Due Diligence in Concept With Financial Due Diligence
Due Diligence in Concept With Financial Due Diligence
Due Diligence in Concept With Financial Due Diligence
Imagine you are buying a house. The owners tell you that they are interested in selling
because they are close to retirement and want to downsize to an apartment in the city.
They also assure you that, other than a few minor cosmetic repairs, the house is in great
condition. Would you, or any other home buyer, simply take the owners’ word that the
house will be a great investment for you?
Of course not! You would do your own research on the property, as well as contact a
professional such as a home inspector, to ensure that there weren’t any nasty surprises
lurking beneath the surface. If you do this for your home purchase, why wouldn’t you do
so for your business? And yet a surprising number of people buying businesses fail to
complete the necessary steps to ensure that the company they are purchasing is as sound
and profitable as the current owners claim.
Due diligence in relation to buying a business is when the potential buyer thoroughly
investigates the business. Its operations, profits, accounting, and workforce—these are
some examples of the areas of the business that can and should be subjected to due
diligence.
One of the benefits of completing your due diligence before purchasing a business is that
you are able to obtain a clearer picture of the health of the business while ensuring that
information that would prevent you from purchasing the business comes to light. A
business seller, for example, could tell you that the business always makes a profit and
the reason for sale is the death of another owner. However, on closer inspection, it could
be possible that the real reason the seller is getting rid of the business is that it has
consistently lost money over the last few years. Knowing the truth ahead of time could
save you from purchasing a “black hole” business—one that will consume your
resources, energy, and money without a future payoff.
Another way that your due diligence can help you make the right purchasing decision is
that it reveals the status of the company’s books. A close inspection of the debits and
credits in the accounting records could reveal modified figures designed to make the
business more attractive to buyers. Worse, you may discover that the business owes a
large amount of debt to suppliers, distributors, or even the IRS. Completing due diligence
on a business’s accounting records and practices can give you a clearer picture of the
profitability of the company and ensure that you aren’t “inheriting” a large amount of
debt with the purchase.
Due diligence gives you the reliable and verified information you need to make a smart
purchasing choice. Before you sink thousands, or even millions, into a business, consult a
qualified attorney who can help you navigate both the due diligence and purchasing
processes.
1. General:
Measure of prudence, responsibility, and diligence that is expected from, and ordinarily
exercised by, a reasonable and prudent person under the circumstances.
2. Business:
Duty of a firm's directors and officers to act prudently in evaluating associated risks in
all transactions.
3. Investing:
Duty of the investor to gather necessary information on actual or potential risks involved
in an investment.
4. Negotiating:
Duty of each party to confirm each other's expectations and understandings, and to
independently verify the abilities of the other to fulfill the conditions and requirements of
the agreement.
Due diligence became common practice (and a common term) in the U.S. with the
passage of the Securities Act of 1933. Securities dealers and brokers became responsible
for fully disclosing material information related to the instruments they were selling.
Failing to disclose this information to potential investors made dealers and brokers liable
for criminal prosecution. However, creators of the Act understood that requiring full
disclosure left the securities dealers and brokers vulnerable to unfair prosecution if they
did not disclose a material fact they did not possess or could not have known at the time
of sale. As a means of protecting them, the Act included a legal defense that stated that as
long as the dealers and brokers exercised "due diligence" when investigating companies
whose equities they were selling, and fully disclosed their results to investors, they would
not be held liable for information not discovered during the investigation.
A standard part of an initial public offering is the due diligence meeting, a process of
careful investigation by an underwriter to ensure that all material information pertinent to
the security issue has been disclosed to prospective investors. Before issuing a final
prospectus, the underwriter, issuer and other individuals involved (such as accountants,
syndicate members, and attorneys),will gather to discuss whether the underwriter and
issuer have exercised due diligence toward state and federal securities laws.
Due Diligence is the assessment that a prudent person might be expected to exercise in
the examination and evaluationof risks affecting a business transaction. It should be the
first step taken before embarking on any successful national or international business
venture.
A question may arise why due diligence should be conducted. There are many reasons for
doing so, including the following:
ü Identifying potential "deal killer" defects in the target and avoiding a bad business
transaction;
ü Gaining information that will be useful for valuing assets, defining representations
and warranties, and/or negotiating price concessions; and
Due diligence involves a number of different areas of investigation. For example, the
company’s financial status will be assessed by accountants and the pension arrangements
will be the subject of an actuarial review. Due diligence is the necessary amount of
diligence required in a professional activity to avoid being negligent. This commonly
arises in major acquisitions where the legal principle of caveat emptor (let the buyer
beware) requires the purchaser to make a diligent survey of the property or service.
The approach to due diligence depends on the type of transaction and what is intended to
be achieved. Due diligence may be of various types:
ü Commercial due diligence – review of industry, market, and the business model of
the issuer.
ü Reputational due diligence – review of credit worthiness and reputation of individual
counterparties.
ü Financial, Accounting & Tax due diligence – review of tax, financial position,
policies and internal controls.
ü Legal due diligence – review of documentation to identify potential legal issues that
may be risks/impediments to the (i) transaction or (ii) in the general operations of the
issuer, that may affect the value or consideration in connection with the transaction.
ü Operations Due Diligence - review of all operations and their role, utilisation &
capacity of each operation.
A little due diligence can go a long way in protecting the business capital and reputation.
There is no substitute for a thorough investigation. In these days of strict adherence to
regulations, territory.
It is very much necessary that the scope of DDR is determined in consultation with the
client. It is not confined to financial due diligence but extends to operational due
diligence, market due diligence, technical due diligence, legal due diligence, systems due
diligence, etc. all of which form an integral part of the overall due diligence exercise.
3. To ensure the compliance of necessary statutes and ascertain the liability in the
event of non-compliance.
7. Assess the quality of management and identifying key employees of the Target
Company.
13. An examination being achieved by asking certain key questions, including, how
do we buy, how do we structure an acquisition, and how much do we pay?
The due diligence process (framework) can be divided into nine distinct areas:-
It is essential that the concepts of valuations (shareholder value analysis) be linked into a
due diligence process. This is in order to reduce the number of failed mergers and
acquisitions.
In this regard, two new audit areas have been incorporated into the Due Diligence
framework:
the Compatibility Audit which deals with the strategic components of the transaction and
in particular the need to add shareholder value and
the Reconciliation audit, which links/consolidates other audit areas together via a formal
valuation in order to test whether shareholder value will be added.
The relevant areas of concern may include the financial, legal, labor, tax, IT, environment
and market/commercial situation of the company. Other areas include intellectual
property, real and personal property, insurance and liability coverage, debt instrument
review, employee benefits (including the Affordable Care Act) and labor matters,
immigration, and international transactions. Areas of focus in due diligence continue to
develop with cybersecurity emerging as an area of concern for business acquirers. Due
diligence findings impact a number of aspects of the transaction including the purchase
price, the representations and warranties negotiated in the transaction agreement, and the
indemnification provided by the sellers.
Due Diligence has emerged as a separate profession for accounting and auditing experts.
With the number and size of penalties increasing, the Foreign Corrupt Practices Act
(FCPA) is causing many U.S. institutions to look into how they evaluate all of their
relationships overseas. The lack of a due diligence of a company’s agents, vendors, and
suppliers, as well as merger and acquisition partners in foreign countries could lead to
doing business with an organization linked to a foreign official or state owned enterprises
and their executives. This link could be perceived as leading to the bribing of the foreign
officials and as a result lead to noncompliance with the FCPA. Due diligence in regard to
FCPA compliance is required in two aspects:
Initial due diligence – this step is necessary in evaluating what risk is involved in
doing business with an entity prior to establishing a relationship and assesses risk at that
point in time.
In the M&A context, buyers can use the due diligence phase to integrate a target into their
internal FCPA controls, focusing initial efforts on necessary revisions to the target's
business activities with a high-risk of corruption.
While financial institutions are among the most aggressive in defining FCPA best
practices, manufacturing, retailing and energy industries are highly active in managing
FCPA compliance programs.
HUMAN RIGHTS.
Passed on May 25, 2011, the OECD member countries agreed to revise their guidelines
promoting tougher standards of corporate behavior, including human rights. As part of
this new definition, they utilized a new aspect of due diligence that requires a corporation
to investigate third party partners for potential abuse of human rights.
In the OECD Guidelines for Multinational Enterprises document, it is stated that all
members will “Seek ways to prevent or mitigate adverse human rights impacts that are
directly linked to their business operations, products or services by a business
relationship, even if they do not contribute to those impacts”.
The term was originally put forth by UN Special Representative for Human Rights and
Business John Ruggie, who uses it as an umbrella to cover the steps and processes by
which a company understands, monitors and mitigates its human rights impacts. Human
Rights Impact Assessment is a component of this.
The UN formalized guidelines for Human Rights Due Diligence on June 16 with the
endorsement of Ruggie’s Guiding Principles for Business and Human Rights.
CIVIL LITIGATION.
Due diligence in civil procedure is the idea that reasonable investigation is necessary
before certain kinds of relief are requested.
For example, duly diligent efforts to locate and/or serve a party with civil process is
frequently a requirement for a party seeking to use means other than personal service to
obtain jurisdiction over a party. Similarly, in areas of the law such as bankruptcy, an
attorney representing someone filing a bankruptcy petition must engage in due diligence
to determine that the representations made in the bankruptcy petition are factually
accurate. Due diligence is also generally prerequisite to a request for relief in states where
civil litigants are permitted to conduct pre-litigation discovery of facts necessary to
determine whether or not a party has a factual basis for a cause of action.
In civil actions seeking a foreclosure or seizure of property, a party requesting this relief
is frequently required to engage in due diligence to determine who may claim an interest
in the property by reviewing public records concerning the property and sometimes by a
physical inspection of the property that would reveal a possible interest in the property of
a tenant or other person.
Due diligence is also a concept found in the civil litigation concept of a statute of
limitations. Frequently, a statute of limitations begins to run against a plaintiff when that
plaintiff knew or should have known had that plaintiff investigated the matter with due
diligence that the plaintiff had a claim against a defendant. In this context, the term “due
diligence” determines the scope of a party’s constructive knowledge, upon receiving
notice of facts sufficient to constitute “inquiry notice” that alerts a would-be plaintiff that
further investigation might reveal a cause of action.
CRIMINAL LAW.
In criminal law, due diligence is the only available defense to a crime that is one of strict
liability (i.e., a crime that only requires an actus reus and no mens rea). Once the criminal
offence is proven, the defendant must prove on balance that they did everything possible
to prevent the act from happening. It is not enough that they took the normal standard of
care in their industry – they must show that they took every reasonable precaution.
Due diligence is also used in criminal law to describe the scope of the duty of a
prosecutor, to take efforts to turn over potentially exculpatory evidence, to (accused)
criminal defendants.
In criminal law, “due diligence” also identifies the standard a prosecuting entity must
satisfy in pursuing an action against a defendant, especially with regard to the provision
of the Federal and State Constitutional and statutory right to a speedy trial or to have a
warrant or detainer served in an action. In cases where a defendant is in any type of
custodial situation where their freedom is constrained, it is solely the prosecuting entities
duty to ensure the provision of such rights and present the citizen before the court with
jurisdiction. This also applies where the respective judicial system and/or prosecuting
entity has current address or contact information on the named party and said party has
made no attempt to evade notice of the prosecution of the action.
India presents a complex economic, regulatory, and legal landscape for doing business.
Consequently, the success of a business venture in India is dependent on a company’s
ability to traverse the Indian business landscape. A company’s success is in turn linked to
the risk management and mitigation strategy that it undertakes. It is in this regard that due
diligence becomes a powerful tool that companies may utilize when dealing with Indian
businesses. Due diligence ensures that a company is able to manage the risk prior to
entering into a business transaction.
1.A company that plans to trade with an Indian company should verify that the business is
what it appears to be. This is vital in India, where several companies sprout up every day
with the sole motive of duping prospective clients and businesses. For example, in April
2016,pretend chit-fund companies (institutions which promote low interest rates and lend
money for houses and other purchases) were found to have cheated depositors out of U.S
12.2 billion (Rs 800 billion). This indicates a mala fide intent in the transaction, and
while such cases might be easier to identify in the preliminary stages of due diligence,
some scenarios require more in-depth exploration of the business.
2.The scenarios that require extended due diligence include identifying potential deal
destroyers”. This involves studying Indian companies’ financial health, including their
track record of bin payment their creditworthiness, and their standards of
compartmentalization and international regulatory and statutory requirements. Due
diligence of this nature is particularly important in India, where the tax regime is
extremely fragmented and companies often deal with business entitles from other states
within India that have different payment norms and taxes.
A company that wants to collaborate with an Indian company often needs to perform
extensive due diligence in comparison to trading with one. The nature of the transaction
while trading, including selling and purchasing goods and services, acts as an inherent
check on the risks. This requires that a foreign company undertake all aspects of due
diligence required for trading with Indian companies, such as a thorough assessment of
legal scope to check compatibility. In addition, companies should procure information
that aids in the valuation of assets and in negotiating price concessions. Finally, the due
diligence should verify that the proposed business transaction complies with the
mandated investment and acquisition criteria.
Independent reports note that countries that are more developed on average tend to have
less corruption and more transparency, which makes it easier to verify information that is
found. In turn, the presence of multiple government offices, which also act as public
offices of records, make information easily accessible to a business that wishes to
conduct due diligence. However, another factor that intricately linked to the accessibility
of information is the efficiency of such offices in maintaining information records. This is
dependent on the archiving and filing processes that such offices follow, as well as the
level information of records that they have undertaken. Developed countries often have
an excellent record of accomplishment on the aforementioned parameters as they have
access to superior IT Infrastructure. However, pushing towards digitization with
government initiatives such as ‘Digital India’ will help India close the gap in terms of
procuring and providing vital information digitally.
·2 Identify potential “deal destroyer” defects in the target and avoid a bad business
transaction
·6 Gain information that will be useful for valuing assets, defining representations
and warranties, and/or negotiating price concessions
·14 A ‘big picture’ of the vision of the target company and its future earnings;
To ensure best results there are certain steps that should be taken into consideration:
·18 Clearly, define the objective make firm and clear strategies;
·19 Form groups of personnel for project management, data management, core due
diligence team and support team;
·20 Lay down the terms of reference for each group and formulate procedures for a
clear allocation of responsibilities;
·21 Observe an integrated approach for the due diligence process and rely on
technical consultants’ expertise wherever necessary;
·22 Use appropriate technology for the collection, analysis, indexing and retrieval of
data;
·23 Store the data in electronic form which makes it portable, capable of being
transferred to and accessed from remote locations, and providing a single point
access to the entire transaction team;
·25 Always insist on plant visits – the on-site conditions contain a wealth of
information which would be never be available on paper;
·26 Due diligence should be continued until after the transaction is completed; and
·27 Take media reports in stride, do not value them too much nor ignore them.
Conducting due diligence is the best way for you to assess the value of a business and the
risks associated with buying it. Due diligence gives you access to important and
confidential information about a business, often within a time period specified in a letter
of intent.
With this information you can assess the business's financial position and identify risks
and ongoing potential. It is your chance to answer any questions you might have about
the business. The due diligence process ensures that you get good value for a business.
Done correctly, it can be the difference between buying a business that makes you money
and buying a business that costs you money.
You should always perform due diligence with the help of your lawyer, accountant or
business adviser.
Investigating a business
Below are detailed steps for individual investors undertaking due diligence. Most are
related to equities, but aspects of these considerations can apply to debt instruments, real
estate and other investments as well.
The first step: determine just how big the company is. The company’s market
capitalization says a lot about how volatile the stock is likely to be, how broad the
ownership might be and the potential size of the company's end markets. For example,
large cap and mega cap companies tend to have more stable revenue streams and a large
more diverse investor base, both of which generally equate to less volatility. Mid cap and
small cap companies, meanwhile, may only serve single areas of the market, and may
have more fluctuations in their stock price and earnings. When you start to examine
revenue and profit figures, the market cap will give you some perspective.
Conversely, the largest, most expensive real estate in any market is generally less liquid
than more average-priced properties.
You should also confirm one other vital fact on this first check: What stock exchange do
the shares trade on? Are they based in the United States (such as the New York Stock
Exchange, Nasdaq, or over the counter)? Or, are they American depositary receipts
(ADRs) with another listing on a foreign exchange? ADRs will typically have the letters
"ADR" written somewhere in the reported title of the share listing. This information
along with market cap should help answer basic questions like whether you can own the
shares in your current investment accounts.
When beginning to look at the numbers, it may be best to start with the revenue and profit
margin (RPM) trends. Understanding a company's gross revenue, profit margins and
return on equity and whether it is growing or shrinking is essential in any equity or
corporate bond investment.
Look up the revenue and net income trends for the past two years at a general finance
website. These should have links to quarterly (for the past 12 months) and annual reports
(past two to three years). Look at the recent trends in both sets of figures, noting whether
growth is choppy or consistent, or if there any major swings (such as more than 50% in
one year) in either direction.
Profit margins should also be reviewed to see if they are generally rising, falling, or
remaining the same. Some investors demand that a company's return on equity plus its
profit margins be equal to 50 or greater – the higher the better. This information will
come into play more during the next step.
Now that you have a feel for how big the company is and how much money it earns, it's
time to size up the industries it operates in and who it competes with. Every company is
partially defined by its competition. Compare the margins of two or three competitors.
Looking at the major competitors in each line of business (if there is more than one) may
help you nail down just how big the end markets for products are. Is the company a
leader in its industry? Is its industry growing overall, and could its position in the field
change?
Information about competitors can be found in company profiles on most major research
sites, usually along with a list of certain metrics filled in for both the company you're
researching and its competitors. If you're still uncertain of how the company's business
model works, you should look to fill in any gaps here before moving further along.
Sometimes just reading about some of the competitors may help to understand what your
target company does.
Step 9: Expectations
This is a sort of a catch-all, and requires some extra digging. Investors should find out
what the consensus of Wall Street analysts for earnings growth, revenue and profit
estimates are for the next two to three years. For real estate, what is the opinion of
professionals regarding future price trends and interest rates? Investors should also
research discussions of long-term trends affecting the industry and company-specific
details about partnerships, joint ventures, intellectual property, and new
products/services. News about a product or service on the horizon may be what initially
turned you on to the stock, and now is the time to examine it more fully with the help of
everything you've accumulated thus far.
Quality of earnings
For obvious reasons, investors are particularly concerned with the fair valuation of the
business. Because businesses are often valued based on a multiple of EBITDA (earnings
before interest, taxes, depreciation and amortization),[5] financial due diligence providers
focus on the “quality,” or sustainability, of the company’s earnings. Unusual or non-
recurring income and expense items, over/understated assets and liabilities, post-closing
cost structure changes, and the inconsistent application of accounting principles are all
analyzed to adjust historical EBITDA to reflect sustainable earnings. The sustainability
of a company’s EBITDA is not reflected in a standard audit report.
Trend analysis
Audit procedures may include analytics to understand trends and relationships over the
historical period, but audit reports do not comment on the market drivers behind those
trends. Financial due diligence reports address key market drivers, sales strategies,
customer relationships and customer churn, and attempt to understand whether the trends
reflected in the financials are sustainable. Financial due diligence providers may also
analyze the target’s cost structure and vendor relationships to identify potential post-
transaction synergies.
Working capital
Buyers and sellers typically negotiate a “target” working capital to be delivered at
transaction close. The negotiated amount is usually based on the average working capital
balances over the previous twelve months, but a sophisticated buyer may also consider
(i) recent growth trends
(ii) industry conditions
(iii) the seasonality of the business
(iv) the specific composition of working capital balances.
An audit report does not provide insight into monthly working capital accounts, putting
the buyer at a significant disadvantage when negotiating the working capital target.
Forecast
Audits are concerned with historical financial statements only. Investors, however, are
more interested in the company’s ability to sustain and grow earnings. For that reason,
investors need to understand the key assumptions used by the company’s management
team in assembling the forecast. Financial due diligence providers often analyze the
company’s forecast and document the key assumptions to enable the investor to assess
the feasibility of that forecast.
Qualitative observations
Perhaps most importantly, the financial due diligence provider may provide the investor
with key qualitative observations from discussions with management. These
observations may include key findings regarding the Company’s internal control
structure, management and accounting team, and accounting information systems.
Qualitative observations rarely appear in audited financial statements, but may be just as
important in helping a buyer make an investment decision.
Summary
An audit provides assurance that management has presented a true and fair view of a
company’s financial performance and position in accordance with well-defined rules and
procedures. For a buyer to make a well-informed investment decision, however, he/she
should understand that an audit is a complement to, rather than a substitute for, a
specifically tailored financial due diligence investigation of the investment target.
Summary of key differences between audits and financial due diligence engagements:
FDD REPORT.
FINANCIAL DUE DILIGENCE REPORT (FDD):-
Financial due diligence is a reasonable level of enquiry into the financial affairs having a
material impact on the prospects of the business.
A FDD reveiws may not only look at the historical financial performance of a business
but will generally consider the forecst performance also.
FDD is about evaluation, interpretation, and communication.
CONCLUSION.
Due diligence is used to investigate and evaluate a business opportunity. The term due
diligence describes a general duty to exercise care in any transaction. As such, it spans
investigation into all relevant aspects of the past, present, and predictable future of the
business of a target company. Due diligence sounds impressive but ultimately it translates
into basic commonsense success factors such as "thinking things through" and "doing
your homework".
There are many reasons for conducting due diligence, including the following:
·105 Confirmation that the business is what it appears to be;
·106 Identify potential "deal killer" defects in the target and avoid a bad
business transaction;
·107 Gain information that will be useful for valuing assets, defining
representations and warranties, and/or negotiating price concessions; and
·108 Verification that the transaction complies with investment or acquisition
criteria.
Lead and co-investors, corporate development staff, attorneys, accountants, investment
bankers, loan officers and other professionals involved in a transaction may have a need
or an obligation to conduct independent due diligence. Target management typically
assists these parties in obtaining due diligence information but because it is unwise to
totally rely on management third party consultants such as Astute Diligence are often
brought in to conduct due diligence.
Initial data collection and evaluation commences when a business opportunity first arises
and continues throughout the talks. Thorough detailed due diligence is typically
conducted after the parties involved in a proposed transaction have agreed in principle
that a deal should be pursued and after a preliminary understanding has been reached, but
prior to the signing of a binding contract.
The parties conducting due diligence generally create a checklist of needed information.
Management of the target company prepares some of the information. Financial
statements, business plans and other documents are reviewed. In addition, interviews and
site visits are conducted. Finally, thorough research is conducted with external sources --
including customers, suppliers, industry experts, trade organizations, market research
firms, and others.
The amount of due diligence you conduct is based on many factors, including prior
experiences, the size of the transaction, the likelihood of closing a transaction, tolerance
for risk, time constraints, cost factors, and resource availability. It is impossible to learn
everything about a business but it is important to learn enough such that you lower your
risks to the appropriate level and make good, informed business decisions.
Due diligence costs are based on the scope and duration of the effort, which in turn are
dependent on the complexity of the target business and other factors. Costs are typically
viewed as an essential expense far outweighed by the anticipated benefits and the
downside risks of failing to conduct adequate due diligence. The involved parties
determine who will bear due diligence expense.
Every transaction will have different due diligence priorities. For example, if the main
reason you are acquiring a company is to get access to a new product they are developing
to accelerate your own time to market, then the highest priority task is to ensure that the
product is near completion, that there are no major obstacles to completion, and that the
end product will meet your business objectives. In another transaction, the highest
priority might be to ensure that a major lawsuit is going to be resolved to your
satisfaction.
Certain activities conducted during due diligence can breach confidentiality that a
transaction is being contemplated. For example, contacting a customer to assess their
satisfaction with the target company's products might result in a rumor spreading that the
company is up for sale. Accordingly, to maintain confidentiality, we often contact
customers under the guise of being a prospective customer, journalist, or industry analyst.
A well-run due diligence program cannot guarantee that a business transaction will be
successful. It can only improve the odds. Risk cannot be totally eliminated through due
diligence and success can never be guaranteed.
REFERENCE.
WWW.GOOGLE.COM
WWW.IVESTOPEDIA.COM
WWW.WIKIPEDIA.COM
WWW.DIVESTOPEDIA.COM
WWW.BUSINESSKNOWHOW.COM
WWW.TECHTARGET.COM
WWW.ICAEW.COM