Run-On Sentences and Sentence Fragments - Is The Instruction Treat
Run-On Sentences and Sentence Fragments - Is The Instruction Treat
Run-On Sentences and Sentence Fragments - Is The Instruction Treat
1984
Recommended Citation
Nielsen, Lori J., "Run-on sentences and sentence fragments: is the instruction treating the problem?" (1984). Retrospective Theses and
Dissertations. 193.
https://lib.dr.iastate.edu/rtd/193
This Thesis is brought to you for free and open access by the Iowa State University Capstones, Theses and Dissertations at Iowa State University Digital
Repository. It has been accepted for inclusion in Retrospective Theses and Dissertations by an authorized administrator of Iowa State University Digital
Repository. For more information, please contact [email protected].
Run-on sentences and sentence fragments:
Is the instruction treating the problem?
by
Major: English
Approved:
Members of the Committee:
TABLE OF CONTENTS
Page
INTRODUCTION 1
LIST OF TABLES
Page
TABLE 1: Grammatical descriptions and examples of
run-on sentences from the research and from
the student sample JO
TABLE 2: Grammatical descriptions and examples of
sentence fragments from the research and
from the student sample 35
1
INTRODUCTION
Run-on Sentences
In general, the research defines a run-on sentence as one
of two types: (1) a run-together sentence, or two independent
clauses joined without punctuation, and (2) a comma splice,
or two independent clauses linked by only a comma. Comma
splices receive most of the attention in the research, al-
though both types of run-ons indicate that students do not
recognize grammatically independent clauses and do not use
punctuation marks correctly. According to Shaughnessy, lack-
ing those abilities and thinking in rhetorical units larger
than sentences, students hesitate to use a period when their
thoughts go on; they use a comma instead.16 Their commas con-
nect sentences that make rhetorical sense together: "'In her
late teens my mother looked for enjoyment, I'm the end re-
sult.'"l7 Do run-ons indicate a stage in some students' de-
velopment of the ability to coordinate independent clauses
correctly?
According to a study completed by Philip DiStefano and
Robert Marzano, run-on sentences may occur when students first
attempt more complicated structures and so may be indicators
of growing syntactic maturity. DiStefano and Marzano analyzed
compositions of varying quality written by students grouped by
ages nine, thirteen, and seventeen. They sought to identify
8
Summary
Comma splices receive the most attention in the research,
although both types of run-on sentences are errors because a
reader expects to stop at the end of a sentence. The lack of
punctuation between two independent clauses or the use of a
comma between them causes confusion. The research explains
that run-ons are caused by a failure to recognize two inde-
pendent clauses and by misunderstanding the rules of punc-
tuation. Because coordination is an early-developing skill,
most college students should link two rhetorically related
independent clauses intuitively. Since only one study
specifies the grammatical construction of the two clauses run
together, few conclusions can be made regarding the gram•
matical composition of run-on sentences. When errors occur
at the college level, instruction in punctuation may ade-
quately alleviate the problem of run-ons. Lessons that review
the structure of independent clauses and the principles of
coordination and teach the uses of punctuation marks should
reduce the number of run-ons in college students' compositions.
Although the research claims that under some conditions comma
splices are acceptable, college instructors usually do not
accept them in expository writing.
14
Sentence Fragments
Sentence fragments are another common type of sentence
structure error college students make in their compositions.
Fragments, like run-ons, generally occur because students use
the wrong punctuation mark; using a period instead of a comma,
students inadvertently cut off part of a sentence and create
a fragment. In other words, a fragment occurs when students
"break a single grammatical sentence into two punctuated sen-
tences incorrectly," as in "'My mother had four children. On-
ly because she had no choice.'"J6 Shaughnessy explains that
students punctuate by rhetorical, not grammatical, units, as
in the preceding example; that is, students' sense of com-
pleteness is not a grammatical sense, so they mark off as sen-
tences units that may present a complete idea but are depen-
dent grammatical structures.37 Frequently, fragments are
grammatically dependent sentence final structures that have a
sense of rhetorical independence, as in "'We would live off
the earth, and nature. Living together to survive .... JS Here
the student uses a period instead of the comma necessary to
attach the sentence final participial phrase to the base
clause.
Students punctuate a number of dependent grammatical
structures as sentences. According to Shaughnessy, sentence
initial adverbial clauses may become fragments because
15
Summary
A sentence fragment is an error that occurs when students
punctuate as sentences rhetorical units that are actually de-
pendent grammatical structures. The research cites a number
of those dependent structures as common sentence fragments,
and most often they are final free modifiers. At the college
level, fragments are frequently subordinate clauses. As in-
dicators of syntactic maturity, fragments occur as students
learn to subordinate increasingly more complicated grammatical
structures. Then from grade to grade, as the research sug-
gests, students fragment different structures as they struggle
to subordinate each successfully. To facilitate the process,
instructors should present the principles of subordination
and teach the difference between independent and dependent
sentence structures. Although the research amply covers the
rhetorically acceptable uses of sentence fragments, these sit-
uations would normally not occur in the types of expository
writing students do in college. Besides, before students
22
Run-on Sentences
According to the research, run-on sentences are of two
types: a comma splice or a fused sentence. In both cases,
students connect two sentences that they perceive as one rhe-
torical unit, which indicates that they remember the principle
of coordination but use inadequate punctuation. They fail to
recognize two independent clauses punctuated as one sentence,
and they do not use the correct punctuation mark or a con-
junction at the juncture.
From the research, only Kagan's study specifies gram-
matical contexts for run-on sentences, but do those contexts
represent run-on sentences actually written by students? To
28
the students in the sample wrote, only one of the long sen-
tences contains a participial phrase, one has a compound verb
(another one is also a compound sentence),· and four have de-
pendent clauses. In fourteen of the run-ons, both sentences
are simple sentences. The results of Kagan's study do not
seem to reflect accurately the types of run-on sentences stu-
dents write. While the twenty-one student-written run-ons are
not an adequate sample from which to draw definitive conclu-
sions, they nonetheless raise questions and show the need for
more extensive research.
The Harper Handbook of College Composition offers a dif-
ferent list of four grammatical contexts for comma splices
which prove more accurate than Kagan's findings. The contexts
are as follows: (1) the two joined sentences are related by
content but not by syntax; (2) the second sentence begins with
a personal pronoun whose antecedent is in the first sentence;
(J) the second sentence begins with a demonstrative pronoun or
Kagan
1. short sentence + long "The phone rang he did not
sentence with subordinate hear it because he was in the
clause shower" (p. 134)
2. short sentence + long "It snowed heavily people
sentence with compound watched and waited in their
verb cabins" ( p. 134)
3· long sentence with "Grinning from ear to ear he
participial phrase + entered the house the~ were
short sentence all waiting" (p. 134)
The Harper Handbook of
College Composition, 5th edition
1. two sentences related by "A meeting of the club is
content, not by syntax scheduled for tonight, many
important items are on the
agenda." (p . .328)
2. second sentence begins "The ambulance driver exam-
with a personal pronoun ined the victim carefully,
with its antecedent in he did not say a word."
the first sentence (p. 328)
3· second sentence begins "Drive carefully when you
with a demonstrative pro- approach the bridge, this is
noun or adjective very narrow." (p . .328)
4. second sentence begins "I was late for the lecture,
with or contains a con- however, Ms. James did not
junctive adverb scold me." (p . .329)
.31
Table 1. (continued)
grammatical description example
Student sample
1. long sentence + short "Once in awhile I will bring
sentence or sentences back the wonderful memories and
of similar length shed a tear over his loss, it
was a, great one to me."
second sentence is a (see example one)
simple sentence
.3· subject of second sentence (see example one)
is first word
4. subject of second sentence (see example one)
is personal pronoun that
links it rhetorically with
first sentence
Sentence Fragments
With sentence fragments, the students' sense of juncture
also seems to be accurate, but often punctuation incorrectly
separates sentence final dependent clauses from their indepen-
dent base clauses. The research defines a sentence fragment
as a single grammatical sentence incorrectly broken into two
sentences by a period. The period separates two rhetorical
units: one is an independent clause, the other a dependent
grammatical structure that students incorrectly sense is com-
plete by itself. Although students use a period instead of a
comma, the complete sentence shows growing syntactic maturity
because students are trying to add clauses and phrases per
T-unit. They create dependent structures but do not yet at-
tach them to main clauses. Students' intuition for joining
(commas) instead of terminating (periods or semicolons) is
not quite formed. With fragments, students are applying the
principles of subordination and have an accurate sense of
juncture. Their failure is in comprehending independent and
dependent structures and in using appropriate punctuation.
Several dependent grammatical structures are commonly
cited as being fragments in students' compositions. Shaugh-
nessy names two structures: initial adverbial clauses and the
second part of compound structures. Kagan, from her test,
cites three structures that students selected as sentences:
J4
.Table 2. (continued)
Kagan (continued)
3· two prepositional "In the corner under the table"
phrases (p. 131)
Harris
1. sentence final sub- "'Playboy has a reputation for
ordinate clause getting a sophisticated and elite
group of readers. Although this is
a value judgment and in some cir-
cumstances, not a true premise.'"
(p. 180)
2. final free modifier, "'I believe that the author is try-
noun phrase ing to convey the meaning of life
to the reader. A sense of purpose
and fulfillment to life.'" (p. 180)
3· final free modifier, "'The story appealed to your sense
nominative absolute of nostalgia and proved a point.
The point being that at maturity we
have to fit into a style and be-
come responsible.'" (p. 180)
4. final free modifier, "'She opened the door and let us
verb phrase into her home. Not realizing at
the time that we would never enter
that door in her home again.'"
(p. 180)
Student Sample
1. final free modifier "In an attempt to break my nervous-
verb phrase ness, I decided to leave early for
(misuse of semicolon) school; hoping the fresh air and
sunshine would help."
2. sentence initial "After straightening myself in the
adjective clause with mens room, where I received a
two participial strange look from a guy seeing me
phrases change. I go to class and am about
five minutes late."
J7
Table 2. (continued)
grammatical description example
Run-on Sentences
The texts, like the research, generally categorize run-on
sentences as one of two types: comma splices or fused sen-
tences. A comma splice, sometimes referred to as a comma
fault, occurs when two independent clauses are joined by only
a comma. A fused sentence consists of two independent clauses
run together without a conjunction or punctuation. The defi-
nitions of each type of run-on sentence are fairly consistent
in the handbooks, and, with one exception, the texts cover
run-ons in sections within chapters that deal with errors that
occur in compositions.
Only The Random House Handbook deals with run-ons solely
in the glossary. While the other handbooks with glossaries
define them there, too, they deal with them in more detail
in other sections. After defining comma splices and fused
sentences, the texts usually list rules by which run-ons may
45
shows how this method·works: the comma splice, "We will add
another room to the house this summer, painting will have to
wait until next year." is then revised as "We will •• · this
summer, but painting . year." 88 No more explanation is
given, although some texts refer students to other sections
for more complete explanations, such as the section on con-
junctions. The other three commonly listed methods for cor-
recting comma splices are joining the independent clauses with
a semicolon, separating them into two sentences with a period,
or subordinating one of the clauses. One of The Heath Hand-
book's additional methods is to use a semicolon or a period
plus a conjunctive adverb between the two sentences. The
o.ther method explains that commas adequately join sentences
when .they are "short, closely related independent clauses in
a series," such as "The wind blew, the shutters banged, the
children trembled ... 89
While this last method admits instances when comma
splices are acceptable, most of the handbooks do not include
it. Only three others ref~r to a similar rhetorical use of
comma splices, so generally the handbooks regard run-on sen-
tences as errors to be corrected by one of four or five valid
means. The explanations of those corrective measures, however,
are often unsatisfactory. Other than stating the method and
giving an example, explanation is often not provided, as has
47
Sentence Fragments
Similar shortcomings characterize the handbooks' treat-
ment of sentence fragments. In explaining them, the texts
use even more technical grammatical terminology. Following
the same pattern of presentation used with run-ons, the texts
define fragments, explain and give examples for correcting
them, and prescribe exercises on identifying and correcting
fragments. However, in the case of sentence fragments, the
handbooks more often name the numerous grammatical struc-
tures that become fragments and spend more time discussing
permissible uses of fragments. Overall, the handbooks'
coverage of sentence fragments is lengthier and uses more
grammatical terms in explanations but indicates more directly
how students might proofread for fragments in their compo-
sitions.
50
53
61
NOTES
29 Irmscher, p. 123·
3° Irmscher, p. 123.
31 Mohan R. Limaye, "Approaching Punctuation as a System,"
ABCA Bulletin, 46 (March 1983), 31.
Joseph M. Williams, Style: Ten Lessons in Clarity and
Grace (Glenview, Ill.: Scott, Foresman and Company, 1981),
p. 187.
32 H. Sopher, "The Problem of Punctuation," English Lan-
guage Teaching Journal, 31 (July 1977), 308.
33 Limaye, p. 31.
34 Irene Brosnahan, "A Few Good Words for the Comma
Splice," College English, 38 (October 1976), 186-187.
Sopher, p. 308.
35 Brosnah~, p. 188.
36 WJ.lliams,
. Style,. p. 64 .
Shaughnessy, P· 25·
37 Shaughnessy, P• 18.
38 Shaughnessy,
P• 24.
39 Shaughnessy, P· 25·
40 Shaughnessy, P• 25·
41 Sarah D'Eloia, "The Uses--and Limits--of Grammar," in
43 D'Eloia, p. 229·
44 Kagan, p. 12 8 .
45 Kagan, p. 131.
46 Kagan, pp. 131-132·
47 Kagan, p. 137·
4S Muriel Harris, "Mending the Fragmented Free Modifier,"
College Composition and Communication, 32 (May 1981), 177·
49 Harris, p. 180.
50 Harris, p. 178.
5l Harris, pp. 177-178.
52 Constance Weaver, "Welcoming Errors as Signs of
Growth," Language Arts, 59 (May 1982), 443.
53 Weaver, pp. 440-442.
54 Martin Gliserman, "An Act of Theft: Teaching Grammar,"
College English, 39 (March 1978), 794.
55 Shaughnessy, p. 68.
56 Harris, pp. 175-176.
Charles R. Kline and w. Dean Memering, "Formal Frag-
ment: The English Minor Sentence," Research in the Teaching of
English, 11 (Fall 1977), 108-109.
57 Harris, p. 176.
Kline and Memering, p. 108.
58 Harris, p. 176.
59 Harris, p. 176.
60 Kline and Memering, pp. 108-109.
69
71
BIBLIOGRAPHY
Brosnahan, Irene. "A Few Good Words for the Comma Splice."
College English, 38 (October 1976), 184-188.
Christensen, Francis, and Bonniejean Christensen. Notes to-
ward ~New Rhetoric: Nine Essays for Teachers. New York:
Harper & Row, 1978.
Corbett, Edward P. J. The Little English Handbook: Choices
and Conventions. 4th ed. Glenview, Ill.: Scott, Fores-
man and Company, 1984.
Corder, Jim w. Handbook of Current English. 6th ed. Glen-
view, Ill.: Scott, Foresman and Company, 1981.
Crews, Frederick. The Random House Handbook. Jrd ed. New
York: Random House, Inc., 1980.
D'Eloia, Sarah. "The Uses--and Limits--of Grammar." In The
Writing Teacher's Sourcebook. Ed. Gary Tate, and Edward
P. J. Corbett. New York: Oxford University Press, Inc.,
1981, PP• 225-24).
DiStefano, Philip, and Robert J. Marzano. "Basic Skills in
Composition: A New Approach." English Education, 9
(Winter 1978), 117-121.
Elsbree, Langdon, Nell G. Altizer, and Paul v. Kelly. Th~
19. God, was I ever happy, my dream had finally come true.
comma splice 1st sentence: simpl~
2nd sentence: simple
20. I wish he were here now, I loved him then and now.
comma splice 1st sentence: complex, noun clause
2nd sentence: simple, subject is personal pronoun, head
of clause, antecedent in first clause (same pronoun)
21. I thought we had it made she just stood there shaking.
run together 1st sentence: complex, noun clause
2nd sentence: simple, subject is personal pronoun, head
of clause
80