Pakistan Studies - History - Section 2 Notes - Muhammad Ali Wasim
Pakistan Studies - History - Section 2 Notes - Muhammad Ali Wasim
Pakistan Studies - History - Section 2 Notes - Muhammad Ali Wasim
Section II Notes
Compiled by Muhammad Ali wasim
Partition reasons
Bengal was a very large province geographically and with population of (54 million) :
(42 million Hindus) and (12 million Muslims) in East Bengal 31 million in West
Bengal).
Terms
East Bengal & Assam: Dhaka as its capital.
The eastern province would include Assam and three districts previously considered to
be a part of West Bengal, Dhaka, Chittagong and Mymensingh. It had a population of
31million people out of which 18 million were Muslims.
West Bengal: Calcutta its capital. It had a population of 54million out of which
45million were Hindus.
Reactions
The Muslims greatly welcomed the partition and felt jubilant over it because in the
newly created East province, they were in majority.
The Hindus on the other hand reacted violently to the partition because they had been
holding a privilege position in the socio - economic life of Bengal till the partition took
place. They now believed that they lose their status & declared that the partition was an
attempt to weaken & divide Bengal and called it "Divide and rule" policy of British. The
Hindus greatly opposed this partition & started a movement generally known as
"Swadeshi Movement " in which they boycotted all English goods . Many Hindus
observed he partition day as the day of National mourning. Even the Indian national
congress supported the Hindus.
But soon they realized that attempts to crush Hindus are not sufficient thus reforms
showed up (Morley - Minto Reforms)
They launched a movement for boycott the British goods. The Muslims were also asked
to participate in it but they refused to do so. Their refusal caused more agitation among
the Hindus & led to Hindu - Muslim riots.
Lord Harding the new Viceroy agreed to reverse the partition of Bengal. King George
V, who was visiting India, announced the decision at a Durbar in Delhi.
Muslims lost faith in British to allow them any real power. Muslims also realized that
Minto - Morley reforms did not provide Indians any genuine voice, which resulted as
Poor relations between British and Muslims.
ii. In the council Muslims should have higher percentage of seats than their
percentage in population
Lord - Minto agreed on separate representation for Muslims
Behaviour of different Hindu Organization: Hindu extremist group " ARYA SAMAJ"
demanded that Muslims should be forcibly converted into Hinduism.
Hindu Muslim riots: The frequent and never ending riots between Hindus and Muslims
further strengthened the formation of separate political party for the Muslims. These
riots generated the spirit on Muslims Nationalism among the Indian Muslims.
Reaction of the Hindus to the Partition of Bengal : The negative reaction of the Hindus
when the government declared the partition of Bengal in 1905 further convinced the
Muslims to establish their own separate political organizations.
Simla Deputation (1906): Minto accepted most of the demands & it was a great success
for the Muslims. After the acceptance of demands from Lord Minto, now Muslims of
India realized that it's high time to organize a political party, which can protect the rights
of Muslims in India.
i. appeared to give Indians more say, but they had no power, just an advisory role was
given.
ii. British don’t want to give locals power to change law.
iii. Importance: acceptance of separate electorates, it was major demands of Muslims
iv. Hindus believed that it was undemocratic
War broke out in Europe in August 1914…resulting in mix views in India. British
needed Indians help. Muslims don’t wanted to fight against Turkey as it was against
their fate as Khalifa was head of Muslims, but British promised to not harm Muslims
Khalifa or Holy Places.
Both League and Congress agreed, which brought them further close together.
Joint Demands
1916 annual session at city Lucknow. Jinnah represented Muslim League and Mahajan
represented Congress. The Lucknow Pact was drown up. It showed that Congress is
Muhammad Ali Wasim
ready to make concessions:
Importance
i. It marked the first acceptance by the Hindus that a degree of partition would be
necessary
ii. The first Agreement between Congress and Muslim League
iii. Sowed that Muslims; have acknowledged they stood more chance if worked with
Congress
iv. Marked a high - water mark on Hindu - Muslim unity.
v. Possibility of self - government was now seen.
2. Legislative Assembly would have 145 members from which 103 would be elected for
3 years.
3. Legislative Assembly would hold separate electorate for Muslims, Hindus and Sikhs.
Diarchy System
This system was introduced in Provinces
Reversed Subjects (British)
Police
Revenue
Power Resources
Press/ Publications
Justice
Transferred Subjects (Indians)
Education
Public Health
Public Works
Forests
Amritsar Massacre
On 10 April two banks were attacked in Amritsar and 5 Europeans were killed there.
General Dyer banned all public meetings to restore law and order situation of Amritsar.
A peaceful meeting was going on in which 20,000 people were there in Jallianwala
Bagh, which had narrow entrances and was surrounded by 5 feet wall, But the troops
Muhammad Ali Wasim
started firing on order on General Dyer in which 400 people were killed and 1200 were
injured.
General dyer was not given any kind of punishment but was removed from active
service.
2) Muslims should be given one - third of the seats in the central legislature through
joint electorates
Khilafat Movement
General Secretary. Congress also supported this movement under Abdul Kalam Azad.
This movement was launched to pressurize the British into keeping their promises.
Hijrat Movement
In 1920 Abdul Kalam Azad gave a call for Hijrat Movement and urged the Muslims to
migrate to a place where they can freely practice their religion, they called India as ‘ Dar
- ul - Harb’. Nearly 18000 Muslims after selling their land and properties, migrated to
Afghanistan. Many of them had to return due to no entry at border and were
disappointed them. This caused a large impact on Khilafat Movement.
Treatment of Turkey
1920, The Treaty of Sevres: British announced. The treaty indicated that Ottoman
Empire was to be split up. Arabia will be independent and Turkey’s land was to be given
to Greece.
The Turkish rebelled against this treaty of Sevres, so The Treaty of Lausanne replaced it
in 1923. Some if the land was gained, but Turkey never regained the control of Muslim
territories in Middle East.
Chaura - Chauri incident in Feb 1922, Gandhi called of his support and
withdrawal Khilafat Movement.
Muslims leaders of the movement were arrested in 1922 with the arrest of leaders
the movement lost its momentum.
It was first movement in which Hindus and Muslims worked together, their unity
was probably always resulted in failure.
Hijrat Movement at critical stage was another blow for Muslims.
Mustafa Kamal Ata Turk Pasha who exiled Khalifa, Muhammad Vl and abolished
Khilafat and established nationalist government of Turkey
Consequences
This was the movement for which Hindu - Muslims both worked together, it healed their
relations
Simon Commission
In 1927 British Government announced to send a seven - member commission under the
chairmanship of Sir John Simon to prepare the report for the new reforms. The
commission had no Indian member, so Congress and a section of Muslim league
announced to boycott the commission.
Simon Report
i. Abolition of Diarchy
ii. Federal form of government with maximum powers for the provinces.
iii. Separate electorates for Muslims.
iv. Weightage for the Muslims in minority provinces.
v. Muslims demanded for the separation on Sindh from Bombay and introduction of
reforms in NWFP which was not rejected but postponed.
vi. Muslims should not be given one third of the seats in Central Legislature.
It was a 2 volume report presented in April,1930 but rejected and for decision of future
constitution of India Round Table Conferences were scheduled.
Nehru Report
The Congress and Muslim League had already rejected the recommendations of the
Simon commission
Muslims dislike the findings of the Nehru report as most of the Muslims demands were
rejected. Quaid - e - Azam proposed three amendments in the Nehru report which were
as follow:
Hindu majority rejected all these amendments. It was last attempt M.A Jinnah to
reconcile. The Nehru report marked the end of any future cooperation between the
Congress and the Muslim league
In 1929 Quaid - e - Azam decided to give its own formula for the constitutional reforms
in reply of Nehru report which was asking to make so many unbearable sacrifices.
14 points
1) The future constitution should be federal
8) No bill shall be passed in any passed in any elected body if 3/4 of any community in
that body opposed it.
9) Sindh should be separated from Bombay.
Muhammad Ali Johar, Maulvi Fazal - ul - Haq and Muhammad Ali Jinnah. Important
issues decided at the conference were:
i. The Princely States agreed to extend their cooperation in forming an All India
Federation.
ii. The British agreed that representative government should be introduced at provincial
level.
iii. Separation of Sindh from Bombay.
iv. To introduce Federal System of government in India.
v. No agreement was reached as to the question of Muslims weightage in future
constitution.
Since congress was India’s largest party and absent from 1st Round Table Conference
So any of decision was not finalized.
4) The government would withdraw all notification/ enactments relating to offences not
involving violence.
5) The government should re lease all persons detained during Civil disobedience
movement.
Evaluation:
This Act of 1935 failed to win appreciation from various sectors.
The political leaders of India rejected it for it failed to meet the demands of the
different political faction.
The federal system was defective in many ways.
Formation of ministries
Congress took offices in 8 provinces. The congress was also reluctant in sharing the
power with the Muslims League and laid down degrading conditions for the Muslim
League to be included in the ministry. The Muslim League rejected these terms and pure
Congress ministries were formed.
Bande Matram It was a song in which degrading remarks were used against the
Muslims and it says to expel Muslims from subcontinent. It was compulsory for
everyone to daily recite before commencing of day.
Vidiya Mander scheme This educational policy aimed at converting the non-
Muslims to Hindus. It was made compulsory to bow in front of Gandhi picture. This
scheme was introduced by Dr. Zakir Hussain
Quaid - e - Azam During this movement, termed it as a Black mail, saying that congress
was trying to exploit Britain’s problems to win advantage for itself.
1) Gandhi wanted British to move from India without partitioning whereas Jinnah
wanted a separate partitioned country.
2) Gandhi wanted to have more power with central government whereas Jinnah wanted
local autonomy.
3) Gandhi claimed himself as representative of India where Jinnah used to call him
spokesman of INC.
Wavell Proposals
There was a deadlock over the Muslim league’s demand that all the five members of the
Executive Council should be the nominees of the Muslim league . The Viceroy accepted
four and Chief Minister of Punjab and Unionist party leader Khizar Hayat Tiwana
demanded one Muslim seat out of Muslim quota, which was accepted by the Viceroy.
Jinnah al so pointed out as the Sikhs and Scheduled Castes on the Counci l were bound
to vote with the Hindus, this would mean permanent Muslims minority in the Executive
Council. Jinnah also objected Lord Wavell could see no solution to the problem and
closed the conference on 14th July 1945. Another British attempt to find a solution had
failed.
ELECTIONS (1945 - 46)
The general elections to the provincial and central legislatures were held in 1945 - 46.
Both the parties took an active part in these elections because the constitutional future of
India was dependent on the results of these elections. Both Congress and Muslim league
contested the election on two exactly opposed slogans. Congress wanted to keep
Subcontinent united, whereas Muslim League wanted to divide it.
Results of Election The results showed that the Muslims league won all the 30 Muslims
Muhammad Ali Wasim
seats in the Central Assembly and 446 out of 495 Muslims seats in the Provincial
Assemblies. The Congress won the same victory in the Hindu majority areas. In Bengal,
the Muslim League won 113 out of
119 Muslim seats and formed ministries in Sindh. The Victory of Congress in N.W.F.P
was a serious blow to the league, Muslim League won 17 out of 36 Muslim seats and
Congress took 19 Muslims seats and Dr. Khan Sahib formed ministry with Congress. In
Punjab, Muslim league won 79 out of 86 Muslim seats and Khizar Hayat Tiwana formed
the ministry with Congress. Congress won total
930 seats gaining an absolute majority in 8 provinces.
Result of the elections not only divided the assemblies between Muslim League and
Congress but also approved the Muslim league claim that, it was a sole representative’s
party of the Muslims of Subcontinent and the demand for the establishment for a
separate Muslim homeland was true.
2) There would be three different parts to post - British India. (Hindu Majority
Territories, Muslims Majority Provinces, Bengal and Assam)
3) Each part would have local autonomy and would be able to draw up its own
constitution
Short term Plan: The mission also proposed of setting up of an interim Central
Government in which the Indian national should hold all portfolios. Gandhi criticized
and rejected the plan and called it ‘An appeal and an advice’ while the Muslim league
accepted long term and short term plans. The viceroy broke his promise by refusing to
form the government only with Muslim league. On other hand Nehru, however said that
Congress would not feel bound by the plan once the British had gone. The Muslim
league felt that his made further discussions pointless. Any agreement might just
overturned after the British had gone. So the Cabinet Plan was dropped.
Partition of India
Lord Mountbatten was appointed a s the last viceroy of India and he was told by the
prime minister, lord Clement Attlee to hand over the power to the Indian by 1st June
1948. Attlee had deliberately set a short time span for arrangement to be made. He
feared that if more time were given, there would only be more disagreement. When
Mountbatten reached India, he faced problems like Muslim League wanting partition
and congress opposing it and he had very short time. In March 1947 there were riots and
killing between Muslims and Hindus in Punjab. Soon the trouble spread to other
provinces. After negotiations, he had worked out a partition plan. The Congress met on
1st may 1947 and gave its acceptance of the partition plan and Muslim League also gave
its approval.
Mountbatten got approval from the British Government and the plan was issued on 3rd
June 1947. The main characteristics of the plan were:
India would be divided into 2 different states on the midnight of 14 and 15 August
1947
Government of India act 1935 would be modified to adopt as the temporary
Muslims areas. Lord Mount batten had appointed Sir Cyril Radcliffe to head a boundary
Commission to establish new borders, particularly in Bengal and Punjab. Radcliffe had
four assistance, two nominated by the Muslim league and two by Congress.
Jinnah told people of Pakistan that the awards were Wrong and unjust and perverse.
However, the partition had been take place two days earlier.