Jurnal 2
Jurnal 2
Conjunctivodacryocystorhinostomy
S
URGERY IS INDICATED IN THE FOLLOWING CASES IN b. Secondary dye test. If the result of the primary dye test is
which disturbing epiphora exists because of canalic- negative, the dye is washed from the conjunctival sac, the
ular failure: patient’s head is tipped forward far enough for fluid to run
out from the anterior nares into a white basin. One cubic
1. Congenital absence, traumatic destruction or com- centimeter of normal saline is injected by a lacrimal can-
plete closure of both canaliculi in one eye. nula that has been inserted as far as the internal common
2. Closures of two or more mm of the nasal ends of the punctum. If the fluid comes out of the nose stained with
canaliculi. the dye, it is a positive test.
3. Cases with patent ducts in which the primary and A positive secondary dye test proves that there is no
secondary dye tests (see later) are both negative after obstruction at the punctum nor in the canaliculus and
all conservative treatment has failed. that the lacrimal pump is functioning as far as the tear
4. Following a dacryocystorhinostomy in which the sac which fills with the dye. The partial obstruction is in
canaliculi are patent but nonfunctioning. the nasolacrimal duct. If there is no dye in the fluid from
5. Cases with a permanent paralysis of the lacrimal pump. the nose, it is a negative test.
A negative secondary dye test proves that no dye has
reached the tear sac; the primary cause of the epiphora
DIAGNOSIS lies in the canaliculi.
Inspection must also rule out inverted, everted or
THE PRESENCE OF A TOTAL OBSTRUCTION CAN BE ESTAB- phimotic puncta, canalicular foreign bodies and neoplasms,
lished easily by irrigation and probing. A congenital allergic edema and inflammations of the ducts as being the
absence of the canaliculi usually can be assumed to be pre- cause of the epiphora. Epiphora due to lacrimal hypersecre-
sent if neither punctum can be found and there is a history of tion is never an indication for surgery on the lacrimal
epiphora since birth. At the time of operation, when the sac excretory mechanism.
is opened, this can be checked further by retrograde probing.
The canaliculus test1 also is of value. When normal saline
solution comes out through the upper canaliculus, after be-
ing injected into the lower, the test is positive, indicating
that the ducts are patent at least as far as their union
SURGICAL PROCEDURES
with each other or the lacrimal sac. EPIPHORA DUE TO DESTRUCTION OF THE LATERAL HALVES
The dye tests2 are of no value in complete obstructions of the canaliculi usually can be cured by an intermarginal
but are indispensable in the differential diagnosis of partial slitting of the patent medial parts.3 A closure of 2.0 mm or
obstructions. They tell one whether the epiphora is due to less of the nasal ends of the canaliculi often can be reopened.
the malfunction of the canaliculi or the nasolacrimal duct Both of these procedures have been reported previously.2
or to hypersecretion. Where the canaliculi are absent or cannot be restored to
a. Primary dye test. One drop of 1% fluorescein solution is normal function, a substitute for the lacrimal pump must
instilled in the conjunctival sac. A small cotton-tipped be found. Such a substitute is a tube that possesses capillary
applicator, moistened with a mixture of 1:1,000 epineph- attraction combined with a negative pressure exerted at its
rine and 5% cocaine solution, is introduced into the inferior nasal end. This latter factor is furnished by the negative pres-
meatus of the nose at intervals from one to five minutes. If sure phase, in the nose, of inspired air. A glass tube, and often
the cotton comes out stained with the dye it is a positive test. an epithelial-lined tube, will furnish the capillary attraction.
A positive primary dye test proves that there is no In my experience, there are only three acceptable types
obstruction in the lacrimal passages and that the epiphora of surgery for canalicular failure: (1) conjunctivodacryocys-
is due to hypersecretion. If, after three to five minutes, there tostomy, (2) conjunctivodacryocystorhinostomy and (3)
is no dye on the cotton, it is a negative test. conjunctivorhinostomy. Many doctors prefer the term
‘‘laco’’ for ‘‘conjunctivo.’’ The term, conjunctivorhinos-
Portland, Oregon. tomy, is used in cases in which the tear sac is absent and
1. CONJUNCTIVODACRYOCYSTOSTOMY
THE USUAL CUTANEOUS APPROACH IS MADE TO THE TEAR
sac and the fundus of the sac is mobilized.4 A stab incision
is then made through the lacus area to the lacrimal fossa,
beginning 2.0 mm posterior to the commissure. This inci-
sion is extended laterally, between the converging heads
of the lower pretarsal muscle, nearly to the conjunctival
side of the tarsus. The fundus is then opened and pulled
into this opening (Figure 1) and sutured to its conjunctival
margins.
I have done 25 cases by this method. There are several
drawbacks. It is often difficult to dissect out the fundus FIGURE 1. (JONES). Conjunctivodacryocystostomy. The
and mobilize it adequately. The new ostium will almost al- fundus of the sac (a) has been mobilized and opened at the
ways close unless held open by a tube with a collar on its top, to be sutured to the conjunctival margins of the stab incision
upper end. The tube is poorly tolerated as the movement into the lacrimal fossa. The deep head of the lower pretarsal
of the lids is at right angles to the direction of the tube muscle is seen on the posterior side of the incision.
(Figure 2). Even if the ostium is kept from closing, drainage
into the nose is unpredictable. Transplanting the fundus
destroys the pumping effect of the preseptal muscles.
2. CONJUNCTIVODACRYOCYSTORHIN-
OSTOMY AND
CONJUNCTIVORHINOSTOMY
THESE TWO PROCEDURES SHOULD BE DESCRIBED TOGETHER
as the technique is identical in nearly every detail. In the
absence of a sac, instead of suturing the nasal mucosal flaps
to the tear sac flaps, the former are sutured to the lacrimal
fascia instead.
a. Transplantation of the sac. This is done in the same way
as the conjunctivodacryocystostomy already described, as
far as the transplantation of the fundus is concerned. The
bone of the medial wall of the lacrimal fossa is then FIGURE 2. (JONES). Conjunctivodacryocystostomy with
removed; the lower end of the sac is severed from the naso- persistent epiphora. A glass tube was installed, but the medial
lacrimal duct and transplanted upward and sutured to the movement of the lids would lift the collar above the level of
margins of an opening made in the nasal mucosa. This is the lacus.
a long and arduous procedure and about half of the patients
will have to wear a tube to keep the passage from closing or
to relieve the epiphora. Sometimes the opening is too large b. Mucous membrane flaps. Conjunctival and nasal
or its final position changes to a less functional place mucosal flaps (Figure 4) have been advocated especially
(Figure 3) . in cases without a tear sac. These all have the same
(Figure 10). As soon as the wall is perforated, one blade of a is then passed along the flat side of the knife into the nose.
small curved iris scissors is inserted into the sac and the The tube is turned so that its point lies between the flat side
incision is extended from the top of the fundus to the bot- of the knife and the probe and then is pushed through the
tom of the nasolacrimal duct. A similar incision is made in new passage. If this technique is not followed, the tube
the nasal mucoperiosteum adjacent and parallel to the one often is difficult to insert, due to its nasal end catching in
in the tear sac (Figure 11). The posterior flaps of the tear sac fascial bands. A 6-0 black silk suture on a cutting needle
and nasal mucosa are sutured together with two 4-0 plain is passed through the collar of the tube and out through
catgut sutures on an atraumatic, one-fourth inch, half- the adjoining skin of the commissure and tied. If the nasal
circle needle. end of the tube touches the septum, it is cut shorter.
The caruncle is next excised, being careful not to remove Two or more sutures are now placed in the anterior tear
any of the adjacent conjunctival tissue with it. A 23-gauge sac and nasal mucosal flaps. The periosteum is similarly
hypodermic needle, 30-mm long, is bent into a curve so closed and the skin united with a running mattress suture
that the point of the needle is on the inside of the curve. of 6-0 black silk. In the absence of the tear sac, the nasal
The needle should be held with the concavity of the curve flaps are sutured just posterior and anterior to the point
facing anteriorly. The point is then inserted in the lacus where the guide needle emerges. It is necessary for the
exactly 2.0-mm posterior to the cutaneous margin of the tube to have ‘‘soft-tissue’’ suspension, that is, free move-
canthal angle. It is then pushed in a direction that will ment without contact with rigid structures during blinking.
cause its point to emerge just posterior to the anterior The dacryocystorhinostomy may be done by any other
tear sac flap and slightly below the level of the palpebral method. The foregoing description is given primarily
fissure (Figure 11). Several attempts may be necessary to because it furnishes the new passage with a little more
get the point to emerge in exactly the right place. It must epithelization at its nasal end. It is the Ohm6 procedure
be anterior to the body of the ethmoid and middle turbi- with occasional crosshatching of the anterior nasal flap as
nate, whose anterior end should be resected if it interferes described by Dupuy-Dutemps,7 when necessary to suture
with the tip of the needle. the anterior flaps together.
A cataract knife of medium width is then inserted into The polyethylene tube may be left in until the postoper-
the sac, following the guide needle. The needle is then ative swelling subsides. However, a pyrex glass tube may be
removed and the knife (Figure 12) enlarges the passage su- substituted at almost any time. The glass tubes recommen-
periorly and inferiorly just enough to allow insertion of a ded are 2.0 mm in outside diameter with a rounded 4.0-mm
No. 240 polyethylene tube. Do not remove the knife until collar and a 2.25-mm enlargement at the nasal end
the tube is in place, as will be described later. (Figure 13). They are custom made* and vary from 10 to
The tube should have a collar at least 4.0-mm wide. It
should be about 18-mm long and have a bevelled end. It
is threaded, collar first, over a No. 1 lacrimal probe, which Gunther Weiss, 2025 S.W. Briggs Court, Beaverton, Oregon.
COMPLICATIONS
A. THE TUBE MAY COME OUT. SEE THE PATIENT AS SOON AS
possible. During the first few weeks, simply dilate the pas-
sage with a curved Ziegler punctum dilator and a Ziegler
FIGURE 14. (JONES). Appearance of tube in normal position. No. 12 probe (made by Sklar). The dilator shown in
Figure 13 is also excellent for this.* The pyrex tube,
threaded over a No. 1 Bowman probe, can then easily be
reinserted.
The caruncle is first excised. The end of a Bowman No. 1 If the tube has been out too long and the passage has
probe is bent at a slight angle and passed into the canalic- closed, inject about 0.5 cc of 2% novocaine with adrenaline
ulus as far as the lacus area. Here the duct is tented forward solution above and below the medial canthus and cocainize
and buttonholed with pointed scissors. Where the duct is the nasal mucosa in front of the middle turbinate. Install
patent into the nose, a knob-ended canaliculus knife is the tube by repassing the guide needle under intranasal in-
inserted through the new opening, the duct is slit and the spection etc., as previously described. This can be done as
tube installed. If both canaliculi are patent, both are slit an office procedure.
and a single passage is created between them. If the nasal b. Infection with or without granulation tissue. This is usu-
ends are obliterated, the patent parts are slit and a guide ally due to the formation of a rough, hard, scalelike coating
needle is pushed through the obstructed area which is on the outside of the tube. A mucopurulent discharge is
then slit with a Graefe knife. usually seen whenever the outside of the tube gets this de-
In this same group of postoperative failures without us- posit. Pressure from the collar of the tube against the upper
able canalicular epithelium, the caruncle is removed and
the guide needle is inserted as previously described, under Made by Custom Tool Co., 5305 NE. 47th Avenue, Portland, Oregon,
intranasal inspection. This latter is necessary because the 97218.
SUMMARY
COMMENT
IN EVERY CASE OF DISTURBING EPIPHORA DUE TO A PERMA-
THE QUESTION THAT IS MOST FREQUENTLY ASKED IS ‘‘HOW nent failure of the canaliculi, a new passage should be
long will the patient have to wear the tube?’’ This seems to created through which the tears can be propelled. A glass
depend on how long it takes the new passage to epithelize tube or an epithelial-lined passage, possessing capillary
and when the fibroblasts in its walls will cease to contract. attraction combined with the negative pressure phase of
Cases in which canalicular epithelium helps line the pas- tidal respiration in the nose, is a satisfactory substitute for
sage do the best. One 65-year-old patient was able to the lacrimal pump.
discard her tube after about two months. In almost all cases Various methods of creating such a passage are discussed
the tube will begin to get looser after about one year. This is and my experience with a conjunctivodacryocystorhinos-
a sign that the fibroblastic contraction is diminishing. tomy is given. In this procedure a pyrex glass tube is used
The patient can buy the dilator shown in Figure 13 and until the new passage is completely epithelized and ceases
be taught how to use it (Figure 15). He or one of his family, to constrict.
begins by learning to take the pyrex tube out and immedi- 624 Medical Arts Building (5).
ately reinserting it. He then learns to take the tube out,
wait a few minutes and then put the dilator in for a white,
always replacing the tube after withdrawing the dilator.
REFERENCES
Each day the interval of time between taking the tube
out and putting the dilator in, is increased until he can 1. Waldapfel, R.: Clinicopathologic studies of obstructions of the
take the tube out in the morning and insert the dilator in tear passages. Tr. Pacific Coast Oto- Ophth. Soc., 34:289,
the evening. From that time on the patient can discontinue 1953.