Ex Ante and Ex Post Meaning
Ex Ante and Ex Post Meaning
Ex Ante and Ex Post Meaning
meaning
December 17, 2016 by Tejvan Pettinger
It predicts the economy is getting closer to full capacity with unemployment falling towards
5%
The Fed is worried about the impact of leaving interest rates at zero for too long – Zero
interest rates may cause future inflation. A small rate rise now, will help to prevent the
economy overheating.
Fears of an asset bubble if interest rates are kept at zero for too long
However, economists (such as Krugman) are critical of the decision to raise interest rates.
They see that headline inflation rate is still below the target of 2%. Headline inflation is 0.5%
(12 months to Nov 2015). Though core inflation which ignores fuel and food rose 2% last
month)
Given depth and length of recession, there is still lost output compared to the previous trend
growth
The world economy is still weak with prospects of falling demand from abroad.
The US economy is already been affected by an appreciation in the dollar, making
manufacturing exporters less competitive
Given the long period of economic expansion, it is better to overshoot the inflation target
than undershoot the target. If inflation rises to 4%, this will help normalise economic growth
and end fears of deflation, but it is relatively easy to reduce inflation of 4%.
However, if the Fed undershoot the inflation target and we end up with deflation – this is
much more damaging. It has proved much more difficult to overcome deflation (e.g. case of
Japan and increasingly the Eurozone)
Example of ex ante and ex post
And it will be quite some time before we have any evidence about whether
the Fed’s judgement of the economy’s trajectory was right. (I think this was
an ex ante mistake even if it turns out OK ex post, but it’s still interesting to
see how it goes.) We’re talking months if not quarters, and it may take
years. Fed Follies
The decision to raise interest rates is based on ex ante predictions. The Fed doesn’t know for
certain how the US economy will behave. It is making a prediction that the economy is
growing fast enough to justify a rate rise.
However, it will only be in one or two years, whether we will be able to tell whether the
decision was correct. For example, if this interest rate, combined with the global recession,
pushes the US economy back into recession, the ex ante analysis of raising rates may prove it
to be the wrong decision.
What does Krugman mean when he says “I think this was an ex ante mistake even if it turns
out OK ex post”
Even if the US economy is still doing well in one or two years time, with strong growth – this
would suggest that the decision to raise interest rates was justified. However, Krugman feels
that it is better to err on the side of caution – it is better for inflation to overshoot than
undershoot. In other words, the problems of inflation above the target are not symmetrical
with the problems of inflation below the target. Given current knowledge of the economy, the
best ex ante decision is to hold back from raising rates.