Impact of Agriculture On Environment
Impact of Agriculture On Environment
Impact of Agriculture On Environment
ENVIRONMENT
Impact of Agriculture on
Environment
Structure
3.1
Introduction
Objectives
3.2
3.3
3.4
3.5
Summary
Terminal Questions
3.1
INTRODUCTION
No industry is more vital to our present and future well being than agriculture and few
have shown the unsustainability of its existing practices. In Unit 1 of this course you
have read about the evolution of agriculture, which humankind has been engaged in
for thousands of years. However, earlier agriculture was closely knit at local level. All
farm inputs were locally available. Livestock provided milk and farm power. The
dung from livestock and agricultural residues were used as farmyard manure, which
replenished soil nutrients depleted by the crops.
The high yielding modern intensive farming systems have shown the amazing ability
of human beings to adapt and control the agro-ecosystems. They have been able to
remove or diminish the limitations nature has put on productivity, and to provide a
more favourable environment for crop growth, increasing dramatically their
productive potential.
However, the problem started with the rise in population, and the consequent need for
more food. For producing more food in the same land area, synthetic fertilizers came
in. For protection against the damage caused by insects and pests, pesticides appeared
on the scene. More food production also led to more withdrawal of water from the
limited available sources leading to high water table in ground water, salinization etc.
The high input intensive agriculture has solved the food and nutrient problem for the
growing population but agricultural land has continued to shrink and environmental
threat to the region has become a reality. Thus agriculture has a major influence on the
environment as it accounts for a large portion of the land use and water use patterns.
In 2010, the population of the developing countries of Asia is expected to become
3729 million. The demand for food is expected to be around 959 million tons and the
production is estimated to be around 927 million tons leaving a gap of 32 million tons.
It is estimated that though the region may be able to meet the demand without
excessive imports by 2010, over 200 million people would still suffer from chronic
under-nutrition, for crop yields per ha of land are declining every year alarmingly.
The slow down in agricultural output is due to several factors and one of the
significant ones is that the land is becoming unable to support the burden of intensive
47
Environment-Agriculture
Relationship
Objectives
After studying this unit, you should be able to:
3.2
Nations in all regions of the world, if they are to provide for long-term well-being of
their citizens, must find the right means to protect the environment to ensure
continued access to natural resources, generation to generation.
Deterioration of natural resources is being caused by various factors. Inappropriate
agricultural development is one such factor. Conventional agricultural practices result
in land degradation, deforestation, pollution of water bodies and loss of biodiversity.
Some hot spots of severe environmental deterioration may be cited:
48
the river basins of the Indus , Tigris and Euphrates in the middle east Asia
(salinization),
the forest margins of the lower Amazon (overgrazing and nutrient loss),
the peri-urban areas of Mexico City (po llution from agricultural chemicals),
the humid low land areas of Africa (nutrient depletion, acidification and erosion),
the sub-humid, semi-arid border zone of West Africa (migration from dry land
degradation), and
3.2.1
Impact of Agriculture on
Environment
Pollution
High production levels in modern agriculture are achieved by using nutrients such as
nitrogen (N), phosphorus (P) and potassium (K) in the form of chemical fertilizers,
manures, sludge, legumes and crop residues. When nutrients are applied in excess of
plant needs they have the potential to pollute soils, and surface and ground water.
A significant portion of nitrogenous fertilizers leaches through the ground and
increases the nitrate concentration of ground water. When this high nitrate
concentration water is used for drinking, it may cause diseases like
methaemoglobinaemia (blue baby) in bottle fed babies and also cancer. WHO has
prescribed the safe drinking water limit for nitrogen (N) as 45 ppm (part per million).
But the study of nitrate content of ground water in several parts of India has revealed
that in water table aquifers (dug wells), the nitrate concentration at many places is
quite high, more than 100 ppm. (mg/l). Table3.1 shows the worst affected areas in
India having nitrate concentration more than 300 ppm.
Table 3.1: Nitrate concentration in various Indian states exceeding 300 ppm
State
Site
District
West Bengal
Uttar Pradesh
Uttar Pradesh
Jangipur
Birdha
Bansi
Badshapur
Hastinapur
Mirapur
Bangarmaou
Murshidabad
Hamirpur
Jhansi
Jaunpur
Meerut
Saharanpur
Unnao
Sangrur
Bhatinda
Hoshiarpur
Ambala
Faridabad-1
Faridabad-2
Sirsa
Hissar
Hisar-2
Hisar-3
Gurgaon-1
Gurgaon-2
Gurgaon-3
Mahendragarh-1
Mahendragarh-2
Mahendragarh-3
Mahendragarh-4
Mahendragarh-5
Punjab
Haryana
NIL
NIL
Koraput
NIL
310
Though the nitrate in water is harmful for drinking purposes, it is beneficial for crops.
Most of the plants/crops take nitrogen in the form of nitrate or ammonium. When this
water having high nitrate concentration is used for agriculture, the requirement of
nitrogen fertilizer is reduced accordingly. For example, 10 cm irrigation with ground
water containing 100 ppm nitrate (mg/l) will contribute 44.5 kg of NO 3-N. If a farmer
is using the recommended dose of 120 kg N, then three irrigation of such water will
49
Environment-Agriculture
Relationship
meet the entire nitrogen requirement of the crop thus making any additional nitrogen
unnecessary.
In crop production the main emphasis is on the use of synthetic N fertilizers. As an
example, in Haryana N, P (P 2O5), K (K2O) is used in the ratio of 48:11:1 showing the
heavy dose of nitrogen application as compared to P and K. If the NO3 concentration
in ground water is not taken into consideration and additional nitrogen is applied, it
will further accentuate the nutrient imbalance and ground water pollution may go on
accumulating further. Excessive nitrogen is also not good for plants because it affects
the maturity of crop adversely. It may cause lodging and even reduce the sugar
content in beetroot and sugarcane crops.
Besides giving the required elements to the crop, the chemical fertilizers used in
agriculture also supply heavy metals to the soils. Though some of them like copper
(Cu), zinc (Zn), manganese (Mn), and iron (Fe) in low concentrations are beneficial to
the crops as micronutrients, some of the other heavy metals like cadmium, lead,
arsenic are toxic and may pollute the soils resulting in uptake of these toxic heavy
metal by plants and enter the food chain for humans and animals. It is therefore,
necessary to know about such fertilizers, which contribute more heavy metals thereby,
exceeding the safe limits.
Table 3.2: Heavy metal contents (ppm) of some of the fertilizers
Fertilizer
Single super phosphate
Urea
Calcium Am. Nitrate
Muriate of Potash
Cu
26
0.36
0.2
3
Zn
60-165
0.5
6
3
Mn
65-270
0.5
11
8
Mo
3.5
0.2
0.2
Pb
609
4
200
88
Cd
187
1
6
14
3.2.2
Land Degradation
In terms of direct impact on the environment, farming activities are major contributors
to soil erosion, land salinization and loss of nutrients. For example, it has been
estimated that about 25 percent of soil degradation in Asia and Pacific region has
occurred directly from agricultural activities.
50
One of the most serious impact of intensive agriculture is the clearing of forest land
and burning of vegetation. In fact agriculture is the most important cause of forest loss
in Southeast Asia. Subsequent burning of the remaining vegetation after land clearing
had been responsible for the haze that covered much of South-east Asia in 1997 and
1998. The burning of vegetation in Kalimantan and Sumatra, after land clearing for oil
palm plantations, got out of hand and spread to forest areas that were not supposed to
be burnt. The problem became more serious when the peat just below the soil surface
also started burning. Once the peat land catches fire it is very difficult to extinguish it.
The smoke produced mainly contributed to the haze experienced in South-east Asia
during last two years.
Impact of Agriculture on
Environment
(a)
(b)
Fig.3.1: Some of the agricultural practices responsible for declining soil structure: a) Excessive
movement of heavy machines; and b) Overgrazing
51
Environment-Agriculture
Relationship
Whenever soil is disturbed it becomes loose and may move with water or wind. There
is natural erosion of soils, especially in hilly areas. But there too human
activity/agricultural activity enhances soil erosion. Levelling of the land and the
drainage system also cause environmental problems.
Soil erosion in humid tropics is a very serious problem especially on slopes.
Poor cultivation techniques, overgrazing, lack of vegetative cover are agricultural
practices that lead to soil erosion.
Much of the eroded soil ends up in waterways. Downstream sedimentation is a serious
impact of modern agricultural practices. Sedimentation fills in productive water
reservoirs, destroys fisheries, coral reefs in tropical waters and as we had said earlier
sediments carry ammonia, nitrates, and other chemicals in downstream waters causing
eutrophication.
Soil Salinization
The soil or water containing excessive salts is classified as saline. The degree of
salinity is measured by the concentration of salts. The easiest way to quantify the
concentration of salts in a soil is to measure its electrical conductivity (EC). Its unit is
Siemens/m. Soil with less salt will have low electrical conductivity. As the amount of
salts increases its EC also increases. A soil is classified as saline if its EC becomes
more than 4 dS/m. A number of factors are responsible for salinity build-up. Some of
them are nature and content of soluble salts in irrigation water, soil type, water table,
nature of crops grown, and the water management practices.
The agricultural practices responsible for saline soil problems are:
52
In coastal areas, excessive exploitation of ground water for agriculture has caused
intrusion of sea water, res ulting in worsening of salinity related problems.
Impact of Agriculture on
Environment
Soil acidification
When pH of a soil becomes less than 6.5 it becomes acidic. Normally
soils having pH between 6.5 and 7.5 are classified as neutral soils. If the soil pH
becomes lower than 6.5 it becomes acidic and if it becomes higher than 7.5 it is
classified as alkaline.
Agricultural practices that may cause soil acidification are:
SAQ 2
What is soil structure and what agricultural practices disturb it?
3.2.3
Water Resources
The growth of agriculture and urbanization has imposed growing pressure on the
South Asian regions already strained water resources in terms of both quality as well
as quantity. This is evident in the gradual decline in per capita availability of water
throughout the region. In India, for instance, the per capita availability fell from 6000
cubic meters in 1947 to 2300 cubic meters in 1998. Estimates for the year 2030
predict acute shortage of water in India (TERI 2000). Use of groundwater for
irrigation has led to the depletion of underground aquifers in several parts of the
region.
In some parts of the Indian states of Haryana, Rajasthan, Punjab and Gujarat the
extent of over exploitation ranges from 100%-260% as compared to the critical levels
of 85%. In Bangladesh excessive withdrawal of water has led to water logging and
salinity and to land subsistence in cities like Dhaka (TERI 2000).
Water quality is affected through intensive agriculture in the following ways:
Environment-Agriculture
Relationship
It is worth mentioning how a water scarce country like Israel has solved this problem
by modern methods of irrigation, timely application of water, recycling of water etc.
(a)
(b)
Fig.3.2: a) Drip irrigation; and b) sprinkler irrigation is more useful for saving water
SAQ 3
How can we save water and still fulfil the requirements of the crops?
3.2.4
Biodiversity Erosion
Within the Asia-Pacific region, overall habitat losses have been the most acute in the
Indian Subcontinent. The underlying causes are international trade in timber;
introduction of non-native species, improper use of agro-chemicals, excessive hunting
and poaching (TERI 2000).
Intensive agriculture has resulted in loss of biodiversity in the following ways:
3.2.5
Pesticide Residues
All types of agriculture suffer from pest infestation. Even today with modern
technology the total losses from all pests are huge. The major agricultural pests are
insects, diseases and nematodes, and weeds and vertebrates (mainly rodents and birds)
that feed on grain and fruits.
Before the Industrial Revolution, farmers could do little to prevent pests except
remove them when they appeared or use farming methods that tended to decrease their
density.
With the advances in modern agricultural sciences, chemical pesticides were
developed. The use of pesticides has grown, reaching $31.25 billion worldwide in
1996. About 80% of the pesticides in use are applied in developing countries.
54
Pesticides are a group of chemicals meant for preventing/ destroying any pest
detrimental to man or his interest during production, processing, storage,
transportation and distribution of food items like cereals, fruits, vegetables and other
crops. These include insecticides, herbicides, rodenticides, nematicides,
chemosterilents, mollusides, fungicides, plant growth regulators, defoliants, desiccants
attractants, and repellents.
Box 3.1: Chemical pesticides
Impact of Agriculture on
Environment
Chemical pesticides like DDT, aldrin and carbendazim etc. have created a revolution
in agriculture. However, in addition to the negative environmental effects of
individual chemicals such as DDT, their use has other major drawbacks. One such
problem is known as secondary pest outbreaks, which occur after extended use (and
possibly because of extended use) of a pesticide. Secondary pest outbreaks can come
about in two ways: (1) reduction in one target species reduces competition with a
second, which then increases and becomes a pest or (2) the pest develops resistance
to the pesticides through evolution and natural selection, which favour those in the
population with a greater immunity to the chemical. Developed resistance has
occurred with many pesticides.
It has been estimated that the crop losses in India because of pests and diseases vary
from 10% to 30 % depending upon the crop, climate and region. In financial terms
these losses amount to Rs. 290 billions per year (Table 3.3).
Table 3.3: Estimated crop losses due to pests and diseases in India
Crop
Rice
Wheat
Jowar
Pulses
Oilseeds
Cotton
Sugarcane
Loss in %
18.6
11.4
10.0
7,0
25.0
22.0
15.0
No of samples analysed
Haryana
H.P.
Tamil Nadu
Gujarat
A.P.
U.P.
W.B.
Kerala
Punjab
Orissa
Delhi
Assam
Rajasthan
Karnataka
M.P.
Maharashtra
Total Average
1236
436
85
104
275
244
75
72
148
105
68
32
388
370
195
278
4111
% samples
contaminated
56.2
19.5
91.8
80.8
29.8
100
56
100
58.1
51.4
77.9
46.9
53.4
19.7
96.5
73.4
55.1
% samples
above MRL
4.5
1.4
15.3
13.5
45.9
52.8
4.7
12.4
12.1
7.3
1.5
13.7
9.5
55
Environment-Agriculture
Relationship
The analysis has shown that pesticide residues affect most of the crops. A comparative
analysis is given in Table 3.5.
Table 3.5: Contamination of fruits and vegetables crops by pesticides (crop wise)
Crop
Tomato
Cucumber
Apple
Okra
Cabbage
Smooth Gourd
Pointed Gourd
Brinjal
Capsicum
Indian Bean
Bitter Gourd
Ridge Gourd
Pea grains
Potato
Cauliflower
Pea
Beans
Spinach
Mustard
Cowpea
Cluster bean
French bean
Bottle Gourd
Snake Gourd
Carrot
Fenugreek
Pigeon pea
Total Average
No of samples
598
186
142
468
302
81
15
843
124
22
125
46
161
219
376
20
8
40
12
55
24
51
33
36
14
12
12
4111
% of samples
contaminated
45.3
52.5
18.3
60.0
62.6
64.2
46.7
58.5
31.5
72.7
65.6
47.8
47.8
62.6
66.2
65.0
62.5
85.0
41.7
81.8
50.0
17.6
45.6
80.5
57.1
41.7
100
55.1
% samples
above MRL
5.4
6.5
-15.8
7.0
--9.8
12.1
9.1
6.4
-7.5
9.6
16.8
--7.5
-32.7
4,2
15.7
3.0
19.4
-8.3
58.3
9.5
Pesticides residues were also found in milk samples collected from the following
locations showing that the cows and buffalo were eating such fodder or feed material
which contained pesticide residues and then these residues entered in the food chain of
milch cattle and in the milk (Table 3.6).
Table 3.6: Residues of HCH and DDT in whole milk in India
(a) HCH (Hexachloro cyclohexane)
Location
New Delhi
Ludhiana
Hissar
Kanpur
Hyderabad
Coimbatore
Pusa Bihar
Bangalore
Bhubaneshw ar
Jorhat
Jaipur
Anand
Vellyani
No. Analyzed
12
30
25
24
38
90
24
30
45
12
20
60
25
No. contaminated
12
30
25
24
38
90
8
25
45
12
20
60
25
Impact of Agriculture on
Environment
No. Analyzed
12
30
25
24
21
80
24
30
45
31
16
60
18
No. contaminated
12
30
25
19
21
80
11
26
36
31
16
60
18
Environment-Agriculture
Relationship
3.3
So far we have discussed the local and regional effects of agriculture on the
environment. Global effects are not so obvious, though they are equally serious. In
this section, we will examine and assess the global impact of modern agriculture on
climate change. Intensification of agriculture has resulted in heavy reliance on
irrigation, increased fertilizer and pesticides use and crop residue burning. All of them
have a direct impact on global climate change via emission of greenhouse gases.
3.3.1
Green house effect is the warming of the lower atmosphere and surface of a planet by
a complex process involving sunlight, gases and particles in the atmosphere.
All hot objects emit electromagnetic radiation at a range of wavelengths depending on
the temperature of the object. The higher the temperature is, the shorter the
wavelength of the radiation, and vice versa. The sun, with a surface temperature of
over 6000oC, emits radiation with wavelengths 200nm to 4m.
The earth is enveloped by gaseous atmosphere and gases in the atmosphere absorb
radiation selectively. When the short-wave radiation from the sun passes through
these gases, they allow it to fall on the earth. As a result, the earth absorbs some of the
radiation and it gets heated to a mean temperatur e of about 15oC. In turn, the earth
radiates long wave infrared radiation some of which is absorbed by the atmospheric
gases and particles. As a result the gases and particles are heated. Sending out infrared
rays of their own then cools them. Some of these rays go into space. The remainder
radiate back towards the earths surface adding to the warming of the surface layer of
air (Fig. 3.3). The heat trapping gases of the atmosphere are known as greenhouse
gases.
Fig.3.3: Greenhouse effect; refers to the wavelength of the radiation. Short implies greater
energy and long radiation has less energy
58
The greenhouse gases are: carbon dioxide, methane, water vapour, nitrous oxide and
ozone. The natural greenhouse gases keep the earth roughly 33oC warmer than what it
would be if there was no atmosphere. However, on an average for the earth as a
whole, the incoming solar energy is balanced by outgoing terrestrial radiation. It is
important to understand that the green house effect is a natural phenomenon that has
been occurring for millions of years on earth as well as other planets of our solar
system. The majority of natural greenhouse warming is due to water in the atmosphere
but the gases we are concerned with are those that result in part from anthropogenic
processes, that is, those that occur due to human activities.
Impact of Agriculture on
Environment
Increases in the concentration of greenhouse gases will reduce the efficiency with
which earth cools. More of the outgoing terrestrial radiation from the surface is
absorbed by the atmosphere and emitted at higher altitudes and colder temperatures.
This results in an enhanced greenhouse effect which tends to warm the lower
atmosphere and surface. This effect has operated in the earth's atmosphere for billions
of years due to the naturally occurring greenhouse gases: water vapour, carbon
dioxide, ozone, methane and nitrous oxide.
Anthropogenic aerosols (small particles) in the troposphere, derived mainly from the
emission of sulphur dioxide from fossil fuel or biomass burnin g can absorb and reflect
solar radiation. They create a negative effect and cool the climate. But these aerosols
have a much shorter lifetime (days to weeks) as compared to most greenhouse gases
(decades to centuries) so their presence responds much more quickly but for short
duration.
Any change in the radiative balance of the earth whether due to greenhouse gases or
aerosols will tend to alter atmospheric and oceanic temperatures and the associated
weather patterns (hydrological cycles, cloud distribution and rainfall patterns).
As explained above, the presence of these green house gases has raised the earths
surface temperature from 19 C to 15 C.
It is quite clear that not only the presence of these gases but their contribution in
raising the temperature is also equally important. Some gases contribute more and
some less depending upon their concentration and warming potential (Table 3.7).
Table 3.7: Greenhouse gases influences by anthropogenic activities
Gas
Pre-industrial
atmospheric
concentration
Current
concentration
Current
annual
increase (%)
Atmospheric
life time
(Yrs)
Global
warming
potential
relative toCO 2
CH4
N2 O
CFC-12
280 ppmv
0.70 ppmv
280 PPBV
370 ppmv
1.72 ppmv
310 ppbv
5.03 pptv
0.25%
(0.75 ppbv)
4%
(18 -20 pptv )
CO2
0.5%
(1.5 to1.8
ppmv)
0.8%
(0.013
ppmv)
50-200
12-17
150
102
24.5
320
4000
The table shows that from many thousand years to about 200 years ago the
concentration of these green house gases in the atmosphere was almost the same/
unchanged. The changing trend started only 200 years ago mainly because of
59
increased anthropogenic activities. Not only this, some of the gases (CFCs) which
were not present in the atmosphere earlier entered into atmosphere from the year 1930
onwards. Though their concentration is very low, their overall contribution to global
warming is very high.
Environment-Agriculture
Relationship
Deforestation/
land use changes
CO2
N 2O
Biomass burning
Land conversion
to agriculture
CH4
Ruminants
Rice paddy
cultivation
Aerosol spray
propellants
Natural gas
releases
Solvent
CFC
Refrigerants
Foam packaging
The composition of greenhouse gases is shown in Fig. 3.5. Note that carbon dioxide,
methane and nitrous oxide are directly related with agriculture.
TRACE GASES
Carbon dioxide
(CO 2)
Nitrous
oxide (N 2O)
49.0%
6.0%
18.0%
13.0%
14.0%
Methane (CH4)
Agricultural Contribution
Fertilizer, cultivated
natural soil, biomass
burning
Ruminants, rice
paddies, biomass
burning
13%
10%
Other
Chlorofluorocarbons (CFCs)
Fig.3.5: Composition and source of greenhouse gases in the atmosphere
60
2.6%
While it is certain that agriculture is a source of carbon dioxide, methane and nitrous
oxide, it can also be considered as a sink of carbon dioxide and to some extent
methane. We will discuss each gas separately in the following subsection.
Impact of Agriculture on
Environment
SAQ 5
a) Why does the sun radiate in the short wave range (mainly UV and visible) while
the earth radiates long wave radiation?
b) Why is global warming known as greenhouse effect?
3.3.2
Carbon Dioxide
Agriculture is not a major source of carbon dioxide. It mainly comes from the burning
of fossil fuels for energy (electrical power, vehicles etc). However, agriculture and
forestry play an important role in land use conversion, (land clearing and forest
burning for cultivation or grazing) which is the second largest cause of increased
carbon dioxide emission. The net effect is carbon loss from both biomass and soils.
Main source of carbon dioxide to the atmosphere by agriculture is through tillage. The
tillage operation increases the biological decomposition of soil organic matter
resulting in release of CO2. The second pathway is use of machinery where fuel
(diesel) releases CO2. The third important source of CO2 is burning of crop residue.
It may be noted the agriculture is also a sink for CO2. During plant growth, the
process of photosynthesis absorbs atmospheric CO 2. Due to this very reason the global
Climate Change Community does not consider agriculture as a source of CO2. (In
official GHG (Greenhouse Gases) accounting procedures as supported by IPCC).
Carbon dioxide from Tillage Operations
During a tillage operation, soil aggregates are broken, increasing oxygen supply and
surface exposure to soil organic matter and thereby promote its decomposition.
In one long- term trial at CIMMYT, Mexico, the impact of 3-4 cultivations per year
was compared with a no tillage experiment. After 8 years it was revealed that soil
organic carbon in the top 20 cm declined from 1.37% to 1.12 %. The net loss of soil
organic carbon in 8 years was 3.6 t C/ha (equivalent to 450 kg C/ha/yr.).
Where has this carbon gone? It has gone to the atmosphere through CO2 emission.
Fuel Consumption in Agriculture
Heavy diesel fuel used by tractors is also responsible for CO2 emission. It is estimated
that for every litre of diesel consumed, 2.6 kg of CO2 is released to the atmosphere.
Assuming that 150 litres of diesel is used per hectare for tractor and irrigation
pumping in conventional systems, this would amount to 400 kg CO 2 being emitted per
year. An off site source which is often neglected, is the production of CO 2 during the
manufacture of fertilizers. It is estimated that production of I kg of N fertilizer would
release 1.8 kg of CO2.
3.3.3 Methane
Methane is the lightest hydrocarbon having one carbon and four hydrogen atoms. Its
molecular weight is 16. It is also a fuel gas commonly called marsh gas because it is
produced from marshy lands. Biogas or Gobar gas also contains 60-70% of methane.
Even if the concentration of methane is quite low as compared to that of CO 2, its
global warming potential (GWP) is 20 times that of CO2. Rice and ruminant animal
production are the two largest sources of anthropogenic methane. These two sources
together contribute about 40% to global methane budget (Table 3.8).
61
Environment-Agriculture
Relationship
Individual estimate
Total
Natural
1 Tg = 1 million tons
Wetlands
Termites
Oceans
Others
Total of Natural Sources
115(55-150)
20(10-50)
10(5-50)
15(10-40)
160(110-210)
Anthropogenic Sources
Fossil fuel based
Natural gas
Coal mines
Petroleum Refining
Coal combustion
Total of fossil related
40(25-50
30(15-45)
15(5-30)
? (1-30)
100(70-120)
Biogenic
Enteric Fermentation
Rice paddies
Biomass Burning
Landfills
Animal wastes
Domestic sewage/waste
Total of Bionic Sources
Total (All Identified Sources)
85(65-100)
60(20-100)
40(20-80)
40(20-70)
25(20-30)
25(15-80)
275(200-350)
535(410-660)
Sinks
Atmospheric removal
Troposphere OH
Stratosphere
Soils
Total Sinks
445(360-530)
40(32-48)
30(15-45)
515(430-600)
552(465-640)
Implied Increase
37(35-40)
1600
1400
1200
1000
800
600
1750
62
1800
1850
1900
1950
2000
Fig.3.6: Methane on the rise. Since 1750 methane in the air has more than doubled due to human
activity. It could double again by 2050.
Impact of Agriculture on
Environment
Environment-Agriculture
Relationship
depends upon the toxic conditions of the dumps. When these wastes become a part of
stagnant water, the amount of methane increas es considerably. Among the various
types of wastes, the most important is the animal excreta. But the crop wastes and
other wastes which are also sometimes used in rice fields also emit methane. The
more the organic matter in the stagnant water, the more methane is expected to come
out. The process also depends upon the temperature and pH. Temperature between 3035C is most favourable for methane production.
The production of methane is reduced as the temperature goes down and below 15C,
the methane production becomes very low. As regards the pH, its range between 6.48.0 is most favourable, on either side of this range, methane production is reduced.
Box 3.2: Methane emission in South Asian Region
Under UNDP-IRRI Inter regional programme, methane emission from rice fields
was measured at eight locations in five rice producing countries (India, China,
Thailand, Philippines and Indonesia) covering main rice ecosystems, i.e., irrigated,
rain fed and deepwater. The results revealed that irrigated rice fields had the
highest emission rates of all rice ecosystems. Seasonal emission varied from 1g/m2
to 50 g/m 2.
Continuously flooded fields emitted more methane. Depending upon local
precipitation, emission from rain fed rice fields may be less than half of the
emission from irrigated fields and w as generally less than 5 g/m 2. In a reference
treatment at all these locations using common cultivar IR72 and continuously
flooded conditions, the seasonal methane emission varied from 1.7 g/m2 to
24.4 g/m2, which may be attributed to soil conditions and climate.
Experiments at IARI during 1994-97 have shown that intermittent irrigation, which
is the usual practice, reduces methane emission unto about 28%. At Pant Nagar
the reduction in methane emission due to intermittent irrigation was found to be
30% as compared to continuous flooded conditions. IPCC in 1996, on the basis of
results obtained by various rice growing countries, have suggested that emission
factors under single and multiple aeration as 0.5 and 0.2 of that against
continuously flooded fields. Using IPCC methodology and countrys default va lue
of 10 g/m2, the methane emission from rice cultivation in India should not exceed
2.5Tg/yr.
The main reason of low methane emission from rice fields in India is that the soils
of major portion of rice growing areas have very low organic carbon. Incubation
studies on some soils of rice growing areas of India have shown large differences
in the methane production potential because of their organic carbon content. The
use of organic manuring is also not very common in India and Indian soils have
very low organic carbon. This is one of the reasons of low methane emission from
Indian rice fields.
wheat is burnt, a total of 0.14 million tons of methane is emitted. This is equivalent to
20% of the total methane emitted from rice fields in this area. Hence burning of crop
residues is also an important source of methane besides carbon dioxide.
Impact of Agriculture on
Environment
But studies have also shown that mitigation of methane emission through intermittent
flooding may lead to N2O emission. However, more experiments are needed to
quantify the combined effect of emissions of methane and nitrous oxide from rice
fields. This has become necessary because the global warming potential of N2O is 15
times more than that of CH4.
Table 3.9: Estimated effect of management practices on CH4 emission from
flooded rice
Mitigation Practice
Irrigation management
Nutrient management
New cultivars and other practices
Total
65
Environment-Agriculture
Relationship
Cattle
Buffalo
Sheep
Goat
Others
Among the green house gases emitted from animal (enteric fermentation and manure
management), methane was the highest (99.985%) with N2O accounting for only very
small fraction (0.015%), which is negligible. Methane emission from domestic animal
source (anthropogenic activities) was 10.0 Tg for the year 1994 of which 8.9 Tg
(90%) was from enteric fermentation and the balance 1.1 Tg (10%) came from
manure management. The proportional contribution of emission is almost in the ratio
of 9:1 (enteric fermentation and manure management).
The best way to mitigate the methane emission from enteric fermentation of ruminant
animals is to improve their feed. Several efforts have been made to improve the feed
in such a way that they produce less methane.
SAQ 6
a) Why is methane an important greenhouse gas even if its concentration in
atmosphere is 1.8 ppmv as compared to a high concentration of about 360 ppmv
of CO2?
b) Can other aquatic plants and stagnant water emit methane?
3.3.4
Nitrous Oxide
Nitrous oxide is one of the oxides of nitrogen. Some other oxides of nitrogen like NO
and NO2 (together called NOx) are pollutants and are emitted by vehicles and other
stationary engines. N2O is another greenhouse gas responsible for climate change.
Year
Fig.3.8: Nitrous oxide on the rise
66
Since 1750, nitrous oxide in the atmosphere has risen by more than 15 percent (see
Fig. 3.8). Each year we add 7 to 13 million tons of nitrous oxide to the atmosphere
mainly by using nitrogen-based fertilizers and disposing of human and animal wastes.
Impact of Agriculture on
Environment
The nitrous oxide we release today could still trap heat more than a century from now.
It stays in the atmosphere about that long. A nitrous oxide molecule traps heat about
200 times more effectively than a carbon dioxide molecule.
The Table 3.10 of the sources and sinks of nitrous oxide clearly indicates that there is
a high degree of uncertainty in the emission figures of nitrous oxide. One of the
reasons may be its low concentration in the atmosphere (300 ppbv) and determination
of N 2O concentration at such low levels. But the latest measuring techniques have
made it possible to measure these fluxes at reasonable costs. Hence it has become
necessary to have more and more experimental measurements to come out with more
and more reliable estimations.
Both fertilized and unfertilized soils emit N2O. While the fertilizer is a source in case
of fertilized soils, the inbuilt nitrogen of the soil contributes otherwise to the release of
this gas. Measurement of N2O fluxes from soils as a result of use of N in inorganic or
organic forms is of great importance to the atmospheric scientists because of the effect
of N 2O on ozone destruction and its radioactive forcing. But the soil scientists and
agronomists are also concerned about the nitrogen losses from the applied fertilizers
and manures.
Table 3.10: Sources/sinks of nitrous oxide
Sources
Nitrification
Denitrification
Cultivated soils
Fertilized soils
Unfertilized soils
Tropical soils
Temperate soils
Oceans
Fossil fuel
Biomass burning
Total
Total emission from soil
Sink
Stratospheric reaction
with ozone
Photolysis
6-11
11
Experiments have shown that both the processes of nitrification and denitrification
contribute to the release of nitrous oxide from the soils.
Experiments in rice fields conducted at IARI have shown that as the redox potential
becomes positive methane emission is decreased, but N2O emission increases. In
another experiment it has been shown that use of nitrification inhibitor DCD along
with urea and ammonium sulphate reduces both the methane and nitrous oxide
emission as compared to their lone use. Though there is lot of uncertainty about the
amount of N2O released, it is suspected that 1-2 % of applied N is lost as N2O.
67
Environment-Agriculture
Relationship
3.4
68
SUMMARY
Food, fibre and fodder are the three important produce of agriculture on which
whole mankind is dependent. Even though the impact of agriculture practices on
environment is quite significant, it is certain that only remedial measures can be
adopted to reduce or prevent the negative impacts of agricultural practices on
environment.
Impact of Agriculture on
Environment
The second important gas is nitrous oxide, though its actual emission is low, but
in view of its warming potential, it is also contributing significantly to climate
change. Its main sources are Nitrogen fertilizers (both chemical and biological)
and animal waste. The main greenhouse gas carbon dioxide is also being emitted
but since agriculture is also a sink for carbon dioxide its net contribution is not
well known. However, efforts are to be made to reduce these emissions also by
reducing tillage operations.
3.5
TERMINAL QUESTIONS
1.
Identify two impacts of agriculture on environment that you think are the most
negative impacts of agriculture.
2.
3.
How secure is India with respect to water resources? Suggest ways in which we
can improve water security.
4.
5.
6.
Why is global warming known as greenhouse effect? And why is climate change
being linked with emission of green house gases?
7.
8.
9.
10. How is methane produced from rice fields? What agricultural practices can
reduce methane emission from rice fields?
11. What is nitrous oxide and why is it classified as a greenhouse gas?
REFERENCES
1. Abrol, I.P. and Sehgal, J: Degraded lands and their rehabilitation in India. In Soil
Management for Sustainable Agriculture in Dry Land Areas; Indian Soc. Soil Sc.
pp. 107-118.
2. Agnihotri, N.P. (1999) Pesticide Safety Evaluation and Monitoring, All India
Coordinated Projecton Pesticide Residues, IARI, New Delhi.
3. Greenhouse gas emissions in India for the base year 1990: Scientific Report
No.11, May 1998, Eds.: Bhattacharya, S. and Mitra, A.P.
4.
5.
The green revolution turns sour Devender Sharma, New Scientist July (2000),
pp. 44-45.
69
Environment-Agriculture
Relationship
70