Negarestani Reza Undercover Softness Introduction Architecture and Politics Decay
Negarestani Reza Undercover Softness Introduction Architecture and Politics Decay
Negarestani Reza Undercover Softness Introduction Architecture and Politics Decay
as
1. 11li. essay was extensively developed from a seminar originally given at l1le
Cemfe for Cultural Studies, Goldsmiths, UniversilY ofL:mdoll, in May 2007. Whilsl
ti,e arguments and analyses are different, the fundamenlS arc still the same. I could
nOI have written this essay without engaging commentaries provided by Robin
Mackay, Ray Brassier, Euge.ne Thacker, Nick Land, Mark FL,her, Eyal Wcizman,
379
COLLAPSE VI
Hem-y poses a ludicrously bizarre yet metaphysi
cally troubling question regarding the possibility of the
generation of one species from the putrefying corpse of
another species: that of whether a fox can spontaneously
be generated from a dog's carcass_ Even more grotesquely
unsettling is Henry's stmng suspicion that 'it is not clear
whether all men are of the same species or not, and so too
with dogs and horses; [since] corpses which had been of
the same species when living might differ in species from
one another when corrupted.'2 For Henry of Langenstein,
puo-efaction creates a differential productive field in
which natural evolution is transmogIified into a sinisterly
putrid inter-species production line. The so-called beloved
creatures of God, in this corrupt scenario, are so unfortunate
tllat mey might be me festering fruits of rotten dead worlds
and corpses. It is not only that forms of different species
can overlap in decay, but tllat, according to Hemy of Hesse,
following the scholastic polymam Nicole Oresme and his
theory of qualities or accidental forms, in putrefaction one
species can uniformly or diffomllY deform in such a way
that it gradually assumes the latitude of fomlS associated
with other species. These defomuties can progress to such
an extent that one species might engender an entirely new
species, an unheard-of thing, a universe whose reality can
only be speculated upon_ The gradational movements of
decay
its vermict1lax liquidation across all latitudes and
longitudes - thus create fields of differential deformity
wherein the rotting corpse of one species or fonnal category
interpolates between all orner known species. In orner
words, gI-adients of decay or me blurring movements of rot
L. Tborndike, A HislUll 0/ Magic mul E<jJI:timcnlal StUll"', Vol III (New York:
Columbia University Press, 1934),485.
2.
380
are
that in putrifactitm
lite universe is calculated; yet even more importantly, the universe tllat
is sensed or specu.lated, wltetlter as an idea or a maierialiudfarm, is
tlte calculus if" an irfmiie rot - this is the belated epigraph from
which we shall begin Our investigation into the architecture,
mathesis and politics of decay:
The world bas its origin in putrefaction.
381
COLLAPSE VI
the entire universe through the putrefying gradations of a
corpse finds its most refined expression in politics and on
socio-political grounds. The power of differential interpola
tion or weird affective dynamism lends the idea of localized
or isolated decay a universal twist. "Vhat is rotting is indis
tinguishable from the wholesome remainder: not only
can the decaying part generate the healdlY parts through
differentiating into d1eir forms and ideas, the healthy parts
themselves may indeed be the gradients of a decaying part.
That is to say, in decay the origin qua the ideal shrinks more
and more toward nothing and becomes urtrecognisable,
whilst the idea is spewed forth from dIe differential
subtraction of the ideal. To put it differently, in putrefac
tion, it is not the decaying formation that is derived from
an idea, but the idea that is differentially or gradationally
formed duough putrefaction. The idea, accordingly, is a
deteriorating husk belatedly formed over an infmitely
shrunken ideal. It is in this sense that the most proper form
of a political formation - its idea - can be dIe product of
a process of decay feeding simultaneously on the uniden
tifiable corpse of the ideals of dlat system along with the
putridly amalgamated forms of odler decaying systems.
The process of decay constructs the idea only as a
byproduct of the differential regurgitation of a shriveling
body which is in the process of becoming less and less,
without ever finding the relief of complete annihila
tion. This is to say, once again, dlat the troubling aspect
of decay has to do more with its dynamism or gradation
dIan with its inherendy defiling namre: The most
proper form of a formation such as a political system
is not enveloped, as an origin or a priori ideal core;
it is rather unfolded as a form which is differentiated
382
383
COLLAPSE VI
limitropically decomposed Middle-Eastern or Balkanese
socia-political formation. In this sense of putrefaction and
rot as persisting and creeping, political decay casts a morbid
shadow on the question of relevancy (or irrelevancy) and
swiftly neutralises tlle idea of a 'localized rot'. There is no
decay whose swollen and slimy nodules of rot - its differ
entiated forms - have not already interpolated themselves
between all known and unknown fomls in the softest
and smoothest way possible so as to disguise the deterio
ration or putrefaction of the ,vhole. These are just a few
of the numerous conclusions to be drawn from a politics
of decay; conclusions that hardly any political system or
agency - despite testifying to the current fetid atmosphere
of world politics - is ready to admit. The reason for this
ironically passive stance, frequently espoused by both the
right and the left, is that sucll conclusions overtlrrow certain
presumptions about the fundanlents, ideas and concrete
fonnations of socio-political systems and agencies. vVhat
putrefaction changes, mimics and hollows Out is not only
the surface of a system but also its essential interiority, all
tlle way down to its inner ideals, fundaments, axioms and
so-called necessities. It is this spontaneous threat against the
interiority of the system or formation from within tllal nO
political system or agency is willing to acknowledge, for
it is exactly the admission of such a resident tlrreat - the
cllemical evil of decay - tllat casts doubts on one's political
agenda or tlle legitimacy of an emancipatory socio-political
formation. In short, to profoundly doubt the interiority of
one's politics or political agency can hardly be anything
other than a real politicalfoux pas.
384
weirdly-resident,
or undercover,
exteriorization of
political
intervention
against
decaying
formations,
385
COLLAPSE VI
Since decay is tile intensive destiny of terrestrial life and
ecology, tellurian formations and earthly tIlOught, a geophi
losophy or tell urian politics mat does nOt inflect upon its
intensive destiny has its head
metaphorically - in me clouds.
DECAY AS A BUILDING PRO CESS, OR EXTERIORlZATION
VIA
NESTED INTERlORITIES
The first axiom of mis essay is mat decay is a building
process; it has a cllemical slant and a differential (hence
open to mathematical formalisation) d ynamic distribution.
TIle process of decay builds new states of extensity, affect,
magnitude and even integrity from and out of a system or
formation vVlmout nullifying or reforming it. TIle decaying
format"ion is dispossessed of its chances to die or to liv e
wholesomely, to be abolished, reformed or delivered to
its origin. For mis reason, decay is an irresolute process of
building mat potentiates architectures which, whilst infinitely
open to new syntheses and transformations, cannot undergo
complete annulment or rerurn to meir original form.
One of the basic questions regarding decay as a building
386
387
COLLAPSE VI
utopian naivety for which the outside - viz. inflection upon
death and binding exteriority
is always available and
zero
the interiorized
388
389
COLLAPSE VI
itself is another interiorized horizon built upon an exterior
horizon which is in the process of loosening into its abyssal
backdrop. Just as the lines of envelopment and growth for
any horizon of interiority (whether the organism, earth,
sun, or matter on the cosmic level) are convoluted and
circuitous paths
(umwege)
an
organisms
mark
the
organic
interiority
as
the
390
disposition which
differential links
between its
actualities
and
391
COLLAPSE VI
its precursor exteriority. Yet precursor exteriority
(whether as the material, systematic, formal or ideal
fundament, as in the case of inorganic materials and
the organic horizon) is itself an interiorized horizon
determined by its i:nner and outer differential bonds.
This nestedness of interiorities wherein every idea
or form differentially - and in this case regresively
- inflects the next idea or form keeps decay's line of .
exteriority in conformity with the differential bonds
and the increasing inflections of the nested horizons of
interiority. Therefore, decay's process of exterioriza
tion does not bind the outside from without so much
as it binds the exteriority from V\rithin nested horizons
of interiority. Tlus binding of exteriority, however, is
in confomuty with differential fields inherent to each
horizon of interiority as well as inter-cOImective differ
ential bonds between these nested horizons. Conse
quently, the course of decay's process of exteriorization
392
the liquid that enters the first niche seeps into all such
connected caverns, the gradationally rotting object,
393
COLLAPSE VI
which are differentially exterior to the decaying horizon
of interiority. TI1e idea X is inflected back upon its
nested fundamental ideas which are themselves differ
entially interconnected (X inflects back to XI' Y, Z, D,
F, Z3> Yl' D2 Y2D3) }. The process of decay,
accordingly, traverses multiple ever-changing ideas
Xl' Y, Z, D,
D, F, Z3'
394
q/ decay
395
COLLAPSE VI
an impeding factOr for the extensive loosening of the
horizon, but contributes to the differential extension
of the horizon to the outside as well as the chemical
- hence contingently dynamic - productivity of the
horizon during decay. This illogical proportionality
between the insistence on remaining interiorized and
the spontaneous chemical loosening into the outside
shares more with the laws of the grave than with the
laws of nature - the putridly productive amalgamation
iJifillitum
. . .
396
Negarestani
Undercover Softness
397
COLLAPSE VI
The three reasons enumerated above briefly explain the
complications that the process of decay brings about for
the idea of return to the ori gin , and for a philosophy based
on the implications of binding extinction and decontrac
tion into originary death. Yet they also diagram the spatial
model in which the process of decay operates. In order
to present a formalism of decay which provides us with
a mathematical model for decay's dynamism, we must, in
addition to decay's conception of space, examine decay's
conception of time. For this reason, we shall inquire into
decay's conception of time and how it is expressed by the
spatial involutions generated by decay's line of exterioriza
tion as it traverses nested interiorities.
MEMENTO TABERE: THE TERNARY CONCEPTION OF TIME,
OR THE MISSING LINK OF CHEMISTRY
The process of decay has a spatial model comprised
of intensive envelopment and extensive development, and
whose subtractive correlation creates differential fields
which
are
398
399
COLLAPSE VI
l1rrough such complicity, the diachronicity of time and the
exteriority of space are evinced by each other: Whilst space
is perforated by time's emptiness or fundamental indiffer
ence, time's contingency is formally expressed by space's
unbound ferocity for the assimilation of any ground of indi
neither
viduation. It is this collective fold of complicity
demanding a conrrnonality between the parties involved
nor the substitution of either of them by the other
that
400
COLLAPSE VI
intermediating time can bring about the possibility of
ontological difference in relation to appropriated regions
(scales) of space.
Space-tinle syntheses necessary to support ontological
determination
require the bifurcation of TillIe into two
different but interconnected conceptions. Without such a
bifurcation, absolute time and thanatropic space remain
inherently exterior to each other and cannot ground the
conditions for ontological detennination on any level. It was
the Stoics who for the first time fully realised the necessity
of having different conceptions of time with the aim of
explaining the vital syntheses of time and space. In order
to explain the intensive vitality of determination qua differ
ence-in-itself, Deleuze adapts and ingeniously modifies the
Stoic model so as to develop and employ two conceptions
of time, the time of alon and the time of chronos.6 Since the
indefinite non-pulsed time of alon is inherently closed to vital
bodies, tllere must be another conception of time capable
of synthesizing with the scales of space and supporting
vital vibrations . This second conception of time is tlle
pulse-time of cill-onos, which supports organic vitalities and
provides time with qualities compatible with tlle structure
of corporeal beings. Accordingly, the first already-established
stage of our solution requires tl1e bifurcation of Time intO
two d ifferent but interconnected times. Following Deleuze,
but in contrast to his quasi-Heideggerian reading of time,
tl1ese two conceptions are reabsorbed in tlUs fashion:
6. See John Seilars, 'Alon and Cltronos: Ddell>c and the Stoic 111cor), of Time:
COLLAPSE III, 177-205.
402
Negarestani
Undercover Softness
2.
403
COLLAPSE VI
the interiorized contingencies of vital time become
s tructurally compatible with
the involutions
or
the
as
as
404
Negarestani
Undercover Softness
contingencies of
405
COLLAPSE VI
interiority inherent to the manifestations of life beconnes
an incubating chamber for the pure contingencies amd
non-belonging of cosmic time. It is this non-belonging qma
principle of negativity that is mobilized by the dynamism
intrinsic to involutions of space. TIle subtractive process of
decay is the outcome of such spatial mobilisation wherelby
the unilaterality of cosmic time undelpinned by its irruptive
contingencies gains a subtractive - that is, extensivdy
positive and intensively negative - momentum through
inflections of space. As an outcome of its complicity
with space, time's unilateral negativity is inlposed on me
horizon of interiority in a way that forces the horizon to lbe
concUlTently swept away along the extensity of space amd
intensively shattered on zero qua the eternaL
Thus cosmic time is deployed inside vital time anJd,
correspondingly, inside the life or the horizon of interiority
that is conditioned by vital time. This remobilisation of
cosmic time's exteriority and redeployment of its contingen
cies witlnn vital time and manifestations of life posits a tllird
conception of time wInch constitutes the second stage of oor
conjectural solution. The blackening complicity betWOl:n
space and time can only be fully explained via recoUJse
to a third conception of time which is always implicit - as
an internal tension - to the dyadic conception of time. We
call the tIllrd conception of time, the insider conceptioll ifcosnic
time. It is conceived of
as
as
406
Negarestani
Undercover Softness
exclusively mark
the temporality
or
407
COLLAPSE VI
and subtractive tensions are nanated by the degenerate
qualities of space through the process of decay in the form
of a progressive softening of forms and loosening of the
horizon. We can say that in decay space is perforated by
time: Although time hollows out space, it is space that gives
time a n"list that abnegates the privilege of time over space
and expresses the inepressible contingencies of absolute
time through dynamic and formal means. This inflective
mobilisation of cosmic time's radical contingencies heralds
the birth of chemistry as the blackening complicity between
time and space. I t is chemisbl' that endows the subtractive
process of decay with a putridly productive nature.
FIGURING OUT THE FACE OF ROT, OR InEl\'TITY AND THE
FORMS OF BEING LESS THAN A ThING, MORE THAN
NOTHING
The subtractive dynamism of d ecay is generated on
the basis of a complicity belween space and time which
allows for the
408
an
inter
complici
409
COLLAPSE VI
and softened to no end yet leaves traces which linger as the
agents and particles of complicity, has a strong socio-polit
ical undertone. Even after a political formation turns into
an
zero
410
411
COLLAPSE VI
entities in putrefaction in Les Miserables: 'In a pit of slime
[ ... ] the dying man does not know whether he has become
a ghost or a toad.'s It is only in putrefaction that death is
essentially and weirdly non-hauntological: one becomes a
toad rather than a poltergeist armoyingly clamouring for
appropriate mourning, for a proper judgment or a spectral
solution. VVhilst in putrefaction the human might end up
as a toad, the toad itself grows a tail. The tail, in this case,
speaks to the differential idea or latitudes of form between
a toad and a tadpole, the mathemathico-chernical affect
between them, the ratio of putrefaction: the longer the tail,
the fouler the putrefaction:
It was observed in the great plague of dle last year, dIal there
were seen, in divers ditches and low grounds about London,
many toads that had tails t\vo or three inches long at the least;
whereas toads (usually) have no tails at all. vVhich argueth a
great disposition to putrefaction in the soil and air. It is reported
likewise, that roots (such as carrots and parsnips) are more
sweet and luscious in infectious years than in o ther years.
So the parts of beasts putrefied
extreme subtile parts,)
are to be placed
[ .]
..
musk, which
412
The toad, the miasma, the sludge and the human all b ecome
part of a differential field wherein each entity can gradually
unfold into another regardless of the congruity of their
traits, environments and habits. These subtle, fluxional or
infinitesinlal movements point to the gradational continuity
of deformities in decay whose basal continuity is maintained
by the dynamism of complicity as a form of participa
tion in which, instead of commonality and replacement,
inflection and nestedness - that is to say, the mathesis of
the insider
10.]. F. Scon, 'Boscovich's Mathematics' in lWger Jruq)n iJosaJuidt, S]., F.R.s., 1711-
1787: SllIdieJ "His Lifo llJld Hft,. on tlte 2501lt Anniumary "His Birth [London: George
Allen &: Unwin Lld 1961). 183-92.
.
413
COLLAPSE VI
the curve and eventually to convolute the already twisled
can
414
415
COLLAPSE VI
yet this concomitant change of identity and fonns leaves
behind it a slimy trace, demonstrated by a pandemonium
of twirling curves which connect the horizon of ma.n to that
of trees.
The universal calculus of decay does not tolerate
an
can
be connected
together via a s traight line. B oth 'being a tree' and ' being a
man' are changing variables rates of change between their
respective actualities and potencies on the one hand and
between their interiorities and the exteriority on the other.
Therefore, the most velitable line of o'ansition that can be
drawn between a human and a tree is not a line connecting
their fixed actualities or traits but a line that encompasses
their existing actualities (given points)
as
well as their
as
a whole) emerging
416
Negarestani
Undercover Softness
and the human but also their remotest derivatives and the
least actual potencies. 111is is the taphonomic logic behind
the slimy forms of pun'efaction and the ever-shrinking
bodies of decomposition (as in ruins) where the complicity
b e tween parts
and
derivatives
becomes a subtractive
as
continuously
417
COLLAPSE VI
mobilises the exteriorizing terror of such complicity right
from the inside of the interiorized horizon and through its
locus of persistence and its definition of survival.
BUILDING WORLDS AND CORPSES, OR ThE
QyESTION OF
M.\THEMATICO-CHEMICAL DYNAMISM
I observe ill advance U1at numerically the
same
!ll1
418
an
(explicatio),
419
This chemicallycharged
COLLAPS E VI
and calculative dynamism, accordingly, operates
as
inclusion
ensures
that
all
emerging
420
(2)
42 1
COLLAPSE VI
(3) Differentiable smoothness: Following and in
accordance with the first two principles, the encom
passing process of decay as an interpolant should be
as smooth as possible, or more precisely, infinitely
differentiable so as to support both the perpetual
inclusion of all extensive and intensive cllanges and
the basal continuity between persistent remnants
and emerging fonus and values.
In decay what is firstly enacted is the subtractive
power ofputrefaction whereby extensive and intensive
changes are simultaneously included. Subtractive
binding of dlanges ensures that vectorially opposite
changes can be included in regard to each other in
such a way that every extensive change inBects an
intensive change and vice versa. For this reason,
the law of basal continuity whicll emphasises the
continuity between ever-shrinking fundaments and
the emerging changes cannot be maintained except
through the subtractive power of decay, or more
accurately, decay's perpetual inclusion of changes
and deformities. Therefore, perpetual inclusion
enacted by the sublTactive logic of decay precedes
the continuity between the intensive ideals of the
formation and its extensive ideas which are in the
process of unfolding. In this sense, continuity C is
built upon the output of inclusion I (i.e. inclusion
of both intensive and extensive changes). Inclusion
alone, however, does not support the continuity of
what is included either in terms of 'the continuity
between those changes which will be included
and those which have already been included' (the
intensively enveloped fundaments) or in terms of
422
extensive
development
and
the
intensive
423
COLLAPSE VI
Putrid deformities Or smooth gradients of decay are
forcefully yet nonviolendy extracted from the ostensibly
secured interiority of the horizon by the combined function
of dle aforementioned principles. Accordingly, for an inte
riorized horizon demarcated by the ratio of its actu alities
(a) and potencies (Pl , decay can be reductively symbolized
as : 12
The
(C(J;x)))nl
Leibnizian
(C(J(x)))"
would
dt
notation
be
for
dn (C(J(x)))
dxn
the
differentiation
expressed
as
424
Negarestani
Undercover Softness
COLLAPS E VI
potentialities'. These are the slopes of body qua complexus
that provide the process of decay with fields of gradation
whose dynamism can only be differentially grasped. Unlike
the co17lplicatio of God, the comJJiicatio of body qua complexus
is under the influence of its actualities whose disu-ibu
tion is extensively toward the outer world or the world of
multitudes. In other words, since the actualities of the body
are not perfect (immutable) , nor are its potencies fixed, the
wmplexus of the body is determined by the ratio of complicatio
(envelopment of potencies) and explicatio (the development
of potencies
as
actualities)
in regard to
each other
then !J.a catu10t have a rate of change or slope, i.e. !J.a must
be a vertical line (illustrated by the vertical fold aJJ in diagran1
2) . It is ti1e verticality of God in the scholastic thTeefold
42 6
the
chemistry
scholastic
through
marriage
natural
of mathematics
philosophy,
the
and
colllplicatio
6.j) >- 6.a and 6.p ;o' 6.a otherwise the body is supplanted by
the full body of entelechies whose possibilities have all been
427
COLLAPSE VI
in this case, as actualities are fulfilled, their number in
l>u-<l
IIp
Ila
that
lim IIp
l>u-D Ila
Therefore, in either
expliwlW
428
Negarestani
Undercover Softness
as
as
429
COLLAPSE VI
scheme or take action without such calculus is tantamount
to calculating out of this world
an
430