What do you think?
Rate this book
Broken Strings
A violin and a middle-school musical unleash a dark family secret in this moving story by an award-winning author duo. For fans of The Devil's Arithmetic and Hana's Suitcase .
It's 2002. In the aftermath of the twin towers -- and the death of her beloved grandmother -- Shirli Berman is intent on moving forward. The best singer in her junior high, she auditions for the lead role in Fiddler on the Roof , but is crushed to learn that she's been given the part of the old Jewish mother in the musical rather than the coveted part of the sister. But there is an upside: her "husband" is none other than Ben Morgan, the cutest and most popular boy in the school.
Deciding to throw herself into the role, she rummages in her grandfather's attic for some props. There, she discovers an old violin in the corner -- strange, since her Zayde has never seemed to like music, never even going to any of her recitals. Showing it to her grandfather unleashes an anger in him she has never seen before, and while she is frightened of what it might mean, Shirli keeps trying to connect with her Zayde and discover the awful reason behind his anger. A long-kept family secret spills out, and Shirli learns the true power of music, both terrible and wonderful.
It's 2002. In the aftermath of the twin towers -- and the death of her beloved grandmother -- Shirli Berman is intent on moving forward. The best singer in her junior high, she auditions for the lead role in Fiddler on the Roof , but is crushed to learn that she's been given the part of the old Jewish mother in the musical rather than the coveted part of the sister. But there is an upside: her "husband" is none other than Ben Morgan, the cutest and most popular boy in the school.
Deciding to throw herself into the role, she rummages in her grandfather's attic for some props. There, she discovers an old violin in the corner -- strange, since her Zayde has never seemed to like music, never even going to any of her recitals. Showing it to her grandfather unleashes an anger in him she has never seen before, and while she is frightened of what it might mean, Shirli keeps trying to connect with her Zayde and discover the awful reason behind his anger. A long-kept family secret spills out, and Shirli learns the true power of music, both terrible and wonderful.
288 pages, Hardcover
First published September 10, 2019
About the author
Eric Walters
149 books887 followersEric was born in Toronto in 1957, which makes him "real old". But, as Eric says, "Just because I have to grow old doesn't mean that I have to grow up!" In his many roles as parent, teacher, social worker, youth sports coach and writer he is in constant contact with children and young adults. He draws from these experiences and feels that this helps him to capture the realistic interaction between young people - the conflicts, tensions, stresses and interests that make up their lives.
Eric began his writing as a teacher. He taught in classes from kindergarten up and his stories often reflect the curriculum that he was teaching. He always read stories - picture books and novels - to his students and this helped him to understand what children liked, responded to, and were inspired by. He enjoys the enthusiasm of his students and often looks at them to provide him with the inspiration to pursue a particular topic in both the classroom and in his writing.
Eric tries to write every day. When he has a story idea he starts with research. This could involve reading books, watching a documentary, or trying to experience the things that his characters are going to go through. This could include rock climbing or riding white water (for STARS), spending time in a wheelchair (Rebound), playing and walking with tigers (Tiger By The Tail), hanging around a tough biker bar (Diamonds in the Rough), standing out in his backyard in a blizzard wearing a T-shirt and shorts (Trapped In Ice), or traveling to Africa (Alexandria of Africa).
"The most important thing anybody ever told me about writing was to write what you know . . . and the only way to get to know things is to do your homework and research before you write," Eric stated.
Once the writing begins the story is always playing around in his head. He takes any opportunity, even if it's just a few minutes between presentations, to put things down, either with pen and paper or on his laptop.
Prior to entering teaching and writing Eric was a social worker (B.S.W., M.S.W., B.A.Hons - specialized major psychology). He worked in a variety of settings including child welfare, private practice, a mental health centre, and, for twenty years on a part-time basis as a Crisis Social Worker in an emergency department. He stopped teaching 4 years ago and left the ER only last year.
The majority of Eric's time is spent in the company of his wife, children and dogs (Lola a big standard poodle and a little white dog named Winnie The Poodle).
Eric began his writing as a teacher. He taught in classes from kindergarten up and his stories often reflect the curriculum that he was teaching. He always read stories - picture books and novels - to his students and this helped him to understand what children liked, responded to, and were inspired by. He enjoys the enthusiasm of his students and often looks at them to provide him with the inspiration to pursue a particular topic in both the classroom and in his writing.
Eric tries to write every day. When he has a story idea he starts with research. This could involve reading books, watching a documentary, or trying to experience the things that his characters are going to go through. This could include rock climbing or riding white water (for STARS), spending time in a wheelchair (Rebound), playing and walking with tigers (Tiger By The Tail), hanging around a tough biker bar (Diamonds in the Rough), standing out in his backyard in a blizzard wearing a T-shirt and shorts (Trapped In Ice), or traveling to Africa (Alexandria of Africa).
"The most important thing anybody ever told me about writing was to write what you know . . . and the only way to get to know things is to do your homework and research before you write," Eric stated.
Once the writing begins the story is always playing around in his head. He takes any opportunity, even if it's just a few minutes between presentations, to put things down, either with pen and paper or on his laptop.
Prior to entering teaching and writing Eric was a social worker (B.S.W., M.S.W., B.A.Hons - specialized major psychology). He worked in a variety of settings including child welfare, private practice, a mental health centre, and, for twenty years on a part-time basis as a Crisis Social Worker in an emergency department. He stopped teaching 4 years ago and left the ER only last year.
The majority of Eric's time is spent in the company of his wife, children and dogs (Lola a big standard poodle and a little white dog named Winnie The Poodle).
Ratings & Reviews
Friends & Following
Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!
Community Reviews
Displaying 1 - 30 of 177 reviews
October 25, 2019
Broken Strings is a layered, thoughtful, and ultimately uplifting book about the power of family, memory, and music. Set only months after the terrible events of 9/11, the story follows Shirli and her middle school classmates, all of whom experienced some of the horror of living through 9/11, whether through images on TV, or seeing the towers fall from across the Hudson River, or having lost friends or family in the attacks.
Now, six months later, the school readies for its spring musical production, Fiddler on the Roof. Shirli is initially disappointed not to get the flashier role of Hodel, the daughter in the musical with the best solo, but she grows to appreciate her role as Golde, especially since it means spending hours working with the adorable Ben, who has the star role of Tevye, Golde's husband.
Shirli knows from her parents that her grandfather's parents' families were originally from Eastern Europe and lived through some of the pogroms that took place in the time period of Fiddler, so she begins to ask him questions in hopes of better understanding the characters. And although she's aware that Zayde survived the Holocaust and bears a concentration camp tattoo on his arm, he's never spoken of his experiences to her or to anyone else in the family. But as she visits Zayde, little by little he begins to share the story of what happened to his family during the Holocaust, and why he has never played his violin or even listened to music in all the years since.
There's so much to love about Broken Strings. First, it's a sweet story about middle school friendship and crushes, about talent and hard work and ambition, and about dedication to one's passions. At the same time, it's about family, the power of love, and the devastation of loss and memories too painful to bring into the light of day. And finally, it's about the healing power of sharing oneself and one's stories, about making connections, and about rising above hatred to find common ground in even unlikely places.
The characters are all well-drawn and realistic, and it's beautiful to see how Zayde influences those around him by reaching across divides and making friends. Shirli is a lovely main character, and I appreciated how well the authors show both her insecurities and her devotion to her friends and family.
Broken Strings is really a special book. Highly recommended for middle grade readers as well as the adults in their lives.
Now, six months later, the school readies for its spring musical production, Fiddler on the Roof. Shirli is initially disappointed not to get the flashier role of Hodel, the daughter in the musical with the best solo, but she grows to appreciate her role as Golde, especially since it means spending hours working with the adorable Ben, who has the star role of Tevye, Golde's husband.
Shirli knows from her parents that her grandfather's parents' families were originally from Eastern Europe and lived through some of the pogroms that took place in the time period of Fiddler, so she begins to ask him questions in hopes of better understanding the characters. And although she's aware that Zayde survived the Holocaust and bears a concentration camp tattoo on his arm, he's never spoken of his experiences to her or to anyone else in the family. But as she visits Zayde, little by little he begins to share the story of what happened to his family during the Holocaust, and why he has never played his violin or even listened to music in all the years since.
There's so much to love about Broken Strings. First, it's a sweet story about middle school friendship and crushes, about talent and hard work and ambition, and about dedication to one's passions. At the same time, it's about family, the power of love, and the devastation of loss and memories too painful to bring into the light of day. And finally, it's about the healing power of sharing oneself and one's stories, about making connections, and about rising above hatred to find common ground in even unlikely places.
The characters are all well-drawn and realistic, and it's beautiful to see how Zayde influences those around him by reaching across divides and making friends. Shirli is a lovely main character, and I appreciated how well the authors show both her insecurities and her devotion to her friends and family.
Broken Strings is really a special book. Highly recommended for middle grade readers as well as the adults in their lives.
October 9, 2021
This book. 😍 Too beautiful to review to even review properly (and it's been a good bit since I've read it), but I gave it a shot.
This is one of the few books that has made me feel most at home in my Jewish identity. It's a story not focused solely on WW2 or the Exodus or the other handful of topics Jewish characters usually get.
The main character is an American Jew learning more about her complicated heritage (sound like me 😉) while getting to rehearse a school play of The Fiddler on the Roof (a.k.a. the greatest piece of Jewish media of all time and a huge favorite of some relatives I never got to meet).
Let's just say my nerd heart was happy, and I enjoyed the quiet, natural discussions of healing, diversity, and loving all people. Truly satisfying.
This is one of the few books that has made me feel most at home in my Jewish identity. It's a story not focused solely on WW2 or the Exodus or the other handful of topics Jewish characters usually get.
The main character is an American Jew learning more about her complicated heritage (sound like me 😉) while getting to rehearse a school play of The Fiddler on the Roof (a.k.a. the greatest piece of Jewish media of all time and a huge favorite of some relatives I never got to meet).
Let's just say my nerd heart was happy, and I enjoyed the quiet, natural discussions of healing, diversity, and loving all people. Truly satisfying.
August 23, 2020
Wow. So many wonderful things within the pages of this book. It’s historical fiction, family heritage, coming-of-age, and a play production of Fiddler On the Roof, all in one! Eric Walters is known for his books about 9/11, and Kathy Kacer has written many books about the Holocaust for middle-grade and Y.A. readers. Their collaboration on “Broken Strings” was simply masterful!
I would recommend this for all Y.A. classrooms, and for history buffs everywhere.
Memorable Quotes:
(Pg. 139)-“I couldn’t imagine what it was that my grandfather was dealing with-what volcano of painful memories was bubbling up inside of him. You can’t throw a kid into the deep end of a swimming pool and not worry that he might drown, I reasoned. I had to let Zayde wade into his past at his own pace.”
(Pg. 248)-“It was then that I suddenly understood all of why it was so important for him to talk about his life. With each part of his story, he was giving us insights into our own characters and our own scenes. He was giving us all a history lesson that would influence our performances.”
I would recommend this for all Y.A. classrooms, and for history buffs everywhere.
Memorable Quotes:
(Pg. 139)-“I couldn’t imagine what it was that my grandfather was dealing with-what volcano of painful memories was bubbling up inside of him. You can’t throw a kid into the deep end of a swimming pool and not worry that he might drown, I reasoned. I had to let Zayde wade into his past at his own pace.”
(Pg. 248)-“It was then that I suddenly understood all of why it was so important for him to talk about his life. With each part of his story, he was giving us insights into our own characters and our own scenes. He was giving us all a history lesson that would influence our performances.”
September 24, 2019
Many thanks to NetGalley, Penguin Random House Canada, Kathy Kacer, and Eric Walters for an ARC in exchange for an honest book review of Broken Strings. My thoughts and opinions are 100% my own and independent of receiving an advance copy.
Shirli is starring in her middle school play. This year the production is Fiddler on the Roof. Shirli has a close relationship with her Zaide and visits him every week. She suspected that he might have some things in his attic that would be helpful for the play. Maybe some old dresses, shawls, or aprons. Her Zaide said she could use whatever she thought would be helpful. But when she was digging around up there she made an amazing discovery. She found a violin. She couldn’t believe that it was her grandfather’s. He never listened to music or attended any of her performances. Shirli knew that he had some bad memories from the war and he never liked to talk about it. She also discovered a poster with a picture of a family and if she wasn’t mistaken it was her grandfather, when he was a child! Having discovered a long hidden family secret is not easy. But through love and understanding, family can help heal a tragic past.
This story is for both children and young adults. I would be very comfortable with a child of 10 or 11 reading this. It does contain stories of the Holocaust, but nothing so graphic that it would be inappropriate. If you have a sensitive child, you might want to read this first just to be sure they wouldn’t be bothered by any of the stories. These are two heavyweight authors. Kathy Kacer has a lot of experience writing Holocaust stories for children and writes sensitive, thoughtful storylines. Eric Walters is a prolific children’s writer who writes incredible adventure stories and also has dealt with the Holocaust subject matter in his novels.
I loved this story. There are so many elements that make it heartfelt and meaningful, without becoming cheesy or forceful in its message. The relationship between Shirli and her grandfather is beautiful. You can see why her Zaide opens up to her about the war. There is a sweet romantic storyline between Shirli and Ben, who is her co-lead in the play. They lightly touch upon 9-11 and the aftermath effects of a community trying to heal. This story has a rich text and as a teacher, I would have a lot of material to use. There are themes of racism, antisemitism, and war along with intergenerational relationships, family and school. My mind is racing with ideas of how to use it in a classroom setting.
At the heart of this beautiful story is one that most children will enjoy reading. For children who don’t know about the Holocaust, it is a wonderful introduction. Shirli is a sweet, kind, likable character, the grandfather is funny and all the supporting characters add something to the story. Every character goes through some kind of growth and yet, it all blends so nicely that the story never gets convoluted or off track. This was an outstanding read for me and timeless, something that I think can be read for years and years to different generations.
Shirli is starring in her middle school play. This year the production is Fiddler on the Roof. Shirli has a close relationship with her Zaide and visits him every week. She suspected that he might have some things in his attic that would be helpful for the play. Maybe some old dresses, shawls, or aprons. Her Zaide said she could use whatever she thought would be helpful. But when she was digging around up there she made an amazing discovery. She found a violin. She couldn’t believe that it was her grandfather’s. He never listened to music or attended any of her performances. Shirli knew that he had some bad memories from the war and he never liked to talk about it. She also discovered a poster with a picture of a family and if she wasn’t mistaken it was her grandfather, when he was a child! Having discovered a long hidden family secret is not easy. But through love and understanding, family can help heal a tragic past.
This story is for both children and young adults. I would be very comfortable with a child of 10 or 11 reading this. It does contain stories of the Holocaust, but nothing so graphic that it would be inappropriate. If you have a sensitive child, you might want to read this first just to be sure they wouldn’t be bothered by any of the stories. These are two heavyweight authors. Kathy Kacer has a lot of experience writing Holocaust stories for children and writes sensitive, thoughtful storylines. Eric Walters is a prolific children’s writer who writes incredible adventure stories and also has dealt with the Holocaust subject matter in his novels.
I loved this story. There are so many elements that make it heartfelt and meaningful, without becoming cheesy or forceful in its message. The relationship between Shirli and her grandfather is beautiful. You can see why her Zaide opens up to her about the war. There is a sweet romantic storyline between Shirli and Ben, who is her co-lead in the play. They lightly touch upon 9-11 and the aftermath effects of a community trying to heal. This story has a rich text and as a teacher, I would have a lot of material to use. There are themes of racism, antisemitism, and war along with intergenerational relationships, family and school. My mind is racing with ideas of how to use it in a classroom setting.
At the heart of this beautiful story is one that most children will enjoy reading. For children who don’t know about the Holocaust, it is a wonderful introduction. Shirli is a sweet, kind, likable character, the grandfather is funny and all the supporting characters add something to the story. Every character goes through some kind of growth and yet, it all blends so nicely that the story never gets convoluted or off track. This was an outstanding read for me and timeless, something that I think can be read for years and years to different generations.
March 4, 2022
My daughter and I listened to this on audio and it was a great experience. I loved this story. I'm a theater nerd at heart, and I always wanted to be in a production of Fiddler on the Roof, so that aspect of the story was a lot of fun. It's also my daughter's favorite musical, so she loved getting a sort of behind-the-scenes of a school production.
But the heart of this story is the relationship between Shirli and her Zayde and her discovery about his past. This book does so much in under 300 pages. I love that it's a story about family and heritage, Jewishness, theater, and life in the immediate aftermath of 9/11. I loved it.
But the heart of this story is the relationship between Shirli and her Zayde and her discovery about his past. This book does so much in under 300 pages. I love that it's a story about family and heritage, Jewishness, theater, and life in the immediate aftermath of 9/11. I loved it.
March 9, 2021
First off, the history aspect of this book was compelling and inspiring. Whether or not you read this book, you should google music and the holocaust, it’s both fascinating and tragic.
I related to the theatre aspect of this book (Shirli’s school is performing Fiddler on the Roof). Though my personal experience has been slightly different, I resonated with Shirli’s love of theatre even though she’s not overly outgoing.
What didn’t I like? To start, I had a hard time relating to Shirli, other than theatre, we don’t have much in common. As I was reading, I would think, “Shirli, what are you doing?!? That’s not what I would do at all!” I think someone else might really relate to Shirli, I just didn’t personally 😕
I was also a little frustrated with the musical director, Ms. Ramsey. In the story, Ms. Ramsey is experiencing a rough patch and she takes it out on the cast (yelling, criticizing, etc). Maybe some directors truly act that way, but as it is radically different from my experience, I had trouble liking Ms. Ramsey as a person.
Okay, now for the teen romance. Sure, it was cute; aww, look at the little 8th graders crushing on each other! But really?!? 13 year olds don’t need passionate kisses!!!!
That may have seemed like a lot of criticism, but don’t let me steer you away too quick. It kept my attention really well, and the unfolding of the plot was intriguing. I especially liked Shirli’s grandfather and her friend Natasha (probably my favorite characters; her grandfather has a lot of depth, and Natasha is both funny and more relatable to me).
Overall, a fun, easy read.
I related to the theatre aspect of this book (Shirli’s school is performing Fiddler on the Roof). Though my personal experience has been slightly different, I resonated with Shirli’s love of theatre even though she’s not overly outgoing.
What didn’t I like? To start, I had a hard time relating to Shirli, other than theatre, we don’t have much in common. As I was reading, I would think, “Shirli, what are you doing?!? That’s not what I would do at all!” I think someone else might really relate to Shirli, I just didn’t personally 😕
I was also a little frustrated with the musical director, Ms. Ramsey. In the story, Ms. Ramsey is experiencing a rough patch and she takes it out on the cast (yelling, criticizing, etc). Maybe some directors truly act that way, but as it is radically different from my experience, I had trouble liking Ms. Ramsey as a person.
Okay, now for the teen romance. Sure, it was cute; aww, look at the little 8th graders crushing on each other! But really?!? 13 year olds don’t need passionate kisses!!!!
That may have seemed like a lot of criticism, but don’t let me steer you away too quick. It kept my attention really well, and the unfolding of the plot was intriguing. I especially liked Shirli’s grandfather and her friend Natasha (probably my favorite characters; her grandfather has a lot of depth, and Natasha is both funny and more relatable to me).
Overall, a fun, easy read.
March 21, 2021
Broken Strings is a strong middle-grade release about the pain of the past and how it can affect future generations. This novel features characters with a deep love of music, a captivating account of surviving the Jewish Holocaust, and the beauty of unlikely friendships. If you enjoy books with any of the themes mentioned, then this book is right up your alley. I would definitely recommend it to fans of middle-grade historical fiction.
Read my full review on my blog.
Read my full review on my blog.
January 17, 2021
As someone who is quite literally sitting under a framed Fiddler on the Roof poster that has hung above my bed for the better half of my life this book really struck home for me. It is such a sweet story about a middle school theater production but it has so many important messages and so much love woven in as well. I loved how it demonstrated the power of family, community, and music when it comes to healing and bringing people together.
I can understand some of the reviews that had a difficult time with this book due to the fact that they were unfamiliar with Fiddler and I would highly recommend watching/reading it before this book so that you can truly understand the story and how impactful it can be.
I can understand some of the reviews that had a difficult time with this book due to the fact that they were unfamiliar with Fiddler and I would highly recommend watching/reading it before this book so that you can truly understand the story and how impactful it can be.
April 16, 2024
A thoroughly heartwarming and wonderful middle grade book.
Loved Shirli’s Zaida!!!
I did think the “romance” was extraneous but it wasn’t so bad or prominent that it bothered me enough to take off any stars. An excellent read.
Loved Shirli’s Zaida!!!
I did think the “romance” was extraneous but it wasn’t so bad or prominent that it bothered me enough to take off any stars. An excellent read.
December 14, 2020
I've got mixed feelings. (That's my original review and I'm sticking to it.)
This book was incredibly well written, and I really loved seeing all the characters grow and change as they interacted with each other. I also really loved showing the aftermath of 9/11, and how the characters handled that. I really loved how tactfully the author handled the grandfather's backstory. We need more fiction with diverse characters like this.
I got a little lost sometimes because I've never seen Fiddler on the Roof, which wasn't a fault of the book so much as just a bit of an irritation.
So why not five stars? I don't know. I just came away not loving this story, even though I loved a lot of parts of it.
I would recommend this to kids 12 and up for thematic elements.
This book was incredibly well written, and I really loved seeing all the characters grow and change as they interacted with each other. I also really loved showing the aftermath of 9/11, and how the characters handled that. I really loved how tactfully the author handled the grandfather's backstory. We need more fiction with diverse characters like this.
I got a little lost sometimes because I've never seen Fiddler on the Roof, which wasn't a fault of the book so much as just a bit of an irritation.
So why not five stars? I don't know. I just came away not loving this story, even though I loved a lot of parts of it.
I would recommend this to kids 12 and up for thematic elements.
July 21, 2021
2021 bk 223: I've been reading the 2021-2022 Young Hoosier List titles. At this point - Broken Strings has my vote for the best I've read thus far. There are so many themes that are tied together in this story of a Junior High production of Fiddler on the Roof - and Eric Walters has done a fantastic job of weaving all of the parts together. 9/11, Holocaust, Bereavement, Latch key kids, caregiving, types of music, diversity of a student body, with a lot of family love and a little romance (very little) thrown in. An excellent read. I will admit - I cried. I recommend this to middle grades and adults.
April 10, 2020
Shirli Berman is chosen to play the lead in her school's production of Fiddler on the Roof. While searching in her grandfather's attic for props for the play, she comes across an old violin and a poster featuring her much younger grandfather with a group of musicians. When she questions her grandfather, he gets very upset and won't discuss it with her.
Shirli is upset because her Zayde (grandfather) is always so open with her. They have a close relationship, which has become even closer after the death of her grandmother (Bubbie). She soon discovers why he is so upset. Her grandfather has a secret that no one in the family knows about. He and his family were traveling musicians in Poland during WWII. They hid in the forests and almost managed to escape being captured by the Nazis. Almost managed. Unfortunately, they were caught and sent to Auschwitz, where the whole family, except for Zayde perished. Zayde managed to bring his violin to Auschwitz and was given the job of playing in a band that serenaded prisoners as the walked to their death. Her grandfather never forgave himself for this and once he was liberated from the camp, he never played the violin again or allowed music in his house.
This middle grade novel, which is set in New Jersey in 2002, right after 911 covers some heavy topics. Coping with a major world tragedies and grief play a big part of the story. But it is also a story of hope, acceptance and learning to put the past behind you. Her grandfather, after years of keeping the tragedy of his youth to himself, finds himself opening up about his past, which allows him to slowly begin to heal and move on. The biggest step for her grandfather is when he is given the chance to help Shirli with her play. It gives him a new purpose in his life and he welcomes music in once again.
This book also touches on racism especially towards Muslims after 911. There is also a really nice side story of Zayde befriending Amir, a Hindu man who helps him after he falls in front of his store. Amir lost a nephew in 911 and even though he is not Muslim, he faces racism.
I think this is an important book for middle-schoolers to read. It is a good starting point for many lessons. There is also a sweet love story between Shirli and her cast mate, Ben that will appeal to this age group. Overall this is a well written story that I thoroughly enjoyed.
Shirli is upset because her Zayde (grandfather) is always so open with her. They have a close relationship, which has become even closer after the death of her grandmother (Bubbie). She soon discovers why he is so upset. Her grandfather has a secret that no one in the family knows about. He and his family were traveling musicians in Poland during WWII. They hid in the forests and almost managed to escape being captured by the Nazis. Almost managed. Unfortunately, they were caught and sent to Auschwitz, where the whole family, except for Zayde perished. Zayde managed to bring his violin to Auschwitz and was given the job of playing in a band that serenaded prisoners as the walked to their death. Her grandfather never forgave himself for this and once he was liberated from the camp, he never played the violin again or allowed music in his house.
This middle grade novel, which is set in New Jersey in 2002, right after 911 covers some heavy topics. Coping with a major world tragedies and grief play a big part of the story. But it is also a story of hope, acceptance and learning to put the past behind you. Her grandfather, after years of keeping the tragedy of his youth to himself, finds himself opening up about his past, which allows him to slowly begin to heal and move on. The biggest step for her grandfather is when he is given the chance to help Shirli with her play. It gives him a new purpose in his life and he welcomes music in once again.
This book also touches on racism especially towards Muslims after 911. There is also a really nice side story of Zayde befriending Amir, a Hindu man who helps him after he falls in front of his store. Amir lost a nephew in 911 and even though he is not Muslim, he faces racism.
I think this is an important book for middle-schoolers to read. It is a good starting point for many lessons. There is also a sweet love story between Shirli and her cast mate, Ben that will appeal to this age group. Overall this is a well written story that I thoroughly enjoyed.
May 25, 2020
This book has been sitting in my to read pile for sometime. I picked it up earlier today and started reading and was immediately hooked. The story has several threads that run through it. It is the story of students who love to sing and act and this means a lot to me as my husband has volunteered a lot with youth theatre through the years as well as being involved in theatre himself. I know young people who could have been the characters in this book. The play they are working on presenting is Fiddler on the Roof which has to be one of my all time favourites. (I will want to watch it again soon after reading this).
The book is also one with an important lesson to teach about how we are all connected in spite of external differences. The most important relationship in the book is that of Shirli and her beloved Zayde (grandfather). The story is set in New York in the time after 9/11. Zayde still mourns the loss of his wife and relies on his grand-daughter for grocery shopping and the deep affection that they share. As Shirli prepares to take on the role of Golde in the play, she gradually learns more about the history of her grandfather and his family during the war. He has never shared his story before even with his son but bits and pieces start to surface when Shirli, looking for potential props for the play, discovers an old violin with broken strings and a poster for a Klezmer band that has a picture of a much younger Zayde. She always knew he was a Holocaust survivor because of his blue tattoo but now she learns more about why he never likes listening to music let alone playing it and what happened to the rest of his family.
There are many other relationships that are also important to the story - the camaraderie that develops among the cast members, the Hindu man who befriends Zayde and who lost a family member when the Twin Towers fell. The authors seamlessly interweave all the characters in a wonderful way to give Zayde back the gift of music and to bring the play to fruition.
The book tells a very moving story and has some very difficult moments as history comes to light. I shed a few tears but I feel it is a very appropriate book for middle school readers which hopefully will spark an interest in learning more about this painful time in history as well as how lessons learned can shape our lives.
The book is also one with an important lesson to teach about how we are all connected in spite of external differences. The most important relationship in the book is that of Shirli and her beloved Zayde (grandfather). The story is set in New York in the time after 9/11. Zayde still mourns the loss of his wife and relies on his grand-daughter for grocery shopping and the deep affection that they share. As Shirli prepares to take on the role of Golde in the play, she gradually learns more about the history of her grandfather and his family during the war. He has never shared his story before even with his son but bits and pieces start to surface when Shirli, looking for potential props for the play, discovers an old violin with broken strings and a poster for a Klezmer band that has a picture of a much younger Zayde. She always knew he was a Holocaust survivor because of his blue tattoo but now she learns more about why he never likes listening to music let alone playing it and what happened to the rest of his family.
There are many other relationships that are also important to the story - the camaraderie that develops among the cast members, the Hindu man who befriends Zayde and who lost a family member when the Twin Towers fell. The authors seamlessly interweave all the characters in a wonderful way to give Zayde back the gift of music and to bring the play to fruition.
The book tells a very moving story and has some very difficult moments as history comes to light. I shed a few tears but I feel it is a very appropriate book for middle school readers which hopefully will spark an interest in learning more about this painful time in history as well as how lessons learned can shape our lives.
December 8, 2021
My heart! This was such a tearjerker for me. This middle grade novel set in the months following the fall of the Twin Towers wrecked me emotionally and I can't recommend it enough. 8th grade singer, Shirli Berman, wants to look forward to something positive in the aftermath of the 9/11 attack and the loss of her grandmother. She has her sights set on being Hodel in the spring musical, Fiddler on the Roof. When she is stuck playing Golde, the mother, she is at first disappointed but then realizes her "husband" will be the most popular boy in school. She may not get any solos but she can act and sing her heart out. As a Jewish teen, Shirli relates to the story of the musical, her grandfather was even from Poland not long after the play is set. She wants to really get into the part so she starts going over to her grandfather's house more and trying to get him to talk about his past, something he never does. Even her father (his son) doesn't know about all the terrible things he suffered through during the Holocaust. Shirli and her grandfather start bonding over the musical and start opening up to each other in very powerful ways. A wonderful, moving story.
May 16, 2024
Good for upper elementary. I liked the music theme throughout and also the lines drawn between post 9/11 treatment of ethnicities in the US and holocaust treatment of Jews.
One of the major plot points felt very unrealistic to me though and I had a hard time with that.
One of the major plot points felt very unrealistic to me though and I had a hard time with that.
August 26, 2019
Told from a first person genre I fell in love with this story.
I love this story because of all the events that were connected in this book. And the violin that was featured in this book. You see, I came from a long line of string players too! And now my son is playing the violin in his school orchestra. I'm hoping that he will continue playing after he graduates.
I felt the author was telling my story of how the violin was found. You see, my mother played the viola and one day I was in the basement looking around. I spied an old worn case that looked in terrible condition. Well you know me and my curiosity as a kid. I went and opened it and there layed this beautiful instrument. I started plucking it and my mom yelled at me to leave it alone. I knew then I had to learn to play it and it has carried me through my own life.
Later I found out that my mom had played in the Columbus Symphony Orchestra. Now I too play in the Lexington Community Orchestra. I love it so much!!
I cried like a baby when Zayde told his story. I'm so glad that he did what he did!! I loved watching him open up and be the man that he should have been with a granddaughter and God's help. All we need to is ask and not be so prideful!!
Friendships from a walks of life are formed in this beautiful story for we are all humans. I believe that the Lord has created us all equal in His eyes and mine too.
I've heard of Fiddler on the Roof but have never actually seen it. So this was treat for me seeing it through the eyes of children of all things! And they did a fabulous job too!
I want to buy this copy when it comes out because there's nothing like holding a book in your hands. Even if it is a young adult I still very much enjoyed it.
I strongly recommend this book.
My thanks to Netgalley for a copy of this book and NO compensations were received. All opinions are my own.
I love this story because of all the events that were connected in this book. And the violin that was featured in this book. You see, I came from a long line of string players too! And now my son is playing the violin in his school orchestra. I'm hoping that he will continue playing after he graduates.
I felt the author was telling my story of how the violin was found. You see, my mother played the viola and one day I was in the basement looking around. I spied an old worn case that looked in terrible condition. Well you know me and my curiosity as a kid. I went and opened it and there layed this beautiful instrument. I started plucking it and my mom yelled at me to leave it alone. I knew then I had to learn to play it and it has carried me through my own life.
Later I found out that my mom had played in the Columbus Symphony Orchestra. Now I too play in the Lexington Community Orchestra. I love it so much!!
I cried like a baby when Zayde told his story. I'm so glad that he did what he did!! I loved watching him open up and be the man that he should have been with a granddaughter and God's help. All we need to is ask and not be so prideful!!
Friendships from a walks of life are formed in this beautiful story for we are all humans. I believe that the Lord has created us all equal in His eyes and mine too.
I've heard of Fiddler on the Roof but have never actually seen it. So this was treat for me seeing it through the eyes of children of all things! And they did a fabulous job too!
I want to buy this copy when it comes out because there's nothing like holding a book in your hands. Even if it is a young adult I still very much enjoyed it.
I strongly recommend this book.
My thanks to Netgalley for a copy of this book and NO compensations were received. All opinions are my own.
December 30, 2019
Broken Strings is a beautiful story about heritage, coming of age, and finding one's voice in the face of the past.
Shirli has her entire 8th grade year figured out. She'll get the lead of her favorite daughter in Fiddler on the Roof, and find some way to cope with the aftermath of the attack on the twin towers and the death of her bubbie. But Shirli is instead cast as Golde, the Jewish mother. Determined to make the best of her situation, she raids her Zayde's attack for props. But what she finds drags up old memories for her Zayde, and soon the past and the present collide. Now, Shirli must try to navigate her Zayde's complicated past to solve the mystery.
Broken Strings was one of the most beautiful middle grade novels I have ever read. Setting the story in the months following the devastating attack on the Twin Towers made for an interesting and poignant story, and the exploration of racism was so beautifully done. The book also dives into the history of the Russian pogroms, the Holocaust, and the aftermath thereof in a manor that is easily digestible for young readers. The characters are believable and fun, but also present realistic challenges. Shirli explores the past while trying to relate it to her present, and her character brings forth so many questions that really encourage the reader to think. Overall, this book is a perfect blend of history and fun. I think it's perfect for younger readers looking to explore a side of history they may not know about, as well as those looking for a realistic retelling of middle school.
Shirli has her entire 8th grade year figured out. She'll get the lead of her favorite daughter in Fiddler on the Roof, and find some way to cope with the aftermath of the attack on the twin towers and the death of her bubbie. But Shirli is instead cast as Golde, the Jewish mother. Determined to make the best of her situation, she raids her Zayde's attack for props. But what she finds drags up old memories for her Zayde, and soon the past and the present collide. Now, Shirli must try to navigate her Zayde's complicated past to solve the mystery.
Broken Strings was one of the most beautiful middle grade novels I have ever read. Setting the story in the months following the devastating attack on the Twin Towers made for an interesting and poignant story, and the exploration of racism was so beautifully done. The book also dives into the history of the Russian pogroms, the Holocaust, and the aftermath thereof in a manor that is easily digestible for young readers. The characters are believable and fun, but also present realistic challenges. Shirli explores the past while trying to relate it to her present, and her character brings forth so many questions that really encourage the reader to think. Overall, this book is a perfect blend of history and fun. I think it's perfect for younger readers looking to explore a side of history they may not know about, as well as those looking for a realistic retelling of middle school.
April 28, 2019
Thank you to NetGalley and Puffin Books for an eARC of this book.
Shirli Berman wants the role of Hodel in the school production of Fiddler on the Roof, and is upset when she gets the part of Golde, the Jewish mother. Her one consolation is that her stage husband is Ben, one of the cutest boys in middle school. When she asks her Zayde if she can borrow props from his attic for their play, she uncovers something hidden away for many years, and learns about family history that has never been discussed. A series of events unfold that reveal the power of music and its impact on the lives it touches.
I really loved Zayde, and the powerful transformation that he went through over the course of this book. I enjoyed how music connected Zayde and Shirli, and the relationship that they had. There is a lot of talk about discrimination, especially since this book is set in the aftermath of September 11th, and some interesting parallels were brought to light. I think students will be drawn to this story by two well-known Canadian authors, and I look forward to hearing their reactions to the story.
Shirli Berman wants the role of Hodel in the school production of Fiddler on the Roof, and is upset when she gets the part of Golde, the Jewish mother. Her one consolation is that her stage husband is Ben, one of the cutest boys in middle school. When she asks her Zayde if she can borrow props from his attic for their play, she uncovers something hidden away for many years, and learns about family history that has never been discussed. A series of events unfold that reveal the power of music and its impact on the lives it touches.
I really loved Zayde, and the powerful transformation that he went through over the course of this book. I enjoyed how music connected Zayde and Shirli, and the relationship that they had. There is a lot of talk about discrimination, especially since this book is set in the aftermath of September 11th, and some interesting parallels were brought to light. I think students will be drawn to this story by two well-known Canadian authors, and I look forward to hearing their reactions to the story.
August 19, 2020
Along with trying to read more diverse books, I have been trying to specifically read more books by Jewish authors and about Jewish people. I ran across this one at my local library and it caught my eye and I brought it home.
A beautiful story about past traumas and trying to learn about family history, this book combines Shirli and her grandfather and their differing opinions. Shirli would like to know more about her grandfathers past and his time during the Nazi takeover, and he would like to forget it happened. I love how it brings them together but also separates them.
I think it is a wonderful story for kids to read, and to be able to learn about the Holocaust in a different way other than just a straight non-fiction book. I think it invites the reader into the atrocities that took place and the effect it had on people who were involved on either side. Anyone of any age can and should read this to continue their education on not only the Holocaust itself, but on being a decent human being. It teaches compassion, honesty, trust, and most of all, love.
A beautiful story about past traumas and trying to learn about family history, this book combines Shirli and her grandfather and their differing opinions. Shirli would like to know more about her grandfathers past and his time during the Nazi takeover, and he would like to forget it happened. I love how it brings them together but also separates them.
I think it is a wonderful story for kids to read, and to be able to learn about the Holocaust in a different way other than just a straight non-fiction book. I think it invites the reader into the atrocities that took place and the effect it had on people who were involved on either side. Anyone of any age can and should read this to continue their education on not only the Holocaust itself, but on being a decent human being. It teaches compassion, honesty, trust, and most of all, love.
March 11, 2021
Broken Strings by Kathy Kacer and Eric Walters is a beautiful novel based on past and current life experiences. Broken Strings captures the essence of high school teenage drama and a history lesson.
Broken Strings is a novel about a young girl named Shirli. Shirli is in grade eight and loves theatre. The novel begins with Shirli trying out for the school play “Fiddler on the Roof” for her favourite part; Hodel. Sadly she doesn’t get the lead. Her antagonist, Mindi, apprehends the part. Shirli is devastated and hurt that she doesn’t get the lead role. Shirli has a grandfather that she loves dearly. Shirli’s grandfather, Zayde is a very domineering and quiet grandfather who loves Shirli. Zayde has a passion for music, but when the topic of Zayde playing an instrument comes up it brings him great pain of his past, and the trauma he had experienced.
When Zayde was young he didn’t have a place to call home. Zayde and his family are Jewish and were always on the run from the Nazis. The Nazis found Zadye and his family. Zayde and his family started to play their instruments. The Nazis took them to a camp alive. Because of Zayde’s playing, they let Zayde, his brother and his father live, but sadly the others did not. Zayde's past starts to come to light when Shirli gets a part in the play. Shirli wants to learn more about the Nazis and Jewish people. Shirli asks Zayde about his past. While asking Zayde questions about his personal history and music, Shrili discovers an emotional secret Zayde has been hiding.
Broken strings is a novel I thoroughly enjoyed. My rating for Broken Strings is four stars. I have given the novel four stars because the book has an excellent story. I adored how the book interlinked the life experiences of Zayde and Shirli. My grandfather and I have a very similar relationship to Shirli and Zayde. I liked how the story plays out in the end, with Zayde and Shirli performing a duet at the end of the play. Broken Strings has so much passion in its writing. While reading this fictional writing, I immediately knew that I loved this book.
This admirable novel expresses conflicts, friendships, and so much more with remarkable depth in the story that makes you feel like you are a part of their world. The plot of Broken Strings was so enjoyable. There were many twists and turns. I do think that the novel needed a little more excitement and more mystery into Zayde’s past. Zayde’s history was very intriguing to learn about and was an excellent plot to the story.
In conclusion, I learned things that I never knew about and what others had to go through. I think Broken Strings is an excellent read. I highly recommend reading this novel. I hope this book review was helpful to you.
Broken Strings is a novel about a young girl named Shirli. Shirli is in grade eight and loves theatre. The novel begins with Shirli trying out for the school play “Fiddler on the Roof” for her favourite part; Hodel. Sadly she doesn’t get the lead. Her antagonist, Mindi, apprehends the part. Shirli is devastated and hurt that she doesn’t get the lead role. Shirli has a grandfather that she loves dearly. Shirli’s grandfather, Zayde is a very domineering and quiet grandfather who loves Shirli. Zayde has a passion for music, but when the topic of Zayde playing an instrument comes up it brings him great pain of his past, and the trauma he had experienced.
When Zayde was young he didn’t have a place to call home. Zayde and his family are Jewish and were always on the run from the Nazis. The Nazis found Zadye and his family. Zayde and his family started to play their instruments. The Nazis took them to a camp alive. Because of Zayde’s playing, they let Zayde, his brother and his father live, but sadly the others did not. Zayde's past starts to come to light when Shirli gets a part in the play. Shirli wants to learn more about the Nazis and Jewish people. Shirli asks Zayde about his past. While asking Zayde questions about his personal history and music, Shrili discovers an emotional secret Zayde has been hiding.
Broken strings is a novel I thoroughly enjoyed. My rating for Broken Strings is four stars. I have given the novel four stars because the book has an excellent story. I adored how the book interlinked the life experiences of Zayde and Shirli. My grandfather and I have a very similar relationship to Shirli and Zayde. I liked how the story plays out in the end, with Zayde and Shirli performing a duet at the end of the play. Broken Strings has so much passion in its writing. While reading this fictional writing, I immediately knew that I loved this book.
This admirable novel expresses conflicts, friendships, and so much more with remarkable depth in the story that makes you feel like you are a part of their world. The plot of Broken Strings was so enjoyable. There were many twists and turns. I do think that the novel needed a little more excitement and more mystery into Zayde’s past. Zayde’s history was very intriguing to learn about and was an excellent plot to the story.
In conclusion, I learned things that I never knew about and what others had to go through. I think Broken Strings is an excellent read. I highly recommend reading this novel. I hope this book review was helpful to you.
This entire review has been hidden because of spoilers.
January 19, 2020
4.5
Shortly after the towers fall on 9/11 in New York, Shirli, a young Jewish girl, is cast as Golde (the older mother) in her middle school's production of Fiddler on the Roof. She's upset she won't have a solo, until her crush, Ben Morgan (who isn't Jewish,) is cast as Tevye (her husband.) She decides to be the best Golde she can be, and even enlists her Zayde (Yiddish for "grandfather") to help by donating old items from his attic for costumes and props for the show. While Shirli is digging around the attic looking for old clothes, she uncovers a poster and an old violin, but when she shows them to her grandfather, he yells at her. Slowly, over the book, he shares with her his experiences as a young boy who was sent to Auschwitz with his entire family.
This ya novel was very moving and respectfully discussed both the Holocaust and bigotry against Muslims after 9/11 in the United States in an appropriate way for middle schoolers who may be new to these subject areas, while saving room for normal middle school subjects like first crushes, jealousy, and friendships. I really see this as a stepping stone for conversations about bigotry and hatred and the horrors that are going on in our own country today. Of course, it's not as deep or graphic as a book written for an older audience would be, but it absolutely works for the group it was written for.
Thank you to LibraryThing and the publisher for providing me with a free copy of this book in exchange for my honest review. It has not influenced my opinion.
Shortly after the towers fall on 9/11 in New York, Shirli, a young Jewish girl, is cast as Golde (the older mother) in her middle school's production of Fiddler on the Roof. She's upset she won't have a solo, until her crush, Ben Morgan (who isn't Jewish,) is cast as Tevye (her husband.) She decides to be the best Golde she can be, and even enlists her Zayde (Yiddish for "grandfather") to help by donating old items from his attic for costumes and props for the show. While Shirli is digging around the attic looking for old clothes, she uncovers a poster and an old violin, but when she shows them to her grandfather, he yells at her. Slowly, over the book, he shares with her his experiences as a young boy who was sent to Auschwitz with his entire family.
This ya novel was very moving and respectfully discussed both the Holocaust and bigotry against Muslims after 9/11 in the United States in an appropriate way for middle schoolers who may be new to these subject areas, while saving room for normal middle school subjects like first crushes, jealousy, and friendships. I really see this as a stepping stone for conversations about bigotry and hatred and the horrors that are going on in our own country today. Of course, it's not as deep or graphic as a book written for an older audience would be, but it absolutely works for the group it was written for.
Thank you to LibraryThing and the publisher for providing me with a free copy of this book in exchange for my honest review. It has not influenced my opinion.
July 1, 2021
Best suited for age 11+
This is a beautifully written book that touches on many difficult topics - grief, aging, crushed dreams, young crushes, family, love.
Shirli Berman is disappointed to be cast in the role the old Jewish mother in her school's production of 'Fiddler on the Roof'. She had her heart set on the lead. The only upside is that her"husband" is the cutest boy in school! At the same time, her family is trying to support Shirli's grandfather as he adjusts to life without his wife, Shirli's beloved grandmother who she is also still grieving.
As Shirli rummages in her Zayde's attic looking for items that will aid her in her role in the musical at school, she discovers a violin tucked in to a corner. She is perplexed because her grandparents never seemed to like music, her Zayde especially has refused to even come see his granddaughter perform. Her discovery causes a long kept family secret to come to light. A secret that stretches back to WWII and the concentration camps of Nazi Germany.
Set in 2002, in the aftermath of the twin towers with the rise of anti-Muslim sentiment in the US, the story is particularly poignant. This book will pull at the heart strings.
This is a beautifully written book that touches on many difficult topics - grief, aging, crushed dreams, young crushes, family, love.
Shirli Berman is disappointed to be cast in the role the old Jewish mother in her school's production of 'Fiddler on the Roof'. She had her heart set on the lead. The only upside is that her"husband" is the cutest boy in school! At the same time, her family is trying to support Shirli's grandfather as he adjusts to life without his wife, Shirli's beloved grandmother who she is also still grieving.
As Shirli rummages in her Zayde's attic looking for items that will aid her in her role in the musical at school, she discovers a violin tucked in to a corner. She is perplexed because her grandparents never seemed to like music, her Zayde especially has refused to even come see his granddaughter perform. Her discovery causes a long kept family secret to come to light. A secret that stretches back to WWII and the concentration camps of Nazi Germany.
Set in 2002, in the aftermath of the twin towers with the rise of anti-Muslim sentiment in the US, the story is particularly poignant. This book will pull at the heart strings.
February 16, 2020
Shirli dreams of playing the role of Hodel in her school’s production of Fiddler on the Roof, and is very disappointed to be cast instead as Golde, Tevye’s wife. In an attempt to get a better grasp on her part, she asks her grandfather, a Holocaust survivor, about their family history. Though he’s initially hesitant to open up, when Shirli discovers an old violin in his attic, he eventually tells her his story, which is more heartbreaking than she could have imagined.
This is a good story, and an important one. It’s well-plotted, but I found the writing to be rather pedestrian: the dialogue is stiff in places, the tone often didactic. I’d recommend it to kids learning about the Holocaust, and to those who love theatre. I probably wouldn’t recommend it to adults, though, unless those subjects are specifically appealing.
This is a good story, and an important one. It’s well-plotted, but I found the writing to be rather pedestrian: the dialogue is stiff in places, the tone often didactic. I’d recommend it to kids learning about the Holocaust, and to those who love theatre. I probably wouldn’t recommend it to adults, though, unless those subjects are specifically appealing.
May 1, 2022
This is a great book for middle school students, especially those involved in musical theater. In a story that centers around a middle school production of Fiddler on the Room, the students learn so many lessons. They learn about the values of hard work, working together toward a common goal, diversity and empathy. They learn about disappointment and tragedy, and the difference between them. They also learn some background of the lives of Jews like Tevye and his family. And they learn about the Holocaust. The grandfather's story is told slowly, and while it does not get graphic or gory, it does not hold back about the tragic losses and some of the horrors of Auschwitz. It is a very good level of information for a middle school student, told in an engrossing story set in 2002, in the shadow of 9/11. Minor criticisms would be that some of the characters are too good to be true, and the Junior High seems to house students in 7th-9th grade whereas most middle schools I'm familiar with these days seem to be 6th-8th grade. It's an excellent story, and I would highly recommend it.
September 17, 2024
Broken Strings is a powerful and poignant novel that delves into the complexities of history, identity, and personal growth. The story follows the journey of a young boy, Sam, who uncovers his grandfather's harrowing past as a Holocaust survivor through a family violin. The dual narrative, shifting between Sam's present and his grandfather's past, is both compelling and heartbreaking.
The authors skillfully weave historical details with emotional depth, creating a narrative that is both educational and deeply moving. The characters are well-developed, and the exploration of themes such as memory, trauma, and reconciliation is handled with sensitivity and nuance.
Though the novel's pacing can occasionally feel uneven, the rich storytelling and the impactful revelations make it a memorable read. "Broken Strings" is a testament to the resilience of the human spirit and a reminder of the importance of remembering and honoring the past.
Overall, this book is a poignant exploration of history and family, and it will resonate deeply with readers interested in stories of personal and historical significance.
The authors skillfully weave historical details with emotional depth, creating a narrative that is both educational and deeply moving. The characters are well-developed, and the exploration of themes such as memory, trauma, and reconciliation is handled with sensitivity and nuance.
Though the novel's pacing can occasionally feel uneven, the rich storytelling and the impactful revelations make it a memorable read. "Broken Strings" is a testament to the resilience of the human spirit and a reminder of the importance of remembering and honoring the past.
Overall, this book is a poignant exploration of history and family, and it will resonate deeply with readers interested in stories of personal and historical significance.
April 14, 2021
A read aloud for history that I picked up on a whim. It combines a look back to the Holocaust and also weaves in experiences from 9/11, so could be helpful for both topics. We found it especially helpful in understanding what Holocaust survivors experienced and how challenging it was not only to live through that terror, but to be left alone with painful memories the rest of your life. I also personally loved the connection to Fiddler on the Roof and had lots of flashbacks to doing the play myself in high school and learning a lot during that time from a dear Jewish friend. I think I would recommend more for middle to high school though than middle grade- there is a bit of a romance with two of the students with a kiss at the end, which I decided to censor in my reading aloud. Just felt that bit was not necessary for my kids’ ages.
This entire review has been hidden because of spoilers.
February 5, 2021
As a musical theatre buff, someone who's interested in Holocaust lit, and someone who was the same age as the MC on 9/11, this book definitely struck a chord with me! I devoured the second half of the novel in one sitting, and cried as Shirli helped her grandfather find joy in music. My only quibble is that there were a few times when the authors glossed over a scene with a quick narration when I would have liked to have seen that scene unfold.
September 26, 2019
An absolutely amazing book! Highly recommended for middle school and up. Weaves the story of the main character’s grandfather who is a Holocaust survivor with his granddaughter’s putting on Fiddler on the Roof. Hits every note perfectly. (Pun intended) I literally couldn’t stop reading it till done!
June 18, 2022
I read this book to my grade 8 class and they loved it. They made excellent connections throughout the book and were able to develop an understanding of the trauma inflicted from concentration camps.
This book takes so many big ideas and packs them into one lovely story. The characters are believable and their emotions are authentic. I loved the combination of the effects of 9/11 and the Holocaust as well as every day teenage angst.
Excellent book for middle school audiences.
This book takes so many big ideas and packs them into one lovely story. The characters are believable and their emotions are authentic. I loved the combination of the effects of 9/11 and the Holocaust as well as every day teenage angst.
Excellent book for middle school audiences.
May 31, 2019
This is a must own for every library - both public and school. It’s an amazing read with some amazing historical details. I adored this!
Thank you to SLC for sending me an ARC to review.
Thank you to SLC for sending me an ARC to review.
Displaying 1 - 30 of 177 reviews