Double Cookie Peanut Butter Pie is a no bake pie with an OREO Pie Crust and a NILLA Wafer Topping! Two cookies and delicious layers of peanut butter goodness in between!
I’ve had the idea in my head for quite a while to make a pie with two different cookies in it. One cookie in the OREO Pie Crust and one cookie in the topping. And no, I didn’t want it to be the same cookie, I wanted multiple cookies!
NILLA Wafers are a fan favorite around here. They were one of my favorite snacks growing up and my daughter is definitely falling in the same footsteps. In fact, she saw the box of them on the counter with the other pie ingredients and she was devastated when I told her she couldn’t have any until after I made the pie! Her sad face kept repeatedly coming into the kitchen and staring longingly at the box with a sad puppy dog look in her eyes. I wish I was making this up for dramatic effect, but seriously, this little girl gets worked up about her snacks. Check out more delicious NILLA Wafer recipes here!
After telling her no 1,000 times, I cracked and pulled a few wafers out of the box for her. And of course, I grabbed a few for myself!
This Double Cookie Peanut Butter Pie is so easy and is no bake, which makes it perfect for any upcoming Spring holiday. You will have enough food in your oven on Easter, so just make this pie in advance and throw it in the freezer to set up! Once it is time to serve, remove from the freezer for 15 or so minutes for it to soften and then top with the peanut butter and chocolate chips and the NILLA wafer crumbles! The topping makes it look way fancier than it is!
We love this Double Cookie Peanut Butter Pie and I hope you will too! What is your favorite easy dessert for this time of the year? I am always looking for good no bake pies!
Double Cookie Peanut Butter Pie
Ingredients
- 1 OREO Pie Crust
- 1 1/2 cups peanut butter
- 8 oz. cream cheese
- 1 1/2 cups powdered sugar
- 3 heaping tbsp. marshmallow creme
- 2 tsp. vanilla
- 3 tbsp. heavy cream
- 8 oz. frozen whipped topping
- 1/2 cup chocolate and peanut butter chips
- 20 NILLA Wafer Cookies crushed
Instructions
-
Add the cream cheese and peanut butter to the bowl of a mixer. Mix on medium speed until well combined.
-
Add powdered sugar, 1/2 cup at a time to the bowl and continue to mix on medium. Once all sugar is added, scrap the sides of the bowl and then add vanilla, cream, and marshmallow creme. Beat on medium high for 3 minutes, or until light and fluffy. Taste and if you like a sweeter filling, add more sugar.
-
Pour peanut butter mixture into the OREO Pie crust and spread into an even layer. Top with whipped topping and then the chocolate and pb chips and then the crushed NILLA Wafers.
-
Freeze for 2-3 hours before serving.
I picked up all my supplies for this pie at Walmart. 
I want to sit down and eat that entire pie right now! No bake pies are right up my alley!
Me too! I am fighting the urge to finish the leftovers !!
This recipe looks delicious I want to buy it right now. While it is it gluten-free I do know of a gluten-free Nila wafer from another company and I’m pretty sure I can re-create this so I can eat it .
Oh good! I hope you are able to find gluten free substitutes!
OMG! Your photos are Gorgeous and this dessert looks delicious. I am a big peanut fan.
Thank you Latasha!!
Vanilla wafers are my all time favorite cookie. They are so versatile, good for babies, and so easy to carry around. Yum.
Yes! I gave my baby one today for the first time and she went crazy!!
This is what I need in my life right now. I have come to be a big fan of peanut butter recently. This pie has everything that I love.
I’m not a big sweet or peanut butter fan but boy, hubby sure is! I do like to make him treats and this is one he’d love
I actually made this for my husband’s birthday!!
Oh my this looks absolutely gorgeous – you can tell how soft and creamy the pie is! Definitely bookmarking for one of those days when we’re having a super sweet tooth xx
It is so good and creamy!! Thanks Tereza!
Yum this look delish. Love this recipe and I will be trying this out. xx
Thanks Anna!
Oh my word…I think I just gained 20 pounds just looking at that pie! It would be totally worth it though – looks so yummy!!
Definitely worth it!!!
This pie looks insanely delicious. I love anything with peanut butter and chocolate. I can see this being the hit of any spring gathering.
It sure looks delectable. I would love to make this for the kids. I’m sure they’re going to love it, especially my boys who are crazy about peanut butter.
My husband would just devour this (haha!). I’m strange – I don’t like PB in anything except on a piece of bread lol.
Today is Friday and looks like this is what we are going to have for dessert tonight. Thanks for the recipe.
It is a perfect weekend treat!
Wow that looks delicious! I love a good no bake pie. I’m saving this to try later. I have a few friends who I know would love this.
I am a sucker for peanut butter! I absolutely love this pie – it looks like it is loaded with flavor!
Oh my gosh stop it! I can’t even look at you right now…my thighs are weeping and my mouth is drooling! lol
No bake recipes are the best! It has been ages and ages since I’ve made a no bake peanut butter pie, but I’m tempted to make one soon.
This was the first time I had made one in forever! So good!!
One of my favorite date-night only restaurants has a magnificent peanut butter pie and this looks just like it. I just pinned this for later because I’ll get mega bonus points if I make this for my hubby.
Thank you for pinning!! It is a really delicious pie! I hope your hubby likes it!
I actually went and bought all the ingredients and my little ones and I are making it today!!!
I made this with my daughter and she loved helping! I hope your littles loved it too!
This looks so yum! I love peanut butter and chocolate, I need to try this recipe stat!