Scribd Logo
Upload

Welcome to Scribd!

  • 24 views

    People vs. Gonzales FACTS: Both of The Families of Andres and That of Gonzalez Were On Their Way To The Exit of The Loyola

    Uploaded by

    Jeorge Ryan Mangubat
    Gonzales and Andres families were leaving a park when their vehicles almost collided at an intersection. Andres followed and confronted Gonzales, shouting at him and his son Dino. Gonzales then shot at Andres' vehicle, hitting and killing Andres' pregnant wife Feliber and injuring his nephew and son. The court ruled that although Andres acted aggressively, it was not sufficient provocation to justify Gonzales shooting into the vehicle.

    Copyright:

    © All Rights Reserved
    Download as DOCX, PDF, TXT or read online from Scribd

    People vs. Gonzales FACTS: Both of The Families of Andres and That of Gonzalez Were On Their Way To The Exit of The Loyola

    Uploaded by

    Jeorge Ryan Mangubat
    24 views1 page
    Gonzales and Andres families were leaving a park when their vehicles almost collided at an intersection. Andres followed and confronted Gonzales, shouting at him and his son Dino. Gonzales then shot at Andres' vehicle, hitting and killing Andres' pregnant wife Feliber and injuring his nephew and son. The court ruled that although Andres acted aggressively, it was not sufficient provocation to justify Gonzales shooting into the vehicle.

    Original Description:

    case digest

    Original Title

    People vs Gonzales

    Copyright

    © © All Rights Reserved

    Available Formats

    DOCX, PDF, TXT or read online from Scribd

    Did you find this document useful?

    Is this content inappropriate?

    Gonzales and Andres families were leaving a park when their vehicles almost collided at an intersection. Andres followed and confronted Gonzales, shouting at him and his son Dino. Gonzales then shot at Andres' vehicle, hitting and killing Andres' pregnant wife Feliber and injuring his nephew and son. The court ruled that although Andres acted aggressively, it was not sufficient provocation to justify Gonzales shooting into the vehicle.

    Copyright:

    © All Rights Reserved
    Download as DOCX, PDF, TXT or read online from Scribd
    Download as docx, pdf, or txt
    24 views1 page

    People vs. Gonzales FACTS: Both of The Families of Andres and That of Gonzalez Were On Their Way To The Exit of The Loyola

    Uploaded by

    Jeorge Ryan Mangubat
    Gonzales and Andres families were leaving a park when their vehicles almost collided at an intersection. Andres followed and confronted Gonzales, shouting at him and his son Dino. Gonzales then shot at Andres' vehicle, hitting and killing Andres' pregnant wife Feliber and injuring his nephew and son. The court ruled that although Andres acted aggressively, it was not sufficient provocation to justify Gonzales shooting into the vehicle.

    Copyright:

    © All Rights Reserved
    Download as DOCX, PDF, TXT or read online from Scribd
    Download as docx, pdf, or txt
    of 1

    PEOPLE VS.

    GONZALES

    FACTS: Both of the families of Andres and that of Gonzalez were on their way to the exit of the Loyola
    Memorial Park. Gonzales was driving with his grandson and 3 housemaids, while Andres was driving with
    his pregnant wife, Feliber, his 2yr old son, Kenneth, his nephew Kevin and his sister-in-law.
    At an intersection, their two vehicles almost collided. Gonzales continued driving while Andres
    tailed Gonzales’ vehicle and cut him off when he found the opportunity to do so, then got out of his vehicle
    and knocked on the appellant's car window.
    Heated exchange of remarks followed. On his way back to his vehicle, he met Gonzales son, Dino.
    Andres had a shouting match this time with Dino.
    Gonzales then alighted from his car and fired a single shot at the last window on the left side of
    Andres' vehicle at an angle away from Andres.
    The single bullet fired hit Kenneth, Kevin and Feliber which caused the latter’s death.

    RULING: Provocation must be sufficient to excite a person to commit the wrong committed and that the
    provocation must be commensurate to the crime committed; The aggressive behavior of the complainant
    towards the accused and his son may be demeaning or humiliating but it is not sufficient provocation to
    shoot at the complainant’s vehicle.

    You might also like