Modals: A Few Basic Grammatical Rules Applying To Modal Verbs
Modals: A Few Basic Grammatical Rules Applying To Modal Verbs
They are verbs which 'help' other verbs to express a meaning: it is important to realise that "modal
verbs" have no meaning by themselves. A modal verb such as would has several varying functions; it
can be used, for example, to help verbs express ideas about the past, the present and the future. It is
therefore wrong to simply believe that "would is the past of will": it is many other things.
Modal verbs are NEVER used with other auxiliary verbs such as do, does, did etc. The negative is
formed simply by adding "not" after the verb; questions are formed by inversion of the verb and
subject:
Examples: You should not do that. Could you pick me up when I've finished?
Modal verbs NEVER change form: you can never add an "-s" or "-ed", for example.
Modal verbs are NEVER followed by to, with the exception of ought to.
The meaning are usually connected with ideas of DOUBT, CERTAINTY, POSSIBILITY and
PROBABILITY, OBLIGATION and PERMISSION (or lack of these). You will see that they are not
used to talk about things that definitely exist, or events that definitely happened. These meanings are
sometimes divided into two groups:
Let’s look at each modal verb separately, and the functions they help to express:
Will
1. Making personal predictions
I'm sure you will understand that there is nothing the Department can do
There's a letter for you. It'll be from the bank: they said they'd be writing.
Don't bother ringing: they'll have left for their 10 o'clock lecture.
4. Talking about the past with certainty
I'm sure you will have noticed that attendance has fallen sharply.
5. Reassuring someone
Will you open the window, please? It's very hot in here.
8. Offering to do something
I'm not surprised you don't know what to do! You will keep talking in class.
Shall
Shall is a form of will, used mostly in the first person. Its use, however, is decreasing, and in any case
in spoken English it would be contracted to "-ll" and be indistinguishable from will.
1. Making offers
2. Making suggestions
May is sometimes a little bit "more sure" (50% chance); whereas might expresses more doubt (maybe
only a 30% chance).
She may be back in her office: the lecture finished ten minutes ago.
I'm surprised he failed. I suppose he might have been ill on the day of the exam.
They can also sometimes be used for talking about permission, but usually only in formal situations.
Instead of saying May I open a window? we would say Is it all right/OK if I open a window? or Can I
open a window? for example. You might, however, see:
May
Talking about things that can happen in certain situations
If the monitors are used in poorly lit places, some users may experience headaches.
The experiment may have been a success, but there is still a lot of work to be done. (= Although it
was a success, there is still ...)
Might
Saying that something was possible, but did not actually happen
You saw me standing at the bus stop! You might have stopped and given me a lift!
Would
1. As the past of will, for example in indirect speech
"The next meeting will be in a month's time" becomes
If I ruled the world, every day would be the first day of Spring.
4. After 'wish', to show regret or irritation over someone (or something's) refusal or insistence on
doing something (present or future)
(This is a complicated area! Check in a good grammar book for full details!)
The assassination would become one of the key events of the century.
2. Making requests
3. Asking permission
Can I ask you a question? Could I ask you a personal question? (more formal, polite or indirect)
4. Reported speech
Could is used as the past of can.
5. General possibility
If you want some help with your writing, you can come to classes, or you can get some 1:1 help.
We could go to Stratford tomorrow, but the forecast's not brilliant. (less definite)
7. Future probability
Could (NOT can) is sometimes used in the same way as might or may, often indicating something less
definite.
When I leave university I might travel around a bit, I might do an MA or I suppose I could even get a
job.
8. Present possibility
9. Past possibility
If I'd known the lecture had been cancelled, I could have stayed in bed longer.
Must
Examples here refer to British English; there is some variation in American English.
Should
1. Giving advice
I think you should go for the Alfa rather than the Audi.
You shouldn't be drinking if you're on antibiotics.
You shouldn't have ordered that chocolate dessert - you're not going to finish it.
3. Deduction
Ought to
Ought to usually has the same meaning as should, particularly in affirmative statements in the present:
1. Ted's flight from Amsterdam took more than 11 hours. He ___________be exhausted after such a
long flight. He ___________ prefer to stay in tonight and get some rest.
2. If you want to get a better feeling for how the city is laid out, you ___________ walk downtown
and explore the waterfront.
3. Hiking the trail to the peak ______________ be dangerous if you are not well prepared for
dramatic weather changes. You ____________research the route a little more before you attempt the
ascent.
4. When you have a small child in the house, you _______________leave small objects lying around.
Such objects _____________ be swallowed, causing serious injury or even death.
5. Dave: _______________ you hold your breath for more than a minute?
Nathan: No, I can't.
6. Jenny's engagement ring is enormous! It ________________ have cost a fortune.
7. Please make sure to water my plants while I am gone. If they don't get enough water, they
___________ die.
8. I ______________ speak Arabic fluently when I was a child and we lived in Egypt. But after we
moved back to Canada, I had very little exposure to the language and forgot almost everything I knew
as a child. Now, I ______________ just say a few things in the language.
9. The book is optional. My professor said we ______________read it if we needed extra credit. But
we ______________read it if we don't want to.
10. Leo: Where is the spatula? It ______________ be in this drawer but it's not here.
Nancy: I just did a load of dishes last night and they're still in the dish washer. It ______________ be
in there. That's the only other place it ______________ be.
11. You ______________take your umbrella along with you today. The weatherman on the news said
there's a storm north of here and it ______________ rain later on this afternoon.
12. ______________ we pull over at the next rest stop? I really ______________ use the bathroom
and I don't know if I ______________ hold it until we get to Chicago.
13. Oh no! Frank's wallet is lying on the coffee table. He ______________ have left it here last night.
15. I ______________ believe she said that to Megan! She ______________insult her cooking in
front of everyone at the party last night. She ______________ have just said she was full or had some
salad if she didn't like the meal.
16. Do you ______________chew with your mouth open like that? Geez, it's making me sick
watching you eat that piece of pizza.
17. Mrs. Scarlett's body was found in the lounge just moments ago, and it's still warm! Nobody has
left the mansion this evening, so the killer ______________ be someone in this room. It
______________ be any one of us!!!
18. Ted: I don't know why Denise starting crying when I mentioned the wedding.
Pamela: It ______________ have been what you said about her brother. Or, perhaps she is just
nervous. After all, the big day is tomorrow.
19. ______________ you always say the first thing that pops into your head? _____________you
think once in awhile before you speak?
20. I was reading the book last night before I went to bed. I never took it out of this room. It
______________ be lying around here somewhere. Where ______________ it be? be swallowed,
causing serious injury or even death.
KEY
1. Ted's flight from Amsterdam took more than 11 hours. He __must_________be exhausted after such a long flight. He __might_________
prefer to stay in tonight and get some rest.
2. If you want to get a better feeling for how the city is laid out, you __should_________ walk downtown and explore the waterfront.
3. Hiking the trail to the peak __could___________ be dangerous if you are not well prepared for dramatic weather changes. You
_must___________research the route a little more before you attempt the ascent.
4. When you have a small child in the house, you ____mustn’t___________leave small objects lying around. Such objects
____might_________ be swallowed, causing serious injury or even death.
5. Dave: __Can_____________ you hold your breath for more than a minute?
Nathan: No, I can't.
7. Please make sure to water my plants while I am gone. If they don't get enough water, they ___________ die.
8. I ___could___________ speak Arabic fluently when I was a child and we lived in Egypt. But after we moved back to Canada, I had very
little exposure to the language and forgot almost everything I knew as a child. Now, I __can____________ just say a few things in the
language.
9. The book is optional. My professor said we ___could___________read it if we needed extra credit. But we ____don’t have
to__________read it if we don't want to.
10. Leo: Where is the spatula? It ____should__________ be in this drawer but it's not here.
Nancy: I just did a load of dishes last night and they're still in the dish washer. It ____must__________ be in there. That's the only other
place it ___could___________ be.
11. You __should____________take your umbrella along with you today. The weatherman on the news said there's a storm north of here
and it ___might___________ rain later on this afternoon.
12. __Can____________ we pull over at the next rest stop? I really ___must___________ use the bathroom and I don't know if I
_can_____________ hold it until we get to Chicago.
13. Oh no! Frank's wallet is lying on the coffee table. He ____must__________ have left it here last night.
15. I ___can’t___________ believe she said that to Megan! She __didn’t have to____________insult her cooking in front of everyone at
the party last night. She __should____________ have just said she was full or had some salad if she didn't like the meal.
16. Do you ___have to___________chew with your mouth open like that? Geez, it's making me sick watching you eat that piece of pizza.
17. Mrs. Scarlett's body was found in the lounge just moments ago, and it's still warm! Nobody has left the mansion this evening, so the
killer ____must__________ be someone in this room. It ___could___________ be any one of us!!!
18. Ted: I don't know why Denise starting crying when I mentioned the wedding.
Pamela: It ___could___________ have been what you said about her brother. Or, perhaps she is just nervous. After all, the big day is
tomorrow.
19. __Must____________ you always say the first thing that pops into your head? ___Can’t__________you think once in awhile before
you speak?
20. I was reading the book last night before I went to bed. I never took it out of this room. It __must____________ be lying around here
somewhere. Where _______can_______ it be? be swallowed, causing serious injury or even death.
2. Change the following affirmative statements into negative statements. For example:
I can answer the question.
I cannot answer the question.
He shall be sorry.
He shall not be sorry.
3. Change the following affirmative statements into negative questions. Do not use contractions
in this exercise. For example:
He must be at work now.
Must he not be at work now?
4. For each of the following sentences, change the verb in the main clause from the Simple
Present to the Simple Past; and change the modal auxiliary from the present to the past. For
example:
He says he can do it.
He said he could do it.
5. For each of the following sentences, change the verb in the main clause from the Simple Past
to the Simple Present; and change the modal auxiliary from the past to the present. For
example:
They felt they could not win.
They feel they cannot win.
7. Complete the following sentences, using the indicated verbs in the Simple conjugation with
the auxiliary could. For example:
If he wanted to, he ___________ how to sail a boat. (to learn)
If he wanted to, he could learn how to sail a boat.
8. Complete the following sentences, using the indicated verbs in the Perfect conjugation with
the auxiliary could. For example:
Had I studied harder, I ___________________ every question. (to answer)
Had I studied harder, I could have answered every question.
_____ she ________ you earlier, she would have spoken to you. (to see)
Could she have seen you earlier, she would have spoken to you.
1. If you ___________________ him trying to skate, you would have laughed. (to see)
2. If I had experienced difficulties, I __________________ him for help. (to ask)
3. It would have been better if we __________________ everything to her. (to explain)
4. Had they had permission, they ______________ the arrangements themselves. (to make)
5. We _______ easily our way if we had not brought a compass with us. (to lose)
6. ______ they _____________ what he had in mind, they would not have been so complacent. (to
know)
7. Had a flying saucer landed on the roof, he _______ not ___________ more surprised. (to be)
8. If only I __________________ them of the truth, much time and trouble would have been saved.
(to convince)
9. If you ____________________ what might happen, would you have acted differently? (to guess)
10. Had I realized he was in town, I __________________ him. (to contact)
9. Fill in the blanks, indicating whether each of the following sentences is somewhat polite (S),
quite polite (Q), or very polite (V). Notice the indirect phrasing of the most polite requests and
suggestions. For example:
Could you pass the butter? S
Would you please pass the butter? Q
Might I trouble you to pass the butter? V
10. Complete each of the following sentences with the auxiliary may, might or must. Use may or
might when the event described seems somewhat probable, and use must when the event
described seems very probable. For example:
You ___ be right; we shall have to wait and see.
You may be right; we shall have to wait and see. or You might be right; we shall have to wait and
see.
11. Rewrite the following sentences, putting the underlined verbs into the future. For example:
They can explain the situation to us.
They will be able to explain the situation to us.
12. Add negative tag questions to the following affirmative statements. For example:
They are lucky.
They are lucky, aren't they?
13. Add affirmative tag questions to the following negative statements. For example:
She isn't well.
She isn't well, is she?
14. Write affirmative short answers to the following questions. For example:
Is he thirsty?
Yes, he is.
15. Write negative short answers to the following questions. For example:
Wasn't he thirsty?
No, he wasn't.
17. Add the short form construction using the words and neither to each of the following
negative statements. Use the subjects shown in brackets. For example:
He is not angry. (we)
He is not angry, and neither are we.
Answers to Exercise 2:
1. You must not come with us. 2. It may not be sunny tomorrow. 3. She could not have won the race.
4. We might not be right. 5. You would not have liked that movie. 6. They cannot swim very well. 7.
She might not be finishing school now. 8. He should not have been walking to work. 9. I shall not be
happy to see him. 10. You will not have been working all night.
Answers to Exercise 3:
1. Should you not be wearing a warm hat? 2. Could he not have decided to stay at home? 3. Might
they not have forgotten the message? 4. Will she not see you again next week? 5. Would they not
enjoy riding on the ferry? 6. May he not decide to go camping? 7. Could they not have been playing
football yesterday? 8. Shall we not visit our friends? 9. Must she not have wanted to join us? 10.
Should he not be getting more sleep?
Answers to Exercise 4:
1. She said he might go. 2. I thought we could finish on time. 3. They knew we would help them. 4.
He said he must leave. 5. We believed she would be there. 6. Did you hope they would reply soon? 7.
Did he not realize we might meet him there? 8. You thought we could reach our destination by
nightfall. 9. I supposed he must be at home. 10. I predicted I should succeed.
Answers to Exercise 5:
1. He thinks he may arrive early. 2. She feels she must make a phone call. 3. I maintain they will not
have any difficulty. 4. They realize they cannot do all the work in one day. 5. We know we shall not be
able to return home for Christmas. 6. They hope they can find their way. 7. He imagines he will be
able to convince us. 8. She suspects they must be living nearby. 9. I hope you will enjoy the play. 10.
We think you may know him.
Answers to Exercise 6:
1. could call 2. could spend 3. could visit 4. could go 5. could find 6. could become 7. could describe
Answers to Exercise 7:
1. could help 2. could accompany 3. could depart 4. could learn 5. could show 6. could send 7. could
find
Answers to Exercise 8:
1. could have seen 2. could have asked 3. could have explained 4. could have made 5. could, have lost
6. Could, have known 7. could, have been 8. could have convinced 9. could have guessed 10. could
have contacted
Answers to Exercise 9:
1. S 2. Q 3. V 4. S 5. V 6. Q 7. V 8. Q 9. S 10. S 11. Q 12. V