(EW-492) - Flux Cored Arc Welding-Hobart Institute of Welding Technology (Yasser Tawfik)
(EW-492) - Flux Cored Arc Welding-Hobart Institute of Welding Technology (Yasser Tawfik)
(EW-492) - Flux Cored Arc Welding-Hobart Institute of Welding Technology (Yasser Tawfik)
TECHNICAL
GUIDE
HOBART INSTITUTE OF WELDING TECHNOLOGY, 400 TRADE SQUARE EAST, TROY, OHIO 45373 U.S.A.
Table of Contents
Chapter
Page
CHAPTER 1
INTRODUCTION TO THE PROCESS
Flux cored arc welding (FCAW) is an arc welding process in which the heat for welding is produced by an arc between a continuously fed tubular electrode wire and the work. Shielding is
obtained by a flux contained within the tubular
electrode wire or by the flux and an externally
supplied shielding gas. Some trade names for
this process are FabCO, Fabshield, Innershield, and Dual Shield. A diagram of the
process is shown in Illustration 1-1.
Gas
Molten Metal
Flux Cored
Electrode
Solidified
Weld Metal
Molten
Slag
Slag
Nozzle
(not required for
self-shielding wires)
Arc
Base
Metal
Direction of Travel
METHODS OF APPLICATION
Although flux cored arc welding may be applied semiautomatically, by machine, or automatically, the process
is usually applied semiautomatically. In semiautomatic
welding, the wire feeder feeds the electrode wire and the
power source maintains the arc length. The welder manipulates the welding gun and adjusts the welding parameters. Flux cored arc welding is also used in machine
welding where, in addition to feeding the wire and maintaining the arc length, the machinery also provides the
joint travel. The welding operator continuously monitors
the welding and makes adjustments in the welding parameters. Automatic welding is used in high production
applications. In automatic welding, the welding operator
only starts the operation.
CHAPTER 2
PRINCIPLES OF OPERATION
The flux cored arc welding process uses the heat of an
electric arc between a consumable, tubular electrode and
the part to be welded. Electric current passing through an
ionized gas produces an electric arc. The gas atoms and
molecules are broken up and ionized by losing electrons
and leaving a positive charge. The positive gas ions then
flow from the positive pole to the negative pole and the
electrons flow from the negative pole to the positive pole.
About 95% of the heat is carried by the electrons and the
rest is carried by the positive ions. The heat of the arc
melts the electrode and the surface of the base metal.
The molten weld metal, heated weld zone, and electrode
are shielded by one of two methods. One is by the decomposition of the flux core of the electrode. The second method is by a combination of an externally supplied
shielding gas and the decomposition of the flux core of
the electrode wire. The flux core has essentially the same
purpose as the coating on an electrode for shielded metal
arc welding. The molten electrode filler metal transfers
across the arc and into the molten weld puddle. A slag
forms on top of the weld bead which can be removed
after welding.
The arc is struck by starting the wire feed which causes
the electrode wire to touch the workpiece and initiate the
arc. Arc travel is usually not started until a weld puddle is
formed. The welding gun then moves along the weld joint
manually or mechanically so that the edges of the weld
joint are joined. The weld metal solidifies behind the arc
which completes the welding process. A large amount of
flux is contained in the core of a self-shielding wire as
compared to a gas-shielded wire. This is needed to provide adequate shielding and because of this, a thicker
slag coating is formed. In these wires, deoxidizing and
denitrifying elements are needed in the filler metal and
flux core because some nitrogen is introduced from the
ARC SYSTEMS
The flux cored arc welding process may be operated on
both constant voltage and constant current power sources. Any welding power source can be classified by its
volt-ampere characteristics as either a constant voltage
(also called constant potential) or constant current (also
called variable voltage) type, although there are some machines that can produce both characteristics. Constant
voltage power sources are preferred for a majority of flux
cored arc welding applications.
In the constant voltage arc system, the voltage delivered to the arc is maintained at a relatively constant level
which gives a flat or nearly flat volt-ampere curve, as
shown in Illustration 2-1. This type of power source is
widely used for the processes that require a continuously
fed wire electrode. In this system, the arc length is controlled by setting the voltage level on the power source
and the welding current is controlled by setting the wire
feed speed. As shown in Illustration 2-1, a slight change
in the arc length will produce a large change in the welding current.
Most power sources have a fixed slope that is built in for
a certain type of flux cored arc welding. Some constant
voltage welding machines are equipped with a slope control which is used to change the slope of the volt-ampere
curve. Illustration 2-2 shows different slopes obtained
from one power source. The slope has the effect of limiting the amount of short-circuiting current that the power
supply can deliver. This is the current available from the
power source on the short circuit between the electrode
40
36
35
D.C. VOLTS
D.C. VOLTS
30
25
20
HIGH
30
MEDIUM
25
LOW
20
200
300
400
500
600
200
300
400
500
600
The constant current arc system provides a nearly constant welding current to the arc which gives a drooping
volt-ampere characteristic, as shown in Illustration 2-3.
This arc system is used with the shielded metal arc welding and gas tungsten arc welding processes. The welding
current is set by a dial on the machine and the welding
voltage is controlled by the arc length held by the welder.
This system is necessary for manual welding because
the welder cannot hold a constant arc length which
causes only small variations in the welding current.
When flux cored arc welding is done with a constant
current system, a special voltage sensing wire feeder is
used to maintain a constant arc length.
For any power source, the voltage drop across the welding arc is directly dependent on the arc length. An increase in the arc length results in a corresponding increase in the arc voltage and a decrease in the arc length
results in a corresponding decrease in the arc voltage.
Another important relationship exists between the welding current and the melt off rate of the electrode. With
low current, the electrode melts off slower and the metal
is deposited slower. This relationship between welding
current and wire feed speed is definite, based on the
wire size, shielding gas type and type of electrode. A
faster wire feed speed will give a higher welding current.
In the constant voltage system, instead of regulating the
wire to maintain a constant arc length, the wire is fed
into the arc at a fixed speed and the power source is designed to melt off the wire at the same speed. The selfregulating characteristic of a constant voltage power
source comes about by the ability of this type of power
source to adjust its welding current in order to maintain
a fixed voltage across the arc.
36
VOLTS
VOLTS
D.C.VOLTS
VOLTS
30
25Arc
length:
Constant
voltage
power
source
Long
20Normal
Short
0
WELD
WELD CURRENT
CURRENT(AMPERES)
(AMPERES)
Constant
current
power
source
200
300
400
500
600
METAL TRANSFER
Metal transfer, from consumable electrodes across
an arc, has been classified into three general modes
CHAPTER 3
EQUIPMENT FOR WELDING
The equipment used for flux cored arc welding is very
similar to that used for gas metal arc welding. The basic
arc welding equipment consists of a power source, controls, wire feeder, welding gun and welding cables. A major difference between the gas-shielded electrodes and
self-shielded electrodes is that the gas-shielded wires
also require a gas shielding system. This may also have
an effect on the type of welding gun used. Fume extractors are often used with this process. For machine and
automatic welding, several items, such as seam followers
and motion devices, are added to the basic equipment.
Illustration 3-1 shows a diagram of the equipment used
for semiautomatic flux cored arc welding.
POWER SOURCES
The power source or welding machine provides the electric power of the proper voltage and amperage to maintain a welding arc. Most power sources operate on 230 or
460 volt input power, but machines that operate on 200
or 575 volt input are available as options. Power sources
may operate on either single phase or three-phase input
with a frequency of 50 to 60 Hz.
Power Source Duty Cycle
The duty cycle of a power source is defined as the ratio
of arc time to total time. Most power sources used for
flux cored arc welding have a duty cycle of 100%, which
indicates that they can be used to weld continuously.
Some machines used for this process have duty cycles
of 60%, which means that they can be used to weld six
of every ten minutes.
With Gas
Types of Current
Flux cored arc welding uses direct current. Direct current can be connected in one of two ways, which are
electrode positive (reverse polarity) or electrode negative
(straight polarity). The electrically charged particles flow
between the tip of the electrode and the work as shown in
Illustration 3-2. Flux cored electrode wires are designed
to operate on either DCEP or DCEN. The wires designed
for use with an external gas shielding system are generally designed for use with DCEP. Some self-shielding flux
cored wires are used with DCEP while others are developed for use with DCEN. Electrode positive current gives
better penetration into the weld joint. Electrode negative
current gives lighter penetration and is used for welding
thinner metal or where there is poor fit-up. The weld created by DCEN is wider and shallower than the weld produced by DCEP.
Types of Power Sources
The power sources generally recommended for flux cored
arc welding are direct current constant voltage types.
Both rotating (generator) and static (single or three-phase
transformer-rectifiers) are employed. Any of these types
of machines are available to produce constant current or
Shielding
Gas Source
(Optional)
Control System
Without Gas
Gas
Out
Gun
Control
Wire
Feed
Drive
Motor
Electrode
Voltage
Control
Electrode Lead
Workpiece Lead
Base Metal
Power
Source
constant voltage output, or both. The same power sources used with gas metal arc welding are employed with
flux cored arc welding. Flux cored arc welding generally
uses higher welding currents than gas metal arc welding, which sometimes requires a larger power source.
It is important to use a power source that is capable of
producing the maximum current level required for an application.
Generator Welding Machines
The generator welding machines used for this process
can be powered by an electric motor, for shop use, or
an internal combustion engine, for field applications. The
gasoline or diesel engine driven welding machines have
either liquid or air-cooled engines and many of them provide auxiliary power for emergency lighting, power tools,
etc. Many of the engine driven generators used for flux
cored arc welding in the field are combination constant
current-constant voltage types. These are popular for applications where both shielded metal arc welding and flux
cored arc welding can be accomplished using the same
power source. Illustration 3-3 shows an engine driven
generator machine used for flux cored arc welding. The
motor driven generator welding machines are gradually being replaced by transformer-rectifier welding machines. Motor-driven generators produce a very stable
arc, but they are noisier, more expensive, consume more
power and require more maintenance than transformerrectifier machines.
Transformer-Rectifier Welding Machines
The most widely used welding machines for flux cored
arc welding are the transformer-rectifiers. A method of
supplying direct current to the arc, other than the use
of a rotating generator, is by adding a rectifier to a basic
+ +
+
-
- +
+
+
-
DCEP
DCEN
CONTROLS
The controls for this process are located on the front of
the welding machine, on the welding gun, and on the wire
feeder or a control box.
The welding machine controls for a constant voltage machine include an on-off switch, a voltage control, and often a switch to select the polarity of direct current. The
voltage control can be a single knob, or it can have a tap
switch for setting the voltage range and a fine voltage
control knob.
Other controls are sometimes present, such as a switch
for selecting CC or CV output on combination machines,
or a switch for a remote control. On the constant current welding machines there is an on-off switch, a current
level control knob, and sometimes a knob or switch for
selecting the polarity of direct current.
The trigger or switch on the welding gun is a remote control that is used by the welder in semiautomatic welding to stop and start the welding current, wire feed, and
shielding gas flow.
For semiautomatic welding, a wire feed speed control is
normally part of, or close by, the wire feeder assembly.
The wire feed speed sets the welding current level on
a constant voltage machine. For machine or automatic
Illustration 3-5
Constant Speed
Wire Feeder
WIRE FEEDERS
The wire feed motor provides the power for driving the
electrode through the cable and gun and to the work.
There are several different wire feeding systems available.
The selection of the best type of system depends on the
application. Most of the wire feed systems used for flux
cored arc welding are the constant speed type, which are
used with constant voltage power sources. This means
that the wire feed speed is set before welding. (See Illustration 3.5.) The wire feed speed controls the amount of
welding current. Variable speed or voltage sensing wire
feeders are used with constant current power sources.
With a variable speed wire feeder, a voltage sensing circuit is used to maintain the desired arc length by varying
the wire feed speed. Variations in the arc length increase
or decrease the wire feed speed. (See Illustration 3.6.)
A wire feeder consists of an electrical motor connected
to a gear box containing drive rolls. The gear box and
wire feed motor shown in Illustration 3-7 has four feed
rolls in the gear box. Many systems have only two. In a
four roll system, the lower two rolls drive the wire. Because of their structure, flux cored wires can be easily
flattened. The type of drive roll used is based on the size
of the tubular wire being fed. The three basic types of
drive rolls are the U-groove, V-knurled and the U-cogged
(gear type), as shown in Illustration 3-8. U-groove drive
rolls are only used on small diameter wires. These can be
used because small diameter tubular wires are less easily
U groove
for soft wires
or soft-shelled
cored wires
V knurled
for hard-shelled
cored wires
U cogged
for extremely
soft wires
or soft-shelled
cored wires
Illustration 3-8
Common Types of Drive Rolls and their Uses
Gear
Ratio
15:1
(mm/s)
500-2000
212-846
37.5:1
60-1000
25-423
46:1
50-825
21-349
75:1
30-500
13-212
90:1
25-400
11-169
150:1
15-250
6-106
300:1
8-125
3-53
600:1
4-63
2-27
1200:1
2-30
1-13
spool of wire. Pull type wire feeders have the drive rolls
attached to the welding gun. Most machine and automatic welding stations use this type of system. Pull type
wire feeders are rarely used in semiautomatic welding.
Pull wire feeders have the advantage for welding small
diameter aluminum and soft nonferrous metals with gas
metal arc welding because it reduces wire feeding problems. Since most flux cored wires are steel, this is not
an advantage for flux cored arc welding. The push type
system, which has the drive rolls mounted near the coil
or spool of wire is the most commonly used in semiautomatic welding. The wire is pulled from the coil or spool
and then pushed into a flexible conduit and through the
gun. The relatively large diameter wires used in flux cored
arc welding are well suited to this type of system. The
length of the conduit can be up to about 12 feet (3.7 m).
Another advantage of this push type system is that the
wire feed mechanism is not attached to the gun, which
reduces the weight and makes the gun easier to handle.
Some wire feed systems contain a two-gun, two-wire
feeder arrangement connected to a single control box,
which is connected to a single power source. Both wire
feeders may be set up and there is a switch on the control to automatically select which of the two systems will
be used. One advantage to this system is that the second wire feeder and gun can provide backup in case of
breakdown, gun maintenance or electrode change. Another advantage is that two different electrodes for different applications can be set up. For example, a gas
metal arc welding electrode and gun can be set up on
one schedule for welding a root pass. The second schedule can be set up with flux cored wire to weld the rest of
10
the joint. This eliminates the need for two power sources
or the need to change the electrode wire and gun. The
liner is made of flexible metal and is available in sizes
compatible with the electrode size. The liner guides the
electrode wire from the wire feeder drive rolls through the
cable assembly and prevents interruptions in the travel.
Heavy duty welding guns are normally used because of
the large size electrode wires used and the high welding
current levels required. Because of the intense heat created by this process, heat shields are usually attached to
the gun in front of the trigger to protect the welders hand.
Both air-cooled and water-cooled guns are used for flux
cored arc welding. Air-cooled guns are cooled primarily
by the surrounding air, but when a shielding gas is used,
this will have an additional cooling effect. Air-cooled guns
are lighter and easier to manipulate. Illustration 3-10
shows a 600 ampere air-cooled welding gun.
Some self-shielded flux cored wires require a specific
minimum electrode extension to develop proper shielding. These welding guns have guide tubes with an insulated extension tube. This guide supports the electrode
and insures minimum electrode extension as shown in
Illustration 3-12. A gun for self-shielded flux cored wire
welding is shown in Illustration 3-11.
FUME EXTRACTORS
Fume extractors are often used to help to reduce the
smoke levels produced by flux cored electrodes. This
Electrode
Guide Tube
Insulated Nozzle
Contact Tube
Flux Cored
Electrode
FCAW Gun
for robotic
applications
Electrode
Extension
Visible Extension
Work
11
The purpose of a gas flow regulator is to reduce the pressure from the gas supply source and maintain a constant
delivery pressure. The gas flowmeter is then used to control the flow of gas from the regulator to the welding gun.
The gas flow rate is adjusted by a valve at the flowmeter
outlet. The flowmeter is often attached to the regulator
as shown in Illustration 3-15. Regulators and flowmeters
are designated for use with specific shielding gases and
should only be used with the gas that they were designed
for.
The hoses are normally connected to solenoid valves on
the wire feeder to turn the gas flow on and off with the
welding current. A hose is used to connect the flowmeter
to the welding gun. The hose is usually part of the welding gun assembly.
WELDING CABLES
The size of the welding cables used depends on the output capacity of the welding machine, the duty cycle of
the machine, and the distance between the welding ma-
12
Weld
Type
Manual
(Low
Duty
Cycle)
Weld
Current
100
60'
4
100'
4
150'
4
200'
2
300'
1
400'
1/0
150
2/0
3/0
200
1/0
3/0
4/0
250
1/0
2/0
300
2/0
3/0
350
1/0
1/0
3/0
4/0
400
1/0
1/0
3/0
450
2/0
2/0
4/0
500
2/0
2/0
4/0
Note: Length of cable circuit equals total electrode and work cable
Illustration 3-16 Suggested Copper Welding Cable Sized for Flux Cored Arc Welding
chine and the work. Cable sizes range from the smallest
at AWG No. 8 to AWG No. 4/0 with amperage ratings of
75 amperes on up. Illustration 3-16 shows recommended
cable sizes for use with different welding currents and
cable lengths. A cable that is too small may become too
hot during welding
Motion Devices
OTHER EQUIPMENT
Water Circulators
When a water-cooled gun is used, a water supply must
be included in the system. This can be supplied by a
water circulator or directly from a hose connection to
a water tap. The water is carried to the welding torch
through hoses that may or may not go through a valve in
the welding machine. A typical water circulator is shown
in Illustration 3-17.
Oscillators are optional equipment that are used to oscillate the gun for surfacing, vertical-up welding, and other
welding operations that require a wide bead. Oscillators
can either be mechanical or electromagnetic devices.
Accessories
Accessory equipment for flux cored arc welding consists
of items for cleaning the weld bead and cutting the electrode wire. Because of the slag coating that is formed,
chipping hammers and wire brushes are usually required
to remove the slag. A grinder is often used for final cleaning and for removing spatter. Wire cutters or pliers are
used to cut the end of the electrode wire between stops
and starts.
Illustration 3-17 Water Circulator
Photo courtesy of Smith Equipment
13
CHAPTER 4
SHIELDING GASES AND ELECTRODES
The electrodes used for flux cored arc welding provide
the filler metal to the weld puddle and shielding for the
arc. A shielding gas is required for some electrode types.
The purpose of the shielding gas is to provide protection,
from the atmosphere, to the arc and molten weld puddle.
The chemical composition of the electrode wire and flux
core in combination with the shielding gas will determine
the weld metal composition and mechanical properties of
the weld.
SHIELDING GASES
The primary purpose of shielding gas, in any gas-shielded
arc welding process, is to protect the arc and weld puddle
from contaminating effects of the atmosphere. The nitrogen and oxygen of the atmosphere, if allowed to come in
contact with the molten weld metal, cause porosity and
brittleness.
In shielded metal arc welding, protection is accomplished
by placing an outer coating on the electrode which produces a gaseous shield as the coating disintegrates in the
welding arc. In flux cored arc welding, the same effect is
accomplished by decomposition of the electrode core or
by a combination of this and surrounding the arc area with
a shielding gas supplied from an external source.
A shielding gas displaces air in the arc area. Welding is
then accomplished under a blanket of shielding gas. Since
the molten weld metal is exposed only to the shielding
gas, it is not contaminated by the atmosphere.
Oxygen, which makes up 21% of air, is a highly reactive
element which, at high temperatures, combines readily
with other elements in the steel to form undesirable oxides and gases. Oxygen combines with iron to form compounds which can lead to inclusions in the weld metal
and also lower its mechanical properties. On coating, free
oxygen in the molten metal combines with the carbon of
the steel to form carbon monoxide. If gas is trapped in the
weld metal as it cools, it collects in pockets and causes
pores in the weld deposit.
Nitrogen, which makes up 78% of air, causes the most
serious problems when welding steel. When steel is molten, it can take a relatively large amount of nitrogen into
solution. At room temperature, the solubility of nitrogen in
steel is very low. Therefore, in cooling, nitrogen precipitates or comes out of the steel as nitrites. These nitrites
cause high yield strength, tensile strength, hardness, and
a pronounced decrease in the ductility and impact resistance of the steel. The loss of ductility due to the presence
of iron nitrites often leads to cracking of the weld metal.
Excessive amounts of nitrogen can also lead to extensive
porosity in the weld deposit.
GAS
Carbon Dioxide
Carbon dioxide is manufactured
from fuel gases which are given off
by the burning of natural gas, fuel
oil, or coke. It is also obtained as a
by-product of calcining operations in
lime kilns, from the manufacturing of
ammonia, and from the fermentation
of alcohol. The carbon dioxide given
off by the manufacturing of ammonia
and the fermentation of alcohol is almost 100% pure. Carbon dioxide is
made available to the user in either
cylinder or bulk containers, with the
cylinder being more common. With
the bulk system, carbon dioxide
is usually drawn off as a liquid and
14
LIQUID
Illustration 4-1
Carbon Dioxide
Gas Cylinder
The carbon dioxide shielding gas breaks down into components such as carbon monoxide and oxygen. Because
carbon dioxide is an oxidizing gas, deoxidizing elements
are added to the core of the electrode wire to remove
oxygen. The oxides formed by the deoxidizing elements
float to the surface of the weld and become part of the
slag covering. Some of the carbon dioxide gas will break
down to carbon and oxygen. If the carbon content of the
weld pool is below about .05%, carbon dioxide shielding will tend to increase the carbon content of the weld
metal. Carbon, which can reduce the corrosion resistance of some stainless steels, is a problem for critical
corrosion applications. Extra carbon can also reduce the
toughness and ductility of some low alloy steels. If the
carbon content in the weld metal is greater than about
10%, carbon dioxide shielding will tend to reduce the
carbon content. This loss of carbon can be attributed to
the formation of carbon monoxide, which can be trapped
in the weld as porosity deoxidizing elements in the flux
core, reducing the effects of carbon monoxide formation.
Argon-Carbon Dioxide Mixtures
Argon and carbon dioxide are often mixed for use with
flux cored arc welding. A high percentage of argon gas in
the mixture tends to promote higher deposition efficiency
due to the creation of less spatter. This mixture also creates less oxidation and lower fumes. The most commonly
used argon-carbon dioxide mixture contains 75% argon
and 25% carbon dioxide. This gas mixture produces a
fine globular metal transfer that approaches a spray. It
also reduces the amount of oxidation that occurs, compared to pure carbon dioxide. The weld deposited in an
argon-carbon dioxide shield generally has higher tensile
and yield strengths. Argon-carbon dioxide mixtures are
often used for out-of-position welding, achieving better
arc characteristics and welder appeal. This mixture also
improves arc transfer on smaller diameters. Argon/CO2 is
often used on low alloy steels and stainless steels.
Electrodes that are designed for use with CO2 may cause
an excessive build-up of manganese, silicon, and other
deoxidizing elements if they are used with shielding gas
mixtures containing a high percentage of argon. This will
have an effect on the mechanical properties of the weld.
Argon-Oxygen Mixtures
Argon-oxygen mixtures containing 1 or 2% oxygen are
used for some applications. Argon-oxygen mixtures tend
to promote a spray transfer which reduces the amount of
spatter produced. A major application of these mixtures
is the welding of stainless steels where carbon dioxide
can cause corrosion problems.
15
ELECTRODES
Sheath
Core
Alloying Materials
Flux
Slag Formers
16
AWS
Specification Specification Title / Metal
Source
Specification for
Electrode
Classification
& Requirements
A5.36
Shielding
Gasd
E7XT-1Cg
C1
E7XT-1Mg
M21
E7XT-5C
C1
E7XT-5M
E7XT-6g
AWS
A5.20/A5.20M
A5.22
M21
None
E7XT-8g
E7XT-9Cg
C1
E7XT-9M
M21
E7XT-12Cg
C1
E7XT-12Mg
M21
Weld
Depositf
CS1
CS3
CS1
E70T-4g
E7XT-7h
Mechanical
Propertiese
None
CS2
CS3
a) These multiple pass electrodes are classified according to the fixed classification system utilized in AWS A5.20/A5.20M as applicable, which has been carried over for these
specific electrodes as a part of AWS A5.36/A5.36M. The mechanical property and weld deposit requirements are as defined in this table. These same electrodes may also be
classified to the same requirements or to different requirements using the open classification system introduced in this specification. In this case, the classification designations
are as described in AWS A5.20/A5.20M, Figure 1. See Table A.1 or Table A.3, as applicable, in Annex A for comparisons of the fixed classification designations and equivalent
open classification designations for the above electrodes when both are classified to the requirements listed in this table.
b) Under AWS A5.20/A5.20M, the E at the beginning of the classification designates an electrode. The 7 is the tensile strength designator. The X indicates the electrodes
position of welding capability. A 0 is used to indicate flat and horizontal only. A 1 is used to indicate all position capability. The T identifies the electrode as a flux cored
electrode The one or two digit number after the dash indicates the electrodes usability characteristics as defined in AWS A5.20/A5.20M. For the open classification system
introduced in this specification, the T identifies the electrode as either a flux cored or a metal cored electrode. The T is combined with a one or two digit number as a part
of the alpha-numeric designator for usability. See Illustration 4-11. Under AWS A5.18/A5.18M for classification E70C-6M, the E designates an electrode. The 70 indicates that
the weld deposit will have a minimum tensile strength of 70 ksi. The C indicates that the electrode is a composite (metal cored) electrode. The 6 indicates the composition of
the weld metal the composition produced with this electrode. The M indicates the type of shielding gas used.
c) The electrodes shown in the darker blue panels are self-shielded.
d) See Illustration 4-8.
e) Mechanical properties are obtained by testing weld metal from the groove weld shown in Figure 2 of AWS A5.36/A5.36M. Welding and testing shall he done as prescribed in this
specification. The requirements for welding and testing are the same as those given in A5.20/A5.20M. All mechanical property testing for the classifications listed in this table
shall be done in the as-welded condition.
f) See Illustration 4-12.
g) The D, Q, and H optional designators which are not part of the electrode classification designation, may be added at the end of the designation as established in
AWS A5.20/A5.20M, i.e., E7XT-XXD, E7XT-XXQ, E7XT-XXHX, E7XT-XXDHX, or E7XT-XXQHX as applicable. The J optional, supplemental designator listed in A5.20/A5.20M is
no longer required. The open classification system introduced in this A5.36/A5.36M specification eliminates the need for this designator.
h) The H optional, supplemental designator, which is not part of the electrode classification designation, may be added to the end of the designation as established in
AWS A5.18/A5.I8M, i.e., E70C-6MHZ. Provisions for the D and Q optional, supplemental designators have not been established in A5.18/A5.18M and, as a result, may not
be used with the E70C-6M designation. However, that does not preclude their use with metal core electrodes classified utilizing the open classification system under the
A5.36/A5.36M specification.
i)Yield strength at 0.2% offset.
J Percent elongation in 2 in. (50 mm) gauge length when a 0.500 (12 mm) nominal diameter tensile specimen and nominal gauge length to diameter ratio of 4:1 is used.
17
Single Pass
Electrodes
U.S.
Customary
Units
International
System of
Units (SI)
Min. Tensile
Strength
ksi (MPa)
Tensile
Strength
(ksi)
Min. Yield
Strengtha
(ksi)
Minimum
Percent
Elongationb
Tensile
Strength
(MPa)
Min. Yield
Strengtha
(MPa)
Minimum
Percent
Elongationb
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
43
49
55
62
69
76
83
90
60 (430)
70 (490)
80 (550)
90 (620)
100 (690)
110 (760)
120 (830)
130 (900)
60-80
70-95
80-100
90-110
100-120
110-130
120-140
130-150
48
58
68
78
88
98
108
118
22
22
19
17
16
15
14
14
430-550
490-660
550-690
620-760
690-830
760-900
830-970
900-1040
330
400
470
540
610
680
740
810
22
22
19
17
16
15
14
14
Illustration 4-7 Tension Test Requirements for Carbon and Low Alloy Steel Flux Cored Electrodes
(Source: AWS A5.36)
AWS A5.36
Shielding Gas
Designatora
C1
M12
M13
M14
M20
M21
M22
M23
M24
M25
M26
M27
M31
M32
M33
M34
M35
Z
% CO2
100
0.5 CO2 5
0.5 CO2 5
5 < CO2 15
15 < CO2 25
.05 CO2 5
5 < CO2 15
5 < CO2 15
15 < CO2 25
15 < CO2 25
25 < CO2 50
25 < CO2 50
5 < CO2 25
25 < CO2 25
% O2
0.5 O2 3
0.5 O2 3
3 < O2 10
3 < O2 10
0.5 O2 3
3 < O2 10
0.5 O2 3
3 < O2 10
10 < O2 15
2 < O2 10
10 < O2 15
10 < O2 15
Nominal Composition of Shielding Gases to be Used for Classification of Gas Shielded Electrodes to AWS A5.36/5.36M
ISO 14175
Designation
C1
M12-ArC-3
M13-ArO-2
M14-ArCO-3/2
M20-ArC-10
M21-ArC-20
M22-ArO-7
M23-ArO-7/3
M24-ArCO-10/2
M25-ArCO-10/7
M26-ArCO-20/2
M27-ArCO-20/7
M31-ArC-38
M32-ArO-12.5
M33-ArCO-38/6
M34-ArCO-15/12.5
M35-ArCO-38/12.5
Oxidizing Componentsc,e
% CO2
100
3
3
10
20
3
10
10
20
20
38
38
15
38
% O2
2
2
7
7
2
7
2
7
12.5
6
12.5
12.5
The designator Z indicates that the shielding gas used for electrode classification is not one of the shielding gases
specified in this table but is a different composition as agreed upon between the supplier and purchaser.
a) The Shielding Gas Designators are identical to the Main group/Sub-group designators used in AWS A5.32M/A5.32:2011 (ISO 14175:2008 MOD), Welding Consumables
Gases and Gas Mixtures for Fusion Welding and Allied Processes, for these same shielding gases.
b) Under AWS A5.32M/A5.32:2011, the inert gas used for the balance of the gas mixture may be either argon, helium, or some mixture thereof.
c) The mixture tolerances are:
For a component gas with a nominal concentration of >5%, 10% of nominal.
For a component gas with a nominal concentration of 1-5%, 0.5% absolute.
For a component gas with a nominal concentration of <1%, not specified in this standard.
d) AWS A5.32M/A5.32:2011 shielding gas designators begin with AWS A5.32 (ISO 14175). That part of the designation has been omitted from the Shielding Gas Designator
brevity.
e) The inert gas to be used for the balance of the gas mixtures specified for the classification of gas-shielded flux cored electrodes shall be argon.
18
For A5.36
U.S. Customary
Units
For A5.36
International System
of Units (SI)
60 F preheat min.
15 C preheat min.
300 F 25 F Interpass 150 C 15 C Interpass
For A5.36
U.S. Customary
Units
For A5.36
International System
of Units (SI)
1150 F 25 F
620 C 15 C
300 F 25 F
150 C 15 C
1150 F 25 F
620 C 15 C
350 F 25 F
275 C 15 C
1275 F 25 F
690 C 15 C
400 F 100 F
200 C 50 C
1375 F 25 F
745 C 15 C
B91, B92
500 F 100 F
260 C 50 C
1400 F 25 F
760 C 15 C
300 F 25 F
150 C 15 C
a) These temperatures are specified for testing under this specification and are not to be considered as recommendations for preheat and postweld heat treatment (PWHT) in
production welding. The requirements for production welding must be determined by the user.
b) Postweld heal treatment is required only for those classifications with the P designator for condition of heat treatment.
c) The PWHT schedule is as described in 9.2.1.2 of AWS A5.20/A5.20M.
d) PWHT temperature in excess of 1150 F (620 C) will decrease Charpy V-Notch impact strength.
e) Held at temperature for 2 hours -0 +15 minutes.
Maximum Test
Temperaturec,d (F)
+68
Minimum Average
Energy Level
Impact
Designatora,b
Maximum Test
Temperaturec,d (C)
+20
-20
-20
-40
-30
-50
-60
20 ftlbf
-40
-50
-80
-60
10
-100
-70
15
-150
10
-100
Z
G
No Impact Requirements.
Minimum Average
Energy Level
27 J
No Impact Requirements.
a) Based on the results of the impact tests of the weld metal, the manufacturer shall insert in the classification the appropriate designator from this table.
b) When classifying an electrode to A5.36 using U.S. Customary Units, the Impact Designator indicates the maximum impact lest temperature in degrees Fahrenheit. When
classifying to A5.36M using the International System of Units (Sl), the Impact Designator indicates the maximum impact test temperature in degrees Celsius. With the exception
of the Impact Designator 4, a given Impact Designator will indicate different temperatures depending upon whether classification is according to A5.36 in U.S. Customary Units
or according to A5.36M in the International System of Units (SI). For example, a 2 Impact Designator when classifying to A5.36 indicates a lest temperature of -20 F. When
classifying to A5.36M, the 2 Impact Designator indicates a test temperature of -20 C, which is -4 F.
c) Weld metal from an electrode that meets the impact requirements at a given temperature also meets the requirements at all higher temperatures in this table. For example, weld
metal meeting the A5.36 requirements for designator 5 also meets the requirements for designators 4, 2, 0, and Y. (Weld metal meeting the A5.36M requirements for designator
5 also meets the requirements for designators 4, 3, 2, 0, and Y.)
d) Filler metal classification testing to demonstrate conformance to a specified minimum acceptable level for impact testing, i.e., minimum energy at specific temperature, can be
met by testing and meeting the minimum energy requirement at any lower temperature. In these cases, the actual temperature used for testing shall be listed on the
certification documentation when issued.
Illustration 4-10 Impact Test Requirements for Carbon and Low Alloy Steel Flux Cored Electrodes (Source: AWS A5.36)
19
Usability
Designatora
Process
Position
of Weldinga, b
Polarityf
T1
FCAW-G
Flux cored electrodes of this type are gas-shielded and have a rutile base
slag. They are characterized by a spray transfer, low spatter loss, and a
moderate volume of slag which completely covers the weld.
H, F, VU, OH
DCEP
FCAW-G
Flux cored electrodes of this type are similar to the T1 type of electrode
but with higher manganese or silicon, or both. They are designed primarily
for single pass welding in the flat and horizontal positions. The higher levels
of deoxidizers in this electrode type allow single pass welding of heavily
oxidized or rimmed steel.
H, F, VU, OH
DCEP
FCAW-S
Flux cored electrodes of this type are self-shielded and are intended for
single pass welding and are characterized by a spray type transfer. The
titanium-based slag system is designed to make very high welding speeds
possible.
FCAW-S
Flux cored electrodes of this type are self-shielded and are characterized by
a globular type transfer. Its flouride-based basic slag system is designed to
make very high deposition rates possible and to make low sulfur welds for
improved resistance to hot cracking.
H, F
DCEP
FCAW-G
Flux cored electrodes of this type are gas-shielded and are characterized
by a globular transfer, slightly convex bead contour, and a thin slag that
may not completely cover the weld bead. They have a lime-flouride slag
system and develop improved impact properties and better cold cracking
resistance than typically exhibited by the T1 type electrodes.
H, F, VU, OH
DCEP or
DCEN
FCAW-S
Flux cored electrodes of this type are self-shielded and are characterized by
a spray type transfer. Its oxide-based slag system is designed to produce
good low temperature impacts, good penetration into the root of the weld,
and excellent slag removal.
H, F
DCEP
FCAW-S
Flux cored electrodes of this type are self-shielded and are characterized by
a small droplet to spray type transfer. The flouride-based slag system is designed to provide high deposition rates in the downhand positions with the
larger diameters and out of position capabilities with the smaller diameters.
H, F, VU, OH
DCEN
FCAW-S
Flux cored electrodes of this type are self-shielded and are characterized
by a small droplet to spray type transfer. The flouride-based slag system is
designed to provide improved out-of-position control. The weld metal pro- H, F, VD, VU, OH
duced typically exhibits very good low temperature notch toughness and
crack resistance.
T1S
T3S
T4
T5
T6
T7
T8
H, F
DCEP
DCEN
Illustration 4-11 Usability Characteristics for Carbon and Low Alloy Steel Flux Cored Electrodes
(Source: AWS A5.36)
20
Usability
Designatora
Process
Position
of Weldinga, b
Polarityf
T9
FCAW-G
Flux cored electrodes of this type are similar in design and application to
the T1 types but with improved weld metal notch toughness capabilities.
H, F, VU, OH
DCEP
T10S
FCAW-S
Flux cored electrodes of this type are self-shielded and are characterized by
a small droplet transfer. The flouride-based slag system is designed to make
single pass welds at high travel speeds on steel of any thickness.
H, F
DCEN
T11
FCAW-S
Flux cored electrodes of this type are self-shielded and are characterized by
a smooth spray type transfer, limited slag coverage, and are generally not
recommended for the welding of materials over 3/4 in. (20 mm) thick.
H, F, VD, OH
DCEN
T12
FCAW-G
Flux cored electrodes of this type are similar in design and application to the
T1 types, however, they have been modified for improved impact toughness and to meet the lower manganese requirements of the A-No. 1 Analysis Group in the ASME Boiler and Pressure Vessel Code, Section IX.
H, F, VU, OH
DCEP
T14S
FCAW-S
Flux cored electrodes of this type are self-shielded and are characterized by
a smooth spray type transfer. The slag system is designed for single pass
welds in all positions and at high travel speeds.
H, F, VD, OH
DCEN
T17
FCAW-S
This flux cored electrode type is a self-shielded electrode specifically deH, F, VD, VU, OH
signed for use with AC power sources with or without modified waveforms.
Not Specified
ACh
Not Specified
a) An S is added to the end of the Usability Designator when the electrode being classified is recommended for single pass applications only.
b) For more information refer to AWS A5.36/A5.36M, A7, Description and Intended Use, in Annex A.
c) Properties of weld metal from electrodes that are used with external shielding gas will vary according to the shielding gas used. Electrodes classified with a specific shielding gas
should not be used with other shielding gases without first consulting the manufacturer of the electrode.
d) H = horizontal position, F = flat position, OH = overhead position, VU = vertical position with upward progression, VD - vertical position with downward progression.
e) Electrode sizes suitable for out-of-position welding, i.e., welding positions other that flat and horizontal, are usually those sizes that are smaller than the 3/32 in. (2.4 mm) size or
or the nearest size called for in Clause 9 for the groove weld. For that reason, electrodes meeting the requirements for the groove weld test may be classified as EX1TX-XXX-X
(where X represents the tensile strength, usability, shielding gas, if any, condition of heat treatment, impact test temperature, and weld metal composition designators) regardless
of their size.
f) The term DCEP refers to direct current electrode positive (dc, reverse polarity). The term DCEN refers to direct current electrode negative (dc, straight polarity).
g) Some EX1T5-XXX-X electrodes may be recommended for use on DCEN for improved out-of-position welding. Consult the manufacturer for the recommended polarity.
h) For this electrode type the welding current can be conventional sinusoidal alternating current, a modified AC waveform alternating between positive and negative, an alternating
DCEP waveform, or an alternating DCEN waveform.
Illustration 4-11 Usability Characteristics for Carbon and Low Alloy Steel Flux Cored Electrodes
(Source: AWS A5.36)
21
Weld Metal
UNS
Designation Numberb
Mn
Si
Weight Percentc
Ni
Cr
Mo
Al
Cu
Otherd
0.12
1.75
0.90
0.030
0.030
0.50f
0.20f
0.30f
0.08
0.35
CS2e,g
0.12
1.60
0.90
0.030
0.030
0.50f
0.20f
0.30f
0.08
0.35
CS3e
0.30
1.75
0.60
0.030
0.030
0.50f
0.20f
0.30f
0.08
1.8f,h
0.35
0.40 to
0.65
W1703X
0.12
1.25
0.030
0.030
0.30
W5103X
0.05 to
0.12
1.25
0.80
0.030
0.030
0.40 to
0.65
0.40 to
0.65
B1L
W5113X
0.05
1.25
0.80
0.030
0.030
0.40 to
0.65
0.40 to
0.65
B2
W5203X
0.05 to
0.12
1.25
0.80
0.030
0.030
1.00 to
1.50
0.40 to
0.65
B2L
W5213X
0.05
1.25
0.80
0.030
0.030
1.00 to
1.50
0.40 to
0.65
B2H
W5223X
0.10 to
0.15
1.25
0.080
0.030
0.030
1.00 to
1.50
0.40 to
0.65
B3
W5303X
0.05 to
0.12
1.25
0.80
0.030
0.030
2.00 to
2.50
0.90 to
1.20
B3L
W5313X
0.05
1.25
0.80
0.030
0.030
2.00 to
2.50
0.90 to
1.20
B3H
W5323X
0.10 to
0.15
1.25
0.80
0.030
0.030
2.00 to
2.50
0.90 to
1.20
B6
W50231
0.05 to
0.12
1.25
1.00
0.030
0.025
0.40
4.0 to
6.0
0.45 to
0.65
0.50
B6L
W50230
0.05
1.25
1.00
0.030
0.025
0.40
4.0 to
6.0
0.45 to
0.65
0.50
B8
W50431
0.05 to
0.12
1.25
1.00
0.030
0.040
0.40
8.0 to
10.5
0.85 to
1.20
0.50
B8L
W50430
0.05
1.25
1.00
0.030
0.040
0.40
8.0 to
10.5
0.85 to
1.20
0.50
B91i
W50531
0.08 to
0.13
1.20j
0.50
0.015
0.020
0.80j
8.0 to
10.5
0.85 to
1.20
0.15 to
0.30
0.04
0.25
Nb: 0.02-0.10
N: 0.02-0.07
B92
0.08 to
0.15
1.20j
0.50
0.015
0.020
0.80j
8.0 to
10.0
.0.30 to
0.70
0.15 to
0.30
0.04
0.25
Nb: 0.02-0.08
W: 1.5-2.0
N: 0.02-0.08
Cok
W2103X
0.12
1.75
0.80
0.030
0.030
0.80 to
1.10
0.15
0.35
0.05
1.8h
Ni2
W2203X
0.12
1.50
0.80
0.030
0.030
1.75 to
2.75
1.8h
Ni3
W2303X
0.12
1.50
0.80
0.030
0.030
2.75 to
3.75
1.8h
Illustration 4-12 Chemical Composition Requirements for Carbon and Low Alloy Steel Flux Cored Electrodesa
(Source: AWS A5.36)
22
Weld Metal
UNS
Designation Numberb
Mn
Si
Weight Percentc
Ni
Cr
Mo
Al
Cu
Otherd
W1913X
0.12
1.25 to
2.00
0.80
0.030
0.030
0.25 to
0.55
D2
W1923X
0.15
1.65 to
2.25
0.80
0.030
0.030
0.25 to
0.55
D3
W1933X
0.12
1.00 to
1.75
0.80
0.030
0.030
0.40 to
0.65
W2113X
0.15
0.80 to
1.40
0.80
0.030
0.030
0.80 to
1.10
0.15
0.20 to
0.65
0.05
K2
W2123X
0.15
0.50 to
1.75
0.80
0.030
0.030
1.00 to
2.00
0.15
0.35
0.05
1.8h
K3
W2133X
0.15
0.75 to
2.25
0.80
0.030
0.030
1.25 to
2.60
0.15
0.20 to
0.65
0.05
K4
W2223X
0.15
1.25 to
2.25
0.80
0.030
0.030
1.75 to
2.60
0.20 to
0.60
0.20 to
0.65
0.05
K5
W2162X
0.10 to
0.25
0.60 to
1.60
0.80
0.030
0.030
0.75 to
2.00
0.20 to
0.60
0.15 to
0.55
0.05
K6
W2104X
0.15
0.50 to
1.50
0.80
0.030
0.030
0.40 to
1.00
0.20
0.15
0.05
1.8h
K7
W2105X
0.15
1.00 to
1.75
0.80
0.030
0.030
2.00 to
2.75
K8
W2143X
0.15
1.00 to
2.00
0.40
0.030
0.030
0.50 to
1.50
0.20
0.20
0.05
1.8h
K9
W2323X
0.07
0.50 to
1.50
0.60
0.015
0.015
1.30 to
3.75
0.20
0.50
0.05
0.06
K10
0.12
1.25 to
2.25
0.80
0.030
0.030
1.75 to
2.75
0.20
0.50
0.50
K11
0.15
1.00 to
2.00
0.80
0.030
0.030
0.40 to
1.00
0.20
0.50
0.05
1.8h
W2
W2013X
0.12
0.50 to
1.30
0.030
0.030
0.35 to
0.80
0.40 to
0.80
0.45 to
0.70
0.30 to
0.75
GSn
a) The weld metal shall be analyzed for the specific elements for which values are shown in this table.
b) Refer to ASTM DS-56/SAE HS-1086, Metals and Alloys in the Unified Numbering System. An X, when present in the last position, represents the usability designator for the
electrode type used to deposit the weld metal. An exception to this applies to the 11 electrode type where a 9 is used instead of an 11.
c) Single values arc maximums.
d) An analysis of the weld deposit for for boron is required and shall be reported if this element is intentionally added or if it is known to be present at levels in excess of 0.0010%.
e) The total of all the elements listed in this classification shall not exceed 5%.
f) The analysis of these elements shall be reported only if intentionally added.
g) Meets the lower Mn requirements of the A-No. 1 Analysis Group in the ASME Boiler and Pressure Vessel Code, Section DC, Welding and Brazing Qualifications, QW-422.
h) Applicable to self-shielded electrodes only. Electrodes intended for use with gas shielding normally do not have significant additions of aluminum.
i) The B91 designation is a new designation, replacving the B9 designation previously used for this alloy type.
j) Mn+Ni = 1.40% maximum. See AWS A5.36/A.536M, A7.17.2 in Annex A.
k) Analysis for Co is required to be reported if intentionally added, or if it is known to be present at levels greater than 0.20%.
m) The limit for gas-shielded electrodes is 0.18% maximum. The limit for self-shielded electrodes is 0.30% maximum.
n) The composition of weld metal is not particulalry meaningful since electrodes in this category are intended only for single pass welds. Dilution from the base metal in such weld is
usually quite high. See AWS A5.36/A.536M, A7.2 in Annex A.
Illustration 4-12 Chemical Composition Requirements for Carbon and Low Alloy Steel Flux Cored Electrodesa
(Source: AWS A5.36)
23
AWSd
Classification
UNS
Numberc
Weight Percentb,c
C
Cr
Ni
Mo
Nb + Ta
Mn
Si
Cu
Other
0.13
18.0 to
20.5
18.0 to
21.0
18.0 to
21.0
18.0 to
21.0
18.0 to
21.0
18.0 to
21.0
22.0 to
25.0
22.0 to
25.0
22.0 to
25.0
21.0 to
25.0
21.0 to
25.0
20.5 to
23.5
22.0 to
25.0
25.0 to
28.0
28.0 to
32.0
17.0 to
20.0
17.0 to
20.0
17.0 to
20.0
18.0 to
21.0
9.0 to
10.5
9.0 to
11.0
9.0 to
11.0
9.0 to
11.0
9.0 to
11.0
9.0 to
12.0
12.0 to
14.0
12.0 to
14.0
12.0 to
14.0
12.0 to
16.0
12.0 to
16.0
15.0 to
17.0
12.0 to
14.0
20.0 to
22.5
8.0 to
10.5
11.0 to
14.0
11.0 to
14.0
11.0 to
14.0
12.0 to
14.0
0.5 to
1.5
1.0
0.04
0.03
0.75
0.75
1.0
0.04
0.03
0.75
0.75
3.30 to
4.75
0.5 to
2.5
0.5 to
2.5
0.5 to
2.5
0.5 to
2.5
0.5 to
2.5
0.5 to
2.5
0.5 to
2.5
0.5 to
2.5
0.5 to
2.5
0.5 to
2.5
0.5 to
2.5
0.5 to
2.5
1.0 to
2.5
0.5 to
2.5
0.5 to
2.5
0.5 to
2.5
0.5 to
2.5
0.5 to
2.5
1.0
0.04
0.03
0.75
1.0
0.04
0.03
0.75
1.0
0.04
0.03
0.75
1.0
0.04
0.03
0.75
1.0
0.04
0.03
0.75
1.0
0.04
0.03
0.75
1.0
0.04
0.03
0.75
1.0
0.04
0.03
0.75
1.0
0.04
0.03
0.75
1.0
0.04
0.03
0.75
1.0
0.04
0.03
0.75
1.0
0.03
0.03
0.75
1.0
0.04
0.03
0.75
1.0
0.04
0.03
0.75
1.0
0.04
0.03
0.75
1.0
0.04
0.03
0.75
1.0
0.04
0.03
0.75
0.5 to
2.5
1.0
0.04
0.03
0.75
E307TX-X
W30731
E308TX-X
W30831
0.08
E308HTX-X
W30831
0.04 to
0.08
E308LTX-X
W30835
0.04
E308HMoTX-X
W30832
0.08
E308LMoTX-X
W30838
0.04
E309TX-X
W30931
0.10
E309HTX-X
W30931
0.04 to
0.10
E309LTX-X
W30935
0.04
E309LMoTX-X
W30939
0.12
E309LNiMoTX-X W30938
0.04
E309NiMoTX-X
W30936
0.04
E309LNbTX-X
W30932
0.04
E310TX-X
W31031
0.20
E312TX-X
W31331
0.15
E316TX-X
W31631
0.08
E316HTX-X
W31631
0.04 to
0.08
E316LTX-X
W31635
0.04
E317LTX-X
W31735
0.04
0.75
2.0 to
3.0
2.0 to
3.0
0.75
0.50
0.75
2.0 to
3.0
2.0 to
3.0
2.5 to
3.5
0.75
0.70 to
1.00
0.75
0.75
2.0 to
3.0
2.0 to
3.0
2.0 to
3.0
3.0 to
4.0
8xC min
to 1.0
max
E347TX-X
W34731
0.08
18.0 to
21.0
19.0 to
11.0
0.75
E347HTX-X
W34731
0.04 to
0.08
18.0 to
21.0
9.0 to
11.0
0.75
8xC min
to 1.0
max
0.5 to
2.5
1.0
0.04
0.03
0.75
E409TX-X
W40931
0.10
18.0 to
21.0
0.60
0.75
0.80
1.0
0.04
0.03
0.75
E409NbTX-X
W40957
0.10
10.5 to
13.5
0.6
0.5
1.2
1.0
0.04
0.03
0.75
E410TX-X
W41031
0.12
0.60
0.75
1.2
1.0
0.04
0.03
0.75
E410NiMoTX-X
W41036
0.06
4.0 to
5.0
0.40 to
0.70
1.0
1.0
0.04
0.03
0.75
E430TX-X
W43031
0.10
0.60
0.75
1.2
1.0
0.04
0.03
0.75
E430NbTX-X
W43057
0.10
0.6
0.5
1.2
1.0
0.04
0.03
0.75
W39239
0.04
7.5 to
10.0
8.5 to
10.5
8.0 to
10.5
2.5 to
4.0
2.9 to
3.9
2.5 to
4.5
0.5 to
1.5
E2209TX-X
11.0 to
13.5
11.0 to
12.5
15.0 to
18.0
15.0 to
18.0
21.0 to
24.0
24.0 to
27.0
24.0 to
27.0
8xC min
to 1.0
max
Ti=10xC
min to 1.5
max
0.5 to
2.0
0.5 to
1.5
0.5 to
2.5
1.0
0.04
0.03
0.75
1.5 to
2.5
0.75
W = 10
E2553TX-X
W39533
0.04
E2594TX-X
W39594
0.04
0.75
0.04
0.03
1.0
0.04
0.03
0.08 to
0.20
0.10 to
0.25
0.20 to
0.30
1.0
0.04
0.03
0.75
1.0
0.04
0.03
0.75
Not Specified
EGTX-X g
E307T0-3
W30733
0.13
E308T0-3
W30833
0.08
19.5 to
22.0
19.5 to
22.0
9.0 to
10.5
9.0 to
11.0
0.5 to
1.5
0.75
3.30 to
4.75
0.5 to
2.5
Illustration 4-13 Chemical Composition Requirements for Stainless Steel Flux Cored Electrodes
(Source: AWS A5.22)
24
AWSd
Classification
UNS
Numberc
Weight Percentb,c
C
Cr
Ni
9.0 to
11.0
9.0 to
11.0
9.0 to
11.0
9.0 to
10.7
9.0 to
12.0
12.0 to
14.0
12.0 to
14.0
12.0 to
16.0
12.0 to
16.0
12.0 to
14.0
20.0 to
22.5
8.0 to
10.5
11.0 to
14.0
11.0 to
14.0
11.0 to
14.0
13.0 to
15.0
Mo
Nb + Ta
Mn
Si
Cu
Other
0.75
1.0
0.04
0.03
0.75
0.75
1.0
0.04
0.03
0.75
2.0 to
3.0
1.8 to
2.4
2.0 to
3.0
0.75
0.75
2.0 to
3.0
2.0 to
3.0
0.5 to
2.5
0.5 to
2.5
0.5 to
2.5
1.25 to
2.25
0.5 to
2.5
0.5 to
2.5
0.5 to
2.5
0.5 to
2.5
0.5 to
2.5
0.5 to
2.5
1.0 to
2.5
0.5 to
2.5
0.5 to
2.5
0.5 to
2.5
0.5 to
2.5
0.5 to
2.5
E309LNbT0-3
W30934
0.4
E310T0-3
W31031
0.20
E312T0-3
W31231
0.15
E316T0-3
W31633
0.08
E316LT0-3
W31637
0.04
E316LKT0-3 f
W31630
0.04
E317LT0-3
W31737
0.04
19.5 to
22.0
19.5 to
22.0
18.0 to
21.0
19.0 to
21.5
18.0 to
21.0
23.0 to
25.5
23.0 to
25.5
21.0 to
25.0
21.0 to
25.0
23.0 to
25.5
25.0 to
28.0
28.0 to
32.0
18.0 to
20.5
18.0 to
20.5
17.0 to
20.0
18.5 to
21.0
E347LT0-3
W34733
0.08
19.0 to
21.5
9.0 to
11.0
0.75
8XC min
to 1.0
max
E409LT0-3
W40931
0.10
10.5 to
12.5
0.60
0.75
0.80
1.0
0.04
0.03
0.75
E410LT0-3
W41031
0.12
11.0 to
13.5
11.0 to
12.5
15.0 to
18.0
21.0 to
24.0
24.0 to
27.0
24.0 to
27.0
Ti=10xC
min to 1.5
max
E308HT0-3
W30833
0.08
E308LT0-3
W30837
0.04
E308MoT0-3
W30839
0.08
E308HMoT0-3
W30830
0.07 to
0.12
E308LMoT0-3
W30838
0.4
E309T0-3
W30933
0.10
E309LT0-3
W30937
0.4
E309MoT0-3
W30939
0.12
E309LMoT0-3
W30938
0.4
E410NiMoT0-3
W41036
0.06
E430T0-3
W43031
0.10
E2209T0-3
W39239
0.04
E2553T0-3
W39533
0.04
E2594T0-3
W39594
0.04
0.75
0.70 to
1.00
0.75
0.75
2.0 to
3.0
2.0 to
3.0
2.0 to
3.0
3.0 to
4.0
0.04
0.03
0.75
0.04
0.03
0.75
1.0
0.04
0.03
0.75
1.0
0.04
0.03
0.75
1.0
0.04
0.03
0.75
1.0
0.04
0.03
0.75
1.0
0.04
0.03
0.75
1.0
0.04
0.03
0.75
1.0
0.04
0.03
0.75
1.0
0.04
0.03
0.75
1.0
0.03
0.03
0.75
1.0
0.04
0.03
0.75
1.0
0.04
0.03
0.75
1.0
0.04
0.03
0.75
0.5 to
2.5
1.0
0.04
0.03
0.75
0.60
0.75
1.0
1.0
0.04
0.03
0.75
4.0 to
5.0
0.40 to
0.70
1.0
1.0
0.04
0.03
0.75
0.60
0.75
1.0
1.0
0.04
0.03
7.5 to
10.0
8.5 to
10.5
8.0 to
10.5
2.5 to
4.0
2.9 to
3.9
2.5 to
4.5
0.5 to
2.0
0.5 to
1.5
0.5 to
2.5
1.0
0.04
0.03
0.75
0.04
0.03
1.0
0.04
0.03
1.5
W = 10
1.2
0.04
0.03
0.75
0.08 to
0.75
0.20
0.10 to
0.75
0.25
0.20 to 1.5 to 2.5
0.30
Not Specified
EGTX-3g
R316LT1-5
W31635
0.03
18.0 to
21.0
22.0 to
25.0
17.0 to
20.0
R347T1-5
W34731
0.08
18.0 to
21.0
R308LT1-5
W30835
0.03
R309LT1-5
W30935
0.03
RGT1-5g
1.0
0.25 to
0.80
9.0 to
11.0
12.0 to
14.0
11.0 to
14.0
9.0 to
11.0
0.75
0.75
0.75
2.0 to
3.0
8XC min
to 1.0
max
0.5 to
2.5
0.5 to
2.5
0.5 to
2.5
1.2
0.04
0.03
0.75
1.2
0.04
0.03
0.75
0.5 to
2.5
1.2
0.04
0.03
0.75
Not Specified
a) The weld metal shall be analyzed for the specific elements in this table. If the presence of other elements is indicated in the course of this work, the amount of those elements
shall be determined to ensure that their total (excluding iron) does not exceed 0.50%.
b) Single values shown are maximum.
c) For flux cored electrodes and rods intended for elevated temperature service (above approximately 750 F [400 C] and for post weld heat treatment above 900 F [500 C],
bismuth (Bi) should be restricted to 0.002 wt % (20 ppm) maximum. See AWS A7.24 for more information.
d) In this table, the X following the T refers to the position of welding (1 for all-position or 0 for flat or horizontal operation) and the X following the dash refers to the shielding
medium (-1 or -4) as shown in the AWS Classification column in Table 2.
e) SAE HS-1086 / ASTM DS-56, Metals & Metal Alloys in the Unified Numbering System.
f) This alloy is designed for cryogenic applications.
g) See AWS A2.2.7 and A2.2.8.
Illustration 4-13 Chemical Composition Requirements for Stainless Steel Flux Cored Electrodes
(Source: AWS A5.22)
25
AWSa
Classification
External
Shielding Gasb
Welding
Polarity
EXXXTX-1
CO2
DCEP
EXXXTX-3
None (self-shielded)
DCEP
EXXXTX-4
DCEP
EXXXTX-G
Not Specified
Not Specified
a) The letters XXX stand for the designation of the chemical composition
(see AWS A5.22, Table 1). The X after the T designates the position of operation.
A 0 indicates flat or horizontal operation; a 1 indicates all-position operation.
Refer to AWS A5.22, Figure A and Clause A2 for a complete description of this
classification system.
b) The requirements for the use of a specified external shielding gas shall not be
construed to restrict the use of any other media, for which the electrodes are found
suitable, for any application other than the classification tests.
c) See AWS A2.2.7 to A2.2.9 for additional information.
d) AWS A5.32/A5.32M class SG-C.
e) AWS A5.32/A5.32M class SG-AC-25 or SG-AC-20.
f) AWS A5.32/A5.32M class SG-A.
g) AWS A5.32/A5.32M class SG-A, SG-AO-1 or SG-AO-2.
3) Welding Position Flux cored electrodes are designed to be used in specific positions. Wire diameter
is the major factor limiting the position in which an
electrode can be used. All position electrodes are
available only in the smaller sizes. Flat and horizontal
position only electrodes may have very similar compositions but are available in all sizes or the larger
sizes which cannot be easily used for vertical and
overhead welding. Electrodes should be selected to
match the welding position.
4) Welding Current Flux cored electrodes are designed to operate on either direct current electrode
negative or direct current electrode positive. Electrodes operating on DCEN generally give lighter
penetration and higher deposition rates. Electrodes
operating on DCEP generally provide deeper penetration.
5) Joint Design and Fit-up Electrodes should be
chosen according to their penetration characteristics. Gas-shielded flux cored wires produce deeper
penetration than self-shielding wires. This can have
an effect on the joint design used.
2) Base Metal Composition The chemical composition of the metal to be welded should be known.
Closely matching the filler and base metal compositions is important when corrosion resistance and
creep resistance are needed. The filler metals for
welding stainless steels and alloy steels are usually
chosen on the basis of matching chemical compositions.
26
duces a flat to slightly convex weld bead with a moderate slag coating. T-1 electrodes produce a fine globular
transfer and low spatter levels. Welds produced with T-1
electrodes have good mechanical properties.
A T-2 electrode operates on DCEP and also requires gas
shielding. These electrodes are similar to T-1 types, but
are designed to weld over rust and scale. They are for
single-pass welding only because of their high silicon
and manganese contents.
T-3 electrodes are self-shielding wires using DCEP for
single-pass welding operations. These electrodes produce a fine globular transfer and are designed for welding sheet metal at high welding speeds.
T-4 electrodes are self-shielding wires using DCEP for
single or multiple-pass operation. These electrodes produce a globular metal transfer and light penetration for
joints with poor fit-up. Desulfurizing elements are contained in the flux core to help prevent weld cracking.
T-5 electrodes can be used to weld higher carbon steels,
or for joining low alloy steels to carbon steels because of
cleaner welds and lower hydrogen levels.
T-6 electrodes are self-shielded electrodes for single or
multiple pass welding using DCEP. These electrodes are
characterized by a fine globular transfer and deep penetration. The slag coating has good deep-groove removal
characteristics and produces good low temperature impact properties.
T-7 electrodes are self-shielded electrodes that operate
on DCEN for single or multiple pass welding. The larger
sizes of this type of electrode are designed to produce
high deposition rates. The smaller sizes are used for allposition welding. The slag coating desulfurizes the weld
metal to a very low level which helps prevent cracking.
T-8 electrodes are self-shielding electrodes for single or
multiple pass welding that operate on DCEN. The slag
system is designed to allow all-position welding. The slag
also desulfurizes the weld metal and produces good low
temperature impact properties.
T-10 electrodes are self-shielded, single-pass electrodes
that operate on DCEN. These electrodes are used for
making welds in the flat and horizontal positions at high
travel speeds.
27
CHAPTER 5
WELDING APPLICATIONS
Flux cored arc welding has gained popularity for a wide
variety of applications. Flux cored arc welding has replaced shielded metal arc welding for some applications.
One of the major advantages of the process is the high
deposition rates obtained when compared to manual arc
welding processes. Flux cored arc welding deposition
rates are also generally higher than those obtained from gas metal arc welding. Because
flux cored arc welding is a semiautomatic
process, higher productivity can be obtained
compared to shielded metal arc welding. This
process also lends itself easily to machine
and automatic welding. Because of the versatility of flux cored arc welding, it has obtained wide application in shop fabrication,
maintenance and field erection work.
INDUSTRIES
Structures
One of the most important applications of flux cored arc
welding is in the structural fabrication industry. A wide
variety of low carbon and low alloy steels in many different thicknesses are used in this industry. Welding is done
in the shop and the field and flux cored arc welding is
readily adaptable to both types of wires. The major advantages of this process in the structural industry are the
high deposition rates, high production rates, deep penetrating characteristics and the adaptability of the process
for field erection welding. Because a large percentage of
the welds made in structural work are fillets, flux cored
arc welding is widely used for making large single-pass
fillet welds. Many of these welds would require multiple
passes using gas metal arc welding and shielded metal
arc welding.
28
which makes them more difficult to use. Most of the electrodes used for flux cored arc welding of pipe are gasshielded because of the better penetration produced and
the generally better mechanical properties produced.
Railroads
Flux cored arc welding is used extensively in the railroad
industry. Other processes such as shielded metal arc
welding, gas metal arc welding and submerged arc welding are also widely employed, so the choice of the welding process is based on the weld size, joint accessibility,
joint length and welding position. The longest welds on
the heavier metal thicknesses in the flat position are generally welded using submerged arc welding. Flux cored
arc welding is usually used on the heavier metal thicknesses where submerged arc welding is not practical.
Examples would be for joints in other positions, shorter
joints and where accessibility is more limited. Flux cored
arc welding is preferred over shielded metal arc welding
and gas metal arc welding for many uses because of the
higher deposition rates obtained.
Many different components on the engines and the rail
cars are commonly welded.
Most manufacturers of railroad engines and cars primarily use the gas-shielded electrode wires. Self shielding
electrodes are sometimes used where lighter penetration is desirable. Flux cored wires that have good weld-
29
The flux cored arc welding process is very useful for maintenance and surfacing operations. Maintenance operations range from repairing and modifying plant and build-
30
The advantages of flux cored arc spot welding over resistance spot welding are:
1) Access is only required from the top of the joint
2) Flux cored arc spot welding can be done in all positions more easily
3) The gun is light and portable and can be taken to the
weldment
4) Weld joint fit-up is not as critical
5) Faster production rates can be obtained, particularly
on thicker metal
The main disadvantage of flux cored arc spot welding is
the consistency of weld size and strength is not as good.
Either the gas-shielded or self-shielded flux cored electrodes may be used. The weld is made by depressing the
trigger which starts the shielding gas, if used, and, after a
preflow interval, starts the arc and the wire feed. The arc
melts through the top sheet of the lap joint and fuses into
the bottom sheet. When the preset weld time is finished,
the arc and wire feed are stopped, followed by the gas
flow, if used. Metals of the same or different thicknesses
can be made. If dissimilar thicknesses are being welded,
the thinner member should always be placed on top. The
length of the spot weld cycle affects the penetration and
the amount of reinforcement on the surface of the weld
bead. Flux cored arc spot welding generally produces
larger, stronger weld nuggets on the same metal thicknesses as compared to gas metal arc spot welding. The
rest of the welding variables affect the weld in the same
way as normal weld.
31
CHAPTER 6
COST OF FLUX CORED ARC WELDING
The cost of welding is an important factor to consider
when selecting a welding process for an application. Flux
cored arc welding has advantages over other processes
which make it the most economical welding method for
many different applications. Factors such as deposition
rates, welding speeds, joint preparation time, operator
factors, and welding material costs must be compared to
properly choose a welding process.
The initial investment for the equipment can vary considerably depending on the size and complexity of the
equipment used. The equipment used is often basically
the same as for gas metal arc welding. Because of the
higher current levels used in flux cored arc welding, larger
power sources may be needed. With the self-shielding
electrode wires, a gas shielding system is not needed,
which simplifies and reduces the overall cost of the
equipment. In some cases where gas metal arc welding
equipment is available, a change to flux cored arc welding
would require almost no new equipment. The equipment
for semiautomatic welding is much less expensive than
equipment for automatic welding.
An advantage of flux cored arc welding over the manual
welding processes is that a lower degree of welder skill is
needed. A welder skilled in gas metal arc welding would
have very little trouble learning the flux cored arc welding
process that generally has good welder appeal. This is
particularly true when compared to gas metal arc welding at the higher current levels. Another example is the
comparison to semiautomatic submerged arc welding
where it is more difficult to weld because the weld puddle
is not visible. Semiautomatic flux cored arc welding usually competes with shielded metal arc welding, gas metal
arc welding and submerged arc welding. Automatic flux
cored arc welding usually competes with automatic gas
metal arc welding and submerged arc welding. In flux
cored arc welding, the costs of materials will vary depending on the electrode and whether or not shielding
gas is required. The electric power cost will depend on
the machine and the welding parameters.
The cost of this process consists of four major items which
are the labor and overhead, electrodes, shielding gas and
electric power. The cost calculation methods used in this
chapter can be used to compare the cost of flux cored arc
welding to the other processes.
LABOR COST
The labor cost is usually the largest cost factor of a process. Labor and overhead costs are generally combined
in cost calculations, which is common practice in many
plants. The overhead normally includes items such as
Overhead
ELECTRODE COST
The cost of the electrode wire per weld is determined by
several factors. The first is the weight of the weld deposited, which is dependent on the size and shape of the weld
to be made. A second factor is the cost per pound of
electrode wire, which is dependent on the type and size
of the electrode wire. Some types of mild steel electrodes
are substantially less expensive than other types. Small
diameter flux cored electrodes cost more per pound than
larger diameter flux cored electrodes because of the additional wire drawing operations required. Electrode wire is
less expensive per pound when supplied in a reel or large
coil, as compared to a small coil. The total amount of wire
32
.045"
2375
1/16"
1230
5/64"
996
3/32"
640
7/64"
469
1/8"
346
3/32"
225
Cost of
Gas per
Cubic Ft.
Inches of Wire
Per Pound
3704
Gas
Flow
For the first equation, the wire weight per unit of length
is needed. This figure will vary depending on the type of
electrode wire used. Some flux cored electrodes contain
more core elements than others. This is true of the selfshielding wires when compared to gas-shielded wires. A
good approximation of the percent fill or amount of flux
in a tubular wire for cost calculations is about 16% by
weight. This gives the inches of wire per pound as shown
in Illustration 6-1.
.035"
Deposition Efficiency
Wire
Diameter
Arc
Time
33
Welding
Welding
Current X Voltage
Power Source Efficiency
Arc
X Time X
Power Cost
per kW-hr
1000
SMAW
Manual
GMAW
Semiautomatic
E7024
E70S-3
E70T-4
E70T-1
EM 12K
Electrode Diameter
1/4"
1/16"
3/32"
3/32"
3/32"
380
350
375
475
550
33
25
28
29
33
11
18
12
15
12
45
35
.0995
.0654
.0587
.0556
.0605
.0348
.0327
.0264
.0250
.0272
270
215
200
120
30.00
30.00
30.00
30.00
30.00
35
50
45
45
45
.425
.425
.425
.425
.425
1.00
1.60
3.00
.3.00
1.60
67
93
80
90
100*
12.2
13.0
16.1
17.0
15.6
.13
.13
.33
.33
.50
.53
.06
.06
.06
.06
.06
50
80
80
80
80
2.99
1.96
1.76
1.66
1.82
.634
.731
1.594
1.417
.680
.265
.114
.114
.052
.022
.021
.025
.037
3.676
2.827
3.375
3.216
2.802
FCAW
Semiautomatic
SAW
Semiautomatic
34
Examples
Illustration 6-2 shows the figures used for a cost calculation comparison of shielded metal arc welding, gas metal
arc welding, flux cored arc welding using a self-shielding
wire, flux cored arc welding using a gas-shielded wire and
submerged arc welding. The examples given are fairly
typical but the exact data should be obtained from the
manufacturers data sheets and the actual welding conditions.
In equations where arc time is necessary, it can be determined from the following equation:
Length of Weld X Number Passes
Arc Time =
Travel Speed
Weight of Deposit
Or...
Deposition Rate
The following is a sample cost per foot of weld calculation for making a 1/2 in. (12.7 mm) fillet weld in the horizontal
position using semiautomatic flux cored arc welding with a gas-shielded electrode. Figures for calculation are taken
from Illustration 6-1 and 6-2.
Labor Cost =
Labor + Overhead
Cost/hr
Pounds of Weld
Deposit/Weld
Electric
Power Cost =
Arc
Time
Welding
Welding
Current X Voltage
Power Source Efficiency
Gas
Flow
Arc
X Time X
Cost of
Gas per
Cubic Ft.
= $1.66
17 lbs/hr X 45 %
.0250 hr/ft X 12000 in/hr X
(200 IPM x 60 min)
1 lb
X 3.00 $/lb
640 in.
= $1.417
90 %
Power Cost
per kW-hr =
1000
.025
X hr/ft X
.06 $/kW-hr
1000
= $.114
= $.025
35
CHAPTER 7
WELDING METALLURGY
PROPERTIES OF THE WELD
MECHANICAL PROPERTIES
The properties of a weld include the chemical composition, mechanical strength, ductility, toughness, and the
microstructure. These items will relate to the weldability
of the metal. The weldability of a metal is the quality obtained and the ease of welding for the intended service
conditions. The chemical, physical and mechanical properties of the weld are affected by the types of materials used. The mechanical properties and microstructure
are determined by the heat input as well as the chemical
composition and physical properties of the weld.
CHEMICAL COMPOSITION
The chemical composition of the base and filler metal
have a great influence on the weldability of a metal. This
property has an influence of the preheating and postheating used, as well as the welding parameters. For the
welding of stainless steels, the chemical composition of
the weld is often the most important property. The chemical composition of the weld must match the composition
of the base metal when corrosion resistance, thermal and
electrical conductivity, and appearance are major considerations. The chemical composition can also affect
the high and low temperature strength, as well as the microstructure and mechanical properties of the weld.
Preheating reduces the cooling rate of the weld after
welding to prevent cracking. The amount of preheat
needed depends on the type of metal being welded,
the metal thickness, and the amount of joint restraint. In
steels, those with higher carbon contents need higher
preheat than those with lower carbon equivalents. Illustration 7-1 shows typical preheat values for different metals welded by flux cored arc welding.
Another major factor that determines the amount of preheat needed is the thickness of the base metal. Thicker
base metals usually need higher preheat temperatures
than thinner base metals. Thick metal draws the heat
away from the welding zone quicker because there is a
large mass of metal to absorb the heat. This would cause
a quicker cooling of the weld if the same preheat temperature was used, as on thinner base metals. The third
major factor for determining the amount of preheat needed is the amount of joint restraint. Joint restraint is the resistance of a joint configuration to moving or relieving the
stresses due to welding during the heating and cooling of
the weld zone. Where there is high resistance to moving
or high joint restraint, large amounts of internal stresses
build up. Higher preheat temperatures are needed as the
amount of joint restraint increases. Slower cooling rates
reduce the amount of internal stresses that are building
up as the weld cools.
36
Type of Metal
Preheat
400-500 F (205-260 C)
Room Temperature
500 F (260 C)
200-300 F (93-150 C)
Carbon .20%-.35%
600-800 F (315-425 C)
900-1100 F (480-595 C)
400-500 F (205-260 C)
Up to 750 F (400 C)
Carbon less than .15%
Room Temperature
400-650 F (205-345 C)
150-300 F (66-150 C)
300-350 F (150-260 C)
Cast Irons
700-900 F (370-480 C)
Nickel
200-300 F (93-150 C)
Room Temperature
400-600 F (205-315 C)
Copper
500-800 F (260-425 C)
Aluminum
37
Liquid
1. Crystal Formation
The heat affected zone is an area of change in the microstructure of the base metal. The area that is closest
to the weld metal usually undergoes grain growth. Other
parts of the heat affected zone will go through grain refinement. Other areas may be annealed and considerably
softened. Because of the changes due to the heat input
and cooling rate, areas of the heat affected zone can become embrittled and become the source of cracking. A
large heat input during welding will cause a larger heat
affected zone. This is often not desirable, so the welding
parameters used can help influence the size of the heat
affected zone.
Liquid
Steels
Flux cored arc welding is widely used for welding steels.
In general, steel is classified according to the carbon
content, such as low carbon, mild, medium carbon, and
high carbon steels. In addition, steel is also classified according to the alloys used. For the purpose of discussion
in this chapter, the different steels will be grouped according to their welding characteristics.
When welding steel, the carbon and other alloy content
influences the hardness and hardenability of the weld
metal which, in turn, influences the amount of preheat
Solid Grains
(Dendrites)
2. Solidification
Grains
3. Complete Solidification
WELDABLE METALS
Flux cored arc welding is commonly used to weld most
steels and stainless steels. Some nickel alloys are also
welded by this process. Most nonferrous metals are not
welded by this process because of the high heat input
and because suitable electrode wires have not been developed.
Initial
Crystals
38
39
40
41
AISI
Number
Carbon
201
202
0.15 max.
0.15 max.
301
302
302B
303
303Se
304
304L
305
308
309
309S
310
310S
314
316
316L
317
321
347
348
0.15 max.
0.15 max.
0.15 max.
0.15 max.
0.15 max.
0.08 max.
0.03 max.
0.12 max.
0.08 max.
0.20 max.
0.08 max.
0.25 max.
0.08 max.
0.25 max.
0.08 max.
0.03 max.
0.08 max.
0.08 max.
0.08 max.
0.08 max.
403
410
414
416
416Se
420
431
440A
440B
440C
0.15 max.
0.15 max.
0.15 max.
0.15 max.
0.15 max.
Over 0.15
0.20 max.
0.60-0.85
0.75-0.95
0.95-1.2
405
430
430F
430Se
446
0.08 max.
0.12 max.
0.12 max.
0.12 max.
0.20 max.
501
502
Over 0.10
0.10 max.
Manganese
Silicon
Chromium
Chromium-Nickel-Magnesium-Austenitic-Nonhardenable
5.5-7.5
1.0
16.0-18.0
7.5-10.
1.0
17.0-19.0
Chromium-Austenitic-Nonhardenable
2.0
1.0
16.0-18.0
2.0
1.0
17.0-19.0
2.0
2.0-3.0
17.0-19.0
2.0
1.0
17.0-19.0
2.0
1.0
17.0-19.0
2.0
1.0
18.0-20.0
2.0
1.0
18.0-20.0
2.0
1.0
17.0-19.0
2.0
1.0
19.0-21.0
2.0
1.0
22.0-24.0
2.0
1.0
22.0-24.0
2.0
1.0
24.0-26.0
2.0
1.50
24.0-26.0
2.0
1.50
23.0-26.0
2.0
1.5-3.0
16.0-18.0
2.0
1.0
16.0-18.0
2.0
1.0
18.0-20.0
2.0
1.0
17.0-19.0
2.0
1.0
17.0-19.0
2.0
1.0
17.0-19.0
Chromium-Martensitic-Hardenable
1.0
.05
11.5-13.0
1.0
1.0
11.5-13.5
1.0
1.0
11.5-13.5
1.25
1.0
12.0-14.0
1.25
1.0
12.0-14.0
1.0
1.0
12.0-14.0
1.0
1.0
15.0-17.0
1.0
1.0
16.0-18.0
1.0
1.0
16.0-18.0
1.0
1.0
16.0-18.0
Chromium-Ferritic-Nonhardenable
1.0
1.0
11.5-14.5
1.0
1.0
14.0-18.0
1.25
1.0
14.0-18.0
1.25
1.0
14.0-18.0
1.50
1.0
23.0-27.0
Martensitic
1.0
1.0
4.0-6.0
1.0
1.0
4.0-6.0
Nickel
Other
Elements
3.5-5.5
4.0-6.0
N2 0.25 max.
N2 0.25 max.
6.0-8.0
8.0-10.0
8.0-10.0
8.0-10.0
8.0-10.0
8.0-10.0
8.0-10.0
10.0-13.0
10.0-12.0
12.0-15.0
12.0-15.0
19.0-22.0
19.0-22.0
19.0-22.0
10.0-14.0
10.0-14.0
11.0-15.0
9.0-12.0
9.0-13.0
9.0-13.0
S 0.15 min.
Se 0.15 min.
Mo 2.0-3.0
Mo 2.0-3.0
Mo 3.0-4.0
Ti 5xC min.
Cb + Ta 10xC min.
Ta 0.10 max.
1.25-2.5
1.25-2.5
S 0.15 min.
Se 0.15 min.
Mo 0.75 max.
Mo 0.75 max.
Mo 0.75 max.
Al 1.1-0.3
S 0.15 min
Se 0.15 min.
N 0.25 max.
Mo 0.40-0.65
Mo 0.40-0.65
Illustration 7-6 AISI Stainless Steel Classification System (Courtesy of the American Iron and Steel Institute)
42
CHAPTER 8
WELD AND JOINT DESIGN
2) Strength Required
3) Welding Position
4) Joint Accessibility
5) Metal Thickness
6) Type of Metal
The weld joint designs used in flux cored arc welding are
determined by the design of the weldment, metallurgical
considerations, and codes or specifications. Another factor to consider is the method of flux cored arc welding
to be used. A properly selected joint design should allow
the highest quality weld to be made at the lowest possible cost. A weld joint consists of a specific weld being
made in a specific joint. A joint is defined as the junction
of members that are to be, or have been, joined. Illustration 8-1 shows the five basic joint types.
All of the five basic joint types are applicable to flux cored
arc welding, although the butt and T-joints are the most
widely used. Lap joints have the advantage of not requiring much preparation other than squaring off the edges
and making sure the members are in close contact. Edge
joints
are widely used on thin metal. Corner
Lapjoints generalButt
Lap
ly use similarCorner
edge preparations
to those used on T-joints.
Corner
Butt
1) Process Method
B Butt
C Corner
Butt
Butt
E Edge
L Lap
Lap
Lap
Corner
Corner
Butt
Corner
TT
Lap
1
2
1
2
1
Edge
T-Joint
Edge
T-Joint
Illustration 8-1 There are only five basic joints. They can, however, be used in combinations.
13
12
3
3
4
13
8
12
14
14
12
Plug
T-Joint
Plug
Slot
Slot
Edge
T-Joint
T-Joint
2. Single-V-Groove
3. Single-Bevel-Groove
4. Double-V-Groove
5. Double-Bevel-Groove
Groove
Edge
Edge
1. Square-Groove
13
12
13
12
149
13
12
16
Gro
14
15
Plug
Plug
Slot
Slot
14 16
Plug
15
6. Single-U-Groove
13
12
Slot Groove
9. Double-J-Groove
Groove
Bead
Groove
Bead 10. Single Fillet
Arc Seam Arc Seam
12
2
5
13
14
13 7
12
10
15
12
16
13
14
6
4
14
16
10
3
15
8. Single-J-Groove
10
16
15
14
13
12
16
15
4
2
7. Double-U-Groove
13
15 12
14
11
14
Arc Seam
11. Double Fillet
Arc Seam
11
Bead
Bead
12. Single-FlareArc SeamV-Groove
10
12
16
11
15
12
15
5
7 4
14
16
Bead
13. Edge
Weld in a
Flanged Butt Joint
Edge
13
13
11
12
14. Bead
14
13
12
14
10
13
16
15. Plug
15. Arc-Spot
or Arc-Seam
15
Edge Fillet
16
15
Fillet
10
11
16
14
Illustration 8-2 Common Types of Welds (Many other variations of welds are possible)
15
14
Edge
Edge
6
10
15
6
Fillet
Fillet
15
16
10
16
43
7
15 11
16
16
10
10
Groove Weld
5
6
7
4 5
Fillet Weld
5
2
3
1 2 3
1 2 3
47
56
Many of the joint designs used for flux cored arc welding are similar to those used in gas metal arc welding or
shielded metal arc welding. Flux cored arc welding has
some characteristics which may affect the joint design.
The joint should be designed so the welder has good access to the joint and is able to properly manipulate the
electrode. Joints must be located so that an adequate
distance between the joint and nozzle of the welding gun
is created. The proper distance will vary depending on
the type of flux cored electrode being used.
PROCESS METHOD
The joint design, as well as the welding procedure, will
vary depending on whether the welding is done using
gas-shielded or self-shielded electrodes. Both methods
of flux cored arc welding achieve deeper penetration
than shielded metal arc welding. This permits the use
of narrower grooves with smaller groove angles, larger
root faces and narrower root openings. Differences also
exist between the two flux cored arc welding methods
because of the deeper penetration that is produced by
the gas-shielded electrode wires. Illustration 8-4 shows a
comparison of a flat position, V-groove weld on a backing strip for each of the two methods.
The joint design for the self-shielding wire requires a larger root opening to allow better access to the root of the
joint. The joint design for the gas-shielded wire does not
need such a wide root opening because complete penetration is easier to obtain. This weld would be less expensive to make using the gas-shielded electrode because
less filler metal is required. This difference in joint design
usually only applies when a backing strip is employed.
For joints not requiring a backing strip, gas-shielded and
self-shielded wires use the same joint designs.
STRENGTH
The strength required of a weld joint is a major factor
governing weld joint design. Weld joints may be either
full or partial penetration, depending on the strength required of the joint. Full or complete penetrating welds are
those that have weld metal through the full cross section of the joint. Partial penetrating welds are those where
weld metal only extends partially through the joint thickness. Welds that are subject to cyclic, impact, or static
loading require complete penetration. This is even more
important for applications that require low temperature
service. Partial penetration welds may be adequate for
joints where loading is static only. This type of joint is
easier to prepare and requires less filler metal than full
penetration joints. Fillet welds of the same leg size made
by this process are stronger than those made by shielded
metal arc welding. This is because of the deeper penetration obtained from flux cored arc welding, as shown
44
30
30
3/16
3/8
Gas-Shielded Electrode
Self-Shielded Electrode
Illustration 8-4 Comparison between Gas-Shielded and Self-Shielded Wire Joint Designs for the Flat Position
SMAW
Effective
Throat
FCAW
Effective
Throat
POSITION
Flux cored arc welding may be used in all welding positions based on the size and type of electrode wire used.
A diagram of the welding position capabilities is shown
in Illustration 8-6.
Welding positions are classified by a set of numbers and
letters. The four basic welding positions are designated
by the numbers 1 for flat, 2 for horizontal, 3 for vertical
and 4 for overhead. A G designation indicates a groove
weld and an F designation indicates a fillet weld. The 2G,
5G and 6G positions are used in pipe welding. The large
diameter wires which are over 1/16 in. (1.6 mm) in diameter are limited to the flat and horizontal positions only
because the weld puddle becomes too large to control.
The smaller diameter electrodes, which are 1/16 in. (1.6
mm) and less can generally be used easily in all positions.
The joint configuration will vary depending on the position of welding. One example of this is that wider groove
angles are needed for vertical position welding. This is
done to provide enough room to manipulate the electrode wire in the joint. Weaving of the electrode is usually
required in vertical position welding to prevent excessive
reinforcement or dropping the weld metal out of the puddle. Joint designs for overhead welding are generally the
same as for flat position welding. Joints that are welded
in the horizontal position often have an unsymmetrical
joint configuration. This usually consists of a groove angle that has a horizontal lower groove face as shown in
Illustration 8-7. The upper groove face is raised accordingly to provide a groove angle that is large enough to
provide good access. The horizontal lower groove face
is used as a shelf to support the molten weld metal. This
joint configuration is less expensive to prepare because
the bevel is only made in one plate.
45
Fillet Welds
FLAT POSITION
1F
HORIZONTAL POSITION
2F
VERTICAL POSITION
3F
OVERHEAD POSITION
4F
Axis of Weld
Horizontal
Axis of Weld
Horizontal
Axis of Weld
Vertical
Axis of Weld
Horizontal
Groove Welds
FLAT POSITION
1G
HORIZONTAL POSITION
2G
VERTICAL POSITION
3G
OVERHEAD POSITION
4G
FLAT
1G
HORIZONTAL
2G
HORIZONTAL FIXED
5G
45 FIXED
6G
Bell Hole
45 5
46
THICKNESS
The thickness of the base metal has a large influence on
the joint preparation required to produce the best quality weld joint. Flux cored arc welding is used to weld
thicknesses down to 18 gauge (1.2 mm). The process is
also suitable for welding thick metal. Because of this, a
wide variety of joint designs are used. The most common
groove preparations used on butt joints are the squareV, J, U-bevel, and combination-grooves. The square-J,
bevel, and combination-groove preparations are also
used on T-joints. The different preparations are employed
on different thicknesses to make it possible to get complete or adequate penetration.
Square-groove welds are used on the thinnest metal
thicknesses. The square-groove joint design is the easiest to prepare and requires the least filler metal. Thicknesses up to 3/8 in. (9.5 mm) thick can be welded with
full penetration from both sides. This is thicker than the
square-groove joints that can be welded with full penetration by shielded metal arc welding or gas tungsten arc
welding, because of the hotter arc and deeper penetration produced by this process. Root openings are used
to allow complete penetration through the joint. Many
square-groove welds are made in one pass. A backing
strip may be used so that the root can be opened enough
to provide better accessibility and insure adequate penetration.
V-grooves for butt joints and bevel-grooves for T-joints
are commonly used for thicker metal up to about 3/4 in.
(19.1 mm). These joints are more difficult to prepare and
require more filler metal than square groove welds. The
included angle for a V-groove is usually up to 75 with
smaller groove angles such as 45 or 60 being more
1/8
45
3/32
3/8
ACCESSIBILITY
The accessibility of the weld joint is another important
factor in determining the weld joint design. Welds can
be made from one or both sides of the weld joint. Single-V, J, U, bevel, and combination grooves are used
when accessibility is from one side only and on thinner
metal. Double-V, J, U, bevel, and combination grooves
are used on thicker metal where the joint can be welded
from both sides. Double-groove welds have three major
advantages over single-groove welds where accessibility
is only from one side. The first is that distortion is more
easily controlled through alternate weld bead sequencing. Weld beads are alternated from one side to the other
to keep the distortion from building up in the one direction. The weld roots are nearer the center of the plate. A
second advantage is that less filler metal is required to
fill a double groove joint than a single-groove joint. This
tends to make double-groove welds more economical on
metal 1 in. (25 mm) thick or greater. The third advantage
is that complete penetration can be more easily insured.
The root of the first pass on the plate can be gouged
or chipped out before the root pass on the second side
is welded, to make sure there is complete fusion at the
root. The disadvantages of joints welded from both sides
are that more joint preparation is required and gouging or
chipping is usually required to remove the root of the first
pass. Savings in the amount of filler metal needed for a
double-groove weld may more than compensate for the
extra joint preparation costs. Both of these add to the
labor time required. Welding on both sides of a squaregroove weld joint provides fuller penetration in thicker
metal than metal welded from one side only. This would
also save joint preparation time.
47
Backing Strips
TYPE OF METAL
30
3/8
Backing Strip
Ranges are given on many of the joint dimensions to account for varying fit-up and types of electrode wires. The
thickness ranges given are those typically recommended
for use with the joint designs. Minimum weld sizes are
commonly used for partial penetration welds. Recommended minimum weld sizes are given in Illustration 8-9.
60
0-1/8
Illustration 8-8 Single-V-Groove Joints with and without
Backing Strip in the Same Thickness of Metal
Minimum
Weld Size
1/8" (3mm)
3/16" (5mm)
1/4" (6mm)
5/16 (8mm)
3/8" (10mm)
1/2" (13mm)
5/8" (16mm)
48
Arrow
Side
Other
Side
Both
Sides
Fillet
No Arrow
Side or
Other Side
Significance
not used
Slot
not used
not used
Plug
not used
not used
Spot or Projection
not used
Stud
not used
not used
Seam
not used
Back or Backing
not used
Surfacing
not used
not used
Edge
not used
not used
not used
Flare-V
not used
Flare Bevel
not used
E
W
E
L
D
Scarf for
Brazed Joint
Arrow Side
of Joint
Other Side
of Joint
Arrow of
Welding
Symbol
T-Joint
Other Side
Member of Joint
Lap Joint
Arrow Side
of Joint
Arrow of
Welding
Symbol
Field
Weld
Consumable
Insert
S or D(S)
Backing
Spacer
Convex
Concave
Process abbreviations
Where process abbreviations are to be included in the
tail of the welding symbol, reference is made to table
1, Designation of Welding and Allied Processes by
Letters of AWS A2.4:2012
American Welding Society
550 N.W. LeJeune Road, Miami, Florida 33126
49
Arrow Side
of Joint
Edge Joint
not used
Meltthru
Arrow of
Welding
Symbol
Contour
Flush or
Flat
Arrow Side
of Joint
Other Side
of Joint
Supplementary Symbols
Weld
Around
Butt Joint
not used
Bevel
Arrow of
Welding
Symbol
not used
not used
not used
Arrow Side
of Joint
Corner Joint
not used
not used
Arrow of
Welding
Symbol
Other Side
of Joint
Square
50
Symbol
Symbol
Symbol
51
Symbol
Symbol
Symbol
52
Symbol
Symbol
Symbol
Symbol
53
Welds
Symbols
Welds
Symbols
Welds
Symbols
Welds
Symbols
54
Welds
Symbols
Welds
Symbols
Welds
Symbols
55
Symbol
Welds
Symbol
Welds
Welds
Symbol
56
Welds
Symbol
Welds
Symbol
Symbol
Welds
57
Symbol
Symbol
(C) Single-V-groove weld
Symbol
(D) Edge weld
Symbol
(B) Corner-flange weld
Symbol
Joint Detailed
58
Symbol
Joint Not Detailed
CHAPTER 9
WELDING PROCEDURE VARIABLES
Welding variables are those factors which affect the operation of the arc and the formation of the weld deposit. A
smooth running arc and a quality weld deposit will result
when all of the variables are in proper balance. It is essential that the effect of each variable on the different properties or characteristics of the weld be fully understood
to increase the probability of producing the required
weld properties. It should also be recognized that some
welding variables are more easily applied as controls of
a welding process. Based on their ability to be used as
controls, welding variables can be divided into three distinct groups or classes. These are the preselected or fixed
variables, primary adjustable variables, and secondary
adjustable variables.
The preselected or fixed variables are those which can
only be changed in large steps or intervals and are therefore unfavorable as controls. For the flux cored arc welding process, these variables are set according to the type
of material being welded, the thickness of the material,
welding position, deposition rate required, and mechanical properties required. These are variables that cannot
be changed once the welding starts.
The primary adjustable variables are used to control the
welding process after the preselected variables have
been established. They control the formation of the weld
bead itself by affecting such things as penetration, bead
width, bead height, arc stability, deposition rate, and weld
soundness. The primary welding variables are welding
voltage, welding current, and travel speed. Because they
can be easily measured and continually adjusted over
a wide range, they can effectively be used as controls.
Specific values can be assigned to the primary adjustable
variables and these values can be accurately reset time
after time.
The secondary adjustable variables can also be changed
continuously over a wide range of values. However, they
are sometimes difficult to measure accurately. Therefore,
it is not easy to employ them as controls since, for the
most part, they cannot be assigned exact values. This
is especially true in semiautomatic welding operations.
Although difficult to measure, these variables should be
controlled within the range for proper operation. Secondary adjustable variables are such things as electrode extension or stick-out, work and travel angles.
The different variables affect the characteristics of the
weld such as the penetration of the weld, bead height,
bead width, and the deposition rate. The definitions of
bead height, bead width, and penetration are shown in
Illustration 9-1.
Bead Width
Bead Height
Penetration
FIXED VARIABLES
Electrode Type
The type of electrode wire will have an effect on the welding characteristics of this process. The flux core of the
electrodes contains different components that affect
bead shape, penetration, deposition rate, and the operating characteristics. Because of this, a wide variety of
operating characteristics exist which are similar to those
found with the various covered electrodes used in shielded metal arc welding. Some self-shielded flux cored
electrodes have been developed to operate on DCEN.
These electrodes produce relatively light penetration and
are used for many sheet welding and weld surfacing operations. Self-shielded electrodes that operate on DCEP
produce deeper penetration. Gas-shielded electrode
wires operate on DCEP and provide the deepest penetration of the different types because of the gas shielding in
addition to the flux core.
Many electrodes are designed to produce a stable arc
and high deposition rates at the higher current levels. Illustrations 9-3 and 9-4 show some deposition rate comparisons between several types of flux cored electrodes.
59
Desired
Characteristic
Welding
Current
Travel
Speed
Nozzle
Angle
Tip-to-Work
Distance
Wire
Size
Gas
Type
Deeper penetration
1. Increase
3. Trailing
Max. 25
2. Decrease
5. Smallera)
4. CO2
Shallower Penetration
1. Decrease
3. Leading
2. Increase
5. Largera)
4. Ar+CO2c)
Bead
Height
and
Width
Larger Bead
1. Increase
2. Decrease
3. Increasea)
Smaller Bead
1. Decrease
2. Increase
3. Decreasea)
Higher, Narrower
1. Decrease
2. Trailing
3. Increase
Flatter, Wider
1. Increase
2. 90 or
Leading
3. Decrease
1. Increase
2. Increasea)
1. Decrease
2. Decreasea) 3. Largerb)
3. Smallerb)
Key: 1. first choice, 2. second choice, 3. third choice, 4. fourth choice, and 5. fifth choice.
a) When these variables are changed, the wire feed speed must be adjusted so that the welding current remains constant.
b) See deposition rate section of welding variables section.
c) This change is especially helpful on materials 20 gauge and smaller thickness.
Illustration 9-2 Recommended Welding Variable Adjustments for Flux Cored Arc Welding
35
35
14
3/32" (2.4)
25
20
8
.045" (1.1)
1/8" (3.2)
10
6
4
12
10
20
8
15
10
1/16" (1.6)
5
14
6
5/64" (2.0)
E70T-8 DCEN
3/32" (2.4)
E70T-8 DCEN
4
2
0
0 100 200 300 400 500 600 700
Welding Current (Amperes)
0
0 100 200 300 400 500 600 700
Welding Current (Amperes)
60
10
15
.120" (3.0)
E70T-4
12
Deposition Rate (kg/hr)
25
30
30
3/32" (2.4)
E70T-4
Electrode Size
Each electrode wire diameter of a given type has a usable
welding current range. Larger diameter electrode wires
use higher welding currents to produce higher deposition rates and deeper penetration. The rate at which the
electrode melts is based on the welding current density
and the components in the flux. If two electrode wires
of the same type, but different diameters, are operated
at the same current level, the smaller electrode will give
a higher deposition rate because the current density is
higher. Illustrations 9-3 and 9-4 also show the deposition rates produced by different electrode diameters. The
amount of penetration is also based on the current density. A smaller electrode will produce deeper penetration
than a larger electrode at the same current setting. The
weld bead will be wider when using the larger electrode
wire. The choice of the optimum electrode size to be
used is based on the thickness of the metal to be welded,
the amount of penetration required, the position of welding, the deposition rate desired, the bead profile desired,
and the cost of the electrode wires. A smaller diameter
electrode is more costly on a weight basis although, for
out-of-position welding, the smaller diameter electrodes
are the only ones that can be used. For each application,
there is an optimum electrode size that can be used to
produce minimum welding costs.
PRIMARY VARIABLES
Welding Current
The amount of welding current has the greatest effect on
the deposition rate, weld bead size and shape, and the
weld penetration. Welding current is proportional to the
wire feed speed for a given electrode type, shielding gas
type and pressure and amount of electrode extension. In
a constant voltage system, the welding current is controlled by the knob on the wire feeder control, which sets
the wire feed speed. The welding current increases with
the wire feed speed.
61
Proper
Current
Current
Too Low
Current
Too High
(91)
30
(76)
24
(61)
18
(46)
12
6
(30)
Penetration
(15)
(0)
34
32
ARC VOLTS
An arc voltage that is too low will cause a narrow convex weld bead with excessive spatter and reduced penetration. Illustrations 9-7 and 9-8 show the effects of the
welding voltage on bead height and bead width.
36
(cm/min)
cause of the decreased penetration obtained. An excessive voltage or arc length will result in excessive amounts
of spatter and irregularly shaped weld beads. When using self-shielded electrodes, an excessive arc length can
also cause nitrogen pickup, which causes porosity in low
carbon steel weld metal. With the self-shielded stainless
steel electrodes nitrogen absorption can cause cracking. With all types of electrodes, undercutting can also
be produced. A decrease in the arc length results in a
narrower weld bead with a greater convexity and deeper
penetration.
30
28
26
24
Travel Speed
The travel speed influences the weld penetration and
the shape of the weld deposit. In semiautomatic welding, this is controlled by the welder and will vary somewhat depending on the welder. In machine and automatic
welding, as shown in Illustration 9-6, the penetration is
at a maximum with a certain travel speed. Increasing or
decreasing the travel speed from this point will reduce
the amount of penetration. When the travel speed is decreased, the amount of filler metal deposited per unit of
length increases, which creates a large, shallow weld
puddle. Weld metal tends to get slightly ahead of the arc
which reduces the penetration and produces a wide weld
bead. Reducing the travel speed will increase the bead
height as is shown in Illustration 9-7. Travel speeds that
are too slow can result in overheating the weld metal because of the excessive heat input, which creates a very
large heat affected zone. It can also cause excessive piling up of the weld metal, which has a rough appearance
and may trap slag. As the travel speed is increased, the
heat input into the base metal is reduced, which decreases the melting of the base metal and limits penetration.
The bead height and the bead width are also reduced.
An excessive travel speed will result in an irregular, ropy
weld bead that may have undercutting along the edges.
The effect of varying the travel speed on a self-shielded
electrode is shown in Illustration 9-10.
22
370
330
290
250
210
170
130
INCREASING PENETRATION
The effects of the primary welding variables are summarized in Illustration 9-11 for gas-shielded flux cored electrodes and in Illustration 9-12 for self-shielded flux cored
electrodes.
Proper
Voltage
Voltage
Too Low
Voltage
Too High
62
(71)
24
(61)
20
(51)
16
(41)
12
(30)
(20)
28
31
(79)
29
(74)
23
(58)
19
(48)
15
(38)
11
(28)
(18)
(cm/min)
(81)
(cm/min)
32
34
34
ARC VOLTS
36
31
28
25
32
30
28
22
26
19
24
ARC VOLTS
Bead Height
37
600
600
550
550
500
500
450
450
400
400
350
350
300
Bead Width
300
Proper
Speed
Too
Fast
Too
Slow
63
GOOD
Proper Current
Voltage & Speed
BAD
Welding Current
Too Low
(High Voltage)
BAD
Welding Current
Too High
(Low Voltage)
BAD
Welding Speed
Too Fast
BAD
Welding Speed
Too Slow
BAD
Insufficient
Shielding Gas
Coverage
Cross-section Fillet
Cross-section Fillet
Cross-section Fillet
Cross-section Fillet
Cross-section Fillet
Cross-section Fillet
A smooth, regular,
well formed bead.
Excessive spatter
and porosity.
Excessive spatter
and porosity
Weld bead
excessively wide
and flat.
Excessive bead
width.
No undercutting,
overlapping or
pileup.
Weld bead
excessively convex
and narrow.
Difficult slag
removal.
Overlapping without
penetration at edges.
Uniform in cross
section.
Undercutting along
edges weakens joint.
Excellent weld at
minimal material and
labor cost.
Irregular bead
contour.
Poor mechanical
properties.
Undercut at toe
lines of fillet
Fillet with
unequal legs.
Wasted filler metal
and productive time.
Illustration 9-11 Examples of Good and Bad Welds Flux Cored with External Shielding Gas
64
GOOD
Proper Current
Voltage & Speed
BAD
Welding Current
Too Low
(High Voltage)
BAD
Welding Current
Too High
(Low Voltage)
BAD
Welding Speed
Too Fast
BAD
Welding Speed
Too Slow
BAD
Insufficient
Shielding Gas
Coverage
Cross-section Fillet
Cross-section Fillet
Cross-section Fillet
Cross-section Fillet
Cross-section Fillet
Cross-section Fillet
A smooth, regular,
well formed bead.
Excessive spatter
and porosity.
Excessive spatter
and porosity
Weld bead
excessively wide
and flat.
Excessive bead
width.
No undercutting,
overlapping or
piling up.
Weld bead
excessively convex
and narrow.
Difficult slag
removal.
Overlapping without
penetration at edges.
Uniform in cross
section.
Undercutting along
edges weakens joint.
Excellent weld at
minimal material and
labor cost.
Irregular bead
contour.
Poor mechanical
properties.
Undercut at toe
lines of fillet
Fillet with
unequal legs.
Wasted filler metal
and productive time.
Illustration 9-12 Examples of Good and Bad Welds Flux Cored without External Shielding Gas
65
Tip-To-Work
Distance
1-1/2
38.1
Contact Tube
50.8
Actual Stickout
Gas Nozzle
25.4
1/2
12.7
SECONDARY VARIABLES
Electrode Extension
The electrode extension is the distance between the tip
of the contact tube and the tip of the electrode as shown
in Illustration 9-13.
The length of electrode that extends beyond the contact tube is resistance heated in proportion to its length.
The amount of resistance heating that occurs affects the
electrode deposition rate and the amount of penetration,
as well as weld quality and arc stability, by varying the
welding current. Increasing the electrode extension reduces the welding current as shown in Illustration 9-14.
In semiautomatic welding, the electrode extension can
be varied by the welder to compensate for joint variation without interrupting the welding operation. Electrode
extension provides a good control during welding to
change the amount of penetration obtained.
In flux cored arc welding, the electrode extension is a
variable that must be held in balance with the shielding
conditions and the related welding variables. As the electrode extension is increased, the amount of preheating of
the wire is increased. For gas-shielded flux cored electrodes, an electrode extension ranging from 3/4 to 1-1/2
in. (19-38 mm) is normally recommended.
Because the shielding comes from the core of selfshielded electrodes alone, a longer electrode extension
is generally recommended to take advantage of the extra
preheating effect which is needed to activate the shielding components in the electrode core. Welding guns for
self-shielded electrodes often have nozzles where the
contact tube is set inside far enough to ensure a minimum electrode extension. Electrode extensions ranging
from 3/4 to 3-1/2 in. (19-89 mm) are commonly used.
This will vary depending on the type of electrode wire
so the manufacturers data should be consulted for each
electrode. An electrode extension that is too long will
produce an unstable arc and cause excessive spatter. An
extension that is too short will cause an excessive arc
length at a particular voltage setting. With gas-shielded
electrodes, excessive spatter may result which can build
up in the nozzle and restrict the shielding gas flow. Poor
shielding gas coverage can result in porosity and surface
oxidation of the weld bead.
The amount of electrode extension also has an effect on
the deposition rate. Increasing the electrode extension
will increase the preheating effect on the electrode and,
therefore, increase the deposition rate. Illustration 9-15
shows this for a gas-shielded flux cored electrode.
66
50.8
1-3/4
44.5
1-1/2
38.1
1-1/4
31.8
25.4
3/4
19.1
1/2
12.7
1/4
6.4
0
10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20
Deposition Rate (lbs/hr)
Electrode Angle
The angle at which the welding electrode is held with
respect to the weld joint is called the electrode angle.
These angles have an effect on the shape of the weld
bead and the amount of penetration. The electrode angles are called the travel and work angles and are shown
in Illustration 9-16.
The travel angle is the angle between the joint and electrode in the longitudinal plane. A push angle exists when
the electrode points in the direction of travel. A drag angle exists when the electrode points in the direction opposite of travel. The work angle is the angle between the
electrode and the plane perpendicular to travel.
The angle at which the electrode is held during welding
determines the direction in which the arc force acts on
the weld pool. The electrode angles are used to shape the
weld bead and to prevent the slag from running ahead of
the weld pool and becoming trapped in the weld. When
making flat position fillet and groove welds, gravity tends
to make the molten slag run ahead of the weld pool. To
compensate for this, a drag angle is used which forces
the slag back. The proper travel angle depends on the
method of flux cored arc welding being used, the thick-
ness of the base metal, and the position of welding. Using gas-shielded electrodes, maximum weld penetration
is obtained with a 10 drag angle. Drag angles ranging
from about 2 to 15 are normally recommended, but a
drag angle greater than 25 should not be used. Drag angles greater than this do not provide good control of penetration. As the drag angle is decreased, the bead height
decreases and the width increases. This effect continues
into the push angle up to a point where the bead will
start to narrow down again. Push angles are generally not
recommended because of the greater chances of slag
entrapment occurring. For self-shielded electrodes, the
drag angles used are similar to those used in shielded
metal arc welding. Flat and horizontal position welding is
done using drag angles ranging from 20 to 45. Larger
angles may be used for thin sections. As the thickness of
the metal increases, smaller angles are used to increase
the penetration. For vertical position, uphill welding, a
push angle of 5 to 10 is recommended.
When making fillet welds in the horizontal position, the
weld metal tends to flow in both the horizontal and vertical directions. To compensate for the vertical flow, a work
angle of 40 to 50 from the upper plate is used.
67
68
CHAPTER 10
WELDING PROCEDURE SCHEDULES
When changing or adjusting the variables for welding, the effect of the variables on each other must be
considered. One variable cannot usually be drastically
changed without adjusting or changing the other variables, in order to obtain a stable arc and good overall
welding conditions.
1100
1000
450
.045
(1.1 mm)
400
900
800
700
350
1/16
(1.6 mm)
300
600
250
500
400
300
200
100
0
200
3/32
(2.4 mm)
150
100
1/8
(3.2 mm)
50
speed, it is sometimes more convenient to directly establish the welding current without exactly knowing the
wire feed speed. Illustrations 10-1 and 10-2 show wire
feed speeds and their corresponding welding currents
for several sizes of tubular electrode wire. Many of the
charts include welding conditions for both groove and fillet welds given on the same chart. Generally, fillet welds
will use the higher current levels for the ranges given and
groove welds will use the lower end of the current range.
The following schedules are based on welding plain carbon steels using various types of electrodes wires in appropriate positions. Generally, electrode wires over 1/16"
(1.6 mm) diameter are limited to the flat and horizontal
positions. The welding schedules in300
clude the semiautomatic and auto125
matic methods of application, using
1/8
self-shielded and CO2 shielded elec(3.2 mm)
250
trode wires. The tables use the base
100
metal thickness or fillet size, number
3/32
5/64
200
of weld passes, electrode diameter,
(2.4 mm)
(2.0 mm)
welding current, welding voltage, wire
75
feed speed, gas flow rate (if used) and
150
travel speed as variables. Each table
contains the type of shielding gas (if
50
100
used), type of joint and the position of
welding being used. All of the schedules are based on using direct current
50
electrode positive. Both the welding
150 200 250 300 350 400 450 500 550 600
WELDING CURRENT (amperes)
current and wire feed speed values
are given because, even through the
Illustration 10-2 Wire Feed Speed Versus Welding
welding current is set by the wire feed
Current for Self-Shielded Tubular Wires
69
Thickness
of Base
Metal
in. (mm)
1/8 (3.2)
3/16 (4.8)
1/4 (6.4)
5/16 (7.9)
3/8 (9.5)
1/2 (12.7)
5/8 (15.9)
3/4 (19.1)
Welding
Current
Wire Feed
Speed
in./min. (mm/s)
Gas Flow
Rate
Ft3/hr.
(l/min)
Travel
Speed
in./min.
(mm/s)
24-26
300
100 (42)
35-45 (17-21)
44 (19)
3/32 (2.4)
24-26
350
120 (51)
35-45 (17-21)
42 (18)
1/8 (3.2)
24-26
450
90 (38)
35-45 (17-21)
47 (20)
3/32 (2.4)
24-26
400
155 (66)
35-45 (17-21)
24 (10)
1/8 (3.2)
25-27
500
105 (44)
35-45 (17-21)
30 (13)
3/32 (2.4)
28-30
500
205 (87)
35-45 (17-21)
22 (9)
1/8 (3.2)
28-30
500
105 (44)
35-45 (17-21)
22 (9)
3/32 (2.4)
28-30
500
205 (87)
35-45 (17-21)
15 (6)
1/8 (3.2)
29-31
575
130 (55)
35-45 (17-21)
20 (8)
3/32 (2.4)
29-31
525
220 (93)
35-45 (17-21)
11 (5)
1/8 (3.2)
30-32
625
150 (63)
35-45 (17-21)
14 (6)
3/32 (2.4)
29-31
475
190 (80)
35-45 (17-21)
12 (5)
1/8 (3.2)
28-30
500
105 (44)
35-45 (17-21)
14 (6)
3/32 (2.4)
29-31
500
205 (87)
35-45 (17-21)
13 (5)
1/8 (3.2)
29-31
500
105 (44)
35-45 (17-21)
13 (5)
Number
of Passes
Electrode
Diameter
in. (mm)
Welding
Voltage
3/32 (2.4)
Illustration 10-3 Flux Cored Arc Welding of Plain Carbon and Low Alloy Steels
Using External Shielding Gas
70
Thickness
of Base
Metal
in. (mm)
1/8 (3.2)
3/16 (4.8)
1/4 (6.4)
5/16 (7.9)
3/8 (9.5)
1/2 (12.7)
5/8 (15.9)
3/4 (19.1)
Welding
Current
Wire Feed
Speed
in./min. (mm/s)
Gas Flow
Rate
Ft3/hr.
(l/min)
Travel
Speed
in./min.
(mm/s)
24-26
300
120 (51)
35-45 (17-21)
60 (25)
3/32 (2.4)
24-26
400
155 (66)
35-45 (17-21)
36 (15)
1/8 (3.2)
24-26
425
75 (32)
35-45 (17-21)
38 (16)
3/32 (2.4)
24-26
400
155 (66)
35-45 (17-21)
24 (10)
1/8 (3.2)
25-27
450
90 (38)
35-45 (17-21)
26 (11)
3/32 (2.4)
25-27
440
175 (74)
35-45 (17-21)
20 (8)
1/8 (3.2)
26-28
460
93 (39)
35-45 (17-21)
20 (8)
3/32 (2.4)
26-28
475
190 (80)
35-45 (17-21)
15 (6)
1/8 (3.2)
28-30
500
105 (44)
35-45 (17-21)
16 (7)
3/32 (2.4)
24-26
400
155 (66)
35-45 (17-21)
18 (8)
1/8 (3.2)
25-27
450
90 (38)
35-45 (17-21)
20 (8)
3/32 (2.4)
26-28
450
180 (90)
35-45 (17-21)
14 (6)
1/8 (3.2)
27-29
450
90 (38)
35-45 (17-21)
14 (6)
3/32 (2.4)
28-30
400
155 (66)
35-45 (17-21)
20 (8)
1/8 (3.2)
28-30
470
96 (41)
35-45 (17-21)
22 (9)
Number
of Passes
Electrode
Diameter
in. (mm)
Welding
Voltage
3/32 (2.4)
Illustration 10-4 Flux Cored Arc Welding of Plain Carbon and Low Alloy Steels
Using External Shielding Gas
71
1) For square groove welds up to 3/8 inch (9.5 mm) (9.5 mm) base metal thickness.
2) Shielding gas is carbon dioxide.
3) Flat position.
4) Semiautomatic welding.
Thickness
of Base
Metal
in. (mm)
Welding
Current
Wire Feed
Speed
in./min. (mm/s)
Gas Flow
Rate
Ft3/hr.
(l/min)
Travel
Speed
in./min.
(mm/s)
24-26
325-350
120 (51)
35-45 (17-21)
56 (24)
3/32 (2.4)
24-26
350-375
130 (55)
35-45 (17-21)
48 (20)
3/32 (2.4)
25-27
375-400
137 (58)
35-45 (17-21)
41 (17)
3/8 (9.5)
1/8 (3.2)
26-28
450-500
107 (45)
35-45 (17-21)
24 (10)
1/2 (12.7)
1/8 (3.2)
28-30
475-525
120 (51)
35-45 (17-21)
14 (6)
5/8 (15.9)
1/8 (3.2)
30-32
575-600
155 (66)
35-45 (17-21)
14-16 (6)
3/4 (19.1)
1/8 (3.2)
30-32
575-600
155 (66)
35-45 (17-21)
15-20 (6-8)
7/8 (22.2)
1/8 (3.2)
30-32
575-600
155 (66)
35-45 (17-21)
13-18 (5-8)
1 (25.4)
1/8 (3.2)
31-32
575-600
155 (66)
35-45 (17-21)
12-20 (5-8)
Number
of Passes
Electrode
Diameter
in. (mm)
Welding
Voltage
1/8 (3.2)
3/32 (2.4)
3/16 (4.8)
1/4 (6.4)
Illustration 10-5 Flux Cored Arc Welding of Plain Carbon and Low Alloy Steels
Using External Shielding Gas
72
1) For square groove welds up to 3/8 inch (9.5 mm) base metal thickness.
2) Shielding gas is carbon dioxide.
3) Flat position only.
4) Automatic welding.
Thickness
of Base
Metal
in. (mm)
Welding
Current
Wire Feed
Speed
in./min. (mm/s)
Gas Flow
Rate
Ft3/hr.
(l/min)
Travel
Speed
in./min.
(mm/s)
16-18
225-250
65 (27)
35-45 (17-21)
55 (23)
3/32 (2.4)
17-19
275-300
90 (38)
35-45 (17-21)
36 (15)
3/32 (2.4)
26-28
350-375
240 (102)
35-45 (17-21)
22 (9)
1/8 (3.2)
27-29
375-400
125 (53)
35-45 (17-21)
14 (6)
3/32 (2.4)
27-29
400-425
270 (114)
35-45 (17-21)
17 (7)
1/8 (3.2)
29-31
500-525
185 (78)
35-45 (17-21)
14 (6)
3/32 (2.4)
27-29
425-450
290 (123)
35-45 (17-21)
14 (6)
1/8 (3.2)
29-31
525-550
190 (80)
35-45 (17-21)
13 (5)
3/32 (2.4)
27-29
400-425
270 (114)
35-45 (17-21)
14-20 (6-8)
1/8 (3.2)
29-31
475-500
170 (72)
35-45 (17-21)
13-18 (5-8)
3/32 (2.4)
27-29
400-425
270 (114)
35-45 (17-21)
14-20 (6-8)
1/8 (3.2)
29-31
475-500
170 (72)
35-45 (17-21)
13-18 (5-8)
Number
of Passes
Electrode
Diameter
in. (mm)
Welding
Voltage
1/8 (3.2)
3/32 (2.4)
3/16 (4.8)
1/4 (6.4)
3/8 (9.5)
1/2 (12.7)
5/8 (15.9)
3/4 (19.1)
Illustration 10-6 Flux Cored Arc Welding of Plain Carbon and Low Alloy Steels
Using External Shielding Gas
73
Thickness
of Base
Metal
in. (mm)
Welding
Current
Wire Feed
Speed
in./min. (mm/s)
Travel
Speed
in./min.
(mm/s)
25
200-225
80 (34)
16 (7)
3/32 (2.4)
26
250-275
95 (40)
12 (5)
3/32 (2.4)
286
375-400
130 (55)
10 (4)
3/8 (9.5)
1/8 (3.2)
28
400-425
95 (40)
12-14 (5-6)
1/2 (12.7)
1/8 (3.2)
29
425-450
107 (45)
14 (6)
5/8 (15.9)
1/8 (3.2)
28-30
400-425
95 (40)
12-16 (5-7)
3/4 (19.1)
1/8 (3.2)
28-30
425-450
107 (45)
12-16 (5-7)
7/8 (22.2)
1/8 (3.2)
29-31
475-500
120 (51)
12-16 (5-7)
1 (25.4)
1/8 (3.2)
28-31
425-450
107 (45)
12-16 (5-7)
Number
of Passes
Electrode
Diameter
in. (mm)
Welding
Voltage
1/8 (3.2)
3/32 (2.4)
3/16 (4.8)
1/4 (6.4)
Illustration 10-7 Flux Cored Arc Welding of Plain Carbon and Low Alloy Steels
Using Self-Shielded Electrode Wires
74
1) For square groove welds up to 3/8 inch (9.5 mm) base metal thickness.
2) Flat position only.
3) Semiautomatic welding.
Thickness
of Base
Metal
in. (mm)
Welding
Current
Wire Feed
Speed
in./min. (mm/s)
Travel
Speed
in./min.
(mm/s)
19
200-225
60 (25)
12 (5)
3/32 (2.4)
20
250-275
80 (34)
9 (4)
1/8 (3.2)
28
375-400
110 (47)
14 (6)
3/8 (9.5)
1/8 (3.2)
28-30
400-425
135 (57)
13-16 (5-7)
1/2 (12.7)
1/8 (3.2)
27-29
425-450
150 (63)
14-16 (6-7)
5/8 (15.9)
1/8 (3.2)
29-31
400-425
130 (55)
13-18 (5-8)
3/4 (19.1)
1/8 (3.2)
28-30
425-450
150 (63)
13-16 (5-7)
7/8 (22.2)
1/8 (3.2)
29-31
475-500
170 (72)
13-18 (5-8)
1 (25.4)
1/8 (3.2)
28-31
425-450
150 (63)
13-16 (5-7)
Number
of Passes
Electrode
Diameter
in. (mm)
Welding
Voltage
1/8 (3.2)
3/32 (2.4)
3/16 (4.8)
1/4 (6.4)
Illustration 10-8 Flux Cored Arc Welding of Plain Carbon and Low Alloy Steels
Using Self-Shielded Electrode Wires
75
Welding
Current
Wire Feed
Speed
in./min. (mm/s)
Gas Flow
Rate
Ft3/hr.
(l/min)
Travel
Speed
in./min.
(mm/s)
22-24
150
60 (25)
35-45 (17-21)
30 (13)
.045 (1.1)
22-24
200
80 (34)
35-45 (17-21)
24-30 (10-13)
.045 (1.1)
23-25
220
110 (47)
35-45 (17-21)
15-18 (6-8)
3/8 (9.5)
.045 (1.1)
24-25
220
135 (57)
35-45 (17-21)
8-10 (3-4)
1/2 (12.7)
.045 (1.1)
24-26
220
150 (63)
35-45 (17-21)
8-10 (3-4)
3/4 (19.1)
.045 (1.1)
24-26
220
150 (63)
35-45 (17-21)
8-10 (3-4)
Number
of Passes
Electrode
Diameter
in. (mm)
Welding
Voltage
1/8 (3.2)
.045 (1.1)
3/16 (4.8)
1/4 (6.4)
Illustration 10-9 Flux Cored Arc Welding of Plain Carbon and Low Alloy Steels
Using Small Diameter Externally Shielded Electrode Wires
76
CHAPTER 11
PREWELD PREPARATIONS
Preweld preparations are necessary to obtain a good
quality weld. Operations that may need to be done before the welding is started are items such as preparing
the weld joint, maintenance of welding gun and cable assembly, fixturing the weldment, setting the variables, and,
in some cases, preheating. The amount of preweld preparation depends upon the size of the weld and weldment,
the type of base metal, the ease of fit-up, the quality requirements, the governing code or specifications, and the
welder.
77
be wire brushed. Mild steel brushes are used for cleaning plain carbon and low alloy steel. Stainless steel wire
brushes are used for cleaning stainless steel. The joint
surfaces and surface of the previous weld bead should
also be cleaned off between passes of a multiple pass
weld. Stainless steel brushes should be used on these
metals to avoid contamination due to rust or carbon from
the mild steel wire brushes. Welding should be done
soon after cleaning, especially on metals that form surface oxides such as stainless steel. Wire brushing does
not completely remove the oxide but it reduces the thickness and makes them easier to weld. Gloves should be
worn while cleaning stainless steels to prevent oil or dirt,
from the fingers, from getting on the joint surfaces, which
can also cause contamination.
PREHEATING
Preheating is sometimes required, but this depends on
the type of metal being welded, the base metal thickness, and the amount of joint restraint. These factors
were discussed in Chapter 7. The specific amount of
preheat needed for a given application is often obtained
from the welding procedure.
The preheat temperature of the metal should be carefully controlled. There are several methods of performing
this: furnace heating, electric induction coils, and electric resistance heating blankets. On thin materials, hot air
blasts or radiant lamps may be used. With these methods, temperature indicators are attached to the parts
being preheated. Oxy-fuel torches are another method
of preheating. This method gives more localized heating
than the methods that were previously mentioned. When
using oxy-fuel torches, it is important to avoid localized
overheating and deposits of incomplete combustion
products from collecting on the surface of the parts to
be welded. There are several methods of measuring the
temperature of preheat such as temperature sensitive
crayons, pellets and hand-held temperature indicators.
The crayons and pellets melt at a specific predetermined
temperature. The hand-held temperature indicators can
give meter readings, digital readings, or recorder readings of the temperature, depending on the type used.
78
CHAPTER 12
WELDING DISCONTINUITIES AND DEFECTS
Flux cored arc welding, like the other arc welding processes can have welding procedure problems that result in weld discontinuities or defects. Discontinuities
that can occur when using flux cored arc welding are
slag inclusions, porosity, wormhole porosity, undercutting, incomplete fusion, excessive melt through, wagon
tracks, excessive weld spatter, arc strikes and craters.
These problems with the welding technique or procedure
weaken the weld and can cause cracking. A poor welding
technique and improper choice of welding parameters are
major causes of weld defects. Some defects are caused
by the use of improper base metal, filler metal, or shielding gas. The base metal and filler metal should also be
cleaned to avoid creation of a discontinuity. Other problems that can occur and reduce the quality of the weld are
arc blow, loss of shielding, defective electrical contact between the contact tube and the electrode, and wire feed
stoppages.
Wagon Tracks
Wagon tracks are linear slag inclusions
that run along the longitudinal axis of
the weld. These result from allowing the slag to run ahead of the weld
puddle and by slag left on the previous pass. This is especially common
when slag forms in undercuts on the
previous pass. This discontinuity occurs along the toe line of the previous
weld bead and can be corrected by
correcting the electrode travel angles,
increasing the travel speed, or by doing a better slag cleaning.
Illustration 12-2
Wagon Tracks
Porosity
Porosity is a gas pocket in the weld metal that may be
scattered in small clusters or along the entire length
of the weld. These voids left in the weld cause it to be
weakened. Porosity may be internal, on the surface of
the weld bead, or both. This discontinuity is caused by
one or more of the following:
DISCONTINUITIES CAUSED BY
WELDING TECHNIQUE
Slag Inclusions
Flux cored arc welding produces a
slag covering over the weld. Slag inclusions occur when slag particles become trapped inside the weld. These
slag inclusions produce a weaker
weld and can serve as crack initiation
points. These can be caused by:
Illustration 12-1
1) Slag left on the previous weld pass
Slag Inclusion
2) An erratic travel speed
3) Improper electrode angles that let
the slag get ahead of the arc
4) A weaving motion that is too wide
5) A travel speed that is too slow which lets the weld
puddle get ahead of the arc
6) Too low an amperage setting
79
5) Pausing at each side of the weld bead when a weaving technique is used
6) Correcting the electrode angles being used
Incomplete Fusion
Wormhole Porosity
Wormhole porosity is the name given
to elongated gas pockets and is usually caused by sulfur in the steel or moisture on the surface of the base metal
which becomes trapped in the weld
joint. Wormhole porosity can seriously
reduce the strength of the weld. The
best methods of preventing this are to
clean the surfaces of the joint and preheat to remove moisture. If sulfur in the
steel is the problem, a more weldable
grade of steel should be selected.
Illustration 12-4
Wormhole
Porosity
Undercutting
Undercutting is a groove melted in the
base metal next to the toe or root of a
weld that is not filled by the weld metal.
This is particularly a problem with fillet
welds. Undercutting causes a weaker
joint at the toe of the weld, which may
result in cracking. It is caused by one
or more of the following:
1) Excessive welding current
2) Arc voltage too high
3) Excessive travel speed which does
Illustration 12-5
Undercutting
not allow enough filler metal to be
added
4) Erratic feeding of the electrode wire
5) Excessive weaving speed
6) Incorrect electrode angles, especially on vertical and
horizontal welds
This can be prevented by:
1) Reducing the weld current
2) Reducing the welding voltage
3) Using a travel speed slow enough so that the weld
metal can completely fill all of the melted out areas of
the base metal
4) Cleaning the nozzle, inside of the contact tube, or
removing the jammed electrode wire
80
Illustration 12-7
Overlapping
Melt-Through
Melt-through occurs when the arc melts through the bottom of the weld and creates holes. It is usually caused by
the heat input being too high. This can also be caused by
one or more of the following:
1) Excessive welding current
2) A travel speed that is too slow
3) A root opening that is too wide or a root face that is
too small
Illustration 12-9
Arc Strikes
81
Illustration 12-10
Distortion
CRACKING
Weldment cracking can be caused by an improper welding procedure, welder technique, or materials. All types
of cracking can be classified as either hot or cold cracking. These cracks are transverse or longitudinal to the
weld. Transverse cracks are perpendicular to the axis of
the weld where longitudinal shrinkage stresses are acting
on excessively hard and brittle weld metal. Longitudinal
cracks are often caused by high joint restraint and high
cooling rates. Preheating will often help to reduce these
problems.
Hot cracking occurs at elevated temperatures and generally happens just after the weld metal starts to solidify.
This type of cracking is often caused by excessive sulfur,
phosphorous and lead contents in the steel base metal.
It can also be caused by an improper method of breaking
the arc or in a root pass when the cross sectional area
of the weld bead is small compared to the mass of the
base metal.
Hot cracking often occurs in deep penetrating welds and
it can continue through successive layers if it is not repaired. Hot cracking can be prevented or minimized by:
1) Preheating to reduce shrinkage stresses in the weld
2) Using clean or uncontaminated shielding gas, base
metals and filler metals
3) Increasing the cross sectional area of the weld bead
4) Changing the contour of the weld bead
5) Using base metal with very low contents of those elements that tend to cause hot cracking.
6) In steel, using filler metals that are high in manganese
82
OTHER PROBLEMS
Arc Blow
The electric current that flows through the electrode,
workpiece, and work cable sets up magnetic fields in a
circular path perpendicular to the direction of the current.
When the magnetic fields around the arc are unbalanced,
it tends to bend away from the greatest concentration
of the magnetic field. This deflection of the arc is called
arc blow. Deflection is usually in the direction of travel or
opposite to it, but it sometimes occurs to the side. Arc
blow can result in an irregular weld bead and incomplete
fusion.
Top View of Magnetic Field
No
Arc Blow
Illustration 12-16
Inadequate
Shielding
Direction of Travel
Forward
Arc Blow
Backward
Arc Blow
The most common causes of this problem for self-shielded electrodes are:
Illustration 12-15 Arc Blow
83
84
CHAPTER 13
POSTWELD PROCEDURES
There are several operations that may be required after
welding, such as cleaning, inspection of the welds, and
postheating. These are items which may or may not be
part of the procedure. The operations performed will depend on the governing code or specification, type of metal, and the quality of the weld deposit.
c)
CLEANING
b)
Flux cored arc welding produces a moderate slag covering that must be removed after welding. Slag removal is
also required between passes of a multipass weld to prevent slag inclusions and incomplete fusion.
Slag removal is generally done using a chipping hammer.
A certain amount of spatter is created in flux cored arc
welding, which can make slag removal slightly more difficult. If an excessive amount of spatter is created, slag
removal may become very difficult. After the slag has
been removed, wire brushing or buffing can be done to
remove the loose slag particles and to remove discoloration around the bead. Mild steel brushes can be used on
most steels but stainless steel brushes should be used
on stainless steel to prevent contamination. Spatter can
be removed by grinding or wire brushing. Flux cored arc
welding usually produces a smooth weld surface. If a different weld profile is needed, grinding can be used, although grinding of weld profiles should be avoided, due
to the expense.
a)
d)
c)
d)
b)
e)
a)
85
structive testing methods. The most widely used nondestructive testing methods are visual, magnetic particle,
liquid penetrant, ultrasonic, and radiographic. Visual,
magnetic particle, and liquid penetrant
inspection are used to locate surface
defects, while ultrasonic, magnetic particle, and radiographic inspection are
used to locate internal defects.
86
CHAPTER 14
WELDER TRAINING AND QUALIFICATION
WELDER TRAINING
Flux cored arc welding requires a certain degree of skill
to produce good quality welds. In semiautomatic welding, the welder has to manipulate the welding gun and
control the speed of travel. Less skill is required to operate this process when compared to the manual welding
processes because the machine controls the arc length
and feeds the electrode wire. Welders skilled in manual
welding processes and gas metal arc welding generally
have less difficulty learning flux cored arc welding. This
process uses similar equipment and welding techniques
to those used in gas metal arc welding. At higher current
levels, when using larger diameter wires, flux cored arc
welding has a smoother arc and is easier to handle than
larger diameter solid wires with a carbon dioxide shielding. Because of the deep penetrating characteristics of
the process, lack of fusion and incomplete penetration
are easier to avoid and compensate for, than gas metal
arc welding using short-circuiting transfer.
The exact content of a training program will vary depending on the specific application of the process. A training
program should have enough flexibility so that it can be
adapted to changing needs and applications. Because
of this, the emphasis may be placed on certain areas of
training based on the complexity of the parts to be welded, type of metal, and governing code or specification.
A welding course that covers all position welding would
require more training time than one that simply covers flat
position welding only. A welding course for pipe would
require more training time than one for welding plate.
The major purpose of the training program is to give the
welder the skill and knowledge to be able to do the best
job possible. A training program may be broken up into
several areas depending on the training requirements of
the student.
Basic Flux Cored Arc Welding
The basic flux cored arc welding training program is used
to teach the students the basic skills necessary to weld
plate. This course provides training on how to make quality fillet and groove welds. The course also gives the students the knowledge of how to set up the equipment,
clean the base metal, basic operating principles and the
difficulties that are commonly encountered. The training also covers the different welding techniques used
for gas-shielded and self-shielded electrodes. Also covered are the techniques for welding out-of-position using small diameter electrodes. The training obtained by
the student should give the skill to perform a job welding
plate. This course should also provide the background
skill and knowledge required to take an advanced course
for a specific application such as for welding pipe. The
WELDER QUALIFICATION
Before the welder can begin work on any job covered by
a welding code or specification, the welder must become
qualified under the code that applies.
Many different codes are in use today, and it is very important that the specific codes are referred to when taking qualification tests. In general, the following types of
work are covered by codes: pressure vessels and piping,
87
Qualifications tests may be given by responsible manufacturers or contractors. On pressure vessel work, the
welding procedure must also be qualified and this must
be done before the welders are qualified. Under other
codes, this is not necessary. To become qualified, the
welder must make specified welds using the required
process, base metal, base metal thickness, electrode
type, position and joint design. For example, in the AWS
Structural Welding Code (D1.1), certain joint designs are
considered prequalified for flux cored arc welding. Test
specimens must be made according to standardized sizes and under the observation of a qualified person. For
most government specifications, a government inspector
must witness the making of weld specimens. Specimens
must be properly identified and prepared for testing. The
most common test is a guided bend test. In some cases,
radiographic examinations, fracture tests, or other tests
are employed. Satisfactory completion of test specimens, providing that they meet acceptability standards,
will qualify the welder for specific types of welding. The
welding that will be allowed again depends on the particular code. In general, the code indicates the range of
thicknesses which may be welded, the positions which
may be employed, and the alloys which may be welded.
Qualification of welders is a highly technical subject and
cannot be covered fully here. It is recommended that the
actual code be obtained and studied prior to taking any
tests.
88
CHAPTER 15
WELDING SAFETY
Safety is an important consideration when welding.
Material Safety Data Sheets (MSDSs)
OSHA requires that employers must have a comprehensive hazard communication program to inform employees
about hazardous substances that might be used in the
workplace. The purpose of the MSDSs is to explain the
hazards involved in handling/using products such as welding consumables and the precautionary measures which
must be put in place for safe welding. The employer must
maintain continuous training concerning such materials,
and safety in general. Provisions to safeguard employees
are included in Material Safety Data Sheets (MSDSs) as
prescribed by the Hazard Communications Standard of
the U.S. Department of Labor. Information must be provided for all substances taken into the workplace except
food, drugs, cosmetics or tobacco products used for
personal consumption. The use of these data sheets in
all manufacturing workplaces has been mandated since
1985. Employees must be trained on the information in
Material Safety Data Sheets and labels.
AWS/ANSI Z49.1
A set of safety rules which should be followed is presented in the American National Standard Institute Z49.1,
Safety in Welding and Cutting, published by the American Welding Society. There are a number of hazards associated with shielded metal arc welding. These do not
necessarily result in serious injuries. They can also be of
a minor nature which can cause discomforts that irritate
and reduce the efficiency of the welders. These hazards
are:
1) Electrical shock
2) Arc radiation
3) Air contamination
4) Compressed gases
5) Fire and explosion
or ground rod. Welding cables with frayed or cracked insulation and faulty or badly worn connections can cause
electrical short circuits and shocks. An improperly insulated welding cable is both an electrical shock hazard and
a fire hazard.
The welding area should be dry and free of any standing
water. When it is necessary to weld in a damp or wet area,
the welder should wear rubber boots and stand on a dry,
insulated platform.
ARC RADIATION
Flux cored arc welding produces an intense welding arc
which emits ultraviolet and infrared rays. Skin that is exposed to the arc for a short time can suffer serious ultraviolet and infrared burns which are essentially the same
as sunburn, but the burn caused by welding can take
place in a much shorter time and can be very painful. The
welder should always wear protective clothing suitable for
welding to be done. These clothes should be fairly heavy
and fire resistant. Leather is often used to make jackets,
capes, and bibs, or other similar arrangements to shield
the shoulders, arms, and chest from radiation and spatter.
Leather gloves should be worn, but the gloves are often
lighter than those used for shielded metal arc welding.
The eyes must be protected from the radiation emitted by
the welding arc. The welding arc should never be viewed
by the naked eye at a distance closer than 30 ft. (9 m). Arc
burn can result if the eyes are not protected. Arc burn of
the eye is similar to sunburn of the skin and is extremely
painful for about 24 to 48 hours. Usually arc burn does not
permanently injure the eyes, but it can cause intense pain.
There are several commercial solutions that are available
to soothe the skin and eyes during the period of suffering.
Infrared arc rays can cause fatigue of the retina of the eye.
The effects of infrared rays are not nearly as noticeable or
immediate as the effects of ultraviolet rays. Infrared rays
ELECTRICAL SHOCK
There are several precautions that should be taken to
prevent an electrical shock. First, make sure that the arc
welding equipment is properly installed, grounded, and in
good working condition. The electrical equipment should
be maintained and installed in accordance with the National Electrical Code and any state and local codes that
apply. Equipment should be operated within NEMA Standards usual operating conditions for proper safety and
equipment life. The case or frame of the power supply
should be connected to an adequate electrical ground,
such as an approved building ground, cold water pipe,
89
Welding Current
(Amperes)
Minimum
Protective Shade
Suggesteda Shade
No. (Comfort)
Under 60
60-160
10
11
160-250
10
12
250-550
10
14
Welding Bandana
protects head.
Safety Goggles
protects eyes.
a) As a rule of thumb, start with a shade that is not too dark to see the weld zone. Then go to
a lighter shade which gives sufficient view of the weld zone without going below the minimum.
In oxyfuel gas welding, cutting, or brazing where the torch and/or the flux produces a high yellow light, it is desirable to use a filter lens that absorbs the yellow or sodium line of the visible
light spectrum.
Industrial Grade
Auto-Darkening Helmet
protects eyes and face.
Welding Gloves
protects hands.
AIR CONTAMINATION
One of the main problems with flux cored arc welding is
that it gives off more smoke and fumes than processes
such as gas tungsten arc welding, gas metal arc welding,
and submerged arc welding. It even tends to produce
higher smoke and fume levels than shielded metal arc
welding. A hazard warning for fume is placed on the electrode wire box.
The welding area should be adequately ventilated because fumes and gases such as ozone, carbon monoxide and carbon dioxide are hazardous for the welder
to breathe. When welding is done in confined areas, an
Leather Apron
protects lap.
Denim Pants
Without Cuffs
Leather Shoes
protects feet.
90
COMPRESSED GASES
The shielding gas used for flux cored arc welding is
compressed and stored in cylinders. One advantage
of self-shielded flux cored wire is that compressed gas
cylinders are not required, so this is primarily a safety
consideration when gas-shielded electrodes are used.
Improper handling of compressed gas cylinders can create a safety hazard. When in use, gas cylinders should be
secured to a wall or other structural support. The valve
of the cylinder should be opened slowly and the welder
should stand away from the face of the regulator when
doing this. The welding arc should never be struck on a
compressed gas cylinder. When not in use, gas cylinders
should be stored with their caps on. Caps should also be
on when they are moved. If the valve would get knocked
off, the cylinder acts like a missile, because of the escaping gas, and can cause injury and damage. When compressed gas cylinders are empty, the valve should be
closed and they should be marked empty. This is done
by marking the letters, MT or EMPTY on the cylinder.
91
92
28) Cylinders: Safe Storage, Handling, and Use, Safety and Health Fact Sheet No. 30. American Welding
Society, Miami, FL.
29) Arc Welding and Cutting Noise, AWN, American
Welding Society, Miami, FL.
30) Safety and Health Fact Sheets, SHF, American
Welding Society, Miami, FL.
Web Sites
93
INDEX
Index Terms
Links
A
Accessibility
47
Accessories
13
Advantages of FCAW
62
Acid Pickling
77
77
Air Contamination
90
Alternating Current
Annealing
41-42
Arc Blow
83
Arc Length
47
86
86
2-5
42
61-62
66
87
Arc Radiation
89
Arc Strikes
81
Arc Systems
15
Argon-Oxygen Mixtures
15
37
Automotive Products
30
AWS/ANSI Z49.1
89
41-42
B
Backing Strips
48
83
Bead Height
59
61-63
Bead Width
59
61-65
Bevel Angle
44
C
Cables
12
Recommended Lengths
Cadmium
13
90
92
67
Index Terms
Links
Carbon Dioxide
11-12
14-15
31
33
39-41
81
83-84
87
90
Carbon Equivalent
Carbon Steel
36
38-39
16-17
40
62
29
Carriages
13
Centerline Crack
82
37
Chemical Composition
36
Chipping
13
47
61
77
85-86
91
22
29
39
40-42
92-93
Chromium
Chromium-Molybdenum Steels
40
Cleaning
85
77
84
Cold Cracking
20
Columbium
41
Complete Penetration
44-45
Compressed Gases
91
Conformances
27
Constant Current
3-9
Controls
47
61
Corrosion Resistance
15
26
39-41
86
36
32
Comparison Table
34
Electric Power
33
Electrodes
32
32
Shielding Gas
33
Cracking
82
Craters
81
Crater Cracks
82
Current Density
82
5
This page has been reformatted by Knovel to provide easier navigation.
45
61
Index Terms
Links
D
Degreasing
77
Dendrites
38
Deoxidizers
20
90
36
38-39
15
33-35
1-2
13
20
26-35
39
59-61
66-67
78
77
Deposition Efficiency
Deposition Rate
Destructive Testing
85-86
21
26
21
26
84
79
Distortion
81
Drag Angle
67
Drive Rolls
9-11
Ductility
Duty Cycle
79
14-15
26
36
39-42
61
86
6-8
11-12
E
Effective Throat
48
33
Electrical Shock
89
Electrode Angle
67
Electrode Cost
32
Electrode Extension
66
Electrode Lead
Electrode Size
61
Electrode Selection
26
Electrode Type
59
Electrodes
16
Classification
16
Selection
26
27
Elongation
69
17-18
This page has been reformatted by Knovel to provide easier navigation.
12
36
Index Terms
Links
Excessive Spatter
81
Explosions
91
F
Fires
91
Fixed Variables
59
Fixturing
78
31
41
Fume Extractors
11
Fusion Line
37
G
Gas Shielding System
Generator Welding Machines
1-2
32
Grain Size
38
86
Grinding
77
81
85-86
47-48
82
38
40
14
36-38
40
62
82-82
91
Groove Angle
44-45
H
Hardenability
38-40
Hardness
14
86
40
Heavy Equipment
30
Helium
Helmet
89-91
37-38
18
40
16-23
37
20
41
82
Index Terms
Links
I
Impact Strength
19
26
36-37
Impact Tests
19
36
86
82
Inadequate Shielding
83
Inclusions
14
79
85
Industries
28
Incomplete Fusion
80
Industrial Piping
28
85
32
43
47
77
80
Joint Restraint
36
78
43
J
Joint Preparation
K
Kilowatt
33
L
Labor Cost
32
Lead (element)
41
Limitations of FCAW
Longitudinal Crack
82
39
16-23
37
39
16-23
37
M
Machine Welding Guns
11
Magnesium
42
This page has been reformatted by Knovel to provide easier navigation.
82
82-83
Index Terms
Links
30
38-40
89
89
Mechanical Properties
36
37
Preheat Temperatures
37
Melt-Through
81
Melting Point
41
Metal Transfer
Methods of Application
Microstructure
37
Mild Steel
39
16-23
33
Preheat Temperatures
37
40
46
Moisture
14-16
79-80
Molybdenum
22-23
29
37
22
37-41
77
14
42
39-40
Motion Devices
13
N
Nickel
Nitrogen
61-62
Nondestructive Testing
Normalizing
85-86
86
O
Operator Factor
32
Other Equipment
13
Other Problems
83
Overlapping
80
Oxidation
15
83
34-35
40-41
66
Index Terms
Links
P
Partial Penetration Weld
Phosgene
Phosphorous
444-45
48
77
90
40-41
79
77
Porosity
79
Position
45
Positioning
78
Postheating
86
Postweld Procedures
85
Power Sources
Preheating
78
77
Preselected Variables
59
Preweld Preparations
77
Primary Variables
61
Principles of Operation
Procedure Schedules
69
Procedure Variables
59
Process Method
44
36
Protective Clothing
89
Push Angle
91
67-68
Q
Quenching and Tempering
86
R
Radiographic
85-86
Railroads
29
Reduction of Area
36
92
Repairing of Welds
86
Reverse Polarity
Root Face
44
Root Opening
44
This page has been reformatted by Knovel to provide easier navigation.
88
21
82
Index Terms
Links
S
Safety
89
Scavengers
16
Secondary Variables
66
Selenium
41
Shearing
77
14
33
12
38
77
12
15
66
79-80
Shielding Gases
14
Ships
28
45
Slag
1-3
13
15-16
20-21
27-28
32-33
36
62
64-65
67
79
85
38
81-82
1-2
4-5
11
13
15-16
20
27
33
61-62
64-66
79
81
83-85
89-91
91
Slag Inclusions
79
Solidification
16
86
Spatter
Stainless Steels
41
Classification
42
24-27
33
Preheat Temperatures
37
Steels
Straight Polarity
38
6
Strength
44
Stress Relieving
86
Structures
28
This page has been reformatted by Knovel to provide easier navigation.
21
Index Terms
Links
Sulfur
20
40-41
79-80
14
17-18
21
36-37
39-40
85
Thermal Conductivity
41
48
Thermal Cutting
77
Thickness
47
Toe of Weld
44
82
Summary of Safety Precautions
91
T
Tensile Strength
Toughness
36-38
Travel Angle
67-68
Travel Speed
62
Types of Current
48
U
Ultimate Tensile Strength
36
Ultrasonic Testing
85
Undercutting
80
V
Ventilation
Volt-Ampere Curves
Voltage
90-91
4
3-9
33
61-65
69
W
Wagon Tracks
79
Warpage
81
Water Circulators
13
Weldable Metals
38
59
Index Terms
Links
43
Position
46
Strength
44
Thickness
47
Type of Metal
48
48
Weld Backing
77
91
43
87
Welder Training
87
Basic FCAW
87
Welder Qualification
88
Welding Applications
28
Welding Cables
12
Welding Current
61
79
Welding Lens
90
Welding Metallurgy
36
Welding Symbols
49
61
84
Wire Feeders
Work Angle
68
Wormhole Porosity
86
50
Y
Yield Strength
14-15
17-18
36
39
90
92
Z
Zinc
26
APPENDIX
Sources for Standards
104