Modularization
Modularization
Modularization
Russell Shulz
Project Director; Fluor
Modularization
Overview
Introduction
When is Modularization Effective?
Industry Implementation of Modularization
Industry Terminology
When Modularization Decision Needs To Be Made
Execution Approach Differences
Benefits of Modularization
Challenges
Market Trend
Conclusion
Q&A
Modularization
Introduction
Modularization is an
execution approach for
design, procurement,
contracting and construction
that shifts site construction
hours away from the site
Includes skids, preassemblies, entire process
structures, machines, and
other structures including
bridges
Modularization
Introduction Very Large Module (>600Tons)
Modularization
Introduction Small Truck-able Module (<60Tons)
Modularization
Introduction Pipe Rack Modules
Modularization
Introduction Ship Mounted Module
Modularization
When is Modularization Effective?
Modularization
Industry Implementation of Modularization
Modularization
Industry Terminology
Module Type
Size
Large Modules
60 to 100 tons
60 tons or less
Piperack Modules
Skid-mounted Equipment Modules
Hybrid Modules
Modularization
When Modularization Decision Needs To Be Made
1. Define Business
Drivers
2. Accumulate
Information
3. Strategic Evaluation
4. Develop Alternative
Cases
5. Decide Level of
Modularization and
Complex
Preassembly
6. Develop Estimates,
Quantities, and
Schedules
7. Complete Project
Execution Plan
Business
Planning
Scope
Definition
Preliminary
Engineering
Detailed
Engineering
Construction
Modularization
When Modularization Decision Needs To Be Made
Modularization
Execution Approach Differences
ATTACHMENT 2
Sheet 1 of 1
Early Engineering
Early Procurement
Activities Sequence
Fabrication Organization
Interface Management
Operations &
Maintenance
COLUMN H/1
8 FV-62313B-01
LP CRUDE
TRANSFER
PUMP
DESALTER RECYCLE
WATER PUMP
DESALTER
MONORAIL
16 BBAB
DROP ZONE
20 SDV 62301-01
FOAM
DELUGE
SYSTEM
20 MOV-62313B-01
16 BBAB
8 FV-62313A-01
PLTF. EL. 102006
LP CRUDE
TRANSFER
PUMP
LP SEPARATOR
20 MOV-62313A-01
MONORAIL
Modularization
Benefits of Modularization
Safety
Projected
Results
Cost
Modularization
Schedule
Project
Risks
Modularization
Benefits of Modularization
Safety
Work shifted to
controlled shop
environment
Reduced total
site hours
Reduced work at
high elevations
Potential
reduction in
crane usage
Modularization
Benefits of Modularization
Modularization
Benefits of Modularization
Cost Savings
Reduced quantities
for smaller footprint
Productivity gain for
work shifted to
module yard
Reduced indirects
with less field hours
Modularization
Benefits of Modularization
Materials Quantities Comparison *
Prime Account
Quantity Delta (% )
Excavation, Backfill &
-5
Piling
Concrete
-30
Structural Steel
45
Mechanical Equipment
0
Piping
-15
Electrical
-20
Instrumentation
0
Insulation
-15
*Maximized Process Units and Pipe Racks Modularization
Modularization
Benefits of Modularization
Percent Work in
Module Yard(s)
0%
0%
80%
30%
30%
63%
20%
20%
65%
44%
Modularization
Challenges
Increased Planning
Logistics
Engineering / Procurement
Early Engineering / Procurement
Increased Cost of Engineering
Increased Shipping Cost
Increased Steel Quantities
Increased Equipment damage
potential
Additional rigging / lifting
requirements
Module plan interfaces
Modularization
Market Trend
Modularization
Conclusion
When is it efficient to
Modularize?
Decision Timing & Planning
Modularization Benefits and
Challenges
Owner operations personnel to
be involved from start
Design takes longer, but
installation at site means overall
project schedule improvement
Complete project team buy-in
and alignment
Modularization
Q&A