What do you think?
Rate this book
Beguiled
A dark and enthralling story about a young woman who makes a deal with a spirit to try and gain her independence—and the twisted price she has to pay for it
Ella is a 17-year-old weaver whose entire livelihood depends on her loom. She dreams of opening her own shop, but when her father died in debtor’s prison, she had to support herself by taking whatever clients she could get. In order to buy her supplies she goes into debt of her own, and when her loom breaks, Ella realizes she needs more help than a repairperson can give her. She, like everyone, has heard about the old washerwoman spirit called the Bean-Nighe who will grant any one wish—for a price.
But Ella is desperate, so she asks the Bean-Nighe to fix her loom. And it works. The loom is fixed, and she's creating beautiful pieces she could have never imagined before. All she has to do is feed the loom a drop of blood each time she weaves—a small price to pay for such magnificent silks. And when she brings two bolts to a rich client, she meets a mysterious young man named Callum and bargains for an invitation to his exclusive party. At that party, he's so mesmerized by her talent, he offers Ella a place to live and patronage for her art. It seems like Ella's fortune is finally turning for the better . . . until she begins to notice the loom taking more from her than she offered.
As she becomes entangled in the lives of the city’s rich, swept into Callum's allure, and trapped by the Bean-Nighe’s magic, Ella must figure out a way to secure her future while she still has a future at all.
Ella is a 17-year-old weaver whose entire livelihood depends on her loom. She dreams of opening her own shop, but when her father died in debtor’s prison, she had to support herself by taking whatever clients she could get. In order to buy her supplies she goes into debt of her own, and when her loom breaks, Ella realizes she needs more help than a repairperson can give her. She, like everyone, has heard about the old washerwoman spirit called the Bean-Nighe who will grant any one wish—for a price.
But Ella is desperate, so she asks the Bean-Nighe to fix her loom. And it works. The loom is fixed, and she's creating beautiful pieces she could have never imagined before. All she has to do is feed the loom a drop of blood each time she weaves—a small price to pay for such magnificent silks. And when she brings two bolts to a rich client, she meets a mysterious young man named Callum and bargains for an invitation to his exclusive party. At that party, he's so mesmerized by her talent, he offers Ella a place to live and patronage for her art. It seems like Ella's fortune is finally turning for the better . . . until she begins to notice the loom taking more from her than she offered.
As she becomes entangled in the lives of the city’s rich, swept into Callum's allure, and trapped by the Bean-Nighe’s magic, Ella must figure out a way to secure her future while she still has a future at all.
384 pages, Hardcover
First published August 23, 2022
About the author
Cyla Panin
3 books73 followersCyla Panin is an MG and YA writer who prefers to look at the world through a dusting of magic. After spending most of her childhood wanting to escape into the wonderful worlds her favourite authors created, she’s now using her own words to craft magical places. When not writing, Cyla can be found playing dinosaurs with her two young boys, watching swashbuckling and/or period TV shows with her husband, and, of course, reading.
Her YA fantasy debut, STALKING SHADOWS is a gothic, feminist fantasy retelling of Beauty and the Beast. To protect her sister, Marie laces perfumes with honeysuckle to mark victims for Ama to hunt when she transforms into a beast at night. But when a child in their town is killed, Marie is forced to acknowledge that she might be losing control of Ama—and must instead find a cure for this curse. It will be published by Amulet/Abrams in fall 2021.
Her YA fantasy debut, STALKING SHADOWS is a gothic, feminist fantasy retelling of Beauty and the Beast. To protect her sister, Marie laces perfumes with honeysuckle to mark victims for Ama to hunt when she transforms into a beast at night. But when a child in their town is killed, Marie is forced to acknowledge that she might be losing control of Ama—and must instead find a cure for this curse. It will be published by Amulet/Abrams in fall 2021.
Ratings & Reviews
Friends & Following
Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!
Community Reviews
Displaying 1 - 30 of 70 reviews
September 14, 2022
Such a stunning story about Celtic spirit Bean-nighe with feminism vibes!
I love moving, compelling, though provoking stories with powerful, tough, inspirational leading characters like Ella is portrayed in this book!
Only thing Ella wanted was gaining her independence, opening her own store, paying her debt, sharpening her tailoring skills for creating extraordinary pieces in expanse of making a deal with a spirit: washerwoman a. k.a. bean-nighe: Scottish spirit.
And miraculously her dreams start coming true:Her broken loom gets fixed! She keeps creating dreamy masterpieces as number of her distinguished client keep climbing! And now she met a mysterious, wealthy stranger offering her a lifetime opportunity she cannot refuse!
She feeds her loom with a drop of her blood in exchange of creating those marvelous pieces but when her loom turns into something more malicious than Little Shop of Horrors’ blood sucking Audrey- the flower!
What if she has to pay with her life to pay her entire debt!
Overall: it was addictive, well written, enchanting fantasy! I highly recommend it!
Special thanks to NetGalley and ABRAMS Kids , Amulet Kids for sharing this amazing digital weekend for sharing this digital reviewer copy with me in exchange my honest thoughts.
I love moving, compelling, though provoking stories with powerful, tough, inspirational leading characters like Ella is portrayed in this book!
Only thing Ella wanted was gaining her independence, opening her own store, paying her debt, sharpening her tailoring skills for creating extraordinary pieces in expanse of making a deal with a spirit: washerwoman a. k.a. bean-nighe: Scottish spirit.
And miraculously her dreams start coming true:Her broken loom gets fixed! She keeps creating dreamy masterpieces as number of her distinguished client keep climbing! And now she met a mysterious, wealthy stranger offering her a lifetime opportunity she cannot refuse!
She feeds her loom with a drop of her blood in exchange of creating those marvelous pieces but when her loom turns into something more malicious than Little Shop of Horrors’ blood sucking Audrey- the flower!
What if she has to pay with her life to pay her entire debt!
Overall: it was addictive, well written, enchanting fantasy! I highly recommend it!
Special thanks to NetGalley and ABRAMS Kids , Amulet Kids for sharing this amazing digital weekend for sharing this digital reviewer copy with me in exchange my honest thoughts.
October 9, 2022
Thank you to ABRAMS Kids, Amulet Books and NetGalley for the opportunity to read the eARC.
Based on Celtic mythology, Beguiled has an interesting concept. Unfortunately, the execution left something to be desired.
Woven throughout the story are tales (and appearances) of Celtic gods, the fae, and Bean-Nighe. This part of the story was entertaining and explained. It was everything other than the folklore that went astray.
The characters were only half-developed. I never got a good feel for the side characters at all, and for someone who's a character-driven reader, that causes my interest to wane. Then there was the MC. While I understood her motivations based on her backstory, she was so naive about everything around her. Of course, she's only 17, so somewhat understandable. But even so, she puts her head in the sand for a good portion of the book.
Other than the folklore, the worldbuilding was pretty weak. There's a Chieftain—who may be one of many?—who rules her town, country? He's influenced by the Players, which is never explained well. Once certain twists were revealed, it seemed like the whole background dropped.
Overall, not a terrible book. It was entertaining, but it just needed more to make it a good book.
Side-note: At 17, the romance in the book is kind of creepy.
Based on Celtic mythology, Beguiled has an interesting concept. Unfortunately, the execution left something to be desired.
Woven throughout the story are tales (and appearances) of Celtic gods, the fae, and Bean-Nighe. This part of the story was entertaining and explained. It was everything other than the folklore that went astray.
The characters were only half-developed. I never got a good feel for the side characters at all, and for someone who's a character-driven reader, that causes my interest to wane. Then there was the MC. While I understood her motivations based on her backstory, she was so naive about everything around her. Of course, she's only 17, so somewhat understandable. But even so, she puts her head in the sand for a good portion of the book.
Other than the folklore, the worldbuilding was pretty weak. There's a Chieftain—who may be one of many?—who rules her town, country? He's influenced by the Players, which is never explained well. Once certain twists were revealed, it seemed like the whole background dropped.
Overall, not a terrible book. It was entertaining, but it just needed more to make it a good book.
Side-note: At 17, the romance in the book is kind of creepy.
May 4, 2024
You're on your own, kid
You always have been
From sprinkler splashes to fireplace ashes
I gave my blood, sweat, and tears for this
I hosted parties and starved my body
Like I'd be saved by a perfect kiss
The jokes weren't funny, I took the money
My friends from home don't know what to say
I looked around in a blood-soaked gown
And I saw something they can't take away
4.5/5
You always have been
From sprinkler splashes to fireplace ashes
I gave my blood, sweat, and tears for this
I hosted parties and starved my body
Like I'd be saved by a perfect kiss
The jokes weren't funny, I took the money
My friends from home don't know what to say
I looked around in a blood-soaked gown
And I saw something they can't take away
4.5/5
August 28, 2022
Beguiled is an immersive YA fantasy that follows Ella, a weaver struggling to pay off her debt and make ends meet when her loom breaks. Since her loom is her livelihood and Ella’s only way of gaining security, independence, and getting out of debt from an underhanded and lecherous lender, Ella makes a bargain with a magical granter of wishes. However, Ella soon learns to be careful what she wishes for and who she makes deals with. The story reminds me a bit of The Monkey’s Paw by W. W. Jacobs in that way. Your wishes might come true but not in the way you initially hoped, and sometimes those wishes can work to your detriment.
The world-building in the story is really well done, and I enjoyed the integration of Celtic folklore and legends. The Bean-Nighe is a major influence in the story, and I didn’t know much about the legend prior to reading this book. Ella travels a twisted and dark path as she makes a deal with the Bean-Nighe and promises to give a drop of blood every time she uses her loom. Elle learns a lot by making this deal with the Bean-Nighe and is pulled into a world of opulence, beauty, and mystery.
Ella lives a solitary and poverty-stricken life, especially since her father died. Riddled with debt with little hope of pulling herself out of the dire situation she is in, Ella longs for more. She wants her own shop, a successful business, and the financial independence and safety that come with it. Above all, Ella wants to be seen – to be recognized for her extraordinary skill but also valued as a person, and this has rarely happened in her life. It’s no surprise when she makes a deal with the Bean-Nighe to improve her situation. Ella is a layered character, determined and brave, scheming and lonely with a tragic backstory, and though I didn’t find her the most likable protagonist, I understood her desires and motivations and sympathized with her situation.
The story is filled with many morally grey characters, some who toe the line between good and evil and some who gleefully jump back and forth. They’re the kind of characters who keep the reader on their toes, as it’s never clear who can be trusted, who is scheming, and who has good intentions. Throughout the book, I wondered about Callum’s motivations, in particular. Was he good? Was he evil? What did he really want from Ella? I felt that way about several characters, and the enigma surrounding Callum and the others was one of the highlights of the story. The plot also touches upon thought-provoking themes of classism, manipulation, poverty, and more. I like that, though it seems like a relatively simple story, it has many layers to unravel.
Overall, this was a unique and intriguing YA fantasy, and I would recommend it to readers who like enchanting tales steeped in Celtic lore. Thanks so much to Amulet Books and TBR and Beyond Tours for gifting me a copy of the book. All thoughts are my own.
The world-building in the story is really well done, and I enjoyed the integration of Celtic folklore and legends. The Bean-Nighe is a major influence in the story, and I didn’t know much about the legend prior to reading this book. Ella travels a twisted and dark path as she makes a deal with the Bean-Nighe and promises to give a drop of blood every time she uses her loom. Elle learns a lot by making this deal with the Bean-Nighe and is pulled into a world of opulence, beauty, and mystery.
Ella lives a solitary and poverty-stricken life, especially since her father died. Riddled with debt with little hope of pulling herself out of the dire situation she is in, Ella longs for more. She wants her own shop, a successful business, and the financial independence and safety that come with it. Above all, Ella wants to be seen – to be recognized for her extraordinary skill but also valued as a person, and this has rarely happened in her life. It’s no surprise when she makes a deal with the Bean-Nighe to improve her situation. Ella is a layered character, determined and brave, scheming and lonely with a tragic backstory, and though I didn’t find her the most likable protagonist, I understood her desires and motivations and sympathized with her situation.
The story is filled with many morally grey characters, some who toe the line between good and evil and some who gleefully jump back and forth. They’re the kind of characters who keep the reader on their toes, as it’s never clear who can be trusted, who is scheming, and who has good intentions. Throughout the book, I wondered about Callum’s motivations, in particular. Was he good? Was he evil? What did he really want from Ella? I felt that way about several characters, and the enigma surrounding Callum and the others was one of the highlights of the story. The plot also touches upon thought-provoking themes of classism, manipulation, poverty, and more. I like that, though it seems like a relatively simple story, it has many layers to unravel.
Overall, this was a unique and intriguing YA fantasy, and I would recommend it to readers who like enchanting tales steeped in Celtic lore. Thanks so much to Amulet Books and TBR and Beyond Tours for gifting me a copy of the book. All thoughts are my own.
Read
October 12, 2023When someone alerts to me to a story in which the main character is a textile artist, especially if the crafted work takes on unique magical properties, I jump at the chance to read, so I was grateful to get my hands on an early review copy of this one.
.
Panin draws on fabulous folklore that's a little less often tread than we sometimes see in YA. I loved that the lore felt familiar, and yet, not quite. A magical device that costs the user more than they anticipated when they bargained for it, given by a granter of wishes, but one readers might not have previously encountered, and one whose existence takes on more interesting layers as the story progresses. Unfolding much like The Picture of Dorian Gray, we see our heroine make her bargain in hopes of getting her heart's desire, only to fuel her greed and ambition until she's dug herself a heck of hole to climb out of. I loved that in this way, the heroine had lots of agency within the story, creating her own downfall before she could fight her way back to a place of hope and stability.
.
The textiles and weaving and clothing weren't as central to the story/as detailed as I'd anticipated, but for many readers, this will be an asset as the story doesn't slow down for lengthy descriptions or employ specialized terminology that might give a reader pause. It's also a tightly focused story, with only a few characters to follow and a few locations for the action, creating an interesting sense of claustrophobia as tension mounts and we sense that something's about to go terribly wrong. A good fit for readers who enjoy a blend of folklore with a hint of light horror and a thematic look at the impact of wealth disparity in an undefined other-time/other-place community.
.
Panin draws on fabulous folklore that's a little less often tread than we sometimes see in YA. I loved that the lore felt familiar, and yet, not quite. A magical device that costs the user more than they anticipated when they bargained for it, given by a granter of wishes, but one readers might not have previously encountered, and one whose existence takes on more interesting layers as the story progresses. Unfolding much like The Picture of Dorian Gray, we see our heroine make her bargain in hopes of getting her heart's desire, only to fuel her greed and ambition until she's dug herself a heck of hole to climb out of. I loved that in this way, the heroine had lots of agency within the story, creating her own downfall before she could fight her way back to a place of hope and stability.
.
The textiles and weaving and clothing weren't as central to the story/as detailed as I'd anticipated, but for many readers, this will be an asset as the story doesn't slow down for lengthy descriptions or employ specialized terminology that might give a reader pause. It's also a tightly focused story, with only a few characters to follow and a few locations for the action, creating an interesting sense of claustrophobia as tension mounts and we sense that something's about to go terribly wrong. A good fit for readers who enjoy a blend of folklore with a hint of light horror and a thematic look at the impact of wealth disparity in an undefined other-time/other-place community.
August 18, 2022
I received an ARC from Edelweiss
TW: self harm, gaslighting & emotional abuse, mentions of domestic abuse, knife violence
3.3
When Ella's loom, her only source of what little income she has, is broken, she has no one to turn to but a legend. Everyone knows seeking out the Bean-Nighe and her wish is more dangerous than any boon can worth, but those people aren't desperate. Her deal brings Ella a place of importance, the attention of a magnetic man, and a loom she must feed her blood. But Ella may be in even more danger than she knows. There are plans unfolding, and Ella is in the middle of them.
This book has an interesting folktale quality. I enjoyed the idea of these mythic beings, these gods strangely close to mortals. The very celtic, folky vibe also added to the atmosphere, which was great throughout. It's easy to picture this place, these beings, the parties and the fog. Panin writes well, and uses this background masterfully to fill in the gaps and paint a complete picture.
However, the other side of this is that the worldbuilding then relies more on assumptions than on actual concrete details. I would have loved more expansion instead of this nebulous footing that the setting has, this mythos that itself feels only partially unsubmerged from that fog.
As for the story, while I don't think it necessary to keep a twist or reveal so far under lock and key it is unguessable, I was let down by how obvious the main twist was. It felt very clear by earlier than halfway through, and while I hoped for some further complication or intrigue to keep it impactful, I was unsatisfied. There is another smaller reveal that I did find interesting, but after the main plot point it didn't hit me quite the same way it might have.
I also feel as if Ella's arc could have been far more interesting. It's slow and mostly stagnate, she paces around a bit as if wearing a hole in the proverbial carpet, but gives herself nowhere to make a lasting impression past that starting line. When she does finally take real steps forward it happens all at once, and comes across inorganic and fails to feel like lasting character growth.
I wanted to like this more than I did, thanks to descriptive writing and and interesting concept, but much of it felt too thin.
TW: self harm, gaslighting & emotional abuse, mentions of domestic abuse, knife violence
3.3
When Ella's loom, her only source of what little income she has, is broken, she has no one to turn to but a legend. Everyone knows seeking out the Bean-Nighe and her wish is more dangerous than any boon can worth, but those people aren't desperate. Her deal brings Ella a place of importance, the attention of a magnetic man, and a loom she must feed her blood. But Ella may be in even more danger than she knows. There are plans unfolding, and Ella is in the middle of them.
This book has an interesting folktale quality. I enjoyed the idea of these mythic beings, these gods strangely close to mortals. The very celtic, folky vibe also added to the atmosphere, which was great throughout. It's easy to picture this place, these beings, the parties and the fog. Panin writes well, and uses this background masterfully to fill in the gaps and paint a complete picture.
However, the other side of this is that the worldbuilding then relies more on assumptions than on actual concrete details. I would have loved more expansion instead of this nebulous footing that the setting has, this mythos that itself feels only partially unsubmerged from that fog.
As for the story, while I don't think it necessary to keep a twist or reveal so far under lock and key it is unguessable, I was let down by how obvious the main twist was. It felt very clear by earlier than halfway through, and while I hoped for some further complication or intrigue to keep it impactful, I was unsatisfied. There is another smaller reveal that I did find interesting, but after the main plot point it didn't hit me quite the same way it might have.
I also feel as if Ella's arc could have been far more interesting. It's slow and mostly stagnate, she paces around a bit as if wearing a hole in the proverbial carpet, but gives herself nowhere to make a lasting impression past that starting line. When she does finally take real steps forward it happens all at once, and comes across inorganic and fails to feel like lasting character growth.
I wanted to like this more than I did, thanks to descriptive writing and and interesting concept, but much of it felt too thin.
November 5, 2022
This had such an interesting premise, but unfortunately, it fell a little flat for me. I thought this was a cool twist on a sort of fairy tale vibe based on Celtic mythology but I struggled with the characters - none of them were likable - and the plot grew slow and tedious in the middle, with tons of repetition. I also guessed the main twist fairly early, although there was another twist that I hadn't seen coming which was cool. I wish there was some more world building because I feel like I really don't know anything about this world, and better character development. Overall, not a bad read, but also not one that was super enjoyable either.
Thanks so much to netgalley and the publisher for providing me with an e-arc for review.
Thanks so much to netgalley and the publisher for providing me with an e-arc for review.
January 24, 2023
3.5 stars. I liked this one, but it didn’t necessarily…beguile me. I did love the villain , and I liked the unexpected arc with Odina, but I wasn’t super hooked to the story or anything.
August 22, 2022
"I wasn't trying to fill myself up with other people's praise anymore. I was full, solid, all on my own."
A dark story which tells that money and power can blind people to see what's in front of them.
The world building is fascinating although I wish there's more development about it.
This book has a really interesting premise which brings out one character from the Scottish folklore which is very interesting to know.
I'm not familiar with the original folklore and the one that the author include here is about Bean-Nighe.
It started off with a strong opening but the pace becomes a bit slow in the middle, but fortunately it picks up again near the ending with that small surprise from the background story of the Bean-Nighe.
It took quite a while for Ella's character to warm up to me. It's hard to connect with her because I am too frustrated with her choices throughout the story. Although, I began to like her more near the ending when she wakes up and start fighting back.
Overall, it's a pretty good read. I still enjoy some of the aspects in this book and I was satisfied with how things wrapped up in the end.
If you're interested in reading this dark fantasy YA Scottish folklore retelling, then you can give this one a try.
"I loved weaving, but the fabrics I made weren't my only measur of worth. I was more than a bolt of silk."
Special thanks to Cyla Panin and Netgalley for giving me this e-arc and also to TBR and Beyond Tour for allowing me to be a part of the book tour!
All thoughts are my own.
A dark story which tells that money and power can blind people to see what's in front of them.
The world building is fascinating although I wish there's more development about it.
This book has a really interesting premise which brings out one character from the Scottish folklore which is very interesting to know.
I'm not familiar with the original folklore and the one that the author include here is about Bean-Nighe.
It started off with a strong opening but the pace becomes a bit slow in the middle, but fortunately it picks up again near the ending with that small surprise from the background story of the Bean-Nighe.
It took quite a while for Ella's character to warm up to me. It's hard to connect with her because I am too frustrated with her choices throughout the story. Although, I began to like her more near the ending when she wakes up and start fighting back.
Overall, it's a pretty good read. I still enjoy some of the aspects in this book and I was satisfied with how things wrapped up in the end.
If you're interested in reading this dark fantasy YA Scottish folklore retelling, then you can give this one a try.
"I loved weaving, but the fabrics I made weren't my only measur of worth. I was more than a bolt of silk."
Special thanks to Cyla Panin and Netgalley for giving me this e-arc and also to TBR and Beyond Tour for allowing me to be a part of the book tour!
All thoughts are my own.
June 22, 2022
This is such an enchanting and immersive story with deep roots in Celtic folklore. It’s one that folklore enthusiasts will really enjoy.
Beguiled focuses on the myth of the Bean-nighe, a female spirit in Scottish folklore which is generally seen as an omen and messenger of death. She’s also known as the washerwoman or laundress. I adore Celtic folklore so this story really spoke to my soul. It’s lovely to see Scottish folklore getting more exposure in fantasy books.
The main protagonist Ella is a seamstress who is trying to get ahead in life. She makes a deal with the Bean-nighe and gives a drop of her blood, not realising she will need to pay the debt back. She’s forced to come to terms with the consequences of a decision made purely from desire and longing. The whole subject of ethics and morals is really examined here.
The prose is stunning and the world building is incredibly magical. Cyla knows how to tell a captivating story. It was difficult not to love Ella because you couldn’t help but want her to succeed and to cease struggling. She was quite determined though, so there’s also a sense of quiet strength about her.
Thank you so much to the publisher and Cyla for my free arc of this book in exchange for an honest review.
Beguiled focuses on the myth of the Bean-nighe, a female spirit in Scottish folklore which is generally seen as an omen and messenger of death. She’s also known as the washerwoman or laundress. I adore Celtic folklore so this story really spoke to my soul. It’s lovely to see Scottish folklore getting more exposure in fantasy books.
The main protagonist Ella is a seamstress who is trying to get ahead in life. She makes a deal with the Bean-nighe and gives a drop of her blood, not realising she will need to pay the debt back. She’s forced to come to terms with the consequences of a decision made purely from desire and longing. The whole subject of ethics and morals is really examined here.
The prose is stunning and the world building is incredibly magical. Cyla knows how to tell a captivating story. It was difficult not to love Ella because you couldn’t help but want her to succeed and to cease struggling. She was quite determined though, so there’s also a sense of quiet strength about her.
Thank you so much to the publisher and Cyla for my free arc of this book in exchange for an honest review.
December 28, 2023
Sadly disappointed by this one!
I hate leaving negative reviews, but I don't really know what to say about this book. I enjoyed maybe the second quarter of it, when the pace seemed to pick up... but the magic system, the whole beguilement, and the Players and the Chieftain and the gods and fae and all that were all very muddled together. There were quite a few scenes of dancing around in their magic silks, somehow 'beguiling' a character, but I didn't understand what was going on? And this happened several times. The characters' motivations, personalities, and the magic system all seemed at odds with one another. I completely get that weaving is a very long, complicated process, but the pages and pages of repetition of the many steps throughout the book was overwhelming to the story and characters. I usually like an unlikable mc, but had a really hard time finding anything to empathize with here. The big reveal was pretty obvious, and thus disappointing, and the big climax seemed 'big for big's sake,' if that makes sense.
I'd enjoyed Stalking Shadows, so I really did have hopes for this one.
Thank you Netgalley and Amulet for this arc!
I hate leaving negative reviews, but I don't really know what to say about this book. I enjoyed maybe the second quarter of it, when the pace seemed to pick up... but the magic system, the whole beguilement, and the Players and the Chieftain and the gods and fae and all that were all very muddled together. There were quite a few scenes of dancing around in their magic silks, somehow 'beguiling' a character, but I didn't understand what was going on? And this happened several times. The characters' motivations, personalities, and the magic system all seemed at odds with one another. I completely get that weaving is a very long, complicated process, but the pages and pages of repetition of the many steps throughout the book was overwhelming to the story and characters. I usually like an unlikable mc, but had a really hard time finding anything to empathize with here. The big reveal was pretty obvious, and thus disappointing, and the big climax seemed 'big for big's sake,' if that makes sense.
I'd enjoyed Stalking Shadows, so I really did have hopes for this one.
Thank you Netgalley and Amulet for this arc!
September 14, 2022
What a great life lesson this book has. I needed it. I loved every fiber of this book and look forward to what this author will bring next.
June 14, 2022
Just like Ella could never abandoned one of her bolt creations because she needed to know what it would look like in the end, I was compelled to turn each enchanting page of Beguiled by Cyla Panin. This book is heavy on the heart and beautifully told by one of my new favorite authors in YA Fantasy fiction!
Cyla Panin’s storytelling is captivating and after reading Beguiled, her books will forever be added to my auto-buy author list! There’s something so simple and, well...beguiling...about the way she sets up a story that it’s impossible to not turn the page and find out what happens next…almost like when you think a story couldn’t get any better, it pulls the seat right out from under you.
Ella is a 17-year-old weaver whose entire livelihood depends on her loom. She is filled with hopes and dreams of opening her own shop, but finds herself struggling, unable to dig herself out of the debt she throws herself in to secure her future. She, like everyone, has heard about the old washerwoman spirit called the Bean-Nighe who will grant any one wish—for a price.
Ella is desperate, so she asks the Bean-Nighe to fix her loom. And it works. The loom is fixed, and she's creating beautiful pieces she could have never imagined before. All she has to do is feed the loom a drop of blood each time she weaves—a small price to pay for such magnificent silks. Her bolts of silk mesmerize a young, wealthy, and mysterious gentleman named Callum and finds herself in his elite social circle. It seems like Ella's fortune is finally turning for the better . . . until she begins to notice the loom taking more from her than she offered.
Beguiled is heavily character driven and readers will enjoy spending time with Ella. It’s hard not to love her and sympathize with her because she is so relatable. I’ve seen some of my own struggles reflected back at me while reading: of all the mistakes I’ve made, the hardships and moments of “it couldn’t possibly get any worse,” and the endurance to fight for what you want and what you deserve--to truly understand our worthiness for a happy life and what exactly will make us happy.
I loved the feeling I got when Ella started weaving a new bolt of fabric: ethereal. Like each bolt told it’s own story and as a writer, it transported me into imagining the type of person who could wear such a piece of fabric. The description of Ella’s weaving process is enchanting. It really inspired me and made me think about how much I love writing and creating stories that paint a picture in a reader’s imagination!
Wonderful Things to Expect While Reading:
💕 Lavish descriptions of the world and setting
💕 A strong and determined female heroine
💕 An unexpected love
💕 Ballrooms, dancing, and beautiful dresses
💕 Steam level: 🌶 (Fade to Black)
💕 Gods & Fae
💕 A deliciously deceptive villain
💕 Fairytale Reimagined
💕 Cautionary Tale
Thank you to NetGalley and Amulet Books for granting me a DRC of Beguiled in exchange for an honest review!
My Favorite Quotes While Reading:
"I want to wrap my influence around this city like a scarlet ribbon and squeeze."
"That was part of the thrill--picturing something beautiful in my mind and challenging my hands to make it. sometimes it worked, sometimes it didn't quite. But trying was the good part."
"Did the sun mind sharing the sky with the moon? Did they ever spar over who could shine brighter? Or maybe both the sun and the moon worried about the stars outdazzling them. The ones on this bolt of cloth certainly would."
"It's you. Be yourself. You've swirled up my thoughts, Ella. And even when they stop spinning, they come back to you. Always you and the beautiful things you make."
"I wanted to capture his words as if they were flowers, to dry and keep in an old box and look at whenever I was sad."
"People get addicted to owning and tasting beautiful things."
"I was more than a bolt of silk."
Cyla Panin’s storytelling is captivating and after reading Beguiled, her books will forever be added to my auto-buy author list! There’s something so simple and, well...beguiling...about the way she sets up a story that it’s impossible to not turn the page and find out what happens next…almost like when you think a story couldn’t get any better, it pulls the seat right out from under you.
Ella is a 17-year-old weaver whose entire livelihood depends on her loom. She is filled with hopes and dreams of opening her own shop, but finds herself struggling, unable to dig herself out of the debt she throws herself in to secure her future. She, like everyone, has heard about the old washerwoman spirit called the Bean-Nighe who will grant any one wish—for a price.
Ella is desperate, so she asks the Bean-Nighe to fix her loom. And it works. The loom is fixed, and she's creating beautiful pieces she could have never imagined before. All she has to do is feed the loom a drop of blood each time she weaves—a small price to pay for such magnificent silks. Her bolts of silk mesmerize a young, wealthy, and mysterious gentleman named Callum and finds herself in his elite social circle. It seems like Ella's fortune is finally turning for the better . . . until she begins to notice the loom taking more from her than she offered.
Beguiled is heavily character driven and readers will enjoy spending time with Ella. It’s hard not to love her and sympathize with her because she is so relatable. I’ve seen some of my own struggles reflected back at me while reading: of all the mistakes I’ve made, the hardships and moments of “it couldn’t possibly get any worse,” and the endurance to fight for what you want and what you deserve--to truly understand our worthiness for a happy life and what exactly will make us happy.
I loved the feeling I got when Ella started weaving a new bolt of fabric: ethereal. Like each bolt told it’s own story and as a writer, it transported me into imagining the type of person who could wear such a piece of fabric. The description of Ella’s weaving process is enchanting. It really inspired me and made me think about how much I love writing and creating stories that paint a picture in a reader’s imagination!
Wonderful Things to Expect While Reading:
💕 Lavish descriptions of the world and setting
💕 A strong and determined female heroine
💕 An unexpected love
💕 Ballrooms, dancing, and beautiful dresses
💕 Steam level: 🌶 (Fade to Black)
💕 Gods & Fae
💕 A deliciously deceptive villain
💕 Fairytale Reimagined
💕 Cautionary Tale
Thank you to NetGalley and Amulet Books for granting me a DRC of Beguiled in exchange for an honest review!
My Favorite Quotes While Reading:
"I want to wrap my influence around this city like a scarlet ribbon and squeeze."
"That was part of the thrill--picturing something beautiful in my mind and challenging my hands to make it. sometimes it worked, sometimes it didn't quite. But trying was the good part."
"Did the sun mind sharing the sky with the moon? Did they ever spar over who could shine brighter? Or maybe both the sun and the moon worried about the stars outdazzling them. The ones on this bolt of cloth certainly would."
"It's you. Be yourself. You've swirled up my thoughts, Ella. And even when they stop spinning, they come back to you. Always you and the beautiful things you make."
"I wanted to capture his words as if they were flowers, to dry and keep in an old box and look at whenever I was sad."
"People get addicted to owning and tasting beautiful things."
"I was more than a bolt of silk."
August 24, 2022
**Many thanks to Amulet Books and Netgalley for an Advanced Reader's Copy (ARC) of this book**
Beguiled is a beguiling book. I loved the premise of the story: what would you give to have everything? What would it take to live the life you want? And though there were many things I liked, there were a few others I wish I had more of, that would have made my experience a bit more enjoyable.
The Best Weaved Story...
1. I liked Ella's ambition. She's a girl who wants to make her own way in the world, get out of debt, and feels like she deserves more for her life. I like that, and I identify with that. She was a very likeable character in that regard.
2. It was nice to see a story based on Celtic mythology. I don't feel there is enough of that going around. It also had a Rumplestiltskin-type feel to it as well, and you can never have enough of those.
3. This book is macabre, and a bit gothic, but not gruesome. It's a lot lighter than some books I've read, which was a nice change of pace. If I were to put this on a scale of 1 (a drop of darkness) to 10 (total blackout), it would probably be around a 4 (the sun is barely setting).
...Somewhat Goes Afray
1. Although I liked Ella, I also found her to be incredibly naive and trusting of things she should have questioned immediately. Especially since she trusted a very bad character... And did not see the same qualities in another. And, they were both right in front of her. There were so many indications that she blindly disallows, and that became frustrating to me.
2. The plot of the book was very predictable. I was able to figure out the majority of what was going on by the end of the first quarter, which left no surprises by the end of it. I know part of this is because I have read many, many dark fairy tale type books lately that DID surprise me, and I was expecting this one to play out like those did. Even the one interesting, mini twist at the end was not enough to really change my opinion. Beguiled is interesting, but not a standout.
3. Speaking of the end, by the end, it felt like there was a lot of buildup to certain appearances and happenings that did not pan out. The mini twist in the end, while interesting, also seemed to be out of "left field". I would have liked more hints towards or away from that, to keep me guessing. It also felt almost like this book was the first part of an incomplete duology or trilogy, where more details could be expanded upon in the near future. I am not sure if the author was planning on continuing the tale, but if so, I'd read it.
4. The villain was...ok. Not the most inventive character. Their motives were pretty shallow. I would have liked someone a bit better developed, that made you feel something more for them than "ok, this is the villain, and they do sneaky, bad things". They were not believable to me.
Verdict
This is a good "starter" dark fairytale: if there is someone out there that wants something gothic, not scary, and enjoyable to read, I would definitely recommend this book.
Beguiled is a beguiling book. I loved the premise of the story: what would you give to have everything? What would it take to live the life you want? And though there were many things I liked, there were a few others I wish I had more of, that would have made my experience a bit more enjoyable.
The Best Weaved Story...
1. I liked Ella's ambition. She's a girl who wants to make her own way in the world, get out of debt, and feels like she deserves more for her life. I like that, and I identify with that. She was a very likeable character in that regard.
2. It was nice to see a story based on Celtic mythology. I don't feel there is enough of that going around. It also had a Rumplestiltskin-type feel to it as well, and you can never have enough of those.
3. This book is macabre, and a bit gothic, but not gruesome. It's a lot lighter than some books I've read, which was a nice change of pace. If I were to put this on a scale of 1 (a drop of darkness) to 10 (total blackout), it would probably be around a 4 (the sun is barely setting).
...Somewhat Goes Afray
1. Although I liked Ella, I also found her to be incredibly naive and trusting of things she should have questioned immediately. Especially since she trusted a very bad character... And did not see the same qualities in another. And, they were both right in front of her. There were so many indications that she blindly disallows, and that became frustrating to me.
2. The plot of the book was very predictable. I was able to figure out the majority of what was going on by the end of the first quarter, which left no surprises by the end of it. I know part of this is because I have read many, many dark fairy tale type books lately that DID surprise me, and I was expecting this one to play out like those did. Even the one interesting, mini twist at the end was not enough to really change my opinion. Beguiled is interesting, but not a standout.
3. Speaking of the end, by the end, it felt like there was a lot of buildup to certain appearances and happenings that did not pan out. The mini twist in the end, while interesting, also seemed to be out of "left field". I would have liked more hints towards or away from that, to keep me guessing. It also felt almost like this book was the first part of an incomplete duology or trilogy, where more details could be expanded upon in the near future. I am not sure if the author was planning on continuing the tale, but if so, I'd read it.
4. The villain was...ok. Not the most inventive character. Their motives were pretty shallow. I would have liked someone a bit better developed, that made you feel something more for them than "ok, this is the villain, and they do sneaky, bad things". They were not believable to me.
Verdict
This is a good "starter" dark fairytale: if there is someone out there that wants something gothic, not scary, and enjoyable to read, I would definitely recommend this book.
September 19, 2022
BEGUILED is the second book I’ve read and loved by Cyla Palin. The first was her debut STALKING SHADOWS. Cyla’s writing is like being wrapped up into a warm blanket with your favourite cup of tea. It’s enchanting and magical. Her main characters are head strong women, who know their own mind and stop at nothing to achieve what they truly desire.
Beguiled is the enchanting story of Ella. She’s a weaver whose dreams are bigger than life: she wants to open her own shop. There’s just one problem, her loom breaks. And if the loom is broken, she can’t pay her debts. Panicking, and alone, Ella takes a chance and wanders down to the waters edge.
You can hear the whispers of her name on the wind. She’s the old washerwoman who sits on the bank of the river, forever scrubbing the blood from a shirt onto a stone. She’ll grant you a wish, but you must be prepared to pay the price. Would you give up your dreams, or youth? Maybe it’ll be your blood.
Ella’s heard the cautionary tales of the Bean-Nighe…. but desperation makes her wade through the freezing water….until she’s face to face with the washer woman.
I was enthralled from the very beginning. Ella is a character that you can’t help but love. Celtic folklore is sprinkled throughout this story and I was absolutely mesmerized by it. Tie that in with the Dorian Gray vibes radiating off of Callum, and the Gatsby-esque parties; be still my heart.
So I must ask you: what would you visit the Bean-Nighe for?
Beguiled is the enchanting story of Ella. She’s a weaver whose dreams are bigger than life: she wants to open her own shop. There’s just one problem, her loom breaks. And if the loom is broken, she can’t pay her debts. Panicking, and alone, Ella takes a chance and wanders down to the waters edge.
You can hear the whispers of her name on the wind. She’s the old washerwoman who sits on the bank of the river, forever scrubbing the blood from a shirt onto a stone. She’ll grant you a wish, but you must be prepared to pay the price. Would you give up your dreams, or youth? Maybe it’ll be your blood.
Ella’s heard the cautionary tales of the Bean-Nighe…. but desperation makes her wade through the freezing water….until she’s face to face with the washer woman.
I was enthralled from the very beginning. Ella is a character that you can’t help but love. Celtic folklore is sprinkled throughout this story and I was absolutely mesmerized by it. Tie that in with the Dorian Gray vibes radiating off of Callum, and the Gatsby-esque parties; be still my heart.
So I must ask you: what would you visit the Bean-Nighe for?
January 26, 2023
Trigger Warnings: blood, gore, manipulation, psychological & physical abuse and violence, gaslighting
Pros:
- Ode to weavers and craftsmen
- Interesting concept of magic and talent
- Interesting world-building
Cons:
- Pace was slow and tough to read at times
- MC discovers what is happening but doesn't immediately do anything*
- Ending left too many more questions for the other characters involved
*Ella discovers that the price of success can be overrated as Ella finds out. She seems to know "the real price" early on in the book but refuses to take charge of things until the end.
Bottomline:
It is an interesting book with an intriguing premise that could have been more if it had discussed the origins of the folklore more, and seeing less disempowerment of Ella seemed to take up so much in the book versus moving with the story's plot.
And although it comes out with a HEA of the sort, the book left me unsatisfied.
Pros:
- Ode to weavers and craftsmen
- Interesting concept of magic and talent
- Interesting world-building
Cons:
- Pace was slow and tough to read at times
- MC discovers what is happening but doesn't immediately do anything*
- Ending left too many more questions for the other characters involved
*Ella discovers that the price of success can be overrated as Ella finds out. She seems to know "the real price" early on in the book but refuses to take charge of things until the end.
Bottomline:
It is an interesting book with an intriguing premise that could have been more if it had discussed the origins of the folklore more, and seeing less disempowerment of Ella seemed to take up so much in the book versus moving with the story's plot.
And although it comes out with a HEA of the sort, the book left me unsatisfied.
August 22, 2022
*I received an e-arc from the author and Netgalley in exchange for an honest review*
Beguiled is a luscious YA Fantasy story that is the perfect autumn read! It is steeped in Celtic folklore, full of mystery and has a spooky gothic atmosphere. I really thought that having the main character be a textile artist was very unique and creative as well.
Ella is a seventeen-year-old weaver whose very livelihood depends on her loom. Her father passed away in debtor’s prison and she has had to take whatever jobs she can to support herself. She has always dreamed of opening her own shop, but that dream is so farfetched as she barely has enough to get by. In order to buy supplies, she winds up owing a large debt to a cruel man in the marketplace. When her loom breaks, she realizes that she needs more than a repair to ever do more than just survive. She entertains the idea of visiting the Bean-Nighe (an old washerwoman spirit by the river)who may grant her a wish, for a price.
Ella becomes so desperate for help, she goes to the Bean-Nighe and asks her to fix her loom. It works, her loom is fixed, and she begins to weave gorgeous pieces that she never could have imagined before. She has to feed the loom a drop of her blood every time she weaves, and she thinks this is a small price to pay for weaving such magnificent silks. She immediately brings a couple of bolts of the beautiful fabric to one of her rich clients, and meets an enigmatic young man named Callum and bargains for an invitation to one of his exclusive parties. At the party, he is so mesmerized by her work, he offers her a place to live at his home and patronage for her art. Ella feels like her fortunes have at last changed for the better, until she begins to notice that the loom is taking more from her than she bargained for.
While Ella is whisked away by Callum’s charm and caught up in the web of the Bean-Nighe’s magic, she must find a way to secure her future endeavors while she still has a future left.
I enjoyed Ella as the main character. I had so much empathy for her, and the situation that she found herself in, but I don’t think I would have made the deal that she did. She lived in a society that basically disregarded her, and I found her relatable in the way she struggled with feelings of self-worth. The story becomes darker as it goes along, and it was interesting to see the twists and turns that Ella has to face. I do wish there was a little more to the ending of the book, but overall I was satisfied.
A great sophomore novel for Panin! I hope that you pick this one up ASAP, as it releases Tuesday, August 23, 2022.
Beguiled is a luscious YA Fantasy story that is the perfect autumn read! It is steeped in Celtic folklore, full of mystery and has a spooky gothic atmosphere. I really thought that having the main character be a textile artist was very unique and creative as well.
Ella is a seventeen-year-old weaver whose very livelihood depends on her loom. Her father passed away in debtor’s prison and she has had to take whatever jobs she can to support herself. She has always dreamed of opening her own shop, but that dream is so farfetched as she barely has enough to get by. In order to buy supplies, she winds up owing a large debt to a cruel man in the marketplace. When her loom breaks, she realizes that she needs more than a repair to ever do more than just survive. She entertains the idea of visiting the Bean-Nighe (an old washerwoman spirit by the river)who may grant her a wish, for a price.
Ella becomes so desperate for help, she goes to the Bean-Nighe and asks her to fix her loom. It works, her loom is fixed, and she begins to weave gorgeous pieces that she never could have imagined before. She has to feed the loom a drop of her blood every time she weaves, and she thinks this is a small price to pay for weaving such magnificent silks. She immediately brings a couple of bolts of the beautiful fabric to one of her rich clients, and meets an enigmatic young man named Callum and bargains for an invitation to one of his exclusive parties. At the party, he is so mesmerized by her work, he offers her a place to live at his home and patronage for her art. Ella feels like her fortunes have at last changed for the better, until she begins to notice that the loom is taking more from her than she bargained for.
While Ella is whisked away by Callum’s charm and caught up in the web of the Bean-Nighe’s magic, she must find a way to secure her future endeavors while she still has a future left.
I enjoyed Ella as the main character. I had so much empathy for her, and the situation that she found herself in, but I don’t think I would have made the deal that she did. She lived in a society that basically disregarded her, and I found her relatable in the way she struggled with feelings of self-worth. The story becomes darker as it goes along, and it was interesting to see the twists and turns that Ella has to face. I do wish there was a little more to the ending of the book, but overall I was satisfied.
A great sophomore novel for Panin! I hope that you pick this one up ASAP, as it releases Tuesday, August 23, 2022.
August 28, 2022
Be careful what you wish for is a saying as old as time. It’s about being content with what we have and not being tricked out of that.
Ella is desperate. A money lender wants her to pay back with more than just cash. She’s barely getting by and her one client chooses to pay her later. She goes to the washerwoman spirit called the Bean-Nighe. The Bean-Night grants every wish but at a price, and Ella has no idea what she’s really paid with.
As a whole Cyla Panin is a good writer. The plot is interesting; Ella is not just desperate for money, but she also desperately needs love and affection; to the point where she will close her eyes and blind herself to facts around her. How did she meet Callum that day? Why does no one comment on her changing appearance?
I was frustrated with Ella at the start, I couldn’t understand why she would bargain for so little, but I realised that was Cyla Panin’s very clever way of showing us how so many people, despite their talent and hard work, live in poverty even then; they truly have no idea of the worth of their work; and which of us would ever pay them fairly?
While I thought Beguiled was an interesting read, I feel like the ending was too chaotic for my personal taste. That being said, it’s a 4 star read and there are certain things that I really liked, but can’t say because that’ll spoil everything! If you read Rosamand Hodge and her books Cruel Beauty and Gilded Ashes, I feel like you’ll love this too.
Ella is desperate. A money lender wants her to pay back with more than just cash. She’s barely getting by and her one client chooses to pay her later. She goes to the washerwoman spirit called the Bean-Nighe. The Bean-Night grants every wish but at a price, and Ella has no idea what she’s really paid with.
As a whole Cyla Panin is a good writer. The plot is interesting; Ella is not just desperate for money, but she also desperately needs love and affection; to the point where she will close her eyes and blind herself to facts around her. How did she meet Callum that day? Why does no one comment on her changing appearance?
I was frustrated with Ella at the start, I couldn’t understand why she would bargain for so little, but I realised that was Cyla Panin’s very clever way of showing us how so many people, despite their talent and hard work, live in poverty even then; they truly have no idea of the worth of their work; and which of us would ever pay them fairly?
While I thought Beguiled was an interesting read, I feel like the ending was too chaotic for my personal taste. That being said, it’s a 4 star read and there are certain things that I really liked, but can’t say because that’ll spoil everything! If you read Rosamand Hodge and her books Cruel Beauty and Gilded Ashes, I feel like you’ll love this too.
Want to read
August 23, 2022Ella is a seventeen-year-old weaver and creates beautiful art pieces of clothing. Unfortunately, one day her loom breaks and the young woman is desperate. She has no money left and has a debt to repay, which is why she seeks out the Bean-Nighe to get her wish granted. But this wish will cost her dearly, and soon she finds herself in a lot more trouble than she could have ever imagined.
Firstly, let me squeal in peace. I loved Panin’s writing style. The author managed to make me want to read this book in one sitting, and if real life weren’t so stressful right now, I would have done it. The writing style was magical, the rhythm fast-paced, and we even get twists from time to time. I would even go as far as to say that you definitely get something for your money. This book is worth being read but before of the trigger warnings (mentioned under the synopsis) because this might not be something for everyone out there.
“Beguiled” has its spotlight on its MC, Ella. Therefore, the reader spends a lot of time getting to know the young girl, and I understood her actions a lot more than I probably would have if the author had decided a different approach.
This book is a great read for the upcoming season and if you like to be compelled by a great new YA Novel then “Beguiled” just has to be on your next TBR or “Current Reading” list.
Firstly, let me squeal in peace. I loved Panin’s writing style. The author managed to make me want to read this book in one sitting, and if real life weren’t so stressful right now, I would have done it. The writing style was magical, the rhythm fast-paced, and we even get twists from time to time. I would even go as far as to say that you definitely get something for your money. This book is worth being read but before of the trigger warnings (mentioned under the synopsis) because this might not be something for everyone out there.
“Beguiled” has its spotlight on its MC, Ella. Therefore, the reader spends a lot of time getting to know the young girl, and I understood her actions a lot more than I probably would have if the author had decided a different approach.
This book is a great read for the upcoming season and if you like to be compelled by a great new YA Novel then “Beguiled” just has to be on your next TBR or “Current Reading” list.
Want to read
August 20, 2022"Ella is desperate, so she asks the Bean-Nighe to fix her loom. And it works. The loom is fixed, and she's creating beautiful pieces she could have never imagined before. All she has to do is feed the loom a drop of blood each time she weaves—a small price to pay for such magnificent silks... As she becomes entangled in the lives of the city’s rich, swept into Callum's allure, and trapped by the Bean-Nighe’s magic, Ella must figure out a way to secure her future while she still has a future at all."
Shelved as 'tbr-unreleased'
April 27, 2022Thank you ABRAMS Kids and Amulet Books for the ARC.
Blog | Twitter | Instagram | BlogLovin’
Blog | Twitter | Instagram | BlogLovin’
August 12, 2023
OH. MY. GOD.
If I could give this a 10/5, I would. I could've tried to finish reading this in one sitting, but had to space it over 4 days for two reasons: I had to process some parts of the book, and ... also I'm just a very busy person.
If you wanna literally read a book where men fit the description of being trash, this is the perfect book to read.
If I could give this a 10/5, I would. I could've tried to finish reading this in one sitting, but had to space it over 4 days for two reasons: I had to process some parts of the book, and ... also I'm just a very busy person.
If you wanna literally read a book where men fit the description of being trash, this is the perfect book to read.
June 20, 2022
Wishes and curses and gods. Oh my!
Callum was infuriatingly mysterious, and I mean that in the best way. So twisty and evasive!
My reason for taking away a star is that the set-up felt waaaaay too long. The MC, Ella, spends many a chapter giving us a sense of her life and history, before finally getting down to the magic. I'm impatient.
Callum was infuriatingly mysterious, and I mean that in the best way. So twisty and evasive!
My reason for taking away a star is that the set-up felt waaaaay too long. The MC, Ella, spends many a chapter giving us a sense of her life and history, before finally getting down to the magic. I'm impatient.
September 2, 2022
Disclaimer: I received this e-arc and finished copy from the publisher. Thanks! All opinions are my own.
Book: Beguiled
Author: Cyla Panin
Book Series: Standalone
Rating: 3.5/5
Recommended For...: young adult readers, fantasy, retelling, Cinderella, Sleeping Beauty, Celtic mythology, Historical fiction, horror, fairy tale
Publication Date: August 23, 2022
Genre: YA Fantasy Retelling
Age Relevance: 14+ (gore, death, religion, self harm, gaslighting, emotional abuse, domestic violence, violence)
Explanation of Above: There is a lot of gore involving blood and self harm in the manner of the MC purposefully hurting herself so she can supply the loom. There are some domestic violence mentions and knife violence. Death is shown and mentioned. There are some mentions of religion. There is some gaslighting and emotional abuse shown in the book too.
Publisher: Amulet Books
Pages: 384
Synopsis: Ella is a 17-year-old weaver whose entire livelihood depends on her loom. She dreams of opening her own shop, but when her father died in debtor’s prison, she had to support herself by taking whatever clients she could get. In order to buy her supplies she goes into debt of her own, and when her loom breaks, Ella realizes she needs more help than a repairperson can give her. She, like everyone, has heard about the old washerwoman spirit called the Bean-Nighe who will grant any one wish—for a price.
But Ella is desperate, so she asks the Bean-Nighe to fix her loom. And it works. The loom is fixed, and she's creating beautiful pieces she could have never imagined before. All she has to do is feed the loom a drop of blood each time she weaves—a small price to pay for such magnificent silks. And when she brings two bolts to a rich client, she meets a mysterious young man named Callum and bargains for an invitation to his exclusive party. At that party, he's so mesmerized by her talent, he offers Ella a place to live and patronage for her art. It seems like Ella's fortune is finally turning for the better . . . until she begins to notice the loom taking more from her than she offered.
As she becomes entangled in the lives of the city’s rich, swept into Callum's allure, and trapped by the Bean-Nighe’s magic, Ella must figure out a way to secure her future while she still has a future at all.
Review: Overall, I really liked this book! I thought it was a little bit Cinderella and a little bit Sleeping beauty, which is a cool combination. There book is easy to read and reads like a classic fairytale, maybe something a bit Grimms Brothers? The book is based in Celtic mythology and it’s beautifully written and flows well.
However, I thought that the book needed a little bit of work still. I would like to see more world building and a lot more character development. I also thought that the book was a bit too slow for how it was written.
Verdict: It’s good!
Book: Beguiled
Author: Cyla Panin
Book Series: Standalone
Rating: 3.5/5
Recommended For...: young adult readers, fantasy, retelling, Cinderella, Sleeping Beauty, Celtic mythology, Historical fiction, horror, fairy tale
Publication Date: August 23, 2022
Genre: YA Fantasy Retelling
Age Relevance: 14+ (gore, death, religion, self harm, gaslighting, emotional abuse, domestic violence, violence)
Explanation of Above: There is a lot of gore involving blood and self harm in the manner of the MC purposefully hurting herself so she can supply the loom. There are some domestic violence mentions and knife violence. Death is shown and mentioned. There are some mentions of religion. There is some gaslighting and emotional abuse shown in the book too.
Publisher: Amulet Books
Pages: 384
Synopsis: Ella is a 17-year-old weaver whose entire livelihood depends on her loom. She dreams of opening her own shop, but when her father died in debtor’s prison, she had to support herself by taking whatever clients she could get. In order to buy her supplies she goes into debt of her own, and when her loom breaks, Ella realizes she needs more help than a repairperson can give her. She, like everyone, has heard about the old washerwoman spirit called the Bean-Nighe who will grant any one wish—for a price.
But Ella is desperate, so she asks the Bean-Nighe to fix her loom. And it works. The loom is fixed, and she's creating beautiful pieces she could have never imagined before. All she has to do is feed the loom a drop of blood each time she weaves—a small price to pay for such magnificent silks. And when she brings two bolts to a rich client, she meets a mysterious young man named Callum and bargains for an invitation to his exclusive party. At that party, he's so mesmerized by her talent, he offers Ella a place to live and patronage for her art. It seems like Ella's fortune is finally turning for the better . . . until she begins to notice the loom taking more from her than she offered.
As she becomes entangled in the lives of the city’s rich, swept into Callum's allure, and trapped by the Bean-Nighe’s magic, Ella must figure out a way to secure her future while she still has a future at all.
Review: Overall, I really liked this book! I thought it was a little bit Cinderella and a little bit Sleeping beauty, which is a cool combination. There book is easy to read and reads like a classic fairytale, maybe something a bit Grimms Brothers? The book is based in Celtic mythology and it’s beautifully written and flows well.
However, I thought that the book needed a little bit of work still. I would like to see more world building and a lot more character development. I also thought that the book was a bit too slow for how it was written.
Verdict: It’s good!
November 19, 2022
This novel winds itself around you slowly but insidiously. It’s a fantasy tale but also one for the YA set for older readers can recognize the trap being set by one of its compelling leads.
However, the story isn’t as straightforward as it might seem. The players or Players are confusing; we’re not certain who are the pawns or conspirators. The main antagonist is one of the enthralling sort, the kind that Jane Austen wrote about in her novels. Hiding being smiles, good looks, enticing words and promises, our heroine is drawn in both by her own longings and her blindness to the trap behind snare.
Where the story really sparks interest is in the introduction and explanation of the Bean Nighe (pronounced ben nee-ah), a spirit out of Scottish folklore. I read about them months ago and wondered what could be the story behind such a creature. Doomed forever to wash the blood out of clothes that never come clean—what could condemn a being to such a fate? What could she have done to earn it?
Some creatures are forced to kill human beings—not for sustenance, or out of malice or for food but because murdering a certain number of humans will gain them a prize. Perhaps it’s immortality or escape from their grim fate. A woman who drowns a certain number of men in her pond, e.g., may win her way out of her watery prison after she’s drowned a specific number. She may not wish to kill the men but it’s made clear to her that their murders are the only way to win her freedom.
Such eldritch bargains are notorious in folklore, myth and legend. In the famous “Beauty and the Beast” tale, the transformed creature can regain his humanity only after a girl he’s willfully imprisoned loves him and he loves her as well.
So what’s the deal behind an old woman fated to stay by a river washing a bloody rag? The author’s answer is as ingenious as it is insightful. In fact, Ms. Fanin has given us a tale grounded in the misery of those who toil and the enviable richness of those who seem to be above it all, the wealthy who swan about in delicate clothes, eat sumptuous foods and live in grand palaces. We are put in the place of poor Ella, whose lovely silks draw in an avaricious god, and like her we are led down the garden path.
Our eyes are opened long before hers are and we find ourselves wanting to shout at her to get out before it’s too late. But Ella proves to have a backbone of iron underneath her soft exterior. She’s the best kind of heroine; even her seeming flaws turn out to be a kind of strength.
The story is excellent, compelling, sorrowful and ultimately filled with triumph. Weaving, after all, is done by spiders as well as silkworms but only one is laid out to trap flies.
However, the story isn’t as straightforward as it might seem. The players or Players are confusing; we’re not certain who are the pawns or conspirators. The main antagonist is one of the enthralling sort, the kind that Jane Austen wrote about in her novels. Hiding being smiles, good looks, enticing words and promises, our heroine is drawn in both by her own longings and her blindness to the trap behind snare.
Where the story really sparks interest is in the introduction and explanation of the Bean Nighe (pronounced ben nee-ah), a spirit out of Scottish folklore. I read about them months ago and wondered what could be the story behind such a creature. Doomed forever to wash the blood out of clothes that never come clean—what could condemn a being to such a fate? What could she have done to earn it?
Some creatures are forced to kill human beings—not for sustenance, or out of malice or for food but because murdering a certain number of humans will gain them a prize. Perhaps it’s immortality or escape from their grim fate. A woman who drowns a certain number of men in her pond, e.g., may win her way out of her watery prison after she’s drowned a specific number. She may not wish to kill the men but it’s made clear to her that their murders are the only way to win her freedom.
Such eldritch bargains are notorious in folklore, myth and legend. In the famous “Beauty and the Beast” tale, the transformed creature can regain his humanity only after a girl he’s willfully imprisoned loves him and he loves her as well.
So what’s the deal behind an old woman fated to stay by a river washing a bloody rag? The author’s answer is as ingenious as it is insightful. In fact, Ms. Fanin has given us a tale grounded in the misery of those who toil and the enviable richness of those who seem to be above it all, the wealthy who swan about in delicate clothes, eat sumptuous foods and live in grand palaces. We are put in the place of poor Ella, whose lovely silks draw in an avaricious god, and like her we are led down the garden path.
Our eyes are opened long before hers are and we find ourselves wanting to shout at her to get out before it’s too late. But Ella proves to have a backbone of iron underneath her soft exterior. She’s the best kind of heroine; even her seeming flaws turn out to be a kind of strength.
The story is excellent, compelling, sorrowful and ultimately filled with triumph. Weaving, after all, is done by spiders as well as silkworms but only one is laid out to trap flies.
March 11, 2024
I wanted to love this book, I really did.
I went into it very excited, thinking I had found a hidden gem. The author's note at the start of the book, dedicating this tale to all the unappreciated tradespersons of the 17th century, only spurred me on. And at first, I was pulled in. Ella was immediately sympathetic, and I was excited to see where her deal with the Bean-Nighe would take her. But as I'm sure is clear by now, the rest of the story didn't pan out so well.
I think everything started going downhill the moment Callum was introduced. He was so... barely there. For a character that went on to be a major character and love interest for the rest of the book, I couldn't really get a feel for him. In fact, I couldn't really get a feel for most of the characters. They all seemed poorly thought out and shallow. I couldn't bring myself to feel attached to them. I mean, I could barely keep them straight, what with the jumping characterizations. For example, Ella was supposed to be a meek lower class girl used to bending her head when dealing with the upper class, but for some reason, always sounded strangely confident when talking to and literally making demands of Callum and Odina. Also, at some point, we were just expected to know that Odina was a member of the Players and Callum was the leader? I feel like at some point, some character was just expected to show deference to him as the leader of the Players, even though I don't recall it being explicitly mentioned, or even reasonably implied before that point.
If it had been mentioned, I must've missed it while undertaking the heavy task of trudging through the this book. At 50% through, I was seriously considering DNF-ing. Nothing was really endearing me to the book. The cast of characters was weirdly small, and again, none of the characters were really likable. There was a whole love story and I felt nothing. Absolutely nothing. In fact, I couldn't comprehend how a romance was even happening.
I kept reading only to see what the result of Ella's deal would be, and getting to the end, I suppose it makes sense that certain characters weren't likable. But honestly, its not even that I disliked the characters -- I was pretty much completely apathetic. As such, none of the betrayals or reveals affected me much at all. Even the stupid magic system, didn't rile me as much as another story's would have. I just kept reading until the book was over.
I really wish I'd liked this book, I really do. But I don't think I can give it any more than 2.5 stars.
I went into it very excited, thinking I had found a hidden gem. The author's note at the start of the book, dedicating this tale to all the unappreciated tradespersons of the 17th century, only spurred me on. And at first, I was pulled in. Ella was immediately sympathetic, and I was excited to see where her deal with the Bean-Nighe would take her. But as I'm sure is clear by now, the rest of the story didn't pan out so well.
I think everything started going downhill the moment Callum was introduced. He was so... barely there. For a character that went on to be a major character and love interest for the rest of the book, I couldn't really get a feel for him. In fact, I couldn't really get a feel for most of the characters. They all seemed poorly thought out and shallow. I couldn't bring myself to feel attached to them. I mean, I could barely keep them straight, what with the jumping characterizations. For example, Ella was supposed to be a meek lower class girl used to bending her head when dealing with the upper class, but for some reason, always sounded strangely confident when talking to and literally making demands of Callum and Odina. Also, at some point, we were just expected to know that Odina was a member of the Players and Callum was the leader? I feel like at some point, some character was just expected to show deference to him as the leader of the Players, even though I don't recall it being explicitly mentioned, or even reasonably implied before that point.
If it had been mentioned, I must've missed it while undertaking the heavy task of trudging through the this book. At 50% through, I was seriously considering DNF-ing. Nothing was really endearing me to the book. The cast of characters was weirdly small, and again, none of the characters were really likable. There was a whole love story and I felt nothing. Absolutely nothing. In fact, I couldn't comprehend how a romance was even happening.
I kept reading only to see what the result of Ella's deal would be, and getting to the end, I suppose it makes sense that certain characters weren't likable. But honestly, its not even that I disliked the characters -- I was pretty much completely apathetic. As such, none of the betrayals or reveals affected me much at all. Even the stupid magic system, didn't rile me as much as another story's would have. I just kept reading until the book was over.
I really wish I'd liked this book, I really do. But I don't think I can give it any more than 2.5 stars.
August 20, 2022
BEGUILED is an intriguing YA fantasy about magic, power, and desire. Ella lost her father a few years earlier due to his debts, and she is close to following in his footsteps. The man from whom she borrows is asking for repayment in one way or another, and she feels out of options. The stories of the Bean-Nighe at the river are looking better and better - what price would she pay for a wish?
After her loom breaks, ruining any chance of hope, Ella is out of options and decides to make a wish with the Bean-Nighe to have it fixed. All the Bean-Nighe asks in return is a drop of blood when she weaves. Returning home, it all seems too good to be true, especially when the fabric she weaves is more stunning than anything she ever could have imagined - with unexpected side effects. As her fabrics get her noticed by the wealthy Callum and open the world to her, Ella begins to realize that the true price of the Bean-Nighe is much more than she ever could have anticipated on several levels.
What I loved: This is a story that grows darker as Ella becomes more steeped amongst the wealthy and the magic of her loom. At its heart, it is a story of hunger and desire for something more. Themes around wealth disparity, want, bargains, mistruths, and the games we play make this a thought-provoking read. Ella lives in poverty, desiring to make things by hand, but her path into security is through the benevolence of those around her. She is willing to work herself to the bone to achieve what she wants, and her new benefactor places her value on her products.
Ella is a compelling character, who hungers for more, but is faced with a society who discards her for the very reason she has to work. Her value is tied into her product plus luck in selling it. As the loom exacts its price while creating a magical product, Ella is enchanted by the possibilities of what it can bring. Ella is somewhat isolated amidst the glitz and glamor, particularly considering that they seem incapable of accepting someone of the working class.
The story unfolds in an intriguing way, becoming darker as Ella moves forward. While the reader can see some things coming, the way Ella reacted to it all was a great twist, and the ending became something different. The mythology and magic of the story was enchanting, and just enough knowledge woven throughout to help the reader understand.
Final verdict: BEGUILED is a magical YA fantasy about power, want, and poverty with compelling characters and surprising twists. Recommend for fans of GILDED, WISHTRESS, and THE WISH GRANTER.
Please note that I received an ARC. All opinions are my own.
After her loom breaks, ruining any chance of hope, Ella is out of options and decides to make a wish with the Bean-Nighe to have it fixed. All the Bean-Nighe asks in return is a drop of blood when she weaves. Returning home, it all seems too good to be true, especially when the fabric she weaves is more stunning than anything she ever could have imagined - with unexpected side effects. As her fabrics get her noticed by the wealthy Callum and open the world to her, Ella begins to realize that the true price of the Bean-Nighe is much more than she ever could have anticipated on several levels.
What I loved: This is a story that grows darker as Ella becomes more steeped amongst the wealthy and the magic of her loom. At its heart, it is a story of hunger and desire for something more. Themes around wealth disparity, want, bargains, mistruths, and the games we play make this a thought-provoking read. Ella lives in poverty, desiring to make things by hand, but her path into security is through the benevolence of those around her. She is willing to work herself to the bone to achieve what she wants, and her new benefactor places her value on her products.
Ella is a compelling character, who hungers for more, but is faced with a society who discards her for the very reason she has to work. Her value is tied into her product plus luck in selling it. As the loom exacts its price while creating a magical product, Ella is enchanted by the possibilities of what it can bring. Ella is somewhat isolated amidst the glitz and glamor, particularly considering that they seem incapable of accepting someone of the working class.
The story unfolds in an intriguing way, becoming darker as Ella moves forward. While the reader can see some things coming, the way Ella reacted to it all was a great twist, and the ending became something different. The mythology and magic of the story was enchanting, and just enough knowledge woven throughout to help the reader understand.
Final verdict: BEGUILED is a magical YA fantasy about power, want, and poverty with compelling characters and surprising twists. Recommend for fans of GILDED, WISHTRESS, and THE WISH GRANTER.
Please note that I received an ARC. All opinions are my own.
January 16, 2023
1700's fantasy that takes place in an undisclosed land but by the names of the gods/fae, I'm guessing Ireland or at least one of the Celtic areas.
Ella is a weaver whose father died in debtor's prison. As such, she still owes for his debts and must take on her own debts to pay for the supplies she needs to continue to create cloth. After her only customer refuses to pay her for fabric woven (though not ordered), leaving Ella with only a tarnished silver necklace and her loom broken, with Gregory, the lender, threatening her and no way to afford more supplies to create cloth, Ella goes to the river to call on the Bean-Nighe, the fae washer-woman who grants wishes for a price.
It seems so simple - a drop of blood given to the Bean-Nighe each time she weaves - and Ella agrees to the price. When she returns home, her loom is repaired and a new bit added - a needle, sharp and glittery but Ella's willing to pay and sticks her finger.
The cloth she turns out is beautiful and she weaves through the night. The next morning, a knock on her door surprises her with a gift of threads and ribbons, enough to really start weaving. In a very short time, she has two beautiful pieces of cloth to show to Odina, her one and only customer. And Odina is definitely willing to buy - but in the meantime, her suitor (or friend), Callum, is also fascinated by the fabric and Ella's willingness to stick up for herself by requesting an invitation to the party Odina will wear one of the dresses made from Ella's fabric.
There, at the party, Ella realizes the Bean-Nighe has not only given her power to weave enchanting fabric that people want to purchase but also that the fabric itself has its own power - the power to beguile others, to make them pliable to suggestions. And Cullum notices this too, deciding to become Ella's patron if she will make him fabric he can use to take over the city.
This was an interesting story and a bit creepy. I would've enjoyed a bit more creepy to it. Ella seems both naive and intelligent in some of her choices but when pressed up between a rock and a hard place, her decisions make sense.
Definitely hints of fairy tales and Irish gods and fair folk within.
Ella is a weaver whose father died in debtor's prison. As such, she still owes for his debts and must take on her own debts to pay for the supplies she needs to continue to create cloth. After her only customer refuses to pay her for fabric woven (though not ordered), leaving Ella with only a tarnished silver necklace and her loom broken, with Gregory, the lender, threatening her and no way to afford more supplies to create cloth, Ella goes to the river to call on the Bean-Nighe, the fae washer-woman who grants wishes for a price.
It seems so simple - a drop of blood given to the Bean-Nighe each time she weaves - and Ella agrees to the price. When she returns home, her loom is repaired and a new bit added - a needle, sharp and glittery but Ella's willing to pay and sticks her finger.
The cloth she turns out is beautiful and she weaves through the night. The next morning, a knock on her door surprises her with a gift of threads and ribbons, enough to really start weaving. In a very short time, she has two beautiful pieces of cloth to show to Odina, her one and only customer. And Odina is definitely willing to buy - but in the meantime, her suitor (or friend), Callum, is also fascinated by the fabric and Ella's willingness to stick up for herself by requesting an invitation to the party Odina will wear one of the dresses made from Ella's fabric.
There, at the party, Ella realizes the Bean-Nighe has not only given her power to weave enchanting fabric that people want to purchase but also that the fabric itself has its own power - the power to beguile others, to make them pliable to suggestions. And Cullum notices this too, deciding to become Ella's patron if she will make him fabric he can use to take over the city.
This was an interesting story and a bit creepy. I would've enjoyed a bit more creepy to it. Ella seems both naive and intelligent in some of her choices but when pressed up between a rock and a hard place, her decisions make sense.
Definitely hints of fairy tales and Irish gods and fair folk within.
August 21, 2022
This was an enjoyable book about a young weaver who makes a deal with a spirit to get her independence but there is a price to pay. I really enjoyed the story for this book as it was a good dark, folklore story with an amazing spirit. The author’s writing was beautifully written as they captured the story so well and knew how to tell Ella’s story. The world building was simple and easy to understand but I have to say that the pacing was a little all over the place. I felt that some scenes were just dragged out too much for some reason. The setting was just great and I enjoyed the whole independence theme and power hungry in this book. It was very feminism driven which I enjoyed especially because it was a fantasy book.
Ella is the main character in this story and I enjoyed her character. She is an easy character to relate to as she struggles with money but becomes hungry for wealth which we can all say has happened to us before. I enjoyed her character development in this book and it was different from what you would expect in a fantasy story. There are a good bit of side characters in this book which whom some I enjoyed and some didn’t. I really enjoyed how the author wrote the Bean-Nighe in this book. I thought it was really cool to learn about this Scottish folklore. There is also romance in this book which was enemies to lovers but it wasn’t the main factor of the story and was just there.
The ending was well done and I enjoyed how the story ended. There is a bit of mystery in this book but I have to say that it was a little lacking though not bad. This book did have a good story and I did love the main character also the Scottish folklore because it was new for me. There were some minor problems but overall it was a great read and I recommend it. This book is perfect for fans of The invisible Life of Addie Larue and Spinning Silver.
*this book was sent to me by the publisher to give an honest reviewing return*
August 28, 2022
I've been craving a fairytale-esque retelling and Beguiled certainly hit that spot. Ella is a weaver who finds herself trapped in debt she can't hope to repay and with a broken loom; her last hope is to pray to the Bean-Nighe, a mythical creature that grants wishes, to aid her. Suddenly Ella is weaving magical creations and is taken under the wing of a charming young man but as in every fairytale, you must be careful what you wish for.
I really liked the premise of the story, I hadn't heard of the Bean-Nighe story before, it's a little reminiscent of the Rumpelstiltskin tale, and I enjoyed this foray into Celtic folklore. I always enjoy stories that take lesser known folk tales and weave them into something unique, giving them a wider audience. The plot is set up nicely and whilst there was a slight lull in the middle, by the last third the pacing really picks up and I did find myself unable to put it down.
I loved Ella's character. It's no secret I like a determined, strong-minded MC and Ella was fiercely independent in her pursuit of a better life for herself. Her sacrifices to make her dream come true may seem naïve but you can't help but want her to succeed because of her resolve. Ella also grows in character a lot throughout the book, she comes to terms with her choices and faces the consequences head on.
The writing is captivating, it has that fairytale quality to it whilst also feeling fresh. Panin writes these characters and their world so well, they know how to enchant their audience and create a enthralling story of morals and magic.
I did find the middle of the story a little slow. I also thought that the overall arc of the storyline was very obvious so my intrigue suffered slightly too. I would have also liked the Bean-Nighe to have played a more central role.
Saying that this is a enchanting story that blends fantasy and folklore really well. With strong female characters and a feminist twist, it questions what you'd be willing to sacrifice in order to get your hearts desires and enforces that everything comes with a price.
I really liked the premise of the story, I hadn't heard of the Bean-Nighe story before, it's a little reminiscent of the Rumpelstiltskin tale, and I enjoyed this foray into Celtic folklore. I always enjoy stories that take lesser known folk tales and weave them into something unique, giving them a wider audience. The plot is set up nicely and whilst there was a slight lull in the middle, by the last third the pacing really picks up and I did find myself unable to put it down.
I loved Ella's character. It's no secret I like a determined, strong-minded MC and Ella was fiercely independent in her pursuit of a better life for herself. Her sacrifices to make her dream come true may seem naïve but you can't help but want her to succeed because of her resolve. Ella also grows in character a lot throughout the book, she comes to terms with her choices and faces the consequences head on.
The writing is captivating, it has that fairytale quality to it whilst also feeling fresh. Panin writes these characters and their world so well, they know how to enchant their audience and create a enthralling story of morals and magic.
I did find the middle of the story a little slow. I also thought that the overall arc of the storyline was very obvious so my intrigue suffered slightly too. I would have also liked the Bean-Nighe to have played a more central role.
Saying that this is a enchanting story that blends fantasy and folklore really well. With strong female characters and a feminist twist, it questions what you'd be willing to sacrifice in order to get your hearts desires and enforces that everything comes with a price.
Displaying 1 - 30 of 70 reviews