(Emuch - Net) Carbon Quantum Dots and Their Applications
(Emuch - Net) Carbon Quantum Dots and Their Applications
(Emuch - Net) Carbon Quantum Dots and Their Applications
REVIEW ARTICLE
conventional semiconductor quantum dots. In addition to their comparable optical properties, CQDs
have the desired advantages of low toxicity, environmental friendliness low cost and simple synthetic
routes. Moreover, surface passivation and functionalization of CQDs allow for the control of their
physicochemical properties. Since their discovery, CQDs have found many applications in the fields of
Received 4th August 2014
DOI: 10.1039/c4cs00269e
chemical sensing, biosensing, bioimaging, nanomedicine, photocatalysis and electrocatalysis. This article
reviews the progress in the research and development of CQDs with an emphasis on their synthesis,
functionalization and technical applications along with some discussion on challenges and perspectives
www.rsc.org/csr
1. Introduction
The unique properties of carbonic nanomaterials such as nanodiamonds, fullerenes, carbon nanotubes, graphene sheets and
fluorescent carbon nanoparticles or carbon quantum dots (CQDs)
have inspired extensive studies on them due to their great
potential for a wide variety of technical applications. Among the
electronic and physicochemical characteristics of CQDs, their
optical properties and their fluorescence emissions in particular have attracted increasing interest in recent years. For many
years, semiconductor quantum dots have been extensively investigated for their strong and tunable fluorescence emission
properties, which enable their applications in biosensing and
bioimaging. However, semiconductor quantum dots possess
Department of Chemistry, National University of Singapore, Singapore 117543.
E-mail: [email protected]; Fax: +65 6779-1691; Tel: +65 6516-3887
Wei Shen
Review Article
Fig. 2 (A) CQDs with strong absorption in the UV region and weak
emissions and (B) CQDs with weak absorption in the near UV-vis region
but strong multicolour emissions in the visible region. (Reproduced with
permission from ref. 13.)
Review Article
Fig. 3 (A) Aqueous solutions of PEG1500N-passivated CQDs (a) excited at 400 nm and (b) excited at the indicated wavelengths; (B) absorption and
emission spectra of PPEI-EI passivated CQDs in water with increasing lex from 400 nm on the left with 20 nm increments. Inset: emission intensities
normalized to quantum yields. (Reproduced with permission from ref. 7.)
Review Article
Up-conversion fluorescence
in addition to their normal down-conversion fluorescence emission.34 Upon excitation in the NIR region of 8001000 nm, green
light with a peak wavelength of 540 nm was emitted from their
CQDs. The up-conversion florescence emissions likely originated
from a multi-photon excitation process an essential feature of
up-conversion fluorescence emission.
This is, however, not without dispute. In view of the practically constant energy dierence of B1.1 eV between the excitation light and emission light, Shen and colleagues argued that
the multi-photon excitation is inadequate to account for the
up-conversion fluorescence emission properties of CQDs.26
They postulated that the up-conversion fluorescence emission
originates from the relaxation of electrons from a higher energy
state of the p orbital (LUMO) to the s orbital since some electrons
would inevitably transit to the LUMO when a large number of lowenergy photons excite the electrons in the p orbital. Of course, the
electrons in the s orbital can also be excited, but they only emit
conventional down-conversion light.
On the other hand, Wen et al. believed that some of the apparent
up-conversion fluorescence emissions are artefacts originating from
the conventional down-conversion emissions which have been
excited by the leaking component from the second diraction in
the monochromator of the spectrofluorometer.40 By simply inserting
a long pass filter into the excitation pathway the leaking component
can be removed. Thus, great care must be taken when interpreting
the fluorescence emissions of CQDs and further clarification is
necessary to explain up-conversion CQDs.
3. Synthesis of CQDs
3.1
a one-step electrochemical approach utilising low-cost and readily available graphite as a carbon source was recently proposed
by Ming et al.45 The prepared CQDs were predominantly multilayer graphene oxide exhibiting both down- and up-conversion
fluorescence emissions.
3.2
Review Article
Fig. 4 Supported-synthesis of CQDs using modified silica spheres as carriers and resols as carbon precursors. (Reproduced with permission from ref. 3.)
Review Article
Table 1
Precursor
Synthetic method
Carbohydrate
Carbohydrate (glucose)
poly(ethylene glycol) and saccharide
Ethanol in NaOH solution
Citrate
GlucosamineHCl
Ascorbic acid
Ascorbic acid
Glucose
Sucrose
Candle soot
Watermelon peels
Pomelo peels
Orange juice
Strawberry juice
Sugar cane juice
Chicken egg
Chitosan
Chitosan
Organogel
Gelatine
Hair fibre
Ionic liquids
3-(3,4-Dihydroxyphenyl)-L-alanine, L-histidine,
and L-arginine
Citric acid and ethylenediamine
Acetic acid
Grass
Quantum
yield (%)
Application
Ref.
14.7
3.22
3
Bioimaging
pH sensing
3
34
46
13
7
3.16.3
4
68
5.7
6
1.12.4
3
7.1
6.9
26
6.3
5.76
6.8
43
31.6
11.1
1.655.14
Hg2+ sensing
Bioimaging, pH sensing
Bioimaging
Bioimaging
Bioimaging
Bioimaging
Hg2+ sensing
Bioimaging
Hg2+ sensing
Bioimaging
Printing
Bioimaging
Bioimaging
Bioimaging
Quercetin sensing
Bioimaging
47
48
49
50
51
52
53
54
55
56
57
58
59
60
61
62
63
64
65
66
67
68
69
70
80
2.56.2
71
72
73
Review Article
4. Applications of CQDs
4.1
Chemical sensing
Review Article
Fig. 6 UV-vis (black lines) and fluorescence spectra of (a) CQD-1 and (b) CQD-2 aqueous solutions in the absence (blue lines) and presence (red lines) of
Hg2+; fluorescence responses of (c) CQD-1 and (d) CQD-2 aqueous solutions in the presence of 20 mM of dierent metal ions. (lex = 360 nm).
(Reproduced with permission from ref. 87.)
2-amino-3,4,8-trimethyl-3H-imidazo[4,5-f]quinoxalin110 through
fluorescence quenching have been reported.
Apart from utilising the fluorescence of CQDs as an analytical
signal, recent studies have revealed that CQDs exhibit good
chemiluminescence111 and electrochemiluminescence.112 Therefore, several groups have developed chemiluminescent assays for
NO2 113 and Co2+;114 and electrochemiluminescent assays for
traces of pentachlorophenol115 and Cu2+.116
So far, a wide variety of procedures and a large number of
starting materials have been used in the preparation of CQDs
for the assays, thus leading to substantial batch-to-batch and
lab-to-lab variations. Such variations in the synthesis of CQDs
have serious consequences since studies have suggested that
the fluorescence characteristics are strongly dependent on
the composition of CQDs and residue chemical groups on
their surface; and dierent starting materials and procedures
inevitably produce CQDs with rather dierent physicochemical
properties and optical properties in particular. Standardisation
is therefore urgently needed in the preparation of CQDs and the
assessment of the performance of CQDs.
4.2
Biosensing
CQDs were also used in biosensing based on the use of antibodies and their gene-recombinant fragments. In this scheme,
CQDs are mainly applied in immunoassays as fluorescent labels.
This was shown in an example by Posthuma-Trumpie et al.117
with an emphasis of the use of CQDs in lateral flow and
microarray immunoassays. CQDs are less costly, more stable
and more sensitive, hence they were chosen over other commonly used fluorescent labels for this study. CQDs were shown
to have higher sensitivity as labels in lateral flow assays (LFAs)
in comparison to gold or latex nanoparticles.118 It was claimed
that CQDs exhibit sensitivity in the picomolar range.13 In a
general example of nucleic acid LFA (NALFA) (Fig. 7), the
discriminating tags on the amplicons are recognised by their
Review Article
Review Article
Bioimaging
Review Article
Fig. 9 (a) Emission spectra of CQDs at dierent excitation wavelengths; fluorescence images of MCF-10A cells treated with CQDs upon excitation with
(b) UV, (c) blue and (d) green light. (Reproduced with permission from ref. 134.)
cells to take in CQDs was revealed to be dependent on temperature, where no CQDs were found to internalise into the cells at
48 1C.1 It was proposed that CQDs likely translocate into cells by
endocytosis. Also, it was suggested that the uptake of CQDs may
be enhanced by coupling CQDs with membrane translocation
peptides, so as to facilitate this translocation procedure by
overcoming the cell membrane barrier.139,140
As mentioned above, CQDs are able to exhibit multicolour
emissions, which is a huge advantage that sets them apart from
the majority of labelling agents. This allows researchers to
control and choose the excitation and emission wavelengths.141
As illustrated in Fig. 9, the property of tunable emissions of
CQDs was clearly visible,134 where light at dierent wavelengths
was emitted upon excitation at dierent wavelengths. This property
was also seen in HepG2 cells incubated with 4,7,10-trioxa-1,13tridecanediamine-passivated CQDs, which portrayed multicolour
emissions when excited at dierent wavelengths.142 Green CQDs
prepared from sugar cane juice also exhibited multicolour emissions upon dierent excitation modes in bacteria and yeast cells.62
Notably, Ray et al. revealed that surface passivation might not be
necessary to achieve a high level of fluorescence intensity required
for cell imaging.57 CQDs prepared from the thermal combustion of
soot and treated with acid were able to translocate into Ehrlich
ascites carcinoma cells successfully even though they were not
coated with any surface passivating agents.57
If the excitation wavelength is red-shifted enough, CQDs
could emit in the NIR region. Although the emission in the NIR
region is relatively weak, CQDs have great potential for in vivo
fluorescence tracking studies141 because the animal body is
practically transparent in the NIR region.143 Yangs group was
the first to explore the viability of CQDs as contrast agents in
live mice.15 In their experiments, PEG1500N-passivated CQDs
were injected subcutaneously into mice and bright fluorescence
emissions were observed, only fading away 24 h after the
injection. If the CQDs were injected intravenously, emissions
were only observed in the bladder region, thereby suggesting
that urine extraction is the main exiting route for intravenously
introduced CQDs. The same group also successfully tracked the
migration in lymph vessels using ZnS-doped CQDs (Fig. 10).15
In another report, Cao et al. employed the ZnS-doped CQDs
for in vivo imaging in mice, which showed comparable brightness with the well-established CdSe/ZnS quantum dots.144
However, after intradermal injections of the CQDs and CdSe/
ZnS quantum dots into mice, it was observed that though both
Nanomedicine
Review Article
that their organs and internal functions are hardly aected. The
high biocompatibility of CQDs was also supported by prothrombin time assays in plasma samples. The results indicated
that CQDs do not limit the activity of thrombin and do not lead
to any blood coagulation.134
The work by Bechet and co-workers showed that CQDs can
be used for photodynamic therapy. Photodynamic therapy is a
clinical treatment mainly for superficial tumours.146 It involves
the localisation and accumulation of photosensitizers in the
tumour tissue, following which they are irradiated with a
specific wavelength, triggering the formation of singlet oxygen
species that result in cell death. It has been validated that CQDs
have high inhibition eect on MCF-7 and MDA-MB-231 cancer
cells.134 This phenomenon was attributed to CQDs being able to
generate more reactive oxygen species, making them promising
photosensitizers. It was also noted that the circulation and
uptake of CQDs in the body is dependent on their surface coating
and the route of administration.147 Huang et al. investigated the
eect of the injection route on the distribution, clearance and
tumour uptake of CQDs.81 It was learnt that CQDs are quickly
and eectively excreted from the body when intravenous, intramuscular and subcutaneous injection routes are used. Additionally, the high tumour-to-background fluorescence contrast and
low fluorescence levels in other tissues and organs demonstrated
the suitability of CQDs to act as photosensitizers as they are able
to localise selectively into tumours (Fig. 11).
Juzenas and colleagues also explored the use of CQDs as
photosensitizers in photodynamic therapy to destroy cancer
cells.148 Small CQDs functionalised with PPEI-EI (PPEI-EI-CQDs)
were prepared. Upon irradiation with UV light, these CQDs
displayed substantial photodynamic eect in Du145 and PC3
cells. It was proposed that photo-induced generation of singlet
oxygen (Type II mechanism) and other reactive oxygen species
and radicals (Type I mechanism) is responsible for the observed
photodynamic eect. TiO2 is one of the most popular semiconductor photocatalysts, but it can only be excited with UV
light due to the size of its bandgap.149 Unfortunately, UV
radiation has a low penetration power and can only penetrate
slightly into the skin tissue, thus resulting in poor photodynamic eciency in deep tissues.150 Compared to TiO2, PPEI-EICQDs have the additional advantage of tunable bandgap, where
their bandgap can be made smaller to allow excitation at longer
wavelengths. This would allow for the destruction of buried
tumours because light at longer wavelengths can penetrate deeper
into tissues. By attaching a photosensitizer (chlorin e6) to CQDs, a
synergistic photodynamic therapy platform was developed.151 It
was shown that the CQDs can indirectly excite the photosensitizer
Fig. 11 Fluorescence images of tumour-bearing mice. (Reproduced with permission from ref. 81.)
Review Article
4.5
Photocatalysis
Review Article
Electrocatalysis
Review Article
Fig. 15 Cyclic voltammograms of (a) N-CQD/graphene and (b) commercial Pt/C on a GC electrode in N2-saturated 0.1 M KOH, O2-saturated 0.1 M KOH
and O2-saturated 3 M CH3OH solutions. (Reproduced with permission from ref. 196.)
Review Article
potential biomedical uses should proceed in parallel with a thorough evaluation of the cytotoxic eect of CQDs.
The general strategy for the adoption of environmentally benign
CQDs as photocatalysts in synthetic chemistry represents an attractive approach in the development of green chemistry, which may
eventually lessen the burden of energy consumption, product
clean-up and waste disposal. The immediate goal in this emerging
area should be geared toward the discovery of photochemical
solutions for increasingly ambitious synthetic goals. The longterm goals should be to improve eciency and synthetic utility
and to eventually perform chemical synthesis under sunlight.
Compared to other applications of CQDs, there have been
fewer studies in the usability of CQDs as electrocatalysts for
ORR and OER. In-depth theoretical and experimental studies
are needed to delicately design CQD-based electrocatalysts with
desirable electrocatalytic activity and long-term operation stability. The combination of CQD doping and CQD-based nanocomposites with other nanomaterials may open up new
avenues to systematically study the eect of structural parameters and chemical compositions on the catalytic performance of the electrocatalysts, thus leading to fundamental
insights and practical applications.
Although still in the midst of development, CQDs have already
shown immense potential to play a big role in nanotechnology
for the development of assays, sensors, bioimaging agents,
drug carriers, phototherapy, photocatalysis and electrocatalysis.
Despite the fact that many optical and electronic properties of
CQDs are not well understood yet, there is no doubt that CQDs
will play a huge role in bioimaging and biomedical research in the
near future upon further development. Being highly versatile,
CQDs have the propensity to be rationally modified according to
dierent needs. Applications of CQDs in niche areas such as
photocatalysis exemplify the versatility of CQDs in the most
unexpected areas. It is heartening to witness the diversion of
research interest in CQDs away from traditional fields such as
bioimaging, and into more urgent and pressing needs such as
green chemistry and clean energy production. The fact that
the advantages of CQDs are being recognised by researchers
with interest in areas as diverse as materials science, synthetic
chemistry, drug delivery, nanomedicine and clean energy suggests
that research on CQDs will continue to grow in synergistic
relationship with intellectually adjacent fields. It seems clear that
the future of CQDs remains promising.
Acknowledgements
This work is supported by Ministry of Education and the
A*STAR-ANR Program.
References
1 L. Cao, X. Wang, M. J. Meziani, F. S. Lu, H. F. Wang,
P. G. Luo, Y. Lin, B. A. Harru, L. M. Veca, D. Murray,
S.-Y. Xie and Y.-P. Sun, J. Am. Chem. Soc., 2007, 129,
1131811319.
Review Article
Review Article
Review Article
Review Article