Computer-Assisted Programme For The Teaching of The English Syllable in RP Allophonic Pronunciation
Computer-Assisted Programme For The Teaching of The English Syllable in RP Allophonic Pronunciation
131
Roach (2002:66) states that the syllable is a fundamentally important unit in
both phonetics and phonology.
Crystal (1989: 164) defines the syllable as " an element of speech that acts as
a unit of rhythm, consisting of a vowel, a syllabic consonant or vowel / +
consonant combination ". On the other hand, Hancock (2003: 50) beliefs that a
syllable is often described as a group of one or more sounds with a peak or
nucleus.
Phonetically speaking, the air pressure is most noticeable in the nucleus. The
hearer may distinguish the central part of a syllable because it has more
prominence than the surrounding sounds, but people often have difficulty in
hearing when one syllable ends and another begins, for example, the word
"bitter"[b'Itə] may be heard as (bi-tter, bit-ter or bitt-er).
Phonologically speaking, a syllable is defined as the way in which vowels
and consonants combine to form various sequences ( the study of the location of
sounds in sequence is called phonotactics) . Vowels can form a syllable on their
own or they can be the " centre or nucleus " of a syllable , e.g. [e] in bed [b |ed],I
[aI].
In addition, some consonants like / m, n, ŋ , 1 / are called syllabic
consonants since they function as syllables in final position and also we have what
is called " minimum syllable ", as in [ |m ] to show agreement and [ |∫ ] to keep
someone quiet and these are consonant sounds, but they have meaning. (Roach,
2002: 76).
Roach (ibid: 66) divides a syllable into two parts onset plus rhyme (hence
nucleus & coda). For example, sit consists onset[s]+nucleus[I]+coda[?t]]; therefore
[ I ] + [?t ] represent the rhyme part of the syllable as in fig ure 1
[ sI?t ]
Onest Rhyme
[s] [I?t]
132
The proposed definitions of the term "syllable" can be divided into three
types: phonetic, phonological and phonotactic.
Phonetically, a syllable is usually described as consisting of a centre which
has little or no obstruction to the flow of air out of the mouth and which sounds
comparatively loud and before and after this centre. (Abrecrombie, 1989:39;
Roach, 2002:67).
Phonologically speaking, a syllable is defined by Laver (1994:39) as “a
complex unit made up of nucleus and marginal elements”. Nucleus elements are
the vowels or syllabic consonants. In the „one word syllable‟ try [tr|aI] the
diphthong /aI/ is the nucleus element; while the initial consonant cluster which
consists of [t] and [r]are the marginal elements.
A number of scholars suggest that the term "syllable "should not be used in
either a phonetic or a phonological sense, but it should refer to a linguistic unit
composed of phonemes that are arranged according to certain phonotactic criteria.
McCarthy (1978:107)
3. Significance of the Syllable
For Crystal (2003:447) “The syllable is important in phonology in relation to
prosody, and cross-linguistic studies of rhythm .In the distinctive features
theory of phonology „syllable‟ is used to replace the syllabic nucleus”.
Likewise, Bolinger (1975:56) emphasizes that the syllable obtains much of
its obviousness because of the role it plays in rhythm, i.e., when people segment
the stream of speech and give it a rhythm of strong and weak beats, as in music. In
addition, the best justification for ending the structure of sound–units at the level of
the syllable is that anything higher is almost necessarily related to the meaning and
the structure of the language.
It is necessary to mention that the significance of syllable has increased
especially in models of non–linear phonology in relation to derivation .In addition,
a syllable plays a role in prosodic morphology as being “a level above the „mora‟
and below the „foot‟- the unit of rhythm in languages” (ibid.).
133
Finch (2000:68); and the Free Encyclopedia (2005:Int.) state that syllables
serve in carrying the stressed patterns of English which are essential to the way in
which speech is organized.
O‟Connor (1973:201) explains the importance of the syllable when he
affirms that “the syllable is useful as the largest unit one needs to consider in
explaining how phonemes are permitted to combine together in a
language”.Moreover, Smith and Wilson (1980:141) also refer to the importance of
the syllable in the need for something larger than a phoneme and smaller than a
word.
4. The Syllable : Various Theories
A number of studies have been made to explain theories of syllable.
Phonetically speaking, one of the most important theories is “the chest pulse
theory” which tackles the syllables in the context of muscular activities and lung
movements in the process of speech. Experiments which have shown that the
number of chest pulses, accompanied by the increase of air pressure, can determine
the number of syllables produced, thus, allowing associate with the number of
chest pulses. (ibid.56)
This theory, however, can not account for cases when two vowels occur one
after another, for example, in words like being [b'i:Iŋ] the second chest pulse must
be almost irrelevant and thus leads erroneously to the conclusion that such English
words consist of one syllable only. (Roach, 2004:1)
Another well-known theory is „the prominence theory‟, which tackles the
syllable from a phonological point of view and depends on auditory judgements,
i.e., the number of syllables in a word is determined by the number of peaks of
134
Another theory is the “Sonority theory” in which “the pulses of pulmonic air
stream in speech correspond to peaks in sonority”. The sonority of speech of a
sound is seen as its relative loudness compared to other sounds. Each syllable
corresponds to a peak in the flow rate of pulmonic air. Thus, the nucleus elements
or syllabic segments are described as intrinsically more sonorant than marginal or
non-syllabic segments.Speech sounds can be ranked in terms of their intrinsic
sonority according to sonority scale as in figure(2) (Rogers,2000:268).
↑ vowels . .
More
Sonorous approximants .
nasals . .
Less fricatives
Sonorous
↓ affricatives
plosives .
t r ei n I ŋ
Figure (2): The Sonority Scale of the Word Training [tr'eInIŋ]
(after Roach 2004:2).
In the above figure two peaks of sonority can be seen in the linear sequence
of phonemes /tr-eI-n-I- ŋ/i.e., the diphthong /eI /and the pure vowel / I /.Thus, the
number of syllables is two (ibid).
5 . English syllable: Nature of Structure of patterns .O‟Connor,
(1973:201) states that the nature of a syllable structure varies from one language to
135
another since there is no universal phonological syllable. The phonological view of
the syllable requires a separate definition for each language. However, Malmberg
(1963:1), among other phoneticians, believes that a syllable consisting of a
consonant plus a vowel is the only one which is general for all languages.
There are two types of English syllable structures which can be classified
into two types: a phonetic syllable structure and a phonological one.
5.1 Phonetic Syllable Structure :
The phonetic syllable structure consists of three phonetic parts: the onset, the
peak and the coda (Hyman, 1975:188). Sequences of segments within a phonetic
syllable depend upon an inherent hierarchical scale of sonority. The most sonorous
segment occupies the nucleus and farther from the nucleus on either margin the
least sonorous, the sounds will be optional consonants (Hawkins, 1984:66). On the
other hand, the phonological syllable structure displays the following pattern of
arrangements: 0, 1, 2, 3 consonants +V + 0, 1, 2, 3, 4 consonants. This pattern
means that a syllable consists of a vowel(V)which is preceded by zero, one, two,
three, consonants and followed by zero, one, two, three, four consonants as in[ |aI ]
[th |i:],[tr |aI],[str |i:t ],[ In], [i:?t],[ g |a:dn] ….etc. (O‟Connor, 1973:229).
5.2 Phonological Syllable Structure :
Moreover, as for phonological theories of syllable, they are mostly
concerned with the internal structure of syllables .In this respect, phonologists
have adduced every possible configuration for the internal structure of syllables.
For instance, the main concern of CVC syllables is whether the vowel is
grouped with the prior consonant (called the onset) or with the posterior
consonant (called the Coda) or with neither.
More recently, some phonologists have claimed that the components of the
syllable are units of weight called „Moras‟ (Hyman, 1982:9) .
Two parts can be found in the internal structure of the syllable. These parts
are onset and rhyme; with the rhyme, nucleus and coda are found .It is important to
point out that not all syllables have these parts; the smallest possible syllable
136
contains a nucleus only .Simply, onset means the beginning sound(s)of the syllable
which precede the nucleus and coda means the sounds at the end of the syllable
which follow the nucleus. These are always consonants in English (Roca and
Johnson, 2000:239). Vowels and consonants do not act alone, but there are very
few words-like which consist of only one sound, for instance, (I, eye, oh, m (to
show agreement), or, are….etc.)(ibid.)
Accordingly, there are four patterns of syllables.They are: (ØVØ), (CVØ),
(ØVC) and (CVC). In this case, a syllable may be a vowel only, viz. the pattern
(ØVØ), as in or ['ɔ:], this kind of syllable is known as a „minimum syllable‟. The
syllable which is not closed by consonant, viz. the pattern (CVØ) as in be [b'i:] is
called an “open syllable”.
Phonetically speaking, syllables consist of a centre, which has little or no
obstruction to air flow and before and after this centre, there may be greater
obstruction as in eye ['aI], in ['In]. more [m'ɔ:]. But phonologically, consonants
always occupy the margins of the syllable structure, and it happens that a
consonant occupies the nucleus of the syllable as in syllabic consonant‟ (Gimson,
1989: 54).
6. English Syllables: Major Types
6.1 Simple Vs Complex Syllables
English syllables are classified into simple and complex according to their
structure.. The simple syllable consists of a nucleus only or a nucleus with one
consonant preceding it and /or another consonant following it. Consequently, the
simple syllable has the structures: V, CV, VC and CVC as in “I” ['aI] , „knee‟ [n'i:] ,
„if‟['If] and dog[d'ɒg]. Other types of syllables are complex, i.e., they have cluster(s)
of consonants before and /or after the vowel (ibid.).
Concerning the longest complex monosyllable English words, the following
is a list of some of the nine- letter English words which have (7) sounds that each
consists of a single complex syllable:
137
Table 1
Nine – letter Monosyllabic words in English
The word narrow Trans. syllable structure
scratched [skr'æ?ʧ t] CCCVCCC
138
have it in their structures and may be the first systematic utterances of children are
expected to be of this form (Hogg and McCully, 1989:36).
Cox et al., (2004:Int.) show the different structures of each type in English
monosyllabic words as illustrated below:
Table (2)
Open and closed Syllables
(A). Closed syllables
VC is ['iz]
VCC end ['end]
VCCC ants ['ænts]
CCVCCCC prompts [ prompts ]
CVC moon [m'u:n]
CVCC jump [ʤ ʌ mp]
CVCCC hands [h'ændz]
CVCCCC sixths [s'Iksθs]
CCVCCC plants [ pl'ænts]
CCVCCC twelfths [twelf θ]
CCCVC strong [ str'ɒŋ]
CCCVCC springs [spr'Iŋz]
CCCVCCC splints [spl'Ints]
(B.) Open syllables
V or ['ɔ:]
CV sea [s'i:]
CCV through [θr'u:]
CCCV screw [skr'u:]
139
Smith (1982:10) refers to strong syllables using the terms “heavy” and
“long”, and to weak syllables using the terms “light” and „short”. These two types
of syllables can be described in part in terms of stress since they are closely
associated with this aspect. Also, in a polysyllabic word there is always a syllable
with primary stress; this syllable is called a “strong syllable”. Syllables that have
no stress are known as “weak syllables” (Singh and Singh 1979:170).
Crystal (2003:493) states that syllables can be metrically “heavy” or
“light”:- a light syllable is one whose rhyme comprises a short vowel nucleus alone
or followed by a coda of no more than one short consonant, thus it has the structure
CV or CVC.
In fact, English puts certain restrictions on the structures of strong syllables
.They can be open only if they contain a long vowel or a diphthong and only a
closed strong syllable may have a short vowel. In other words, long vowels and
diphthongs can occur in both open as in „sue‟ [s'u:], „bay‟[b'eI] and closed as in
„bean‟[b'i:n]and „eight‟['eI?t]which constitute strong syllables, whereas short
vowels occur only in closed ones as in „cat‟ [kh'æ?t] and „ill‟ ['Il](Roach et al.,
2004:Int).
Generally, strong syllables can have in its centre any long vowel, like the
first syllable of the word „father‟ [f'a:ðǝ] or diphthong as the first syllable of the
word „daily‟ [d'eIlI] except the vowel [ǝ], whereas weak syllables can only have
the following types of nucleus (Roach, 1999:76):
A. Short Schwa
Schwa is symbolized as /ǝ/, which is the most common unstressed vowel in
English. This vowel occurs initially e.g. „alive‟ [ǝl'aIv], medially e.g. „forget‟
[fǝg'e?t] and finally as in „cinema‟ [s'Inǝmǝ]. Many English words have one
140
„elephant‟ ['elIfǝnt] and „tremendous‟ [trǝm'endǝs] (Kreidler, 2003:80). Actually
in English, there are words that have two forms in pronunciation: one with short
schwa (the weak form) and the other with some other vowels like / I /, / æ / and / ɒ/
instead of this schwa. For example, „of‟ has the weak form [ǝv] and the strong
B. The [ i, u ] vowels
Roach (1999: 77-8) illustrates that the weak syllable can have one of two
other vowels as its centre. The first is a vowel that occurs in the general area
between /i:/ and /I/ while the second one lies in the region between /u:/ and /u/.
Here, unlike the case with strong syllables, there is no clear borderline between
the long and short forms of each vowel in weak syllables, i.e., no one can tell
which vowel one realizes in words like „easy‟ or „busy‟. Wells and Colson
(1981:22) argue that these vowels are more like the long forms when they come
before another vowel and they tend to be shorter when they precede a consonant or
pause. Thus, a different (or a third) vowel is introduced symbolized as [i] in the
first example and [u] in the second one. As a result, the words „busy‟,„easy‟ and
influence are transcribed as [b'Izi] ,['i:zi] and ['Influǝns] respectively. Some other
examples are the [i] in „happy‟ /hæpi/; „valley‟ [væli] and [u] thank you [θæŋkju]
C. Syllabic Consonants:
Laver,( 1994:114 ) pointed out that “the syllable must have a compulsory
constituent in its structure, i.e., the nucleus, which consists of a vowel (pure or
diphthong” ). The exception to this rule is syllabic consonants. Those are the lateral
sound [ l| ] and the nasals [ m| ], [ n| ], [ ] in which each consonant can form a
|
141
written under the sound as in „bottle‟ [b'ɒt l ]; „bottom‟ [b'ɒt m ];
| |
7.1 Syllabication
Pulgram (1970:40) defines syllabication as a phonotactic operation which is
performed in conformity with the distributional criteria of the language under
analysis (CF.Hans, 1981:257). Although it is possible that one can specify the
number of syllables in words, it is very difficult to determine syllable boundary
placement. (Ladefoged, 1975:218).
Some phonotactic criteria for syllable boundary placement are suggested by
a number of phoneticians.
Pulgram (1970:47-51) proposes the following principles:
1. A principle of maximal open syllabicity.
2. A principle of minimal coda and maximal onset.
3. A principle of irregular coda.
As far as the first principle is concerned, a syllable boundary is inserted after
every vowel of a word. Thus, words such as rooster and master are syllabified as
[r|υ.stə] and [m|æ.stə] so as to make the first syllable open. A problem arises;
however, in the form (mæ . stə) since the principle of maximal open syllabicity
creates a sequence which violates a sequential constraint in English by which the
short vowel /I, e, æ, ɒ, υ / are disallowed in word-final position. Since [m| æ. stə]
contains the vowel / æ/, which doesn‟t occur in word finally, it must be
resyllabified by the next principle to yield [m|æs.tə]. A similar motivated
readjustment must occur in a second set of circumstances.
Pulgram (1970:40) explains this by stating that:
If the syllable can not be kept open because the consonant or consonants that
would form the onset of the next syllable do not occur in word- initial position,
then many consonants, as necessary –but not more –to reduce the onset to a
142
permissible word-initial shape, must be detached from it and transferred to the
preceding syllable as coda, to close the syllable.
Hence, while employ [Impl'oI] would be syllabified [I .mpl'oI] by the
principle of maximal open syllabicity, this would create a syllable- initial /mpl/
sequence which can not occur in word initially. Hence, the/m/ must be sent back to
the first syllable to yield [Im.pl'oI] where each syllable now meets the syllable
structure constraints of English. Pulgram‟s final principle is stated as follows:
If the necessary transfer from syllable- initial to syllable-final position leads
to a group of consonants, then the burden of irregularity must be borne by the coda
rather than the following onset.
Pulgram‟s principle is further expanded by Fallows (1980:78) who suggests
two principles of syllabication: stress and ambisyllabicity. The first principle
means that a stressed syllable will attract the maximum number of consonants in
both initial and final position. The next principle shows the sharing of an inter-
vocalic consonant by the neighbouring syllables. So, a word like begin [bIg'In] is
syllabified as [bI.gIn] or [bIg.In). It seems that the second division of the word
begin [bIg-In] is more acceptable since it is familiar to find English beg and in
through the dictionary.
7.2 Rules of syllabification
Note: Division of disyllabic and polysyllabic words should not produce unacceptable consonant
cluster in both the onset and coda in English language.
4- In VCV if one consonant occurs between two vowels and the second vowel
is long (stressed or unstressed), the consonant becomes part of the second syllable.
143
Example.
Return [rI ?t 'ə: n ] VCV
|
V C V [ rI?t'ɜː n ]
|
| |
Short long
| | |
V C V
| |
short long
Delay [ dIl'eI ] VCV [ dI.l'eI ]
Example
Windy [ w'In.dI ]
[ w'Ind.I ]
But not
[ wI . ndI ] English words can not begin with (nd-)
5- In (VCV) if one consonant occurs between two short vowels, and the first
vowel is stressed the consonant goes with the preceiding vowel.
Example.
[ l 'I m I? t ] [ l'Im.I?t ]
| |
short short
| |
Stressed unstressed
[ b ] can be
144
8- The Manipulation of Computer Techniques in Monitoring
English Syllables
Studying the English Syllable at the University level practically represents
the task of the researcher who does his best to design a comprehensive programme
to be used by teachers at the college on one hand and the students themselves on
the other hand.
145
into presentation, application or practice and testing. A learner can click on the
button "introduction" to read the main aims and advantages of the programme. On
the presentation stage, the learner can click on any topic from the main menu to
study it in all its details. In each slide, a number of buttons appeared to give the
learner the freedom to choose whatever he likes to do the next. On the left hand, in
the bottom, there is a button of reading the material in the selective slide, whereas
on the right hand,there is a button of music which he can use while reading the
slide silently.
To attract the learner's attention and make the process of learning more
interesting, different pictures and colours are used with soft music which
accompanied all the stages of programme.
A learner can repeat the material endlessly until he/she is satisfied with the
results.
2- Application
After presenting and explaining the contents in words, the learner can click
on an icon of application which transfers what has been written in words to a
simple tree diagram to combine between theory and practice on the same screen.
3- Testing
The last stage of the programme is a test for the learner to check
himself/herself whether she /he understands the material of each item in the main
menu or not. Questions have been designed or prepared according to the nature of
each item in the topic and its weight in the text-book itself.
4.4 Programme Mechanism
146
Our programme entitled "the English syllables" has been designed through the use
of VB 2005 which has wide spread capacities on educational and productive
scientific levels.At first, the mechanism will be explained, illustrated by some
electronic windows with its own demonstration, and then a simplified explanation
about the programming language (VB 2005) will be given. (See Figure.3)
147
The following designed1 window shows the aim of our study and a letter to
the users to know why this programme has been designed and its effect on the
scientific level of the university students in this branch of knowledge (phonetics
and phonology). In this window, there will be a button entitled (Main Menu) by
which one can see and choose the item he / she wants to study of the English
Syllables.
148
Figure 5: The Main Menu
The above compiled window (Figure5) represents (the main menu) where
the eight topics that are included in this study (The English syllable) will be shown.
Only one example has been taken, that is the First button (Definition: The English
Syllable) with its windows represented in the following pages.
149
Figure 6: The Electronic Slide of the Definition of the English
Syllable
The above frame (Figure 6) represents the electronic slide of the first topic in
the main menu where one can see a number of buttons to control sound or another
to show the next electronic window that leads to presenting questions about the
topic itself.
150
Figure 7: Exercise on Definition: The English Syllable
This window represents as in its full form the first two questions of the first
topic where it contains some important buttons repeated in other windows of other
topics as follows:
1- (Main Menu): This button leads us to the eight – button window.
2- (More): This button shows us successive choices of the same question.
3- (Next Exercise): This button transfers to the window of the following question
of the same topic.
4- (Results): This button examines the results of responses of all the choices of the
present question where the green colour shows the correct responses and the red
color states the wrong answer
151
9. Conclusions:
In the light of the empirical evidence revealed in this study and according to
the researcher's own observation, the following conclusions are drawn on the
theoretical and practical level of this study :
1- Some allophones in RP pronunciation change the form of CV system of the
English syllable by using narrow transcription as in put [ phʊ?t ] becomes
CCVCC but not CVC; text [thè?kst] becomes CCVCCCC but not CVCCC
(Roach, 2009) in a letter to the researcher on Thursday, April 16, 2009, 5: 36
P.M.
Roach says: "It would be true to say those counting phonetic segments in
narrow transcription would result in a different number of segments from the
number resulting from counting phonemes".
2- Whenever we deal with a particular accent, for example (BBC/RP) narrow
transcription must be used to distinguish this accent from other varieties of
EngliAccording to the sonority theory of the English syllable, the place of stress
must be put above the peak and not on the preceding consonant in the stressed
syllables.
whereas, on the practical level, this study shows that: First, the achievement
of the experimental group is higher than that of the control group and that is
attributed to the application of computer techniques. Secondly, there is an
improvement in the level of knowledge of the experimental group between pre-
and post test.
152
Bibliography
Bolinger,D.(1975).AspectofLanguage.(2nded.).NewYork::Harcourt
Bra ce Jovanovich,Inc.
Deweijer,V.(2002)."Glossary".http:/www.ling./use/persons/joost/texts/glossary.Pdf
.
Hans,B. (1981) "On The Function of Boundaries in Phonological
Rules". In Goyvaerts, D. (ed.) Phonology
153
Hogg, R. and McCully,C.B. (1989 ). Metrical Phonology. Cambridge:
Cambridge University Press.
154
----------(2002)." ALittle Encyclopedia of Phonetics
".www.linguistics.reading.ac.uk/staff /PeterRoach.
155