Single-Dose Azithromycin Versus Benzathine Benzylpenicillin For Treatment of Yaws in Children in Papua New Guinea: An Open-Label, Non-Inferiority, Randomised Trial
Single-Dose Azithromycin Versus Benzathine Benzylpenicillin For Treatment of Yaws in Children in Papua New Guinea: An Open-Label, Non-Inferiority, Randomised Trial
Single-Dose Azithromycin Versus Benzathine Benzylpenicillin For Treatment of Yaws in Children in Papua New Guinea: An Open-Label, Non-Inferiority, Randomised Trial
Summary
Lancet 2012; 379: 34247
Published Online
January 11, 2012
DOI:10.1016/S01406736(11)61624-3
See Comment page 295
Lihir Medical Centre
International SOS, Newcrest
Mining, Lihir Island,
Papua New Guinea (O Mitj MD,
R Hays MD, A Ipai HEO,
M Penias HEO, R Paru BSc,
D Fagaho BSc); and Barcelona
Centre for International Health
Research, Hospital Clinic,
University of Barcelona,
Barcelona, Spain (O Mitj MD,
E de Lazzari MSc, Q Bassat PhD)
Correspondence to:
Dr Oriol Mitj, Department of
Medicine, Lihir Medical Center,
PO Box 34, Lihir Island, NIP,
Papua New Guinea
[email protected]
Background Yawsan endemic treponematosis and, as such, a neglected tropical diseaseis re-emerging in children
in rural, tropical areas. Oral azithromycin is eective for syphilis. We assessed the ecacy of azithromycin compared
with intramuscular long-acting penicillin to treat patients with yaws.
Methods We did an open-label, non-inferiority, randomised trial at Lihir Medical Centre, Papua New Guinea, between
Sept 1, 2010, and Feb 1, 2011. Children aged 6 months to 15 years with a serologically conrmed diagnosis of yaws
were randomly allocated, by a computer-generated randomisation sequence, to receive either one 30 mg/kg oral dose
of azithromycin or an intramuscular injection of 50 000 units per kg benzathine benzylpenicillin. Investigators were
masked to group assignment. The primary endpoint was treatment ecacy, with cure rate dened serologically as a
decrease in rapid plasma reagin titre of at least two dilutions by 6 months after treatment, and, in participants with
primary ulcers, also by epithelialisation of lesions within 2 weeks. Non-inferiority was shown if the upper limit of the
two-sided 95% CI for the dierence in rates was lower than 10%. The primary analysis was per protocol. This trial is
registered with ClinicalTrials.gov, number NCT01382004.
Findings We allocated 124 patients to the azithromycin group and 126 to the benzathine benzylpenicillin group. In the
per-protocol analysis, after 6 months of follow-up, 106 (96%) of 110 patients in the azithromycin group were cured,
compared with 105 (93%) of 113 in the benzathine benzylpenicillin group (treatment dierence 34%; 95% CI
93 to 24), thus meeting prespecied criteria for non-inferiority. The number of drug-related adverse events (all
mild or moderate) was similar in both treatment groups (ten [8%] in the azithromycin group vs eight [7%] in the
benzathine benzylpenicillin group).
Interpretation A single oral dose of azithromycin is non-inferior to benzathine benzylpenicillin and avoids the need
for injection equipment and medically trained personnel. A change to the simpler azithromycin treatment regimen
could enable yaws elimination through mass drug administration programmes.
Funding International SOS and Newcrest Mining.
Introduction
Yawsan endemic treponematosis and, as such, a
neglected tropical diseaseis re-emerging. 40 years after
a worldwide control programme almost eradicated the
disease, it has re-emerged in children in poor, rural, and
marginalised populations in parts of Africa, Asia, and
South America. Yaws is caused by Treponema pallidum
subsp pertenue, and aects mainly skin, bones, and
cartilage. The disease has a natural history in primary,
secondary, and tertiary stages. Unless diagnosed and
treated at an early stage, yaws can become a chronic,
relapsing disease, and can lead to severe deforming bone
lesions in the long term.1
Between 1952, and 1964, WHO and UNICEF led a
worldwide campaign to control and eventually eradicate
yaws and other endemic treponematoses.2 Yaws became
the second disease targeted for eradication, after
smallpox. Control programmes were established in
46 countries and, by the end of 1964, the number of cases
had reduced by 95%, from 50 million to 25 million.
However, control eorts were gradually abandoned in
342
Articles
Methods
Study setting and patients
We undertook a prospective, open-label, non-inferiority,
randomised controlled trial at Lihir Medical Centre in
Papua New Guinea between Sept 1, 2010, and
Feb 24, 2011. The Lihir islands are geographically
remote, and despite being host to a major gold-mining
operation since 1995, the living conditions and sanitation
remain basic in most areas. Yaws is still a substantial
cause of morbidity in Papua New Guinea.18,19 Monthly
reports for monitoring several indicators of infectious
diseases and maternal and child health are being
collected via forms from hospitals, health centres, and
aid posts throughout the country. The national health
department estimated the number of yaws cases to be
17 000 nationwide in 2003, and 23 000 in 2008, of which
5000 were in New Ireland province, where Lihir Island
is located, and another 5000 in the neighbouring
province of West New Britain (unpublished).
All patients examined in the outpatient medical
department and suspected to have primary-stage or
secondary-stage yaws were assessed for possible inclusion
in the study. Eligible patients were children aged 6 months
to 15 years with a rapid plasma reagin titre of at least 1 in
16 and a reactive T pallidum haemagglutination test.
Exclusion criteria were known allergy to penicillin or
macrolide antibiotics, use of antibiotics active against
T pallidum during the preceding month, and known or
suspected coexisting diseases for which additional
antibiotic treatment with drugs eective against T pallidum
would be needed (use of quinolones, sulphonamides,
trimethoprim, and metronidazole was allowed).
www.thelancet.com Vol 379 January 28, 2012
Procedures
The primary endpoint was serological cure, dened as
a decrease in the rapid plasma reagin titre by at least
two dilutions at the 6-month follow-up examination,
compared with the titre at time of treatment. For ulcers,
improvement of lesions in 2 weeks after treatment was
also needed. Secondary endpoints were the individual
components of the primary endpoint, cure rate 3 months
after treatment, and cure rates according to stage of yaws,
rapid plasma reagin titre at treatment, and history of
household exposure.
To guarantee timely follow-up of participants, we
implemented a community-based follow-up strategy.
A eld team, consisting of a physician, a laboratory
technician, and a local health worker, located patients
twice a week (for follow-up visit) at their residence by
tracking detailed locator information. All participants
were re-examined 2 weeks after treatment to assess
clinical resolution. Photographic documentation of skin
lesions was obtained at diagnosis and at the 14-day followup visit for comparison over time. Patients with
worsening ulcers were retreated with benzathine
benzylpenicillin (at the same dose). We assessed all
participants at 3 months and 6 months after treatment. A
343
Articles
Statistical analysis
255 patients enrolled
5 ineligible
3 declined to participate
2 allergic to benzathine
benzylpenicillin
250 patients underwent
randomisation
12 lost to follow-up
2 adverse events
13 lost to
follow-up
110 completed
113 completed
92 (37)
84 (33)
Male sex
54 (44%)
59 (47%)
Exposure*
26 (21%)
20 (16%)
Primary stage
50 (40%)
56 (44%)
Secondary stage
74 (60%)
70 (56%)
Persisting ulcer
18 (15%)
15 (12%)
16 (13%)
11 (9%)
Arthralgias
68 (55%)
64 (51%)
12 (10%)
10 (8%)
Clinical presentation
47 (38%)
60 (48%)
1 in 64
77 (62%)
66 (52%)
Data are mean (SD) or number (%). RPR=rapid plasma regain. *Household
exposure to other children with open skin ulcers during the previous 3 months.
Results
Figure 1 shows the trial prole. 250 patients with
serologically conrmed yaws were randomly assigned
to receive either azithromycin or benzathine benzylpenicillin. Baseline clinical and serological characteristics
of the two treatment groups were similar (table 1). Mean
age of the participants was 88 years (SD 36; range
8 months to 15 years). 42% of patients had primary yaws
(table 1). The rapid plasma reagin titre was less than 1 in
32 in 107 (43%) participants and 1 in 64 or more in
143 (57%; table 1).
www.thelancet.com Vol 379 January 28, 2012
Articles
5 cm
5 cm
Figure 2: Ulcers in patients with primary-stage or secondary-stage yaws who were re-examined 2 weeks
after treatment
(A, B) Red, moist, bedded, 5 cm ulcer on the left leg of a 9-year-old patient with primary yaws. (C, D) Partially
epithelialised tumour 2 weeks after treatment with azithromycin.
Azithromycin %
(95% CI)
Risk dierence %
Benzathine
benzylpenicillin % (95% CI)
(95% CI)
100% (965100)
Cure at 3 months
PP=per protocol. ITT=intention to treat. *Including only patients with complete follow-up and study endpoint.
Including all randomised patients; we regarded patients with missing data as having treatment failure.
Azithromycin %
(95% CI)
Benzathine
Risk dierence %
benzylpenicillin % (95% CI) (95% CI)
909% (788964)
100% (945100)
891% (782949)
966% (883991)
929% (830972)
930% (833972)
100% (908100)
944% (866-978)
100% (851100)
955% (889985)
100% (816100)
920% (850959)
345
Articles
Discussion
Our ndings show that azithromycin was non-inferior to
benzathine benzylpenicillin for the primary composite
endpoint of serological cure at 6 months and healing of
ulcers. Furthermore, the two treatment groups had
similar rates of cure at 3 month follow-up and in
subgroups dened according to demographic and
biological characteristics. These results add to previous
evidence of the suitability of use of a single dose of a drug
such as azithromycin to treat various infectious diseases
(panel). Rates of serologically dened cure at 6 months
were substantially higher than expected for both
treatments, which validates our non-inferiority hypothesis
for the estimated penicillin cure rate. All participants had
a lower rapid plasmin reagin titre at 6 months than at
3 months, including 150 (67%) patients who
seroconverted. Additionally, we did not identify any
clinical or serological relapse after cure at 6 month followup. The azithromycin regimen did not resolve active
primary lesions in four patients. However, in the three
cases of failure that could be investigated, an
immunoperoxidase stain from a skin biopsy specimen
was negative for spirochaetes; therefore, we could not
conrm the biological treatment failure.
Azithromycin was well tolerated and no major adverse
eects occurred. Of participants who were treated with
azithromycin and interviewed, 8% reported mild to
moderate side-eects that were mainly gastrointestinal.
Only two children vomited within 30 min of oral
azithromycin administration, thus negligible drug
absorption would have occurred. These children were
then re-treated with benzathine benzylpenicillin. The
small number of participants vomiting after administration emphasises the suitability of azithromycin for
mass treatment programmes.
Our study had several limitations. First, diagnostic
criteria for inclusion in the study of primary lesions
did not include a microbiological test (eg, darkeld
microscopy); therefore, the non-healing ulcers could have
had post-treatment infection by other pathogens.
However, darkeld microscopy is rarely used to diagnose
treponemal infections because rapid serological tests are
available. Second, the imprecise denition of serological
cure, which could lead to overestimations in true rates of
cure, is a major issue aecting all research on the
treatment of treponematoses. Because laboratory technicians in this study were unaware of participants
treatment assignments, this drawback should not have
biased the comparison of cure rates between the groups.
Third, 6 months of follow-up might not be sucient to
assess the results after antibiotic treatment for yaws. Four
participants in the benzathine benzylpenicillin group did
not achieve serological cure. This nding could represent
a slower than usual decline in non-treponemal test titres
346
Articles
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
347
Reproduced with permission of the copyright owner. Further reproduction prohibited without permission.