Geothermics: Halldor G. Svavarsson, Sigurbjorn Einarsson, Asa Brynjolfsdottir
Geothermics: Halldor G. Svavarsson, Sigurbjorn Einarsson, Asa Brynjolfsdottir
Geothermics: Halldor G. Svavarsson, Sigurbjorn Einarsson, Asa Brynjolfsdottir
Geothermics
journal homepage: www.elsevier.com/locate/geothermics
a r t i c l e
i n f o
Article history:
Received 22 February 2013
Received in revised form 16 July 2013
Accepted 1 August 2013
Available online 6 September 2013
Keywords:
Geothermal silica
Chromatographic
Adsorption
Protein separation
Phycocyanin
a b s t r a c t
Silica, precipitated out of geothermal uid discharged from a geothermal powerplant in Svartsengi on the
Reykjanes peninsula in Iceland, was used as a chromatographic adsorbent to extract blue colored protein,
C-phycocyanin, from coccoid blue-green algae. The only supplement used was salt obtained by evaporating the geothermal uid. Analysis of the silica, using scanning electron microscopy, X-ray diffractometry
and BrunauerEmmettTeller (BET) adsorption conrmed it has a high specic surface area and is amorphous. Upon adsorption and subsequent elution the purity of the extracted protein, measured as the ratio
of the light absorbance of 620 and 280 nm, increased from 0.5 to above 2.0. Our results could facilitate
utilization of a mostly unused byproduct of geothermal powerplants as chromatographic material.
2013 Elsevier Ltd. All rights reserved.
1. Introduction
1.1. Geothermal silica
Geothermal resources are widespread throughout the world
although generally associated with areas of volcanic activity. The
HS-Energy geothermal powerplant is located in Svartsengi on the
Reykjanes peninsula, southwest Iceland on a sequence of lava
ows, the youngest being roughly 800 years old (Saemundsson
et al., 2010). The geological structure is further characterised by
interlayers of scoria and hyaloclastite reecting interglacial and
glacial periods. Since the lava ows, scoria and interlayers of hyaloclastite are highly porous and permeable, they allow seawater to
percolate deep into their aquifers where it heats up and mixes
with meteoric water (Arnorsson, 1995). Geothermal wells drilled
through the lava ows to depths of up to 2000 m discharge a mixture (here referred to as geothermal uid) of 2/3 seawater and 1/3
meteoric water with a temperature of about 240 C. Due to leaching
the hot geothermal uid contains a high concentration of silicon
(Si) when it enters the wells. Originally, the silicon is present in
the hot geothermal uid as silicic acid (SiOx (OH)42x )n . Upon cooling, the silicic acid precipitates as a three-dimensional network
of coagulated primary silica (SiO2 ) particles. The primary particles
grow up to some nanometers in size before they coagulate to form
aggregated clusters. Such a small particle size gives rise to high
specic surface area, which makes the SiO2 a suitable candidate for
adsorption and catalytic applications.
Steam from the ashed geothermal uid is used to produce
electricity (output power of 75 MWe ). The residual liquid is used
in a heat exchange process (output power of 150 MWt ) to heat
up freshwater for district heating of local communities of roughly
20,000 habitants. This heat exchange process limits the minimum temperature for heat extraction of the geothermal uid to
about 90 C. Most of the spent geothermal uid is reinjected into
the geothermal reservoir (6 106 m3 annually) but some of it
(1.2 106 m3 annually) is discharged on the surface where it
forms the Blue Lagoon (Grether-Beck et al., 2008; Petursdottir et al.,
2009). A small fraction of the discharged uid is bypassed to sedimentation tanks at the Blue Lagoon where it cools from 90 C to
ambient temperature. The cooling causes supersaturation of the
silicic acid which in turn precipitates as amorphous SiO2 . The pH
of the resulting supernatant is 7.7 0.2, sligthly higher than the
pH of the Blue Lagoon which is 7.5 0.2. At 90 C, the geothermal
uid contains about 600 ppm SiO2 and thus the 7 106 m3 of liquid being discharged and reinjected annually carries about 4000
tonnes. At 1015 C, a realistic ambient temperature, the SiO2 concentration has dropped by roughly an order of magnitude (Fleming
and Crerar, 1982) and thus a precipitation of over 3000 tonnes could
potentially be harnessed annually from uid discharged from the
HS-Energy facility alone.
Few authors have reported on practical applications of modied geothermal SiO2 and still fewer on applications of unmodied
SiO2 . A possible use of geothermal SiO2 as a ller in paper (Johnston
et al., 2004) and as a precursor for silicates (Gallup et al., 2003) has
31
Silica gel (SiO2 xH2 O) is widely used as an adsorbent in chromatographic columns for isolation and purication of compounds
from a mixture. One of the most common methods for the analysis of basic pharmaceuticals is liquid chromatography (McKeown
et al., 2001), which conventionally relies on synthetic silica and
silica derivatives as the stationary phase. The production of synthetic chromatographic silica typically involves several chemical
reaction steps followed by a series of after-treatment processes
(Hoffmann et al., 2006; Zhang et al., 2009). In this paper we discuss the chromatographic application of unmodied geothermal
silica. A comparison to sintered geothermal silica is also made.
1.3. Phycocyanin
The Blue Lagoon is a specic geothermal biotope known for
its unique microbial ecosystem (Petursdottir and Kristjansson,
1997; Petursdottir et al., 2009). It contains about 6000 m3 of
geothermal uid that is replenished every 40 h. The lagoons temperature remain constant at 38 1 C. The coccoid blue-green algae,
Cyanobacterium aponinum, one of the dominating species in the
microbial ecosystem, is used in this research. A water-soluble photosynthetic pigment in blue-green algae, Phycocyanin (C-PC), is a
protein that belongs to a family of phycobiliproteins. It is an accessory pigment to the green-colored pigment chlorophyll, also found
in blue-green algae. Together they are an essential component of
the algaes light harvesting system (McCall, 1998). Phycobiliproteins have in common a similar three-dimensional structure in
addition to their hydrophilic nature. Among the many interesting applications of C-PC is its use as a uorescent marker of cells
and macromolecules (Ramos et al., 2010) and as a natural colorant in food and cosmetic products, replacing synthetic dyes,
which are often unsafe or even toxic. C-PC has also been shown
to exhibit bio-activity (Eriksen, 2008) which makes it an excellent
choice as an additive in food and pharmaceutical products. However, the use of C-PC in these products is dependent on obtaining
the appropriate grade of purity. The purity of C-PC can be evaluated as the ratio between the light absorbance at = 620 nm and
280 nm (A620 /A280 ), where A620nm is the maximum absorbance of
C-PC and A280nm is the total absorbance of proteins. A purity of
0.7 is considered food grade, 3.9 reactive grade and greater than
4.0 analytical grade (Rito-Palomares et al., 2001). Despite the many
possible applications of phycobiliproteins, their use is limited by
the high cost of extraction and purication. Most of the methods
used for purication of C-PC involve a sequence of operations that
include precipitation, centrifugation, dialysis, ion-exchange and gel
ltration chromatography and chromatography on hydroxyapatite
(Rito-Palomares et al., 2001). The purication cost has been estimated at 5090% of the total production cost (Patil et al., 2006).
Thus, improvements in the purication procedure can lead to a
signicant reduction in the production cost. C-PC is unstable to
heat and light in an aqueous solution and denatures at temperatures above 45 C (Jespersen et al., 2005). This instability puts
constraints on the possible processing methods that can be used.
In the experiments described in this paper, unmodied geothermal
SiO2 precipitated from Blue Lagoon geothermal uid was used as
an alternative to other chromatographic materials to extract C-PC
from the coccoid blue-green alga, cyanobacterium aponinum. When
SiO2 powder was soaked in a saline solution of a ruptured cell mass,
the C-PC was selectively adsorbed in contrast to other hydrophobic
2. Experimental conditions
32
Fig. 3. Concentration of C-PC (dashed line) and C-PC purity (solid line) as a function
of eluent volume.
of using the geothermal SiO2 as a stationary phase in the chromatographic column requires further evaluation. An attempt to
strengthen the SiO2 agglomerates with sintering resulted in a total
loss of performance accompanied by a decrease of its specic surface area from 60 to 1 m2 (see Table 1). This problem might be overcome by embedding the unsintered SiO2 agglomerates in a rigid
matrix, but such speculations are beyond the scope of this paper.
(1)
Table 1
Surface characteristics of the BL-silica.
BL-silica
Micropore surf.
area t-Plot [m2 /g]
Unsintered
Sintered
50
1
6
0.3
0.24
0.001
23
N/A
Fig. 4. Absorption spectra for algae extracts of different purity: crude extract (dotted
line), collection #1 (dashed line), and collection #2 (solid line).
33
Fig. 5. X-ray diffraction pattern of BL-silica before (black solid line) and after sintering at 1000 C for 2 h (red dotted line).
The PR and CC-PC values for the crude extract are between 0.46
and 18.2 mg/ml, respectively. It therefore contained 1.800 mg
C-PC (100 ml 18.2 mg/ml) whereas the area under the measured concentration curve (Fig. 3.) corresponds to 1100 mg. This
equals to a total recovery of 61% ((1.1/1.8) 100%). A higher BLsilica/crude-extract ratio might increase the recovery rate of the
C-PC but most likely at the expense of its purity.
Fig. 6. SEM images at two different magnications of the BL-silica: (a) before sintering; and (b) after sintering. The inset in (b) shows crystals formed during the sintering
process.
34
Table 2
Chemical composition of BL-silica and BL-salt (wt%).
Acknowledgements
Component
SiO2
Cl
Na
Ca
Mg
Total
BL-silica
BL-salt
92.9
0.02
3.9
58.7
2.2
34.0
0.49
1.83
0.39
1.75
<0.1
<0.1
99.9
96.3