United States v. Microsoft
United States v. Microsoft
United States v. Microsoft
- - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - -
UNITED STATES, )
Petitioner, )
v. ) No. 17-2
MICROSOFT CORPORATION, )
Respondent. )
- - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - -
Pages: 1 through 64
2 - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - -
3 UNITED STATES, )
4 Petitioner, )
5 v. ) No. 17-2
6 MICROSOFT CORPORATION, )
7 Respondent. )
8 - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - -
10 Washington, D.C.
12
15 at 10:21 a.m.
16
17 APPEARANCES:
23
24
25
1 C O N T E N T S
3 MICHAEL R. DREEBEN
9 MICHAEL R. DREEBEN
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
1 P R O C E E D I N G S
2 (10:21 a.m.)
6 Mr. Dreeben.
24 materials over.
11 keyboards -
1 information.
5 prohibits it.
21 application?
3 extraterritorial.
10 abroad.
18 required here.
10
2 statute.
8 antecedent conduct.
12 position?
19 application.
11
9 extraterritorial conduct.
12 Ginsburg's question.
23 locations.
12
16 new age -
20 create?
13
24 be located.
14
5 international obligations.
17 status quo.
15
16
4 And as to the -
16 the data.
22 safeguards.
17
15 understanding territorially.
23 the difference.
18
1 that.
16 driver's seat.
19
2 and a warrant.
16 orders.
21 disclosure.
20
2 executed.
11 not warrants.
21
22
19 2703.
23
3 implicated.
24
25
21 think.
23 did.
25 district judge?
26
2 court -
15 investigated -
19 Rule 45.
27
8 something.
11 then?
15 is the answer?
28
2 not here -
5 if there is -
14 more -
29
30
15 you say -
22 MR. DREEBEN: So -
31
8 here -
11 overseas?
17 information by providers.
32
9 for rebuttal.
11 counsel.
12 Mr. Rosenkranz.
33
2 --
16 country.
34
10 evidence.
35
18 focus is at step 2.
23 that argument.
36
4 in storage.
14 done.
37
3 countries.
24 correct?
38
12 respond urgently.
39
3 account.
8 that?
14 weighing -
24 standards.
40
3 question?
10 standard.
21 2702?
41
3 by a subpoena?
16 subpoena?
23 point is -
42
23 extraterritorial -- extraterritorially to
43
1 United States?
19 act.
25 to fetch them.
44
14 intervention?
45
2 foreign interests.
7 running wild.
8 (Laughter.)
46
10 would be in Ireland.
13 it would want to do -
47
15 is -
48
11 tail -
15 overseas?
49
24 It's 99.9 -
50
12 government?
51
14 Justice Alito.
52
11 someplace.
22 movable as well.
53
5 in electronic storage.
18 provisions.
54
4 saying.
14 (Laughter.)
17 shots.
55
4 warrant.
7 storage.
56
18 are protected.
20 2702.
57
4 right?
10 head?
19 district.
24 --
58
2 requires a warrant.
6 Criminal Procedure."
24 --
59
2 (Laughter.)
5 this case.
8 in our brief.
10 -
12 -
18 question.
60
1 extraterritorial.
61
5 international tensions.
13 Second Circuit.
15 counsel.
62
10 other bases.
13 issue orders.
63
64
4 was submitted.)
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
65
Official - Subject to Final Review
�
account [7] 5:6,9 6:12 29:21 39:3, answer [15] 24:25 27:15,16,19 33: backdrop [2] 7:7 8:2
1 23 51:12 25 34:18 38:16 39:16 40:5 50:14 backs [1] 63:9
10:21 [2] 1:15 3:2 achieves [1] 5:19 56:9 57:21 58:14,14 61:2 bank [2] 27:3,6
11:22 [1] 64:3 across [2] 34:23 60:15 answered [2] 11:11 50:2 banking [1] 17:5
12A [1] 62:6 Act [27] 3:12,20 4:21,22 7:6,20 15: answers [1] 42:19 banks [1] 17:7
15 [1] 56:23 12,21 21:22 22:1 26:11 30:7 32: antecedent [2] 10:8,17 barred [1] 62:18
17-2 [1] 3:4 19,21 33:20 34:2,20 36:1 40:11, anticipates [1] 10:7 based [1] 16:1
18.1a [1] 14:13 18 43:19 46:25 48:19 55:11,21 56: anybody [2] 18:13,15 baseline [1] 14:14
180 [2] 41:11 42:9 10 62:11 anyplace [1] 52:9 bases [1] 62:10
1958 [2] 7:9 29:12 action [1] 63:12 anyway [1] 47:19 basic [8] 7:10 23:4 26:10 36:1 48:
1986 [6] 6:3,11,20 11:13,14 60:6 actions [2] 42:21,22 apart [2] 16:24 18:10 16 50:1 53:1 55:10
1987 [1] 7:10 active [2] 17:6 48:9 appealing [1] 24:9 basically [2] 8:11 62:22
2 activity [2] 9:17 10:15 appeals [1] 24:11 begins [1] 63:6
2 35:18
[1] acts [1] 47:14 APPEARANCES [1] 1:17 behalf [8] 1:20,22 2:4,7,10 3:8 32:
20 [1] 13:2 actual [1] 9:25 appendix [2] 62:4,6 14 61:18
200 [3] 48:9,22 49:16 actually [17] 3:17 4:12,19 16:12 application [7] 7:21 8:4,7,25 9:8 believe [2] 34:23 46:18
2010 33:17
[1] 18:4 21:2 28:25 30:20 33:20 36: 10:19 11:4 below [2] 21:1,7
25 37:14,15 43:10 48:21 49:8 52: applied [1] 29:23 best [3] 49:6,17 54:13
2018 [1] 1:11
27 [2] 1:11 57:22 2,20 applies [2] 19:18 40:16 between [4] 4:23 35:6 53:24 54:
2701 30:21 31:1,13 55:9 56:4
[5] adapt [1] 39:19 apply [1] 22:1 10
2702 [13] 30:21 31:14 40:21,23 55: add [1] 17:1 approach [1] 23:21 big [1] 41:5
9 56:4,4,5,13,14,15,20 62:18
adding [1] 22:22 approached [1] 9:23 bilateral [1] 16:18
2703 [27] 3:11 13:15,22 16:25 19: address [3] 17:1 21:13 63:10 architecture [1] 60:20 bill [5] 12:8,15 14:23 15:5 16:9
19 20:20 22:15,19,21 30:14,18 31:
addressed [1] 21:17 area [1] 17:5 billion [1] 49:4
20 53:10,13 54:12,18,19 55:2,9,18
addresses [3] 12:18 20:24 31:20 areas [1] 22:18 billions [1] 60:14
56:2,4,13,19 61:25 62:21 63:6
adds [1] 32:3 aren't [2] 22:18 35:8 binary [2] 35:6,13
2703(a [1] 57:23 adopting [1] 40:9 argue [1] 30:19 bipartisan [2] 12:9 14:25
2703(d 18:24[1] Aerospatiale [2] 7:9 39:23 arguing [3] 8:6 14:15 35:19 bit [2] 22:14 26:7
Affairs [1] 13:12 argument [13] 1:14 2:2,5,8 3:4,7 block [1] 50:10
3 affirm [1] 61:12 10:4 30:14 32:13 35:20,21,23 61: blocking [1] 29:17
3 [1] 2:4 age [1] 12:16 17 blocks [1] 31:2
32 [1] 2:7 agree [9] 6:2,19 7:19 32:18 42:9, arguments [1] 6:5 both [3] 5:19 7:11 25:1
35 [1] 13:22 12 52:15,16 58:18 around [2] 24:1 52:13 bothering [1] 25:1
agreed [1] 15:16 aside [5] 14:22 20:18 46:7,8,19 box [1] 44:3
4 agreeing [1] 29:1 asks [1] 60:3 branch [1] 17:7
41 [9] 18:9 19:11,11,12 20:15 22:8 agreement [1] 28:11 aspect [1] 5:7 brave [3] 6:16 36:5 55:13
57:7 58:11,12 agrees [2] 46:4 53:15 asserted [1] 28:22 break [2] 51:7 61:8
41-B-1 [1] 58:11 ahead [1] 46:16 assertion [1] 30:2 breaks [1] 37:15
45 [1] 26:19 algorithms [1] 23:25 assets [1] 10:24 BREYER [39] 21:18 24:22 25:10,
5 Alito [18] 9:4 21:20 23:8 24:6 36: Assistance [1] 13:20 12,24 26:3,6,8,16,20,25 27:10,14,
10 37:10,22 38:2 47:8,16,18 51: associated [1] 20:10 19 28:1,4,7,10,15 38:13 39:10,15
50 [1] 14:7
10,14,15 52:5,17 59:9,13 assume [3] 14:18 31:18 48:25 40:5 56:21,24,25 57:6,12,15,25
54 49:23
[1]
allowed [1] 53:17 assumed [1] 57:7 58:3,8,13,19,25 59:3,6,19 61:22
6 allowing [1] 5:8 assuming [2] 14:22 33:25 brief [7] 30:14 39:25 45:15 59:1,8
60,000 [2] 49:21,23 allows [6] 19:24 20:13 23:4 26:12 assure [1] 49:11 62:4,7
61 [1] 2:10 63:13,22 Atlantic [1] 43:17 briefs [1] 13:6
6A [1] 62:3 alludes [1] 12:3 attention [1] 61:11 bring [2] 11:5 28:8
alone [1] 23:12 author [1] 55:2 broader [2] 6:1 54:12
9 alphabet [1] 45:24 authority [11] 14:9 16:10 25:16,16 broken [1] 36:25
99.9 [1] 49:24 already [1] 55:3 26:18 57:17 58:16 61:22,23 62:12, brought [2] 18:3 49:18
A alternative [2] 3:22 4:14 23 Budapest [3] 14:6,13,21
although [1] 59:23 authorization [1] 18:11 build [2] 22:21 49:5
a.m [3] 1:15 3:2 64:3
amended [2] 6:21 55:21 authorize [1] 4:9 building [1] 50:5
ability [7] 14:1 15:18 16:13,19,20
Amendment [2] 54:25 62:11 authorized [2] 6:23 62:19 built-in [1] 17:1
20:22 59:24
American [2] 36:16,20 authorizes [2] 5:22 46:22 bunch [1] 13:6
able [4] 42:16 48:2 49:13 59:21
Americans [1] 36:8 available [2] 50:19 51:6 burdensomeness [1] 20:9
above-entitled [1] 1:13
amici [3] 13:4,6 27:20 avoids [1] 20:12 button [2] 44:5,18
abroad [10] 8:20 9:10,14,15 10:18,
amicus [1] 45:15 away [1] 24:13
25 11:20 12:13 31:23 49:23
analogous [1] 5:10
C
absolutely [2] 27:5 42:11
analysis [4] 27:17 29:3,21 35:15
B call [1] 39:13
access [10] 15:3 17:8 31:2 34:25 B-1 [2] 57:8,16 called [2] 15:21 48:20
analyzed 33:18 [1]
35:4 48:1 49:13 50:7 54:20 55:3 back [13] 7:7 8:22 11:18 12:23 14: came [1] 1:13
angles [1] 26:9
accesses [1] 44:6 19 24:24 30:12 42:6 46:1 52:25 Canada [2] 47:24 50:18
another [4] 33:15 41:5 45:25 48:
accordance [1] 63:12 55:8 56:2 60:9 cannot [1] 56:3
19
complete [1] 63:16 16 37:2 60:8 device [2] 22:23 51:5 49:2 50:3 51:12
17 46:15,18,25 48:17 57:17 58:16 language [6] 5:20 9:24 25:3 30:13 material [1] 42:10 needs [2] 5:17 22:11
it'll [1] 39:6 Laughter [3] 45:8 54:14 59:2 meaning [1] 4:15 Nobody [1] 28:25
Italian [1] 28:4 law [36] 7:4,4,7,11 8:16,18 10:14 meant [2] 22:15,21 noncompliance [1] 29:10
18:3,4
1,4 47:22 48:10 49:17,21 52:2 54: will [10] 10:21 16:18 24:14 27:24
theoretically [1] 48:6 1,9 59:25 63:2 34:14 37:8 39:5 52:14 54:15 60:
theory [1] 31:23 unless [2] 8:3 48:2 23
there's [18] 6:8 9:17 12:8 14:19,20 Unlike [1] 17:17 willing [1] 31:18
15:10 21:21 23:11 28:11 30:3 36: unqualified [1] 16:13 wires [1] 43:17