2013 - KOF Isotop Effect and Carbocation
2013 - KOF Isotop Effect and Carbocation
2013 - KOF Isotop Effect and Carbocation
TestingaMechanism: TestingaMechanism:
KineticIsotopeEffects KineticIsotopeEffects
i ff i ff Primary Isotope Effect Primary Isotope Effect - - rate change due to rate change due to
isotopic substitution at a site of bond breaking isotopic substitution at a site of bond breaking
or bond making in the rate determining step of or bond making in the rate determining step of
a mechanism. a mechanism.
Secondary Isotope Effect Secondary Isotope Effect -- rate change due to rate change due to
i t i b tit ti t th th it f b d i t i b tit ti t th th it f b d isotopic substitution at other than a site of bond isotopic substitution at other than a site of bond
breaking or bond making in the rate breaking or bond making in the rate
determining step of a mechanism. determining step of a mechanism.
PrimaryKineticIsotope
Effect:Typical Values
Nuclide k
light heavy
k
(at 25
o
C)
C H/C D 6 8 C-H/C-D 6 - 8
C-H/C-T 15 - 16
C
12
/
13
C 1.04
C
12
/
C
14
1.07
14 15
N/ N 103 N/ N 1.03
16
O/
18
O 1.02
32
S/
34
S
1.01
35
Cl/
37
Cl 1.01
2
EXAMPLES OF
KINETIC ISOTOPE EFFECTS
Consider thefollowing dehydrohalogenation reactions:
CaseI:
CH
3
CH
2
CH
2
Br
NaOC
2
H
5
C
2
H
5
OH
C CH
2
H
3
C
H
H C
k k
H D
/ k k
H D
/
= 6.7
1
o
KIE f C H/C D
CH
3
CD
2
CH
2
Br
NaOC
2
H
5
C
2
H
5
OH
C CH
2
H
3
C
D
CaseII:
CH
3
CH
2
C
CH
3
CH
3
Br
H
2
O
C C
CH
3
CH
3
H
3
C
H
H
2
O
C C
CH
3
CH
3
H
3
C
D
C
CH
3
CH
3
Br CH
3
CD
2
k k
H D
/ k k
H D
/ = 1.4
1
o
KIE for C-H/C-D
o
KIE for C-H/C-D 2
3
Rationale:
Transition Statefor CaseI (E-2)
H (D)
(D)
C
2
H
5
O
H
H
Br
H
3
C
H
C
C
-
-
Transition Statefor CaseII (E-1)
H (D)
(D)
-
Br
H
3
C
H
C
C
CH
3
CH
3
rds
+
H (D)
(D)
H
3
C
H
C
C
CH
3
CH
3
+
Br
-
MoreExamplesofKineticIsotope MoreExamplesofKineticIsotope
Effects Effects
Consider the following decomposition of an azo compound:
R N N R R N N R 2 R + N
2
k k
N N
14 15 = 1.02
Rationale: Although the above rate enhancement is small in absolute terms,
for the nitrogen nuclides indicated, the enhancement is indicative
of a primary kinetic isotope effect.
Consider the nitration of benzene shown below:
C
6
H
6
HNO
3
/H
2
SO
4
C
6
H
5
NO
2
rate
H
HNO /H SO
C
6
D
6
HNO
3
/H
2
SO
4
C
6
D
5
NO
2
rate
D
Observation: rate
H
rate
D
=
~
Conclusion to be drawn: A C-H (C-D) bond is not being broken in the
rate determining step of electrophilic aromatic
nitration.
3
INTERMEDIETKARBOKATION
StrukturC
+
:hibridisasi
6
=>
4
CONTOHC
+
:
1. Metil karbokation
2 t b til k b k ti 2. t-butil karbokation
3. Benzil kation
4. Alil kation
Contoh lain : tulis struktur resonansinya
7
=>
1. CH
3
O C
+
(CH
3
)
2
1. Ph
2
N C
+
- (Ph)
2
CH
2 CH
2
etc
+
+
BENZYL
BENZYL AND ALLYL CARBOCATIONS BENZYL AND ALLYL CARBOCATIONS
RESONANCE
STABILIZATION
CH
2 CH
2
etc
+
+
etc
CH
2 CH
2
ALLYL
+ +
O H
3
C CH
2
+
(benzylic) (allylic)
Systems that are similar in form to benzyl and allyl are called benzylic and allylic.
isoelectronic
with allylic
5
SenyawaVinilandFenil
Vinyl and Phenyl compounds are completely inert in both y y y
S
N
1 and S
N
2 reactions!!
C
CH
2
H
Cl
vinyl
phenyl
Cl
Pembentukan C
+
:dr sistem tdk jenuh
Tulislah persamaan reaksi :
1. Sikloheksena dan HCl
2. 2-metilpropena dan H
2
O/H
+
10
=>
2
3. 2-metilpropena dan HOCl
4. 2-metil2-butena dan HBr
5. Styrena dan HBr
6. Me
2
N
+
--CH=CH
2
+HI ?
6
tgl 25senin :jam12.3014.10
Rabu tgl 27:12.3014.10
atau atau
kamis tgl 28:12.3014.10
1. Di danTri-arilmetil kation
2. Aromatik kation
11
=>
3. 2-metilpropena dan HOCl
4. 2-metil2-butena dan HBr
5. Styrena dan HBr
6. Me
2
N
+
--CH=CH
2
+HI ?