Selenium Level and Depressive Symptoms in A Rural Elderly Chinese Cohort
Selenium Level and Depressive Symptoms in A Rural Elderly Chinese Cohort
Selenium Level and Depressive Symptoms in A Rural Elderly Chinese Cohort
RESEARCH ARTICLE
Open Access
Abstract
Background: Selenium is considered a protective agent against free radicals through the maintenance of better
enzyme activity. The few studies examining the relationship between selenium and depression have yielded
inconsistent results and none of these studies considered the role of cognitive function in this context.
Methods: A cross-sectional evaluation of 1737 rural Chinese age 65 and over from two provinces in China was
conducted. Depressive symptoms were assessed using the Geriatric Depression Scale (GDS). Cognitive function was
assessed using various cognitive instruments. Selenium measures were obtained from nail samples. Other
information collected included demographic characteristics and medical history. Analysis of covariance models
were used to identify factors associated with GDS score.
Results: Higher selenium levels were associated with lower GDS scores adjusting for demographic and medical
conditions (p = 0.0321). However, the association between selenium and depressive symptoms was no longer
significant when cognitive function score was adjusted in the model (p = 0.2143).
Conclusions: Higher selenium level was associated with lower depressive symptoms without adjusting for
cognition in this cohort. However, after cognition was adjusted in the model the association between selenium and
depressive symptoms was no longer significant, suggesting that seleniums association with depressive symptoms
may be primarily through its association with cognitive function.
Background
Selenium is a trace element associated with the antioxidant enzyme glutathione peroxidase (GP-x) and is considered a protective agent against free radicals through
the maintenance of better enzyme activity. Several studies examining the relationship between selenium and depression have provided inconsistent results, with some
showing lower selenium levels associated with greater
risk of depression [1-4] while others showing no association [5]. It is interesting to observe that a beneficial effect of selenium supplementation was mostly seen when
a substantial number of participants had low dietary selenium levels and selenium supplementation in subjects
with already adequate selenium levels does not seem to
* Correspondence: [email protected]
1
Department of Biostatistics, Indiana University School of Medicine,
Indianapolis, IN, USA
9
Department of Biostatistics, Indiana University School of Medicine, 410 West
10th Street, Suite 3000, Indianapolis, IN 46202-2872, USA
Full list of author information is available at the end of the article
2012 Gao et al.; licensee BioMed Central Ltd. This is an Open Access article distributed under the terms of the Creative
Commons Attribution License (http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/2.0), which permits unrestricted use, distribution, and
reproduction in any medium, provided the original work is properly cited.
The rural elderly Chinese population represents an opportunity for examining the relationship between longterm selenium exposure and depressive symptoms. The
rural Chinese are stable with most living in the same village throughout their entire life and consuming locally
grown food. In addition, it is rare for them to take dietary supplements. Our group has previously reported on
the association between selenium and cognitive function
in this cohort. In this article, we investigate the association between selenium levels and depressive symptoms
and examine the role of cognitive function on the association between selenium and depression in the same
cohort.
Methods
Study population
A total of 2000 older adults were recruited for the Selenium and Cognitive Decline study, a longitudinal epidemiologic project funded by the National Institute of
Health examining the long-term impact of selenium on
cognitive function in rural elderly Chinese [8]. Two
counties from Sichuan Province in southwestern China
and two counties from Shandong Province in eastern
China were selected based on: rural areas with historically low in- and out-migration, wide range of selenium
levels but comparable trace elements otherwise, comparable age and gender proportions, and sufficient population to provide 500 elderly subjects per county. Sites
with known endemic diseases (including Keshan disease,
Kaschin-Beck disease, goiter and Cretinism, and fluorosis) were excluded from consideration.
For each village included in the study, a team of interviewers who were employees from provincial or county
offices of Chinese Center for Disease Control traveled to
the area, established a temporary headquarter and conducted a complete census of residents over age 65 in the
area. They enrolled eligible residents by going door-todoor, obtaining informed consent before conducting the
interview and collecting biological samples. There were
no refusals. However, a few subjects with hearing problems were not enrolled. The study was approved by Indiana University Institutional Review Board and the
Institute for Environmental Health and Related Safety,
Chinese Center for Disease Control and Prevention.
A second evaluation of this cohort was conducted approximately two and half years after the initial evaluation. In addition to cognitive assessment, the Geriatric
Depression Scale (GDS) was administered to all participants during the second evaluation.
Measure of depressive symptoms
Page 2 of 8
mild depression and scores of 21 or higher are considered severe depression [11]. The GDS was validated with
a psychiatric outpatient sample in a previous study in
Chinese age 60 or older [12]. Internal consistency was
high (alpha = 0.89), and the test-retest reliability was
0.85. The GDS also showed excellent criterion-related
validity (0.95) when compared to psychiatrist diagnosis,
and substantial concurrent validity (0.96) when compared with the Center for Epidemiologic Studies Depression Scale (CES-D) [13]. Although the GDS is generally
self administered, because of low literacy rates in our cohort, the GDS was administered by trained interviewers
in face-to-face interviews.
Selenium measures
Nail samples from all study subjects were collected during the initial interview and stored in clean plastic bags
labeled with participant identification numbers. The
method of fluorometric determination of trace amount
of selenium with 2,3-diaminonaphthalene, described in
details elsewhere [14], was used to determine trace
amounts of selenium in nail samples. Quality control in
the laboratory was maintained by using certified reference materials and by inter-laboratory comparisons.
Quality control measures used for the laboratory analyses were described in details previously [8].
Cognitive assessment
Other information
Page 3 of 8
Mean
SD
p-value
<0.0001
Age group
65-74
1002
7.68
5.83
75-84
652
9.02
5.86
85+
83
9.38
5.55
Male
815
7.52
5.77
Female
922
8.92
5.87
Yes
676
7.05
5.73
No
1061
9.04
5.82
Gender
<0.0001
Marital status
Statistical analysis
Married
1016
7.65
5.71
Widowed
704
9.08
5.91
Other
17
11.47
8.18
With spouse
828
7.39
5.69
With children
585
8.85
5.58
Living alone
311
9.60
6.51
< 20.45
578
8.80
5.94
[20.45, 23.24)
577
8.38
6.02
23.24
582
7.62
5.57
Yes
697
7.59
5.73
No
1040
8.72
5.91
553
7.72
5.89
Results
The GDS was administered to 1737 participants. Mean
age in the cohort is 74.3 years (SD = 5.2), with 53.1 %
being women and 61.1 % never attended school. Mean
BMI was 22.3 (SD = 3.8). In Table 1, we present mean
GDS scores by participants characteristics. Age, gender,
schooling, marital status, living arrangement, BMI, alcohol, smoking, histories of stroke, heart attack, head injury, fractures and selenium levels were significantly
associated with GDS scores in each separate univariate
analysis. In Table 2, we present results of ANCOVA
models including significant factors associated with GDS
scores. Older age, living alone, lower BMI, history of
<0.0001*
Living arrangement#
<0.0001
Smoking
Current smoker
Former smoker
148
7.39
5.57
Non-smoker
1036
8.68
5.85
Yes
33
8.85
6.51
No
1704
8.25
5.85
0.0013
History of Cancer
0.5634
History of Parkinsons
Yes
36
8.67
6.04
No
1701
8.26
5.86
Yes
75
8.25
5.83
No
1662
8.67
6.64
0.6774
History of diabetes
0.5435
History of hypertension^
Yes
1029
8.36
5.83
No
708
8.13
5.91
45
10.20
6.97
0.4141
History of stroke#
Yes
0.0245
Page 4 of 8
1690
8.21
5.83
Yes
52
12.00
6.42
No
1685
8.15
5.81
Yes
66
11.42
6.44
No
1671
8.14
5.81
Yes
30
12.47
6.00
No
1707
8.19
5.83
Yes
291
8.51
5.69
No
1446
8.22
5.90
Low (<0.32)
561
8.83
5.64
582
8.16
5.79
High ( 0.47)
594
7.83
6.10
History of fracture
<0.0001
APOE e4 carriers
0.4360
0.0132
<0.0001
434
5.5
4.8
Q3 (50 % to 75 %)
434
7.7
5.7
Q2 (25 % to 50 %)
435
9.1
5.7
Q1 (0 to 25 %)
434
10.7
5.9
stroke, heart attack, head injury and fracture were associated with higher GDS scores, while having attended
school and ever drinking alcohol were associated with
Table 2 Results of analysis of covariance (ANCOVA) models between selenium levels and depressive symptoms
measured by GDS score adjusting for other factors (n = 1735)a
Without Cognitive Score
Variable
Estimate
Std Err
Age, years
0.10
0.03
1.40
1.37
Estimate
Std Err
0.0002
0.00
0.03
p-value
0.29
<0.0001
0.41
0.29
0.1681
0.35
0.0001
1.53
0.34
<0.0001
0.8688
0.97
0.29
0.0009
0.74
0.28
0.0093
0.12
0.04
0.0012
0.05
0.04
0.1470
History of stroke
1.96
0.86
0.0223
1.62
0.83
0.0500
3.31
0.80
<0.0001
3.55
0.77
<0.0001
2.74
0.72
0.0001
2.49
0.69
0.0003
History of fracture
3.00
1.05
0.0042
2.36
1.01
0.0190
1.66
0.77
0.0321
Selenium, g/g
Composite cognitive z-score
a
0.93
0.75
0.2143
0.38
0.20
<0.0001
Page 5 of 8
Table 3 Results of analysis of covariance (ANCOVA) models between selenium tertile groups and depressive symptoms
measured by GDS score adjusting for other factors (n = 1735)a
Without Cognitive Score
Variable
Estimate
Std Err
Age, years
0.10
0.03
1.39
1.35
Estimate
Std Err
0.0002
0.01
0.03
p-value
0.29
<0.0001
0.49
0.29
0.0932
0.36
0.0002
1.47
0.34
<0.0001
0.6132
1.03
0.29
0.0005
0.74
0.29
0.0095
0.12
0.04
0.0016
0.05
0.04
0.1311
History of stroke
1.98
0.86
0.0209
1.73
0.83
0.0364
3.34
0.80
<0.0001
3.59
0.78
<0.0001
2.67
0.72
0.0002
2.43
0.69
0.0005
History of fracture
2.92
1.05
0.0054
2.64
1.01
0.0091
0.96
0.35
0.0063
0.58
0.34
0.0876
0.42
0.34
0.2143
0.3712
reference
0.29
0.32
reference
4.61
0.42
<0.0001
2.64
0.39
<0.0001
Q2 (25 % to 50 %)
1.43
0.38
0.0001
reference
Q1 (0 to 25 %)
a
depressed subjects and 0.43 g/g (SD = 0.18) in the nondepressed subjects (p = 0.0006). Higher levels of selenium were significantly associated with lower probability
of depression (OR = 0.40, p = 0.0047) in the logistic model
Discussions
In this rural elderly Chinese cohort with an extensive
range of selenium distribution, we found that lower selenium levels were significantly associated with higher depressive symptoms adjusting for demographic and
medical conditions. However, when cognitive function
was included as an independent variable in the model,
the relationship between selenium and depressive symptoms was no longer significant, suggesting that seleniums
association with depressive symptoms is explained in part
by its association with cognitive function.
Several previous publications including observational
studies as well as clinical trials had examined the association between selenium levels and depression in various
populations. Two studies observed that low selenium diet
was associated with worsening mood [2,3]. In addition,
there were studies showing that selenium supplementation or high dietary selenium was associated with
improved mood with the most significant effect seen in
participants with low dietary selenium [1,3,26]. However,
a recent randomized trial of selenium supplementation
found that a 6-month selenium supplementation had no
significant effect on mood or quality of life in 501 participants age 60 to 74 from the United Kingdom [5]. The differences in study findings between the recent trial and
previous results may be explained by differences in dietary selenium levels of study participants. The UK trial
consisted of participants whose baseline selenium status
was higher than the UK national average [5]. It is known
that the brain has a unique feature in storing selenium
and it also receives priority supply of selenium in times
of deprivation [27]. Animal studies have shown that after
generations of selenium deficiency when selenium concentrations in liver, skeletal muscle and blood dropped to
below 1 % of normal level, the brain still retained 60 % of
selenium as in normal controls.[7] In addition, studies
have shown that plasma GP-x activity plateaus after sufficient selenium supply indicating that selenium supplementation in high selenium individuals may not provide
additional benefit [28]. It is perhaps not surprising that
the UK trial found no selenium effect as most of the participants would already have adequate selenium supply
at baseline and additional supplementation was not able
to increase mood measures. However, results of the UK
trial still left open the question of whether low selenium
is associated with depression in those with low dietary
selenium levels at baseline.
The review of current literature suggests that longterm exposure to low selenium may be needed to impact
brain function. The brains unique selenium metabolism
may also make it more difficult to show the effect of
short-term selenium exposure on brain function than on
other organs.
The rural Chinese population offers an opportunity to
investigate the association of long-term selenium exposure and depression by identifying populations where substantial numbers are exposed to low selenium diet for an
extended length of time and comparing their depressive
symptoms to those with normal selenium levels. The
overwhelming majority of our study participants were
life-long residents of the same towns where they were
interviewed and very few take dietary supplements.
Hence the ascertained selenium levels can be inferred as
life-long exposure to selenium without the influence of
supplements. In this stable cohort, we found a significant
association between lower selenium levels and increased
depressive symptoms which is consistent with previous
reports in participants with low dietary selenium intake.
The mechanism underlying an association between selenium and depression is not yet clear, although published
results point to the fact that selenium is important to
brain functions. In animal models, selenium deficiency
was shown to alter neurotransmitter turnover rate [29]
and sodium selenite protected against dopamine loss
[30]. In addition, the enzyme closely related to selenium
activity (GP-x) protected against neuron loss [31], cell
Page 6 of 8
death [32], and decreased free radical generation or amyloid beta peptide [33]. In human studies, selenium supplementation was shown to reduce intractable epileptic
seizures [34,35]. A recent cross-sectional study reported
that whole blood GPX activity was significantly lower in
depressed patients than in normal controls [36]. More research is needed to elucidate the biological mechanism
for seleniums function in the brain.
To our knowledge, no previous studies on selenium
and depression have examined the role of cognitive function. Numerous studies have reported the co-existence of
cognitive impairment and depression [37], although the
underlying mechanism for such an association is not yet
established. Some suggest that depressive symptoms are
early manifestation of the dementia disorder [38], while
others believe that depression represents an independent
risk factor for cognitive decline [25]. We have previously
reported a significant relationship between selenium level
and cognitive function in the same cohort using data collected from baseline [8]. The non-significant association
between selenium and depressive symptoms after adjusting for cognitive function suggests that cognitive function plays an important role in the relationship between
selenium and depression.
Our study has a number of strengths. Selenium levels
were measured in nail samples reflecting stable longterm exposure. The study included participants from
sites with extensive range of selenium exposure. In
addition, the majority of our study participants were lifelong residents of the same towns where they were interviewed and the participants were known to have not
taken dietary supplements. Hence the ascertained selenium levels can be inferred as life-long exposure to selenium without the influence of supplements. A number of
cognitive instruments were used so that a reliable composite measure of cognitive function can be derived.
There are also important limitations in this study. Our
results were based on cross-sectional analyses in the
sense that cognitive function and depressive symptoms
were measured at the same time. Longitudinal follow-up
of this cohort would be necessary to examine the casual
direction of the association between cognitive function
and depressive symptoms. A second limitation is that we
relied on the GDS to assess depressive symptoms rather
than clinical diagnosis of specific depressive disorders,
an approach adopted by many large epidemiological
studies [25,38]. Further limitations include the exclusion
of potentially important risk factors for depression such
as disability or social support.
Conclusions
In summary, we found that selenium level was inversely
related to depressive symptoms in models without adjusting for cognition in this rural elderly Chinese cohort.
Page 7 of 8
Page 8 of 8
34. Weber GF, Maertens P, Meng XZ, Pippenger CE: Glutathione peroxidase
deficiency and childhood seizures. Lancet 1991, 337(8755):14431444.
35. Ramaekers VT, Calomme M, Vanden Berghe D, Makropoulos W: Selenium
deficiency triggering intractable seizures. Neuropediatrics 1994,
25(4):217223.
36. Maes M, Mihaylova I, Kubera M, Uytterhoeven M, Vrydags N, Bosmans E:
Lower whole blood glutathione peroxidase (GPX) activity in depression,
but not in myalgic encephalomyelitis/chronic fatigue syndrome: another
pathway that may be associated with coronary artery disease and
neuroprogression in depression. Neuro Endocrinol Lett 2011, 32(2):133140.
37. Steffens DC, Otey E, Alexopoulos GS, Butters MA, Cuthbert B, Ganguli M,
et al: Perspectives on depression, mild cognitive impairment, and
cognitive decline. Arch Gen Psychiatry 2006, 63(2):130138.
38. Ganguli M, Du Y, Dodge HH, Ratcliff GG, Chang CC: Depressive symptoms
and cognitive decline in late life: a prospective epidemiological study.
Arch Gen Psychiatry 2006, 63(2):153160.
doi:10.1186/1471-244X-12-72
Cite this article as: Gao et al.: Selenium level and depressive symptoms
in a rural elderly Chinese cohort. BMC Psychiatry 2012 12:72.