2720 37 PDF
2720 37 PDF
Indian Standard
METHODS OF TEST FOR SOILS
PART XXXVII DETERMINATION OF SAND EQUIVALENT
VALUE OF SOILS AND FINE AGGREGATES
Chairman Representing
PR~F DINESH MOHAN Central Building Research Institute (CSIR),
Roorkee
Members
PROP ALAna SINGH University of Jodhpur
LT-COL &TAR SINGH Engineer-in-Chiefs Branch, Army Headquarters
MAJ R. R. SUDHINDRA(dbrnute)
DR A. BANERJEE Cementation Co Ltd, Bombay
SHRI S. GUPTA (Alfemate)
SHRI K. N. DADINA In personal capacity (P-826 &NewA&ore, Calcutta)
SHRI A. G. DA~TIDAR In personal capacity [Zntef-State Equipment (P) Ltd,
3/l Loudon Street, Calcutta]
QHRI R. L. DEWAN Irrigation Research Institute, Khagaul, Pat&
DR G. S. DHILLON Indian Geotechnical Society, New Delhi
bu2acToR Indian Institute of Technology, New Delhi
DR SHA~WIK. GULHATI (Alternate)
DIRECTOR Irrigation & Power Research Institute, Amritsar
RESEARCHOFFICER(GEOTECW-
NICALSECTION) (Alternate)
DIRECTOR(CSMRS) Central Water Commission, New Delhi
DEPUTY DIRECTOR(CSMRS) (Alternate)
SHRI A. H. D~VANJI Rodio Foundation Engineering Ltd; and Hazarat
& Co, Bombay
SHRI A. N. JANGLE (Altematej
SHRI V. G. HEGDE National Buildings Organization, New Delhi
SHRI S. H. BALCHANDANI(Altematc)
JO~IN~~I~~XXOR R~IZARCH (FE), Railway Board (Ministry of Railways)
DEPUTY DIRECTORRESEARCH,
SOIL MECHANICS,RDSO (Altematc)
SHRI 0. P. MALHOTRA Public Works Department, Government of Punjab
SHRI J. S. MAaYA Roads Wing (Ministry of Shippings & Transport)
SHRI N. SEN (AltesnafL)
(Continued on page 2)
(B Copyright 1976
INDIAN STANDARDS INSTITUTION
Thii publication is protected under the Zndiun Copyright Act (XIV of 1957) and
reproduction in whole or in part by any moans except with written permission of the
publisher shall be deemed to be an infringement of copyright under the said Ac(.
IS : 2720(Part XXXVII) - 1976
(Continuedffompage1)
Members Zbpescnting
SHRI G. D. MATHUR Public Works Department, Government of Uttar
Pradesh, Lucknow
SHRI D. C. CHATURVEDI(Altcrturic)
SHRI M. A. MEHTA Concrete Association of India, Bombay
SHRI T. M. MENON (Aliernak)
SHRI T.K. NATARAJAN CenuD$lyd Research Institute (CSIR), New
Secretmy
SHRIG.IGMAN
Deputy Director (Civ Bngg), IS1
Members
SHlu AbwR SINoH Ckn~mr~eilding Research Institute (CSIR),
2
IS : 2720 (Part XXXVII) - 1976
Indian Standard
METHODS OF TEST FOR SOILS
PART XXXVII DETERMINATION OF SAND EQUIVALENT
VALUE OF SOILS AND FINE AGGREGATES
0. FOREWORD
0.1 This Indian Standard (Part XXXVII) was adopted by the Indiaii
Standards Institution on 16 February 1976, after the draft finalized 1))
the Soil Engineering Sectional Committee had been approved by the
Civil Engineering Division Council.
0.2 The term sand equivalent expresses the concept that most granular
soils and fine aggregates are mixtures of desirable coarse particles, samd
and generallyundesirable clay or plastic fines and dust. This test is not
intended to replace the test covered by IS : 2720 (Part IV)-1975.
0.3 This test assigns an empirical value to the relative amount, fincncss
and character of claylike material present in the test specimen. A minimum
sand equivalent value may be specified to limit the permissible quantity
of claylike fines in an aggregate. This test provides a rapid field method
for determining changes in the quality of aggregates during production
or placement.
0.4 In the formulation of this standard due weightage has been given
to international co-ordination among the standards and practices prevailing
in different countries in addition to relating it to the practices in the field
in thiscountry. This has been met by deriving assistance from the following
publications :
A89.22A-1973 Methods of testing soils for engineering purposes :
Test 22A- Sand equivalent of aggregate and soil using a power-
operated shaker. Standards Association of Australia.
ASTM D 2419-74 Standard method of test for sand equivalent value
of soils and fine aggregate. American Society for Testing
and Materials.
*Methods of test for soils: Part IV Grain size analysis (jr~t reuision).
tRules for rounding off numerical values (revised).
3
IS : 2720 (PartXXXVII) - 1976
1. SCOPE
1.1 Thib standard Part XXXVIIj covers the method for the dctcrmi-
nation af sand equivalent value of 50ils. Ihi, indicates, under standard
canditiani, the rclativc proportion\ of claylikc or plastic fines and dusts
in granular soils and fine ag,grrgates that pass 4.75mm IS Sieve. This
mc;thod is intended to serve as a rapid field-correlation test.
2. GENERAL PRECAKTI-IONS
2.1 Maintain the: tcmpcraturc of the \\orking solution at 27 3: 3C during
the performance of this test.
2.1.1 If field conditions preclude the maintenance of the tcmpcrnturc
range, frcqucnt rcferce samples should bc submittccl to a labora.tory whcrc
proper tcmperaturc control is possible. It is also possible to c*stablish
temperature correction curves for each material being tcstcd ~vhcrc proper
temperature control is not possible. However, no gcncral correction
curve should bc utilized for several matcrialS cvcn within a narrow range
of sand equivalent values. Samples that meet the minimum sand cqui-
valcnt requircmcnt at a lvorking solution tempera.ture 1~~10~~the rccom-
mcndcd range need not bc subjected to .referee testing.
2.2 Perform the test at a location tiee from vibration. Excessive \,ibration
may cause the suspended material to settle at a greater rate than normal.
2.3 Do not expose the plastic cylinders to direct sunlight any more than
is ncccssary.
4
IS : 2720 (Part XXXVII) - 1976
2.5 OccasionalIy the holes in the tip of th.e irrigator tube may become
clogged by a particle of sand. If the obstruction cannot be freed by any
other method, use a pin or other sharp object to force it out using extreme
care not to enlarge the size of the opening.
3. APPARATUS
3.8 4-Litre Bottles - two, to store stock solution and working solution.
5
IS : 2720 (Part XXXVII) - 1976
+ 5w--{
012 WEIGHT
6tOs02 6
HOLE
ILL b6 GUIDE
LE FOR ROLL
PIN [ONE SIDE)
DRILL llmm
ASSEMBLY C @_ ROD
01 FOOT
All dimensions in millimetrcs.
FIG. 1 SAND EQWALENT TEST APPAFGWUS-CO~~~
LIST OF MATERIALS
A Siphon Assembly :
1 Siphon tube 5 diameter, 410 length Copper tube (may be plated)
Siphon hose 3 lD, 1 220 length Rubber tube, pure gum or equivaient
3
4
Blow hose
Blow tube
3 ID, 50 length
5 diameter, 50 length
Rubber tube, pure
CCJ~~ tube (may
gum or equivalent
be plated)
P-hole stopper To fit 4-litre bottle
: Irrigator tube 6.4 OD wall, 500 length Stainless steel tube
7 Clamp . A suitable pinchcock
B Graduar~ Asscmb[y
:
CO
8 Tube 38 OD, 450 length Transparent acrylic plastic
9 Base 12X100x100 Transparent acrylic plastic
4. MiVERIALs
4.1 Stock Calcium Chloride Soh~tion - The materials listed below will
be required :
a} 480.4 g of technical @ade anhydrous calcium chloride conforming
toIS: 1314- 1967*.
b) 2 179 g of glycerine (technical grade) conforming to IS : 1796 -1961 t .
c) 49.7 g of formaldehyde (40 percent by volume solution) conforming
to IS : 3321-1973:.
4.1.1. Dissolve the 480.4 g of calcium chloride in 2 litres of distilled water;
Cool and filter through ready pleated rapid filtering filter paper. Add
2 179 g of glycerine and the 49.7 g of formaldehyde to the filtered solution,
mix well and dilate to 4 litres.
5. SAMPLE PREPARATION
5.1 Obtain at least 1 500 g of material passmg 4.75-mm IS Sieve in the
following manner.
5.1.1 Separate the sample on the 4*75-mm IS Sieve bv means of a lateral
and vertical motion of the sieve, accompanied by a jariing action so as to
keep the sample moving continuously over the surface of the sieve. Continue
the sieving until not more than one percent by mass of the residue passes
the sieve during one minute. The sieving operation may be performed
either by hand or by a mechanical apparatus. When thoroughness of
mechanical sieving is being determined, test by the hand method described
above using a single layer of material on the sieve.
5.1.2 Breakdown any lumps of material in the coarse fraction to pass the
4.75-mm IS Sieve. A mortar and rubber-covered pestle or any other means
that will not cause appreciable degradation of the aggregate may be used.
5.1.3 Remove any coatings of fines adhering tp_ the coarse aggregate.
These fines may be removed by surface-drying the coarse aggregate, then
rubbing between the hands over a flat pan.
5.1.4 Add the material passing the sieve as obtained in 5.1.2 and 5.1.3
to the separated fine portion of the sample.
5.2 Prepare test specimens from the. material passing 4.75-mm IS Sieve
portion of the sample by the procedure described in either 5.2.1 or 5.2.2.
NOTE - Experiments show that as the amount of material being reduced by splitting
or quartering is decreased, the accuracy of providing representative portions is decreased.
For this reason, it is imperative that extreme care be exercised when preparing the test
specimens.
5.2.1 Split or quarter enough material to fill four can measures to the
brim or slightly rounded above the brim in the following manner.
5.2.1.1 Ifit appears necessary, dampen the material to avoid segregation
or loss of fines during the splitting or quartering operations. Use care in
adding water to the sample to retain a free-flowing condition of the
material.
5.2.1.2 Using the measuring can, dip out four of these measures from
the sample. Each time a measure full of the material is dipped from the
sample, tap the bottom edge of the measure on a work table or other hard
surface at least four times and jog it slightly to produce a measure of con-
solidated material level-full or slightly rounded above the brim.
5.2.1.3 Determine and record the amount of material contained in
these four measures either by mass or by volume in a dry plastic cylinder.
5.2.1.4 Return this material back to the sample and proceed to split
or quarter the material making the necessary adjustments to obtain this
predetermined mass or volume. When this mass or volume is obtained,
two successive splitting or quartering operations without adjustment should
provide the proper amount of material to fill the measure.
5.2.1.5 Dry each test specimen to constant mass at 105 f 5% and cool
to room temperature before testing.
NOTE- Sand equivalent results on test specimens that have not been dried will
generally be lower than the results obtained on identical test specimens that have been
dried. As a time-saving expedient, it is permissible to test most materials without drying
when the sand equivalent value is used to determine compliance with a specification
giving a minimum acceptable test value. If the resulting test value is lower than that
specified, however, it will be necessary to rerun the test on a dried test specimen. If the
sand equivalent, determined from a test on one dried test specimen, is below the minimum
specification limit, it will be necessary to perform two additional tests on dried test speci-
mens from the same sample. The sand equivalent for a sample shall be determined in
accordance with 8.
10
IS : 2720 (Part XXXVII) - 1976
5.2.2 Prepare the desired number of test specimens from the sample as
follows.
5.2.2.1 Maintaining a free-flowing condition, dampen the material
sufficiently to prevent segregation or loss of fines.
5.2.2.2 Split or quarter out 1 000 to 1 500 g of the material. Mix
thoroughly with a hand trowel in a circular pan by stopping toward the
middle of the pan while rotating it horizontally. Mixing or remixing should
be continued for at least 1 minute to achieve uniformity. Check the material
for the necessary moisture condition by tightly squeezing a small portion
of the thoroughly mixed sample in the palm of the hand. If a cast is formed
that permits careful handling without breaking, the correct moisture range
has been obtained. If the material is too dry, the cast will crumble and
it will be necessary to add water and remix and retest until the material
forms a cast. If the material shows any free water it is too wet to test and
should be drained and air-dried, mixing it frequently to ensure uniformity.
This overly wet material will form a good cast when checked initially, so
the drying process should continue until a squeeze check on the drying
material gives a cast which is more fragile and delicate to handle than the
original. If the as received water content is within the limits described
above, the sample may be run immediately. If the water content is
altered to meet these limits, the sample should be put in a pan, covered
with a lid or with a damp trowel that does not touch the material, and allowed
to stand for a minimum of 15 minutes.
5.2.2.3 After the minimum curing time, remix for 1 minute without
water. When thoroughly mixed, form the material into a cone with a trowel.
5.2.2.4 Take the can measure in one hand and push it directly through
the base of the pile while holding the free hand firmly against the pile opposite
the measure.
5.2.2.5 As the can travels through the pile and emerges, apply enough
hand pressure to cause the material to fill the can to overflowing. Press
firmly with the palm of the hand, compacting the material until it consoli-
dates in the can. The excess material should be struck off level with the
top of the can, moving the ed,ge of the trowel in a sawing motion across
the brim.
5.2.2.6 To obtain additional test specimens, repeat the procedures
in 5.2.2.3 to 5.2.2.5.
6. PREPARATION OF APPARATUS
6.1 Fit the siphon assembly to a 4-litre bottle of working calcium chloride
solution. Place the bottle on a shelf 915f25 mm above the work surface.
NOTE- Instead of the 4-litre bottle, a glass or plastic vat having a larger capacity may
be used provided the liquid level of the working solution is maintained between 915 and
115 mm above the work surface.
11
IS : 2720 (Part XXXVII) - 1976
6.2 Start the siphon by blowing into the top of the solution bottle
through a short piece of tubing while the pinch clamp is open.
6.3 When using either the mechanical or the manually operated sand
equivalent shaker, fasten the apparatus to a firm and level mount.
NOTE - If only a few sand equivalent tests are to be performed at one location, it is
possible to hold the manually operated shaker by hand on a firm mount.
7. PROCEDURE
7.2 Pour one of the test specimens into the graduated cylinder using the
funnel to avoid spillage.
7.3 Tap the bottom of the cylinder sharply on the palm of the hand several
times to release air bubbles and to promote thorough wetting of the specimen.
7.4 Allow the wetted specimen and cylinder to stand undisturbed for 10 & 1
minutes.
7.5 At the end of the IO-minute soakingperiod, stopper the cylinder; then
loosen the material from the bottom by partially inverting the cylinder and
shaking it simultaneously.
7.6 After loosening the material from the bottom of the cylinder, shake the
cylinder and contents by any one of the following three methods.
7.6.1 Mecha~Gzl Shaker Method - Place the stoppered cylinder in the
mechanical sand equivalent shaker, set the time, and allow the machine to
shake the cylinder and the contents for 45 & 1 seconds.
7.6.2 Manual Shaker Method - Secure the stoppered cylinder to the shaker
and shake for 100 strokes, with half stroke length of 125 f 5 mm.
7.6.3 Hand Method
7.7 Following the shaking operation, set the cylinder upright on the work
table and remove the stopper.
12
IS : 2720 (Part XXXVII) - 1976
7.8.1 Curing the irrigation procedure, keep the cylinder vertical and the
base in contact xvith the xvork surface. Insert the irrigator tube in the top
of the cylinder, rcmovc the spring clamp from the hO.SC, and rinse the material
from the cylinder walls as the irriga.tor is lowered. Force the irrigator
through the material to the bottom of the cylinder by applying a gentle
stabbmg and twisting action while the workin.g solution flows from the
irrigator tip. This flushes the fine material into suspension a.bove the coarser
sand particles.
7.8.2 Continue to apply a stabbing and twisting action while flushing the
fities upward until the cylinder is filled to the 380 mm graduation. Then
raise the irrigator tube slowly without shutting p!f the flow so t&at the liquid
level is maintained at about the 380 mm graduation whiic the irrigator tube
is being withdrawn. Regulate the flow just before the irrigator tube is
entirely withdrawn and adjust the final level to the 380 mm graduation.
7.9 Allow the cylinder and contents to stand undisturbed for 20 minutes & 15
seconds. Start the timing immediately after withdrawing the irrigator tube.
7.10 At the end of the 20-minute sedimentation period, read and record
the level of the top of the clay suspension as prescribed in 7.12. This is
referred to as the clay reading. If no clear line of demarcat,ion has formed
at the end of the specified 20-minute sedimentation period, allow the sample
to stand undisturbed until a clay reading can be obtained; then immediately
read and record the level of the top of the clay suspension and the total
sedimenta.tion time. If the tota.1 sedimentation time exceeds 30 minutes,
rerun the test using three individual specimens of the same material.
Record the clay column height for the sample requiring the shortest sedi-
mcntation period as the clay reading.
7.12 If clay or sand readings fall between 2-mm graduations, record the
level of the higher graduation as the reading.
13
IS : 2720 (Part XXXVII) - 1976
8. CALCULATIONS
8.1 Calculate the sand equivalent (SE) to the nearest 0.1 using the following
formula :
JE : gj x 100
T
\\llClT
8.2 When the result of this calculation is not a whole number, the sand
equivadent (SE) sha.11 be the next higher whole number.
Exam/de :
8.3 I!f it is desired to average a series of sand equivalent values, average the
whole number values determined as described in 8.2.
Since the average value is not a whole number, the sand equiva-
lent value is 43 (see 8.3).
9. PRECISION
9.1 Before an operator is allowed to pertorm the samd equivalent test, he
should be capable of obtaining consistent test results on representa.tive
samples of any given material when the test is performed in accordance
with the prescribed procedure for the particular method used. An operators
test results are considered to be consistent if the individual results of three
tests performed by him on representative samples of the same material do
not vary by more than & 4 points from the average of these tests.
14
IS : 2720(Part 2IXXVII) - 1976
(Continued from page 2)
Members Representing
DEPUTY DIRECTORRESEARCH Railway Board (Ministry of Railways)
(SOIL MECHANICS)-I
ASSISTANT
DIRECTORREWARCH
SHRI R("LoI~dE!fANICS)-I (fib7Wtc)
Irrigation Research Institute, Khagaul, Patna
DIRECT~R(CSMRS) Central Water Commission, New Delhi
DEPUTY DIREIXOR (CSMRS) (Altcmafe)
SHRI H. K. GUHA Geologists Syndicate Pvt Ltd, Calcutta
SHRI N. N. BHA~ACHARAYA (Alternate)
DR S-HI K. GULHATI Indian Institute of Technology, New Delhi
SHRI R. K. JAIN United Technical Consultants Pvt Ltd, New Delhi
DR P. K. D~(Altcmatc)
SHRI 0. P. MALH&A Buildings & Roads Reseakh Laboratory, Govern-
ment of Punjab
DIRECTOR(Alternate)
DR V. V. S. RAO In personal capacity (F-24 Green Park, New Delhi)
SHRI H. C. VERMA Associated Instrument Manufacturers (India) Pvt
Ltd, New Delhi
PROF T. S. NACARAJ (Alternate)
15
INDIAN STANDARDS
ON
METHODS OF TEST FOR SOILS