Spectral Analysis of Welding Plasma of Magnesium Alloy Using Flux Coated Wire
Spectral Analysis of Welding Plasma of Magnesium Alloy Using Flux Coated Wire
1909 to 1914
#2009 The Japan Institute of Metals
The activated flux coated wires are used to examine the effect of the fluxes on the weld penetration of the magnesium alloy. A series of
emission spectroscopy of arc plasma for TIG welding for magnesium with normal wire and activated flux coated wire are developed. It is found
that intensities of emission spectra of Mg I increase significantly when the flux wires are used. All the flux coated wire can increase the weld
penetration of the TIG welding. The electron temperature and electron density of welding plasma are estimated. The result indicated that the
electron temperature of arc plasma decrease when the flux coated wires are used; on the contrary, the electron density of the plasma got
enhanced. It is believed that the current density increases with the electron density increase, which is one of the reasons that the penetration depth
increase when the flux wires are used. [doi:10.2320/matertrans.M2009023]
(Received January 19, 2009; Accepted May 14, 2009; Published July 25, 2009)
Keywords: emission spectrum, activated flux tungsten inert gas (A-TIG) welding, magnesium alloy, electron temperature, electron density
constant and is about 50 mgmm2 . The alternating current Distance (mm) 6 0.6
source like a sine wave is used in welding. AC-TIG bead-
on-plate welds with filler wire are made with an automatic
D/W
4 0.4
control system in which the test piece is moved at a constant
speed. The filler wire feed ahead of the weld pool, at the
edge of the weld pool, the filler wire and the base metal 2 0.2
make the wire feed angle of about 25 , and the rate of wire
feeding is 360 mmmin1 . The welding parameters are listed 0 0.0
in Table 2; 99.9% argon is used as shielding gas. Normal TiO2 AFM01
12000 25000
Mg I 516. 732nm
Mg I 518. 362nm
Mg I 552. 840nm
Ca I 585. 745nm
(a)
Ca I 526. 424nm
10000
20000
Mg I 518. 362nm
Intensity (a.u.)
Mg I 516. 732nm
8000
15000
Intensity (a.u.)
Ca I 487. 813nm
Zn I 481. 053nm
Mn I 478. 342nm
Ca I 534. 947nm
Mg I 383. 826nm
Mg II 279. 553nm
6000
Mg I 293. 673nm
Mg I 552. 846nm
Mg I 448. 133nm
Mg I 293. 673nm
Ca I 504. 162nm
Mg I 470. 299nm
10000
Ti I 393. 424nm
Ar II 434. 811nm
4000
5000
2000
0 380 400 420 440 460 480 500 520 540 560
200 300 400 500 600
Wavelength, λ/nm
Wavelength, λ/nm 25000
Mg I 516. 732nm
Mg I 518. 362nm
(b)
Fig. 3 The spectra of welding plasma with the AFM01 flux coated wire.
20000
Intensity (a.u.)
emission spectra are compared, the plasma spectra from
383 nm to 555 nm in the stable processes of TIG welding are 15000
Mg I 552. 846nm
Mg I 383. 826nm
Mn I 478. 342nm
Mn I 482. 352nm
shown in Fig. 4. The spectra of plasmas in TIG welding
Zn I 481. 053nm
Mg I 448. 133nm
with three kinds of wires are acquired under the same
Mg I 470. 299nm
10000
Ti I 393. 424nm
acquiring parameters of the spectrograph, so the influence of
Ar II 434. 811nm
the spectrograph on the intensity of the spectral line is
neglected. Through the comparison of plasma spectra of 5000
three kinds of wires, it is found that the intensities of
emission spectra of Mg I when flux coated wires are used
are much stronger than that in TIG welding with normal 380 400 420 440 460 480 500 520 540 560
wires. In TIG welding with the AFM01 flux coated wires, Wavelength, λ/nm
25000
the intensity of Mg I 518.362 nm (4s3 S1 3p3 P02 ) is two (c)
times of that of normal wire. With flux TiO2 coated wires,
the intensity of Mg I 518.362 nm increases about 10% of 20000
Mg I 518. 362nm
that of normal wires.
Intensity (a.u.)
Mg I 516. 732nm
15000
3.3 Electron temperature
Mg I 383. 826nm
Mg I 552. 846nm
the most obvious and the spectral lines have the best noise
Mg I 470. 299nm
10000
Ti I 453. 558nm
Ti I 393. 424nm
Ti I 430. 056nm
Fig. 5 Arc plasma of Mg I in TIG welding with normal wire and AFM01 flux coated wire.
acquire the arc plasma to study the variation of arc plasma. It is confirmed that there are emission lines of Mg I, Mg II,
The wavelength and the full width at half-maximum Ar II, Ca I, Mn I, Ti I and Zn I in the arc plasma with AFM01
(FWHM) of the narrow-band filter are 514.9 nm and 6 nm. flux wires. The ionization energies of the Ar, Mg and Ca
Figure 5 shows the arc plasma of welding magnesium alloy atoms are 15.7 eV, 7.6 eV and 6.1 eV. The electron energy
with AFM01 flux coated wire and normal wire under the need to excite the Mg and flux elements atoms is lower than
standard welding conditions (Table 2). In the FWHM of the that of Ar atom. Then the ionization degree of the arc plasma
narrow-band filter, the emission lines spectrum are spectrum should increase when the evaporation of magnesium and the
of Mg I in the welding plasma. In this case, intensity of arc activated flux elements (the dissociation of the flux) exist
plasma image through the filter in includes the continuous in the regions of the arc plasma. With the ionization degree
spectrum and line spectrum. Compared with the line of the arc plasma increased, the electron temperature of the
spectrum, the intensity of the continuous spectrum is very arc plasma would decrease. In the experiment, the electron
weak. Accordingly the intensity of arc plasma image is temperature of arc plasma in TIG welding with normal
dependent on the intensity of line spectrum of Mg I. wire is about 9000 K 500 K and that of the composite
For the ACTIG welding, it includes EN (negative flux AFM01 coated wire decreases to 7900 K 400 K. The
electrode period) cycle and EP (positive electrode period) electron density of the arc plasma would increase with the
cycle. In TIG welding with normal wire, the arc plasma is ionization degree of the arc plasma increased. The electron
weak. In TIG welding with AFM01 flux coated wire, the density of the AFM01 flux wires arc plasma is much higher
views for EN period suggest that the arc plasma of Mg I than that of normal wires in TIG welding of magnesium
intensifies and expands in a large extent and the views for alloy.
EP period suggest that the plasma of Mg I intensifies a little. The current density of conducting channel depends on
It indicates that mg atoms evaporates and burns severely and the electron density of the plasma. The relationship between
the plasma expands due to the evaporation of magnesium the current density and the electron density can be described
alloy. The variation of mg atoms in arc plasma is consistent by:
with the plasma spectrum. The arc voltage variation is jx ¼ e N e K e X ð6Þ
recorded in TIG welding. It observed that the effective arc 9
pffiffiffiffi
voltage of the normal wires is 12 V, that of the AFM01 flux Ke ¼ 2:83 10 = T ð7Þ
coated wires is 15 V, and that of the TiO2 flux coated wires where jx is the current density, Ne is the electron density, Ke
is 13 V. is the electron mobility and X is the electric field intensity,
is the electron mean free path, which is a constant in the
3.7 Discussions arc plasma of TIG welding.
In the TIG welding process of magnesium alloy, magne- The electron mobility Ke depends on the electron
sium vaporizes severely due to its low melting point and temperature and the electric field intensity X will be
boiling point under the action of flux.20) According to the suitable for the arc voltage. It observed that the electron
study by P. Sahoo,21) the presence of the activated elements temperature decreases when the AFM01 flux wires are used,
(the dissociation of the flux) in welding ambient will increase the electron mobility Ke increases with the electron
the vaporization rates of the weld metal. In the experiments, temperature decrease. It observed that the effective arc
the spectral lines of Mg element intensify when the AFM01 voltage is 12 V with normal wire, 15 V with AFM01 flux
flux wires are used, at the same time, the arc plasma images wire and 13 V with TiO2 flux wire in the welding. The
of Mg atom observed by narrow-band filters expand. It effective arc voltage increases when the AFM01 flux wires
shows that the evaporation of magnesium alloy intensify are used, the electric field intensity X increases with the arc
under the effect of activating fluxes. Then the quantity of voltage increases. The electron density increases from
mg atom increase in the arc plasma. 2:49 1016 cm3 to 4:68 1016 cm3 when the AFM01
1914 Z. Zhang and F. Zhang
flux coated wires are used. According to the eq. (6), and the REFERENCES
arc current density increases when the AFM01 flux coated
wires are used. 1) B. L. Mordike and T. Ebert: Mater. Sci. Eng. A 302 (2001) 37–45.
2) C. S. Roberts: Magnesium and its Alloys, (JohnWiley and Sons, New
The increase of the arc current density indicated the
York, 1960).
conducting channel of arc column constricts significantly. 3) L. M. Liu, J. F. Wang and G. Song: Mater. Sci. Eng. A 381 (2004) 129–
Consequently, the current density increase and the arc 133.
conducting channel constriction improve the energy density 4) G. Song, L. M. Liu and M. S. Chi: Mater. Sci. Forum 488–489 (2005)
of arc plasma; a substantial increase in the penetrating 371–375.
5) S. M. Gurevich, V. N. Zamkov and N. A. Kushmienko: Avtom Svarka.
depth of the molten pool can be achieved compared with
9 (1965) 1–4.
conventional TIG welding at the same welding current. 6) S. M. Gurevich and V. N. Zamkov: Avtom Svarka. 12 (1966) 13–16.
7) M. Tanaka, T. Shimizu and H. Terasaki: Sci. Technol. Weld. Join. 5
4. Conclusions (2000) 397–402.
8) L. M. Liu, X. F. Hao and G. Song: Mater. Trans. 6 (2006) 1611–1614.
9) A. Rodrigues and A. Loureiro: Sci. Technol. Weld. Join. 10 (2005)
The composite flux AFM01 coated wire led to a great
760–765.
improvement in penetration, up to 200%, comparing with the 10) D. S. Howse and W. Lucas: Sci. Technol. Weld. Join. 5 (2000) 189–
normal wire at the same welding current. In TIG welding, the 193.
intensities of spectral lines of Mg increase compare with 11) S. Leconte, P. Paillerd and J. Saindrenan: Sci. Technol. Weld. Join. 11
normal wire. The amount of the evaporation of magnesium (2006) 43–47.
12) Palanco, M. Klassen and J. Skupin: Spectrochimica Acta Part B:
will increase dramatically when the flux wires are used. With Atomic Spectroscopy 56 (2001) 651–659.
the AFM01 flux and TiO2 flux coated wires, the electron 13) B. Le Drogoff, J. Margot and M. Chaker: Spectrochimica Acta Part B:
temperature of the arc plasma decrease from 9000 K 500 K Atomic Spectroscopy 56 (2001) 987–1002.
to 7900 K 400 K and 8700 400 K comparing with 14) J. Hoffman and Z. Szymanski: J. Phys. D: Appl. Phys. 37 (2004) 1792–
normal wire; the electron densities increase from 2:49 1799.
15) J. Mirapeix, A. Cobo and O. M. Conde: NDT&E International 39
1016 cm3 to 4:68 1016 cm3 and 3:17 1016 cm3 .
(2006) 356–360.
Due to the low ionization energies of the evaporation of 16) Metallurgical Industry Information Research Institute of Product
magnesium and the activated flux elements (the dissociation Standards: Wavelength list of spectral lines, (Industry press of China,
of flux), the ionization degree of the arc plasma increases. Beijing, 1971).
The current density increases and the arc conducting channel 17) National Institute of Standards and Technology database. http://
physics.nist.gov/PhysRefData/ASD/lines form.html.
constriction with the electron density increase which is
18) J. Sabbaghzadeh, S. Dadras and M. J. Torkamany: J. Phys. D: Appl.
induced by the ionization of magnesium and flux elements Phys. 40 (2007) 1047–1051.
atoms. The energy density of arc plasma enhances with 19) H. R. Griem: Plasma Spectroscopy, (McGraw-Hill, New York, 1964).
the current density increase, which is one of the reasons 20) X. Cao, M. Jahazi and J. P. Immarigeon: J. Mater. Sci. Technol. 171
that the penetration depth increase when the flux wires are (2006) 188–204.
21) P. Sahoo, M. Coollur and M. Debroy: Metall. Trans. B 19B (1988)
used.
967–972.