1. Introduction
As the global population continues to increase, so does the human demand for food. Therefore, finding ways to improve crop yield and quality is a top priority for food security [
1]. The growth of crops, however, has always been under the stress of an unfavorable environment. However, the growth of crops has been facing adverse environmental stresses such as drought, salt stress, insect pests, and so on. These biotic or abiotic stresses are serious constraints to crop yield and quality [
2,
3]. With the development of society, environmental pollution caused by improper agricultural management, sea level rise due to global warming, and a series of problems have gradually increased soil salinization, and salt stress has become a major adverse factor in agricultural production [
4]. The total area of saline soil in the world is more than 8.3 × 10
8 hm
2, which is about 25% of the total land area, spreading over all regions of the world. According to statistics, more than half of the irrigated land in the world is jeopardized by salinity and waterlogging, which seriously restricts the growth and development of crops [
5]. Salt stress inhibits seed germination and plant growth and development, resulting in reduced yields. Salt stress injury to plants is mainly caused by Na
+, high concentrations of Na
+ accumulation, but also inhibits the absorption of K
+, the accumulation of excessive Na
+ will make the biofilm function impaired, affecting the osmotic balance, and causing physiological and metabolic disorders [
6]. A large number of studies have shown that chlorophyll synthesis in leaves is inhibited under salt stress, and the photosynthetic rate of plants decreases, resulting in slow growth [
7]. The plant’s photosynthetic rate decreases, resulting in slow growth.
Rapeseed is a vital oilseed, vegetable, and forage crop, with the planting area accounting for about 30% of the world and China’s production accounting for about 20% of the world’s production [
8]. It is also an essential protein and edible oil source and can be used for ornamental purposes, oil extraction, wintergreen fodder, and fresh grass feeding [
9]. As an essential green manure crop, winter oilseed rape proliferates, has a significant nutrient body, good mulching effect, low planting cost, and is essential for farmland soil protection and soil fertilization [
10]. It has become vital to meet the increasing food demand by developing salt-tolerant varieties suitable for growing in saline soils.
Prohexadione-calcium (Pro-Ca) is a cyclohexane carboxylic acid plant growth retardant, which can regulate flowering time, improve plant fruiting rate, control plant growth, improve fruit yield and quality, and improve resistance to stress, etc., and has no residual toxicity and no pollution [
11]. Because of its low toxicity and no residue, it is increasingly attracting widespread attention. In recent years, the positive effects of Pro-Ca on plant growth and development under adversity have been gradually discovered. Foliar spraying of Pro-Ca can alleviate the reduction of superoxide dismutase (SOD), peroxidase activity (POD), and catalase (CAT) activities in tobacco leaves under low-temperature stress, promote proline biosynthesis, and regulate the relative balance of reactive oxygen species (ROS) [
12]. Improved root vigor, induced chlorophyll biosynthesis, increased leaf soluble protein content, and increased fruit weight and yield in peanuts [
13]. Improve photosynthetic characteristics and promote soluble substance synthesis in soybeans under salt stress [
14]. More and more researchers hope to improve crop salinity tolerance by developing and applying Pro-Ca.
In contrast, seed initiation technology can improve seed germination, seedling emergence, and seedling quality, which is conducive to the cultivation of solid seedlings and even improve plant resistance [
15]. Therefore, in this experiment, Pro-Ca was used as an initiator to investigate the regulatory effects on seed germination and seedling growth of oilseed rape under salt stress. This study aimed to reveal the regulatory mechanism of Pro-Ca primed to alleviate salt stress in oilseed rape seedlings, to investigate the effect on salt tolerance of oilseed rape and its physiological metabolism mechanism changes after Pro-Ca primed, to solve the inhibition of soil salinity on oilseed rape growth, and to improve the sustainability of agricultural production. The results showed that prohexadione-calcium priming improved the photosynthetic capacity of oilseed rape by promoting leaf growth, stomatal opening, and photosynthetic pigment synthesis. Meanwhile, it reduced Na
+ content and promoted K
+ and Mg
2+ absorption and antioxidant enzyme activities, which jointly alleviated salt damage and improved salt tolerance of oilseed rape.
4. Discussion
Seed germination is the beginning of the life course of oilseed rape, and the germination and seedling stages are more sensitive to salt stress during the growth and development of oilseed rape. Studies have concluded that germination index, vigor index, and seedling fresh weight can be used as effective indicators for screening salt tolerance in oilseed rape at the germination stage [
26]. Some scholars have found that sorghum seed shoot length, root length, germination potential, and germination rate showed a sequential decrease with increasing salt concentration and different degrees of delayed germination [
27]. The results of the present study were similar to it; with increasing salt concentration germination index and vigor index continued to decline, and the average germination time increased, inhibiting the vigor of oilseed rape seeds and weakening the germination ability (
Figure 1). With the increase in salt concentration, the germination rate, germination index, and vigor index decreased more, and the seed vigor index was more sensitive than the germination rate and germination index under salt stress [
28]. The experiment concluded that the vigor index decreased the most with increasing salt stress (
Figure 1), similar to its results, and the more sensitive change of seed vigor index under salt stress was verified. After being primed with different concentrations of Pro-Ca, the seed germination index and vigor index increased significantly, and the average germination time decreased significantly, indicating that primed could alleviate the inhibitory effect of salt stress on seed germination and improve germination neatness [
29]. Comparison among the concentrations revealed that the seed germination and vigor indexes tended to increase and decrease. The average germination time decreased and then increased (
Figure 1), so EA8 (8 mg·L
-1) initiation had the best effect in promoting the germination of oilseed rape. Seeds affected by salt stress would inhibit seed germination growth with weak young shoots and yellowing cotyledons. Injury by salt stress deepens cell membrane lipid peroxidation, resulting in elevated MDA content, so the degree of injury by salt stress was assessed by measuring the MDA content of young shoots [
30]. As a result of salt stress, the fresh weight of young oilseed rape shoots decreased, and the MDA content tended to increase. Pro-Ca primed an increase in fresh weight and a significant decrease in MDA content under salt stress (
Figure 2), indicating that Pro-Ca promotes the growth of young oilseed rape shoots under salt stress and reduces cellular lipid peroxidation. It was concluded that the optimal initiation concentration of Pro-Ca primed was EA8 (8 mg·L
-1).
Salt stress leads to slow growth and development and dwarf plants [
31]. Our study showed that salt stress inhibited plant height, root length, and leaf area in oilseed rape, with a significant decrease in the stoutness index (
Figure 3), typical of developmental retardation. It was found that under salt stress (S150), plant height and leaf area decreased by 49.45% and 70.69% in Huayouza 158R, 50.41% and 75.03% in Huayouza 62, and 24.83% and 26.40% in root length, respectively. The inhibition of plant height and leaf area was higher than that of root length, which was inconsistent with the trend of changes in previous studies [
32], probably due to the limited space in pots, which restricts the growth of the root system. Pro-Ca is primed to promote the growth and development of oilseed rape and leaf growth (
Figure 3C), which provides the basis for photosynthesis in oilseed rape. The strong seedling index can reflect whether the plant thrives [
17], and after Pro-Ca was primed, the strong seedling index was significantly increased under unstressed conditions, which promoted plant robustness (
Figure 3D). It showed an increasing trend under salt stress, and the PCS100 treatment of Huayouza 158R was significantly higher than S100, indicating that Pro-Ca primed could significantly improve the growth inhibition of Huayouza 158R by salt stress.
Most reports indicated a decrease in photosynthetic capacity and significant inhibition of photosynthetic pigment synthesis under salt stress. Prolonged salt stress reduces the biosynthesis of the chlorophyll protein-lipid complex, which affects the photosynthetic system and results in stunted plant growth [
33,
34,
35]. However, no uniform conclusion has emerged on the changes in photosynthetic pigments under salt stress, with some studies showing that chlorophyll content increases in salt-tolerant plants under salt stress [
36]. In contrast, others suggest that the elevation of chlorophyll content is temporary, increasing and then decreasing with the continued effects of salt stress [
37]. In this study, it was shown that the sprouting growth of oilseed rape under salt stress inhibits the synthesis of photosynthetic pigments, and the salt-tolerant variety Huayouza 62 has a higher level of photosynthetic pigment content (
Figure 4). It was found that although the level of photosynthetic pigment content of Huayouza 158R was lower, the photosynthetic pigment content was significantly increased after initiation, and the effect was better than that of Huayouza 62. Maintaining a certain level of photosynthetic pigment can improve light energy conversion efficiency and maintain photosynthetic activity. It has been pointed out that photosynthetic parameters were significantly reduced, and growth and development were inhibited under salt stress [
38]. In this study,
Pn,
Gs,
Ci, and
Tr were significantly decreased at S150 (
Figure 5), which indicated that the decrease in
Pn under salt stress was due to stomatal restriction, reduced stomatal opening to reduce transpiration, and decreased inter-cellular CO
2 content, resulting in a significant decrease in
Pn. Leaf stunting and photosynthetic pigment content decreased under salt stress, while photosynthetic parameters such as
Pn only decreased significantly at S150, suggesting that oilseed rape had some resistance at S100. The study also showed that Pro-Ca priming promoted
Pn by promoting stomatal opening and intercellular CO
2 content, and the promotion became more significant with the elevation of salt stress. This suggests that Pro-Ca priming seems to play a more significant role in oilseed rape when it is more severely inhibited, and the exact mechanism of its effect needs to be further investigated.
The ionic damage of salt stress on oilseed rape is mainly caused by Na
+; excessive Na
+ will disturb the plant metabolism, cause damage to the cell membrane system, increase the permeability of the cell membrane, and electrolyte extravasation, resulting in cellular metabolism disorders and the accumulation of reactive oxygen species, which will lead to the inhibition of plant growth or even death [
39]. When the concentration of Na
+ and Cl
- in the plant is too high, it also interferes with the uptake of nitrogen and nutrients such as K
+ and Mg
2+ by the root system, which leads to plant stunting [
40]. The present study showed a significant increase in Na
+ content and a significant decrease in K
+ and Mg
2+ content under salt stress (
Figure 8). Excessive accumulation of Na
+, increased cellular plasma peroxidation, and damage to membrane lipids or membrane proteins caused a significant increase in relative conductivity and MDA content of oilseed rape leaves (
Figure 6), which is consistent with the results of previous studies. The central metal element for chlorophyll synthesis is Mg [
41]. The significant decrease in Mg
2+ content may further affect chlorophyll synthesis, and the reduced photosynthetic capacity leads to slow development. It was found that antioxidant enzyme activities were elevated at this time, and oilseed rape activated the self-defense mechanism (
Figure 7). The antioxidant defense system is a crucial mechanism for plants to regulate the balance of reactive oxygen species and resist environmental stress [
42]. The changes in antioxidant enzyme activities under salt stress were variable, and it was noted that the activities of SOD, CAT, and APX were significantly enhanced in tomato seedlings under salt stress [
43]. Our results were similar to theirs; SOD, POD, and APX activities increased significantly under salt stress except for CAT activity (
Figure 7), which may be related to the degree of salt stress and cultivar salt tolerance, and the antioxidant defense system of oilseed rape was enhanced under salt stress. After Pro-Ca primed, Na
+ content decreased significantly, and K
+ and Mg
2+ showed an increasing trend (
Figure 8). A large amount of Na
+ accumulation inhibits K
+ uptake, and researchers have suggested that the K
+/ Na
+ ratio can reflect the degree of salt stress in crops [44]. The K
+ content (
Figure 8A), which decreased after Pro-Ca primed under unstressed conditions, is worth noting. Under salt stress conditions, it increased after Pro-Ca primed; however, both K
+/ Na
+ increased (
Figure 8D). This suggests that the mode of regulation is inconsistent, with the unstressed condition primarily contributing to a decrease in Na
+ content and the salt stress condition contributing to a decrease in Na
+ while also promoting the uptake of potassium ions. The study also showed that Pro-Ca primed a decrease in relative conductivity and MDA content and increased antioxidant enzyme activities. Therefore, our results strongly suggest that Pro-Ca primed alleviates salt stress in oilseed rape.
Figure 1.
Effect of Pro-Ca primed on the germination of oilseed rape under salt stress (day 7). Germination index (A and B), vigor index (C and D), and average germination time (E and F). Data are expressed as mean ± standard error and are not significantly different with the same letter by LSD test (p < 0.05).
Figure 1.
Effect of Pro-Ca primed on the germination of oilseed rape under salt stress (day 7). Germination index (A and B), vigor index (C and D), and average germination time (E and F). Data are expressed as mean ± standard error and are not significantly different with the same letter by LSD test (p < 0.05).
Figure 2.
Effect of Pro-Ca primed on fresh weight and malondialdehyde in oilseed rape under salt stress (day 7). Fresh weight (A and B), MDA: malondialdehyde (C and D). Data are expressed as mean ± standard error and are not significantly different with the same letter by LSD test (p < 0.05).
Figure 2.
Effect of Pro-Ca primed on fresh weight and malondialdehyde in oilseed rape under salt stress (day 7). Fresh weight (A and B), MDA: malondialdehyde (C and D). Data are expressed as mean ± standard error and are not significantly different with the same letter by LSD test (p < 0.05).
Figure 3.
Effect of Pro-Ca primed on morphological development of oilseed rape under salt stress. Plant height (A), root length (B), leaf area (C), and seedling strength index (D). Data are expressed as mean ± standard error and are not significantly different with the same letter by LSD test (p < 0.05).
Figure 3.
Effect of Pro-Ca primed on morphological development of oilseed rape under salt stress. Plant height (A), root length (B), leaf area (C), and seedling strength index (D). Data are expressed as mean ± standard error and are not significantly different with the same letter by LSD test (p < 0.05).
Figure 4.
Effect of Pro-Ca primed on photosynthetic pigments in oilseed rape under salt stress. Chlorophyll a (A), chlorophyll b (B), carotenoids (C), total chlorophyll (D). Data are expressed as mean ± standard error and are not significantly different with the same letter by LSD test (p < 0.05).
Figure 4.
Effect of Pro-Ca primed on photosynthetic pigments in oilseed rape under salt stress. Chlorophyll a (A), chlorophyll b (B), carotenoids (C), total chlorophyll (D). Data are expressed as mean ± standard error and are not significantly different with the same letter by LSD test (p < 0.05).
Figure 5.
Effect of Pro-Ca primed on photosynthetic properties of oilseed rape under salt stress. Pn: net photosynthetic rate (A), Gs: stomatal conductance (B), Ci: inter-cellular CO2 concentration (C), Tr: transpiration rate (D). Data are expressed as mean ± standard error and are not significantly different with the same letter by LSD test (p < 0.05).
Figure 5.
Effect of Pro-Ca primed on photosynthetic properties of oilseed rape under salt stress. Pn: net photosynthetic rate (A), Gs: stomatal conductance (B), Ci: inter-cellular CO2 concentration (C), Tr: transpiration rate (D). Data are expressed as mean ± standard error and are not significantly different with the same letter by LSD test (p < 0.05).
Figure 6.
Effect of Pro-Ca primed on membrane lipid peroxidation in oilseed rape under salt stress. Leaf relative conductivity (A), MDA: malondialdehyde (B). Data are expressed as mean ± standard error and are not significantly different with the same letter by LSD test (p < 0.05).
Figure 6.
Effect of Pro-Ca primed on membrane lipid peroxidation in oilseed rape under salt stress. Leaf relative conductivity (A), MDA: malondialdehyde (B). Data are expressed as mean ± standard error and are not significantly different with the same letter by LSD test (p < 0.05).
Figure 7.
Effect of Pro-Ca primed on antioxidant enzymes in oilseed rape under salt stress. SOD: superoxide dismutase (A), POD: peroxidase (B), CAT: catalase (C), APX: ascorbate peroxidase (D). Data are expressed as mean ± standard error and are not significantly different with the same letter by LSD test (p < 0.05).
Figure 7.
Effect of Pro-Ca primed on antioxidant enzymes in oilseed rape under salt stress. SOD: superoxide dismutase (A), POD: peroxidase (B), CAT: catalase (C), APX: ascorbate peroxidase (D). Data are expressed as mean ± standard error and are not significantly different with the same letter by LSD test (p < 0.05).
Figure 8.
Effect of Pro-Ca primed on ion content of oilseed rape under salt stress. K+: potassium ions (A), Mg2+: magnesium ions (B), Na+: sodium ions (C), K+ /Na+: potassium to sodium ion ratio (D). Data are expressed as mean ± standard error and are not significantly different with the same letter by LSD test (p < 0.05).
Figure 8.
Effect of Pro-Ca primed on ion content of oilseed rape under salt stress. K+: potassium ions (A), Mg2+: magnesium ions (B), Na+: sodium ions (C), K+ /Na+: potassium to sodium ion ratio (D). Data are expressed as mean ± standard error and are not significantly different with the same letter by LSD test (p < 0.05).