CDMA Drive Test
CDMA Drive Test
CDMA Drive Test
Remainder Set
Candidate set
PN 132
Introduction Network optimization overview CDMA concepts for understanding drive-test measurements Phone-based drive-test measurements Receiver-based drive-test measurements Conclusion
Section 4:
Section 5:
Section 6:
Section 1: Introduction
The growth and expansion of cellular and PCS networks continues at a rapid pace throughout the world. To retain existing customers and attract new customers, wireless service providers must maintain the highest quality of service throughout their networks. Drive-testing remains an essential part of the network life cycle, as an effective means for continually optimizing network performance to maintain customer satisfaction and reduce subscriber churn. This application note provides an overview of how drivetest tools can help optimize your CDMA-based cellular and PCS networks. These tools allow you to turn-up networks faster, reduce optimization time and improve network quality of service. Drive-test tools include both those required for collecting data as it relates to a users location and those that are used to post-process the collected data for final analysis. Drive-test solutions are used for collecting measurement data over a CDMA air interface. The optimum solution combines network-independent RF measurements using a digital receiver with traditional phone-based measurements. A typical collection system includes a digital RF receiver, phone, PC, GPS receiver and antennas.
Optimization is an important step in the life cycle of a wireless network. An overview of the optimization process is illustrated in Figure 2. Drive-testing is the first step in the process, with the goal of collecting measurement data as it relates to a users location. Once the data has been collected over the desired RF coverage area, the data is output to a post-processing software tool. Engineers can use the post-processing and collection tools to identify the causes of potential RF coverage or interference problems and analyze how these problems can be solved. Once the problems, causes, and solutions are identified, steps are performed to solve the problem. Figure 2 illustrates that optimization is an ongoing process. The goal is to improve quality of service, retain existing subscribers, and attract new oneswhile continually expanding the network.
Figure 2. Optimization process begins with drive testing, moves to post-processing, then requires data analysis, and finally action needs to be taken to correct the problems. Drive-testing is performed again to verify that the actions were effective.
Site Evaluation
On-going Optimization
Drive-test overview
This section describes the basic concepts of drive-testing. Both network equipment manufacturers and wireless service providers perform drive-testing. Wireless service providers need to optimize their networks, as new cell sites are added, new buildings constructed or other conditions change. Drive-testing allows them to perform this optimization on an ongoing basis. Traditionally, CDMA drive-testing is performed using a phone connected to a portable computer. Cellular and PCS subscribers view the performance of their service on the basis of the network coverage or the call quality. The drive-test tool uses a phone to re-create the problems that a subscriber is experiencing. For example, if a subscribers call is dropped while operating in a moving vehicle in a particular location, the drive-test should be able to duplicate this problem. Other examples of subscriber complaints include blocked calls (access failures), poor voice quality, and lack of significant coverage. The drive-test system makes these measurements, stores the data in the computer database, and stamps the data as a function of time and location. Frame erasure rate (FER) is a phone measurement that provides an indication of link quality. Several types of drive-test systems are availablephonebased, receiver-based and combination phone- and receiverbased. Figure 3 shows a combination phone- and receiverbased drive-test system.
The drive-test system is placed in a vehicle and driven throughout the wireless service providers network coverage area. Refer to Figure 4.
Figure 3. Typical combination phone- and receiver-based drive test collection tool. A GPS receiver and antenna, and a laptop PC, are also required.
To understand how the pilot signal works, it is necessary to understand short codes. The last step in generating the CDMA signal in the base station is modulation of the data by a pseudo-random sequence called a short code. The short code is identical for all base stations, with one exception. Each base station has a different phase-delayed version of the same short code. This is usually represented as a time shift measured in chips. (A chip is approximately 0.8 microseconds). This time offset in the short code is what uniquely identifies each base station. The time offset essentially acts as a color code. The pilot channel (Walsh code 0) is an unmodified version of the short code just described. Therefore, it is identical for every base station, with the exception of the timing of its short code generator. It is this pilot channel timing offset that is used by a mobile phone to identify a particular base station, distinguish it from the others, and thereby communicate with the proper base station. The pilot channel timing offset is expressed as a PN offset referenced to absolute time. The short code sequence repeats every 2 seconds, which is the period of the GPS even-second clock. Therefore, PN 0 aligns with the beginning of the short code period, exactly on the GPS evensecond clock. PN 1 is advanced in timing by 64 chips. PN 2 is 128 chips higher than PN 0, and so on. PN stands for pseudo noise, a term that has its origins in spread spectrum theory. There are up to 512 unique PN offsets available to network operators, although only a subset is typically used. The set of PNs is further confined to integer multiples of a PN value known as the PN increment. Common PN increments used by wireless service providers are 3, 4 or 6. A PN increment of 3 means that PN 0, PN 3, PN 6, PN 9, for example, may be assigned to base stations or base station sectors in the network. Each CDMA operator selects a value of PN increment based primarily on its base station density. A PN increment of 3 provides more PN offsets than a PN increment of 6, since the total number is computed by dividing 512 by the PN increment. PN values may be reused in the same network, provided the base stations are located at a significant distance from one another and their antennas are pointed away from each other. It is the pilot channel that is measured by the digital receiver-based drive-test system. To identify a base station, the receiver measures the timing offset of the short code comprising the pilot channel. The receiver obtains its precise timing from the pulse-per-second reference signal available on standard GPS receivers. Numerous examples of base station pilot displays will be shown later when the drive-test measurements are described. Phones can also measure pilot signals. However, they depend on the network to tell them which pilots to measure. (A description of neighbor lists will be given later.)
T P
F
Figure 5. CDMA spectrum occupies 1.25-MHz bandwidth and consists of multiple code-domain channels, rather than individual narrowband frequency channels that were used in analog FM systems.
Each channel in a CDMA signal is spread by one of 64 orthogonal codes called Walsh codes, as shown in Figure 6. The Walsh codes spread the signal over a bandwidth range of approximately 1.25 MHz. Most of the Walsh codes are used for voice traffic channels. The other codes are dedicated to pilot, paging and sync channels. The paging channels (Walsh codes 1 through 7) are used by the base station to alert the phone. In most networks, only Walsh code 1 is used for paging, making codes 2 through 7 available for traffic use. The sync channel (Walsh code 32) is used to provide timing to the phone. Refer to figure 6.
Code domain power
Pilot
ng raffic T Pagi
Sync
Traff
ic
1-7
8-31
32
33 - 63
Walsh code
Figure 6. Walsh codes comprising CDMA signal
Ec and Io definitions
Depending on whether a phone or a receiver is used to perform pilot scanning, the pilot displays are usually measured in units of Ec, Io, or Ec/Io. Ec is the signal strength measurement of the pilot expressed in dBm units. For example, the pilot signal may have an Ec value of -50 dBm, -80 dBm, or -100 dBm, depending on where the drive-test equipment is located with respect to the base station transmitting that pilot signal. Figure 9 illustrates that each base station Ec is just a small portion of the total power in the 1.25 MHz bandwidth channel. Io is a measure of the total power (dBm) within the 1.25 MHz bandwidth channel. It includes the power of all 64 Walsh codes from each base station and any noise or interference that may reside in the 1.25 MHz channel. Practically speaking, Ec/Io is the power in an individual base station pilot divided by the total power in the 1.25 MHz channel, expressed in dB. It provides a useful ratio to compare the power levels of the base stations with respect to one another. (The more technical definition of Ec/Io is the ratio of energy per chip to the interference power spectral density. It is equivalent to thinking of these termsEc and Ioas the ratio of powers.)
T
T
Ec of base station 1
Power from BS 1 pilot channel
Figure 8 is a depiction of the four closest base stations that correspond to the four pilot signals shown in Figure 7. The diagram is simplified for illustration purposes and does not include the sectorization normally present at each base station. Note also that it is not always the closest base station that produces the highest received pilot signal strength. Different propagation conditions often exist that allow distant signals to be received at higher levels, presenting difficult-to-solve problems. It will be shown later that the receiver-based drive-test tool helps diagnose these problems.
1.25 MHz
Figure 9. CDMA composite signal consisting of all the Walsh codes of each base station.
Pilot signals can be displayed by drive-test solutions in several ways, depending on whether a network-independent receiver or a test mobile phone performs the measurements. The pilot display shown in Figure 7 originated from a receiver. The receiver measures all the pilots, completely independent of any network instructions. In contrast, a phone-based drive-test measurement display will look somewhat different. To better understand the contributions that the phone and receiver each provide, the next two sections of this document are split between phone-based and receiver-based drive-test measurements. The remainder of the document describes the benefits of combining the phone and receiver into an integrated drive-test solution.
135 159
111
303
Figure 8. Wireless network consisting of multiple base stations.
As Figure 11 illustrates, the phone is constantly in communication with many base stations. Active pilots represent those base stations that are currently involved in transmitting and receiving a "live" call. Candidate pilots indicate those base stations that are transitioning into or out of the active set, depending on whether their power levels rise above or fall below a network-defined threshold (Tadd or Tdrop). The neighbor pilot set includes a list of base stations that are potential choices for the active set. The wireless service providers network planning staff programs the network to download the neighbor list to the mobile phone. It usually represents the nearby base stations that are servicing the mobile phone. Consequently, the neighbor list is constantly changing as the mobile moves through the network coverage area. Each base station sector has a unique neighbor list. When a call is in the hand-off process from one cell to another (or one sector to another on the same cell), the phones neighbor list is comprised of the neighbors associated with each sector involved in the hand-off.
Remainder Set
Candidate set
PN 132
Figure 10. The phone-based drive-test tool with laptop PC, and GPS receiver with antenna.
Since a test mobile phone is dependent on the network, it displays the pilots that it is instructed to measure. To better understand how a phone measures base station pilot signals, refer to Figure 11. A phone categorizes base station pilots into three major sets: active, candidate and neighbor. All other pilots are part of a fourth group called the remainder set. As described later, the receiver-based drive-test tool measures all pilots, including those in the remainder set, which are often the source of interference.
Figure 11. Active, candidate, and neighbor pilot set lists are constantly being updated.
To represent the three pilot sets, the phone-based drive system displays the pilot categories in colorred for active, yellow for candidate and blue for neighbor. Since this document does not use color, the categories are indicated with titles above each pilot set in Figure 12. The number inside each of the active pilots indicates which phone rake receiver finger (or correlator) is currently demodulating the active phone call. Most CDMA phones have three rake fingers for use in soft handoff or for holding calls in low signal environments by using different multipath signals.
While phone-based tools tell the engineer what the symptom of the problem is, they often do not tell why the problem occurred. For example, why did a dropped call occur at a specific location? To better understand the cause of air-interface network problems, a receiver-based drive-test tool was developed by Agilent Technologies. Since the network controls phone-based tools, they lack the independence to make measurements in an unconstrained manner. The phones timing is initially derived from the network using the base station sync channel (Walsh code 32). Any timing errors in the base station will cause subsequent errors in the phone. In addition, the network tells the phone which base station pilots to scan, based on the neighbor list that is sent to the phone over-the-air from the base station. Base stations that are not included in the neighbor list may never be measured by the phone, although they can cause major interference, resulting in dropped calls. In contrast, receiver-based drive-test tools are completely independent of the network. Thus, they have the capability to measure all pilots (up to 512) independent of any neighbor lists. In addition, they can perform absolute timing measurements, which are the cause of many network problems.
Figure 12. Phone-based drive-test measurement shows active, candidate, and neighbor pilots.
Phone-based tools are necessary for assessing the performance of the wireless network with call statistics such as blocked and dropped calls as a function of the users location. Figure 13 shows an example summary of these statistics.
Figure 13: Phone-based drive-test system measures statistics like dropped and blocked calls.
Figure 14. In a receiver-based drive-test system, the GPS receiver provides one pulse-per-second timing and location information.
It is important to remember that the receiver derives its timing from the GPS one pulse-per-second signal. The receivers timing is aligned with the even-second clock of GPS, which is the same timing signal that CDMA base stations use. To correctly measure the pilots, the receiver requires knowledge of the PN increment for the particular network. The PN increment is the spacing of the pilot signals within a given service providers network. A PN increment of 3 means that PN0, PN3, PN6, PN9, can be used by a provider. The user must enter this PN increment value into the receiver-based drive tool software.
Figure 16. Properly optimized network. Receiver display indicates that pilot pollution is not present. Both the All Pilots and Top N displays are shown.
Figure 17. Poorly optimized network. Receiver display indicates that pilot pollution is present, since more than three significant pilots are present.
10
Figure 19. Delay spread measurement, using the receiver-based system, helps to characterize multipath.
11
CW measurements
During the early life cycle of a wireless network, it is necessary to evaluate prospective cell site locations to see if construction of the cell site will provide adequate coverage. To perform this evaluation, a signal generator with a power amplifier is used to transmit CW (continuous wave) signals from the potential cell site. Often the signal generator and antenna are positioned to the approximate elevation of the proposed antennas using a forklift or crane. Then a receiver, with antenna and accompanying collection software, is driven around in a van along the roads in the proposed cell site coverage area. This receiver is usually a dedicated instrument only capable of measuring CW signals. The collected data is exported to a mapping software package and the CW coverage results are evaluated. Using a receiver-based drive-test system, both CW and CDMA drive-test measurements can be performed (simultaneously, if desired) using the same hardware. A single compact receiver reduces costs when compared to other systems that require separate receivers for CW and CDMA measurements. Using a narrow, 30-kHz analog filter and numerous choices of DSP filtering, the receiver-based system records CW power as a function of the users location. CW power is the power at the peak of the transmitted signal. (This is equivalent to placing a marker on a spectrum analyzer trace.) CW power is different than channel power, which is the integrated power in a defined channel bandwidth.
Figure 21. The receiverbased drive-test system with built-in spectrum analyzer capability. A CDMA carrier (with marker) and several GSM signals are shown.
Figure 20. CW power measurements using the receiver-based solution are useful for the site evaluation stage of the wireless network life cycle. Channel power measurements are also available.
12
Section 6: Conclusion
We have demonstrated how CDMA drive-test systems can help wireless service providers and network equipment manufacturers quickly optimize their CDMA networks. Based on an integrated receiver and phone approach, the solutions benefit the optimization engineer by telling "what" the problem is and why it happened. This reduces the resources required and minimizes the time needed to optimize networks, resulting in financial savings to the wireless company.
Collection Software
Post-processing Software
Miss neigh ing bor
Figure 22. Integrated drive-test solution with RF receiver and phone quickly identifies "missing neighbor" condition. Alarms and post-processing software simplify the identification of wireless network problems.
13
For specific examples of how the Agilent Technologies drive-test solutions are used to solve optimization problems:
CDMA Drive-Test Product Note (literature number 5968-5554E) Spectrum and Power Measurements Using the Agilent CDMA, TDMA and GSM Drive-Test System Product Note (literature number 5968-8598E)
Web-based information:
Visit our website at www.agilent.com/find/wireless
14
15
Agilent Technologies Test and Measurement Support, Services, and Assistance Agilent Technologies aims to maximize the value you receive, while minimizing your risk and problems. We strive to ensure that you get the test and measurement capabilities you paid for and obtain the support you need. Our extensive support resources and services can help you choose the right Agilent products for your applications and apply them successfully. Every instrument and system we sell has a global warranty. Support is available for at least five years beyond the production life of the product. Two concepts underlay Agilent's overall support policy: Our Promise and Your Advantage. Our Promise Our Promise means your Agilent test and measurement equipment will meet its advertised performance and functionality. When you are choosing new equipment, we will help you with product information, including realistic performance specifications and practical recommendations from experienced test engineers. When you use Agilent equipment, we can verify that it works properly, help with product operation, and provide basic measurement assistance for the use of specified capabilities, at no extra cost upon request. Many self-help tools are available. Your Advantage Your Advantage means that Agilent offers a wide range of additional expert test and measurement services, which you can purchase according to your unique technical and business needs. Solve problems efficiently and gain a competitive edge by contacting us for calibration, extra-cost upgrades, out-ofwarranty repairs, and on-site education and training, as well as design, system integration, project management, and other professional services. Experienced Agilent engineers and technicians worldwide can help you maximize your productivity, optimize the return on investment of your Agilent instruments and systems, and obtain dependable measurement accuracy for the life of those products.
By Internet, phone, or fax, get assistance with all your test and measurement needs. Online assistance: www.agilent.com/find/assist Phone or Fax United States: (tel) 1 800 452 4844 Canada: (tel) 1 877 894 4414 (fax) (905) 206 4120 Europe: (tel) (31 20) 547 2000 Japan: (tel) (81) 426 56 7832 (fax) (81) 426 56 7840 Latin America: (tel) (305) 267 4245 (fax) (305) 267 4286 Australia: (tel) 1 800 629 485 (fax) (61 3) 9272 0749 New Zealand: (tel) 0 800 738 378 (fax) 64 4 495 8950 Asia Pacific: (tel) (852) 3197 7777 (fax) (852) 2506 9284
Product specifications and descriptions in this document subject to change without notice. Copyright 2000 Agilent Technologies Printed in USA 04/2000 5968-9916E
16