Scribd Logo
Upload

Welcome to Scribd!

  • 68 views

    Indecision

    Uploaded by

    Iremsu Sanliturk
    The document analyzes Dante's portrayal of the undecided in Canto III of Inferno. Dante condemns those who fail to take a stand and choose sides. However, the text notes that indecision is a natural human state brought on by fear and a desire for fairness. While Dante tortures the undecided in Hell, the document suggests their indecision allows for temporary discord that prevents humanity from settling on imperfect choices and helps ensure a just end is eventually reached. It argues readers should take on Virgil's role of reassuring themselves to avoid endless oscillation between options like the condemned souls.

    Copyright:

    © All Rights Reserved
    Download as RTF, PDF, TXT or read online from Scribd

    Indecision

    Uploaded by

    Iremsu Sanliturk
    68 views3 pages
    The document analyzes Dante's portrayal of the undecided in Canto III of Inferno. Dante condemns those who fail to take a stand and choose sides. However, the text notes that indecision is a natural human state brought on by fear and a desire for fairness. While Dante tortures the undecided in Hell, the document suggests their indecision allows for temporary discord that prevents humanity from settling on imperfect choices and helps ensure a just end is eventually reached. It argues readers should take on Virgil's role of reassuring themselves to avoid endless oscillation between options like the condemned souls.

    Original Description:

    Indecision

    Copyright

    © © All Rights Reserved

    Available Formats

    RTF, PDF, TXT or read online from Scribd

    Did you find this document useful?

    Is this content inappropriate?

    The document analyzes Dante's portrayal of the undecided in Canto III of Inferno. Dante condemns those who fail to take a stand and choose sides. However, the text notes that indecision is a natural human state brought on by fear and a desire for fairness. While Dante tortures the undecided in Hell, the document suggests their indecision allows for temporary discord that prevents humanity from settling on imperfect choices and helps ensure a just end is eventually reached. It argues readers should take on Virgil's role of reassuring themselves to avoid endless oscillation between options like the condemned souls.

    Copyright:

    © All Rights Reserved
    Download as RTF, PDF, TXT or read online from Scribd
    Download as rtf, pdf, or txt
    68 views3 pages

    Indecision

    Uploaded by

    Iremsu Sanliturk
    The document analyzes Dante's portrayal of the undecided in Canto III of Inferno. Dante condemns those who fail to take a stand and choose sides. However, the text notes that indecision is a natural human state brought on by fear and a desire for fairness. While Dante tortures the undecided in Hell, the document suggests their indecision allows for temporary discord that prevents humanity from settling on imperfect choices and helps ensure a just end is eventually reached. It argues readers should take on Virgil's role of reassuring themselves to avoid endless oscillation between options like the condemned souls.

    Copyright:

    © All Rights Reserved
    Download as RTF, PDF, TXT or read online from Scribd
    Download as rtf, pdf, or txt
    of 3

    Iremsu Sanliturk

    EL201

    The Sin of Indecision

    Dante, in Canto III of Inferno, does not accept the idea of being in between: he

    needs defined polars and screams loud enough. He also does not let go of a human being

    easily who simply lives a life for living a life, without having chosen to stand here or

    there or acknowledging bravely what they are, what they have chosen. Such passivity is

    given a sickly punishment, it is condemned both by Virgil's words and the descriptions of

    the tortures deserved; yet deep into his lines there are some signs that it is only natural

    that humans hesitate and oscillate.

    In itself, the state of not choosing does not include any fully developed hatred or

    attraction against anything; yet in Dante's imagination, it is such a deplorable state that

    even Hell does not want to be associated with such persons, who lack not only "beauty",

    but also "glory" according to Virgil's words (3.40-42). These souls, the Pilgrim

    understands later, are the ones "hateful to God and to his enemies", which means that

    they are standing at exactly equal distances to both sides. This, apart from being a state

    that is undecided and confusing, requires feeling not only for one's own self but for others

    too; in such a position, indecision comes naturally, and then of course Dante's torturous

    punishments, unnaturally.

    Yet despite all the heartlessness towards that unbalanced folk, the Pilgrim's
    "cowardly" reaction to the inscription above the gate is welcomed with lines "Now here

    you must leave all distrust behind / let all your cowardice die on this spot", which openly

    shows the presence of fear in the Pilgrim's human nature even though in a way that it is

    condemned (3.14-15). The acknowledgment of such a fear reveals the vulnerability of the

    Pilgrim's humanity, by which the reader can understand the naturality of the undecided

    sinners' fear and even start to disagree with the ways of Hell that are shown. Right at that

    place, however, Virgil provides "reassurance" for the Pilgrim, so that he does not fear the

    mysteries any more (3.20). Then it is either that without Virgil, Dante the Pilgrim is also

    to be doomed to being in torturous betweens forever, or it is nothing but cruelty for

    cruelty's sake for those undecided sinners as they had to walk the world alone and

    unguided.

    Yet even Hell "fear the damned might glory over them", it is suggested that even

    Hell itself is capable of fear (3-42). Then it is only natural that the sinners did not choose

    to be this or that, oppressed by a feeling that the chosen might not be the most right. Hell

    "fears" that one group might glory over another in itself and cause trouble; the sinners

    fear that one thing that they incline to might glory over another in an unfair way and

    cause trouble. Still, while the Pilgrim's fragile human nature and Hell's cute fears are

    accepted as perfectly normal, the politically or religiously unsettled is still not even

    worthy of "truly dying" (3.46).

    In a more inspirational note, however, maybe what Dante the poet had in mind was

    that just as Virgil guides the Pilgrim, reassures his heart and accepts his humane fears'

    existence, the reader should also assume that role for himself so that he is not left in a

    state as wretched as those sinners not even able to reach a true ending. The reader
    himself, as a reader of Dante, should become his own reassurance so that there is no

    oscillation or fears any more. Moreover, as it is accepted in the mentioned lines above,

    the unsettled state is a natural state of resistance and a battle for fairness, and even though

    it leads to disharmony on the way, it consequently saves humanity from settling to what

    few, unsatisfying choices there are, which do not happen to be perfectly salvational most

    of the time. Then, if Dante aims at final harmony, the temporary disharmony that the

    undecided has given to the world is to be allowed, and then, with the right guide, the

    battle is to come to a just and fair end.

    You might also like