Sudha Milk
Sudha Milk
Project Report on
“Study of Market Demand and supply for Milk
and Milk Products of Sudha (Comfed)”
This is to certify that this project report entitled “Study of Market Demand
and supply for Milk and Milk Products of Sudha (Comfed),” embodies
the result of training work carried out by “Mr. Ranjan Kumar Das”, student of
“Master of Business Administration” from Amity Patna, under
Amity University, Noida.
(Marketing Manager)
Patna.
Page 2
Faculty Guide Certificate
His research work was found to be very valuable to our organization. We wish
all the success in her future endeavors.
Amity Patna
Page 3
CONTENTS
BIBLIOGRAPHY
Page 4
DECLARATION
Page 5
Executive Title
Since this study is of short duration and I research deeply about the milk
industry and its market, channel of distribution, customers and its strategies.
Hence my project title is:-
Objectives:-
Page 6
ACKNOWLEDGEMENT
“Gratitude is the hardest of emotions to express and one often does not find
adequate words to convey what one feels and trying to express it”
Take this opportunity to thank all those who have directly and
indirectly inspired, directed and helped me towards successful
completion of project report on Marketing Research of Sudha Dairy
(Comfed).
There are several other people who also deserve much more than a
mere acknowledgement at their exemplary help. I also acknowledge
with deep sense of gratitude and wholehearted help and co-
operation intend.
Page 7
EXECUTIVE SUMMARY
The training at Patna Dairy Project, COMPFED helped me to gain the practical
experience and the study conducted by me centers around the importance and
position of different dairy industries. A thriving dairy sector is of vital importance
to every person specially farmers. It provides milk, Ghee, Cheese other products
to every person. It provides a source of income to rural and urban enterprises and
productive individuals and also a way for the farmers to make their living
standard high. During my summer training in Patna Dairy Project, COMPFED, the
basic focus of my training was on comparative analysis of pouched liquid milk of
SUDHA. Under this project I had to find out the different players carrying on
business of liquid milk in Patna and also their market share in the same region.
After that we had to make comparative analysis so that we can recommend
suggestion to the Patna Dairy Project, COMPFED to increase its share in the
market in Patna. The training was quite a comprehensive one in itself.
Page 8
COMFED OFFICE PATNA
Page 9
PREFACE
Summer Training is the bridge for a student that takes him from his
theoretical knowledge world to practical industry world. The main purpose of
industrial visit is to expose for industrial and business environment, which
cannot be possible in the classroom.
Analysis:-
Recommendation/Suggestion:-
It is the last step which involves the feedback, and suggestion for the project.
Page
10
INTRODUCTION
Page
11
INTRODUCTION
History
India is the highest milk producer in the
entire globe. India is well known as the
‘Oyster’ of the global dairy industry, with
opportunities galore for the entrepreneurs
globally. It might be dream for any nation
in the world to capitalize on the largest
and fastest growing milk and milk
products' market. The dairy industry in
India has been witnessing rapid growth
with liberalization. As the economy
provides good opportunities for MNCs and
foreign investors to release the full
potential of this industry. The main
objective of the Indian Dairy Industry is to
manage the national resources in a
manner to enhance milk production and
upgrade milk processing using innovative
technologies.
Page
12
The crossbred technology in the Indian Dairy Industry has further augmented
with the viability of the dairy units by increasing the milk production per
animal. Then subsequently milk production has also increased at an
exponential rate while the benefits of an increase in milk production also
reached the consumers from a relatively lower increase in the price of milk.
The favorable price environment for milk producers for the Dairy Industry in
India however appeared to have weakened during the 90's, a decline in the
real price of milk being noticed after the year 1992. And then slowly regained
it is glory after 1992 to till now.
Brief Introduction
India had tremendous milk production in 40 years
and has become the world’s largest milk-producing
nation with a gross output of 84.6 million tons in
2001. The Indian Dairy Industry has achieved this
strength of a producer-owned and professionally-
managed cooperative system, despite the facts that
a majority of dairy farmers are illiterate and run
small, marginal operations and for many farmers,
selling milk is their sole source of income. More
than 10 million dairy farmers belong to 96,000
local dairy cooperatives, who sell their products to
one of 170 milk producers’ cooperative unions
who in turn are supported by 15 state cooperative
milk marketing federations.
Page
13
In India dairy business has been practiced as rural cottage industry over the
years. Semi-commercial dairy started with the establishment of military dairy
farms and co-operative milk unions throughout the country towards the end
of the 19th century. Since Independence this Industry has made rapid
progress. A large number of modern milk and milk product factories have
since been established. The organized dairies in India have been successfully
engaged in the routine commercial production of pasteurized bottled milk for
Indian dairy products.
The growth of Indian Dairy Industry during the last three decades has been
impressive, at more than 5% per annum; and in the 90's the country has
emerged as the largest producer of milk. This is not a small achievement when
we consider the fact that dairying in India is largely stringent that farmers in
general keep dairy animals in proportion to their free crop and also are
available for family labor with little or no purchased inputs and a minimum of
marketed outputs. The existence of restrictive trade policy milk in the Diary
Industry and the emergence of Amul type cooperatives have changed the
dairy farming practices in the country. Farmers have gained the favorable
price for their milk and for their production. Which was essentially a self-
reliant one is which is now being transformed into a commercial proposition.
India in the early 1950's was commercially importing around 55000 tons of
milk powder annually to meet the urban milk demand. Most of the significant
developments in dairying have taken place in India in this century only.
Page
14
INDIAN DAIRY INDUSTRY (NDDB)
Ghee 27.0%
Butter 6.5%
Curd 7%
The Indian Diary industry which is in the developing stage provides gainful
employment to a vast majority of the rural households. It employs about 8.47
million people on yearly basis out of which 71% are women.
Jobs in Indian dairy industry are mainly in the fields of production and
processing of dairy products. An individual with minimum of 60% marks who
has bachelor’s degree course in the dairy technology can easily be availing an
opportunity to work in this industry. For the graduation course in Dairy
technology one has to qualify the All India Entrance Test that is affiliated to
the Indian Council of Agricultural Research. After that the person can continue
with his masters in dairy technology. Jobs would be for the following
positions.
Dairy Scientists: The main job of the dairy scientists is to deal with
collection of milk and taking care of the high yielding variety of animals.
Dairy Technologists: the work of Dairy technology requires
procurement officers who take the responsibility of collecting milk from
farmers, milk booths and cattle-rearers. This particular procurement
officer should well understand the latest technology that is applicable in
maintaining the quality of milk of the process of transporting it to the
desired location.
Dairy Engineers: dairy engineers are usually appointed is to set up and
maintain dairy plants.
Marketing Personnel: These individuals deal with the sale and
marketing of milk together with milk products.
Page
16
Amul's success story
Amul's success had huge impact in the creation of same structure of milk
producers in other districts of Gujarat initially. Amul's experience was driving
force in project planning and execution. The ‘Anand Pattern' was followed in
Kaira district, Mehsana, Sabarkantha, Banaskantha, Baroda and Surat
districts. As even before the setting up of the Dairy Board of India, farmers
and their leaders carried out various tests of the hypotheses that explained
Amul's success. All through these districts, milk producers and their leaders
experienced significant commonalties and found easy, effortless ways to
adapt Amul's game plan to their respective areas. This eventually led to the
Creation of the National Dairy Development Board with the clear mandate of
replicating the 'Anand pattern' in other parts of the country. Initially this
pattern was followed for the dairy Industry but at later stage oilseeds, fruit
and vegetables, salt, and tree sectors also benefited from its success.
Page
17
Latest developments
Indian Dairy Industry is the largest milk producer all over the
world, around 100 million MT Indian Dairy Industries value of
output amounted to Rs. 1179 billion in 2004-05 which
approximately equals combined output of paddy and wheat. With
1/5th of the world’s bovine population.
In India the Milk animals constitutes 45% indigenous cattle, 55 %
buffaloes, and 10% cross bred cows
Dairy Venture Capital Fund- this is introduced in the Tenth Five Year Plan to
bring about structural changes in unorganized sector, which would measure
like milk processing at village level, marketing of pasteurized milk in a cost
effective manner, quality or the up gradation of traditional technology to
handle commercial scale using modern equipments and management skills.
Page
18
COMPANY PROFILE
The Bihar State Milk Co-operative Federation Ltd. (COMFED) was established
in 1983 as the implementing agency of OPERATIONAL FLOOD programme of
dairy development on “Anand pattern” in Bihar and Jharkhand (erstwhile
Bihar). COMFED is the state level co-operative organization, having six district
level affiliated Milk unions in the state of Bihar. As on March 2011, COMFED
had 9775 village dairy cooperatives (DCS) federated into six milk unions
located in the state of Bihar and having average 11.03 lakh kgs of milk every
day. Approximately 5.53 lakh Farmers are presently members of village dairy
cooperatives.
Different milk unions, which are organizing the DCS network in these
districts, are listed below:-
Page
19
The Milk Federation has already taken up organization of Dairy Cooperative
Societies (DCS) in the districts of Gaya, Jahanabad, Arwal and Nawada under
Magadh Dairy Project and work has been initiated by Kosi Dairy Project in
Saharsa, Supaul and Madhepura districts. However, Kosi Dairy Project will be
covering Katihar, Purnia and Araria districts also. At present the total number
of districts covered by unions and Dairy Projects is thirty six (36).
The districts of East and West Singhbhum, Ranchi, Bokaro and Dhanbad now
in Jharkhand are being covered by the dairies directly under the control of
Milk Federation for the supply of milk and milk products to the urban
consumers in these cities. Procurement of milk has been taken up in Ranchi
district only.
COMFED has adopted the following Mission Statement: “To integrate all
business processes across the organization in order to provide online
information which will facilitate quick decision making”
Page
20
(B) Goals and Objectives
(C) Objectives
a) Create a new vision of Business policies and processes that are cost-
effective, customer oriented, efficient and innovative.
b) Create and implement an operational environment which is pro-active and
results in
c) Savings in inventory carrying cost
d) Reducing operational costs
e) Eliminating redundancy
f) Promoting near paperless environment
g) Streamlining data flow
h) More effective use of resources
i) Support to the business growth
j) Leverage of administrative costs
k) Providing most advanced real time information system.
l) Standardization of processes
m) Regulatory requirements
The primary benefits expected to accrue from the SAP implementation are:
a) Support a flexible, evolving and responsive business environment.
b) Eliminate non-value adding activities such as data entry duplication.
Improved ability to service customers.
Reduction in administrative costs.
Better management of inventory
Support information sharing and access
Streamline processes and reduce waste.
Better credit control.
MIS reports timely &accurately.
Batch management.
Page
21
Bihar's rural landscape has undergone a silent revolution under an umbrella
organization that involves around six lakh farmers and provides indirect
employment to many others. It has been brought about by Bihar State Milk Co-
operative Federation Limited (Comfed), which markets milk and milk
products under the brand 'Sudha'. It celebrated its 29th foundation day this
month. Its Managing Director Harjot Kaur told that Comfed was committed to
serve its customers and realize the dream of having at least one Bihari dish in
the plate of every Indian. Although COMFED’s journey started since 1983, and
from then to till now it has achieved so many things not for itself but also for
the many of farmers joined to it. Comfed is a rural organization involving six
lakh farmers. Starting with just 1030 cooperatives in 1983, today the number
of cooperatives has risen to 11,400. The milk production is 11 lakh liters per
day, and the annual turnover in 2011-12 was Rs 1503.00 crore, 11% more
than that of previous year. This is remarkable for any cooperative. In 2011-12,
the Comfed marketed 8.17 lakh liters milk per day, which is a record in its
history. Many farmers associated with our cooperatives have been awarded at
the national level for their performance. Recently Haryana dairy farmers are
vehemently agitating against milk companies, to rule out such agitations we
have taken sufficient steps as farmers are the most precious part of our
organization. Whatever profit the Comfed earns, trickles down to farmers. We
procure milk from farmers at Rs 25.58 per litre, which is higher than the
cooperatives of Haryana, Rajasthan, Punjab, Karnataka and Maharashtra,
apart from others. The recent hike in the prices of milk was also passed down
directly to farmers. There are no middleman between us and the farmers. The
Comfed also provides fodder at subsidized rates to farmers. We also assist
them in artificial insemination and maintaining health of their domestic
animals. As per the new road map for dairy development, we envisage to
produce 44 lakh liters milk per day from the existing 11 lakh liters per day,
covering around 60% villages of the state against the existing 33%. We are
also trying to capture new markets. At present we sell packaged milk in Bihar
and Jharkhand, parts of Orissa, West Bengal, Uttar Pradesh and North-east.
We send bulk milk to Delhi, Manesar and Kolkata, where it is sold by various
dairy cooperatives like Amul and Mother Dairy under their own brand names.
In these places, we plan to market our milk under the 'Sudha' brand.
Moreover, we are also looking to export to other countries like Bangladesh
and Bhutan. Moreover, we have also decided to do value addition to our
existing more than two dozen milk products by increasing their variety.
Consequently, I believe, our cumulative profit would rise by around 15% per
annum in the coming five years.
Page
22
Sudha to go international
After positioning Bihar firmly among major milk producing states of the
country, Bihar State Cooperative Milk Producers' Federation Limited
(Comfed) is all set to export milk and milk products to Bangladesh and Bhutan
by early next year. It is also in the final stages of commissioning new dairies at
Biharsharif and Hajipur next month, which will hike its milk-processing
capacity significantly. "We have plans to increase the existing milk production
from 12 lakh liters to 20 lakh liters daily by the end of the year," said Comfed
MD Vipin Kumar. Comfed is the apex cooperative federation of six milk unions
of the state. Patna Dairy Project, run under the name and style of Vaishali-
Patliputra Dugdh Utpadak Sahkari Sangh Ltd, is the lead union. Though the six
unions have their own procurement and marketing arrangements, they
market their products under the brand name 'Sudha'. Comfed has currently 26
milk products. "But we are planning to export only those products that are not
sensitive to temperature fluctuation — like ghee, milk powder and milk in
tetra pack," said Patna Dairy Project MD Sudhir Kumar Singh. "The shelf life of
tetra pack is around 90 days while temperature fluctuation is not a matter of
concern for products like ghee and milk powder," Singh said and added the
products would have to undergo quality test of Export Council of India before
the exports begin. As of now, Comfed has been supplying milk and milk
products to different parts of the country as well as Nepal. And the demand
has been gradually going up. "We have tie-up with Mother Dairy-Kolkata,
Amul- Manesar, Delhi Milk Scheme and other dairy cooperatives in various
states to whom we supply milk and milk products which are sold by them
under their brand names. But now we are planning to sell them under the
brand name Sudha," Singh said. Of the 12 lakh liters of milk produced by
Comfed-affiliated dairies daily, around 3 lakh liters are supplied to Jharkhand,
Orissa, Delhi, Kolkata, Varanasi and Guwahati. "Besides, we export around
50,000-60,000 liters of milk to Nepal daily," Singh said and added Comfed has
6000 milk outlets and 14 dairies which involve as many as 5.5 lakh dairy
cooperative farmers. Patna Dairy will get a shot in the arm when its upcoming
dairy plants at Biharsharif and Hajipur are commissioned in September. "The
dairy at Biharsharif, likely to cost Rs 120 crore, is coming up on a 26-acre plot
of prime land made available by the state government, and will have a
capacity to process four lakh liters of liquid milk per day," Singh said. Besides,
the Biharsharif dairy will have tetra pack facility and could also produce 30
tons of milk powder per day by drying 3 lakhs liters of liquid milk. The dairy
coming up at Hajipur would have a capacity of one lakh liters of milk.
Page
23
A proposal has been mooted to set up a dairy plant in Chhapra, where a
25,000-litre chilling plant already exists and milk availability is very good.
There's also a plan to set up a 30-tonne capacity milk powder plant either at
Hajipur or Chhapra, the Patna Dairy MD said.
Patna Dairy brought Sheikhpura district under its ambit last year. Now, a milk
chilling plant is being planned in the district. Around 100 primary milk
cooperative societies have already been formed in the district. Singh said the
Patna Dairy this year completed expansion of its balanced cattle feed plant
from 100 tons to 150 tons. Work is in progress for setting up another plant of
the same capacity. The dairy makes cattle feed available to farmers at their
doorstep at a concessional rate of Rs 11.50/kg. Dairy farmers are given
remunerative price of Rs 18 to 26 per litre for milk, depending on the quality
as per set parameters. In its eagerness to expand its footprint to new areas,
Patna Dairy is not ignoring its local base. Said Sudhir Kumar Singh, "At
present, we meet 50% demand for milk in the state capital, while the rest is
met by local milkmen and private dairies. By 2015, our procurement will
increase to 5 lakh liters daily, which at present varies between 2.5 to 3 lakh
liters every day. So, even if supplies by local vendors fall, we will be in a
position to meet the demand of Patnaites in the coming years."
Patna Dairy's smooth operation has not gone unrecognized. It won National
Productivity awards four times – in 2000-01, 2002-03, 2004-05 and 2005-06.
Given a new lease of life in 1981, when a team of National Dairy Development
Board took it over, Patna Dairy (or, for that matter, Comfed) has proved, to
use a cliché, that where there's a will, there's a way.
Page
24
SUDHA IN INDIA
Marketing section
Administration section
Cleaning section.
Page
25
ORGANISATIONAL STRUCTURE
COMFED
CHAIRMAN (IAS)
MD (MANAGINGDIRECTOR)
IAS
GM (GENERAL MANAGER)
ASSISTANTMANAGER MANAGER
ASSISTANT MANAGER
TECHNICAL OFFICER
MILK PROCUREMENT OFFICER
Page
26
Objective of the Study
Page
27
Scope of the study
The scope is limited to the extent of the place, time, organization and their
information collected during the project. It is done as a part of academic study.
The scope o f the study limited to information supplied by the Department
Head and information collected by standing order and settlement copies of
the company. The information collected is limited to the academic knowledge
gained by the student during the study of the course.
Page
28
Limitation of the Study
Page
29
Methodology:
Primary data
Secondary data
Primary data:
a. Personal observation.
b. Interview with:
Consumers
Marketing Department
Account Department
Procurement Department
Secondary data:
The secondary data has been collected with reference to various records of
the company, Such as:
1. Website: www.compfed.co.in
2. Files.
Page
30
Abstract
Page
31
An Introduction to the Problem
Page
32
HISTORY OF COMFED
1. Background
The Bihar State Co-operative Milk Producers’ Federation Ltd. (COMFED) came
into existence in 1983 as the implementing agency of Operation Flood (OF)
program of dairy development on Anand pattern in the State. All the operation
or erstwhile Bihar State Dairy Co-operation was handed over to COMFED.
2. Area of operation
There are six district level Milk Producers' Co-operative Unions affiliated to
the Milk Federation. These milk unions are covering twenty-six districts and
in addition five districts are being covered by the Federation. Different milk
unions, which are organizing the DCS network in these districts, are as
follows:
Page
33
The Milk Federation has already taken up organization of Dairy Co-operative
Societies (DCS) in the districts of Gaya, Jahanabad, arwal and Nawada under
Magadh dairy project and work has been initiated in Saharsa, Supaul and
Madhepura districts.
However, kosi dairy project will be covering Kishangunj, katihar, Purnia, and
Araria districts also. The districts of East and West Singhbhum, Ranchi,
Bokaro, Dhanbad, Jamshedpur and other districts of Jharkhand is covered by
the COMFED(dairies) directly also under the control of Milk Federation for the
supply of milk and milk products to the urban consumers in these cities.
Procurement of milk has been taken up in Ranchi districts only. The Milk
Federation has already taken up organization of Dairy Co-operative Societies
(DCS) in the districts of Gaya, Jahanabad, Bhagalpur and GOI has approved a
proposal for dairy development in Supaul, Madhepura and Saharsa districts.
The districts of East and West Singhbhum, Ranchi, Bokaro and Dhanbad are
being covered by the dairies directly under the control of Milk Federation for
the supply of milk and milk products to the urban consumers in these cities.
Procurement of milk has been taken up in Ranchi district only.
3. Physical Performance:
Because of initial teething troubles and the set back caused by the natural
vagaries, the progress was impeded. Regaining of confidence of the milk
producers in the cooperative dairying system shattered due to poor
management by erstwhile Bihar State Cooperation earlier was also of one of
the major reasons for sluggish growth. Lack of functional infrastructure in the
sphere of animal husbandry, especially in breed improvement, artificial
insemination (AI) and animal health cover also contributed to the torpid
progress.
Policy decisions taken six to seven years ago have changed the trend of
growth in all quarter’s of cooperative dairying in Bihar. In the earlier years,
the emphasis was on the horizontal of dairy cooperative network. Now the
strengthening / consolidation of the dairy cooperatives is being done to make
them viable and gradual expansion of area is also being done. Achievements
under different activities are summarized in the following pages.
Page
34
4. Marketing
A. Liquid Marketing
In the initial years, the emphasis of COMFED was on organizing DCS and
educating farmers. In the initial years the milk sale moved at snail's speed
from Later, marketing was given a boost by considering it a thrust area, about
5 to 100.55 thousand liters per day in 1987 to 106.54 thousand liters per day
(TLPD) in 1992-93. However, strategies adopted in 1993-94, changed the
trend completely. Year 2003 was declared as "Market Development Year". The
daily average milk marketing has now reached a level of about 531 TLPD
showing a continued increase which is depicted below:
In order to boost the sale of liquid milk, the dairies adopted the following
strategies:-
Continual improvement in the quality of milk. It was achieved as a
result of taking up taking up Dairy Plant Management (DPM) and
Quality Assurance Program (QAP) by all the dairies with technical and
financial assistance from NDDB / Comfed. Nine out of ten dairies of
Comfed, namely, Patna, Muzaffarpur, Ranchi, Bokaro, Gaya, Bhagalpur,
Jamshedpur, Barouni and Samastipur dairy have already been
accredited with ISO : 9001:2000 and HACCP :ISO and HACCP
certification.
Bihar is one of the few States in the country which has been permitted
by the National Dairy Development Board to use the “Mnemonic”
symbol on the confirming the quality standards fixed by NDDB.
AI's Performed
Adequate arrangements have been made to expand the coverage of dairy co-
operative societies under this program. For AI training, training facilities
available at Comfed headquarter are being utilized and some persons are
provided training at ERDTC, Siliguri, a NDDB managed training centre. Around
80% of the total functional DCS are covered under this program.
Page
36
Prophylactic Vaccination
Around 2665 Veterinary First Aid (VFA) centers have been established which
do the vaccinations. Prophylactic inoculations are mainly done against Foot
&Mouth Disease (FMD), Hemorrhage Septicemia (HS), Black Quarter (BQ) and
Theileriosis diseases. During 2001-02, after initial trial, mass vaccination with
Trio-o-vac (combined FMD, HS and BQ vaccine) on the lines of Pulse Polio
vaccinations in children was taken up. During 2009-10 about 16.35 lakh
vaccinations have been done.
This program has been taken up with the technical assistance from NDDB.
Under this program, screening of milk animals is done using "Masticate". The
doubtful or sub-clinical cases are given treatment. Awareness amongst the
milk producers is created for disinfecting the udders and teats after milking
with a view to check the infection of animals. Milk unions provide necessary
disinfectant and treat cups to the milk producers on cost basis.
Deworming
Veterinary Camps
The milk unions organize veterinary camps where the milk producers bring
their animals for treatment.
Since, seventy five to eighty percent of the cost of milk production depends on
the feeding of milk animals; this is very important affecting the economy
of dairying activity. Both green fodder and balanced cattle feed are required to
beefed in appropriate quantities for optimizing the output i.e. the production
and also to maintain the health of the animal. The farmers in select dairy co-
operative societies are being provided training through a computerized
nutrition balancing system with the help of National Dairy Development
Board.
Page
37
Adult Cattle feed (ACF) and Bypass Protein Feed (BPF) is manufactured by our
cattle feed plants (CFP) located at Patna, Ranchi and Muzaffarpur. The total
installed capacity of these plants is 260 Metric Tons Per Day (MTD) The cattle
feed produced by these plants is supplied on cost basis to the farmers. Besides
manufacturing BPF and ACF, CFP Ranchi also manufactures other livestock
feeds to meet the requirement of Govt. farms in Bihar and Jharkhand. During
2009-10, the sale of cattle feed to DCS was 57.55 thousand Metric Tons.
Green fodder is equally important in animal nutrition. Besides providing
important nutrients, it helps in reducing the intake of balanced cattle feed and
in turn the cost of production. After prolonged extension work and
persuasion, the farmers have started not only the cultivation of different
fodders in their fields but have started the production of fodder seeds.
Another Important scheme under fodder development has been the treatment
of straw with urea, which not only increases the palatability of dry fodder but
increases its nutritional value also. Feeding of urea treated straw helps in
reducing the cost of production of milk. Farmers have now taken it up on
regular basis and during 2009-10 about 11613 MTs of straw has been treated.
Page
38
Clean Milk Production
Plant
Page
39
Procurement
The milk procurement during 1994-95 averaged 114.32 thousand kg’s, per
day which jumped more than five times to around 608.38 TKPD in 2006-07
but the devastating floods in July-Sept 2007 and also during second half of
2008 had very severe effect on the production of milk and its procurement by
DCS. In 2008-09, it fell down to 415.36 TKPD but due to sustained efforts it
again picked up the momentum. The daily average milk procurement during
2011-12 was 1074.92 TKPD.
Milk Union/
1887-88 1997-98 2003-04 2006-07 2010-11 2011-12
Unit
Barouni 20.57 65.93 135.00 173.69 333.08 314.12
Muzaffarpur 10.77 24.43 52.84 87.13 118.13 115.12
Samastipur 7.44 32.00 69.86 129.85 248.13 250.99
Patna 30.18 56.18 102.66 157.33 221.23 210.15
Shahabad - 8.77 29.99 45.41 123.75 129.44
Vikramshila 1.41 2.81 3.27 7.78 35.05 35.73
Gaya .68 .0.15 3.55 2.42 10.76 7.50
Kosi - - - - 6.29 7.13
Ranchi - 5.35 6.06 4.78 4.95 4.74
Total 71.05 213.19 403.00 608.38 1101.38 1074.92
Page
40
Extra Curricular Activities Performed
By COMFED
Page
41
RASHTRIYA KRISHI VIKAS YOJNA:
After crucial analysis of the situation, the state government, for the
development of diary area has prepared a diary road map for the year 2008-
12. In this plan emphasis will be made for the complete development of dairy
area.
These plans are being implemented by all the units of COMFED. In 2009 and
2010 the state government has provided an amount of Rs. 27.59 crore and Rs.
21.39 crore respectively to COMFED for implementation of these plans. In
2010-11 Rs. 21.86 crore has been provided by the state government.
Due to the implementation of the dairy road map programme approx 1210
villages are being benefited. This has been possible due to establishment of
co-operative societies in these villages. Approx 112 farmers have got training
in this field. Under this programme there are 65 AI centers which provide
their services to five to six villages nearby. These centers are also helping in
improving the breed of milk animals.
Page
42
BIHAR GRAMIN JEEVIKOPARJAN YOJNA:
Bihar government with the help of financial assistance of World Bank has
started ‘Bihar Gramin Jeevikoparjan yojna’ to improve the living standard of
people residing in villages. The main objective of this programme is to raise
the living standard of women and other people of backward community by
dairying activities. This programme has also aimed to create awareness
among the villagers about their fundamental rights. For implementing this
plan self help groups are also formed.
COMFED is helping the members of this self help group in earning the regular
income by connecting them to the milk co-operative societies. For this a plan
has been prepared under which the three districts of Bihar i.e. Muzaffarpur,
Nalanda and Khagaria are targeted for implementation for this plan.
Page
43
SWOT
Analysis of Sudha Dairy, Patna
Strengths:
•Demand profile:
Absolutely positive
•Technical manpower:
Weaknesses:
•Logistics of procurement:
•Competition:
Page
44
Opportunities:
"Failure is never final, and success never ending”. Dr Kurien bears out
this statement perfectly, if dairy entrepreneurs are looking for opportunities
in India, the following areas must be tapped:
Value addition:
Efforts to use export potential are already on.Opportunities will increase trem
endously for the export of agri- products in general and dairy products in
particular.
Threats:
Today milk vendors are occupying the pride of place in the industry.
Organized dissemination of information about the harm that they are doing to
producers and consumers should see a steady decline in their importance.
Page
45
Real Facts
and previous year’s
records of sales
and presentations
Page
46
Item wise sale summary to distributors during 2010-2011
Page
48
CUSTOMERS PER DAY DEMAND OF
SUDHA
1. Customers demand of milk from the retailer per day (in liter)?
250-300 4 20
300-350 1 5
TOTAL 20 100
15%
200-250
250-300
20%
300-350
60% 350-ABOVE
5%
5-10 10 50
10-15 6 30
15-20 2 10
20 & ABOVE 2 10
TOTAL 20 100
60
50
40
30 number of repondents
percentage
20
10
0
5 to 10 10 to 15 15 to 20 20 & above
Page
50
CUSTOMERS DEMAND OF GULAB
JAMUN FROM RETAILERS (IN KG)
10 & above
5 to 10
number of respondents
percentage
3 to 5
1 to 3
0 20 40 60 80
4. Customers demand to Lassi from the retailers per day (in packets)?
RESPONSES NUMBER OF PERCENTAGE (%)
RESPONDENTS
100-150 1 5
150-200 3 15
200-250 3 15
TOTAL 20 100
16
14
12
10
8 number of respondents
percentage
6
0
100-150 150-200 200-250 250 & above
INFERENCE:- Out of 20 retailers, 65% of them have 250 & above packets of
demand, 15% have 200-250 packets of demand, 15% have 150-200 demand
and 5% have 100-150 demand of packets of lassi from the retailers per day.
Page
52
CUSTOMERS DEMAND OF PEDA FROM THE RETAILERS (IN
KG)
60
50
40
percentage
30
respondents
20
10
0
1-3.0 3-5.0 5-10.0 10 & ABOVE
CUSTOMERS DEMAND OF ICE-CREAM FROM THE
RETAILERS (IN KG)
80
70
60
50
percentage
40
number respondents
30
20
10
0
10 to 20 20 to 30 30 to 40 40 & above
7. Customers demand of Sudha ghee from the retailers per day (in
kg)?
RESPONSES NUMBER OF PERCENTAGE (%)
RESPONDENTS
1-3 5 25
3-5 2 10
5-10 6 30
10 & ABOVE 7 35
TOTAL 20 100
35
30
25
20
number of respomdents
15 percentage
10
0
1 to 3 3 to 5 5 to 10 10 & above
INFERENCE: Out of 20 retailers, 35% of them have demand 10 & above kg, 30%
demand of 5-10kg, 25% demand of 1-3 kg and 10 % demand of 3-5 kg of Sudha
ghee from the retailers of total customers per day.
Page
55
8. Customers demand of Misti Dahi the retailers per day (in kg)?
RESPONSES NUMBER OF PERCENTAGE (%)
RESPONDENTS
10-20 18 90
20-30 1 5
30-40 1 5
40 & ABOVE 0 0
TOTAL 20 100
100
90
80
70
60
50 number of respondents
percentage
40
30
20
10
0
10 to 20 20 to 30 30 to 40 40 & above
Page
56
CUSTOMERS DEMAND OF PLAIN DAHI FROM RETAILERS (IN KG)
100
90
80
70
60
percentage
50
number of respondents
40
30
20
10
0
10 to 20 20 to 30 30 to 40 40 & above
10. Customers demand of Butter from the retailers per day (in g)?
RESPONSES (gram) NUMBER RESPONDENTS PERCENTAGE (%)
50-100 13 65
100-150 5 25
150-200 2 10
200-250 0 0
TOTAL 20 100
70
60
50
40
number of respondents
30 percentage
20
10
0
50-100 100-150 150-200 200-250
Page
58
11. Customers demand of Milk from the retailers on special occasions (i.e.
Deepawali, marriage session etc.) in Liters?
5-20 14 70
20-35 4 20
35-50 1 5
50 & ABOVE 1 5
TOTAL 20 100
5%
5%
5 to 20
20%
20 to 35
35 to 50
10 & ABOVE
70%
Page
59
12. Are Retailers satisfied with the delivery time of the distributor?
YES 16 80
NO 4 20
TOTAL 20 100
respondents
yes
no
Page
60
RETAILERS PER DAY DEMAND OF SUDHA
PRODUCTS FROM THE COMPANY
1. Retailers demand of milk from the company per day (in liters)?
25-50 13 65
50-75 4 20
75-100 2 10
TOTAL 20 100
5%
10%
25-50
50-75
20%
75-100
100 & above
65%
INFERENCE:- Out 0f 20 retailers, 65% of them demands 25-50 liters of Milk, 20%
demands 50 – 75 liters, 10% demands 75-100 liters and 5% demands 100 and
above liters from the company per day.
Page
61
RETAILERS DEMAND OF LASSI FROM CO. (IN
PACKETS)
60 & above
40-60
no of respondents
percentage
20-40
0-20
50
40
percentage
30 no of respondents
20
10
0
0-250 250-500 500-1000
4. Retailers demand of Ice cream from the company per day (in litre)?
RESPONSES NUMBER RESPONDENTS PERCENTAGE (%)
0-50 6 30
50-100 3 15
100-150 1 5
TOTAL 20 100
60
50
40
percentage
30 no of respondents
20
10
0
0-50 50-100 100-150 150 & above
INFERENCE: - Out of 20 retailers, 50% of them demands 150 & above liters, 30%
of them demands 0-50 and 20% demands 50-150 litre of ice – cream from the
company per day.
Page
64
5. Retailers demand of Sudha ghee from the company per day (in kg)?
0-1 10 50
1-2 5 25
2-3 4 20
3 & ABOVE 1 5
TOTAL 20 100
5%
20%
50%
25%
INFERENCE: - Out of 20 retailers, 50% of them demands 0-1 kg, 25% demands
1-2 kg, 20% demands 2-3 kg and 5% demands 3 & above kg of Sudha ghee
from company per day.
Page
65
RETAILERS DEMAND OF PLAIN DAHI (IN KG)
100%
90%
80%
70%
60% percentage
50%
no of respondents
40%
30%
20%
10%
0%
10 to 20 20 to 30 30 to 40 40 & above
RETAILERS DEMAND OF MILK ON SPECIAL OCCASIONS IN KGS
PERCENTAGE (%)
100%
90%
80%
70%
60% percentage
50%
no of respondents
40%
30%
20%
10%
0%
0-5 5 to 10 10 to 15 15 & above
CUSTOMER’S
ATTRIBUTES
Page
68
1. Preference given on different attributes:-
TASTE 50 25
PRICE 5 2.5
PACKAGING 4 2
VARIETY 10 5
QUALITY 60 30
ABUNDANCE 50 25
INFERENCE: - Among the various attributes of Sudha products, 25% likes its
taste, 30% likes its quality, 25% likes it because of its abundance and 20% like
other attributes.
Page
69
COMPLAINTS
OF
THE CUSTOMERS
Page
70
1. Complaints of the customer :-
7% late delivery
TASTE
10%
1% PRICE
2%
PACKAGING
INFERENCE: - Out of 200 customers, 54% off them had no complaints but
46% of them have to face certain problems respectively.
Page
71
Questionnaire For Consumer
PART A: INTRODUCTION
a) Age: -
c) Qualification: - ________________________.
d) Occupation: - ________________________.
2. Address of consumer:-
3. Contact number:-
PART B: INTRESTS
Page
72
7. What are the sources of purchasing milk?
a) yes b) No
11. Weather SUDHA sweets and milk price are reasonable or not?
a) Yes (b) No
12. What is your level of satisfaction with Sudha milks and products?
COMPLAINTS: - ________________________________________________________
__________________________________________________________________________.
SUGGESTIONS: - ________________________________________________________
__________________________________________________________________________.
Page
73
Questionnaire For Retailer
PART A: INTRODUCTION
a) Age: -
c) Qualification: - ________________________.
d) Occupation: - ________________________.
2. Address of consumer:-
3. Contact number:-
PART B: INTRESTS
Page
74
7. Which type of milk is more demanded?
b) yes b) No
11. Weather SUDHA sweets and milk price is affordable for consumer?
12. What is the level of satisfaction in consumers about Sudha milks and products?
COMPLAINTS: - ________________________________________________________
__________________________________________________________________________.
SUGGESTIONS: - ________________________________________________________
__________________________________________________________________________.
Page
75
FINDINGS OF THE STUDY
Out of the two types of Sudha milk, standard milk is more sold by the
retailers and is more preferred by the customers.
56% of the retailers are facing the problem of shortages.
Out of the two milk packets, full liters milk packets are mostly sold by
the retailers.
50% of the retailers have to face complaints from the customers.
Majority of the retailer’s i.e. 88% of them are satisfied as being a part of
Sudha diary.
Majority of retailers are satisfied with the margin of Sudha dairy.
Sudha milk has captured majority of the market share of processed milk
in Patna. It is the market leader having 92% market share.
58% of customer uses Sudha milk for drinking.
Majority of the customers are satisfied with the Sudha milk and have no
any complaints.
Majority of customer prefer Sudha milk because of its quality, taste and
abundance.
55% of customer prefers fat milk.
37% of the customers have to face from the problem of shortages,.
93% of the customers are satisfied with our delivery system.
Majority of customers are in a favors to open more milk booths.
87% of customers want cow milk from Sudha dairy.
Till now, the companies have been able to maintain a healthy relation at
both level (External and Internal).
It is lacking behind in remote areas.
Page
76
SUGGESTIONS
After an analysis of the findings of survey I feel that there are some strength
which the company can work on and some drawback which can remove:-
1) Patna dairy should give notice to every retailers and distributers about
how to preserve and guide them for the proper maintenance of the milk.
3) The company should take steps to provide closer interactions with the
retailers who feel that greater patronage is given to the wholesalers. For this I
would suggest regular retailers meet and attractive incentives schemes
targeted to them.
6) Patna dairy should increase the margin on the Sudha milk to at least Rs.
1, which will increase the motivation level of the retailers.
Page
77
8) Patna dairy should advertise about the products to make them aware to
the customers by providing display board, banner to their outlets and using
other means of advertisement.
9) Price of half liters milk should be equal to half the price of full liters
milk.
Page
78
Page
79
CONCLUSION
Taken as a whole the company does seem to have good share of the retail market
but it does not appear to have reached its full potential. Periodic market surveys
to study market conditions, customers changing taste, marketing network and the
competitive environment would help greatly in strengthening the presence of the
company.
I sincerely hope that my findings and suggestions may somehow prove useful to
the company and it continues to go from strength to strength.
I express my thanks to Mr. Rajeev Verma (Asst. General Manager), Ritesh sir and
all other staffs who encouraged and help me in conducting the survey and
compiling the information.
Page
80
BIBLIOGRAPHY
Websites:
http://www.google.co.in/
http://compfed.co.in/index_2.html
http://www.motherdairy.com/MotherDairyPages/home.aspx
Page
81
Case Study: The dairy giant AMUL
Dear sir,
I came across with an interesting case study on the dairy giant AMUL :
Every day Amul collects 447,000 liters of milk from 2.12 million farmers
(many illiterate), converts the milk into branded, packaged products, and
delivers goods worth Rs 6 crore (Rs 60 million) to over 500,000 retail outlets
across the country.
Every day Amul collects 447,000 liters of milk from 2.12 million farmers,
converts the milk into branded and packaged products, and delivers goods
worth Rs 6 crore (Rs 60 million) to over 500,000 retail outlets across the
country.
Its supply chain is easily one of the most complicated in the world. How do
managers at Amul prevent the milk from souring?
Page
82
Organization structure
Based in the village of Anand, the Kaira District Milk Cooperative Union
(better known as Amul) expanded exponentially. It joined hands with other
milk cooperatives, and the Gujarat network now covers 2.12 million farmers,
10,411 village level milk collection centers and fourteen district level plants
(unions) under the overall supervision of GCMMF.
There are similar federations in other states. Right from the beginning, there
was recognition that this initiative would directly benefit and transform small
farmers and contribute to the development of society.
Markets, then and even today are primitive and poor in infrastructure. Amul
and GCMMF acknowledged that development and growth could not be left to
market forces and that proactive intervention was required. Two key
requirements were identified.
The first, that sustained growth for the long term would depend on matching
supply and demand. It would need heavy investment in the simultaneous
development of suppliers and consumers.
Page
83
Management of this network is made more complex by the fact that GCMMF is
directly responsible only for a small part of the chain, with a number of third
party players (distributors, retailers and logistics support providers) playing
large roles.
Developing demand
At the time Amul was formed, consumers had limited purchasing power, and
modest consumption levels of milk and other dairy products. Thus Amul
adopted a low-cost price strategy to make its products affordable and
attractive to consumers by guaranteeing them value for money.
Despite competition in the high value dairy product segments from firms such
as Hindustan Lever, Nestle and Britannia, GCMMF ensures that the product
mix and the sequence in which Amul introduces its products is consistent with
the core philosophy of providing milk at a basic, affordable price.
Page
84
Wholesale dealers carry inventory that is just adequate to take care of the
transit time from the branch warehouse to their premises. This just-in-time
inventory strategy improves dealers' return on investment (ROI). All GCMMF
branches engage in route scheduling and have dedicated vehicle operations.
Umbrella brand
The network follows an umbrella branding strategy. Amul is the common
brand for most product categories produced by various unions: liquid milk,
milk powders, butter, ghee, cheese, cocoa products, sweets, ice-cream and
condensed milk.
Coordination
Given the large number of organizations and entities in the supply chain and
decentralized responsibility for various activities, effective coordination is
critical for efficiency and cost control. GCMMF and the unions play a major
role in this process and jointly achieve the desired degree of control.
Buy-in from the unions is assured as the plans are approved by GCMMF's
board. The board is drawn from the heads of all the unions, and the boards of
the unions comprise of farmers elected through village societies, thereby
creating a situation of interlocking control.
Page
85
The federation handles the distribution of end products and coordination with
retailers and the dealers. The unions coordinate the supply side activities.
These include monitoring milk collection contractors, the supply of animal
feed and other supplies, provision of veterinary services, and educational
activities.
It is worth noting that a number of these third parties are not in the organized
sector, and many are not professionally managed with little regard for quality
and service.
In developing these practices, the federation and the unions have adapted
successful models from around the world. It could be the implementation of
small group activities or quality circles at the federation. Or a TQM program at
the unions. Or housekeeping and good accounting practices at the village
society level.
More important, the network has been able to regularly roll out improvement
programs across to a large number of members and the implementation rate
is consistently high.
Page
86
For example, every Friday, without fail, between 10.00 a.m. and 11.00 a.m., all
employees of GCMMF meet at the closest office, be it a department or a branch
or a depot to discuss their various quality concerns.
Each meeting has its pre-set format in terms of Purpose, Agenda and Limit
(PAL) with a process check at the end to record how the meeting was
conducted. Similar processes are in place at the village societies, the unions
and even at the wholesaler and C&F agent levels as well.
Kaizens at the unions have helped improve the quality of milk in terms of
acidity and sour milk. (Undertaken by multi-disciplined teams, Kaizens are
highly focused projects, reliant on a structured approach based on data
gathering and analysis.) For example, Sabar Union's records show a reduction
from 2.0% to 0.5% in the amount of sour milk/curd received at the union.
The most impressive aspect of this large-scale roll out is that improvement
processes are turning the village societies into individual improvement
centers.
Few dairies of the world have the wide variety of products produced by the
GCMMF network. Village societies are encouraged through subsidies to install
chilling units. Automation in processing and packaging areas is common, as is
HACCP certification. Amul actively pursues developments in embryo transfer
and cattle breeding in order to improve cattle quality and increases in milk
yields.
Page
87
GCMMF was one of the first FMCG (fast-moving consumer goods) firms in
India to employ Internet technologies to implement B2C commerce.
Today customers can order a variety of products through the Internet and be
assured of timely delivery with cash payment upon receipt.
Page
88
THANK YOU
Page
89