Descriptive Writing Sample
Descriptive Writing Sample
Descriptive Writing Sample
Teacher Series
Descriptive Writing
by John Schacter, Ph.D.
The
Master
Contents Continued
LESSON 17: The Insect (Skill Review) LESSON 18: The Place (Creating Attribute Charts) LESSON 19: The Place (Precise Words, Verbs & Comparisons Draft) LESSON 20: The Place (Evaluate & Rewrite) LESSON 21: Descriptive Writing Posttest LESSON 22: Pretest to Posttest Growth (Self-Evaluate) LESSON 23: Sentence Combining LESSON 24: Writing Multi-Paragraph Essays LESSON 25: The Stuffed Toy (Creating Attribute Charts) LESSON 26: The Stuffed Toy (Essay Organizer) LESSON 27: The Stuffed Toy (Writing Your First Draft) LESSON 28: Sentence Combining LESSON 29: The Stuffed Toy (Writing Orientations) LESSON 30: The Stuffed Toy (Writing Closing Paragraphs) LESSON 31: The Stuffed Toy (Self-Evaluation & Feedback) LESSON 32: The Stuffed Toy (Evaluating Classmates Essays) REFERENCES
TO PURCHASE THE BOOK AND CD-ROM GO TO WWW.TEACHINGDOCTORS.COM OR CALL 650.323.1378
79 85 88 93 97 99 103 106 108 113 117 121 128 132 135 141 146
Preface
Preface
This book and accompanying CD ROM
incorporate the best in educational research with classroom practices that show the theory in action. In this volume, we present 32 lessons on how to teach descriptive writing in grades 1 to 5. Each lesson is guided by experimentally proven writing strategies that increase student achievement from 13 to 86 percent (see reviews by Hillocks,1984, and Graham & Perin, 2007). In the pages that follow, lessons are described through visual storyboards. All lessons include Teacher PowerPoint Slides (with grade-levelspecific model texts, prompts, pictures, and activities), and Student Workbooks stored on the accompanying CD ROM. Writing this book and developing the teaching examples would not have been possible without the creativity of classroom teachers, researchers, and state department educators. Thank you, Dr. Gina Koency, Katie Welch, Janet Grevious, Dr. Phyllis Veith, Ellen Oderman, Paula Wykle, and Kathy Mears for your instructive comments and encouragement! Appreciation is also expressed to Jennifer Duke for her graphic design, Paul Kepple for his innovative cover artwork, and Joanne Michiuye for her meticulous copyediting. Lastly, thank you Nikki Serafin for your abundant creativity and wealth of ideas.
Lesson Progression
Lessons progress from writing simple descriptive sentences to paragraphs to multi-paragraph essays. Skill development exercises range from generating descriptive attributes to sentence combining to including comparisons and hyperbole. Some first-and second-grade students may not be ready to compose multi-paragraph descriptions. Others may. We encourage teachers to use their judgment to decide how far through this curriculum each student is prepared to advance. As educators, we know that students learn at different rates and enter every grade with different performance levels. That being said, a possible ending point for lower elementary students (grades 1 to 3) is Lesson 21.
Teaching Descriptive Writing Rather than teach writing using a singular approach (e.g. process writing, rubrics, study of models, collaborative writing, self-regulation strategies, scaffolds, etc.) we employ a variety of experimentally proven strategies (see Reference section). While your students will experience elements of process writing, study of models, rubrics, collaborative writing, and self-regulation strategies, the guiding instructional approach in this book is called Goals and Progress Feedback (Schunk & Swartz, 1993).
X X X X
X X X X X
Lesson 4
1
Today, we have two writing goals. One is writing Topic Sentences, the other is generating descriptive attributes. Open your workbooks and put a check next to: Writes topic sentences that orient and engage the reader. Put another check next to: Generates attribute charts.
DESCRIPTIVE WRITING SKILL SHEET ORGANIZING SKILLS Generates attribute charts to develop and sort ideas and details for descriptive writing. Organizes descriptions either by time, visual field (left to right; top to bottom; small to large; large to small), or procedure. Writes topic sentences that orient and engage the reader. Writes concluding sentences that use a concluding word or phrase, give advice, or summarize the description.
2
One way to engage and orient a reader is to tell the reader WHERE what youre describing takes place. There are lots of ways to write WHERE Topic Sentences. On our writing bulletin board, I have placed several examples. In a minute, youll practice writing different WHERE Topic Sentences.
WRITING WHERE TOPIC SENTENCES In the school gym . . . . Across the train tracks . . . Inside our classroom . . . At my friends pool . . . Next to the creek . . . On the soccer field . . . Outside my bedroom window . . .
8 3
Lesson 4 4
After I write WHERE, I need to write what happened. Ill say the volcano erupted, and write that in RED. Watch me write another WHERETopic Sentence. This time Ill start with Next to . . . Next to my grandpas sugar cane field. . . Now, I need to write what happened in RED, I heard the volcano rumble.
Im going to write a WHERE Topic Sentence for this picture (volcano). When you write a WHERE Topic Sentence, first look at the Topic Sentence Poster for an idea. Im going to start with On the soccer field . . . But this isnt a picture of a soccer field its On the big island of Hawaii . . . Ill write this with my BLACK marker on my dry erase board.
WHERE On the big island of Hawaii WHERE Next to my grandpas sugar cane field
5
Heres another picture (CITY). On your whiteboards, make an organizer that looks like this. First write the WHERE part of your Topic Sentence in BLACK, then write the WHAT HAPPENED part in RED. Share your topic sentence with your neighbor, then hold up your whiteboards.
6
Nice work on writing WHERE Topic Sentences. Remember, we have two writing goals today. 1. Write WHERE Topic Sentences. 2. Generate descriptive attributes. Today you are going to describe this picture, The Storm. To help us come up with details that describe this picture well make an attribute chart, just like we did with the snow characters.
CITY WHERE
+ WHAT HAPPENED
AMUSEMENT PARK WHAT HAPPENED STORM
WHERE
WHERE
WHAT HAPPENED
Here is the next picture (AMUSEMENT PARK). First write the WHERE part in BLACK, then WHAT HAPPENED in RED. Share your topic sentence with a different person. This is the last picture (STORM).
Lesson 4 7
Im passing out small Post-It Notes. In your workbook, open to the page, The Storm Attribute Chart. As I look at the picture, Im going to write down descriptions for the attribute, TEMPERATURE.
8
At your table, study the picture of The Storm, then write down one descriptive word on a Post-It for one of the attributes. Next, pass your attribute chart to the person on your left. Write a different descriptive word for another attribute on a Post-It, and stick that Post-It on your tablemates chart.
Watch and listen as I think and record ideas on my Post-It, and then stick the ideas under the Temperature column on my attribute chart.
Keep passing your charts around the table until there are at least 2 descriptive words for each attribute in the chart.
9
Lets have some tables share the descriptive words they recorded. Ill write them on a big class chart. Tomorrow, were going to use these ideas to write a descriptive paragraph about the picture, The Storm.
10
Today we had two writing goals. Goal #1 was to write a WHERE Topic Sentence. Goal #2 was to generate descriptive attributes. Make sure you checked these two skills on your Descriptive Writing Skill Sheet.
DESCRIPTIVE WRITING SKILL SHEET ORGANIZING SKILLS Generates attribute charts to develop and sort ideas and details for descriptive writing. Organizes descriptions either by time, visual field (left to right; top to bottom; small to large; large to small), or procedure. Writes topic sentences that orient and engage the reader. Writes concluding sentences that use a concluding word or phrase, give advice, or summarize the description.
10
Lesson 5
1
Yesterday we wrote WHERE Topic Sentences, and made an attribute chart for The Storm picture. Today, our writing goal is to compose a draft paragraph about The Storm. To do this, we will use a paragraph frame.
WHAT HAPPENED
2
Share with your partner, why you think we are we using a paragraph frame? If you said, Good writers organize their writing, you are correct. Put a check next to Organizes descriptions by time, visual field, procedure or details on your Descriptive Writing Skill Sheet.
DESCRIPTIVE WRITING SKILL SHEET ORGANIZING SKILLS Generates attribute charts to develop and sort ideas and details for descriptive writing. Organizes descriptions either by time, visual field (left to right; top to bottom; small to large; large to small), procedure, or details. Writes topic sentences that orient and engage the reader. Writes concluding sentences that use a concluding word or phrase, give advice, or summarize the description.
Lesson 5 3
If your descriptions are not organized, readers get confused. Heres an example of a recipe for cookies. Its in your workbook. Notice that its out of order.
11
4
Like a recipe, your descriptions need to be organized to help the reader understand. Paragraph frames help us organize our writing. This frame starts with a Topic Sentence, then describes the picture from top to bottom, and finishes with a conclusion. DESCRIPTIVE PARAGRAPH FRAME
WHERE
TOPIC SENTENCE TOP ATTRIBUTES MIDDLE ATTRIBUTES BOTTOM ATTRIBUTES CONCLUSION
RECIPE FOR COOKIES Place the baking pans in the oven and bake. Beat in eggs, one at a time. Preheat oven to 375 degrees. Let the cookies cool after baking. Mix butter and eggs with the dry ingredients. Scoop one tablespoon of cookie dough onto a baking sheet one inch apart.
WHAT HAPPENED
With a partner, cut out the steps, then organize the sentences into an order that will result in good-tasting cookies.
5
Lets start by writing a Topic Sentence. First, look at the picture. Next, choose a WHERE Topic Sentence starter from the poster. Ill choose, Outside . . . Then, add what happened, there was a storm. Now its your turn. Look at the picture, use the WHERE Topic Sentence Poster, and write your topic sentence in your Storm paragraph frame.
6
Now that we have our Topic Sentence, we need to describe the picture in an organized way. Our organization is from TOP to BOTTOM.
WHERE TOPIC SENTENCES In the school gym . . . . Across the train tracks . . . Inside our classroom . . . At my friends pool . . . Next to the creek . . . On the soccer field . . . Outside of the classroom . . .
WHERE
TOPIC SENTENCE TOPIC SENTENCE TOP ATTRIBUTES MIDDLE ATTRIBUTES BOTTOM ATTRIBUTES
WHAT HAPPENED
Outside
CONCLUSION
12 7
Lesson 5 8
Next, Ill write the descriptive words I highlighted in the box, TOP ATTRIBUTES. Now, Ill write a sentence or two that includes these descriptive words. My sentences are, Lightning came from the dark clouds, and The sound of thunder was loud. DESCRIPTIVE PARAGRAPH FRAME
WHERE
TOPIC SENTENCE Outside
Watch as I show you how to use the attribute chart we made yesterday to describe the picture from TOP to BOTTOM. First, Ill look at the TOP of the picture.
WHAT HAPPENED
Lightning came from the dark clouds. The sound of thunder was loud.
Second, Ill highlight the words that relate to the TOP part of the picture in red.
CONCLUSION
9
Are you ready to describe the TOP part of the picture? First, THINK and highlight in red the details and words in your attribute chart that describe the TOP of the picture. Now PAIR up and discuss the attributes you highlighted.
10
Lets look at the middle of the picture. Im going to highlight in yellow the words that describe the MIDDLE of the picture.
THINK-PAIR-WRITE-SHARE Think - Highlight the words from your attribute chart that describe the TOP of the picture. Pair - Discuss the words you highlighted with a partner. Write - Write your ideas in the TOP Attributes box, then use them to write a sentence or two. Share - Share your sentences with different members at your table.
WRITE the top attributes in the TOP ATTRIBUTES box, then write a sentence or two. SHARE your sentences with others at your table.
Lesson 5 11
Ill write the descriptive words from the MIDDLE of the picture in the box, MIDDLE ATTRIBUTES. Then, Ill write a sentence or two that includes these descriptive words. My sentences are, The rain fell on the barn. Trees moved as the wind blew. DESCRIPTIVE PARAGRAPH FRAME
WHERE
TOPIC SENTENCE Outside
13
12
Are you ready to describe the MIDDLE part of the picture? First, THINK and highlight in yellow the details and words that describe the MIDDLE of the picture. Now PAIR up and discuss the attributes you highlighted.
THINK-PAIR-WRITE-SHARE Think - Highlight the words from your attribute chart that describe the MIDDLE of the picture. Pair - Discuss the words you highlighted with a partner. Write - Write your ideas down in the MIDDLE Attributes box, then use them to write a sentence or two. Share - Share your sentences with different members at your table.
WRITE down the middle attributes in the MIDDLE ATTRIBUTES box and write a sentence or two. SHARE your sentences with others at your table.
WHAT HAPPENED
Dark clouds
Lightning came from the dark clouds. The sound of thunder was loud.
The rain fell on the barn. Trees moved as the wind blew.
13
The last thing well do today is look at the bottom of the picture. Follow the same process. Highlight the bottom details in your attribute chart in green. PAIR and discuss what you highlighted. WRITE AND SHARE. When you finish, your paragraph frame should look like this. DESCRIPTIVE PARAGRAPH FRAME
WHERE
TOPIC SENTENCE TOP ATTRIBUTES Outside
14
Remember, todays writing goal was to use our descriptive attribute chart and our paragraph frame to write a description of The Storm. Tomorrow we will write a conclusion.
WHAT HAPPENED
Dark clouds Thunder Lightning streaking Rain on roof Trees swaying Wind whirling
Lightning came from the dark clouds. The sound of thunder was loud.
MIDDLE ATTRIBUTES
The rain fell on the barn. Trees moved as the wind blew.
neighing Wet
CONCLUSION
14
Lesson 6
2
Todays goal is writing Concluding Sentences. The Conclusion Poster lists 9 different ways to write Concluding Sentences. Lets practice one way, writing conclusions that USE A CONCLUDING PHRASE OR WORD.
CONCLUSION POSTER 1. Tell how you feel Example - When I saw that my robot worked, I was proud of all the effort I put into building it. 2. Summarize the main point Example - Mammals have hair, are warm blooded and are born alive. 3. Offer advice Example - Wearing a helmet when you ride your bike will protect you if an accident happens. 4. Challenge the reader to think Example - If a tornado were to strike your home, make a list of the things you need to be prepared. 5. Ask a question Example - I love playing in the park. Where is your favorite place to play? 6. Use a concluding phrase or word Example - To sum up . . . In conclusion. . . All in all . . . Always. . . Everybody . . . Clearly. . . Obviously . . . Surely . . . In fact . . . No one 7. Encourage the reader to take action Example - One way you can prevent pollution is to recycle. 8. Convince the reader of your point Example - Clearly smoking is bad for your health. 9. Make a prediction Example - I think that if our school is full, theyll use trailers for classrooms instead of sending children to a different school.
1
Last night, I used the sentences in my frame to write a paragraph about The Storm. Lets read it. Whats wrong with the ending?
THE STORM Outside there was a storm. Lightning came from the dark clouds. The sound of thunder was loud. The rain fell on the house. Trees moved as the wind blew. Horses neighed as they walked on the grass. The end.
Good writers finish their descriptions. There are lots of ways to complete your paragraph. Writing The end, is not one of them.
Lesson 6 1 3
Watch how I USE A CONCLUDING PHRASE OR WORD to write a Concluding Sentence for the paragraph, Siti The Orangutan. First, Ill read the paragraph. Second, Ill look at the Conclusion Poster. Third, Ill choose a CONCLUDING PHRASE OR WORD and write a Concluding Sentence on one of my sentence strips.
15
1 4
I am placing you in pairs. Open your Writing Workbook and read the paragraph about Elephant Problem Solvers. Im handing out one sentence strip to each person. Individually, read the paragraph and write a conclusion USING A CONCLUDING PHRASE OR WORD on the sentence strip. Next, pass your sentence strip to your partner. That person will read your conclusion, and write a different conclusion on the back. I WOULD LIKE THE FOLLOWING STUDENTS TO COME WORK WITH ME.
Conclusion #1 To sum up, Siti knew how to open the coconut, but didnt want to do the work.
Conclusion #1
Conclusion #2 Clearly, Siti was smart enough to open the coconut on her own. Conclusion #3 In conclusion, intelligent animals can learn how to do something just by watching.
Conclusion #2
I was able to write three different Concluding Sentences by using three different CONCLUDING PHRASES OR WORDS. Remember to look at the Conclusion Poster under Concluding Phrases or Words for ideas.
Pairs, share your Concluding Sentences with another pair. Read all the Concluding Sentences and choose the best one to share with the class.
16 5
Lesson 6 6
Turn to the page with your descriptive writing frame for The Storm. Im going to read my paragraph frame, then write a conclusion USING THE CONCLUDING PHRASE OR WORD technique. Remember to look at the Conclusion Poster for ideas. DESCRIPTIVE PARAGRAPH FRAME
WHERE
TOPIC SENTENCE TOP ATTRIBUTES Outside
Lets read the next paragraph in your Workbook. This time you will read it on your own, and individually write two different conclusions USING THE CONCLUDING PHRASE OR WORD technique. Dont forget to look at the Conclusion Poster for ideas.
WHAT HAPPENED
Dark Clouds Thunder Lightning Streaking Rain on roof Trees swaying Wind whirling Field Horses neighing wet
Lightning came from the dark clouds. The sound of thunder was loud.
The rain fell on the house. Trees moved. The wind blew.
7
Conclusion #1
Now its your turn. Read your descriptive paragraph frame, choose a concluding word or phrase, and write a Concluding Sentence in your paragraph frame. After you write your conclusion, transfer the writing in your frame to paragraph form.
THE STORM Conclusion #2 Outside there was a storm. Lightning came from the clouds. The sound of thunder was loud. The rain fell on the house. Trees moved as the wind blew. Horses neighed as they walked on the grass. Clearly, you would not want to be caught outside during this storm!
Share the conclusions that you wrote at your table. Pick your tables favorite conclusion to share with the class. Now that weve had some practice writing conclusions, lets write a conclusion for our descriptive paragraph, The Storm.
To do this use your Topic Sentence as the first sentence, then add your TOP ATTRIBUTES sentence, the MIDDLE ATTRIBUTES sentence, and so on. When youre finished, your descriptive paragraph should look like mine.