Comparative Clauses

Download as pdf or txt
Download as pdf or txt
You are on page 1of 3
At a glance
Powered by AI
The passage discusses different types of comparisons that can be made in a comparative clause, including comparisons of equivalence, non-equivalence, sufficiency, excess, and others. It also provides examples of comparative structures that can be used with different parts of speech.

The types of comparisons discussed are comparisons of equivalence (as...as, just as ...as, etc.), comparisons of non-equivalence (more than, less than, etc.), comparisons of sufficiency (enough...to), and comparisons of excess (too...to).

Examples given include comparisons of adjectives (e.g. It is darker today than it was yesterday) and with infinitives/gerunds (e.g. Getting a visa will soon be more difficult than it is now), as well as comparisons with finite verbs (e.g. He didn’t play as well as you did).

COMPARATIVE CLAUSES

In a comparative clause, a proposition expressed in the main clause is compared with a


proposition expressed in the subordinate clause.
e.g. It is darker today than it was yesterday
Main clause
Subordinate clause
Types of comparison
Comparison of equivalence:
as...as, just as ...as, the same...as, not as...as, not so...as
Comparison of non-equivalence:
more than, less than, twice as...as, three times as...as
Comparison of sufficiency:
enough...to
Comparison of excess:
too...to
Comparisons with adjectives (also postdeterminers like quantifiers) and finite
verbs:
e.g. It is darker today than it was yesterday

Comparisons with quantifiers and finite verbs:


e.g. He doesnt pay as much tax as we do
Comparisons with adverbs and finite verbs:
e.g. He didnt play as well as you did
He sings more loudly than anyone else (does)
You work harder than he does
Notes
Than/ as + Subject + verb
e.g. He doesnt pay as much tax as we do
Than/ as + Object pronoun
e.g. He doesnt pay as much tax as us
Ellipsis:

Parts of the comparison that repeat the main verb can be left out in the subordinate clause,

though auxiliaries are repeated and the verb can be replaced by a form of do:
e.g. James enjoys the theatre more than Susan enjoys it
James enjoys the theatre more than Susan does
However, when ellipsis is taken to its fullest extent, ambiguity can arise as to whether the
remaining noun phrase is subject or object:
e.g. He loves his dog more than his children
more than they love it? (children is Subject)
or more than he loves them? (children is Object)
Formal English makes the distinction if his children is replaced by a pronoun:
e.g. He loves his dog more than they
He loves his dog more than them
But in other styles, the objective case them is used for both. So where there is danger of
ambiguity it is better to expand the clause.
Comparisons with adjectives and infinitives/ gerunds

e.g. Its sometimes as cheap to buy a new car as (it is) (to) repair the old one
Getting a visa will soon be more difficult than it is now
To-inf
Gerund

Particular occasions
General statements

However, often either can be used:


e.g. Its sometimes as cheap to buy a new car as (it is) (to) repair the old one.
Buying a new car is sometimes as cheap as repairing the old one.
It will soon be more difficult to get a visa than it is now.
Getting a visa will soon be more difficult than it is now.

To-inf + as/ than + to-inf.


e.g. It is as cheap to buy a new car as to repair the old one.

Gerund + as/ than + gerund


e.g. Buying a new car is as cheap as repairing the old one.

Finite verb + this/ that/ which + as/ than + gerund


e.g. He cleaned his shoes, which was better than doing nothing
2

cf. ?He cleaned his shoes, which was better than to do nothing
Ill deliver it by hand; this will be cheaper than posting it.
cf. ?Ill deliver it by hand; this will be cheaper than to post it
Would rather/ sooner
e.g. Most people would rather work than starve
As though/ as if
They acted as if/ as though they had never heard of us
(They acted the way one would do if they had never heard of us)
The situation in the main clause is compared to the situation in the comparative clause

You might also like