Clinical and Histological Evaluation of An Analogue of Palmitoylethanolamide, PLR 120 (Comicronized Palmidrol INN) in Cats With Eosin
Clinical and Histological Evaluation of An Analogue of Palmitoylethanolamide, PLR 120 (Comicronized Palmidrol INN) in Cats With Eosin
Clinical and Histological Evaluation of An Analogue of Palmitoylethanolamide, PLR 120 (Comicronized Palmidrol INN) in Cats With Eosin
Abstract Fifteen cats with eosinophilic granuloma or eosinophilic plaque were given PLR 120 at the dosage
of 10 mg kg71 twice daily for one month. PLR-120 down-modulates mast cell degranulation via a receptormediated mechanism. No other drugs were permitted and cats were kept free of parasites throughout the
study. A clinical evaluation and skin biopsies were performed before and after the treatment. Clinical
improvement was assessed at 15 and 30 days. Mast cell numbers were counted and their granular content was
assessed by densitometric analysis on toluidine blue-stained sections before and after the treatment. Ten of 15
(67%) cats showed clinical improvement of signs and lesions. There was no signicant dierence between mast
cell numbers in skin biopsies taken before and after the trial, whereas the number of granules was signicantly
increased (P 5 0.009). This pilot study suggests that PLR-120 might be a useful drug for the treatment of
eosinophilic granuloma and eosinophilic plaque.
Ahed
Bhed
Ched
Dhed
Ref marker
Fig marker
Table
marker
Ref end
Keywords: ALIAmides, cats, eosinophilic granuloma, eosinophilic plaque, mast cells, Palmidrol, PLR-120,
skin disease.
Ref start
INTRODUCTION
The eosinophilic plaque (EP) and the eosinophilic
granuloma (EG) are cutaneous lesions commonly
seen in cats and are usually considered possible
reaction patterns to underlying allergic skin diseases
(ea bite allergy, atopic dermatitis, food hypersensitivity, mosquito bite dermatitis).16 EP is a wellcircumscribed area of erosion and exudation, with
marked erythema and self-induced alopecia. Lesions
may appear anywhere in the body; the inguinal,
perianal and medial thigh regions are most commonly involved.3 EG occurs mainly as a raised,
alopecic, erythematous area, usually along the caudal
aspect of the rear limbs.5,7 Alternatively, the lesions
may appear in the oral cavity, chin and extremities.3
The histopathological features of EP include a
supercial and deep eosinophilic, mastocytic diuse
inltrate with epidermal hyperplasia, spongiosis and
ulceration.8 EG is characterized histologically by a
nodular to diuse granulomatous dermatitis, with
areas of collagenolysis surrounded by macrophages,
giant cells, eosinophils and mast cells under an intact
epidermis.8 Although the clinical appearance and
aetiology may vary, these lesions are characterized
Correspondence: Dr Chiara Noli, Studio Dermatologico Veterinario, Via Sismondi 62, 20133 Milano, Italy. E-mail: [email protected]
# 2001 Blackwell Science Ltd
F. Scarampella et al.
A local feedback mechanism called ALIA (autacoid local injury antagonism) that down-regulates
mast cell degranulation during damaging processes
has been recently identied.21,22 In pathological
conditions, tissue accumulation of N-acylethanolamine-related lipid amides,23,24 such as palmitoylethanolamide, seems to play a local autacoid role in
down-modulating mast cell degranulation by exerting
local anti-inammatory eects.21,25 Palmitoylethanolamide and its derivatives bind peripheral cannabinoid receptors (CB2) present on mast cells,26 which in
turn down-regulate mast cell degranulation. The
therapeutic implications of the existence of this
specic binding mechanism include the development
of innovative anti-inammatory drugs specically
targeted to control mast cell activation and inammatory tissue injury (ALIAmides).
The aim of the present pilot study was to assess
clinically and histologically the pharmacological
eect of the oral pharmaceutical formulation of an
analogue of palmitoylethanolamide called PLR-120
(comicronized Palmidrol INN, Innovet, Milan, Italy)
in cats with EG and EP.
MATERIALS AND METHODS
Animals
Seventeen privately owned European shorthaired cats
were included in the study (Table 1). The cats were
referred to the investigators by colleagues specically
for this study. All owners were previously informed
and agreed with its aims and procedures. The cats
were four intact females, two intact males, ve spayed
females and six castrated males. The age of the cats
ranged from 7 to 123 months (mean, 34 months).
Clinical lesions compatible with EP and EG were
Table 1. Signalment and clinical and histological diagnosis of the
15 cats included in the study. Cats nos. 2 (an intact male with EP)
and 11 (a castrated male with EG) were excluded because they
improved between day T715 and day T0
Case no. Age (mo)
Sex
Clinical
diagnosis
Histological
diagnosis
1
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
12
13
14
15
16
17
mc
fc
mc
f
f
f
f
mc
fc
fc
mc
fc
m
mc
fc
EG
EP
EP
EP
EG
EG
EG
EG
EP
EG
EP
EP
EG
EP
EG
ED
ED
EP
EP
EG
EG
ED
EG
ED
EG
EP
EP
EG
EP
EP
123
21
48
24
10
11
11
10
48
22
24
50
7
120
12
31
Statistical analysis
Statistical analyses were performed with the programme Statistica for Windows 5.1, 1997 edition
(Statsoft Inc, Tuls, OK, USA). Student's t-test was
used to determine dierences in pre-treatment scores
of cats with EG and those with EP. Analysis of
covariance (ANCOVA) for repeated measures was used
to determine the dierence trend between the two
groups with time. Mast cell counts were analysed by
means of Student's t-test. A Shapiro-Wilk test
conrmed a normal distribution of the data. Densitometric data were analysed by means Student's t-test.
To determine the relationship of clinical improvement and densitometric response, a linear Pearson's
correlation test was used.37
RESULTS
Clinical evaluation
Improvement of signs and improvement of lesions
were evaluated separately for all animals (Table 2).
Furthermore, a global improvement comprising signs
and lesions was also calculated. The are results
divided by groups and are presented below.
Evaluation of signs (erythema, pruritus and alopecia)
in all animals. Fourteen of 15 cats were evaluated,
since one cat with granuloma showed no erythema,
pruritus or alopecia (free of any sign). Five of the 14
cats (35.7%) showed improvement after 15 days of
therapy and nine of the 14 cats (64.3%) had improved
after 30 days.
Evaluation of lesions (granuloma or plaque) in all
animals. Eight of 15 cats (53.3%) showed improvement in extension and severity of lesions already
after 15 days of therapy, and 10 of 15 (66.7%) had
improved after 30 days (three were judged completely cured).
Global improvement. When the results of the aforementioned evaluations were considered together,
global improvement of all cats was 46.7% after 15
days (seven of 15 cats) and 66.7% after 30 days (10 of
15 cats).
As the initial score was lower in cats with EG than
in those with EP (Fig. 2), the two groups were
compared using Student's t-test. A signicant dierence was observed in pre-treatment scores (T0)
(P 5 0.01). It was thus decided to also evaluate the
improvement separately according to the clinical
diagnosis (EG vs. EP).
Evaluation of signs and lesions in cats with EP
(n = 7). Three out of seven cats with EP (42.9%)
showed improvement of signs and lesions and 3 of the
lesions (42.9%) after 30 days of therapy.
# 2001 Blackwell Science Ltd, Veterinary Dermatology, 12, 2939
F. Scarampella et al.
Figure
1. Case
number
3:
densitometric image of mast cells
before (a) and after (b) treatment
with PLR-120 (black and white
images from toluidine blue-stained
sections have been inverted). Arrow
indicates mast cells.
Table 2. Evaluation scores of signs and lesions before, during and after treatment
No.
T0
Signs
T15
T30
T0
Lesions
T15
T30
T30
1
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
12
13
14
15
16
17
24
41
62
45
9
12
15
6
27
18
21
29
24
28
0
12
37
52
48
6
9
7.5
6
16.5
9
21
14.5
24
28
0
5.5
21.5
48
48
3
4.5
3.75
1.5
11.25
4.5
21
14
24
14
0
6
20
36
23
6
3
6
9
5
9
11
18
6
12
6
3
16
27
23
0
1.5
3
4.5
3
4.5
10
9
6
12
3
1.5
12
23
23
0
0.75
0
2.25
1
2.25
9
4.5
6
6
0
30
61
98
71
15
15
21
21
32
27
32
47
30
40
6
7
33.5
71
71
3
5.25
3.75
3.75
12.25
6.75
30
18.5
30
20
0
15
53
79
71
6
10.5
10.5
10.5
19.5
13.5
31
23.5
30
40
3
33
120
T0
100
T15
80
T30
60
40
20
0
1
6
7
8
9
12
15
17
3
4
5
10
13
14
16
[_______Eosinophilic Granuloma___________________] [____________Eosinophilic Plaque___________]
Figure 2. Histogram of the same data as Table 2, with cases according to clinical diagnosis.
1
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
12
13
14
15
16
17
Mean
Standard deviation
503.0
170.3
218.5
331.5
349.8
182.5
367.7
304.1
454.6
508.7
441.6
314.1
159.6
640.7
1013.5
397,35
219,90
314.2
454.0
544.2
183.0
198.4
294.0
269.0
345.2
112.0
519.8
465.4
282.7
459.5
265.9
1483.0
412,69
322,66
F. Scarampella et al.
Table 4. Densitometric evaluation of toluidine blue-stained mast cells before and after treatment
2 Case no.
Basal mean
Basal SD
Final mean
Final SD
Valid counts
1
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
12
13
14
15
16
17
Total
67540.00
69287.23
73102.05
89704.55
62498.76
64608.24
84981.80
75554.62
58257.29
62330.95
71007.14
58684.95
72403.19
80970.91
66335.09
70484.45
12576.83
17738.15
18663.66
18572.97
13633.22
16952.60
32780.71
17892.78
10862.72
18289.67
15792.77
17378.43
12965.56
12641.58
11567.36
9284.77
103565.2
79397.1
104514.3
94274.1
73047.1
73795.7
69198.5
86321.8
63356.5
55755.7
71253.9
78195.4
77086.2
97573.2
99648.3
81798.87*
43690.29
20282.70
26118.83
24659.65
10089.40
19603.63
18135.27
19661.52
22512.58
13606.97
16193.18
9325.46
19831.12
14440.14
25868.73
15126.19
21
21
21
20
21
21
20
21
21
21
21
21
21
21
21
313
*P = 0.009
Basal mean
Final mean
Density
120000
100000
80000
60000
40000
20000
0
1 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 12 13 14 15 16 17 Total
Cases
Figure 3. Histogram of densitometric evaluation of toluidine blue-stained mast cells before and after treatment (same data as in Table 4).
35
F. Scarampella et al.
REFERENCES
1. McDougal, B.J. Allergy testing and hyposensitization
for three common feline dermatoses. Modern
Veterinary Practice 1986; 67: 62933.
2. Chalmers, S., Medleau, L. Feline allergic dermatoses:
diagnosis and treatment. Veterinary Medicine 1989; 4:
399405.
3. Power, H.T., Ihrke, P.J. Selected feline eosinophilic
skin diseases. Veterinary Clinics of North America:
Small Animal Practice 1995; 25: 83350.
4. Mason, K., Evans, A.G. Mosquito bite caused
eosinophilic dermatitis in cats. Journal of the
American Veterinary Medical Association 1991; 198:
20868.
5. Nagata, M., Ishida, T. Cutaneous reactivity to
mosquito bites and its antigens in cats. Veterinary
Dermatology 1997; 8: 1926.
6. Rosenkrantz, W.S. Feline eosinophilic granuloma
complex. In: Grin, C.E., Kwochka, K.W.,
MacDonald,
J.M.
eds.
Current
Veterinary
Dermatology. 1st edn. St. Louis: Mosby Year Book,
1993: 31924.
7. Scott, D.W. Observations on the eosinophilic
granuloma complex of cats. Journal of the American
Animal Hospital Association 1975; 11: 26170.
8. Yager, J.A., Wilcock, B.P. Color Atlas and Text of
Surgical Pathology of the Dog and Cat. London: Wolfe
PublishingMosby Year Book Europe, 1994: 1469.
9. Scott, D.W. Epidermal mast cells in the cat. Veterinary
Dermatology 1990; 1: 659.
10. Scott, D.W. Feline dermatology 190078: a
monograph. Journal of the American Animal Hospital
Association 1980; 16: 331459.
11. Gordon, J.R., Burd, P.R., Galli, S.J. Mast cells as a
source of multifunctional cytokines. Immunology
Today 1990; 11: 45864.
12. Galli, S.J. New concepts about the mast cell. New
England Journal of Medicine. 1993; 328: 25765.
13. Galli, S.J., Costa, J.J. Mast cell-leukocyte cytokine
cascades in allergic inammation. Allergy 1995; 50:
85162.
32.
33.
34.
35.
36.
37.
38.
39.
40.
41.
42.
43.
44.
45.
46.
47.
48.
37
F. Scarampella et al.
59.
60.
61.
62.
63.
64.
65.
66.
67.
68.
69.
70.
Resume Quinze chats presentant un granulome eosinophilique ou une plaque eosinophilique ont ete traites
avec le PLR 120 a la dose de 10 mg kg1 deux fois par jour pendant un mois. Le PLR-120 diminue la
degranulation mastocytaire par l'intermediaire d'une action sur les recepteurs. Aucun autre traitement n'etait
autorise et les chats etaient traites contre les parasites pendant toute l'etude. Une evaluation clinique, et des
biopsies cutanees, etaient realisees avant et apres le traitement. L'amelioration clinique etait evaluee apres 15
et 30 jours. Les mastocytes etaient comptes, et les granulations etaient evaluees par une analyse
densitometrique sur des sections colorees au bleu de toluidine, avant et apres le traitement. Dix des 15
chats (67%) ont presente une amelioration clinique et lesionnelle. Il n'a ete observee aucune dierence
signicative pour le nombre de mastocytes avant et apres le traitement, bien que le nombre de granulations ait
statistiquement augmente (P 5 0.009). Cette etude preliminaire suggere que le PLR-120 pourrait constituer
une molecule interessante dans le traitement des granulomes eosinophiliques et des plaques eosinophiliques.
[Scarampella, F., Abramo, F. et Noli, C. Clinical and histological evaluation of an analogue of
palmitoylethanolamide, PLR 120 (comicronized Palmidrol INN) in cats with eosinophilic granuloma and
eosinophilic plaque: a pilot study. (Evaluation clinique et histologique d'un analogue du
palmitoylethanolamide, PLR 120 (comicronized Palmidrol INN) chez des chats presentant un granulome
eosinophilique ou une plaque eosinophilique: etude preliminaire.) Veterinary Dermatology 2001; 12: 2939.]
# 2001 Blackwell Science Ltd, Veterinary Dermatology, 12, 2939
39
Resumen Se administro PLR 120 a una dosicacion de 10 mg kg1 dos veces al d a durante un mes, a quince
gatos con granuloma eosinof lico o placa eosinof lica. El PLR-120 reduce la degranulacion de mastocitos
mediante un mecanismo mediado por receptor. No se permitieron otros farmacos y los gatos fueron
mantenidos libres de parasitos durante todo el estudio. Se realizo una evaluacion cl nica y biopsias cutaneas
antes y despues del tratamiento. La mejor a cl nica se evaluo a los 15 y 30 d as. Se conto el numero de
mastocitos y su contenido en granulos fue evaluado por analisis densitometrico en secciones tenidas con azul
de toluidina antes y despues del tratamiento. Diez de 15 (67%) gatos mostraron mejor a cl nica de los
s ntomas y de las lesiones. No se produjo una diferencia signicativa entre el numero de mastocitos en biopsias
cutaneas tomadas antes y despues de la prueba, mientras que el numero de granulos se vio signicativamente
incrementado (P 5 0.009). Este estudio piloto sugiere que el PLR-120 podr a ser un farmaco util para el
tratamiento del granuloma eosinof lico y la placa eosinof lica. [Scarampella, F., Abramo, F. y Noli, C.
Clinical and histological evaluation of an analogue of palmitoylethanolamide, PLR 120 (comicronized
Palmidrol INN) in cats with eosinophilic granuloma and eosinophilic plaque: a pilot study. (Evaluacion
cl nica e histologica de un analogo de la palmitoiletanolamida, PLR 120 (Palmidrol INN comicronizado) en
gatos con granuloma eosinof lico y placa eosinof lica: un estudio piloto.) Veterinary Dermatology 2001; 12:
2939.]
Zusammenfassung Funfzehn Katzen mit eosinophilem Granulom oder eosinophilen Plaques wurde PLR 120
in einer Dosierung von 10 mg kg1 zweimal taglich fur einen Monat gegeben. PLR-120 vermindert
Mastzellendegranulation durch einen Rezeptor-vermittelten Mechanismus. Andere Medikamente wurden
nicht erlaubt und die Katzen wurden wahrend der Studie von Parasiten freigehalten. Klinische Bewertung
sowie Entnahme von Hautbiopsien erfolgten vor und nach der Behandlung. Eine klinische Besserung wurde
nach 15 und 30 Tagen bewertet. Vor und nach der Behandlung wurde die Anzahl von Mastzellen bestimmt
und Mastzellengranula durch densimetrische Analyse von mit Toluidinblau gefarbten Schnitten bewertet.
Zehn von 15 Katzen (67%) zeigten klinische Besserung der Symptome und Lasionen. Ein signikanter
Unterschied in der Anzahl der Mastzellen vor und nach der Behandlung konnte nicht festgestellt werden,
wahrend die Granula-Anzahl sich erheblich erhohte (P 5 0.009). Diese Pilotstudie deutet darauf hin, da
PLR-120 fur die Behandlung des eosinophilen Granuloms und der eosinophilen Plaques nutzlich sein konnte.
[Scarampella, F., Abramo, F. und Noli, C. Clinical and histological evaluation of an analogue of
palmitoylethanolamide, PLR 120 (comicronized Palmidrol INN) in cats with eosinophilic granuloma and
eosinophilic plaque: a pilot study. (Klinische und histologische Bewertung eines PalmitoylethanolamidAnalogs, PLR 120 (komikronisiertes Palmidrol INN) bei Katzen mit eosinophilem Granulom und
eosinophilen Plaques: Eine Pilotstudie.) Veterinary Dermatology 2001; 12: 2939.]