Jewish Standard 2-2-18
Jewish Standard 2-2-18
Jewish Standard 2-2-18
FEBRUARY 2, 2018
VOL. LXXXVII NO. 20 $1.00 86 2017
7
Fired up
Sinai Schools graduate
Yaakov Guttman
saves lives in Tel Aviv page 22
CHANGE SERVICE REQUESTED
Teaneck, NJ 07666
1086 Teaneck Road
Jewish Standard
Name: Englewood Hospital; Width: 60p0; Depth: 13 in; Color: Black; Ad Number: -
National leaders.
Local address.
To find a specialist,
call 866-980-3462 englewoodhealth.org
SOPHIE WEINSTEIN/OHSOARTY.COM
layered coating absorbs the hot rays copy us, because the technology is heat in the process. The SolCold lished weekly on Fridays with an additional edition every October,
by the New Jersey Jewish Media Group, 1086 Teaneck Road,
of the sun and re-emits that energy very complicated and not familiar to coating has two layers: The outer Teaneck, NJ 07666. Periodicals postage paid at Hackensack, NJ and
additional offices. POSTMASTER: Send address changes to New
in the form of cold. The hotter the too many people,” SolCold’s other layer filters the light to the optimum Jersey Jewish Media Group, 1086 Teaneck Road, Teaneck, NJ 07666.
solar radiation the more the coat- co-founder, Gadi Grottas. “We gath- frequencies, and the inner layer per- Subscription price is $30.00 per year. Out-of-state subscriptions are
$45.00, Foreign countries subscriptions are $75.00.
ing cools down, making SolCold’s ered a unique combination of knowl- forms the cooling. The appearance of an advertisement in The Jewish Standard does
paint a potentially game-changing edge in the worlds of thermodynam- “The paint could decrease elec- not constitute a kashrut endorsement. The publishing of a paid
political advertisement does not constitute an endorsement of any
electricity-free solution for places ics, nanotechnology, and quantum tricity consumption by up to 60 candidate political party or political position by the newspaper or
any employees.
with hot, sunny climates. physics and have been working on it percent and is expected to last for The Jewish Standard assumes no responsibility to return unsolic-
The Herzliya-based startup is for the past four years.” 10 to 15 years before needing a new ited editorial or graphic materials. All rights in letters and unsolic-
ited editorial, and graphic material will be treated as uncondition-
raising funds and plans to begin tri- The coating operates on the long- coat,” Grottas said. ISRAEL21C.ORG ally assigned for publication and copyright purposes and subject
to JEWISH STANDARD’s unrestricted right to edit and to comment
editorially. Nothing may be reprinted in whole or in part without
written permission from the publisher. © 2017
Injuries sideline
2 from the Tribe
The 52nd Super paper products com- man of the year by the
Bowl takes place pany (Kraft Group). His Harvard Theatricals Club
on February 4. many philanthropies and they were going to
The New England include Israel, education, be feted on January 25. I
Patriots, last year’s and health care. His son also noted that activists
winner, are looking for a JONATHAN, 53, is the wanted Kunis to speak
repeat win. The Philadel- president of the Kraft up about the fact that
phia Eagles were the Group and also president the Club didn’t cast
surprise team of the of the Patriots. women in their shows
playoffs and are looking The Eagles are owned (men play the female
for their first Super Bowl by JEFFREY LURIE, parts and have done so
win in franchise history. 66, and his ex-wife since 1844). Well, late on
The Eagles have ap- CHRISTINA WEISS LU- the 25th, the Club
peared in two Super RIE, 57. Lurie’s wealth Nate Ebner Joey Kramer Max Weinberg announced that women
Bowls (most recently in stems from a movie will be cast (playing
2005, when they lost to theater chain that his women) in their shows
the Patriots). The grandfather founded. He starting next year.
Patriots have appeared grew up in the Boston The Freeform
in nine Super Bowls, area and tried to buy cable station
winning five (all wins the Patriots in 1993 — (formerly ABC
came in 2002 or later). but Bob Kraft won out. Family) has a few good
Sadly, the Patriots’ Lurie then bought the shows aimed at a
special teams’ super- Eagles in 1994. Jeffrey younger audience. Here’s
star NATE EBNER, 29, and Christina divorced in one worth finding the
suffered a knee injury in 2012 and she retains sub- channel and checking
November and is out for stantial ownership in the out. “Alone Together,”
the season. Patriots’ star team. Despite her first which began on January
receiver Julian Edelman name, Christina’s par- 10, is about Esther and
suffered an ACL tear last ents both were Jewish. Roy Bittan Mark Ronson Esther Povitsky Benji, two 20somethings
September that ended In a 2010 interview, she in Los Angeles who are
his season. As I noted said both she and Jef- Super Bowl makes (this groups. In 1987, the Bowl ish entertainer again got aspiring comedians. They
last year, Ebner grew frey come from secular year it is Justin Timber- went a bit more show- solo credit as a perform- have a strong platonic
up in a religious Jewish Jewish homes and their lake). The NFL says that it biz; the named perform- er — MARK RONSON, friendship. They are
home. Edelman had one practice of Judaism was does not pay performers, ers were showbiz vets now 42, played guitar as played by real-life
Jewish great grandfather, limited to Passover sed- but it does cover costs, GEORGE BURNS, then Bruno Mars sang “Up- stand-up comedians
but has called himself ers. Both have academic which can range up to an 91, and Mickey Rooney, town Funk” (a song they ESTHER POVITSKY, 29,
Jewish and he’s gone out backgrounds in film and astonishing $10 million. In then 67. In 2001, the co-wrote). I dare say that and BENJI ALFARO,
of his way to emphasize she was a documen- return for their “free” per- band Aerosmith was the nobody at a Bowl party 29ish. Alfaro is Jewish
his ties to the Jewish tary maker. Jeffrey is formance, entertainers headliner (its drummer, will guess that George and Povitsky alternately
community (including an active film producer, get the biggest commer- JOEY KRAMER, now 67, Burns was the first Jew calls herself Jewish and
visiting Israel). mostly of documentaries. cial of the year, enhanced is Jewish). In 2009, Bruce to be a credited halftime half Jewish (her mother
ROBERT KRAFT, 76, He briefly appeared as recordings sales, and the Springsteen and the E entertainer at a Super isn’t Jewish). The show
has owned the Patri- himself in “Jerry Magu- opportunity to charge Street Band performed Bowl. Take bets and see isn’t laugh-out-loud
ots since 1994. Kraft ire,” the hit fictional film more for concerts and (the band includes drum- what happens. funny, but it is often
grew up in an Orthodox about pro football. endorsements. Until 1987, mer MAX WEINBERG, I noted last week amusing in a gentle way.
home and is an obser- I was curious, so I Super Bowl perform- now 66, and keyboardist that MILA KUNIS The stars kvetch funny.
vant Jew whose family looked up what the ers mostly were march- ROY BITTAN, now 68). and PAUL RUDD New episodes air Wednes-
fortune stems from a halftime entertainer at a ing bands and choral Finally, in 2016, a Jew- were named woman and days at 8:30 p.m. –N.B.
S
ing violin, piano, and saxophone.
ome things simply fit together so well that it’s hard to Thurnauer’s orchestra will participate in the concert as
ignore their connection. Take the Thurnauer School well. That will bring the number of participants to more than
of Music’s upcoming Gift of Music benefit concert, 250, including children as young as 4 as well as adults. The
P
hysicians, nurses, paramedics,
firefighters and others who are
willing to drop everything and
fly to Israel in times of need
now have a formal program through which
to volunteer their services.
“We’re partnering with an Israeli orga-
nization, Emergency Volunteers Project,
which is authorized by, and works with,
the Israeli government to organize and cer-
tify American first-responders to serve in
Israel in times of emergency,” said Ethan
Behling, director of the Center for Israel
Engagement at the Jewish Federation of
Northern New Jersey.
A one-time full-day training session for
interested volunteers, sponsored by JFNNJ
and led by trainers from Israel, will take
place on March 11. (See box for details.)
“We wanted to focus on an initiative to
help the security of Israel, which is one of
our goals,” Mr. Behling said.
Although JFNNJ’s Partnership2Gether
program has sponsored exchange trips
to Israel for North Jersey first responders,
this is the first time it is participating in
EVP, and it is the first EVP session for New
Jersey residents. This first responder delegation from the Jewish Federation of Northern New Jersey went to Israel in 2016. The delegation
Since its inception in 2009, EVP has included local police officers, ER doctors, and a firefighter.
trained and certified about 1,000 emer-
gency volunteers and professional first practice in Israel; nurses and paramedics the ground,” said Franci Steinberg, chair She emphasized that “responding to
responders in the United States and Israel, will be authorized to provide assistance of JFNNJ’s Partnership2Gether Committee. crises in Israel is something the federa-
including many response teams in Ari- at hospitals and bomb shelters; firefight- “Our federation wants Israel to know that tion hopes we won’t have to do, but it’s
zona, California, Colorado, Florida, Mary- ers will work alongside Israeli counter- if they face threats or disasters at home, we extremely important that certified volun-
land, New Mexico, New York, Oklahoma, parts responding to emergency calls; will be there. We support Israel in times of teers can have the ability to help in case
and Texas. The training also counts toward and general community volunteers will need and in good times, and always want of conflict, earthquake, or wildfire, and
FEMA (Federal Emergency Management be trained to serve in emergency depots, to keep the lines of communication open.” EVP also provides an opportunity for
Agency) certification. deliver food and water to shelters, and The t ype of volunteers needed people to learn critical skills from expe-
In 2016, during a period when there provide support services. depends on the nature of the emergency, rienced Israelis.”
were widespread forest fires in Israel, In case of deployment, each volunteer which can range from forest fires to wars.
EVP deployed 39 American firefighters to would be paired with an Israeli counter- The federation would decide whom and What: Emergency Volunteers Project
the Jewish state to provide support and part. Therefore, knowledge of Hebrew is how many to send from among the certi- training and certification class
relief services. helpful but not required. EVP arranges fied volunteers, who would join EVP vol- When: Sunday, March 11, 8 a.m.
The federation is aiming to recruit 20 all logistics, including flights and hous- unteers from other communities. to 7 p.m.
medical personnel, 20 firefighters, and ing. EVP volunteers generally remain in Ms. Steinberg explained that when, Where: Law and Public Safety Institute,
20 general volunteers. “The more people Israel for a week to 10 days, depending for example, a military conflict arises, 281Campgaw Road, Mahwah
we have certified to respond, the better,” on the situation. many Israeli medical professionals are
How much: $60 (waived for
Mr. Behling said. “Whenever there’s a crisis anywhere called for reserve duty. “So it can hap- firefighters)
Participating physicians of any spe- in the world we all know Israel is the first pen that hospitals are short-staffed and
Registration: www.jfnnj.org/evp
cialty will receive a temporary license to country to have emergency personnel on our responders would fill those needs.”
KOSHER GROCERY KOSHER FRESH BAGELS KOSHER ROASTED CHICKEN KOSHER FRESH SUSHI
Our kosher bagels are made exactly We only use freshest kosher
as they should be—from scratch all chickens and prepare them to the
day, every day, in small batches highest kosher standards
5
$ 99
lb. SAVE
UP TO 1
$ 00
LB.
$ 49
3 SAVE
UP TO 1
$ 00 99 ¢
SAVE
UP TO 50¢
9
$ 99 lb.
SAVE $
UP TO 7 00
LB.
$ 89
2 lb.
SAVE $
UP TO 1 00
LB.
$ 99
7 lb.
SAVE $
UP TO 200
LB.
T
God,” as one of his most famous sermons
he writer Julius Lester died on put it, and warned about being “overrun
January 18. by Jews and papists,” Rabbi Prouser said.
An African American, he was “In my American history classroom
the son of a Methodist minister in Northampton High School, I could sit
and, as he learned, the great grandson of back in my chair and see the church where
a Jewish man. He was a vocal supporter of Edwards preached,” he added.
the Black Power movement in the 1960s, Eventually Mr. Lester left Northampton
an essayist and writer, a musician and pho- and therefore, necessarily, B’nai Israel; he
tographer, an academic who retired as a moved to Vermont and joined a congrega-
professor emeritus at the University of tion there, Beth El Synagogue in St. John-
Massachusetts at Amherst, and the author sbury, where he became a lay leader. But
of, among many other works, including he kept his ties to the Northampton shul.
many for children, “Lovesong,” the 1988 “During one of the rabbinic interregnums,
memoir subtitled “Becoming a Jew.” when the lay leaders had to do everything,
He was, in other words, very complicated my father often would do unveilings,”
and quintessentially American. He was at Rabbi Prouser said. “He had Julius Lester
the center of a debate about anti-Semitism record El Moleh Rachamim” because his
— he had a radio program and allowed the father particularly loved the way Mr. Les-
reading of a seriously nasty, undeniably Julius Lester ter did it, and wanted to learn how to do it
anti-Semitic poem on the air during the New that way himself.
York City teachers’ strike in 1968. as professor emeritus of Judaic and Near there. It was the gabbai, Mr. Prouser, The problem, Rabbi Prouser said deli-
He also became more and more sure Eastern studies. who offered it to him, by asking if he was cately, was that his father’s voice was not
that his soul would be most fulfilled were Joseph Prouser, the rabbi of Temple a kohen or a levi. That question told Mr. particularly good. Or, as he put it, “My
he to become Jewish — he realized that Emanuel of North Jersey in Franklin Lakes, Lester that Mr. Prouser was assuming that father taught me to daven, so his davening
on the most profound level it already was was particularly touched by Dr. Lester’s this clearly African-American stranger was sounded great to me, but it was somewhat
Jewish — so he converted. “Lovesong” death because he had been touched by a Jew. That act of pure kindness told Mr. … uh… somewhat atonal. He was all but
is the story of his Jewishness, and it is Mr. Lester’s life. Mr. Lester’s affiliation was Lester that he was at home. tone deaf.”
deeply beautiful. with the Conservative movement. That’s Later, Mr. Lester wrote, he often led Mr. Lester, on the other hand, “had a
Mr. Lester never left his identity as a black because, as Rabbi Prouser said, “He was parts of the service, and he writes about beautiful voice, the voice of a real baal tef-
man behind, and he filtered what he saw an intellectual and spiritual searcher and what it felt like the first time he led Hallel ilah,” the singer who voices the congrega-
through that identity. He also took on his he came to Judaism both for its spiritual at B’nai Israel. tion’s prayers. “A rich, deep voice, and
identity as a Jew, and once he recognized richness and community and because it “I know now,” he wrote, in his memoir’s the El Moleh Rachamim he recorded was
it for what it was, he filtered everything he provides room for free thinking and criti- last page. “At long last I know what my very beautiful.
saw through that vantage point as well. cal analysis.” That’s what he found in Con- voice was meant to sing. All those years I “So for my father to say, as he often did,
What he saw was idiosyncratic, impor- servative Judaism, Rabbi Prouser, who is sang folk songs, spirituals, blues, work that he was doing the Julius Lester version
tant, and true. Conservative, said. songs, and always knew that something of El Moleh carried a bit of irony.
His changes can be traced throughout Rabbi Prouser knew Mr. Lester because was absent, that as much as I loved spiri- “The one mercy to it was that Julius
his academic career at UMass; he joined Mr. Lester had been a member of Congre- tuals, I was not wholly present when I sang never heard my father do it, because if
its department of Afro-American studies gation B’nai Israel in Northampton, Mas- them. Now I know why. It was this music Julius was there, then Julius would do it.”
in 1971 and became an associate professor sachusetts. That was Rabbi Prouser’s shul; my voice was meant to sing.” Rabbi Prouser did get to hear Mr. Les-
in 1975. In 1977, he became a full professor his father, Mel Prouser, was the gabbai And it was Rabbi Prouser’s father who ter’s version. When his mother, Anne, a
there. From 1982 to 1988, he had a joint there for 34 years. helped open that world to him. high school math teacher, died, “Julius
appointment in that department and the At the end of “Lovesong,” Mr. Lester It is a gabbai’s job to know who to ask; did the El Moleh at her funeral,” he said.
department of Judaic studies; he retired wrote about the first time he had an aliyah it’s a sense that the gabbai can develop “It was a great comfort to my father. It
and refine over the course of many years. was beautiful.”
“He had an instinct to know who to ask for He knew Mr. Lester; in fact, when he
what,” Rabbi Prouser said of his father. “It wrote his own first book, “Noble Soul: The
is both recognizing who should be hon- Life and Legend of the Vilna Ger Tzedek,”
ored because of events in their lives or a study of an 18th-century Polish count
experiences the gabbai knows they are who converted to Judaism — and was mar-
going through, and also being sensitive tyred for it — he sent the manuscript to Mr.
Rabbi Prouser’s to when someone feels the need to be Lester early in the process. The connec-
parents, Mel included for any reason. Those are two tion between reader and subject was obvi-
and Anne. different skills.” ous, and Mr. Lester “was very encouraging
Northampton was a progressive com- about the project,” Rabbi Prouser said.
munity, Rabbi Prouser said; egalitarian- Rabbi Prouser tells one more story
ism came early to the shul there, and there about Mr. Lester. “In his autobiography, he
weren’t racial issues. It is an academic gives his Hebrew name as Yakov ben Avra-
town. But there is some irony in that. It ham, but later in life he called himself Lev
was the home of Jonathan Edwards; it’s Sameach.” In English, that’s Joyous Heart.
where the 18th-century Protestant theo- Not a conventional name, but then noth-
logian thundered about his congregants ing about Julius Lester was conventional.
Sunday Evening
February 25, 2018
ANNUAL
BENEFIT DINNER
Marriott Glenpointe Hotel, Teaneck, NJ
Honoring
EXCELLENCE IN
SPECIAL EDUCATION
Ruthie & Chazan Shim Amy & Dr. Joshua Dr. Perla & Dr. Gerardo INDIVIDUALIZATION
Craimer Fogelman Yablonovich
INCLUSION BY DESIGN®
TRANSFORMING LIVES
Special tribute in
memory of our beloved
Associate Director
SINAI alumnus & star of this Shomer She'erit Yisrael
year's feature documentary
IT IS ONLY
THROUGH YOUR
COMPASSION AND GENEROSITY
THAT OUR VITAL WORK
Lawrence R. Inserra, Jr., CEO CAN CONTINUE.
and Inserra Family
Inserra Supermarkets, Inc. We accept gifts of appreciated securities
Community Partnership Award
OVERCOMING
DISABILITIES AND
PAINFUL LOSS,
HE ROSE TO CREATE
HIS OWN DESTINY
Return to sender
TeaneckShuls mailing list leaves Yahoo Groups for Groups.io
LARRY YUDELSON
R
uthie Levi doesn’t want this story to be about
her.
Ms. Levi is one of the four people who
oversee the electronic mailing list called
TeaneckShuls.
TeaneckShuls has more than 14,000 members and it
sends out dozens of messages a day. As of Monday, it has
sent a total of 414,846 messages since it was launched in
October 2000.
One of the moderators reviews each one of the mes-
sages sent to the list, to make sure it adheres to poli-
cies designed to ensure that they are both useful and
focused. The messages approved on a recent evening
included requests — for a Mahjong set, for a freezer, for
a recommendation for a handyman who repairs decks,
for a ride to the Upper West Side of Manhattan, and for
teachers for a preschool in West Orange. There were
also offers to sell — an iPhone, a drum set, and diapers
all were available for the right price. And there was an
announcement that a canvas sukkah and outdoor furni-
ture all were available for the taking.
The moderators are not in it
for the glory. A sampling of the inbox at TeaneckShuls.
“If I could change some-
thing from when we started, a return home. The list was
we should have been anony- launched on the eGroups plat-
mous moderators,” Ms. Levi form in October 2000, shortly
said. “The name recognition is after Yahoo bought eGroups The hardest part is the
beyond crazy.”
The other three moderators
and before it was rebranded as
Yahoo Groups. Mark Fletcher,
continuous nature of it.
are Bryan Alter, Kevie Feit, and the programmer who started People expect you are
Bernie Suskewicz.
Now, though, they seek a
eGroups in the first place (and
who posts on Twitter and else-
going to post their
bit of publicity because of the where under the less-than- request for a babysitter
biggest transition in the list’s
17-year history. As of last week,
kosher moniker of WingedPig)
launched Groups.io in 2014.
in FedEx time. Every
TeaneckShuls no longer is hosted by Yahoo Groups. The transition was years in the making. Those who time you sit down at
Instead, it runs on Groups.io, an email service created by
the original inventor of Yahoo Groups. And while behind-
follow the rise and fall of internet companies know the
story of Yahoo’s rise in the 1990s as a curated guide to
your desk there are
the-scenes magic ensured that the messages continue to everything worth viewing on the World Wide Web. But pending messages.
flow, that all the subscribers migrated, that inboxes that the 21st century brought many corporate acquisitions
and restructurings, culminating in Verizon’s purchase of “We decided to let it fly,” Ms. Levi said.
Yahoo last year. Throughout this time, Yahoo’s various Now, Yahoo Groups is back up — which means the
internet services, including Yahoo Groups, languished. TeaneckShul moderators can see the errant posts sent to
For Ms. Levi and her fellow moderators, this was the old email address and reply with a request to repost
The moderators had immensely frustrating. to the new address.
planned for the “About two years ago, we noticed that Yahoo Groups
was starting to deteriorate in terms of service and abil-
“If the message is super important, we won’t delay
that,” she said. “People are learning. We had about five
transition to take ity to deliver messages in a timely fashion,” she said. “It messages to the old list today. The daily message load is
place this weekend — was clear to us, though this was not evident to the end
user member.”
40 to 50.”
Ms. Levi likes the new service.
until a Yahoo outage So the moderators — the “Mod Squad,” as they call “A lot of the cosmetic things appear nicer,” she said.
last week led them to themselves — started researching alternatives to Yahoo.
By December, they were ready to try out Groups.io. They
“The creator is hands on. He responds to our emails. We
noticed some bugs. I wrote to Mark — and presto! he fixed
move up the timetable. shifted an announcement only list to which only 20 or so them. His responsiveness is off the charts.”
synagogue administrators posted and only about 1,000 It doesn’t hurt that TeaneckShuls is the largest group
once overflowed with messages from TeaneckShuls-nore- readers received, to the new service. That worked well on his platform.
[email protected] now are being filled by messages — though it was relatively easy to retrain such a small Unlike Yahoo Groups, the new platform charges a fee:
from [email protected], there still is the more dif- group to use a new email address. $100 a year for each list. Rather than collecting a penny
ficult matter of changing human behavior. “That will be a little more difficult for TeaneckShuls,” from each subscriber, the moderators are paying for it
So, a week into the transition, there’s still the need to Ms. Levi said. themselves. Compared to the hundreds of hours they vol-
get the word out: Posts to the mailing list should be sent The moderators had planned for the transition to take unteer, the money isn’t very much. And the new platform
to [email protected]. place this weekend — until a Yahoo outage last week led has time-saving features, like an easy way for the modera-
For TeaneckShuls, the move to Groups.io is a bit of them to move up the timetable. tors to send out detailed form letters when they reject a
post for violating the list guidelines. For a totally new look using
Ms. Levi joined the Mod Squad back in 2000, not
long after Nathan J. Lindenbaum and Chaim Shulman your furniture or starting anew.
started the group.
“I had some criticism and I said at the same time, if Staging also available
you need help, I’m eager to help,” she said. “Famous
last words. 973-535-9192
“The hardest part is the continuous nature of it.
People expect you are going to post their request for
a babysitter in FedEx time. Every time you sit down at
PASSOVER 2018
your desk there are pending messages. If you’re going
OUR 60th YEAR
to a movie for two hours and the other guys are on
vacation, you feel the pressure. People expect their
messages will be approved or rejected in real time.”
Also unpleasant: Having to reject people. For every
60 posts that go out on a typical day, there might be
another 15 or 20 that are rejected.
“There’s push back and conversations and replies,” 6 Spectacular Pesach Destinations
she said.
PHOENIX, ARIZONA BOCA RATON, FLORIDA PALM BEACH, FLORIDA
“Rejections are not personal,” she said, with an ada-
mancy that makes you think that she’s had to repeat Arizona Boca Raton PGA National
that message far more than once. “We don’t look at
the name of the person we are rejecting. We aim to
Biltmore Resort & Club Resort
A WALDORF ASTORIA RESORT A WALDORF ASTORIA RESORT
be fair.
“I too had a home for sale. I made sure to post it
only every four weeks,” as the rules mandate. “It’s a
long list of rules, because there are a lot of situations
that come up. We can’t possibly think of every sce-
nario and codify it. There are judgment calls. At the
end of the day it’s only an email list.”
The list is named Teaneck Shuls, but subscribers
span the globe. • Condé Nast Traveler, 2016 Gold List Top • Gorgeous half-mile stretch of Private • Entire Hotel Kosher for Pesach
Beach • 2 Championship Golf Courses • AAA 4-Diamond Resort • All Rooms Have
“The child of a friend of mine in Israel went to Camp Arizona Resort • 8 heated swimming pools
• 30 Clay Tennis Courts • 40,000 sq. ft. Private Balconies • 5 Tournament-Ready
Moshava, in Pennsylvania. He broke his glasses over •7 Tennis Courts • Two 18 hole championship World Class Spa • Haute Gourmet Cuisine by Golf Courses • 19 Har Tru Tennis Courts
Shabbat. My friend contacted me Sunday morning golf courses • Professional Day Camp the Waldorf Astoria Resort Chefs • Scholar- • Fantastic Scholars-in-Residence
asking if I had a way to get a new pair of glasses from • Haute gourmet cuisine by VIP Ram Caterers in-Residence: Rabbi Ephraim Mirvis - Chief • Exceptional Cuisine by Foremost Ram
Israel to Moshava. Monday morning, the kid has his • Fantastic Scholar- in-Residence • International Rabbi of England • International Kosher Caterers • ORB Glatt Kosher Supervision
glasses in Moshava.” Kosher Mehadrin (IK) Glatt Kosher Supervision Mehadrin (IK) Glatt Kosher Supervision
That said, the list has limited geographic scopes.
“We’re not here to help every Jew everywhere,” she
FLORENCE, ITALY FIUGGI (ROME), ITALY RYE BROOK, NEW YORK
said. The core geography is Teaneck, Bergenfield,
and New Milford. Those are the only towns whose Four Seasons Grand Hotel Hilton
residents are allowed to post real estate listings, and Florence Palazzo Della Fonte Westchester
where the synagogues post their announcements.
If you’re looking for a housekeeper, on the other
hand, you can post from anywhere in Bergen County.
“We don’t want there to be a hundred messages a
day,” she said. “We want to be readable.” In fact, the
list traffic has dropped steadily. In 2010, 32,156 mes-
sages went out. Last year, there were only 16,479. Ms.
Levi attributes this to stronger moderation, and drop-
ping occasional “business weeks” that allowed for the
posting of commercial messages. Entire La Villa building Kosher for Pesach • Entire Hotel Kosher for Pesach • Entire hotel Kosher for Pesach • Only 30
• Luxury 5-star resort • Hotel set amidst a • Member of the Leading Hotels Of The minutes from New York City • Hotel
Among the nearly half a million messages, there are
350,000 sq.ft. botanical garden World • Haute Italian Cuisine • Beautiful spa, beautifully renovated • Spectacular lineup
some that seem like miracles. • Gourmet cuisine by Michelen rated Four indoor & outdoor pools • Free daily shuttle of Scholars-in- Residence • Fantastic
“We’ve done three kidney matches,” Ms. Levi said. Seasons chefs • Professional Day Camp to Rome • Professional Day Camp entertainment & daily activities
“To be able to save a life through an email list? That’s • Scholar- in-Residence: Rabbi Lord • Scholar-In-Residence: Rabbi Yisrael Lau - • Professional day camp • Exceptional
unbelievable. Jonathan Sacks • Glatt Kosher Supervision Chief Rabbi of Tel Aviv • Glatt Kosher cuisine by Prestige Caterers • ORB Glatt
“What I’m most proud of are the crises. Hurricane by Rabbi G.M. Garelik Supervision by Rabbi G.M. Garelik of Milan Kosher Supervision
Sandy? We rocked it. We were a vehicle for informa-
Puppy love kids were donating their hair [to a charity], I took
before and after photos at no charge.” She also
composed an ad for the Jewish Standard many
years ago, showcasing Orthodox families in the
Activist-photographer puts community. (Citing another Jewish Standard con-
adoptibles in the picture nection, she pointed out that community editor
Beth Chananie is a big supporter of dog adoption.)
LOIS GOLDRICH “I try to do good in the world,” Ms. Ofrane said.
W
She helps people find dogs to adopt, whether from
atch out, Super Bowl. There’s another Bowl RBARI or from other reputable shelters. “It’s my per-
— far cuter and more meaningful (except sonal goal,” she said. “I helped about 10 families in
to avid football fans, I guess) — coming our Teaneck adopt.” She explained that a large part of
way, and this year it will be bigger than ever. her dog advocacy is educational. Families can get
“Every year, the channel Animal Planet runs a Puppy any kind of dog from a shelter, she said, but many
Bowl on Super Bowl Sunday, featuring puppies from differ- people are misled into thinking that shelter dogs
ent rescues and shelter,” Lyn Ofrane of Teaneck said. “This necessarily are damaged.
year, on the day before, they will also have a Dog Bowl, fea- “Dogs are put down that shouldn’t be,” she said.
turing senior dogs that need a home.” “So many people buy dogs at a pet store. It breaks
Talking to Ms. Ofrane on the phone is somewhat of a chal- my heart.” There are really pitfalls to buying pup- Lyn Ofrane holds Scooter, left, and Harley. Both are
lenge. Not only does the photographer and animal activist pies bred in puppy mills and that means that “so available for adoption.
volunteer at RBARI, the Ramapo-Bergen Animal Refuge in many dogs are thrown away. It’s beyond belief.”
Oakland, but she also dog sits, often hosting as many as six Ms. Jurovitsky said that at any given time, there are about love it and teachers love it. It’s a great mitzvah for everyone.”
canine guests. 35 or 40 dogs at the shelter and others that are in foster care. She said that she would like to begin visiting Sinai Schools,
According to RBARI president Arlene Jurovitsky, Ms. Ofrane, The group has been called by animal control to intervene but the program needs more volunteers. “We’re dying for
a board member, “donates her valuable time to photograph in hoarding situations, or to help with dogs that are surren- volunteers,” she said. “I talk to everybody about this.”
all of the shelter animals at their time of intake, in order for us dered because their owners no longer can take care of them. Her own pet is a therapy dog, and she has taken him to
to be able to showcase RBARI cats and dogs on our website, Some dogs are brought in because they are severely dam- the Teaneck library. While she would love to expand such
social media outlets, and websites that potential adopters are aged and need a good deal of help. visits as well, “we run on a wing and a prayer,” she said. “We
searching when looking for a new family member.” The group is funded entirely by donations and receives don’t get government help. We need more volunteers. We
That description is accurate, but does not convey the pas- no government help. used to take high school kids, but now they have to be 18 or
sion Ms. Ofrane feels for the shelter and its rescue animals. RBARI, which takes in animals from the tristate area, runs older for insurance reasons.”
While Lyn and husband, Avi, have grown twin sons, Josh a number of valuable community programs, Ms. Ofrane Ms. Ofrane is proud of her reputation in the community as
and Etan, and Etan and his wife Becky have added children said. Paws in Hand, for example, brings together “gentle and a talented photographer. “I’ve had a studio in my home for
Mazie and Leon to the family — all of whom, she said “are kind dogs” with special needs children. It began by visiting 30 years,” she said. She began by photographing people in
the most important part of my life” — her commitment to only one school, but now it sends representatives to pub- their homes, and then, almost against her will, branched out
help animals and people in need is clearly evident. lic and private schools almost every day. “We bring retired to cover larger events, such as b’nai mitzvah. Much of her
Using her skills as a photographer, “I have always donated teachers, or whoever loves children and dogs, and visit work has been in the local Orthodox community, and she
time to anything or anyone in need,” Ms. Ofrane said. “If schools for several hours,” Ms. Ofrane said. “The children now finds herself photographing the children of people she
W
as refresher lessons for the come along later, but “cer- make those decisions appropriately.”
e’re all gonna die. chevra kadisha volunteers. tainly, once they’re married A growing issue is the rise of popularity
That’s a sentiment that As Rabbi Zohn sees it, you and raising a family, plan- of cremation, which Rabbi Zohn strongly
has been expressed in should start thinking about ning for your burial and condemns.
song by musicians as var- your inevitable death as you beyond is an appropriate “Besides the fact that burial is very much
ied as the former Guns N’ Roses guitarist turn 18. “Every person over thing to do.” a biblical requirement, it’s a matter of
known as Slash, and the folk rocker Tay- the age of 18 should have These include making a respect,” he said. “The things we respect,
lor Goldsmith from the band Dawes. Or, as a living will and therefore will, which Rabbi Zohn said the things we treasure, that are valuable, we
Shel Silverstein put it, “Eliminate everything a halachic living will,” he “has to be written within bury. Things that are not valuable, we burn.
fatty or fried / And you get real healthy, but said. “There are issues deal- halachic guidelines. We burn the trash.
you’re still gonna die.” ing with end-of-life medical Rabbi Elchonon Zohn “From a Torah perspec- “We believe in an afterlife. We bury peo-
Rabbi Elchonon Zohn strongly agrees preparedness. tive, the male children ple because we believe the body will be
with that settlement. “These are things that people very often inherit and the eldest child receives a dou- resurrected, hopefully. Many Jews believe
And he wants you to be prepared. don’t think about. We’re encouraging them ble portion. If someone wishes to distribute those are Catholic concepts, but they’re not.
Rabbi Zohn is the president of the to do so. We encourage living wills, which their estate differently there are ways to do “Burial in a family plot is part of continu-
National Association of Chevra Kadisha designate not only a person to make medi- it, but it needs to be done in accordance ity. Judaism is built on traditions that are
and director of the Queens Chevra Kadi- cal decisions, but a rabbi that person will with Jewish law. Without a will, it sometimes handed down from parents to children.
sha. A chevra kadisha — Aramaic for sacred reach out to when questions arise as to the ends up in court or a beit din and can some- The fact we are part of a chain going back
society — is the group responsible for pre- appropriate medical decisions to make from times tear families apart.” to Abraham is a very important part of our
paring dead bodies for burial in the tradi- a halachic perspective. We offer a card that In addition to making sure that you have faith, our value system. Burial is part of
tional Jewish fashion. On Sunday, the four people carry like a credit card that lists the a grave prepared for yourself, Rabbi Zohn that. The custom is to be buried where your
chevrei kadisha serving Teaneck’s Ortho- proxy and the rabbi to call and all kinds of would like to encourage people to spread parents are. We look at the monuments of
dox synagogues are hosting Rabbi Zohn as statements that are important to know in a the word among their family, friends, and our forebears and the fact that they were
a keynote speaker for a study day devoted medical emergency,” he said. acquaintances about traditional Jewish good people encourages us to be the same.
JewishStandard
N E W J E R S E Y R O C K L A N D
an older dog, which one of her children was no longer
[email protected]
able to care for. [email protected]
The RBARI shelter is extremely proud that two of its
845-354-7763
dogs will be showcased in the Dog Bowl, its executive
director, Megan Brinst, said. The dogs, Lexi and Kody,
OVERWHELMED
both since have been adopted. Ms. Jurovitsky said the
connection with the Dog Bowl came about through the
shelter’s partnership with Grey Muzzle, which, accord-
ing to its website, “believes no senior dog should die
alone and afraid.” The group provides grants and other
funding to pay for expenses, such as medical care, “so
the wonderful organizations that give these dogs a sec-
ond chance can focus on their care.”
by home financing options?
When it planned this year’s Dog Bowl, “Animal Planet
contacted Grey Muzzle,” Ms. Jurovitsky said. “Since they
were filming in New York, they recommended that we
be part of it.” The program, she said, is not only impor-
tant but “very entertaining. They film dogs doing differ-
ent things, related to the Super Bowl.” For example, she
said, some dogs will be cheerleaders, while others will
run with a ball. They’ll be playing their own game.
The Dog Bowl will air on Saturday, February 3, at 8
p.m. For more information about RBARI, call (201) 337-
5180 or go to RBARI.org.
on Cedar Lane
ing Jewish novelist Nicole Times Book of the Year final-
Krauss will deliver this ist and “The History of Love”
year’s Hillel Rogoff memo- was a New York Times best-
rial lecture on February 6 seller and winner of the Sar-
in Teaneck
at 7 p.m. for Yeshiva Univer- oyan Prize for International
sity. She’ll be at YU’s Israel Literature. Her books have
Goni Riskin
Henry Beren Campus, in been translated into more
the Koch auditorium at 245 than 35 languages.
Apple Asian Express Lexington Avenue. Hillel (Harry) Rogoff was
Ms. Krauss’ talk, “For- Nicole Krauss an early alumnus of Yeshiva
461 Cedar Lane
est Dark: The Path to Writ- University and a longtime
201-530-5958 ing,” will focus on her most editor of the Jewish Daily
Just Right Fitness recent work, “Forest Dark,” a novel set Forward. The lecture was established
NEW BUSINESS
494 Cedar Lane in New York and Israel. The main charac- in 1971 through the efforts of late YU
Kameleas Beauty Boutique ters, an aging lawyer and a young novel- English professor and administrator Dr.
362 Cedar Lane 201-835-4119 ist, each searching for truth, find them- David Mirsky and members of the Rogoff
201-836-6200 State Farm Insurance selves in the Israeli desert. Ms. Krauss’ family.
504B Cedar Lane earlier novels all have been bestsellers The lecture is free and open to the
Rock Collage and award winners. “Man Walks into public. Email [email protected].
364 Cedar Lane 201-530-7779
201-357-2347 NEW ADDRESS
Mod Corals Castillo Salon Artists’ beit midrash continues
394 Cedar Lane 398 Cedar Lane The artists’ beit midrash at Congrega- The program, led by Harriet Finck,
201-836-0850 201-692-1644 tion Beth Sholom in Teaneck offers “The who has facilitated and taught in the
Word, The Sound, The Shape: Poetry in program since it began, is open to art-
Mr. Fresh Cut Cohen Printing
the Modern and Medieval Jewish World.” ists working in all media and skill lev-
394 Cedar Lane 547 Cedar Lane The season of study, dedicated to the els who wish to explore Jewish and
551-900-1022 201-287-0343 memory of Jay Seth Greenspan, a sofer Hebrew poetry while creating visual,
and a good friend of the artists’ beit musical, and written midrashim based
JR Coiffure Hair Salon Direct Line Carpet
midrash, runs for eight sessions, from upon class study. For more informa-
443 Cedar Lane 553 Cedar Lane Sunday, February 4, to Sunday, May 6, tion, call (201) 833-2620 or email Carol
201-357-5050 201-357-4021 from 10 to 11:30 a.m. Weinstein at [email protected].
Arnold and his wife Sandra – a deeply inspired JCC past president,
who serves on the JCC Board of Trustees – were founding leaders of the JCC
and championed many efforts that shaped its mission. To support under-served
populations in our community, they established the Sandra and Arnold Gold Fund for
Rehabilitation Services at the JCC to ensure that people with disabilities could receive
the therapy they needed. They brought the Therapeutic Nursery from Albert Einstein
College of Medicine to the JCC, which has been bringing hope and promise to families
with children struggling with developmental delays for more than thirty years.
They instituted JCC programs for the developmentally disabled and helped
the JCC establish its Special Services Department that now brings quality of life
to thousands of people with special needs each year. And as lifelong patrons of the arts,
they were instrumental in making the JCC the rich and thriving cultural center it is today.
They established the JCC’s Cultural Arts program and were the inspiration behind the
establishment of the Thurnauer School of Music, which continues to bring the gift
of music to thousands of students and unparalleled cultural enrichment
to the community at large.
Courtesy BChsJs
BCHSJS students are ‘super’ callers
Sunday, BCHSJS Bergen County High Northern New Jersey’s Super Sunday.
School of Jewish Studies students Super Sunday is JFNNJ’s largest phone-a-
including Annabelle Simhon, left, and thon — a day when volunteers, donors,
Brianna Leopold, joined its principal, and community leaders come together
Fred Nagler, right, and board members, to make a difference.
to make calls at Jewish Federation of
Courtesy BChsJs
B
T
A
SUN
IT
Enjoy an afternoon of fun camp activities including
LLOON M
O
GL
N
sports, dance, drama, art, science, technology, as
FEB 4
BO
well as glitter tattoos, balloon artists, and more!
Meet our camp directors and camp specialists, and
1-3 PM
UN C E
A
explore all the incredible summer opportunities for
K
I
N
toddlers thru teens.
G
i l y
only discounts!
Fam
Sun, Feb 4, 1-3 pm,
FREE and open to the community
ACTIVITI
P E
M
See Phil & Chris Simms Live at the J
S
CA
AT OUR 1ST ANNUAL SPORTS NIGHT OF CHAMPIONS!
F UN
Wear your team jersey and join us for a fun evening
with strolling dinner and live auction featuring
priceless sports experiences, awards, and more.
Tuesday, February 13, 6 pm
For tickets visit jccotp.org/sportsnight
TODAY
Bergen County Academies, Hackensack
Visit jccotp.org/gom for tickets
The Gift of Music was established by Drs. Joan and Alan Handler
The Leonard & Syril Rubin Nursery Social Adult Day Care for People Saturday Night Zumba Party
School Registration is Open! with Alzheimer’s and Dementia FOR AGES 12+, BEGINNERS WELCOME
AGES 3 MONTHS-KINDERGARTEN KAPLEN ADULT REACH CENTER Your feet will feel as light as air when you dance with
Your child will enjoy a solid foundation Montessori-style social day care program us at our FREE annual cardio fitness event at the J.
of education and exploration in a warm promotes independence, self-esteem and Expert instructors lead a fun Zumba Party featuring
environment, with a developmentally- cognitive abilities for those living with dementia, Latin, African, hip-hop, and pop music.
appropriate, child-centered approach to in a vibrant, community center atmosphere. Sat, Feb 10, 7:30 pm,
learning, and a progressive curriculum Aides and companions are welcome. FREE and open to the community
rooted in Jewish values. Half day, full day Mon-Fri, 9 am-4 pm, Sun, 11 am-4 pm
and extended day (7:30 am-6 pm) options (Partial day options available)
available. TO REGISTER OR FOR MORE INFO
Ask for a FREE 3 day trial!
Open House: Feb 9, 9 am
For more information visit jccotp.org/senior-
VISIT jccotp.org
Schedule a tour today! Contact Elissa Yurowitz services or contact Judi Nahary at 201.408.1450 STAY IN THE KNOW! LIKE US ON
at 201.408.1436 or [email protected] facebook.com/KaplenJCCOTP
KAPLEN JCC on the Palisades TAUB CAMPUS | 411 E CLINTON AVE, TENAFLY, NJ 07670 | 201.569.7900 | jccotp.org
JEWISH STANDARD FEBRUARY 2, 2018 21
22 JEWISH STANDARD FEBRUARY 2, 2018
Cover Story
Putting out
fires
Sinai School’s honoree, featured in video,
talks about his trajectory from rage to the
IDF to Tel Aviv’s fire department
Y
Joanne Palmer therapists, its teachers and counselors Few students come to Sinai with Yaa- take care of her children, and then, eight
and administrators, see each child as com- kov’s history, and so far none have come months after his brother-in-law died, Mr.
aakov Guttman’s life has pletely individual. Because it is based on to them who have made Yaakov’s career Saks died too.
been about putting out and housed in day schools, it models both choices, but every student who comes to Yaakov had been in a mainstream day
fires, both metaphorically inclusion and specificity, both community Sinai is different from every other student school, but his learning issues, now com-
and literally. and individuality. there. (In fact, of course, every student bined with a burning anger, made it hard
We understand that the The children Sinai serves come to the who comes to every other school in the for him to do the work. “I hated school,”
word literal often doesn’t school with different needs. Some of them world is different from every other stu- he said. “I really just hated everything. I
mean literal any more, but here we are are visible — some students have physi- dent there, but it is easier to generalize an withdrew from everything. I just hated
using it in its classic sense. Yaakov Gutt- cal disabilities, and some have the sort of education when there are no special needs everything.”
man runs into burning buildings, rescues developmental delays that make them- adding another layer of complication.) So, he said, “My mom and the educators
people, and even their pets, and fights the selves obvious to most careful observers Yaakov Guttman was born in Bergenfield thought it would be best for me to go to
fire until it is out. Most of us run away from pretty quickly. in 1984, the second of four children. When Sinai.”
fires. He runs toward them. And then some come to Sinai as Yaakov he was 10, his father, Sruli, died suddenly, Sinai was a different place then too, he
You look at him now and you see a pro- did, with dyslexia and ADD, issues that are collapsing as his wife, Shelly, and their said; “there were maybe four or five of us
totypical firefighter, not only strong but expressed through behavior but can be children looked on, wheeled out by med- who had learning disabilities, and we just
also handsome, a firefighter straight out of and often are misdiagnosed, misunder- ics as they watched. His mother’s brother, needed a lot of extra education and then
central casting. But the truth of his life is stood, and mistreated. Jeffrey Saks, helped his grief-stricken sister we’d be fine.” Now, Sinai educators know
more complicated than that. Long before
he was able to fight literal fires, Yaakov had
to fight the metaphorical ones that burned
inside him.
He was an angry child, battling both
learning disabilities and personal tragedy.
Sinai Schools is featuring Yaakov in this
year’s video; it will premier at the school’s
annual dinner later this month (see box).
This video is different from Sinai’s other
documentaries. Usually those videos fea-
ture close-ups of faces, faces with emo-
tions clear on them, delicate, intimate
shots of despair and hope and transfor-
mation. Those videos are beautiful, pro-
foundly moving, deeply true.
But what Sinai does is take children with
a wide range of special needs and tailor
the education each of them needs specifi-
cally to that child. There is no one model
for education at Sinai; its range of art
and music and speech and occupational Yaakov’s unit stands in front of its truck at one of Tel Aviv-Yaffo’s fire stations.
1.85 1.70
Choose the
% APY
account that’s
right for you.
% APY
APY**
1.25%
Money Market
Great Rate & APY
100% Liquid for balances of
$2,500 and up**
Visit our Monsey branch today! 75 Route 59, Monsey Town Square (Evergreen Kosher Market Center)
Anita Levine, VP, Branch Manager • 845-425-0189
Open Sunday from 9AM - 1PM
Annual Percentage Yields (APYs) disclosed are effective as of 1/16/2018 and may be changed by the Bank at any time. *CDs require a $1,000 minimum balance
to open and earn interest. Early withdrawal penalty may apply. CDs must be opened in person at an Apple Bank branch. **For the Apple Bank Money Market Ac-
count, interest earned on daily balances of $2,500 or more at these tiers: $2,500-$24,999: 1.25% APY, $25,000-$49,999: 1.25% APY, $50,000-$74,999: 1.25% APY,
$75,000 or more: 1.25% APY. There is no interest paid on balances between $1-$2,499. $100 minimum deposit required to open account. $2,500 minimum daily Established 1863 · Member FDIC
balance required to avoid $10 monthly maintenance fee. A combined $3,000,000 maximum deposit per household applies to the Apple Bank Money Market
Account. A household is defined as a family residing at the same address. Fees may reduce earnings. Offer may be withdrawn at any time without prior notice. www.applebank.com
3 24apple
Jewish Standard
bk - JEWISH FEBRUARY
STANDARD - CD-MONEY 2, 2018
MARKET - EFF DATE 1-16-18.indd 1 1/17/2018 4:31:42 PM
Cover Story
and said ‘Holy cow, this is great!’” he her supervision. later he was drafted into the RAF.” That was still during the
said. “I just did it, and it was just, ‘Okay Yaakov was at Sinai from fifth through British Mandate.
already, yalla, this is fine, let’s go on to ninth grades (with a one-semester failed Mr. Saks’ father had gone to the United States at some point,
the next thing now.” attempt at mainstreaming at the begin- his grandson recounted, and therefore the son had U.S. citi-
As Sam Fishman, Sinai’s managing ning of ninth grade). After that, he went on zenship. “The RAF knew about his time in the Haganah, and
director, said, “Perhaps in hindsight, to MTA, and graduated from high school they told him ‘You could go to America — or you could go to
had we gotten Yaakov in first grade there. jail.’ So he went to America.”
rather than in fifth, it would have been After high school, he went on a gap year Yaakov reversed that move.
easier, but it is what it is. program in Israel, and there his life changed After his year in a yeshiva, “I stayed in Israel, and I went into
“When we got him, he had com- once again. the army on August 24, 2004,” he said.
pletely shut down. He was not func- “Growing up, my plans were to join the “I went through the Machal program,” he said. Machal —
tioning in a regular environment any Navy Seals,” Yaakov said. “A friend of mine the Hebrew acronym for Mitnadvei Hutz LaAretz, volunteers
more. The way our educators describe Judi Karp — who just retired from the Seals after a from other countries — was the main program for what today
it, we have a lot of kids who are in pain 14-year stint there — and I were going to go are called lone soldiers. “There wasn’t a lot of help for lone
by the time they get to us, because they are dealing with together.” soldiers then,” he said. But Rabbi Yehoshua Fass, the head of
the emotional issues that come from not fitting in. We But some of the rabbis who taught him in high school Nefesh B’Nefesh, was a mentor, role model, and inspiration
are good at dealing with children who are hurting, and suggested that he go to Israel first, and his mother
we thank God that we were able to break through to agreed. “And my girlfriend at the time also was pushing
Yaakov.” this religious card on me,” Yaakov said. “So I said maybe
Mr. Fishman said that what Ms. Karp was able to teach
Yaakov, along with how to read, was that “we were not
there is something there.” So he went to Israel.
When he was in Israel, Yaakov’s desire to join the
seasonal promotions
Tables & Chairs - all sizes, all styles
going to give up on him. You should never give up on a America military morphed into the dream to join the
child.” Israel Defense Forces. “I always wanted to be in the mili- Tables & Chairs - all sizes, all styles
Now, Yaakov relies on his body, as well as his brain; tary,” he said. “It is a passion of mine. There is a greater
his physicality is one of his main assets as a firefighter. calling when you can serve your country, and serve the Traditional. Modern.
Then, though, “our educators who knew him said that Jewish nation.
he was like a lost and angry child in an enormous body,” “My father was an ish chesed,” a man who did good Contemporary.
Abigail Hepner Gross, Sinai’s director of communica- works, an inherently good man. “He emanated chesed
tions, said. “He was very big for his age, and he had a in the community.
tough, intimidating exterior, but they all say that under- “My dad never talked about what he did to help peo-
neath that surface was mush. He was such a loving, kind ple. He was a food distributor, and he never talked about
boy, protective of other students — a wonderful boy — helping to run Tomchei Shabbat at Roemer.
but he put up a terrible show. “He never talked about any of what he did, but he just
“And he was so big.” helped people. And after he died, and people didn’t get
His size helped him at Sinai in Kushner, Mr. Fishman the chesed, then they realized. That’s the best way to do
said. “By the time that Yaakov was beginning to trust us, chesed — keep your mouth closed, and just do it. Don’t
and to advance educationally, he was invited to join the talk about it. Don’t do it for the glory. Just do it.
mainstream basketball team at Kushner. Despite all the “I can never hit my dad’s level, but I figured that
other issues, he was big, and he was well-coordinated. what I could do is use my strengths. I have very specific
He was a natural. So he went on to become the star of strengths — my physical ability, and my mental capacity
the team, and that did so much for his self-esteem, to to push through hardships. That’s something you need
find something that he was really good at. in the military.”
“He had other kids look up at him, both figuratively He also felt history and destiny calling to him. His
and literally.” connection to Israel wasn’t only metaphor. It was very
Mr. Fishman has good reason to know a great deal personal.
about Yaakov Guttman, and Ms. Hepner Gross has even Yaakov’s mother’s father, Avi Saks, was born in Pal-
more reason; the two of them made the video together, estine around 1912, Yaakov said, “and I believe that he
as they have made all the school’s videos for many years, was a third-generation Yerushalmi. I would have been a
and last summer Ms. Gross went to Israel to oversee the fifth-generation Israeli. He was born in Mea Shearim, he
filming there. The firefighting footage was made under fought in the Haganah when he was 14 or 15, and then
908.583.6109
2500 Brunswick Avenue
Bldg 908.583.6109
H, Linden, NJ 07036
2500 Brunswick Avenue
www.uniqueelegantseating.com
Bldg uniqueelegantseating
H, Linden, NJ 07036
www.uniqueelegantseating.com
uniqueelegantseating
Decorators & Designers Welcome!
While he was at Sinai, Yaakov was a star of the Joseph Kushner Hebrew Academy’s basketball team.
Decorators & Designers Welcome!
Jewish Standard FEBRUARY 2, 2018 25
Cover Story
jccotp.org/familyfunday
Sun
l y
free and open to the Community
i
Feb 4
am
1-3 pm er C
ampS
F
m
n Sum
SKi
K l at
eil
b yn
ed ie
Sor vit s
Spon ti
c tt oos
ta
a
r &
p
e
ca m
b
t
it
al
Gl
l o on
fun
m
a
k
in
Enjoy an afternoon of fun camp activities including sports, dance, G
m
drama, art, science, and technology. A great way to meet our camp team o
and find out about all the incredible summer opportunities the JCC offers.
o
n
bounc
• Sign up for 2 or more weeks of specialty camps & get $50 off per week!
• Sign up for an annual JCC Family Membership & receive $200 in JCC Cash!
• All attendees will be entered to win 1 week of camp free!!!
Offers valid February 4th only.
Kaplen JCC on the Palisades taub CampuS | 411 e Clinton ave, tenafly, nJ 07670 | 201.567.8963
Yaakov and his IDF unit. Yaakov Guttman was a sniper commander in the IDF.
for other people. for a short time, looking for his path, but his the Arab quarter of the Old City, doing “I was doing that, and at the same time I
“Some people are okay with working 9 heart was in Israel, and soon he was back. undercover security,” he said. “It was a was trying to get into the fire department.”
to 5, putting food on the table, and hav- But he was back with a goal. He had real- very interesting dynamic. I was respon- Israel’s fire department is centralized,
ing great houses and great cars, but that ized that he really wanted to use his gifts, sible for helping the police and taking and it has been since the Carmel fires in
wasn’t what I was looking for. I made ali- passion, and desire to help others as a fire care of the people we worked for. Most of 2010, Yaakov said; you join that main
yah for a reason. Not to make money, but fighter. Now he just had to figure out how the time it was Ateret Cohanim, a yeshiva body, and then you are assigned to a spe-
to make a difference. And God gave me to reach that goal. based in the Arab shuk. We did security cific place. “It is a boys club,” he said.
certain gifts. I know how to use my hands.” “I moved back to Jerusalem, and I for them and the other Jewish residents “Guys bring in guys they know and trust.
Yaakov moved back to the United States worked for a private security firm in in the Old City. It’s a very close-knit group.
Arnold P. Gold
Dearest Sandra,
We share together with you and your family, the sadness
our music school community feels on the loss of your beloved Arnold.
May you find comfort from the many people you have touched in creating
a music school at the Kaplen JCC on the Palisades.
With love,
“At the time, I didn’t know anybody. I didn’t and between parents and grandparents
know anything. I didn’t have any connec- about how to treat it.
tions. But I worked very hard, I broke down “And often parents wonder if they
a lot of doors, I called people and went for are doing everything they can to help
interviews and asked and talked and talked their child. That is a lot of pressure.
and talked and went at it as best I could. They think ‘I take my kid to all of the
“I started volunteering in the Herzlia fire therapies I possibly can — spend all that
department in 2012, and that helped me money, all that time — and I still am ask-
break down the door. Those guys helped me. ing myself if I’m doing the right thing.’
“Five years after I started trying, I got “There is a lot of pressure. There is a
accepted. In March 2014. Just by being a lot at stake. Parents come to us with a
stubborn horse. lot of hopes and dreams.”
“When you have a dream, if you really So Yaakov’s story is both unique and
believe in it, you have to go forward and get basic. “The underlying theme to the
it,” Yaakov said. “My mom and my dad and story is the power of community,” Rabbi
my mentors, they gave me that example. Rothwachs said. “Here you have a fam-
“Everyone told me to forget it, to give up, ily unit that was terribly shocked, and
to try to do something else, and I did try the community came together in lots of
other things. I worked at other places, I did different ways to make sure that Shelly
every blue collar job you could imagine, but and Yaakov and all the children had all
I was always working at it.” the support they needed.”
Why does he love fighting fires? “In the Dahlia and Yaakov Guttman are the glowing parents of one-year-old Jon Jon. One of the lessons of Yaakov’s story
police, you deal with some very bad people, is that you can’t always look at a child
and you have to arrest them, and God forbid “It is about saving lives, helping people, The fire department actually is fire and know that he has problems, or what
you have to use your weapon. In the military not hurting them. I want to be able to turn and rescue, he added. “We also do things those problems might be. You also can’t
you have to use your weapon. In fire fight- around in 40 years and say that I made a dif- like get cats out of trees. We rescue dogs look at a child and know what his prom-
ing, you’re just saving people’s lives. There ference,” Yaakov said. that have fallen into holes, and people ise is, what his potential is, or where
can be a downside, if you lose a victim, if you He works in the fire department in Tel who are too drunk to find their keys. We his path might take him. Sinai Schools
can’t get to someone in time, if you show up Aviv; most of his work is with urban fires, rescue anything that has a soul.” knows that. But Sinai also knows that it is
and the person is already dead, but you are although he is deployed to fight wildfires He is married, “and my wife is my big- only if you understand that every child,
just going to be doing good. too, when it is necessary. gest supporter, and she is always behind no matter how angry or withdrawn or
me, saying ‘Don’t worry. You can do it!” troubled, has potential, that you possi-
His wife, Dahlia, is a graphic designer; bly can begin to unearth it.
Yaakov and Dahlia are the parents of Or, as Yaakov put it, when he was diag-
a one-year-old, Jon Jon, “the cutest, nosed with dyslexia and ADD, “I could
smiley-est kid in the world,” Yaakov have said ‘I have dyslexia and ADD, and
said. “He just smiles all the time. Noth- boo hoo, cry me a river,’ or I could have
ing bothers him. My wife is an amazing said ‘I have dyslexia and ADD, and I can
mother.” The family lives in Raanana. use it to my advantage.’
Rabbi Dr. Yisrael Rothwachs is Sinai’s “I was very skilled at social skills. And
dean. He came to the school after Yaa- then later I decided to face my crap and
kov left, but he sees Yaakov Guttman’s start doing something with it.
life trajectory as impressive, at the same “If I can give any message to people,
time specific and symbolic. it’s that we all have issues. We all have
“Yaakov’s story is anomalous — and it problems. But the people who will suc-
isn’t,” Rabbi Rothwachs said. “What he ceed are the people who can stand up
had to overcome, both the special needs and face them.
and the biography, and then going into “All you need is a little bit of cour-
the IDF and then becoming a commander age and drive. You don’t have to be the
of a unit there and then becoming a fire- smartest. You don’t have to be the most
fighter — all that is unique and anomalous. talented. I wasn’t. I’m not the greatest at
“On the other hand, we have many anything. But what I did is that I said, ‘All
At Brightview we believe everyone thrives on fun, social, and intellectual stimulation. In that spirit
students who look different and have right. It is time to man up.’ And that is
Brightview Tenafly is sponsoring a series of “Community Lectures” aimed at helping families aging different profiles and biographical what it takes to succeed.
with seniors navigating through Dementia. This month’s lecture will be held on February 7th at sketches, and who come to our school “At Sinai, I learned how to overcome,
6:30PM in the Private Dining Room.
with so many challenges and with so and that gave me a foundation for the
“Feeding the Heart: Maintaining Physical and Emotional Health” much potential. With so much promise. rest of my life,” Yaakov Guttman said.
Presenter: Stacey Maines, MSW, Care Manager at Generations Counseling & Care Management, LLC
It is hard for them to take those steps —
Stacey Maines received her Master of Social Work from New York University in 1998. She started
to make friends, to become a leader. Who: Yaakov Guttman is among the
her career as a Director of Social Services in various long term care systems throughout northern “Life is about taking risks, but so many honorees
New Jersey on a full time and consulting basis. She had a private practice as a geriatric care of our students have been burnt. Many
manager for several years prior to joining the team at GENERATIONS in January 2015. What: At the Sinai School’s annual
of our students have had so many years benefit dinner
of failure before they come to us.”
When: On Sunday, February 25; the
Few families face the dramatic chal- buffet opens at 4:45 and the pro-
Please RSVP to Richard or
lenges that the Guttmans had to deal gram starts at 6:30
Lindsay by February 6th
with, but the strains of having special- Where: At the Marriott Glenpointe
[email protected]
needs children often harm families. Hotel in Teaneck
[email protected] There are many strains, among them
201.510.2060
Why: To honor the school and to
“the financial and the social,” Rabbi raise funds to support it
Rothwachs said. “It can be embarrassing
For more information and reservations,
for parents to go out, and often there are
go to or call (201) 833-1134, ext. 105.
familial disagreements between spouses
P R E D I C T A B L E
Israel implements
‘gradual reopening’ Scarpa
of embassy in Jordan
Israel is implementing the reopening of its embassy in
Jordan this week, after the Israeli and Jordanian gov-
ernments earlier in January announced an agreement
to restore the diplomatic office. The embassy had
been closed since July 2017, when an Israeli security
guard at the site fatally shot two Jordanians in what the
Israeli government described as an act of self-defense.
The guard, Ziv Moyal, shot a Jordanian who attacked
him with a screwdriver, and a second Jordanian was
killed by a stray bullet. As part of the compromise to BORO PARK: FLATBUSH: LONG ISLAND: LAKEWOOD: TEANECK:
restart full diplomatic relations, Israel was forced to
apologize for the incident as well as a previous inci- 5020 13th Avenue 1505 Coney Island Ave. 467 Central Avenue 1700 Madison Ave. 215 W. Englewood Ave.
dent involving the killing of a Jordanian judge at an 718.972.4665 718.676.7706 516.295.5006 732.987.9480 201.530.7300
Sunday & Legal Holidays 10-6 Sunday & Legal Holidays 10-6 Sunday & Legal Holidays 10-6 Sunday & Legal Holidays 10-6 Mon-Thurs 10-9
Mon-Wed 10-7 Mon-Wed 10-7 Mon, Tues & Thurs 10-7 Mon-Thurs 10-7 Fri 10-2
Thurs 10-8, Fri 10-2 Thurs 10-9, Fri 10-2 Wed 10-9, Fri 10-2 Fri 10-1:30 Closed Sunday
116 Main Street, Fort Lee by getting the lights on, the water flowing & the econ- one of the recently uncovered terror tunnels while on
116 201.947.2500 omy growing. Hamas spews hateful rhetoric & foments a tour of the Israel-Gaza border, led by IDF’s Coordina-
3493212-01
Main Street, Fort Lee a vicious cycle of violence. Gaza deserves better!” tor of Government Activities in the Territories, Maj. Gen.
www.inapoli.com
201.947.2500
3493212-01
Greenblatt also demanded that three Israeli civilians Yoav Mordechai. JNS.ORG
www.inapoli.com
Registration OPEN!
WARM,
CHILD-CENTERED
preschool with a
PROGRESSIVE
curriculum rooted in
JEWISH VALUES Enroll today! OPEN HOUSE: FEB 9, 9 AM
PROGRAM CURRICULUM INCLUDES:
• Reading & math readiness skills • Judaic programming
• Logical thinking & problem solving skills • Art, music, dramatic play & cooking
• Social & emotional growth • Gym & swimming
• Fine & gross motor skills • Preparation for Kindergarten & beyond
• Sensory experiences
KAPLEN JCC on the Palisades TAUB CAMPUS | 411 E CLINTON AVE, TENAFLY, NJ 07670 | 201.569.7900 | jccotp.org
32 Jewish Standard FEBRUARY 2, 2018
Jewish Standard FEBRUARY 2, 2018 33
Jewish World/Purim
PRESENTS
gorz Schetyna, said that Ukrainians, not Russians, lib- ance Center here honoring the 75th anniversary of the Jewish people’s history and led to their having “a strong
erated the Nazi death camp in Poland. Sobibor Uprising, a prisoners’ rebellion at the death camp country with considerable offensive capabilities that can
Appreciation for Israel’s recognition of Russia’s role in northeastern Poland where 11 Nazis were killed and 300 defend itself against fanatics who openly say they aim to
in defeating Nazism “is especially important amid the Jews escaped. destroy us. They won’t succeed. But we need to under-
destruction and desecration of monuments to Soviet It provided the perfect backdrop for Netanyahu’s stand the danger they pose is not limited to us, but you,
soldiers who gave their lives to liberate prisoners of thinly veiled warnings of Israel’s low tolerance for Iranian too.”
Nazi concentration camps, and save Europe and the threats. He ended his speech with these words: “There will not
entire world from Nazism,” Putin said. “If you don’t check hatred toward Jews, it will spread be another Holocaust.”
The politics of memory, as they are called in this to other peoples quickly enough,” Netanyahu said, invok- JTA WIRE SERVICE
part of the world, command an importance that ing the lessons of the Holocaust. “Our mission is to fight
may surprise outsiders. Struggling with stagnant or
ruined economies amid rampant corruption, some of
these countries might seem to have more immediate
AMAZINGARTSCROL SHASSALE
challenges.
But these issues are of major importance to mil-
lions of voters across Eastern Europe. Case in point:
the international outcry that followed Poland’s passing
Friday of a controversial bill to criminalize the term VOTED #1 JUDAICA BOOKSTORE AND GIFTSHOP BY THE JVA
“Polish death camps” and frank discussions of Polish
complicity in the Holocaust. Join Us For Our Annual Book & Seforim SALE!
30OFF!
By recognizing that such gestures are as important
%
to Russia as, say, declarations about Jerusalem are to
Israel, Netanyahu is leveraging Israel’s authoritative
voice internationally on Holocaust commemoration
issues to curry favor with Moscow.
“We never forget the crucial role of the Red Army
in halting the Nazi machine,” Netanyahu said in his
speech at the Jewish museum, addressing Putin. “You
mentioned the monument in Israel: I initiated its erec-
tion in Netanya as a symbol of the appreciation we THE INTERNATIONAL
think must be eternalized for the Red Army,” Netan-
BEST SELLER “A YIDDISHE KOP”
yahu said.
Under Netanyahu, Israel has done more for Russia
NOW PART II. AVAILABLE!
than erect a monument. LIST PRICE... $29.99
Almost alone among Western nations, the Jewish
DURING SALE 30% OFF!
state has essentially maintained total radio silence,
and therefore neutrality, on the invasion of Ukraine, Every Book! Every Sefer! The Perfect Afikomen
FUL -SIZE SET list price $2,9 9 FUL -SIZE SET list price $2,650
ister said he would talk to Putin about Iran’s involve-
ment in Lebanon, which Netanyahu said Iran was
turning into a “missile base” to be used against Israel.
SALE Sunday, Feb. 4th thru Sunday, Feb. 18th
Putin is not the only one in the relationship who 478 Cedar Lane, Teaneck, NJ · www.judaicahouse.net · (201) 801-9001
JEWISH STANDARD FEBRUARY 2, 2018 35
Keeping Kosher
Food and wine show in Manhattan
is prepping for big turnouts
E
nthusiastic crowds are expected at the KFWE is sponsored by New Jersey-based
12th annual Kosher Food & Wine Expe- Royal Wine Corp. The Royal Wine Corp. is the
rience New York on Monday, February largest producer, importer, and distributor
5, at Pier 60, Chelsea Piers (23rd Street of kosher wines and spirits in the world. New
and the West Side Highway in Manhattan). Doors York’s premier kosher event of the year will
open to the public at 6:30 p.m. showcase some 700 intriguing kosher wines
Visitors to the KFWE will savor the latest in fine and spirits from around the world. A high-
kosher wines, spirits, and creative cuisine from light of KFWENY will be the release of high-
top local kosher caterers, restaurateurs, and end wines from the exceptional 2015 vintage
PHOTO PROVIDED
gourmet specialty companies. in Bordeaux.
Among the featured products are new wines for For more information, go to thekfwe.com.
Passover, and kosher for Passover LVOV vodka dis-
tilled from beets and tequila from wild agave. From last year’s KFWE.
Choose a Delicious
deliver a tasty punch of vitamin C, iron,
fiber, magnesium, and other elements
essential for good health. It is also deli-
cious served chilled on its own.
You’ll also need a strategy for guests Fresh Salad from our Menu
or Create Your Own
who aren’t into mixed drinks. Keep some Beetology Blends and Joyvin Sangria
crisp sangria on hand to serve straight up together can make drinks for the big
or garnished with a few pieces of fruit. game fun and refreshing. This year,
Joyvin Sangria, from Royal Wine, is a sat- serve your guests versatile beverages,
isfying sip of fresh citrus and berries with alone or mixed together.
just a touch of fizz for some festive fun.
S
husband and I went began by asking everyone to sing
to Congregation Beth a niggun; he said that he does the haina, these are my last words to you Today, you have been chosen by Moshe to
Sholom’s annual Shabbaton. same thing at his seminary classes. as the most important man in your stand together beneath the chuppah. The
It was our fifth year there, and for Those niggunim break down the life. In a few moments, it will be your ancient rabbis say that a chuppah is also a rec-
the fifth time we marveled at what wall between the mysticism he husband who replaces me. reation of Eden, which is why it is covered in
one congregation can do. teaches and the dispassion of the When you were born, your mother and I beautiful flowers and other natural ornaments.
In between meals in the social students. It does not remove the named you Shaina Brocha, and you have been That is especially poignant because today is
hall and davening in the syna- analytic content but it shows by just that, a beautiful blessing to us throughout Tu b’Shvat, the Jewish new year for trees. In
gogue and music by the choir and example that passion and intellect your life. But now, under the chuppah, you a sense, you are both the primordial couple:
the children’s choir and the cantor, can work together, and that study- will embrace a new future with your married Moshe, you are the first man, and you, Shaina,
the shul’s talented and charismatic ing works best when it joins heart, soul mate. are Eve, the first woman, in this new world
music director, Ronit Wolff Hanan, mind, and soul. It’s an amazing thing that parents put on you both are building. Together, you are ful-
there were classes, all taught by I took a session taught by Dr. Ben parties called weddings to celebrate their filling the biblical injunction that a man must
Beth Sholom members, a wild Sommer, who teaches Bible at JTS. newly minted secondary status to their chil- leave his father and mother, marry, and “they
range of opportunities presented by We looked at some psalms, focusing dren. It is humbling for parents to be forced shall become one flesh.”
scholars who are good teachers to a on the switch many have between to acknowledge that they cannot provide what Seeing you join a fine young man with
group of students, their peers, who the plea with which they begin and their child seeks most in life, which is not to be whom you will build a life makes me feel like
also are also breathtakingly smart the thanks to God that end them. loved but to be chosen. I have reversed some of the wounds I have
and well-educated, comfortable Is that switch internal, as most tra- Love makes us feel protected. endured as a child of divorce. I
in their practices and knowledge, ditional scholars say, or is it exter- But chosenness makes us feel have been given the privilege of
happy to be together, eager to make nal, a function of the way in which special. To be loved is to be seeing love come alive from my
their brains work. psalms were used at the temples cherished. To be chosen is to own flesh and blood.
It is, to be clear, not a model that once stood before the system be rendered irreplaceable. Love In the Torah, we learn that
that many synagogues can follow. was centralized in Jerusalem? And is warm. But chosenness is Adam and Eve owned absolutely
Beth Sholom has what probably is before he did that session in Eng- electrifying. nothing, not even clothing. And
an intimidating number of rabbis lish, Dr. Sommer also presented it Your wedding falls during the yet they found paradise in each
— people say about 30 — and Jew- in Hebrew, and more than 15 peo- Torah reading of Yitro, with its other. Their only possession was
ish professionals among its mem- ple joined him. recounting of the giving of the love, and they reveled in the full-
bers. Many of them work at the I also went to a session by Dr. Torah at Mt. Sinai. At that place, Rabbi ness that their companionship
Jewish Theological Seminary, right Steve Garfinkle, who gave us texts God selected the Jews as His cho- Shmuley provided. Adam, whose first
over the bridge from the shul. And showing the interplay of ancient sen people. The Jewish wedding Boteach emotion, the Torah says, was
those rabbis and Jewish profes- near eastern concepts with the ceremony reflects that awesome loneliness, discovered fulfill-
sionals have attracted other inter- Jewish concepts we know, point- experience, with the groom wait- ment in the wife at his side, and
ested, well-educated, serious Jews ing out both the similarities and ing under the canopy for his bride, just as God Eve, too, found happiness in her penniless
to the community. the differences that make our own waited for the Israelites with thunder and light- husband.
Beth Sholom also is an answer tradition Jewish. ning. And the bride and groom stand under We commemorate that tradition till today
to the critics of the Conserva- It was all so very smart! the chuppah, just as God, according to legend, by having a bridegroom empty his pockets
tive movement, who say that it’s And those were just three of draped Mt. Sinai over the Jewish nation as a prior to his arrival at the chuppah, so that his
middle-of-the-road, boring, not the 30 or so courses on offer. The sign of protection. And then he uttered the wife accepts him for who he is without any
authentic enough for the modern hardest part of the entire Shabba- Ten Commandments, with the first two being accouterments. With Eve believing in him,
Orthodox world on its right and ton, in fact, was deciding which to the very essence of marriage: Adam gained confidence. He felt his existence
too stodgy and tradition-bound for go to, because that meant deciding I am the Lord Your God. You shall have was sufficient to make his wife blissful. She
the Reform Jews on its left. What I which to skip. no other Gods before me. Make me the One. laughed at his jokes. She snuggled at his side.
see is a shul glorying in both tradi- And of course it was fueled not Make me the Only. Eve, too, felt desirable and essential. She truly
tion and scholarship, which means only by food and song, but also by In marriage we choose each other by giving was Adam’s one and only. There was no one
that it is open to new ideas and new cookies. So very many cookies! So each other primacy and exclusivity. When it else in the entire world to distract him, and
understandings, always marinated much chocolate. comes to love there can be many. But when it he loved her with every molecule of his being.
in the tradition but also spiced by The Conservative movement comes to being chosen there can be only one. Last summer, Shaina, our family embarked
science and open to art. might be in trouble in some places,
My husband went to a session but it is flourishing at Beth Sholom. Shmuley Boteach has written books, including “Kosher Sex” and “Ten Conversations You Need to
on Nachman of Bratzlav taught by —JP Have with Yourself.” Follow him on Twitter @RabbiShmuley.
Jewish Editor
Joanne Palmer
Correspondents
Warren Boroson
Advertising Coordinator
Jane Carr
Production Manager
Jerry Szubin
Founder
Morris J. Janoff (1911–1987)
Standard Associate Editor
Larry Yudelson
Lois Goldrich
Banji Ganchrow Account Executives
Peggy Elias
Graphic Artists
Deborah Herman
Editor Emeritus
Meyer Pesin (1901–1989)
1086 Teaneck Road Abigail K. Leichman Bob O'Brien
Community Editor Miriam Rinn Brenda Sutcliffe City Editor
Teaneck, NJ 07666
Beth Janoff Chananie Dr. Miryam Z. Wahrman Administrative Assistant Mort Cornin (1915–1984)
(201) 837-8818
Fax 201-833-4959 About Our Children Editor Advertising Director Jenna Sutcliffe Editorial Consultant
Heidi Mae Bratt Natalie D. Jay Max Milians (1908-2005)
Publisher International Media Placement
James L. Janoff Classified Director P.O. Box 7195 Jerusalem 91077 Secretary
Janice Rosen Tel: 02-6252933, 02-6247919 Ceil Wolf (1914-2008)
Associate Publisher Emerita
Marcia Garfinkle Fax: 02-6249240 Editor Emerita
Israeli Representative Rebecca Kaplan Boroson
thejewishstandard.com
T
much to bear, as we traveled to Auschwitz, Maidanek,
Treblinka, and Dachau. By the time we reached Buda- he NBC series “This Is Us” has become a ritual they must visit Germany. My father’s response was cordial
pest, the capital of a country that saw 500,000 Jews in our home. It is reminiscent of “Thirtysome- yet direct. “I will go if you will take me to the lampshade and
murdered in just five months, your younger sister, thing” in its cadence and examination of relation- soap factories.”
Rochel Leah, said to you, “This is shaking my relation- ships, which may not be surprising considering The executive was stunned into silence.
ship with God, who remained silent while so many that Ken Olin, one of the main actors from “Thirtysome- From that moment on, this senior executive would work
innocents perished.” And you responded, “But we did thing,” is a director and executive producer on the series. with no one but my father, even though two of the part-
not come to these places for God. We came to remem- Rather than exploring friendships, however, the overarch- ners were of German heritage, and one had been born in
ber the lost six million, so that they are never forgot- ing storyline in the current series primarily is focused on the Germany. This man respected my father. He, like my dad,
- ten. Even if it causes momentary distance from God.” Pearson family. Jack and Rebecca Pearson are the parents of had lived through World War II, and from this interaction
It was then that I knew that you had absorbed the triplets — Randall, Kevin, and Kate. Randall was adopted but he understood that my father was principled and couldn’t
. central lesson in the life of Moses. When he receives born on the same day as Kevin and Kate (and to get more be bought, either as an American or as a Jew. They both
the Torah in this week’s parsha, events quickly spiral details, you will need to tune in). Right now, fans are waiting knew that a luxury car meant nothing compared to Mer-
out of control, as the Jews build and worship a golden for an episode that will air immediately after the Super Bowl cedes’ support of the Nazi dictatorship and exploitation of
: calf. Rather than preserving the Torah, Moses quickly that finally will reveal how Jack, their dad and Rebecca’s hus- forced laborers.
, destroys the Ten Commandments so the Jews cannot band, died just before the kids finished high school. This Think about how the world would be different if we
be held accountable for a law which they have now episode should result in impressive ratings. spoke about countries having respect for each other. What
- broken. He puts the people before God. In the most recent episode, the brothers were talking about respect deals rather than peace deals? Sound silly?
t And God loves him for it. Because a parent loves his about mortality, and Randall made the point that they now When is the last time you heard of someone who willfully
y children more than he loves himself. have lived longer without their father than they had with murdered someone they held in esteem? How different
The Lubavitcher rebbe, too, lived by this maxim, so him. Seems like a simple, almost throwaway line but the might the world be if governments respected their peo-
often arguing with God in front of thousands of people gravity of this simple statement of fact is palpable if this is ple’s opposing opinions rather than suppressing them
at his public discourses, demanding that God send the part of your own life story. with the threat of terror and murder, as we see in too many
Messiah and put a permanent end to human suffering. My dad died suddenly just as I finished my sophomore year countries around the world, from Iran to Cuba and Russia,
I I knew then, in Europe, surrounded by all this hor- in college. His death was so unexpected that his to name just a few?
f ror, that its remedy lay in God finding you your soul own doctor was in as much disbelief as were And what about standing up together
y mate, with whom you could rebuild the destroyed we. And though life continued, there is not a as American Jews, calling out anyone who
house of Israel. After we returned, just a few weeks day that I don’t think of my father and all the stands with the anti-Semitic, anti-American,
t later, you began dating Moshe, a young Chabad sha- lessons he taught my brothers and me in those racist leader of the Nation of Islam, Louis
y liach who devotes his life to providing inspiration and brief 19 years. And I clearly remember that Farrakhan?
guidance to youth. seemingly innocuous and yet consequential day Askia Muhammad is the photographer who
And here we are, blessed by God to be at your wed- that Randall was talking about — the moment shot a photo of then-Senator Barack Obama
ding, with so many people who love you in attendance. when you now are living longer without your smiling with Farrakhan at a meeting of the
- And why are we all here? Why is marriage — so loved one than you had with them. It was a Congressional Black Caucus. According to
private and personal a commitment — celebrated in very strange feeling, as so many of the things Martha Mr. Muhammad, the photo was taken in their
t public? he taught me, both through both words and by Cohen room at the Capital in 2005. When he was
Because love is never meant to be private. The exclu- example, fill my head. There were so many les- asked why the photo never appeared until this
- sivity you have for one another leads to the inclusivity sons about living life to its fullest, about never month, Mr. Muhammad said that he didn’t
of a home that is built to welcome in guests and share giving up, and about survival if the world goes dark. publish it after receiving an urgent request from a member
your blessings with strangers. That’s why you marry There isn’t a week that goes by that issues my father of the Congressional Black Caucus immediately following
under a chuppah, the tent of Abraham, which has only talked about decades ago are not in the news, but I think this meeting. Thus far, there have been no denials about the
y a roof and no walls, so that no one can be locked out. the most important lesson I learned from him was not to be meeting taking place, nor the request. The question now is
Today we look to you for inspiration. Those who are afraid to stand up for who you are, whether as a woman, an what are we going to do?
in less than loving marriages, or who were hurt by love, American, or a Jew. He showed us in so many ways that if Are we going to be silent, or are we going to stand up
y want to believe again that they too may be chosen. All you don’t respect yourself, no one else will. And respect is and ask the Congressional Black Caucus about this story,
, those whom life has beat up and who felt superflu- key to any relationship, professional or personal. and whether anyone in their caucus has a relationship with
ous or discarded are looking to you to heal. All those Though words are important, actions convey so much Farrakhan now or has hosted him or the Nation of Islam in
whom relationships have let down are looking at you more, as it was with this life lesson. My parents decided the years since this photo was taken? And which member
. to feel ennobled. Inspire us. Move us. Free us from to invest in a business that sold and repaired trucks in the issued this urgent request to bury the photo years ago? If the
y cynicism and despair. Give us hope. By witnessing the 1970s. The firm had been my father’s client for many years, caucus invited Farrakhan to a meeting room in the Capital,
two of you dedicating yourselves to each other, you and when one of the original partners died, he was offered don’t we have the right to full disclosure?
offer us all a taste of paradise. the opportunity to buy in. At that time, the business had Was Congressman John Lewis present? Did he know
. I bless you tonight, Shaina. May you embody your an arrangement with Mercedes Benz in Germany for the about the meeting? What about Congresswoman Maxine
mother’s beauty, selflessness, righteousness, and lov- trucks, but they used American-made Leach chassis. My Waters? Or James Clyburn, the current assistant Democratic
ing kindness. May you be all she is and more. May you father’s stipulation was that his location wouldn’t sell any of leader in the House of Representatives?
also be like the matriarchs of the Jewish people. May the trucks, but that they would repair them. All the partners Hosting someone in the Capital who spews hatred is
you have the fortitude of Sarah, who drew a line and agreed, and the deal was signed. abhorrent. If it were a congressional meeting with David
protected the exclusivity of her relationship with Abra- When the executives at Mercedes in Germany learned of Duke, we would demand answers. If we don’t find out why
ham. May you have the wisdom of Rebecca, who saw the new partner, they wanted to send my father a Mercedes- this event took place, who supported it, and what the cur-
aspects of character in her children to which even her Benz car as a gift. He thanked them but declined the offer. rent relationship between the Congressional Black Caucus,
husband remained blind. May you have the industri- The person offering the car, however, was a persistent senior their members, and the Nation of Islam is now, how can we
ousness of Rachel, to whom we are first introduced as executive who wouldn’t quit. He kept offering the car and — as Americans and as Jews — respect ourselves?
a shepherdess and entrepreneur. And may you have my father continued to decline graciously. Then one day the
the perseverance of Leah, who understood that rela- man came from Germany to visit my parents’ shop in Mount Martha Cohen is an award-winning producer and creative
tionships are built rather than created. Vernon. During their conversation, he told my parents that executive. She lives in Fort Lee with her husband and son.
Go forth and build an eternal home among Israel
and the Jewish people. Go forth and turn the ordinary
The opinions expressed in this section are those of the authors, not necessarily those
into the extraordinary, the natural into the miraculous,
of the newspaper’s editors, publishers, or other staffers. We welcome letters to the editor.
and the darkness into a sunlit paradise.
Send them to [email protected].
N
“ othing matters.” That photograph, of Barack
You hear that a lot Obama and Louis Farrakhan, sur-
these days. faced last week when the photog-
Yo u h e a r i t rapher who took the shot released
when the Wall Street Journal it to Politico. Many agree that had
reports that the president’s the photo seen the light of day
personal lawyer paid a porn before the 2008 election, there
actress $130,000, at the height would have been no President
of the presidential campaign, Obama. It may have cemented
so she would stay silent about Andrew later accusations that he had con-
an alleged affair she’d had with Silow-Carroll sorted with radicals, including his
S
ome years ago, I pro- I have come to believe that yet another often neglected reflected in history than the statement that those who
posed that a new “Ha- group merits recognition among the Ha-Rachaman bless Israel will be blessed and those who curse it will
Rachaman” prayer be prayers in Birkat haMazon: loyal and principled friends be cursed. The decline of a nation can often be clearly
added to Birkat haMa- of the Jewish people and the Jewish state. There are related to the way it has treated the Jew.”
zon (the series of blessings or nations, religious groups, political organizations, promi- The friends of the Jewish people and significant acts of
“grace” offered after meals), nent national leaders, and public figures who demon- friendship and moral courage directed toward the peo-
acknowledging the unique role strate friendship and support for the Jewish people and ple Israel are many and varied. Consider the performing
of the United States both in the causes we hold dear, who are deserving of our grati- artists and bands who have defied the BDS movement to
world affairs and in the Jewish tude, yet whom we too often neglect. Perhaps we are sus- perform in the Jewish State: The Rolling Stones, Jethro
national experience. Rabbi Joseph picious of their motives or sincerity. Perhaps we disagree Tull, Madonna (who wrapped herself in an Israeli flag on
I argued that the standard, H. Prouser with other religious principles or political positions that stage), Alicia Keys, Guns ‘N Roses, Britney Spears, Nick
generic petition asking God those proffering their friendship have adopted. Perhaps Cave, Aerosmith, Rod Stewart, Elton John, Ringo Starr,
to bless “ha-aretz ha-zot” — we are so preoccupied with other pressing issues that we and others.
“this country” — represented a simply have allowed sustained acts of support, kindness, Think, too, of tennis great Venus Williams, who took a
neglectful injustice to the exceptional quality of the United and affection to go unrequited. principled stand when the United Arab Emirates barred
States. (The same blessing just as well could be recited by The cosmic implications and theological significance an Israeli athlete from a tournament. Her sister Serena
devoted citizens of Canada, Chile, or Uganda on behalf of of befriending the Jewish people is stated in the Torah and tennis (and feminist) icon Billie Jean King added
their nations, and “ha-aretz ha-zot” does not have the same repeatedly, and lies at the very heart of our historic mis- their voices to the protest, and succeeded in changing
meaning when recited by Americans abroad.) Drawing upon sion and covenant. In the very first moments of Jewish the tournament host nation’s visa policy.
the words of Abraham Lincoln, the new blessing asks: “Ha- history, God assures Abram: Va-avaracha mevarchecha Consider the principled support for the state of Israel
Rachaman, Hu yevarech et Artzot Ha-Brit, she-memshalah u-mekalelcha a-or — “I will bless those who bless you by political and governmental leaders such as former U.S.
shel ha-am, al yedei ha-am, u-l’maan ha-am lo tikached min and curse whoever curses you” (Genesis 12:3). Isaac Secretary of Education William J. Bennett, who wrote (and
ha-aretz” — “May the Merciful One bless the United States of transmits this divine promise to Jacob: “Cursed be they at a massive Washington D.C. rally in support of the Jewish
America, that government of the people, by the people, and who curse you, blessed they who bless you” (Genesis State, proclaimed to his fellow Americans from the Capi-
for the people shall not perish from the earth.” 27:9). Balaam, too, repeated God’s covenantal blessing tol steps): “Keeping faith with the people of Israel in their
I was gratified by the response to my liturgical innova- to Israel: “Blessed are they who bless you. Accursed they still unfinished confrontation with evil is, to me, a species
tion, and by the correspondence I received from those who curse you” (Numbers 24:9)! of keeping faith with ourselves; breaking faith, a species
who shared my sentiments and had adopted my pro- Rabbi W. Gunther Plaut affirms this fundamental arti- of self-negation. It is exactly that simple, and exactly that
posed prayer. cle of faith: “Few biblical dicta have been more clearly difficult, and exactly that consequential.”
sloppy planning into political felonies. Last week, Rep- Democratic president attacking
resentative Lou Barletta (R-Pa.) took heat when it was the FBI? Can you imagine if Hillary
learned that in 2006 he gave an interview to a publication had won the election and there
that peddles in Holocaust denial, and that a year later he were unmistakable signs that the
headlined a rally that also heard from a musician with his Russians had gamed Facebook in
own interesting theories about the Shoah. Barletta was a her favor? (It works the other way,
small-town mayor at the time, and last week he blamed too: Can you imagine, ask Trump’s
his staff for bad vetting. I’d want to know a lot more before defenders, if Hillary had protected
dismissing Barletta as soft on Holocaust denial. a campaign adviser accused of
Whether events like these do, or should, sink a politi- sexual harassment — oh, wait, that
cian’s career depends on a number of things. Fairly or actually happened.)
Spencer Platt/Getty Images
unfairly, bad things stick to politicians if they somehow Had the Farrakhan photo come
of the daily outrages associated with Trump would have There has to be a way of thinking about our leaders that
sunk a normal politician. Can you imagine if it were a falls somewhere between overreacting to an inexpedient Andrew Silow-Carroll of Teaneck is JTA’s editor in chief.
Recently, genuine friendship toward the state of But God’s promise in Genesis was twofold. Those who David Freedman (Sefer Shalmei David) which, notwith-
Israel was demonstrated by Guatemala, in that Cen- bless us will be blessed and those who curse us will be standing the actual etymology of the term, homileti-
tral American nation’s recognition of Jerusalem as the cursed (mekalelcha a-or). It seems patently improper cally links the execrable “a-or” of Genesis 12:3 to “or,”
capital of Israel. (My congregation now gratefully dis- and unseemly to introduce a curse into our blessings meaning light: “The Holy One’s blessing suggests that
plays a Guatemalan flag next to that of the Jewish State of gratitude. Rabbi Joseph B. Soloveitchik taught that God will enlighten and open the eyes of Abraham’s
in our sanctuary.) cruelty “desecrates the very essence of prayer, since it enemies, so that they will curse him no more.” Such a
Further, let us not forget the thousands of Christian encases man in an ugly little world into which God is sentiment is worthy of Jewish prayer — if not necessar-
Zionists among the evangelical community, of whose unwilling to enter. If man craves to meet God in prayer, ily of earnest students of Hebrew grammar.
motives and friendship many Jews remain deeply sus- then he must purge himself of all that separates him During Birkat haMazon, we thank God for our sus-
picious, but whose concern for the Jewish state often is from God.” Our new Ha-Rachaman blessing must not tenance. During Birkat haMazon, we articulate our
more impactful on national policy, and more faithfully petition a merciful God to curse our enemies. gratitude for the State of Israel (“reishit tzemichat
translated into voting patterns, than our own. They Rather, let us more discreetly invoke God’s covenantal ge’ulateinu” — “the beginning of a still unfolding pro-
explicitly cite the covenantal promise to Abraham as assurances through prayerful wordplay: “Ha-Rachaman cess of Jewish national redemption”). During Birkat
the basis of their principled political posture and bib- Hu yevarech et mevarecheinu, v’et mekaleleinu yancheh haMazon, we offer our gratitude for our own excep-
lical fealty. la-or” — “May the Merciful One bless those who bless us, tional nation, as well as for many other blessings and
The long history of persecution and exclusion, and lead those who curse us toward the light.” (Yancheh aspirations in our lives. It is only right that in the light of
hatred and betrayals endured by the Jewish people — “May God lead” is the same verb used in Psalm 23: God’s covenantal promise to Abraham and his heirs, we
does not excuse continued ingratitude, nor does it “Yancheini b’maglei tzedek l’maan Shemo” — “You lead also gratefully acknowledge true friends of the Jewish
relieve us of the moral obligation of hakarat ha-tov me on paths of righteousness, for Your Name’s sake.”) people and the Jewish state. We thereby effectively rise
— the duty to acknowledge the good and honorable The Hebrew la-or — “to the light” (root: alef-vav- above a historic pattern of pain and cynical suspicion,
acts of others, especially when we are the recipients resh) — evokes through assonance the famous term and declare our determination to embrace the hand of
of such gestures of friendship and support. in Genesis: A-or — “I will curse” (root: alef-resh-resh). friendship when it is extended to us.
If we are to translate this increasingly grateful sen- Yet it does so without allowing our mealtime petition “Ha-Rachaman Hu yevarech et mevarecheinu, v’et
sibility into words of prayer, it makes sense to tie our to descend into the very expressions of hate from mekaleleinu yancheh la-or.” “May the Merciful One bless
efforts to the scriptural record of a merciful God’s cov- which we yearn for salvation. Such a Ha-Rachaman those who bless us, and lead those who curse us toward
enantal promise to our founding generations. “Ha- maintains the language and the poetic resonance of the Light.”
Rachaman, Hu yevarech et mevarecheinu — May the the covenantal original, while elevating our postpran-
Merciful One bless those who bless us” provides a suc- dial prayer to a peace-loving, worthy, and optimistic Joseph H. Prouser is the rabbi of Temple Emanuel of
cinct but unmistakable literary echo of Genesis. vision. It also revisits the lovely interpretation of Rabbi North Jersey in Franklin Lakes.
A
number of years
ago, when we
started to campaign
for a Holoc aust
memorial and education cen-
ter, it seemed that the memorial
would be a standalone project
in a park setting. We envisioned
it as a place that would give the
community a way to memorial- Steve Fox
ize family members who were
killed during the Holocaust and
be a Shoah education center for the surrounding area.
As the project progressed, we were offered a place
on the Teaneck municipal green, an area that would be
open to other memorials as well. We accepted the offer,
and called the place “The Garden to Nurture Human
Understanding.”
T
he magic words we would share in its peace
were taught as chil- and prosperity. The Mishna and Talmud require
dren were please
and thank you.
Ezra expressed a simi-
lar sentiment in requiring
that a person pray for the welfare of
Who doesn’t remember a that the community pray the government. This includes the
parent or teacher insisting on
this basic courtesy? Gratitude
for the life of the king and
his sons. The Talmud had
king and the others who comprise
is a fundamental value, and no illusions about the self- the governmental apparatus.
expressing it is a virtue.
Jewish law and custom ele- Leonard
ish motives of the Persian
government in allowing
Absent this vital function in the
vates this principle to a com- Grunstein Jewish exiles to return to society, there would be anarchy.
munity mandate in a variety Jerusalem and build the
of circumstances. Thus Jer- Second Temple. This, The Mishna and Talmud require that apparatus. Absent this vital func-
emiah enjoined the exiles in Babylon to though, did not detract from the require- a person pray for the welfare of the gov- tion in the society, there would be anar-
seek and pray for the welfare of the city ment to be gracious and to demonstrate ernment. This includes the king and the chy, and as the Mishna notes so vividly,
in which they resided, so that they too our gratitude as a community. others who comprise the governmental people would swallow each other alive.
Blessing the monarch or other leader
Leonard Grunstein of Teaneck, a retired attorney and banker, founded and served as chairman of Metropolitan National Bank of the government and praying for his or
and then of Israel Discount Bank of NY. He also founded Project Ezrah and serves on the board of Revel at Yeshiva University and of her welfare became a customary part of
AIPAC’s Bergen Council. He has published articles in the Banking Law Journal, Real Estate Finance Journal, and other publications. the Sabbath prayer service. I remember
S
and continue inside the library. There While everyone has their own charities eeing my high poverty, expand access to
will be space both inside and outside for and schools to support, we believe that school in national health care, promote envi-
group discussions and lectures. Part of this the importance of this project cannot headlines last week ronmental protection, and
project is to create a video library that will be overemphasized. This sentiment has was mildly surreal. fight racism? It’s difficult to
include Holocaust testimonies of relatives been expressed by clergy of all faiths who The Frisch School, a mod- imagine a modern Ortho-
of people from Bergen County. The change we have been in contact with, as well as ern Orthodox high school dox school organizing a let-
to bring their children and grandchildren by community and political leaders. The in Paramus, was my home ter-writing campaign about
to see their ancestors honored at our educational and moral benefits that this for four formative years. any of those issues, and we
memorial and education center is some- project will bring to its visitors (about 70 It also is the alma mater of should ask ourselves why.
thing that we believe families will cherish. to 80 percent of the visitors to most Holo- Jared Kushner, currently an Alexander These issues, and many
Giving schools, synagogues, churches, and caust memorials and museums are non- adviser to his father-in-law, Lichtenberg more, ought to be as con-
other organizations the opportunity to Jews) can affect generations to come in President Donald Trump. cerning to any civic-minded
experience what we believe will be an eye- an extremely positive way. These improbable facts Jew as the well being of the
opening, emotional visit will help us make To do all of the things for the physi- collided last week when a story broke in Jewish state.
sure that the lessons of the Holocaust are cal as well as the educational parts of Haaretz that some parents of students The problem with politics in modern
not forgotten, and that the stories of the the project requires serious funding. at Frisch were upset at the school for Orthodox communities is even more
survivors are kept alive. We have received seed money from the instructing students to write letters of acute today. The specter and disaster of
state of New Jersey but we have a long thanks to Trump for recognizing Jerusa- Trump’s presidency and what it symbol-
Designing an exhibit way to go. (Please go to our website, lem as the capital of Israel. The letter-writ- izes should act as a wake-up call for all
To help us navigate the important www.nnjholocaustmemorial.org, for ing campaign was initiated by NORPAC, a religious Jews. President Trump has made
exhibit/educational program, we have more details.) pro-Israel group that fundraises for candi- clear his contempt for democratic norms
contracted Ralph Applebaum Associates, dates who take certain positions on Israel. and his admiration for white suprema-
one of the world’s leading exhibit design- Continuing education NORPAC has long had close relationships cists. His administration has made itself
ers. Our architect, Alan Hantman, FAIA, As we work on raising the funds for our with many schools and synagogues across the enemy of the poor, the widowed, and
who was the 10th architect of the Capitol project, we will continue to sponsor northern New Jersey, including Frisch. the orphaned, precisely those people
in Washington from February 1997 until educational programs for the commu- That a teacher at Frisch was encourag-
February 2007, worked with Applebaum nity, like the one we had at the library. ing students to participate in a NORPAC-
on that project. Applebaum also designed We will work with Holocaust educators led campaign is itself entirely unremark-
the Jewish Museum and Tolerance Cen- and exhibit experts to produce an effec- able. Many other groups of Orthodox
ter in Moscow, the Newseum in Washing- tive and memorable exhibition and will Jews are doing the same thing. The fact Trump’s
ton, the Holocaust Museum in Washing-
ton, the Clinton presidential library, and
continue to work with the Enslaved Afri-
can Memorial Committee to create a
that there was some parental backlash is
somewhat surprising, but hardly the stuff
presidency
many of the high profile museums and true “Garden to Nurture Human Under- of a viral news story. and what it
exhibits around the world. So we really
have a top-notch team working with us.
standing” that will be a model for others
to emulate.
Except, in this case, the point of the
campaign is to express gratitude to an
symbolizes
unpopular and problematic president, should act
Communal involvement
Creating a lasting Holocaust memorial
Steve Fox is the president of Fox Marketing
& Video Productions and co-chair of the
and the group in question is his adviser’s
high school.
as a wake-up
and education center is a daunting proj- Northern New Jersey Holocaust Memorial I was surprised to see this story in the call for all
ect and needs lots of communal support. and Education Center. news, and I was reminded of my own
political activism in high school. I have
religious Jews.
fond memories running Frisch’s Israel
advocacy club, including editing its news- whom the Torah repeatedly commands
letter and organizing a trip to Washington, us to care for. Now more than ever, it is
D.C., so that high school seniors could crucial to educate the next generation of
lobby members of Congress on issues religious Jewish voters about the danger
related to Israel. Frisch did a service to Trump and his allies pose for anyone who
me and my politically minded classmates supports liberal democracy, abhors rac-
by encouraging political activism and civic ism, and looks after the most marginal-
well as a child, in the synagogue on the and urged others to do so as well. engagement at a young age. ized in our society.
Sabbath, hearing the gabbai read the In reflecting on the importance of I thought about these past events in I am grateful to Frisch for supporting
special prayer for the welfare of the gov- expressing our gratitude to governmen- light of last week’s story. The problem goes my political activism before I could even
ernment of the United States of America, tal leaders, I am reminded of ancient beyond the few modern Orthodox Jews vote. I hope that Frisch, and other modern
including the blessings for the president times and an incident involving another whose support for Trump is, and opposi- Orthodox schools, continue to educate
and vice president. This was a nonpar- leader of a superpower at the time. The tion to Obama was, rooted in racism. The their students on the importance of civic
tisan matter. It made no difference who Talmud reports that the Roman Caesar bigger issue is the myopic focus on Israel engagement. The question is not whether
served in the office of the president at made a gesture. It took the form of a sac- whenever modern Orthodox Jews discuss these schools should encourage politi-
the time, or how many members voted rifice to be offered in the Second Tem- national politics. It’s not only a matter of cal activism. It’s a matter of which poli-
for that person. Always, the congregation ple. It was intended as a test, to see if the using Israel as a proxy for which candidates tics should be discussed and promoted.
joined in the prayer by answering amen. sacrifice would, in fact, be brought and to support. Virtually all political activism in Will schools continue to talk only about
The need to publicly express our grati- thereby honor the Roman Caesar and modern Orthodox communities centers politics in the context of the U.S. govern-
tude to our governmental leaders is an his government. The Talmud goes on to around pro-Israel advocacy. ment’s stance on a handful of Israel issues?
important duty we all share as members relate how Bar Kamtza (of the notorious Concern for, and prioritization of, Isra- Or will schools educate students on acute
of the Jewish people. This is especially so incident of Kamtza and Bar Kamtza) art- el’s welfare is not by itself problematic. It issues facing our country, and how, even
when a governmental leader reaches out fully blemished the animal to prevent becomes a problem when that concern as minors, they can work toward a more
and takes courageous action, like Presi- the sacrifice. His object was to subvert comes at the expense of thinking about perfect union for all Americans?
dent Trump did, in formally recogniz- the relationship between Rome and the any other political issues. How many times
ing Jerusalem as the capital of Israel. I, Jewish people. The Sages considered have modern Orthodox schools organized Alexander Lichtenberg of Teaneck is a
therefore, wrote him a thank-you note See Thanks 44 in support of policies to alleviate chronic student at New York Medical College.
Thank you, President Trump be proud that Frisch and many other Jewish day schools dozen New Yorkers around him. His driver was nowhere
I write in disappointed incredulousness regarding the ‘less know how to motivate their students’ recognition of the in sight — I assume he went into one of the bodegas. I
than a molehill made into a mountain’ Frisch H.S. letters blessings bestowed upon us and to give thanks to those stood there for a few minutes then nodded to the future
issue (“Was a thank-you note a breach of etiquette?” Jan- who deserve it. president and continued on my way. As I walked away
uary 26). Let’s face reality; while the Standard’s article Leonard Fuld I remember thinking that if I was one the richest men
provided valid background information to the non-issue, Teaneck in New York I wouldn’t be standing around like that. I’d
the anonymous and attributed quotes reflect nothing be inside that car with the doors locked. I believe the
but the continued whining of liberal sore-losers. The fact Shame on you, Trump haters! President is a people person. He genuinely enjoys being
that Jared Kushner went to Frisch many years ago is irrel- According to the Book of Ezra, 2500 years ago the around people.
evant, and speciously used to generate headlines. Taking great Persian king, Cyrus, allowed the Jews to return It is refreshing to finally have a president that tells
it another step, Shammai Engelmayer, in his weekly edito- to their homeland and rebuild the second Temple. In you what he is thinking without having to turn to his
rial of supposed Talmudic wisdom, felt the need to chime his honor, they dedicated the Eastern gate of the outer pollsters to find out what to believe or say. It is remark-
in with distorted and irrelevant references to saving lives walls of the Temple Mount, the Shushan Gate facing able to have a president that is not afraid to do things in
and spilling blood. Does he seriously believe that letters Persia. Fast forward to the present and for the first time his first year in office that other presidents do in their
of thanks from high school students to the President of an American President proclaimed Jerusalem as the eighth year as they walk out the door!
the U.S. will lead to loss of life or spilling of blood? His dis- eternal capital of Israel. Rabbi Ciner, thank you for the amazing job you are
ingenuous use of our beloved Sages’ words to bolster his As a token of appreciation, Frisch students (the First doing and please ignore Facebook and this fake contro-
own unhappy prospective is disappointing and not worth Son-in-Law’s alma mater), were urged to write thank-you versy. What happens on Facebook should stay on Face-
refuting, especially given the innumerable citations in our notes to the President. The reaction: a few token parents book. Most of it goes against Jewish values anyway.
history to the expressions of thanks given to our non-Jew- (needless to say, Trump Haters) objected and the rest I also hope Frisch will continue to invite people like
ish rulers. Will he next call for a discontinuance of our was left for the media to pounce upon. To add salt to Jason Greenblatt to speak to the students, and not turn
weekly prayer for the government, which we have said in the wound, Rosh Yeshiva and teacher of Talmud Ozer into another Rutgers. A wonderful quality of the Orthodox
one form or another since Jeremiah’s time? Oh, and let’s Glickman weighed in by stating “that the timing of the community, as a recent Pew Research poll shows, is the
not ignore Neal Borovitz’s “shock” in his letter, upon read- letter writing campaign was unfortunate.” Seriously! The varied and balanced opinions and political viewpoints in
ing about this issue in the always even-handed reporting timing? When would be the correct timing? On another our community (about 50-50 as contrasted with the Con-
of Haaretz. Isn’t it astoundingly ironic that a reform ‘rabbi’ front, various so-called Jewish leaders invoked separa- servative and Reform movements where it is skewed 70-30
would call for a protective fence (gezeirah) for secular tion of Church and State! and 80-20 respectively towards liberal viewpoints).
legal principles? Shame on these parents. Shame on Ozer Glickman. Mr. Greenblatt’s message is truer in our time as ever.
So now, let’s consider the realities from a nonpolitical per- Shame on self-hating Jews. Perhaps these individuals As a community we know how Israel is often the vic-
spective. This President has undoubtedly raised the world- should take a moment to open the Book of Ezra and glean tim of this biased reporting. How many times has a false
wide stature of Israel. He has fulfilled long-made promises of some sense of spiritual guidance. story been splashed across the headlines of the “news-
recognizing the reality that Jerusalem is the capital of Israel. Herbert Burack paper of record” only for a retraction to be buried
He has and continues to shift the U.N.’s and, for that mat- Teaneck deep inside the paper days later. How many times has a
ter, the world’s attitude toward Israel. All of this is good for story that puts Israel in a positive light been completely
the Jews. We must also be concerned by a number of the Thank you, Rabbi Ciner ignored by the popular media.
negatives ascribed to President Trump that are incessantly As a current Frisch parent, I completely support the The media’s biased treatment of the president should
reported by the press, but that should certainly not counter- school’s decision to ask their students to thank the pres- be evident to every thinking individual. Just a look at Time
mand our appreciation for all the good. ident. “Was a thank-you note a breach of etiquette?” is magazine’s recent covers is enough to tell you that this is
Accordingly, the idea that Frisch students, who appreci- the headline of your article. Seriously? Shouldn’t we no longer a news magazine put a propaganda tool. On Feb-
ated his Jerusalem stance, should voluntarily send a note be teaching our children if someone does something ruary 16, 2017, just a month after the president took office,
of gratitude to the President seems absolutely proper and nice for you to say thank you? Not saying thank you is a Time printed an article by Maya Rhodan titled: “Trump’s
apolitical. After eight years of a president who was decid- breach of etiquette! immigration crackdown seems designed to spread fear”.
edly unfriendly to Israel, it is truly refreshing to finally In recognizing Jerusalem as the capital of Israel, our Every law enforcement official interviewed said it would
have a U.S. leader who is willing to publicly recognize president stuck his neck out with this monumental be impossible to plan and implement this type of oper-
Israel’s correctness, especially in contrast to its adversar- gesture and went against the advice and threats of the ation in under a month and that this was planned well
ies. There is no question that we should be a light onto entire world. before Mr. Trump’s election. So, is this honest and bal-
the nations, but not to the detriment of our own people. Our community should be most grateful to the presi- anced journalism or propaganda?
As my former professor, Elie Wiesel, aptly stated, “When dent — regardless of how you voted! As citizens of this great nation we should support our
a person doesn’t have gratitude, something is missing in In full disclosure I am a fan. I came across Mr. Trump president and wish him continued success and teach our
his or her humanity” and silence or protest is certainly not around 12 years ago as I was walking up Broadway near children to do the same.
the way to reflect that thankfulness. the Letterman theater. Mr. Trump was standing next to Sam Rappaport
Frisch H.S did nothing wrong, and in fact, we should all his limousine with a random mishmash of about a half Teaneck
The talmudic text concludes with a course of history have been different? our gratitude, as a community, by writ-
Thanks resounding criticism of the overly virtu- We must be mindful of these lessons, ing to the president and expressing our
from page 43
ous pronouncements of Rabbi Zechariah even as we treasure the right to have hon- thanks for his brave decision to recognize
the matter and thought to consummate ben Avkulas. While he didn’t intend to est and vigorous debate and to vote for the Jerusalem as the capital of Israel. While
the sacrifice, despite the animal’s blem- slight the Roman emperor, the effect was candidate of our choice. The exercise of we’re at it, we might also thank Vice Pres-
ish, to maintain peace with the Roman the same; the emperor’s goodwill gesture these freedoms does not displace the duty ident Pence for his inspirational remarks
overlords. However, Rabbi Zechariah was rejected. The Talmud notes this was we have to express our gratitude to the sit- before the Knesset and the announce-
ben Avkulas, one of the Sages, protested the precipitating cause for the destruction ting president. He is the leader of the gov- ment that the U.S. embassy soon will be
that this would send the wrong message of the Second Temple and the exile. Imag- ernment, which assures our protection, moved to Jerusalem.
to the people. As a result of his protesta- ine had the dictates of extreme piety been including our right to free speech. As we approach the 70th anniversary
tions, the Sages did not intervene, and rejected, and instead practical consider- I, therefore, urge everyone, men, of the State of Israel, let’s show our grati-
the sacrifice was aborted. ations had prevailed. Might the entire women, and children, to demonstrate tude. Just say thanks.
R
ecently, I’ve been
nursing some con-
cerns about the
way the Israeli
government is handling its
response to the BDS campaign
against the Jewish state, and
with it the wider challenges of
anti-Zionism and anti-Semitism
in the Western world. Ben Cohen
Some of my concerns already
have been expressed with envi-
able clarity by two other commentators, my JNS colleague
Jonathan Tobin and the Times of Israel’s Haviv Rettig Gur.
In response to Israel’s decision this month to ban 20
BDS-related organizations from entering the country,
Tobin made the broader point in his column that the
material impact of the BDS campaign upon Israel has been
gratifyingly minimal. The true danger of this campaign, he
continued, lies in its persistent targeting of Jewish commu-
nities in the diaspora.
Meanwhile, Rettig Gur’s critique of the official Israeli
response to BDS included a wryly amusing account of how
Israel has generated a handful of boutique-sized govern-
ment ministries during the last decade. These ministries
have no clear mandate, but are staffed by bureaucracies
whose “primal” goal is survival. This drive, Rettig-Gur
argued, explains to significant degree why the Israeli gov-
ernment’s own campaign to counter BDS is escalating.
I want to amplify some of these concerns, and then offer a Bds movement protest against Israel in Melbourne, australia. moHameD oUDa vIa WIkImeDIa commonS
a few of my own.
As a general rule, governments engaging in campaigns major concern for Jewish communities in the diaspora? Israel and its people.
to defend their own records, or to project a certain image To my mind, the greatest error of all here is the denial of Meanwhile, Israel is now positively enjoying life as a
of their country, is rarely a good idea. That’s particularly a basic reality that we should all welcome. The BDS cam- member of the international community—the world’s
true if the ultimate goal is to win over skeptics and adver- paign is in decline. That is not to say that BDS has failed 10th-most-innovative country, according to a Bloomberg
saries — or at least persuade them to consider a given situ- definitively; merely to note that by its own very specific News index released this week, respected and embraced
standard of political success, it has performed miserably. in the worlds of technology, television drama, food, and
That standard is the global movement that opposed wine, as well as its more traditional spheres, like agricul-
apartheid in South Africa. ture and defense.
The BDS campaign is in That was an explicitly racist form of government, based
upon the formal segregation by the state authorities of
All this makes the idea of a government ministry that
is dedicated to countering a political demonization cam-
decline. That is not to white and non-white peoples. BDS proponents lie when paign seem even more incongruous. It suggests that the
say that BDS has failed they say that this shameful system has been resurrected
in Israel, but that lie allows them neatly to adopt the fight
NGOs involved with this hateful campaign represent such
a threat to Israel’s national security that a government-
definitively; merely to against apartheid in South Africa as their inspiration and backed response suddenly is warranted. More seriously, it
graphics, that represent grassroots opposition to BDS and indicator of success for a political campaign whose goal is
its claims? More troublingly, what kind of credibility is to end a particular example of injustice. Ben Cohen writes a weekly column on Jewish affairs and
there in a government ministry that was repurposed hast- Even with an entire world of social media that didn’t Middle Eastern politics. His work has been published in
ily to confront the BDS campaign only in 2015, more than exist 30 years ago at its disposal, the BDS movement can Commentary, the New York Post, Haaretz, the Wall Street
a decade after the campaign to boycott Israel became a only dream of inflicting similar reputational damage on Journal, and many other publications.
T
he Torah portion this week is are doing is not right! You will intermediary between God celebrate the rebirth of Jewish Inde-
called Yitro and is named after surely wear yourself out and and the people, nor his pendence. I suggest to you this Shab-
Moses’ father-in-law, also known these people as well. The task willingness to be the arbi- bat that the whole story of the political
as Jethro. While the highlight is too heavy for you; you can- ter of disputes between battle to establish and build the Jewish
of this parsha and the climax of the entire not do it alone.” the people, are healthy for State of Israel is a very Yitro-like story.
Torah is the Ten Commandments found in Yitro criticizes Moses for him or the community. As Each time that any one leader, be it the
Exodus 20 with which it concludes, I believe offering total commitment to I reflect back upon my rab- British Jew Chaim Weizmann or the
that the opening narrative in Exodus 18 has communal service without binic career, I can see that American Jew Louis Brandeis, sought
a very salient message to we 21st century even asking the people for a often I took on the Moses- to take total credit and total control
Jews on the issue of national and communal contribution. He teaches his Rabbi Neal like approach that is criti- for the Zionist enterprise, there were
leadership. son-in-law a lesson: that the Borovitz cized here by failing to heed setbacks. When Jewish leaders over
To refresh our memories: The dialogue best thing for a communal Rabbi emeritus, the advice of Yitro. Our best the past century have been willing to
Temple Avodat
between Moses and his father-in-law takes leader to do is to delegate Shalom, River
leaders are not those who work together in partnership as did the
place after Yitro has brought his daugh- and share both authority and Edge, Reform do things for us, but rather diametrically opposed Prime Minister
ter and grandsons to meet Moses and the responsibility. those who inspire us to Menachem Begin, z”l, and the leader of
Israelites in the wilderness following their Yitro’s admonition of Moses help ourselves and to join American Reform Judaism, Rabbi Alex-
dramatic Exodus from Egypt. After a brief sets the stage for the reader to hear the mes- together to help others. ander Schindler, z”l, in the 1970s and
description of the happy reunion, Yitro, in sage later in this week’s Torah reading that Yitro’s advice to Moses to share power 80s, Jewish unity was preserved and
a manner that is certainly less than tactful, God makes His covenant not with Moses and responsibility is a message that is not Jewish life prevailed.
criticizes Moses’ leadership style and his but with “We the People.” Yitro points out only applicable to contemporary Jew- 2017 was a difficult year in diaspora–
authoritarian manner of governing the com- that self-centeredness can emanate from ish leaders, both lay and rabbinic, but Israeli relationships. I am sure that 2018
munity. In verses 17 and 18 Yitro bluntly crit- even the most altruistic of leaders. Nei- to we the people of the world. Democ- is going to be a year in which there will
icizes his son-in-law by saying: “What you ther the good intentions of Moses to be the racy works only when we all participate. be new challenges to the national rights
Abdicating responsibility leaves power of the Jewish People. I am also certain
vacuums that too often get filled by peo- that the internal battles over the ques-
ple who care more about the “me” than tion of who is a Jew, as well as the rights
the “we.” of all Jews to worship and to live in the
“Speaking Truth to Power” happens land of Israel, are going to challenge our
to be the theme for the North Jersey Jewish unity and sense of community.
Board of Rabbis’ Sweet Taste of Torah My question is: How are our leaders
program on Motzei Shabbat Yitro, (Feb- going to deal with these challenges?
ruary 3, at The Fair Lawn Jewish Center). I began this D’var Torah with a teach-
It is a Jewish tradition that dates back to ing from a great non-Jewish, Biblical
our Patriarchs in Genesis, is echoed by figure, Yitro. Allow me to conclude this
Yitro in this week’s Parsha, and through with a challenge from a post Biblical Jew-
our Prophets and Sages across the ages ish teacher, who lived some 1,200 years
has been incised into our Jewish com- after Moses, a Sage named Hillel. In Pirke
munal soul. Over the last century when Avot, we are taught in the name of Hillel:
we Jews have been willing to speak truth- “If I am not for myself who will be for
fully to each other and to share power me? If I am only for myself what am I? If
and responsibility even with those with not now, when?”
whom we disagree, we have accom- On this Shabbat Yitro I ask myself and
plished amazing feats. Conversely, when each of you to rephrase Hillel’s question
we have allowed our differences to divide and ask of ourselves and of our commu-
us, we too often paid a costly price. nal and societal leaders:
Beginning with the Balfour Declara- If I try to do it all myself who will be
tion issued 100 years ago on November with me? If I am unwilling to share power
2, 1917, and continuing with the U.N. and responsibility what am I? And then,
Partition Plan approved on November to echo Hillel’s rhetorical retort: “If not
29, 1947, and culminating on April 19, now when?” In an age when totalitarian-
2018, when we will celebrate the 70th ism is making a political comeback, may
anniversary of Israel’s Independence, we all remember Yitro’s admonition to
we are blessed this year with multi- Moses here in this week’s parsha that
ple anniversaries upon which we can bears his name.
Like us on Facebook.
facebook.com/jewishstandard
46 JEWISH STANDARD FEBRUARY 2, 2018
Dear Rabbi Zahavy
W
inter break, January family has no desire to eat in a restaurant
2018. Husband #1 and that requires a reservation, so we did the
I are taking a leisurely “Ganchrow method” of eating dinner in
stroll on the board- Miami Beach, with all of the Jews. What’s
walk in Miami Beach. The weather is the method, you ask? Well, husband #1
beautiful, the sun has set, the Vikings and son #3 attend the afternoon and eve-
have lost, son #3 has left us ning prayer service at the
for his friends, and we have local synagogue, while
decided that we had to stay I read a little and then
awake past 8 p.m. Together. change my already stylish
A rare occurrence, but who outfit for the exciting eve-
knew that what we were to ning out. And you know
experience would be even me, ball gown, Manolos,
more unique? hair and make up….ya,
As we are walking down so three minutes later, I
the boardwalk, it is around was ready. I walked from
9:30 to 10 p.m. There are Banji the hotel, they walked
hundreds of black-hatted, Ganchrow from the synagogue, and
bekeshe-wearing men. Payis we scoped out which res-
curled to perfection, beards taurants had no or very
gently waving in the wind. They’re little line. I have got to say, it worked out
with their wives. Some wives are in pretty well. And we didn’t have to book
their sheital/pillbox hat finest. Some in it months ago! (And you people wonder
snoods. Some in chupkas. Housecoats. why I think people are nuts.)
Stockings with seams in the back. Some We tried to do something touristy
Across Down
with strollers. Some with walkers. All each night. One night, we went to Wyn-
1. “Shalom” 1. “For ___ a jolly ...”
ages. All sizes. All speaking Yiddish. wood Walls, which is a new art district.
6. ___ Shalom 2. Samuel’s High Priest teacher
10. ___ Shalom 3. One might be said for peace in the Have they been in hiding all day? Do Amazing murals painted on warehouse
14. David’s oldest brother family they not come out because of the heat? walls, sculptures, and two galleries with
15. Basic rhyme scheme 4. ___ B’Omer Do they not come out so they won’t be
16. A written reminder 5. Having a lot to lose? exposed to the women running in biki-
17. The Romans laid one on Jerusalem 6. Southern Jerusalem neighborhood
nis? Husband #1 would not let me ask,
18. Rav Yosef of note 7. “Voice of Israel” author Abba
and I don’t speak Yiddish, but it was
19. Kill, biblically
20. Mount Sinai CAT
8. Black gunk no good for lighting shab-
bat candles quite the sight!
Chasidim on the
22. 4, on a phone keypad 9. Streaming app for Simon’s “The Wire” The next night, it was the same boardwalk. I
24. “Shalom, ___” — Bill Clinton 10. Short NFL kick scene. I had to find out what was going
28. “Shalom” 11. Note after fa
on. Husband #1 had gone upstairs a
think it could be
32. Yom Kippur tractate
33. ___ many words
12. El Al announcement, for short
13. “Shalom” few minutes earlier and I found myself a new type of
36. Says Shalom, perhaps
37. Starting point?
21. Peninsula in 2014 headlines with
Russia
in the elevator, with two chasidic cou-
ples. “Excuse me,” I asked hesitantly.
Twilight Series.
38. American desert 23. Prefix before -pathic “Why do you go out only at night?
40. ___A (March Madness org.) 24. Larry David’s show, initially
Is it the heat or the bikinis?” One of incredible exhibits. I was having the
41. Like the experience of Phil Connors 25. ___ HaSharon, Israel
in “Groundhog Day”...or several of 26. Where Trump is the leader the husbands looked at his wife, she best time, because I love stuff like that. I
this puzzle’s clues 27. Weather ___ looked back at him and nodded. “It’s was texting my sister pictures and really
44. 2016 Oscar winner Mahershala 28. Hairy chin look the bikinis,” they responded together. enjoying the culture. Unfortunately, I
46. Nadal of tennis 29. Hellenistic Jewish scribe I knew it!!! Shmeerat ayenayim. Simple was with two boys who could spend four
47. 1993 Tom Cruise-Sydney Pollack 30. Initials of Jewish schools in
translation? The guarding of the eyes hours at the college basketball hall of
legal thriller, with “The” Jerusalem, Miami, and Denver
50. Chocolate source 31. ___ Einai (from something immodest). Appar- fame, but couldn’t last very long at this
52. “Got it” 34. Unsuitable ently, my very religious sons had not cultural hotspot. Oh well, guess I should
53. OU-D sandwich cookie 35. LaBeouf, and others made that expression up! So this is mus- have brought them some toys and snacks
54. “___ Shalom” 39. Most repellent ing #1. chasidim on the boardwalk. I to keep them busy. I will know for next
56. “Shalom ___” 42. Look into
think it could be a new type of Twilight time. (And, to be clear, the boys were 47
58. Guitarist Paul 43. Spielberg ships
59. Letter after epsilon 44. Home coolers, briefly Series. Discuss amongst yourselves. and 17, respectively.)
61. Actress Fisher who converted to 45. “Well, ___-di-dah!” Vampires that dine only on blood with But in the end, what makes a good
Judaism 48. “Man on the Moon” band kosher certification… vacation? Being able to look at the ocean
64. Band whose members are Este, 49. A Stooge And then we have the restaurants. and not have anyone ask you to take
Danielle, and Alana 51. On fire
Now, husband #1 and son #3 are not them to the bathroom — but I miss that
66. English 101 subject 55. Kind of korban
71. King after Jotham 57. Wolf down foodies. I eat everything that doesn’t stage too. Tune in next week, when we
72. Yeshiva Boys Choir member 59. Last pasta, alphabetically eat me first, but that is another story. explore why you always have to be nice
73. Outfitters clothing brand 60. Parsha after Kedoshim and before Apparently, there is no kosher food in to people and if you aren’t when you are
74. ___ Shalom BeHar the tristate area (well, the Five Towns younger, you will have to fake it when
75. Shalom ___ Tower 61. Actor McKellen who played a Nazi in
and Teaneck, because I do not think that you are older….That is Part II…
76. Shalom “Apt Pupil”
62. Her anyone visiting Miami Beach was from
63. Restroom, for short anywhere else). People felt the need Banji Ganchrow would like to move to
65. Drink in Jerusalem? to make reservations for their Florida Miami Beach. The boardwalk is her new
The solution to last week’s puzzle 67. “Able was I ___ …”
is on page 55. dining experiences, weeks in advance. happy place, during the day with the
68. Adam Silver’s sports org.
Nope, you cannot make this stuff up. bikinis and at night with the chasidim. It’s
69. RBI fly by Green or Greenberg
70. Tel Aviv to Tsfat Dir. Fortunately for me, I know that my all good….
Football party in
Teaneck: The men’s club
of the Jewish Center of
Teaneck is relaunching
with a kickoff Super
Bowl party, 6:30 p.m.
Watch the game on a
10’x10’ screen with an
amazing sound system.
Sumptuous buffet.
Everyone over 13 is
welcome. 70 Sterling
Bob Klapisch Place. (201) 833-0515 or
www.jcot.org/payment.
Columnist in Teaneck: php.
Bob Klapisch, formerly
of the Record, gives
a preview of the 2018 Monday
baseball season, FEBRUARY 5
discusses the Astros
winning the World Series, Networking in Teaneck:
the Hall of Fame voting The Jewish Business
results, and the future of Network meets for
sports coverage in print breakfast at Five Star
media., for the men’s club Premier Residences,
of Congregation Beth
FEB. Tizmoret, the Jewish a capella group from Queen College’s Aaron, 9:30 a.m. He also
8:30 a.m. Hosted
by Shelley Edelson.
Hillel, performs at Temple Israel & JCC in Ridgewood at 6 p.m.,
11
will answer questions. 655 Pomander Walk.
to benefit the Academies at Gerrard Berman Day School’s Light breakfast. 950 www.jbusinessnetwork.
Queen Anne Road. net.
8th grade Israel trip. Tizmoret is joined by the GBDS choir and (201) 836-6210 or www.
features music by Solar Sound Band. All proceeds benefit the trip. 475 bethaaron.org. Lunch and Learn in Fort
Grove St., Ridgewood. (201) 337-1111 or www.SSNJ.org/tizmoret. Lee: Rabbi Zev Goldberg
of Young Israel of Fort
Lee discusses “Eternal
Impact, Six Defining
including repentance,
Wine and whiskey Moments in Jewish
Saturday wisdom, righteousness,
civil disobedience, in Englewood: Sunday History” at the shul, for
FEBRUARY 3 forgiveness, and protest The sisterhood of FEBRUARY 4 the Teaneck Orthodox
Congregation Ahavath Retiree Association
is at the Fair Lawn Jewish
Torah offers a night (TORA). Lunch at noon,
Center/CBI. Doors open
of wine and whiskey talk at 12:45 p.m. 1610
at 6:30 p.m., Havdalah
tastings by Wine Country Parker Ave. Michael,
at 7. Keynoter Rabbi
Stores, 8 p.m. Light (201) 741-7774 or
Barry L. Schwartz of
bites and and music. [email protected].
Adas Emuno in Leonia
will discuss “Truth to 240 Broad Ave. www. Saving rare books in
ahavathTorah.org/wine- Torah tales: Stu
Power: Prophetic Ethics WWII Lithuania: Dr. Lehrer continues
in Troubled Times.” whiskey-event-2018. David Fishman talks “Torah Twists: the ‘Ah’
Evening ends with Comedy in Teaneck: about his book, “The Moment,” a six-week
Israeli folk dancing Congregation Bnai Book Smugglers,” about course at the JCC of
and refreshments. Yeshurun presents the Vilna Ghetto slave Paramus/Congregation
10-10 Norma Ave. “Stayin’ Alive: An laborers who smuggled Beth Tikvah,
(201) 652-1687,
Gil Hoffman precious documents, at
Israeli Comedy Show,” 8:15 p.m. , through March
Sweet Tastes in Fair sweettastesoftorah@ in English, by Gady JNF breakfast in the United Synagogue 5. 304 East Midland Ave.
Lawn: Sweet Tastes gmail.com, or Weissbart and Noam Paramus: Gil Hoffman, of Hoboken, 10:30 a.m. (201) 262-7691.
of Torah, a community sweettastesoftorah. Jacobson, 8:30 p.m. 641 the Jerusalem Post’s Brunch. 115 Park Ave.
night of study and weebly.com. West Englewood Ave. political correspondent (201) 659-4000 or office@
breakout sessions with (201) 836-8916 or www. and author of its hobokensynagogue.org.
local rabbis on topics bnaiyeshurun. org/events. Frontlines column, is
COURTESY JCCOTP
Zumba party in Tenafly
The Kaplen JCC on the Palisades in exercise director, said. “Zumba is one
Tenafly offers its free Zumba party on Sat- great option, because it provides great
urday, February 10, from 7:30 to 8:45 p.m. music and dance routines that are fun to
Beginners are welcome. Participants, who learn. It also offers a great cardio workout
must be at least 12 years old, will dance that incorporates high and low aerobic
nonstop for 75 minutes to Latin, hip-hop, intervals and an appealing routine that
African, and Israeli music, with a high- keeps people motivated. And keeping
energy blend of music and great dance people motivated is our goal.”
moves. The session will be led by a team Registration is encouraged. For more
of expert JCC Zumba instructors. information, call (201) 408-1448 or go to
“In an effort to encourage people to jccotp.org/saturdaynightzumba. Facility
engage in more healthful activities, we tours and one-week guest passes will be
always look to feature a wide variety of available so the entire family can try out
Shopping at last year’s Seforim Sale at YU. COURTESY YU fitness options,” Hagit Tal, the group the JCC.
coming to
Englewood
Cesar Millan, the original host of the “Dog
Whisperer” series and the star of the new
“Cesar Millan’s Dog Nation” series, will
reveal the secrets of happier, healthier
relationships between human beings and
their beloved canines in his exciting live
show. It’s set for Saturday, February 24,
at 8 p.m., at the Bergen Performing Arts
Center. Mr. Millan will share training
secrets in his funny and entertaining way
and the audience will see him demon-
COURTESY BCHSJS
W
executive director of the Jewish Orthodox Feminist
h e n R a b b i A n ge l a B u c h d a h l Alliance, who advocates a hard ban on using Carle-
announced how her synagogue bach’s music. “There’s a difference between one’s
would respond to the #MeToo choice to attend a movie screening and one’s show-
moment, she singled out a man. But ing up to services at shul and having the choice taken
he wasn’t one of her congregants, synagogue clergy away from them.”
or staff members. Other clergy see a Carlebach music ban as an oppor-
He was Rabbi Shlomo Carlebach, perhaps the most tunity to expand their repertoires. A Facebook group
prominent 20th-century composer of American Jew- called Anything But Carlebach, with more than 1,200
ish music. Carlebach wrote a vast body of songs and members, has banned discussion of his behavior and
liturgical melodies, which are used in worship ser- serves as a clearinghouse for new or obscure melo-
vices, summer camps, and sing-alongs. His music is dies to prayers. Large segments of American Jewry
sung in synagogues from nearly every denomination. — including many Sephardic and chasidic commu-
But in the years after his death in 1994, many nities — have their own musical traditions that pre-
women came forward to allege that he sexually date Carlebach.
assaulted them. “Jewish music has a rich, varied, and long tradition
In her January 19 sermon to Manhattan’s Central well before Shlomo Carlebach’s music,” said Cantor
Synagogue, one of the largest congregations in the Jessica Leash, who runs Silicon Valley Jewish Meetup,
country, Buchdahl announced that the Reform syn- an independent community in Northern California. “If
agogue would not sing his melodies for a year. The we keep working in this material, not acknowledging
moratorium is taking effect across the synagogue, in its origin and not making any room for new material to
services, in Hebrew school, in nursery school. come forward, we’re basically shutting a door.”
“We hope this communicates to those who have Despite the allegations, some of Carlebach’s follow-
been victimized by Carlebach that we hear you and we ers still see immense value in his teachings and music.
are not indifferent,” Buchdahl said in the sermon. “In His daughter Neshama, a singer who has carried on his
this coming year, we will see what new music emerges legacy, wrote an essay in the Times of Israel in January
in the vacuum that is created with Carlebach gone.” in which she said she supports “the countless women
Central Synagogue is one of several in the United who have suffered the evils of sexual harassment and
States, across denominations, that has stopped using Rabbi Shlomo Carlebach, seen in a 1989 photo, was assault” and acknowledged that her father had hurt
Carlebach’s name, his teachings, or his melodies in a perhaps the most prominent 20th-century composer of some women. But she defended her father as a kind and
debate that precedes but has been intensified by the American Jewish music. caring spiritual leader who advanced women’s rights.
#MeToo moment. The decisions mostly are a response DAVE BURESH/THE DENVER POST VIA GETTY IMAGES “I do not recognize the version of my father that
to the sexual assault allegations that first appeared in some people describe,” she wrote. “To me, he was the
a 1998 article in Lilith, the Jewish feminist magazine, and said the misconduct allegations mean that Carlebach no kindest, most respectful, most loving person to my friends
have continued to surface since then. longer should be revered as a personal example. and me. I myself witnessed him as a deeply passionate
Because they were aired publicly only after his death, “The allegations about him were sufficiently credible supporter of the role of women as leaders.”
Carlebach never responded publicly to the claims, which and sufficiently serious and sufficiently numerous that Another Carlebach follower, Aryae Coopersmith,
range from dry humping and groping to unwanted kiss- he did not deserve to be treated as a rabbi, as a religious believes the allegations and included them in his book on
ing. Some of the women were underage at the time of authority figure,” Wolkenfeld said. “I also realized that if Carlebach’s movement. But he said it would be wrong to
the incidents. there were victims or their children or grandchildren in erase Carlebach’s music and stories, which have served as
“Essentially it felt like it was time to listen and take a the congregation, what would it mean to them to hear an inspiration for many people.
reckoning to people we ignored who came forward with someone who abused them being referred to as this “His songs for so many people have opened our hearts
their tales of sexual assault,” Buchdahl said. “We should great rabbi?” to what our tradition, what our grandparents, have been
not be in the business of banning any kind of art. I knew It’s also technically difficult to ban Carlebach’s music, teaching us for so long,” said Coopersmith, who co-
that was not the right option for us, but continuing to do said Rabbi Barry Kornblau of the Orthodox Young Israel founded the House of Love and Prayer, Carlebach’s syna-
nothing was also not an option.” of Hollis Hills-Windsor Park in Queens, New York. Kornb- gogue-cum-commune in San Francisco’s Haight-Ashbury
To excise Carlebach is no easy endeavor. His melodies, lau also has not used Carlebach’s name for years, but said district, the neighborhood known for birthing the 1960s
recorded from 1959 until his death in 1994, often are the people do not always know which tunes are Carlebach’s, counterculture movement. “They open our hearts to
most recognizable tunes to common Jewish prayers — and that it is difficult to manage every melody in Orthodox connecting with Hashem, with Torah, with other human
particularly the Friday night service welcoming Shabbat. services, which often are led by lay members. beings. They’re so much a part of who we are today
Synagogues often host “Carlebach services” comprised “I’m dealing with real human beings in a communal set- as Jews.”
largely of his tunes. ting,” Kornblau said. “If I were to use language like ‘prohi- Carlebach will endure as a major influence on Jewish
For a time, Carlebach based himself out of San Fran- bition,’ I would have to take some prayer leader who goes music despite the allegations, Joey Weisenberg, a Jewish
cisco, and his music, which combines chasidic and folk into a song and, A, know it was from Carlebach, and B, composer whose Americana-inspired melodies are grow-
influences, was a Jewish touchstone of the 1960s coun- stop him in public. I’m not going to do that.” ing in popularity, said. Weisenberg said that “it’s not pos-
terculture. His song “Am Yisrael Chai” (“The Nation of These rabbis are, in a way, confronting the same ques- sible to ignore the melodies and the spirituality and the
Israel Lives”) served as an anthem for the movement to tion that has occupied the creative world since the wave community empowerment and the beauty that Carlebach
free Soviet Jewry. He also developed a personal mythol- of misconduct allegations against industry figures began unleashed in the world,” but that Carlebach also betrayed
ogy and a dedicated following, and at concerts he would last year: Is it possible to separate the art from the art- his responsibility as an iconic Jewish musician.
intersperse his songs with intimate stories. ist? Some say yes. Other activists, however, believe that “When we open our hearts in song, we have to take
Recognizing the pervasiveness of Carlebach’s music, because Carlebach was a spiritual leader who wrote melo- care of each other,” Weisenberg said. “The story we really
some synagogues continue to sing his songs but don’t dies for prayers — and worshippers use those melodies in tell is about the power of music and spiritual life in the
refer to him by name or share his stories. The modern the act of prayer — his work carries more moral weight world, and how we need to treat that power with extreme
Orthodox Anshe Sholom B’nai Israel Congregation in Chi- than a movie. care. Shlomo Carlebach had an immense musical spiritual
cago still hosts a Carlebach service but has not used his “I think there’s a huge difference between Woody Allen power, and clearly he misused and abused that power.”
name for years. The synagogue’s rabbi, David Wolkenfeld, and someone who used spirituality and religion and God’s JTA WIRE SERVICE
(Dave), and Mitchell (Nicole); nieces and nephews, and Donations can be made to United Jewish Appeal. Gary Schoem – Manager - NJ Lic. 3811
Jordan E. Schoem – Funeral Director - NJ Lic. 5146
friend, Wayne Reisner. Arrangements were by Louis Suburban Chapel, Fair Lawn.
Conveniently Located
Donations can be sent to www.gofundme.com/melanie- W-150 Route 4 East • Paramus, NJ 07652
children-fund. Arrangements were by Robert Schoem’s Samuel Sternberg 201.843.9090 1.800.426.5869
Menorah Chapel, Paramus. Samuel Myron “Mike” Sternberg, 80, of Monroe
Township, formerly of Bayonne, died January 29.
Marilyn Hillman Born in Bayonne, he was a manager in fast
Marilyn Hillman, née Heller, 89, of West Orange, formerly food restaurants.
of Florida, New Milford, Bergenfield, and Teaneck, died He is survived by children, Charles of Monmouth
January 29. Junction, Mark of Marlton, Alan of Forked River,and Shari
She worked at Huffman and Boyle Furniture and Crystal of Maryland, and seven grandchildren.
Clear Importing. Arrangements were by Eden Memorial Chapel, Fort Lee.
HANDYMAN ANTIQUES
CHHA with New Jersey and NY HOME REPAIRS
lics. looking for 24/7 live-in posi-
tiion. 9 years experience. Referen-
Your Neighbor with Tools
ces. Lt cooking/cleaning. 908-275-
7728 Home Improvements & Handyman Sterling Associates Auctions
Shomer Shabbat · Free Estimates
Over 20 Years Experience SEEKING CONSIGNMENT AND OUT RIGHT PURCHASES Electrical
Adam 201-675-0816
[email protected] · NJ Lic. #13VH05023300
Sculpture • Paintings • Porcelain • Silver Plumbing
Jewelry • Furniture • Etc.
and
Instagram: yourneighborwithtools
ROOFING
TOP CASH PRICES PAID All Home
ROOFING · SIDING
HACKENSACK GUTTERS · LEADERS
201-768-1140 • www.antiquenj.com Repairs
Free ROOFING
OOFING Roof [email protected]
Estimates CO. Repairs 70 Herbert Avenue, Closter, N.J. 07642
INC.
201-487-5050 83 FIRST STREET
HACKENSACK, NJ 07601 FREE APPRAISALS TUESDAYS FROM 12-2
IN OUR GALLERY. CALL FOR APPOINTMENT.
ANTIQUES
Call us.
We’re waiting
Antiques Wanted We pay cash for
for your
Antique Furniture
WE BUY Modern Furniture classified ad!
Modern Art (201) 837-8818
• Oil Paintings • Silver
Paintings
• Bronzes • Porcelain
Bronzes ❖ Silver
• Oriental Rugs • Furniture Dear Rabbi
Chinese Porcelain & Art FrOM PaGe 47
• Marble Sculpture • Jewelry Men’s & Women’s Watches you are considering informing people directly or via
• Tiffany Items • Chandeliers Top Dollar for any kind of social media.
And by the way, do you want people to pray for your
• Chinese Art • Bric-A-Brac Jewelry, including costume recovery? Because when people become aware of your
illness, some will offer their prayers.
There are those who will argue that prayers for a
BY APPOINTMENT
t TEANECK t
1st Time Offered. Mostly Brick Tri-Lev/136' Deep Prop. Lg LR, DR,
EIK, 3 Season Prch. Mstr BR/Bth + 2 more BRs (2.5 Bths Tot). Fin
Bsmt. Tandem Gar. Unlimited Poss! $329,900
Spacious 4 BR, 2.5 Bth Bi-Lev/Quiet Cul-de-sac. Lg LR open to
A FABULOUS LIFESTYLE AWAITS YOU Form DR, Mod EIK. Tiled Fam Rm, Deck. C/A/C, Sprinks, Portable
Generator, 2 Car Gar. Room to Expand. $574,900
24 hour concierge • Valet parking • Movie theater
‘Big Game’ leftovers State of the art health club with indoor and outdoor pools t NEW MILFORD t
can be donated Close to everything • And more Lov Street. Spacious 3 Brm, 2.5 Bth Col. LR open to DR, EIK, Game
Rm Bsmt. Huge Party Deck. Gar. $445,000
to Shearit HaPlate ■ 2 BR 2.5 Baths. Full river view. Low floor. On the ALL CLOSE TO NY BUS / HOUSES OF WORSHIP /
After Sunday night’s football game is over, consider popular J line. $499,000 HIGHWAYS / SHOPS / SCHOOLS
donating any kosher catered or takeout food, includ- ■ 1 BR 1.5 Baths. Spectacular river view. Renovated For Our Full Inventory including
ing fruit and crudite to Shearit HaPlate. The organiza- Details & Pictures, Visit our Website
kitchen, updated bathrooms, hardwood floors. Low
tion will distribute it within 24 hours to its 60 recipient www.RussoRealEstate.com
floor. $274,900
families who receive kosher prepared food each week.
■ 1 BR 1.5 Baths. Renovated kitchen. Hardwood floors (201) 837-8800
For quick and easy pickup, call Daniel Chazin,
throughout. Priced to sell. $119,900
pickup coordinator, at (201) 835-5338 or email
[email protected].
Allan Dorfman
To become a weekly recipient, send a confidential Broker/Associate More than 412,000 likes.
email to [email protected].
201-461-6764 Eve
To volunteer for packing food on weekday mornings
or to help with pickups, email shp.packers@gmail.
201-970-4118 Cell Like us on Facebook.
201-585-8080 Office
com or [email protected]. [email protected] facebook.com/jewishstandard
Jewish standard FeBrUarY 2, 2018 57
Real Estate & Business
A new Chinese-
Israeli incubator
has opened in Xia-
men, a city in Chi-
na’s southeastern
province of Fuijan.
The incubator is
run by Innovare,
a partnership
founded in 2015
by Jiang Baroqi of
Innovation Con-
nect (Xiamen)
Technologies and
Gabriel Simons, Consul General Nadav Cohen and Vice Mayor Li Huiyue
who divides his at the inauguration ceremony.
time between
China, Israel, and London. The incubator’s launch last week, at Xia-
The incubator is different than others in men’s Software Park, was attended by
Call Susan Laskin Today
both China and Israel in that it focuses Israel’s Consul General for the Guang-
To Make Your Next Move A Successful One!
on projects rather than startups. zhou region Nadav Cohen, Xiamen’s
BergenCountyRealEstateSource.com Cell: 201-615-5353 Startup incubators “work very well in Vice Mayor Li Huiyue, and leaders of
©2018 Coldwell Banker Real Estate LLC. Coldwell Banker is a registered trademark licensed to Coldwell Banker Real Estate LLC. Israel because Israel has developed the Xiamen municipality and local busi-
An Equal Opportunity Company. Equal Housing Opportunity. Owned and Operated by NRT LLC.
a startup ecosystem which feeds and nesses. The building has 650 square
feeds off of these incubators,” Simons meters of floor space and a large exhibi-
NVE-3490 1Q Mug Mortgage Ad 5x6.5_NVE-3454 Fall Mortgage Ad 5x6.5 1/24/18 11:15 AM Page 1 says. “In China however, many of these tion hall.
startup incubators have simply become “With a huge market, strong capital
property plays, with landlords subletting and production capabilities, China
to startups and seeing a rental return as will become a perfect partner for tech-
Finding the right mortgage to fit your needs should be quick, easy and
Jimmy J
J
painless — exactly what you’ll find when you work with our Mortgage
Specialist at NVE. Plus, our decision makers are local — paving the way
to a smooth and hassle-free process from start to finish.
18 8
87 201
201-661-4940
insurance is required. Other rates and terms are available. Subject to credit approval.
Bergenfield I Closter I Cresskill I Englewood I Hillsdale I Leonia I New Milford I Teaneck I Tenafly
We do not transport solid or hazardous waste
We d
411 CUMBERLAND STREET $1,198,000 PALISADES PLACE, 119-A 250 WALNUT STREET 320 MOUNTAIN ROAD $5,500,000
J J J J
SO UST SO UST SO UST SO UST
LD LD LD LD
! ! ! !
THE ROOSEVELT TUDOR TERRACE 132 LYDECKER STREET 140 LYDECKER STREET
OP FAN SO SO SO
PO TA LD LD LD
RT STI ! ! !
UN C
ITY
!
543 RIDGELAND TERRACE $688,000 286 BOOTH AVENUE 212 MAPLE STREET 161 BRAYTON STREET
SO SO SO SO
LD LD LD LD
! ! ! !
184 SHERWOOD PLACE 185 MAPLE STREET 401 DOUGLAS STREET 32 SUTTON PLACE
SO SO SO SO
LD LD LD LD
! ! ! !
35 KING STREET 440 ELKWOOD TERRACE 113 EAST HUDSON AVENUE 341 MOUNTAIN ROAD
SO SO SO SO
LD LD LD LD
! ! ! !
400 JONES ROAD 285 MORROW ROAD 215 EAST LINDEN AVENUE 248 CHESTNUT STREET