Scribd Logo
Upload

Welcome to Scribd!

  • 79 views

    Alonzo v. Capulong (G.R. No. L-45551)

    Uploaded by

    midnightbottle
    Scribd Search Search for books, audiobooks, sheet music and more... Search Upload EN Change Language Home Saved Bestsellers Books Audiobooks Magazines Documents Sheet Music Once you upload an approved document, you will be able to download the document Bustamante vs Rosel Digest Don't want to upload? Get unlimited downloads as a member Sign Up Now Document details Processing... Title (Required) Alonzo v. Capulong (G.R. No. L-45551) Description (Required) Delete Done Upload Additional Documen

    Copyright:

    © All Rights Reserved
    Download as PDF, TXT or read online from Scribd

    Alonzo v. Capulong (G.R. No. L-45551)

    Uploaded by

    midnightbottle
    79 views1 page
    Scribd Search Search for books, audiobooks, sheet music and more... Search Upload EN Change Language Home Saved Bestsellers Books Audiobooks Magazines Documents Sheet Music Once you upload an approved document, you will be able to download the document Bustamante vs Rosel Digest Don't want to upload? Get unlimited downloads as a member Sign Up Now Document details Processing... Title (Required) Alonzo v. Capulong (G.R. No. L-45551) Description (Required) Delete Done Upload Additional Documen

    Copyright

    © © All Rights Reserved

    Available Formats

    PDF, TXT or read online from Scribd

    Did you find this document useful?

    Is this content inappropriate?

    Scribd Search Search for books, audiobooks, sheet music and more... Search Upload EN Change Language Home Saved Bestsellers Books Audiobooks Magazines Documents Sheet Music Once you upload an approved document, you will be able to download the document Bustamante vs Rosel Digest Don't want to upload? Get unlimited downloads as a member Sign Up Now Document details Processing... Title (Required) Alonzo v. Capulong (G.R. No. L-45551) Description (Required) Delete Done Upload Additional Documen

    Copyright:

    © All Rights Reserved
    Download as PDF, TXT or read online from Scribd
    Download as pdf or txt
    79 views1 page

    Alonzo v. Capulong (G.R. No. L-45551)

    Uploaded by

    midnightbottle
    Scribd Search Search for books, audiobooks, sheet music and more... Search Upload EN Change Language Home Saved Bestsellers Books Audiobooks Magazines Documents Sheet Music Once you upload an approved document, you will be able to download the document Bustamante vs Rosel Digest Don't want to upload? Get unlimited downloads as a member Sign Up Now Document details Processing... Title (Required) Alonzo v. Capulong (G.R. No. L-45551) Description (Required) Delete Done Upload Additional Documen

    Copyright:

    © All Rights Reserved
    Download as PDF, TXT or read online from Scribd
    Download as pdf or txt
    of 1

    CONSTITUTIONAL*LAW*II*DIGESTS*(2012*–*2013)* * * *********ATTY.

    *SEDFREY*CANDELARIA*
    *
    G.R.$No.$L(45551$ !
    ! $
    Alonzo$v.$Capulong$ RESOLUTIONS:$
    ! YES,!the!petition!has!merit.!!
    Zorayda! Alonzo! (CEO! of! Home! Development! Mutual! Fund)! v.! Judge! WHEREFORE,! the! petition! for! certiorari! is! GRANTED;! the! writ! of!
    Ignacio!Capulong!&!Juliet!Fajardo! preliminary!injunction!dated!April!1,!1993!is!ANNULLED!and!
    ! SET!ASIDE;!xxx!
    Ponente:!Mendoza,!J.! !
    ! As! Chief! Executive! Officer! of! the! Home! Development! Mutual! Fund,!
    BACKGROUND:$ petitioner!Alonzo!is!the!proper!disciplining!authority!within!the!meaning!
    A!petition!for!certiorari!to!set!aside!the!order!dated!March!31,!1993!of! of!§51,!Chapter!7,!Title!1,!Book!V!of!the!Administrative!Code!of!1987.!
    respondent! judge! Ignacio! Capulong,! who! issued! a! TRO! on! the! !
    suspension! of! private! respondent! Juliet! Fajardo! as! manager! of! the! §51.! Preventive! Suspension.! —! The! proper! disciplining! authority! may!
    Administrative!Services!Department!of!the!Home!Development!Mutual! preventively! suspend! any! subordinate! officer! or! employee! under! his!
    Fund.! December! 17,! 1992! Celeste! G.! AlTJawazneh,! who! had! been! authority!pending!an!investigation,!if!the!charge!against!such!officer!or!
    supplying! office! uniforms! and! providing! transportation! service! to! PagT employee! involves! dishonesty,! oppression! or! grave! misconduct,! or!
    ibig! Fund! employees,! wrote! a! letter! to! the! Chief! Executive! Officer,! neglect! in! the! performance! of! duty,! or! if! there! are! reasons! to! believe!
    herein!petitioner!Zorayda!Alonzo,!complaining!against!Ms.!Fajardo.!! that! the! respondent! is! guilty! of! charges! which! would! warrant! his!
    ! removal!from!the!service.!
    The! letter! reads:! “xxx! the! mere! presence! of! Ms.! Fajardo! and! Mr.! Dy,! !
    whom!we!know!have!already!made!some!derogatory!remarks!about!us! Alonzo! is! in! a! position! to! influence! employees! under! her! or! otherwise!
    to!the!DBM!personnel,!constitutes!a!great!bias!against!our!bid.!May!we! impede!the!investigation.!Respondent!court's!order!that!there!must!be!
    therefore!request!that!a!replacement!be!made!in!the!interest!of!fairness! a!hearing!before!preventive!suspension!may!be!imposed!is!thus!a!virtual!
    which!we!are!all!willing!to!abide!with.”! disregard! of! the! settled! rule! that! the! preventive! suspension! of! a! civil!
    ! service! employee! or! officer! can! be! ordered! even! without! a! hearing!
    Alonzo! contends! that! the! investigation! being! conducted! by! her! office! because!such!suspension!is!not!a!penalty!but!only!a!preliminary!step!in!
    was!purely!an!administrative!one!and!that!private!respondent!failed!to! an! administrative! investigation! and! for! this! reason! constitutes! a! grave!
    exhaust! administrative! remedies! by! appealing! to! the! Civil! Service! abuse!of!its!discretion.!
    Commission.! !
    ! Purpose! of! Preventive! Suspension:! To! prevent! the! accused! from! using!
    ISSUES$TO$BE$RESOLVED:$ his!position!or!office!to!influence!prospective!witnesses!or!tamper!with!
    1. Whether!or!not!Judge!Capulong!committed!a!grave!abuse!of!his! the! records! which! may! be! vital! in! the! prosecution! of! the! case! against!
    discretion! in! taking! cognizance! of! the! case! and! stopping! the! him.!
    preventive!suspension!of!private!respondent!whom!he!ordered!
    to!be!allowed!to!continue!in!office!

    *
    Chan=Gonzaga*Evardone*Gutierrez*Lopez*Miclat*Nadal*Radoc*Superio*Tan*Tong*Valdez*Varela*

    You might also like