говорится, заверте... Джетта знакомится с Лео – молодым владельцем театра-кабаре (он же контрабандист), и все глубже увязает в мировых разборках, попутно меняя свое мнение и о повстанцах, и о захватчиках.

В общем-то, все остальное делают персонажи и подача материала.
Перед нами настоящий спектакль: роман разбит не только на главы, но на акты и сцены. Повествование от лица Джетты (в настоящем времени) перемежается с кусками пьесы, телеграммами, афишами, картами, даже нотами. Все вместе это складывается в невероятную картину мира, атмосферную, словно нарисованную тенями на шелковом полотне.
В каждом, даже самом второстепенном персонаже, автор раскрывает какую-то болезненную тему. Те же девушки из театра Лео, эдакие секс-работницы определенной эпохи, представлены в довольно неожиданном ключе (и блин, какие ж они получились классные).
Генералы, солдаты, безумный мальчик-король, актеры, тени и некромантия...
Это было очень красиво, увлекательно и необычно. И я даже рада простому сюжету, ибо окажись он посложнее, такая подача не сыграла бы, лишь запутав и отвратив читателя.

От меня все 5 звезд.
Жду продолжения серии (планируется трилогия) и надеюсь, что на историю обратят внимание наши издатели. Она того стоит.
Read
August 19, 2019
Blog 🍫 Goodreads 🍫 Twitter 🍫 Instagram 🍫 Pinterest 🍫 Tumblr 🍫 Bloglovin'

I don't know, guys, I think I might have chosen the wrong reading format for this one.

The thing with For a Muse of Fire is that it's told in various forms, including poems/songs and plays (scripts) which I believe would be more interesting to read rather than listen to (except the songs, I really liked having an idea of the rhythm and tone of them, and the narrator did an amazing job).

There were so many elements of this book that I loved: the mental illness rep (which was so realistic, but no wonder considering the author herself suffers from it), the world-building (1874 France and South East Asia-inspired places with a unique flair), the shadow puppetry (which I've never seen in any other novel and sounds SO COOL), the exploration of colonialism and how it affects a nation, plus the very essence of fantasy mixed in to create a really enticing story.

Unfortunately, I didn't feel all of these wonderful things while reading it, and got lost so many times that I ended up missing quite a few important bits (that possibly had a huge impact on my understanding of what was going on, plus connecting the dots later on). There were quite a few terrific plot twists that just didn't blow me away as much as I'd hoped because, again, I hadn't paid enough attention before to care now.

This may or may not be the book's fault or the writing. It may just as well be my own, for not having been in the right mindset. Otherwise, I don't actually see anything wrong with it and I'm willing to give it another try sometime. Of course, reading a physical/digital copy instead.

I have chosen not to rate it just because I don't feel like I've actually read this book, or given it a fair chance.
Profile Image for ambsreads.
748 reviews1,593 followers
Read
October 16, 2018
DNF @ 62%

I’ve been pretty good about not DNF’ing this year but I just can’t get into this story. It may be the format (audiobook) but I just can’t connect with the story or world building. I may try this in physical format one day but for now it’s a no.
Profile Image for Judithrosebooks.
542 reviews1,609 followers
May 15, 2019
2,5

SINOPSIS: Jetta viaja con su familia, ellos tienen una compañía de teatro de sombras más famoso de Chakrana, Jetta se encarga de manejar las marionetas que no tienen ni hilos, ni varillas...

En mirad de una rebelión de Chacranos contra aquitanos, estos últimos prohibieron las antiguas costumbres, por eso Jetta debe ocultar su secreto o podría terminar sus días en una cárcel o algo mucho peor.

Por el camino hacia la capital, se ven en envueltos por los rebeldes y el ejército, de los que tratarán de huir.

OPINIÓN: Me costó mucho centrarme en esta historia, no entendía muy bien lo que sucedía al principio, luego si empecé a centrarme en ella y los personajes que aparecen.

Lo positivo es que hay acción en todo momento, la historia avanza a un ritmo trepidante que te va dejando sorprendido a medida que vas avanzando. Se lee muy rápido. La protagonista me ha gustado, esa forma de conectar con los espíritus me ha sorprendido.

Lo negativo es que a pesar de haber mucha acción, como he comentado, me costó mucho entrar en la historia y realmente no me ha terminado de gustar la forma en como se explica todo, creo que la autora da poca información sobre los acontecimientos, sobre la rebelión y ciertos personajes que salen en la novela.

Por último, tenía entendido que era un retelling de Mulán, esa fue una de las razones por las que me animé a leerlo, pero no he visto nada de esto en la historia...
Profile Image for Lilly (Lair Of Books).
373 reviews253 followers
October 2, 2018
ARC received from the Publisher via Edelweiss in exchange for a honest review

Full RTC on LAIR OF BOOKS

INITIAL THOUGHTS: There's so much to love about this uniquely dark tale told in play format, 3 acts where we follow our MC Jetta as she is uprooted from the only place she's known as home. A story about Colonialism, mental health, racism, and necromancy that I just could not stop reading. This story will appeal to those who loved Rin Chupeco's The Bone Witch or anyone really who has interest in reading a book about a Necromancer. The fact that she's also a Puppeteer & can place souls into her puppets or any random object really, makes Jetta one unforgettable fictional character. More in depth thoughts to come in my review...
Profile Image for Lenore ..
Author 2 books65 followers
Shelved as 'you-keep-me-hanging-on'
September 2, 2018
Thank you Harper Collins for the early copy! I'm very excited for this!
Profile Image for Alexandra.
1,881 reviews10 followers
September 28, 2018
I received an e-ARC from Edelweiss in exchange for an honest review. Review can be found on *Milky Way of Books*

Jetta has an extraordinary ability...which must remain hidden if she and her family want to survive. In this world of Empires, conquered cities and full of spies, revolutionaries, and secrets Jetta will discover the extent of her own abilities and struggle with what she considers to be madness.

There were many parts at the beginning of the book that I didn't quite understand but slowly all made sense. There are also breaks between the chapters where from the first POV we go to the third and also the scenes are described like a theatre scenario. The plot is engaging and filled with fantasy and rich history.
Profile Image for Hanaa.
81 reviews
September 12, 2018
“Never show, Never tell.”
Okay, before i start the official review, i wanted to know: didn’t that line remind you of Frozen? Just me? That’s fine.

I have a feeling a lot of you are going to like this book, and that’s good. Personally I am really not sure about my feelings regarding this book. I liked it, but I didn’t love it. I read every page, i wanted to. But I didn’t devour it. There were some things that I didn’t predict, but unfortunately I predicted most of them. Also if you want to know, it isn’t like Frozen.

The story takes place in Chakra which has been conquered by the Aquitans’, and all magic has been banned.

Jetta, is a shadow player, one of the best. She uses her ability of being able to capture dead souls to control her puppets. How? She traps the souls in her puppets and commands them. The problem lies in the fact that the use of , or having such a power could get her killed.
However Jetta has another problem, one that is just inside her: she is mentally ill. The only cure that she knows of is the water of a magical fountain and to get there would mean that she would have to secure a place on the king’s ship that would take her to Aquitan.

However Jetta and her family are soon in danger when she nearly gives them away. With the help of Leo, a gun smuggler for the rebels, she tries to make her way to Aquitan without being found out.

THE CHARACTERS:
Jetta- she is brave and willing to do anything for her family. She is also scared of herself, the power she years and what she really is.

Leo- the owner of La Perl, a bar and a stripper club and the smuggler for the rebels,though he is not directly in league with them. Even though he was present during most of the book, I would have liked to get to know him better.

Captain Le Garde- the army general and an all round asshole.

I wish we could have had characters such as the Boy King, Theodora and Cheeky’s explored a bit more. They were important but weren’t really given the necessary attention.
The writing was engaging and kept you interested but wasn’t unique. The author uses a few french words in the beginning that may confuse you and like me you may find yourself googling “What is a fantoche?”

Themes such as mental illness, colonialism and feminism explored quite well.

All in all, the book was an engaging read that most readers will enjoy. I definitely will read the sequel.

*Thank you to the publisher for providing me with an arc of this book via Edelweiss*
Profile Image for Alexa (Alexa Loves Books).
2,361 reviews13.2k followers
August 13, 2018
It was a little hard to make sense of the world, language and storytelling format initially. But there was just enough of a draw to keep me interested in finding out how things would play out in the end.
Profile Image for Ryan.
273 reviews67 followers
September 5, 2022
An immensely irritating read. It was all angst and action that frequently left me baffled as to what was happening. I'd say it needed to be fleshed out. That for the seemingly traumatising events to really be impactful some downtime was needed to dwell on them, but instead we just got hit with another confrontation with people who were eager to kill for their cause. It got boring really quickly. The reason I won't say that it should have been fleshed out is because the audio narration was horrendously overdramaticised. It couldn't have ended soon enough. A breathless two note performance by Emily Woo Zeller who I'll now avoid for fear that they'll ruin a book I might actually enjoy.

Not so much For a Muse of Fire but a muse for fire because if I owned a physical copy I'd probably burn it.
Profile Image for Britt.
17 reviews28 followers
September 6, 2018
Necromancy with puppets...

French and Asian influences.

Magic and epic adventures.

For a Muse of Fire is a story about a girl named Jetta. Her family is the Ros Nai – a troupe of shadow players that is on their way to being the most famous in the country. Their puppets seem to move and dance without strings and everyone is always captivated by the stories they tell with her father singing the old tales and her mother playing the thom and flute while Jetta directs the puppets behind the scrim.

Learning about Jetta’s dangerous and intriguing magic, while seeing glimpses of her bipolar disorder – all while they are on an epic, hazardous journey is one of the most interesting point of views I have read in a while. I love her character. I also enjoyed the slow-burn romance and her deep connection and love for her family.

The Ros Nai troupe is hoping to perform their way to another country where the Mad King is said to drink from a spring that cures his madness. Their family is hoping this spring may also help Jetta. When tensions rise even further between the armèe and the rebellion in their country, Jetta and her family are caught in the middle and their journey turns even more dangerous and difficult.

A cast of characters, old folktales, telegrams, sheet music, letters, play scripts, and maps are all comprised to make up this story. I loved the interesting and changing ways of information while still hearing the story from Jetta’s point of view.

The world-building was vivid, dark, complex, and captivating. I loved this story and am so happy to hear that there will be more! This is definitely a series to jump on.

And in case I needed to say it again - PUPPET NECROMANCY!

*Thank you very much to HarperCollins via Edelweiss*
Profile Image for The Girl with the Sagittarius Tattoo.
2,585 reviews355 followers
May 24, 2024
I'm disappointed I didn't like this more. I don't even know why I didn't.

Jetta is the daughter of a family of talented shadow puppeteers, with an extra-special something: she can "attach" a soul to a "body," and it will obey her - a useful skill in her line of work. She only uses animal souls like birds, butterflies and kittens, but still. She'd be hung for necromancy if anyone outside her family found out.

The family lives in an occupied country, and the people are on the verge of revolt. Small attacks from rebels are already happening, but it's like a mosquito biting an elephant. They need to make a bigger dent if they're going to affect real change. If only the rebels had an unstoppable army...

This was okay, but I'm just not interested enough to read the other two books. Moving on.
Profile Image for Vicky Again.
626 reviews846 followers
May 16, 2019
3.5 stars

I liked it a lot and I think it's really well written, although I realize this is definitely not for everyone. It doesn't have as much commercial appeal, but the dissection of colonialism and the intricate approach to the politics was something I greatly enjoyed.
Profile Image for Catherine Lefay.
739 reviews438 followers
September 29, 2019
Caos, con esa palabra defino este libro.
La idea era fantástica, pero el desarrollo fue pobre, todo demasiado 'conveniente'.
A los personajes les pasaban muchas cosas pero poco les servía para madurar, era muy unidimensionales, inconsecuentes.
A pesar de que el libro tiene bastante acción, le sobraban unas 100 páginas, con menos palabras y mejor desarrollo esa historia podría haber sido maravillosa, la falta de estructuración también fue perjudicial.
No le bajo más estrellas porque entiendo que una pequeña parte del caos era intencional, parte de la condición de la protagonista, pero eso no justifica todas las escenas innecesarias, diálogos huecos y falta de consistencia de la historia.
Una lástima todo ello, pero aún así la historia es lo suficientemente entretenida como para querer leer que sucede en el siguiente libro.
Profile Image for Viri.
1,235 reviews449 followers
November 27, 2019
Este libro fue muy raro jajaja

no se bien como sentirme al respecto pero ya les dejé la reseña en el blog 😘
Displaying 1 - 30 of 445 reviews

Can't find what you're looking for?

Get help and learn more about the design.