Scribd
Upload
2K views1 page

Comparison of GB & ASME Standard: Double Sided or Full Penetration Single Sided Weld (As Per ASME With Backing Strip)

The document compares the GB 150 standard for pressure vessels in China to the ASME standard. It outlines some key differences in design pressure limits, thickness calculation models, allowable stress values, minimum thickness requirements, corrosion allowance definitions, joint efficiency values, non-destructive testing permissions, hydrostatic testing parameters, post-weld heat treatment rules, welding limitation definitions, impact test requirements, repetitive repair restrictions, and heat treatment of cold formed steels between the two standards.

Uploaded by

irfanlarikhotmailcom
Copyright
© © All Rights Reserved
Available Formats
Download as XLSX, PDF, TXT or read online on Scribd
Download as xlsx, pdf, or txt
2K views1 page

Comparison of GB & ASME Standard: Double Sided or Full Penetration Single Sided Weld (As Per ASME With Backing Strip)

The document compares the GB 150 standard for pressure vessels in China to the ASME standard. It outlines some key differences in design pressure limits, thickness calculation models, allowable stress values, minimum thickness requirements, corrosion allowance definitions, joint efficiency values, non-destructive testing permissions, hydrostatic testing parameters, post-weld heat treatment rules, welding limitation definitions, impact test requirements, repetitive repair restrictions, and heat treatment of cold formed steels between the two standards.

Uploaded by

irfanlarikhotmailcom
Copyright
© © All Rights Reserved
Available Formats
Download as XLSX, PDF, TXT or read online on Scribd
Download as xlsx, pdf, or txt
Download as xlsx, pdf, or txt
You are on page 1/ 1

Comparison of GB & ASME Standard

GB 150 Standard for pressure vessel ASME Remarks


Design pressure Limits 35MPa 20MPa; for greater pressure additional requirements
Thickness calculation Model Same Same
Design model for external pressure Same Same
Allowable stress 2.7/1.5 3.5/1.9

3.0 mm for all type of vessels 2.5 for steam or air, 1.5mm for any vessel , 6mm for unfired
boilers
Minimum thickness of vessel

defines mimium 1mm for steam or air service Not defined


Corrosion Allowance
1/.85 1/..85 double sided or full penetration
0.9/.8 .9/.8 single sided weld (as per ASME with backing strip)
Joint eff. Noting defined for Fillet or without backing strips, but permits No NDT with reduced joint efficiencies
do not permit "NO NDT"

Open, either pneumatic or water mandatory hydro with water


1.25 LSR*P 1.3*LSR*P
Testing
10 min at test pressure Time not specified

1st requirement Same


PWHT for repair , not allowed to repair without PWHT for Allowed up to 38mm with precautions
thickness greater than 13mm

Defines humidity wind and temp limits for welding operaNone


Welding Limitation
Not required above -20 deg C Check against material and thickness and Design MDMT
Impact test Requirement
Repetitive repairs Restricts repetitive repairs more than twice Approval by AI (for stamped vessels), none
HT of cold formed steels Same Same

You might also like