User reviews

Fair Western and not really that much of a remake of the original classic film. Excellent cast tries their best, but not much to work with. Bright spot is the beautiful and talented Barabra Luna who steals the show. Decent entertainment for a rainy midnight.

An inferior remake , this fare is a plain , brisk-paced , direct , mean and entirely entertaining , but mediocre . The picture is developed in 1873 in Onyx and talks about Lin McAdam (Tom Tryon in similar role to James Stewart) and there arrives his cousin Dakin McAdam (John Saxon) to participate in the town competition , and the competitor to be a winner , he will acquire the latest iron from the East , a Winchester 73 rifle . Two cousins - one an ex-con and the other a law officer - compete for possession of a famed repeating rifle. The sheriff obligates strangers to leave their guns . Both of them participate in a shot-contest, then Lin earns an state-of-the-art Winchester 73 , the greatest rifle in the west , but it is robbed and starting the possession through hand to hand , as the sheriff chases his stolen rifle as it changes hands , going on a merciless manhunt . Starring finally corners the original thief at a church with an engrossing and unfortunate shooot-out . Meanwhile , the. Mile by Mile...Showdown by Showdown...He Wreaked the West's Most Terrifying Vengeance! .The Gun That Won The West!

A regular television Western with nice actors , action-packed , sweaty , shootouts , chases , plot twists and breathtaking duels . The script results to be an adaptation based on ¨Big gun¨ , a novel written by Stuart L. Lake and screenwriter by prestigious Borden Chase, being also based about real events because 4 July 1876 in Dodge City had a shot competition and the winner was rewarded with a Winchester 73 model 1873 with ability shoot 17 cartridges caliber 44/40 in a few seconds . Of course, all the western's essential elements are in this film, such as : crossfire , Red Indian attack , violent raids by outlaws , final showdown , among others . Based on the 1950 landmark western ¨Winchester 73¨ that achieved to revive the genre during the decade 50s and that had excellent acting by an outstanding and notorious cast as Dan Duryea , Tony Curtis , Shelley Winters , John Doucette and James Stewart in his first western , subsequently following a lot , most of them directed by Anthony Mann ; formerly , in the early 1930s Stewart had worked with Mann in the theater . This TV retelling Winchester 73 (1967) stands out thanks to an extraordinary support casting , some of them in brief apparitions , such as : John Drew Barrymore , Paul Fix , Jack Lambert , John Hoyt , Ned Romero , James Griffith , Joan Blondell , John Dehner . While Dan Duryea and John Doucette also appeared in the original 1950 theatrical rendition directed by Anthony Mann, of which this is a reboot.

The breathtaking cinematography in in brilliant colour is well made by Bud Thackery , accompanying a thrilling and moving musical score by Sol Kaplan . This oater was regularly directed by ordinary TV director , whose career expanded exclusively in the small screen . He is known for his work on a lot of TV series , such as : General Electric Theater (1953), Star Trek (1966) and Misssion: Impossible (1966) , The Time Tunnel , Banacek , Cannon , Petrocelli, Murder for Murder , Ghost Story , Hawaii 5 0, Cimarron , High Chaparral , Hec Ramsey, Marcus Welby , Custer , Shane , Doctor Kildare , Bonanza , FBI , Gunsmoke and many others. Rating : 5.5/10 , only for Western hardcore lovers.

It's always tough to do a remake. This is no exception -- indeed, an excellent example of the remake challenge. Since there was nothing wrong with the excellent Jimmy Stewart version, there was no need to remake it -- except to do it differently. And different is indeed what they do.

Does it work? Well, not as well as Anthony Mann's did. The various criticisms of previous reviewers are valid: there is wooden acting (especially by the lead, Tom Tryon), and the story line is highly altered. However, there are strong points here, even if the production-as-a-whole is not as well-realized as the 50s version.

• First, the message and emphasis is different. Mann genuinely focused on the rifle as his central plot point (hence the title!), but this film uses the titular rifle as more of a MacGuffin.

• Second, there are genuinely interesting efforts at direction -- e.g., the camera riding along with the coffin during the funeral procession.

• Thirdly, there are strong performances among the more pedestrian (more detail below).

Does it all work? Well -- not quite as well as they wanted. But there is something there, and it does work sometimes. Part of the problem is being a TV movie -- acts must end in cliffhangers, for the commercial breaks, and the whole production has to be made quickly. So it isn't what it might have been, but there are still things to appreciate.

John Saxon is hugely responsible for this version's effectiveness, being the central character -- being a dark reflection upon his father. We are told this more than shown it, but Saxon makes us believe in him throughout, even as we fear him.

There is also Luna's character, which (despite not featuring in the 50s version) is the second joy here. She's very much the actress we see on the original Star Trek, or later on Fantasy Island -- perfectly capable of going from sexy to dangerous in .01 seconds, while stealing the scene. Nice to see she's still working, even if she never had a major hit to call her own. She and Saxon make this worth seeing, and either one or the other appear in almost every scene.

Joan Blondell appears about an hour into the movie, for no real benefit (except to see her perform). One might suppose there were scenes which explained why her character mattered, rather than just a few scenes for her to strut. Personally, this was highly disappointing, as her inclusion was mainly why I bought the DVD.

Overall: the opening is a little slow, the conclusion is a little clumsy, the plot points are sometimes a bit mushy. And yet, I just watched it for a second time and was firmly involved from beginning to end. It's a solid production, which attempts a subtle depiction of dysfunctional family dynamics, and doesn't come off terribly articulate -- and yet, the message is there, with some fine performances along the way.

Not unwatchable, but close to it. I agree with malcomgsw, this pales in comparison to the classic from 1950, one of my personal favorites from any genre. The changes to the plot do not improve upon the original but overly complicate it - in this case less is more. John Saxon gives the best performance here, making the most of a thin script. Saxon is good at playing creeps, see him in "The Appaloosa" with Brando. Tom Tryon gives a wooden performance, shortly before giving up acting to become a writer. It was gratifying to see Dan Duryea from the earlier film, but his turn here seems tired, while in the original he was one of the more memorable villains in screen history. John Drew Barrymore's hippie character is unusual, but out of place in a western, kind of like Donald Sutherland in "Kelly's Heroes". All in all, an inferior remake of a superior film. I would, however, take issue with malcolmgsw's comment that some IMDb contributors seem to "want to eulogize the guns that are featured in films rather than dwell on their harmful consequences". We can of course, dwell on anything we want to, but while we're dwelling, what about the people living on the frontier whose lives were saved by having firearms nearby? Just saying.

I don't know what it says about some of the contributors to this site that they seem to want to eulogise the guns that are featured in films rather than dwell on their harmful consequences.This is a cheap and shoddy TV remake by Universal of one of the great Westerns of all time.They have a determination to reduce everything to the lowest common denominator .It is quite apparent that they want to keep the cast list to below 10 and use all of their standing sets at Universal City.Their "Indian Tribe" seems to consist of just 2 individuals.The acting of the younger members of the cast is so wooden that you would believe that their faces are incapable of mobility.The shootout at the end is poorly staged and the whole film is a total bore which even a fine actor such as Dan Duryea cannot redeem.

There must be a terrific laundry in this town. Every actor's clothes are perfectly cleaned and pressed except for John Saxon. Appears the costume lady just went down the movies studio's "cowboy clothes" department and pulled out something from the 1950's for everyone. Secondly, I take part in shoot competitions and have never seen anyone who could shoot as well as these guys. Totally unbelievable. Thirdly, the depictions of "Indians" is an insult to real native Americans. It's hard to understand why movie studios would put money into this kind of amateurish film. I gave it a 2 only because it had some nice scenery.

If you have just watched the original Winchester 73 with Jimmy Stewart and foolishly followed it with his one -- you have my utmost sympathy. At least the screen writers didn't make a duplicate of the original. That probably would have even been worse. There are a handful of talented actors in this movie; however, they couldn't save it from the bad script or the other actors who were the proverbial flash in the pan -- only on the screen because they had the Look and nothing more. This movie might be more palatable if I had not watched the original right before this one.

The only thing that kept me watching was how impressed I was with the picture for 1967 - bright, vid, and quite sharp. I don't know if I was watching an upgraded version or what but it looked amazing.

Now, the writing - wow, it's really bad. None of the characters make any sense in what they are doing. None of them. They all seem to make the most random and horrible decisions. I could only watch 20 minutes but it kept getting worse and worse. Do not watch more than a couple minutes.

This is a fantastic remake of the original that starred James Stewart. John Saxon plays the bad guy and guess who plays his father, Dan Duryea who also starred in the original. I hope someday they will distribute this on VHS or DVD. If not, I hope they will at least air it again on television.