User reviews

As a longtime Hallmark Christmas movie fan, I'm happy to see a little competition. I liked the Hallmark movies better when they did just a few movies a season. They were fresher. Now that they put them out factory-style, it's harder to find the gems among dozens of offerings.

"A Christmas Proposal" was refreshing, even though it did borrow from Hallmark plots (fake relationship, sibling rivalry, a Christmas ball where all is revealed); it was reminiscent of "Snow Bride."

The cast was great. The diversity was organic; Hispanic actors in an Hispanic family story.

Definitely worth watching, even though you now have to stream it on Paramount+ (clever marketing to attract new viewers, since the same movies aren't shown over and over again).

I look forward to more offerings, and hope the competition inspires Hallmark.

I like the story. I am only half way through watching but I like the way it is progressing.

I am anxious to see how it finishes. The lead characters are very charming and I am hoping that they do end up together. I have a hunch who "Brooklyn" may end up with (2 different ones actually). Only 30 minutes of the movie to go so it has my attention.

This movie fits the usual formula for a Hallmark Christmas movie. I don't want to spend the extra money for that channel and don't have the time to watch lots of movies like this, but the fact is I enjoy these movies.

And it doesn't matter that people are lying and could get in trouble for it later on. That's part of the fun.

And yes, there are plenty of "only in the movies" moments. Who wants to see real life if they don't have to?

The most important thing is Maria will make these people's lives so much better if they let her.

Jessica Camacho is not my ideal female lead in a movie like this, but she is quite beautiful, and while not cute, she is intelligent and confident. Not the traditional cute potential romantic partner, but of course as in so many of these movies, she is shocked at first by the idea that she would ever be with this man. She looks amazing in a ball gown.

I'm not that crazy about Adam Rodriguez either but he's good enough and someone I am willing to root for.

Luisa d'Oliveira as the best friend is just edgy enough and appealing in her own way. And I really like her festive pajamas in one scene. Are they beautiful? As a sweater, the design might be an "ugly holiday sweater".

Bianca Caroca is quire appealing as Julian's sister.

And I like Jaime M. Callica, Julian's friend, who I thought was Alfonso Ribeiro at first.

Frank Crudele is very appealing as the man who runs one of the family's favorite restaurants.

I also liked Serge Houde as the man who runs ... wait ... Pendergast Tool? Didn't Archie Bunker (of New York City) work there? This is Washington, but it is a big company. There must be a story there because Pendergast is not an ordinary name.

Renee Taylor has one line as a server in another restaurant but she does it so well.

Julian found "The Nutcracker" to be torture. At first. I'm not saying I like ballet, but I like the music. The part of the ballet that was shown, while well done of course, did not have the familiar music. What I recall is that my father's LP has two sides, one with all the music we know, and another with less familiar music. I will assume the music in this movie was from the other side.

Is this family friendly? It was rated TV-G on CBS, very unusual in 2021. The most offensive content I was aware of was "shove it up their Christmas stocking" and "nutcracker of a comment", so nothing too serious. Daphne, Juiian's sister, described coming out as gay to her parents, but in 2021 this is perfectly fine in G-rated content, though maybe not for everyone. I don't think Daphne's being gay was ever mentioned again.

Is this a movie you want to watch? I can't speak for those who have Hallmark Channel and watch lots of them, but if you can only choose a few, this is one you can surely enjoy.

I loveddd this Christmas movie! One of my favs now! It was genuine, funny, heartwarming, and best storyline. I highly recommend! Ill watch over and over.

I love Christmas movies, but this one rose above all the others. The characters were believable; the story line was interesting and had depth; the dialogue was interesting, witty, and fun;, and I was glued to the television. I loved every minute!

Another awful hallmark-esque movie with terrible acting and a comically unbelievable script. Right from the cringe-worthy beginning you can tell how bad it's going to be. I'm inclined to think based on the script and wholesomeness that this was written with Christian values in mind, not that that it's a bad thing, but it will give you an idea of what you're getting yourself into. For any of us living in the real world you will be sorely disappointed. If you were to play it off as a satire you might be able to laugh off a bit of it or possibly turn it into a drinking game? Please do yourself a favor and avoid this at all costs.

Summary: Absolutely terrible.

A truly warm and charming Christmas movie.

A movie with a message.

And a amazing cast that you get to know and cheer on.

It is a new Christmas classic.

I encourage every one to get a nice cup of tea or hot chocalate and watch this wonderful movie with friends and family.

Had to stop watching did not care for the Narrating throughout the movie, ridiculous! Would have enjoyed if I could have continued without NARRATING the entire movie, was not needed at all.

Actors were well done. The script , however, was not breezy conversational. The plot called for breezy but the dialogue played a bit arch and stilted. That said it had a Happy Ending and who can overly criticize anything in these times that "proposes" such.

I used my Amazon credits to buy this movie, I have never done that. This is a cute "Harlequin" type romance. The actors are great to watch, there is chemistry between the two main characters and I LOVE Brooklyn. Definitely a clean, lovely little movie that makes you feel good.

I hope CBS continues to make Christmas movies because I loved A Christmas Proposal! The chemistry between Adam Rodriguez and Jessica Camacho (LOVE her on All Rise!) was great and I enjoy the pretend-to-be-my-girlfriend storylines. I also loved the diversity that this movie showcased. Funny, beautiful holiday sets and a great cast!

I enjoyed this movie Tremendously The actors portrayed the storyline perfectly, meeting by chance the way they did,The characters in the storyline seemed real and how they pulled the lead female character into the story her trying to return the cell phone was very different, and it was heartfelt. It's the best Christmas movie I've seen in a while. I like how the writer's changed it up. The characters in the storyline seemed real and It held my attention Because it was different and exciting. I would watch this movie again. It is a feel-good movie, perfect for this time of year! I wish there were another movie out there similar to this that I could watch.

When I'm in the mood to watch a movie like this, it means I want something low romantic and fun, with low drama and those cheesy scenes that can give you butterflies.

EVEN IF the acting is subpar, if it has the above with halfway decent writing/plot/story-line, then I'm here for it.

A Christmas Proposal is all of the above, BUT the acting is actually really great! From the leading characters, to the supporting roles of the friends and family- the cast does a fantastic job.

Definitely one of my favorites! To the point I wish there was a second one... Give it a try and, hopefully, you'll enjoy it as much as I did! (And still do every year around this time ;))