NOVATEUR PUBLICATIONS

International Journal of Research Publications in Engineering and Technology [IJRPET]

ISSN: 2454-7875
VOLUME 3, ISSUE 6, Jun.-2017
ENHANCEMENT OF HEAT TRANSFER BY CHANGING ANGLE OF THE RIB
IN TRIANGULAR DUCT USING EXPERIMENTAL ANALYSIS
SARFRAJ SHAIKH
P.G. Student, M. E. Mechanical Engineering, Rajarshi Shahu College of Engg. Pune, Maharashtra,India

PROF.PRAKASH PATIL
Assistant Prof. M. E. Mechanical Engineering, Rajarshi Shahu College of Engg. Pune, Maharashtra,India

DR.KAMLESH SORATE
Associate Prof. M. E. Mechanical Engineering, Rajarshi Shahu College of Engg. Pune, Maharashtra,India

ABSTRACT: fundamental issue in many fields such as research and

Rough surfaces are one of the most effective industry fields. Because of its uses in many thermal
techniques to increase heat transfer. In this study, applications such as compact heat exchangers and solar
we have created rough surfaces in plain duct collectors also cooling of electrical and electronically
by (e/Dh = 0.043) with changing angle of rib 450 and devices. Different shapes of the cross section area have
600. So we have developed an experimental setup with been analyzed, like square, elliptical, rectangular and
dimensions of the triangular duct base and height is triangular, sinusoidal, rhombic etc, even with abbreviated
200mm and 350mm respectively. We had taken corners.
different readings at a constant flow rate and Artificial roughness provides the turbulence to the flow
changing the temperature of the surface plate. which leads to increase the heat transfer between the air
From experimentation, we have found Reynolds and the heated wall. Roughness is intervened in such a way
number, Nusselt number and friction factor for three that it breaks the laminar sub layer region i.e. near the wall.
plates (plain, 450 and 600) and found 450 angle rib to There are several method to provide artificial roughness on
have better results. Artificial roughness creates the the absorber plate such as casting, forming, machining, and
turbulence to the flow which leads to increase the heat blasting welding ribs and/or fixing thin circular wires, etc.
transfer between the air and the heated wall. The easiest and cheapest way of providing artificial
Roughness is created in such a way that it breaks the roughness on the underside of the absorber plate is
laminar sub layer region i.e. near the wall. There is sticking of ribs.
various method to provide artificial roughness on the Turbulent heat transfer in separated flow fields is an
absorber plate such as casting, forming, machining, attractive and important phenomenon. The detachment
blasting, welding ribs and/or fixing thin circular wires, stream generated by sudden expansion or contraction in
etc. The easiest and cheapest way of providing artificial passage, flow over forward and backward facing step, in
roughness on the underside of the absorber plate is channel ribs, and used swirl generators in passage,
sticking of ribs The scope for this study would focus all happens in wide range of practical flow geometries such as
necessary activities for benchmarking the existing heat exchangers, atomic reactors, combustors and cooling
application with the current performance level and channels and so on. Separation occurs in turbulent and
performance standards to be set for arriving at the laminar flows. In the present paper, the turbulent flow
objectives of the dissertation work. separation has been studied to a greater extent. This is
KEYWORDS: Surfaces (plain, 450 and 600), Reynolds because:
number, Nusselt number and friction factor. a) Turbulent flows are more frequently encountered than
laminar flows.
1. INTRODUCTION b) Separation is more likely to occur when the flow is
The subject of fluid flow and heat transfer in turbulent.
noncircular ducts from a fundamental viewpoint has been c) Due to inertial effects, separation has a much greater
virtually neglected in the literature. In industrial practice influence in turbulent flows.
generally using round pipes in heat transfer equipment. There is a great change of the local heat transfer rate in
Unconventional heat transfer design problem and the the separated flow regions and considerable heat transfer
increasing industrial use of noncircular ducts in heat augmentation may result up to the reattachment region.
exchangers, the problem becomes more than just academic Knowledge of convective heat transfer rate in separation
question. Mixed convection heat transfer in channels flow regions has been consolidated in this review paper
characterized by non- circular cross sections is a and provided more information and precise analysis
192 | P a g e
 NOVATEUR PUBLICATIONS
International Journal of Research Publications in Engineering and Technology [IJRPET]
ISSN: 2454-7875
VOLUME 3, ISSUE 6, Jun.-2017
associated with heat transfer as well as a complete physical highlighted. Different geometries of rib with rectangular
understanding of the flow. For turbulent heat transfer in and square ducts in turbulent flow in a number of studies
separated flow, all analyses are preferred eventually have confirmed increase of heat transfer coefficient in
depended on experimental. The published experimental separation flow behind ribs.
papers related to turbulent heat transfer in separated flow, Mohammed et al.[5] had studied by rectangular wing, pair
could be categorized into: Sudden expansion, forward and of delta winglets, and a pair of rectangular winglets had
backward facing step, Blunt body, Ribs channel, and Swirl been investigated experimentally for Reynolds numbers
generators. ranging from (24500) to (75750). The ratio of the cross-
sectional area of the test duct to that of the vortex
2. LITERATURE REVIEW: generator (AD/AVG) was remaining constant during
Mahdi et. al [1]had concluded clearly, permeable media experiments. The variables parameters, vortex generator
with and without nanofluids have great potential for heat type, angle of attack, and Reynolds number. The variables
transfer enhancement and highly suited to application in parameters, vortex generator type, vortex generator angle
practical heat transfer processes. This offers an open door of attack, and Reynolds number.
for specialists to develop highly compact and effective heat Gupta et al.[6] studied fully developed laminar flow and
transfer equipment. In this article, a comprehensive review heat transfer in equilateral triangular cross-sectional ducts
of previous efforts is presented for different convective following serpentine and trapezoidal path. Friction factors
flow regimes and heat transfer through porous media with for fully developed flow in an equilateral triangular duct
and without nano fluid. The impacts of a few Parameters in containing built-in vortex generators of delta win.
permeable media geometry and nano fluid properties, Tamayol et al.[7]had studied analytical solutions presented
thermal boundary conditions, and sorts of fluid were for laminar fully-developed flow in micro/minichannels of
investigated. hyperelliptical and regular polygonal cross-sections. The
Bharadwaj et al.[2]the range of relative roughness considered geometries cover a wide range of common
height (e/Dh) is from 0.021 to 0.043, value of angle of simply connected shapes including circle, ellipse, rectangle,
attack (α) and relative roughness pitch (p/e) has been 30° rhomboid, star-shape, equilateral triangle, square,
and 8 respectively. pentagon, and hexagon. Therefore, the present approach
The range of Reynolds number is from 5600 to 28000 can be considered as a general solution. Predicted results
and aspect ratio of the duct is 1.15. It has been found that for the velocity distribution and pressure drop are
the thermo hydraulic performance of artificially roughened successfully compared with existing analytical solutions
triangular solar air heater duct is always more than that of and experimental data collected from various sources for a
the smooth absorber plate in the range of Reynolds number variety of geometries, including: polygonal, rectangular,
investigated. circular, elliptical, and rhombic cross-sections.
Salem et.al[3] had investigated thermal creating, mixed
convection, in a flat equilateral triangular channel heated 3. PROBLEMS DEFINATION:
consistently. A test work has been directed for horizontal After reviewing different papers we have seen that there
equilateral triangular channel, heated uniformly, to are many methods to improve heat transfer rate by
investigate thermally developing mixed convection. The creating roughness in triangular duct but there is no any
channel was (1.5 m) long and constructed from three plane work was found to improve heat transfer by changing angle
(100 mm) walls to form the equilateral triangular cross of the rib in triangular duct Enhancement of heat transfer
section. These experiments had been conducted for range by changing angle of the rib in triangular duct using
values of (115 ≤ af ≤ 237(W/m2))) of heat flux and for the experimental analysis
range (0.0005 ≤ m ≤ 0.0015(kg/sec.)) of air mass flow rate.
The test apparatus has been manufactured first, then a 4. METHODOLOGY:
thermocouples have been stickled in proper positions i. To design and develop test section as per design.
Togun et.al.[4] had studied review of experimental ii. To manufacture test rig as per requirement
studies of turbulent heat transfer in separation flow.
Enhancement of turbulent heat transfer rate in separation 5. DESIGN OF TEST SECTION:
region with sudden expansion in passage or flow over Design of test section for experimental investigation of
backward and forward facing steps have been heat transfer enhancement of triangular duct for artificial
chronologically presented with experimental observations. roughness For test section according to ref [3]
Augmentation of turbulent heat transfer rate in separation
flow by introducing swirl generators in pipes, annular
pipes, and with sudden expansion in passage has been

193 | P a g e
 NOVATEUR PUBLICATIONS
International Journal of Research Publications in Engineering and Technology [IJRPET]
ISSN: 2454-7875
VOLUME 3, ISSUE 6, Jun.-2017
Parameter Dimension in mm
e 10
W 200
H 350
P 80

Area of triangle,
A= 0.5×W×H
=34883.72mm2
Perimeter of triangle,
P=3×W
=600mm
Hydraulic diameter
Graph 3: Nusselt no. Vs Reynolds no. for 450 rib angle.
Dh= (4×P) ÷A
=232.56mm =0.23m

For artificial rough surface:

We have selected angle of attack is= 450,600.
From above data we have calculated, Value for relative
roughness height (e/Dh) is from 0.043 and relative
roughness pitch (p/e) has been 8 respectively.
Hence our design is safe for getting more heat transfer rate

6. RESULTS, GRAPHS AND DISCUSSION:

Graph 4: Nusselt no. Vs friction factor for 450 rib angle.

Results graphs and discussion for 450 rib angle plate.

1. From graph 3 it is found that as increasing Nusselt
number Reynolds no. increases. It is found also that for
Reynolds number 2596 having higher Nusselt number
as compared to Reynolds number 2728.
Graph 1: Nusselt no. Vs Reynolds no. for plani duct. 2. From graph 4 it is found that as increasing Nusselt
number friction factor decreases. It is found also that for
friction factor 0.01175 having higher Nusselt number
as compared to friction factor 0.0119

Nusselt no Vs Reynold no
(60 degree)

12000
10000
8000
6000
Nu Vs Re
Graph 2: Nusselt no. Vs friction factor for plani duct. 4000
2000
Results graphs and discussion for plain duct 0
1. From graph 1 it is found that as increasing Nusselt 2400 2600 2800 3000
number Reynolds no. increases.
2. From graph 2 it is found that as increasing Nusselt Graph 5: Nusselt no. Vs Reynolds no. for 600 rib angle.
number friction factor decreases.
194 | P a g e
 NOVATEUR PUBLICATIONS
International Journal of Research Publications in Engineering and Technology [IJRPET]
ISSN: 2454-7875
VOLUME 3, ISSUE 6, Jun.-2017
CONCLUSION:
Nusselt no Vs Friction factor
(60 degree) This research work will lead to findings on the effect of
artificial rough surface on heat transfer enhancement in
12000
triangular duct. It is expected from this research work that
10000
the applications of artificial rough surface will enhance the
8000
heat transfer in triangular duct by providing turbulence
6000 Nu Vs f
movement of fluid in triangular duct.
4000
Nu Vs f
2000
0 REFERENCES:
1) Raed Abed Mahdi, H A. Mohammed , K. M.
0.01140.01160.01180.0120.0122
Munisamy,"Improvement of Convection Heat Transfer
by Using Porous Media and Nanofluid: Review",
Graph 6: Nusselt no. Vs friction factor for 600 rib angle.
International Journal of Science and Research (IJSR),
Results graphs and discussion for 600 rib angle plate. India Online ISSN: 2319-7064,Volume 2 Issue 8,
1. From graph 5 it is found that as increasing Nusselt August 2013,pp 34-47
number Reynolds no. increases. It is found also that for 2) Gaurav Bharadwaj, Varun & Avdhesh Sharma,
”Thermo hydraulic performance of an equilateral
Reynolds number 2596 having higher Nusselt number
as compared to Reynolds number 2728. triangular duct with artificial roughness used insolar
2. From graph 6 it is found that as increasing Nusselt air heater”, International Journal of Mechanical and
Industrial Engineering (IJMIE) ISSN No. 2231 –6477,
number friction factor decreases. It is found also that for
friction factor 0.01175 having higher Nusselt number Vol-2, Iss-3, 2012, pp1-6.
as compared to friction factor 0.0119 3) ThamerKhalif Salem, Raaid R. Jassem & Manar Salih
Mahdi,” thermally developing mixed convection in
From above experimentation, it is found that for
Reynolds number 2596 having higher Nusselt number ahorizontal equilateral triangular channel”, IJRRAS,
as compared to Reynolds number 2728 of both angled Vol16, Issue1/ 16, 2013, pp1-17.
4) Hussein Togun, S.N. Kazi, Ahmed Badarudin, “A
plates.
Review of Experimental Study of Turbulent Heat
7.EXPERIMENTAL INVESTIGATION: Transfer in Separated Flow,”Australian Journal of
Basic and Applied Sciences, ISSN 1991-8178, 5(10),
a. EXPERIMENTAL SETUP:
2011, pp489-505.
5) Mohammed Ghanem Jehad, “Experimental Study of the
Friction Factor in Equilateral Triangular Duct With
Different types of Vorex Generators (Obstacles)”,Al-
Qadisiya Journal For Engineering Sciences, Vol. 3. No.
2 2010, pp 6- 172.
Sectional view of test section
6) A. Tamayol,M. Bahrami, “Analytical Solutions for
Laminar Fully-Developed Flow in Micro channels with
Non-Circular Cross-Section”, Copyright © 2009 by
ASME
7) H. C. CLAIBORNE,” Laminar Flow Velocity Distributions
and Heat Transfer Characteristics f o r Noncircular
Ducts w i t h Fully Developed Hydmdynamic and
menn81 Boundary Layers”, OAK RIDGE NATIONAL
LASORATCSRY,MAY 1951,pp1-45.
Photograph of Experimental plate
SPECIFICATIONS:
I) TEST SECTION:
Dimensions of triangular duct (W=200mm, H=350,
e=10mm, P=80mm).
e/Dh = Relative roughness height =
P/e = Relative roughness pitch= 8.
Value of angle of attack (α) for making roughness is 450
And 600.

195 | P a g e