Final Paper
Final Paper
In Life of Pi (2012), Director Ang Lee uses Computer-Generated Imagery (CGI) to create
stunning scenes to show depth and dimension. In the lifeboat stargazing scene in particular, Lee
creates a context that is easy to get lost in because of the intricate depths and distortion of
dimensions through lighting. Although the audience knows that Suraj Sharma and the Tiger are
on the lifeboat in the middle of the ocean, because of the vastness of the sky created by Lee and
the depth of stars that are in that sky, it is easy to become lost and confused as to where the sea
horizon ends and the actual sky horizon begins. As the scene progresses, Sharma is gazing into
the water at the fish, as the Tiger was. The fish begins to swim away, starting a continuous shot
following the fish deeper and deeper into the sea. As the fish goes deeper, the musical
accompaniment and the surrounding scenes change to illustrate the different layers of the ocean.
Eventually, the fish comes to the bottom of the ocean where the sunken freight ship lies (Lee,
2012). This scene is worthy of attention because it signifies hitting the lowest point in physical
world, the bottom of the ocean, and the lowest point for Sharma in the metaphysical world, being
basically alone and stranded on a lifeboat in the middle of the ocean. Additionally, this is a
valuable scene for the audience, because while traveling deeper in the ocean, the audience is
traveling deeper into Sharmas feelings and soul. Not only does the audience connect with
Sharma, but also it signifies Sharma connecting with nature and most importantly with the Tiger,
which will later become vital to the Tiger and Sharmas survival.
However, depth and dimension are also easily created in cinematography without the use
of CGI technology. For example Director Peter Weir uses the power of shadows and angles to
create depth, specifically in the final scenes of The Truman Show (1998). As Jim Carrey is on
the sailboat sailing into the distance, it becomes increasingly apparent by the lighting angles to
the already aware audience, that Carrey is about to hit a wall- literally. Carreys sailboat
smashes into the perimeter of the dome enclosure that he has been living in for the entirety of his
life. Upon piercing the wall with the bow of the boat, Carrey sees the stark shadows the sailboat
is casting onto the walls. Carrey walks up to the wall and as he gets closer, his shadow becomes
more sharp and distinct. As he touches the wall, Carrey is breaking through and touching the
barrier that, unbeknownst to him, has held him back. Carrey continues to walk along the outer
edge and comes across a set of stairs that are also well defined by the shadows they cast against
the wall. In addition, at possibly the most intense part of the movie, when Carrey finally opens
the exit door, it is completely black- void of all light. This void is important because it shows
that what is beyond the Truman Show bubble is unknown, both to Truman and the audience.
The magic hour is that time just before sunrise and just after sunset when the Earths
atmosphere bounces the hidden suns light, creating a diffused and luminous ambient light
(Hurbis-Cherrier, 2013, p. 293). Arguably one of the most iconic scenes in Lawrence of Arabia
(1962) is the scene in the desert, in which Director David Lean took full advantage of catching
the rising suns magic hour. Actor Peter OToole is looking at a match and as he blows the
match out, the scene cuts to the dark horizon just prior to sunrise. This continuous shot is
exceptionally intense for the audience, because as the sun is creeping up, the background music
is also building in intensity. Finally, the music and anticipation resolve as the sun peaks over the
horizon; and the scene begins to fade into the next shot of two men on camelback riding through
the sand dunes (Lean, 1962). Regardless that the scene lasts for less than one minute total, it is
known throughout the film world for its excellent cutting and lighting aesthetics.
Typically, cinematographers try for consistency in terms of a films narrative emphasis.
In other words, the characters, the style of cuts, the lighting, the sound, it should all match up and
not only flow, but should compliment the narrative itself. Ironically, a lack of consistency can
also create a consistent narrative. This technique is exactly what Directors Daniel Myrick and
Eduardo Snchez use in The Blair Witch Project (1999). The entire artistic premise of The Blair
Witch Project is that it has a home movie feel to it. From the randomly changing lighting
approach to the shaky camera footage- it is like watching a home video from the late 90s. In
one scene in particular, the teenagers are spending the nights in the woods and in a short threeminute clip, the lighting technique changes four times. The scene begins with a home camera
style spotlight on the male character, the light is soft and diffused for the most part and comes
from a weak source, but it does the job. The teens settle and turn off all the lights to go to sleep,
but keep the camera on to record. Within a few seconds of the lights being off, the lights come
on again, as the students get their belongings and begin running through the woods. As they are
running, the lighting changes to a spotlight type light again, and then changes into night vision.
The night vision function causes the lighting of the scene to seem grainy because it has such low
resolution (Myrick & Snchez, 1999). If kept separate, these lighting techniques could not and
would not make up a coherent narrative. However, when constructed in this way, the
inconsistencies become the only thing consistent and therefore create a cohesive narrative with
an emphasis on chaos.
Tone is often described as the authors attitude towards a subject, while mood is more
so how the audience is made to feel about the subject (Scott, 2011). In other words, tone is the
overarching feeling you get from the film as a whole; unlike the mood, which can change from
scene-to-scene depending on the context. In addition, the mood can change for one character,
but not another. For example, the tone for There Will Be Blood (2007) can be described as dark,
morose, and a cautionary tale, regardless of a handful of happier scenes in the movie.
As the sun is setting, the oil Derrick explodes and the entire well goes up into hundredfoot tall flames. The sky continues to get darker and the flames become brighter and brighter,
until it is almost painful to look at the screen because the contrast is so distinct. In the meantime
Daniel Day-Lewis character is manically pulling out all the stop lines for the well, so it does not
implode on itself. At one point, Day-Lewis character stops and stands atop a hill watching the
burning wellhe is among a line of men who are fairly dirty, but Day Lewis is covered head-totoe in crude oil. Day-Lewis sees that the men are despondent, and says to them the men should
not be sad, because he is the only man in the world who can access this oil and this wealth. DayLewis says these lines, smiling like a lunatic, accompanied by an eerie glow from the fire
reflecting off his oil-covered body (Anderson, 2007). Not only does the audiences mood
towards his character evolve, but the character himself transforms from a harmless, smooth
talking, con man into the unscrupulous, depraved, greed-driven psycho that Day-Lewis plays for
the remainder of the movie. Although the script itself is powerful, the added intensity from the
relentlessly burning fire adds an extra demonic layer to Day-Lewis character.
Rembrandt lighting is a well-known lighting setup that is used for portrait photography
(Improve Photography, 2015), and is also a commonly used element in cinematography. This
unique lighting approach is modeled after the 17th-century painter Rembrandt, who used to paint
a small triangle of brightened light on the face of his subjects. The benefits of using Rembrandt
lighting is that it is an easy set up, it can range in degrees of intensity, and it instantly adds depth
to the characters facial expressions through the light and shadows. For example, in Vertigo
(1958), Director Alfred Hitchcock used a subtler Rembrandt approach when illuminating the
faces of James Stewart and Kim Novak throughout the movie. Because the shadows are never
heavy or distinct, it gives a lighter feel to the movie, even though the subject matter is on the
darker side. In a movie like Slumdog Millionaire (2008), Directors Danny Boyle and Loveleen
Tandan create more fierce Rembrandt lighting, especially in the game show scene (Boyle &
Loveleen, 2008). Because of the nature of the iridescent, high beam, game show lights, the
shadows and angles on the contestant and hosts faces are stronger and more distinct. However,
The Godfather (1972) has some of the most extreme examples of Rembrandt lighting known todate. Even to the untrained eye, the dramatic lighting techniques that Director Francis Coppola
used are noticeable. In one of the more memorable scenes, Gianni Russo is getting muscled-up
on in his own home by Al Pacino. As soon as Pacino enters the scene, his face is almost cut in
half by the depth of the shadow- the Rembrandt lighting technique is almost nil. This adds an
extra mysterious characteristic to Pacinos persona, and plays on the fact that he is so two-faced,
especially in this scene. Throughout the scene, Pacino moves around the room talking to Russo,
but everywhere he goes the shadow remains constant- not always to such a severe degree, but it
is still present (Coppola, 1972).
Whether the scene calls for high-intensity drama or a more sedated feel, it is necessary to
keep in mind the importance of lighting and different lighting techniques, because it is an
element that can make or break a scene. Lighting can bring a character to life in a way the
audience did not see before. Lighting can help illustrate changes over time and movement. And
lighting can put the audience into a coma of wonderment.
References
Anderson, P.T., S. J., & Lupi, D. (Producers), & Anderson, P.T. (Director). (2007). There will
be blood [Motion picture]. USA: Paramount Vantage.
Bregman, A. & Golin, St. (Producers), & Gondry, M. (Director). (2004). Eternal sunshine of
the spotless mind [Motion picture]. USA: Focus Features.
Colson, C. (Producer), & Boyle, D. & Tandan, L. (Directors). (2008). Slumdog millionaire
[Motion picture]. UK: Warner Bros.
Hale, G. & Cowie, R. (Producers), & Myrick, D. & Snchez, E. (Directors). 1999. The Blair
witch project [Motion picture]. USA: Haxan Films.
Hitchcock, A. (Producer), & Hitchcock, A. (Director). (1958). Vertigo [Motion picture]. USA:
Alfred J. Hitchcock Productions.
Hurbis-Cherrier, M. (2013). Voice & vision a creative approach to narrative film & DV
production. (2nd ed.). Burlington, MA: Focal Press.
Improve Photography. (2015, June). Rembrandt lighting: what it is, how to do it, why its
awesome!. Retrieved from http://improvephotography.com/19250/rembrandt-lightingawesome/
Lean, D., Harris, R.A., Spiegel, S., & Painten, J. (Producers), & Lean, D. (Director). (1962).
Lawrence of Arabia [Motion picture]. UK: Horizon Pictures (II).
Lee, A., Netter, G., & Womark, D. (Producers), & Lee, A. (Director) (2012). Life of pi [Motion
picture]. Canada: Fox 2000 Pictures.
Niccol, A., Feldman, E.S., Rudin, S., & Schroeder, A. (Producers), & Weir, P. (Director).
(1998). The Truman show [Motion picture]. USA: Paramount Pictures.
Ruddy, A.S. (Producer), & Coppola, F.F. (Director). (1972). The Godfather [Motion picture].
USA: Paramount Pictures.
Scott, Mr. (2011, August). Tone and mood [Web blog]. Retrieved from
http://ourenglishclass.net/class-notes/writing/the-writing-process/craft/tone-and-mood/
Editing Journal
Eternal Sunshine of the Spotless Mind
2004
Meet me in Montauk scene
YouTube; R; 1h48m; Drama, Fantasy, Romance
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=NTmlNigifSI
http://www.imdb.com/title/tt0338013/?ref_=nv_sr_1
Director: Michel Gondry
Writers: Charlie Kaufman, Michel Gondry
Stars: Jim Carrey, Kate Winslet
STYLE
Scene starts with a
light on Winslet and it
looks as if its being
shot form a home
camera
Winslet walks
towards Carrey and
the flashlight follows
her and it shines
between them and up
the stairs
CUTS
Cuts to Carrey in the
hallway and the light
shines on his face
MUSIC
No music
OTHER
Just SFX of being in
the house
Continuous shot
SFX of house
crumbling
Light continues to
follow Carreys feet
as he walks through
the house that is
slowly becoming the
shore
Cut to Carrey alone in
SFX of Winslets
voice as she talks to
Carrey and Carrey
whisper/talking about
what is going on and
what he wishes would
have happened
Carrey talking to
Light starts to
illuminate the side of
Carreys face
Light is right on
Carreys face as if a
spotlight
10
himself about wishing
he had stayed
Music is starting to
creep into the scene
SFX of Carrey
running on the dock
and sound of the
waves getting louder
Cut to Winslet
coming down the
stairs to kiss Carrey
Music continuing
Extreme close-up of
Winslet and Carrey in
an embrace
Music continues
11
12
Life of Pi
2012
Starry night scene
YouTube; PG; 2h7m; Adventure, Drama, Fantasy
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=OMTuBy7ju1o
http://www.imdb.com/title/tt0454876/?ref_=nv_sr_1
Directors: Ang Lee
Writers: Yann Martel, David Magee
Actors: Suraj Sharma, Irrfan Khan
STYLE
Light is reflecting off
Sharmas eyes, but we
do not see the camera
and there is very
bright natural lighting
Natural night lighting
Stars are reflecting off
the ocean water and it
looks like the boat is
in the sky
The stars move very
slightly to show that it
is the water and the
reflection that we are
seeing
Sharma talks to the
Tiger who is looking
in the distance
The fish swimming is
illuminated and you
see the distinct
reflection of the
Tigers face in the
water
Light is reflecting off
of the different parts
of the fish
There is a light blue
center of the water
where a shark swims
out of, and the rest of
CUTS
Extreme close-up of
Sharma and his hands
as he is impatiently
lying down on the
cover of the boat
Fade and change to a
scene now at night
Cut to above Sharma
and the tiger
MUSIC
Instrumental music
OTHER
SFX of Sharma
tapping
Music continues
No SFX
Music continues
Music changes to
show that there is a
discovery
Music is changing
again
Music continues to
change, every time the
creatures change,
signifying a deeper
SFX of swimming
fish
13
Continually zooming
Music continues
Continually zooming
Continue zooming
Music becomes
middle eastern
sounding again
14
CUTS
MUSIC
Calm piano music
OTHER
SFX of the water and
the boat going
through the waves
Cut to close-up of
Truman
New music starts up
Aerial shot of the boat
at the edge of the
dome
Music continues as
Truman tries to break
through the walls
No SFX though
15
Music is continuing
16
Lawrence of Arabia
1962
Sunrise scene
YouTube; PG; 3h36m; Adventure, Biography, Drama
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=0ccB1KTzr9o
http://www.imdb.com/title/tt0056172/?ref_=nv_sr_2
Directors: David Lean
Writers: T.E. Lawrence, Robert Bolt
Actors: Peter OToole, Alec Guinness
STYLE
Scene starts with
Lawrence lighting a
match
CUTS
As he blows out the
match, instead of it
being dark, it cuts to a
full screen shot of the
horizon with the sun
about to rise
Continuous shot
MUSIC
OTHER
SFX of Lawrence
blowing out the flame
No SFX
No SFX
No SFX
17
Vertigo
1958
Tower sequence scene
YouTube; PG; 2h8m; Mystery, Romance, Thriller
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=GnpZN2HQ3OQ
http://www.imdb.com/title/tt0052357/?ref_=nv_sr_1
Directors: Alfred Hitchcock
Writers: Alec Copel, Samuel A. Taylor
Actors: James Stewart, Kim Novak
STYLE
Close-up of Stewart
and Novak kissing
Novak runs off into
the natural light of
daytime
Stewart and Novak
talk for a about 45seconds
Stewart looks up and
sees the tower and
starts chasing after
Novak
The church is dark,
except for the front
alter
Shadows of walking
up the stairs shows
how high up they are
while theyre running
after each other
Rembrandt lighting on
Stewart as he looks
out the window at
Novak lying there
Light is glistening off
Stewarts sweaty head
and you can see how
scared he is
Stewart begins
CUTS
Cut to Stewart
grabbing Novak by
the arm
MUSIC
Dramatic, romantic
music playing
Music becoming
increasingly more
dramatic
Close-ups of them
talking
Chase-scene and
close-ups back and
forth
Increasingly ominous
in tone
Close-up of Stewart
Music gets
increasingly dramatic
as Stewart realizes
hes higher and higher
into the tower
Music is getting
louder and more
drums
OTHER
SFX of Novak
running up the stairs
and Stewart calling
after her
SFX of a woman
screaming and you
hear Novak hit the
roof
No SFX
No SFX
18
19
CUTS
MUSIC
No music
OTHER
SFX of the woods
Cut to someone
talking
Light comes on,
camera is on the floor
so we cant see whats
going on
Continuous shot of
them running through
a field
Continuous shot
SFX of someone
breathing or crying
SFX of them running
20
CUTS
Continuous shot
MUSIC
No music
Cut to Daniel DL
cutting the lines from
the derrick so it will
have nothing to be on
fire
The enormity of the
fire is appreciated by
how small Daniel DL
is against the fire
Now dusk, the flame
is still going and
bright and smoking in
the air
OTHER
SFX of the well going
up in flames
SFX of the lines
cutting, people
yelling, and the fire
blazing
No music
SFX continue
Music continues
SFX continue
SFX continue
Close-up of son
Music is very
Ominous and
psychotic string music
continues
21
22
Slumdog Millionaire
2008
Game show scene
YouTube; R; 2h; Drama
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Ak70AEHw1as
http://www.imdb.com/title/tt1010048/?ref_=nv_sr_1
Directors: Danny Boyle, Loveleen Tandan
Writers: Simon Beaufoy, Vikas Swarup
Actors: Dev Patel, Freida Pinto, Saurabh Shukla
STYLE
Game show setting
Rembrandt lighting on
both sets of faces is
very prominent
Lights come up and
the entire stare is lit
up
Little TVs inside the
editing room are all
lit-up with blue hueseveryones face is
giving off a hue as
well
CUTS
Cut back and forth
between the
contestant and the
host
MUSIC
No music
OTHER
SFX are minimal
No music
SFX of people
clapping and yelling
23
The Godfather
1972
Going to Vegas scene
YouTube; R; 2h55m; Crime, Drama
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=HiCnnsHfadU
http://www.imdb.com/title/tt0068646/?ref_=nv_sr_1
Directors: Francis Ford Coppola
Writers: Mario Puzo, Francis Ford Coppola,
Actors: Marlon Brando, Al Pacino, James Caan
STYLE
Very intense lighting
from the beginning
and dramatic, just one
side of the face
No Rembrandt
lighting, just straight
cut down the face of
lighting
Natural lighting of the
room
CUTS
Continuous shot of
the men walking in
and talking to the guy
First time we
Close up of the guy
Rembrandt lighting on talking
the face, but still very
dramatic
Very dramatic on the
Cut to the other guy
other guy, shows his
and cut back and forth
emotion
while talking
Continue cutting back
and forth as the men
talk
MUSIC
No music
OTHER
No SFX
No music
No music
No music
No music
Ambient noise of
being outside
Dramatic lighting
again, and only half
his face is lit
Very naturally lit
scene outside
Would have NEVER
known it was during
the day, because the
lighting in the house
No music
24
No music
Music starts up
SFX of Carlo
breaking the
windshield as he kicks
it
Birds are chirping